Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010637452022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 543/2022
And
CROSS OBJECTIONS NO. 10 OF 2023
1. MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 543/2022
Between:
1. ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD,
VISHRANTHI MADARAM TOWERS, NO.2/319, RAJIV GANDHI SALAI
(OMR), KARAPAKKAM, CHENNAI-600 097.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. POKURI RANI, W/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE 34 YEARS,
2. POKURI TIRUMALA, S/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE19 YEARS,
RESPONDENT NO.2 DECLARED AS MAJOR AND RESPONDENT NO.1
MOTHER IS DISCHARGED AS THEIR GUARDIAN AMENDED AS PER
COURT ORDERS DATE 28.04.2023 IN IA.NO.2 AND 3/2023.
3. POKURI LAKSHMI DEEPIKA, D/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE 13
YEARS,
4. POKURI RAJAMMA, W/O. VENKATESWARLU, AGED 61 YEARS,
(RESPONDENTS 3 BEING MINOR REP, BY THEIR MOTHER- 1ST
RESPONDENT HEREIN AS NEXT FRIEND) ALL PETITIONERS ARE
R/O.KATTUBADI PALEM VILLAGE AND POST, KONDEPI MANDAL,
PRAKASAM
5. G VENKATA SUBBA RAO, S/ O. NARASINGA RAO, OWNER CUM
DRIVER OF CAR NO. AP 27 BK 4905, DOOR NO.2-46, PERIDEPI POST
AND VILLAGE, KONDEPI MANDAL, PRAKASAM DIST-523 273
DISTRICT-523 271.
...RESPONDENT(S):
2. CROSS OBJECTIONS NO. 10 OF 2023
1. POKURI RANI, W/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE 38 YEARS,
2. POKURI TIRUMALA, S/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE 19 YEARS.
3. POKURI LAKSHMI DEEPIKA, D/O.LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGE 17
YEARS,
4. POKURI RAJAMMA, W/O. VENKATESWARLU, AGED 65 YEARS,
(CROSS OBJECTOR NO.3 BEING MINOR, REP. BY HER MOTHER
OBJECTOR NO.1 AS NEXT FRIEND)
...CROSS OBJECTORS/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 4:
AND
1. ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD,
VISHRANTHI MADARAM TOWERS, NO.2/319, RAJIV GANDHI SALAI
(OMR), KARAPAKHAM, CHENNAI-600 097.
… RESPONDENT/APPELLANT.
2. G VENKATA SUBBA RAO, S/O. NARASINGA RAO, OWNER CUM
DRIVER OF CAR NO. AP 27 BK 4905, R/O NO.2-46, PERIDEPI POST
AND VILLAGE, KONDEPI MANDAL, PRAKASAM DIST-523 273.
… RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT NO.5.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. D RAVI KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. NUTHALAPATI KRISHNA MURTHY
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 543/2022
And
CROSS OBJECTIONS NO. 10 OF 2023
COMMON JUDGMENT:
1.
The Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (for short MACMA)
No.543 of 2022 has been preferred by the appellant/ 2nd respondent – insurance
company challenging the Order/Award passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal (for short MACT) –cum- Principal District Judge, Prakasam at
Ongole, in M.V.O.P.No.157 of 2018 dated 18.07.2022, wherein the Tribunal has
awarded an amount of Rs.24,18,000/- as against the claim of Rs.30,00000/-.
For the above appeal the Respondents No.1 to 4 filed cross objections
No.10 of 2023.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties herein
after are referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellant in
MACMA No.543 of 2022 and 2nd Respondent in Cross Objections No.10 of 2023
as 2nd respondent; and Respondents No.1 to 5 in MACMA No.543 of 2022 and
cross objectors No.1 to 4 in Cross Objections No.10 of 2023 as Petitioners; and
5th respondent in MACMA No.543 of 2022 and 2nd respondent in Cross
Objections No.10 of 2023 as 1st respondent.
2.
M.V.O.P.No.157 of 2018 is filed by the petitioners under section 166
(1)(C) of Motor Vehicles Act claiming compensation of Rs.30,00,000/- along with
subsequent interest and costs for the death of Pokuri Krishna Rao in a motor
vehicle accident on 29.06.2018
3.
Brief averments of the claim petition in MVOP No.291 of 2016 are
that – on 29.06.2018 in the afternoon while the deceased Krishna Rao was
returning from Vennur village to Kattubadivaripalem on his motorcycle bearing
No.AP 27 AF 2455, in the meantime one car bearing No.AP 27 BK 4905 driven
by its driver in a high speed and negligent manner, dashed against the
deceased, due to which, he received fatal injuries and fell in the canal beside the
road in between Kattubadivaripalem to Vennur R & B Road. Immediately he was
shifted to Government Hospital, Ongole, and subsequently he was referred to
KIMS Hospital, Ongole, wherein he was succumbed to injuries at 19.50 hours on
the same day. The Police, Kondepi police station registered a case in
Cr.No.57/2018 U/Sec. 304-A IPC, against the Driver of Car bearing No.AP 27 BK
4905 and investigated into.
i.
At the time of accident, deceased was aged about 38 years, hale and
healthy and getting income of Rs.6,00,000/- to Rs.7,00,000/- per annum by doing
cultivation and maintaining two tobacco barns and contributing all his earnings to
the maintenance and welfare of his family. It is further contended that their family
owned Ac.25.00 of land, deceased used to raise commercial crops like tobacco,
Bengal Gram, Mirchi etc., Petitioners No.2 and 3 are minors and they are
studying First year intermediate and 10th class respectively at Vijayawada and
Kandukur. Deceased was only son to the Petitioner No.4 and he is sole bread
winner of the family.
ii.
Respondent No.1 is Driver-cum-Owner and Respondent No.2 is insurer of
Car bearing No.AP27 BK 4905. Hence, Respondents No.1 and 2 are jointly and
severally liable for payment of compensation to the Petitioners.
4.
Respondent No.1/Driver-cum-owner of crime vehicle bearing No.AP
27 BK 4905 filed counter, denying the allegations made in the petition with regard
to the age, income and avocation of the deceased at the time of accident and
contended that deceased was driving his motorcycle running from Vennur village
to Kattubadipalem village, dashed against the Car (crime vehicle) in a rash and
negligent manner and there is no rash and negligence on the part of Respondent
No.1. If the Hon'ble Tribunal awards any compensation to the Petitioners,
Respondent No.2 being insurer of the crime vehicle is liable to pay the same and
prayed to dismiss the petition, with costs against this Respondent.
5.
Respondent No.2/ Insurance Company filed counter, denying the
allegations made in the petition with regard to the date, time, place, mode and
manner of accident and also denied the age, income and avocation of the
deceased. It is further denied the contention of petitioners that deceased met
with accident due to rash and negligent driving of Car bearing No.AP 27 BK 4905
by Respondent No.1 and contended that as accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of deceased, so insurer of said motorcycle is proper and
necessary parties to the claim petition and the petition is liable to be dismissed
for non-joinder of necessary parties. It is contended that driver of the crime
vehicle has no valid and effective driving license at the time of accident, the
vehicle has no valid registration and insurance policy. It is further contended that
Respondent No.1/owner-cum driver of the car was colluded with petitioners,
hence he did not report the accident to this Respondent with a view to cause
loss, hence this Respondent is not liable to pay any compensation to the
claimants. It is further contended that Respondent No.2/insurance company
seeks protection U/Sec.149 and 170 of Motor Vehicles Act. Thus, prayed to
dismiss the petition against this respondent, with costs.
6.
Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues are settled for
trial by the Tribunal:1) Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of Car bearing NOAP 27 BK 4905?
2) Whether deceased Pokuri Krishna Rao died in the road accident?
3) Whether the petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
4) Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, from whom and what
amount?
5) To what relief?
7.
During course of trial, 1st petitioner herself examined as P.W.1,
eyewitness to the accident by name Ravulapalli Sreenu examined as P.W.2,
mother of the deceased (4th petitioner herein) Pokuri Rajamma examined as
P.W.3 and got marked Ex.A1 – Attested copy of First Information Report in
Cr.No.57/2018 of Kondepi Police Station, Ex.A2 - Attested copy of Inquest
Report, Ex.A3 - Attested copy of PME Report, Ex.A4 - Attested copy of MVI
Report, Ex.A5 - Attested copy of charge sheet, Ex.A6 - Copy of Pattadar
Passbook issued in the name of deceased Krisha Rao to an extent of Ac.3.90
cents at Narasingolu Village. Ex.A7 - Copy of Pattadar Passbook issued in the
name of Petitioner No.1 for the lands situated at Vennur Village to an extent of
Ac.02.32 cents,Ex.AB - Copy of Pattadar Passbook issued in the name of
Petitioner No.4 for the lands situated at Vennur Village to an extent of Ac 11.44
cents, Ex A9 - Copy of Title Deed and Pattadar Passbook issued in the name of
Petitioner No.4 for the lands situated at Narsingolu Village to an extent of
Ac.03.91 1/2 cents, Ex A10 - Copy of Tobacco Farmer Passbook in the name of
Petitioner No.1, Ex.A.11 - Copy of Tobacco Farmer Passbook in the name of
Petitioner No.4, Ex.A.12 - Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by Tobacco Board
for the tobacco sold by deceased and Petitioner No.1 in the year 2018. Ex.A.13 Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by
deceased in the year 2017, Ex.A.14 - Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by
Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by deceased in the year 2016, Ex.A.15 Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by
deceased in the year 2015, Ex.A.16 - Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by
Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by deceased in the year 2015, Ex.A17 -
Tobacco Sales Ledger copy issued by Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by
Petitioner No.4 in the year 2018, Ex.A18 - copy of Tobacco Sales Ledger issued
by Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by Petitioner No.4 in the year 2017,
Ex.A.19 - copy of Tobacco Sales Ledger issued by Tobacco Board for the
tobacco sold by Petitioner No.4 in the year 2016, Ex.A.20 - Tobacco Sales
Ledger copy issued by Tobacco Board for the tobacco sold by Petitioner No.4 in
the year 2015; and Ex.A21 - copy of Gram Storage Bond issued by
Venkateswara Enterprises (Multi Commodity Cold Storage), dt. 18.02.2018.
No oral or documentary evidence is adduced on behalf of Respondents.
8.
Upon hearing both counsel, upon perusing the pleadings, oral and
documentary evidence placed on record, the Tribunal allowed the claim petition
of petitioners in part by awarding Rs.24,18,000/- as compensation together with
interest at 7.5% p.a from the date of petition till the date of realization, together
with proportionate costs, directing the respondents No.1 and 2 to deposit the
compensation amount within 30 days from the date of order.
9.
Being aggrieved by the said order/award, the 2nd respondent
insurance company has preferred the MACMA No.543 of 2022 on the grounds
that the Tribunal wrongly taken the notional income of the deceased at
Rs.12,000/- per month without any proof of income and adding future prospectus
at 40% to the said income which is unreasonable, unjust and contrary to the law,
though the lands possessed by the deceased still remains with the claimants as
his legal heirs and there is no deprivation of income and wrongly awarded
compensation of Rs.24,18,000/- . Hence, prayed to allow the appeal by setting
aside the impugned decree and Order dated 18.07.2022 in MVOP No.157 of
2018 passed by the Chairman, MACT –cum- Principal District Judge, Ongole.
In the above appeal, the petitioners No.1 to 4 filed cross objections on the
ground that the 4th petitioner being mother of the deceased is entitled for
compensation under the head of filial consortium and that the deceased was
getting income of Rs.6,00,000/- to Rs.7,00,000/- per annum by doing cultivation
and maintaining two tobacco barons, in-spite of the same, the tribunal assessed
the income of the deceased as Rs.1,44,000/- per annum.
10.
Heard the learned counsel for appellant and cross objectors,
perused the material in record.
11.
On perusal of the award, it can be observed that in support of the
case of the claimants, claimant No.1 being the wife of the deceased got
examined herself as P.W.1 and got marked Exs.A.1 to A.5. She also got
examined P.W.2, who is the eyewitness to the said incident, who categorically
deposed that on 29.06.2018 while he was going to Kattubadipalem from Vennur
and reached 2 KMs away from Kattubadipalem near Devudi Manyam lands at
about 03.00 p.m., the deceased was going ahead on his motorcycle towards
Kattubadipalem village and at that time, one car bearing No.AP 27 BK 4905
came in opposite direction at high speed in a rash and negligent manner, dashed
against motorcycle of the deceased, resultant which he sustained multiple
injuries and fell in the canal on roadside. Considering the evidence of P.W.1,
P.W.2 coupled with Exs.A.1 to A.5, in the absence of rebuttal evidence from
respondent Nos.1 and 2, the Tribunal held that on 29.06.2018 at 03.00 p.m. the
deceased met with accident, sustained fatal injuries and died while undergoing
treatment at KIMS Hospital, Ongole, on the same day at 07.30 p.m. due to rash
and negligent driving of car bearing No.AP 27 BK 4905 by respondent No.1.
12.
It is the case of the claimant that the deceased was aged about 38
years and used to earn Rs.6,00,000/- to Rs.7,00,000/- per annum. In support of
the said claim, they also got examined P.W.3, who is the mother of the
deceased, deposed with regard to the earnings of the deceased by doing
agriculture and also possessing Ac.25.00 cents of land and in support of her
contention, she also relied on Exs.A.6 to A.21. But, however, the Tribunal
considering the fact that during the course of cross-examination P.W.3 herself
admitted that Exs.A.17 to A.20 pertains to her and after the death of her
husband, she is also residing with the family of deceased and her son used to
cultivate her lands and she does not know whether her son was paying income
tax or not and also the fact that as the agricultural land is intact and even in the
absence of the deceased, the claimants are getting income from the subject land,
the Tribunal fixed the income of the deceased as Rs.12,000/- per month.
Therefore, annual income would come to Rs.1,44,000/- (Rs.12,000 x 12).
13.
Considering the age of the deceased as 36-40 years, he is entitled
for an additional amount of 40% of his income towards his future prospects as
held by the Apex Court in “National Insurance Company Vs. Pranay Sethi1”,
as such the annual income of the deceased would come to Rs.2,01,600
(Rs.1,44,000+57,600). As there are 4 dependents in the present case, 1/4 th has
to be deducted towards his personal expenses. After deducting 1/4th, the monthly
income of the deceased would come to Rs.1,51,200/-. (Rs.2,01,600 –
Rs.50,400). After applying the appropriate multiplier i.e. 15 for the age group of
36 – 40 years, as per the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma Vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation 2 ”, the loss of dependency would come to
(Rs.1,51,200 X 15) Rs.22,68,000/-.
14.
In addition to the above, the Tribunal also awarded a sum of
Rs.40,000/- towards loss of spouse consortium, Rs.80,000/- towards parental
consortium, Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral
expenditure as per the guidelines prescribed by the Apex Court in “National
2018 ACJ 2782
2009 ACJ 1298
Insurance Company Vs. Pranay Sethi3”. In total, the Tribunal below awarded
Rs.24,18,000/- to the claimants.
15.
Considering the material available on record, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the amount of Rs.24,18,000/- awarded by the Tribunal to
the claimants, for the death of the deceased, was on reasonable basis and is
sustainable under law, which needs no interference.
16.
Now, coming to cross-objections filed by the claimants, though it is
the case of the claimants that the deceased was having Ac.25.00 cents of land
and used to earn Rs.6,00,000/- to Rs.7,00,000/-, this Court is of the opinion that
there will be no loss of income derived from the agricultural land as the said land
is intact. In such case, there is nothing wrong in considering the income of the
deceased as Rs.12,000/- per month. Though the claimants got examined P.W.3
in support of possessing Ac.25.00 cents of land. However, P.W.3 is none other
than the mother of the deceased, who categorically admitted that Exs.A.17 to
A.20 pertains to her and after the death of the deceased, she is residing with
family of the deceased. It can also be observed that the claimants failed to
examine any third party in support of their case. In such case, this Court does not
find any error committed by the Tribunal in considering the income of the
deceased as Rs.12,000/- per month. However, on perusal of the award passed
by the Tribunal, it can be observed that though the claimant No.4 is the mother of
2018 ACJ 2782
the deceased, the Tribunal failed to award any amount under the head of filial
consortium. In view of the same, this Court is of the opinion that the award
passed by the Tribunal is enhanced by Rs.40,000/-.
17.
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal vide
MACMA No.543 of 2022 is dismissed and the Cross Objections No.10 of 2023
filed by the claimants is partly allowed by enhancing the compensation from
Rs.24,18,000/- to Rs.24,58,000/- with interest at 7.5% P.A. from the date of filing
of the petition till the date of realization. There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 03.03.2026.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 543/2022
And
CROSS OBJECTIONS NO. 10 OF 2023
DATED 03.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review