The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Taking into consideration all these aspects, I am of the view that the matter requires reconsideration by the 1 st respondent assessing authority. To facilitate reconsideration, Exts.P3 and P9 are set aside. The 1 st respondent shall reconsider the matter and issue a fresh order of assessment, after affording an opportunity of being heard to the petitioner and after considering the contention of the petitioner that he is entitled for the permissible deduction as provided under Rule 2A of the Service Tax(Determination of Values) Rule, 2006 and also to the benefit of Ext.P4 notification No.30/2012 of the Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Government of India as amended from time to time. Fresh orders of assessment shall be passed within an outer limit of 3 months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. The writ petition is disposed of as above. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:1:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 39617 OF 2022
PETITIONER
ROY JACOB,
AGED 56 YEARS
THATTARAKUNNEL ENTERPRISES, ROOM NO. 5, THEKKENATH
BUILDING, KADAVANTHARA, KOCHI-682020
BY ADV RAMESH CHERIAN JOHN
RESPONDENT/S:
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CENTRAL TAX AND
CENTRAL EXCISE, ERNAKULAM DIVISION, CENTRAL EXCISE
BHAVAN, KATHRIKADAVU, KALOOR, KOCHI, PIN - 682017
THE COMMISSIONER (APPEALS),
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER (APPEALS), CENTRAL TAX,
CENTRAL EXCISE & CUSTOMS, CENTRAL REVENUE BUILDING,
I.S.PRESS ROAD, KOCHI, PIN - 682018
BY ADV R.HARISHANKAR
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
03.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28434
:2:
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
---
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -W.P.(C) No.39617 of 2022
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The petitioner has approached this Court challenging Exts.P3
and P9 orders. Ext.P3 is the order of assessment for the years
October 2011 to March 2015, which was completed on 16.01.2018.
Though an appeal was preferred with a petition to condone the
delay, the application seeking condonation of delay was dismissed
as per Ext.P9, holding that the delay cannot be condoned beyond
the statutory period of 90 days as the appeal has been preferred
beyond the statutory period.
2. The specific case of the petitioner is that he was engaged
in the construction and sale of residential apartments and he has
stopped his business from the year 2015 due to serious loss in the
business and he has been detected with cancer and is undergoing
treatment as evident from Ext.P1. Due to the strong dosage and
potency of the medicines taken for cancer and consequent
dizziness, he had a fall from the terrace of his residence which
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:3:
resulted in multiple fractures and he is now totally immobile, as
evident from Ext.P2 discharge summary. The petitioner submits
that for the period from 10/2011 to 03/2015 the adjudicating
authority completed the assessment as per Ext.P3 assessment
order. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would
submit that going by Rule 2A of the Service Tax(Determination of
Values) Rules, 2006(in short 'the Rules, 2006') the 1 st respondent
was duty bound to allow the permissible deductions namely, the
amount charged for the Goods & Services and VAT levied thereon.
The learned counsel would further submit that Going by Rule 2A(i)
of the Rules, 2006, the value of service portion in the execution of
works contract shall be equivalent to the gross amount charged for
the “Works Contract” less the value of property in goods
transferred in the execution of the said works contract. But the 1 st
respondent adopted the gross amount shown in the VAT return and
determined the tax without allowing the permissible deductions
and therefore, the levy of service tax on the gross amount as per
VAT returns is wholly illegal, arbitrary and without authority of
law. It is further contended that as per Ext.P4 notification
No.30/2012 issued by the Ministry of Finance, Department of
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:4:
Revenue, Government of India, for execution of “Works Contract”,
the percentage of service tax payable by the person providing
service namely the petitioner is only 50%. In total violation of
Ext.P4 notification, 100% tax has been made payable by the
petitioner and therefore, on the basis of the same it is contended
that Ext.P3 order of assessment is bad in law.
3. The respondents have filed a detailed counter affidavit and
on the basis of the same the learned Standing Counsel appearing
for the respondents submits that the assessment made as per
Ext.P3 is perfectly legal and valid. As regards the contention raised
by the petitioner relying on Rule 2A of the Rule, 2006, it is the
contention of the learned Standing Counsel that the department
has given the abatement applicable to the services provided by the
assessee, as per the provisions of the Act and therefore, the
contention of the petitioner in this regard is without any basis. It is
further contended that the appeal has been filed beyond the period
of limitation and therefore, it is rightly rejected as per Ext.P9. It is
also contended that Ext.P9 is an appealable order as per Section
86(1) of the Finance Act, 1994 before CESTAT.
4. When the matter came up for consideration on 16.12.2022
2025:KER:28434
:5:
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
this Court has taken note of the fact that the appeal was filed
beyond
the
maximum
condonable
period,
but
taking
into
consideration the contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner that he has been assessed towards works contract
service by treating the entire amounts received by him as
assessable to service tax under the provisions of the Finance Act,
1994 and that at least a portion of that amount is clearly not
assessable to service tax as part of the amount represents the
amount paid by the petitioner towards purchase of material which
was subjected to tax on sale of goods (KVAT) which was applicable
at the relevant time, prima facie entered a finding that this is a
jurisdictional issue and therefore the court was bound to examine
the correctness of the original order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India and admitted the matter and granted interim
order staying Ext.P3 order.
5. The specific contention raised by the petitioner is that the
deduction available to the petitioner as per 2A(i) of the Rules, 2006
has not been extended to the petitioner. Though in the counter
affidavit the stand of the department is that whatever abatement
applicable to the services provided by the assessee has given due
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:6:
credit to as per the provisions of the Act and therefore, the
contention of the petitioner is without any basis, the learned
counsel for the petitioner pointed out that, even in Ext.R1(b)
inspection report of CERA it is specifically found that the VCES
request made by the petitioner was rejected on the ground of nonpayment of dues within the stipulated time and on the basis of the
same it is contended that the stand in the counter affidavit that
whatever benefits of abatement applicable to the service provided
by the assessee as per the Act has been extended to the petitioner
is without any basis.
6. Yet another aspect to be noted is that the petitioner was
detected with cancer and he was undergoing treatment and due to
strong dosage and potency of the medicines taken for cancer and
consequent dizziness he had a fall from the terrace of his residence
which resulted in multiple fractures. The health issues of the
petitioner was stated as reasons for the delay in filing the appeal. It
is also to be noted that though a specific contention was taken by
the petitioner that he is entitled for the benefit of Ext.P4
notification, no answer has been given in the counter affidavit filed
by the respondents regarding the same.
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:7:
7. Taking into consideration all these aspects, I am of the view
that the matter requires reconsideration by the 1 st respondent
assessing authority. To facilitate reconsideration, Exts.P3 and P9
are set aside. The 1 st respondent shall reconsider the matter and
issue a fresh order of assessment, after affording an opportunity of
being heard to the petitioner and after considering the contention
of the petitioner that he is entitled for the permissible deduction as
provided under Rule 2A of the Service Tax(Determination of
Values) Rule, 2006 and also to the benefit of Ext.P4 notification
No.30/2012 of the Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue,
Government of India as amended from time to time. Fresh orders of
assessment shall be passed within an outer limit of 3 months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
The writ petition is disposed of as above.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:8:
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 39617/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY AND
TREATMENT PARTICULARS OF THE PETITIONER
ISSUED BY AMRITA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL
SCIENCES AND RESEARCH CENTER, KOCHI ON
22.02.2021
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY ISSUED
TO THE PETITIONER BY MEDICAL TRUST
HOSPITAL, KOCHI ON 30.07.2022
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER-IN ORIGINAL NO.
07/2018-ST DATED 16.01.2018
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE SAID NOTIFICATION NO.
30/2012 DATED 20.06.2012
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE FORM OF APPEAL ALONG
WITH STATEMENT OF FACTS AND GROUND OF
APPEAL DATED 06.12.2018 WITHOUT THE
ANNEXURES
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE AFFIDAVIT DATED
06.12.2018
Exhibit P6(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATE
DATED 08.11.2018
Exhibit P6(B)
TRUE COPY OF THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATE
DATED 21.11.2018
Exhibit P6(c)
TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION FOR CONDONATION
OF DELAY DATED 06.12.2018
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE EMAIL COMMUNICATION
ISSUED ON 19.10.2022
2025:KER:28434
W.P.(C). No.39617 of 2022
:9:
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE COVERING LETTER DATED
11.11.2022 ALONG WITH THE WRITTEN
SUBMISSION IN SUPPORT OF CONDONATION OF
DELAY AND ON THE MERITS OF THE CASE
WITHOUT THE ANNEXURES MENTIONED THEREIN
DULY ACKNOWLEDGED BY THE OFFICE OF THE
2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER-IN-APPEAL NO. COCEXCUS-000-APP-347-2022 DATED 02.11.2022
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
24.11.2022 FILED BEFORE THE 1ST
RESPONDENT ALONG WITH THE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of reply dated 23.05.2017 to
show cause noticed No.12/2017-ST dated
23.03.2017
Exhibit R1(b)
True copy of inspection report
No.CERA(HQ)/2-5/ST/CHN/2015-16 dated
01.07.2015 of CERA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review