Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Arb.P. No.01/2024
Royal Infraconstru Limited, represented by its Project Manager, having its
registered office at Godrej Waterside Building, Tower No.1, 4 th Floor, No.401,
Plot No.5, DP Block, Salt Lake, Sector-V, Kolkata-700001.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by its Secretary, PWD Department,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Secretary, PWD Department, Government of Tripura, New Capital
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (R&B), Government of
Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
4. The Superintending Engineer, 3rd Circle, Public Works Department (R&B),
Government of Tripura, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura, PIN-799120.
5. The Engineer-In-Charge, Santir Bazar Division, South Tripura, Public Works
Department (R&B), Government of Tripura, P.O.-Santir Bazar, District-South
Tripura, PIN-799144.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
14/08/2024
Heard Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Karnajit De, learned Addl. Government Advocate appearing
for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner approached this Court for appointment of an
independent Arbitrator in connection with Memorandum of Understanding
dated 07.01.2009 (Annexure-2) arrived at between the parties under Section
11(6) read with Section 12 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended.
3.
The case of the petitioner is captured in the order dated
04.07.2024 which is extracted hereunder:
"Heard Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Karnajit De, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
The Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) at Annexure-2 arrived at
between the parties pursuant to issuance of Letter of Intent (LOI) is in the
nature of an agreement wherein clause 19(b) provides for adjudication of
dispute through arbitration. Annexure-1 is the Letter of Intent (LOI) dated
11.12.2008 for award of projects to CPSU and private sector construction
agencies on Cost-Plus percentage basis in which the petitioner was asked to
appear before the office of the Superintending Engineer, Planning Circle,
PWD, Agartala for proceeding further for signing the MOU and arranging
award of the work. Paragraph-6 of the LOI indicates that the contract will be
operated by the terms and conditions of the MOU.
3.
As per the MOU signed on 07.01.2009 the stipulated date of
completion was 26.12.2010. The defect liability period for the project was
one year. The subsequent chronology of dates furnished in the application
show that the date of completion of the work was 19.03.2016. Respondents
also issued completion certificate on 15.12.2017. Thereafter, arose the dispute
since petitioner claims that even after expiry of defect liability period,
security deposit of Rs.25,00,000/- was not released. He also claimed that
VAT increase percentage was not paid to the tune of Rs.39,31,267/-.
Petitioner had made representations through letter dated 11.09.2017 and
13.04.2018. Petitioner had also submitted representation before
Commissioner of Taxes on 25.03.2019. The Additional Commissioner of
Taxes had asked the Superintendent of Taxes to ascertain whether any excess
amount of VAT had been paid as per letter dated 27.03.2019. Petitioner has
also referred to letter dated 05.05.2018 issued by the Superintending
Engineer, Planning & Design, Agartala to the Superintending Engineer, 3rd
Circle regarding the balance of final deviation amount. Petitioner had also
made representation on 21.10.2021 before the Executive Engineer, PWD for
release of bills.
4.
Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
based on these claims, petitioner would be entitled to receive Rs.8,23,83,031/and interest withheld amount of Rs.6,80,56,267/- between the period from
2016 to 2023. Petitioner had issued notice through his counsel as per Clause18 of the MOU to the Engineer-in-Charge on 27.06.2023. Thereafter,
petitioner again issued notice under Clause-18.2 of the MOU to the
Superintending Engineer, PWD, Government of Tripura on 08.08.2023. He
thereafter invoked the arbitration clause 19(b) of the MOU by letter dated
22.09.2023 addressed to the Chief Engineer, PWD (R&B) along with a panel
of Arbitrators proposed to be appointed. He received no reply from the
respondents. Thereafter, he approached this Court.
5.
The first counter affidavit of the respondents states that the petitioner's
tender was accepted for construction of 11(eleven) nature of works. The
names and details of the bridges are furnished at paragraph-3 of the counter
affidavit. Detailed Project Report (DPR) submitted by the petitioner was
approved by the competent authority and he was directed to commence
physical work as per the approved DPR.
6.
Mr. Karnajit De, learned Addl. Government Advocate appearing for
the State, has referred to the direction of Additional Commissioner of Taxes,
Government of Tripura to the Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-VII, Kar
Bhavan, Agartala to take necessary action as per provisions of the TVAT Act
and Rules made thereunder to ascertain whether the petitioner had paid any
excess amount of VAT and is entitled to claim any refund or not. In case any
excess amount is ascertained as paid by the petitioner, he may proceed for
refund of the same as per provisions of the TVAT Act and Rules made
thereunder. However, learned counsel for the respondents-State submits that
claim relating to refund of excess taxes paid are not arbitrable disputes as they
are sovereign in nature as held by the Apex Court in the case of Vidya Drolia
and Ors. Vs. Durga Trading Corporation reported in (2021) 2 SCC 1.
7.
The respondents have in so many words attributed the delay in
execution of the contract upon the petitioner. Petitioner had submitted the
price variation bills after the contract and extended date of completion of the
work in question. Such final price variation is subject to approval by the
competent authority as per norms of the MOU. Respondents also dispute the
claim for incentives as per Clause-12 of the MOU for early completion as it is
an optional clause. The same will be decided by the competent higher
authority. The respondents also have made statements to the effect that
factual aspects regarding determination of payment liability are subject to the
terms and conditions of the contract and satisfactory performance by the
contractor. However, if the entire contract component is vitiated by malice or
criminal interest, no payment need be made pending criminal
investigation/trial. A statement was made in the first counter affidavit that the
work is under investigation in West Agartala P.S. case, the details of which
were not furnished. However, in the additional affidavit filed thereafter, the
respondents have made a categorical statement that after completion of
investigation, involvement of this agency in the West Agartala P.S. case
No.2019WAG251 dated 13.10.2019 is not established. No case is pending
against the aforementioned agency. The averments made in the counter
affidavit further indicate that reference for adjudication under the Clause19(b) should be made within 6(six) months from the date of intimating the
contractor of the preparation of final bill or his having accepted payment
whichever is earlier. This averment has been strongly refuted by the petitioner
in his rejoinder affidavit. At paragraph-8 of the rejoinder, petitioner states that
the respondents have accepted that there are certain disputes between the
parties which can only be settled by arbitration. Moreover, till date the
respondents have not intimated the petitioner regarding preparation of final
bill nor the said final payment has been made by the respondents. As such,
final bills have not been accepted by the petitioner. Therefore, the objection
raised by the respondents that the petitioner failed to comply with Clause19(b) of the MOU is wrong and not tenable. Petitioner also contended that
there is no criminal case pending against the petitioner. Petitioner has duly
followed the process seeking reference of dispute to arbitration by following
the Clause-18 and clause 19(b) of the MOU by submitting notices dated
27.06.2023, 08.08.2023 and 22.09.2023 before the respondents but the Chief
Engineer failed to refer the matter for arbitration.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, therefore, all the
requirements for appointment of an independent arbitrator under Section
11(6)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (as amended) is made
out on the basis of the arbitration Clause-19(b) of the MOU existing between
the parties. Therefore, this Court may appoint an independent arbitrator.
9.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties
and recorded a brief chronology of their respective cases on the germane
issues that is existence of arbitration clause; existence of an arbitrable dispute
and compliance of the process by the petitioner-contractor before approaching
this Court under Section 11(6)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 for appointment of an arbitrator in terms of the arbitration clause. The
narration of facts referred to above leads to the conclusion that the existence
of an arbitration clause in the MOU which is treated as an agreement between
the parties for execution of the enumerated works is not in dispute. Final bills
have not yet been prepared. Therefore, question of acceptance of final bills by
the petitioner also does not arise. The work was started in the year 2010 after
approval of the DPR submitted by the petitioner in terms of the LOI and the
MOU dated 07.01.2009. The execution of the work was finally concluded
after 6(six) years on 19.03.2016. Respondents also issued a completion
certificate on 15.12.2017 which are part of Annexure-15 series. If the final
bills have not been prepared and moreover, security deposit of Rs.25 lakhs
has not been released, there is no doubt that arbitrable dispute exists between
the parties. However, certain claims of the petitioner relate to refund of excess
VAT paid as against the running account payments made from time to time.
This dispute ought not to be referred to the arbitrator as they relate to the
domain of sovereign tax claims. Petitioner also has duly represented before
the concerned authorities before invoking the arbitration clause to the
competent authority, i.e. Chief Engineer vide his letter dated 22.09.2023
under Clause-19(b) of the MOU which remains unresponded. Clause 19 of
the MOU is extracted hereunder for reference:
“19. Settlement of Claims:
All disputes or difference arising of or relating to the
Contract shall be referred for the adjudication as
follows:a) Claims up to a value of Rupees 50,000/- Superintending Engineer of another circle in the same
department.
b) Claims above Rs.50,000/- Another Chief Engineer or Arbitrator appointed by
the Chief Engineer of the same department.
The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with
the provisions of Indian Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 or any statutory modification thereof.
The arbitrator shall state his reasons in passing the
award.
A reference for adjudication under this clauses shall be
made by the contractor within 6(six) months from the
date of intimating the contractor of the preparation of
final bill or his having accepted payment whichever is
earlier. Only contracts executed in Tripura shall have
jurisdiction for any suit arising out of this contract.
More particularly no suit shall be instituted or
entertained in any court outside the state arising out of
contract.”
10.
As such, this Court is satisfied that the petitioner has made out a case
for appointment of an independent arbitrator. It is pertinent to state here that
whether the dispute is alive or not or the merits of the dispute are not to be
gone into by this Court while making reference to an arbitrator.
11.
In such circumstances, this Court proposes to appoint Hon'ble Mr.
Justice Virender Singh, former Chief Justice of Jharkhand High Court to act
as an arbitrator between the parties.
The proposed arbitrator is requested to submit his declaration in terms
of Section 12 read with Schedule VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996.
Let a copy of the instant order be communicated to the proposed
arbitrator by the Registry.
It is made clear that petitioner is left with liberty to raise its claim for
VAT dues in an appropriate proceeding in accordance with law.
Let the matter appear on 09.08.2024."
4.
Pursuant to the order dated 04.07.2024, this Court proposed to
appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, former Chief Justice of Jharkhand
High Court as an arbitrator. The proposed Arbitrator has submitted his consent
along with a declaration under Schedule-VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 as amended.
5.
Learned counsel for the parties, therefore, submit that this Court
may appoint him as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
6.
In view of the consent and declaration submitted by the proposed
Arbitrator, I, hereby, appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, former Chief
Justice of Jharkhand High Court, as an Arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties. Learned Arbitrator is requested to take into consideration
the Schedule of Model Fee prescribed under Schedule IV and the timeline
prescribed under Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended.
7.
Learned counsel for the parties have supplied the e-mail address
and phone number of the respective parties. These are indicated hereunder for
convenience of the learned Arbitrator in conducting the proceedings:
Petitioner:
e-mail i.d.
:
gbanerjee@royalconstruct.com
Phone no.
:
9830579316
Respondent:
8.
e-mail i.d.
:
pwdsantirbazardivision@gmail.com
Phone no.
:
9436471083
Registry is directed to communicate the instant order along with a
copy of the entire pleadings of the instant application to the Learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
9.
The instant petition stands allowed and disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
SIDDHARTHA
LODH
LODH
Date: 2024.08.14 16:47:24 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review