Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
WP (C) No. 43 of 2020
1.
Shri Roshan Giri
Aged about 39 years,
Son of Late Tika Ram Giri,
Resident of Lower Arithang,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Rajiv Giri,
Aged about 34 years,
Son of Late Tika Ram Giri,
Resident of Lower Arithang,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…PETITIONERS
Versus
1.
Shri Rakesh Gurung,
Son of Late Nar Prasad Gurung,
Aged about 43 years,
Resident of Lower Arithang,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim, PIN:737101.
Represented by:
Smt. Laxmi Chakraborty,
Constituted Attorney,
Resident of Lower Arithang,
P.O. and P.S. Gangtok.
East Sikkim, PIN:737101.
2.
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation,
Through its Commissioner,
Near Deorali, East Sikkim,
PIN-737102.
…RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CHIEF JUSTICE
For petitioners
:
Date of hearing &
judgment
:
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate, with Ms. Sushmita
Gurung, Advocate.
11.12.2020
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
( ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ )
This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is filed
against the order dated 24.10.2020, passed by the learned Civil Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, in Title Suit No. 25 of 2018, rejecting the counter-claim.
2.
It is to be noted that by the aforesaid order dated 24.10.2020, the
learned trial court had also rejected an application under Order 14 Rule 5
read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, for short, the
CPC, for framing of an additional issue. Against the rejection of the
application under Order 14 Rule 5 read with 151 CPC, the petitioners had
filed another petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, which is
registered as WP (C) No. 44 of 2020.
3.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has submitted
that the learned court below has committed illegality in rejecting the
counter-claim as after framing of issues, the case has not proceeded further.
He submits that though evidence of plaintiff and his constituted attorney had
been filed, same have not been authenticated and they are also not crossexamined, and therefore, there is no impediment in allowing the counterclaim.
4.
The petitioners are defendant nos.2 and 3 in the suit filed by the
respondent no.1 for declaration, recovery of possession, injunction and other
consequential reliefs. Defendant no.1 in the suit is Gangtok Municipal
Corporation through its Commissioner and defendant no.1 is arrayed as
respondent no.2 in the petition.
5.
The petitioners had filed written statement on 17.04.2019. The plaintiff
had filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
and same was allowed by the learned trial court .The plaintiff had filed
amended plaint on 06.02.2020. The written statement to the amended plaint
was filed by the present petitioners on 18.02.2020.
6.
Five issues were framed on 29.06.2020. The petitioners had filed the
counter–claim and the application under Order 14 Rule 5 read with Section
151 CPC on 07.09.2020.
7.
Having regard to the subject matter in dispute, it would be appropriate
to reproduce paragraph 26 of the amended written statement filed by the
petitioners. The same reads as follows:
“26. That with reference to the contents of paragraph 15 of the
plaint, it is humbly submitted that there was no effect of the
construction work resulting in the disconnection of the water pipelines
and any damage to underground electricity cables. The footpath did
suffer some damage which was restored immediately. It is further
submitted that there was no protest and opposition to the said work as
alleged by the plaintiff or at all such the allegations of challenging the
people complaining and violent retaliation to their protests does not
arise at all. It is denied that the plaintiff was even manhandled. Had
there been any incident of manhandling there would be an FIR to that
effect which is not there. The allegation that the answering defendants
terrorized the plaintiff and his family is false and utterly baseless and
vexatious. It is humble submitted that it is a common knowledge that
when the jhora was under construction by the government the plaintiff
objected to the ongoing construction when it came to his land stating
that there was no compensation was paid to him as such non concrete
drain
was
allowed
to
be
constructed
by
the
plaintiff
to
the
Government. There was only a kutcha drain. Meanwhile, the owners of
the adjoining buildings constructed the drain around their buildings on
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
their own. There is no column that has been erected on or over the
jhora/drain. It is reiterated that the blue print plan referred to by the
plaintiff is the old one prior to the diversion of the jhora flowing
through the landholding of the answering defendants. It is submitted
that the plaintiff one day told the Defendant No.3 that he could buy
some timber at more economic rate from one Mr. Jabber who was
head mason working in the construction work of the plaintiff’s sister.
The Defendant No.3 told the plaintiff that he could not buy the timber
at present since he had no place to store them. At this the plaintiff
asked Defendant No.3 to construct a store house or kutcha sheds in
their vacant land for storing the timbers and shuttering materials of
the answering defendants. After few such verbal assurances and
suggestions from the plaintiff the answering defendants constructed
the kutcha shed with the materials of the answering defendants. The
head mason, Mr. Jabber, working simultaneously as baidar for the
construction works of the plaintiff and his sister offered to sell some
timber to the answering defendants. Meanwhile there was some
dispute between the head mason and the plaintiff’s sister Mrs. Rajani
Gurung and brother-in-law (Rajani Gurung’s husband) over the said
timber. It is to be noted that the police had taken the timber to their
custody for some time and later they returned the said timber to Mr.
Jabber. Being confident that the dispute has been settled and Mr.
Jabber was the true owner of the timber, the answering defendants
bought the timber from him. The answering defendants also brought
their old timber stored in their old house and stored in the same
kutcha shed. On 20.12.2018 the plaintiff and his wife came to the said
kutcha shed and started taking out the timber stored therein without
informing the answering defendants. When the answering defendant
No.3 stopped them from doing so the plaintiff and his wife started
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
shouting by saying that the defendant No.3 had no papers to show
that the timber belonged to him. This resulted in some verbal
exchange of words between the plaintiff, his wife and the answering
defendant No.3 and his wife. It is further submitted that in one of the
evenings following the relevant day the defendant No.3 was called by
the plaintiff and his wife to their residence to talk the matter over.
They asked the defendant No.3 for Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh
only) if he wished to avoid the court case and also said that he should
forego all the timber kept in the said kutcha shed in favour of the
plaintiff. The plaintiff and his wife threatened the defendant No.3 that
if he refused to give them the amount demanded then they would
make sure that he has to go to courts for years on account of various
allegations that they could and would level against him. The answering
defendant No.3 did not oblige to such threats and told the plaintiff and
his wife that he would not yield to such extortionist method and ill will.
It is humbly submitted that this suit is the result of such refusal by the
answering defendant No.3.”
8.
Paragraphs 5 to 8 and part of paragraph 9 of the counter-claim are
more or less reproduction of the averments made in paragraph 26 of the
amended written statement. In paragraphs 9 and 10 of the counter-claim, it
is stated as follows:
“9.
That in one of the evenings following the instant event, the
Defendant No.3 was called by the plaintiff and his wife to their
residence to talk the matter over. They asked the Defendant No.3 for
Rs.1,00.000/- (Rupees one lakh only) if he wished to avoid the court
cases and also said that he should forego all the timber kept in the
said kutcha shed in favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff and his wife
threatened the Defendant No.3 that if he refused to give them the
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
amount demanded then they would make sure that he has to go to
courts for years on account of various allegations that they could and
would level against him. The Defendant No.3 did not oblige to such
threats and told the plaintiff and his wife that he would not yield to
such extortionist method and ill will. It is humbly submitted that the
suit of the plaintiff is the result of such refusal by the Defendant No.3.
Also the plaintiff and his wife told Defendant No.3 that if he wishes to
take away the timber and materials from the kutcha shed then he or
his brother (Defendant No.2) should show the No Objection Certificate
issued by the plaintiff for the construction of the said kutcha shed.
Further the plaintiff’s wife told the Defendant No.3 that they will file a
suit in the court and neither the plaintiff nor the Defendant Nos.2 and
3 shall touch the kutcha
shed till the disposal of the suit. The said
kutcha shed was then sealed with the nail. The plaintiff and his wife
are playing with the façade of the good will they projected and
afterwards turning against the Defendant No.2 and 3 to loot their
properties.”
10.
That after the said incident neither the Defendant No.2 and
Defendant No.3 nor the plaintiff and his wife had touched the said
Kutcha shed. However, sometime in the month of September 2019,
Smt. Yamuna Giri, the mother of the Defendant No.2 and Defendant
No.3 saw the plaintiff opening the said kutcha shed and taking some
timber away while the Defendant No.2 and Defendant No.3 were not at
home. When the suit was brought by the plaintiff the Defendant Nos. 2
and 3 had hoped that the disposal of the suit would bring an end to
their restriction imposed by the threat of the plaintiff for the access to
the said kutcha shed. The instant counter claim became necessary
when the plaintiff himself took away the materials belonging to
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
Defendant Nos.2 and 3 before the disposal of the suit brought by him
before this Hon’ble Court.”
9.
The details of timber, shuttering materials stated to be sold by Mr.
Jabbar to the petitioners are stated in paragraph 11. In paragraph 12, the
petitioners had stated about the timber and shuttering materials stored in
the said kutcha shed from their own house. It is stated in the counter-claim
that the total value of the materials stored in the kutcha house comes to
Rs.3,64,300/- and the damage caused to the materials as indicated in
paragraph 13 is valued at Rs.1,25,440/- and accordingly, the counter- claim
is valued at Rs.4,89,740/-. In the counter-claim, defendant nos.2 and 3
prayed for the following reliefs:
“20. That the Defendants Nos 2 and 3 therefore, pray for the
following relieves:
a.
An Order or decree directing the plaintiff to return all the
timber and shuttering materials including the bamboos if they
are not used by the plaintiff for any purpose.
Or in the alternative
A compensation amount of Rs.4,89,740/- (Rupees four
lakhs eighty nine thousand seven hundred and forty only) may
be paid to the Defendant Nos.2 and 3 by the plaintiff if the said
materials are used by the plaintiff for any purpose.
b.
A decree for pendent-lite and future interest at the rate of
12% from the date of the presentation of this counter claim i.e.
from 06.08.2020 til the final realization of the arrears amount
where the order for compensation is deemed fit by this Hon’ble
Court.
c.
Any other relief or relieves as this Hon’ble Court may deem
fit and proper under the present facts and circumstances.”
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
10.
The learned trial court noted that the issues were framed on
29.06.2020 and the evidence on affidavit of the plaintiff and the constituted
attorney were filed on 20.08.2020. The learned trial court relied on a
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ashok Kumar Kalra vs.
Surendra Agnihotri, reported in (2020) 2 SCC 394, and held that no
counter-claim can be allowed to be filed after framing of issues. Accordingly,
the counter-claim was rejected.
11.
Order 8 Rule 6A of the CPC reads as follows:
“6A. Counter-claim by defendant.- (1) A defendant in a suit may,
in addition to his right of pleading a set off under rule 6, set up,
by way of counter-claim against the claim of the plaintiff, any
right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to the
defendant against the plaintiff either before or after the filing of
to suit but before the defendant has delivered his defence or
before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired,
whether such counter-claim is in the nature of a claim for
damages or not:
Provided that such counter- claim shall not exceed the pecuniary
limits of the jurisdiction of the court.
(2) Such counter-claim shall have the same effect as a cross-suit
so as to enable the court to pronounce a final judgment in the
same suit, both on the original claim and on the counter-claim.
(3) The plaintiff shall be at liberty to file a written statement in
answer to the counter-claim of the defendant within such period
as may be fixed by the court.
(4) The counter-claim shall be treated as a plaint and governed
by the rules applicable to plaints.”
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
12.
The decision in Ashok Kumar Kalra (supra) was rendered by a 3-
Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court on a reference to consider,
amongst others, as to whether the language of Order 8 Rule 6A CPC is
mandatory in nature. In paragraph 18, the Hon’ble Supreme Court stated as
follows:
“18. As discussed by us in the preceding paragraphs, the whole
purpose of the procedural law is to ensure that the legal process
is made more effective in the process of delivering substantial
justice. Particularly, the purpose of introducing Rule 6-A in Order
8 CPC is to avoid multiplicity of proceedings by driving the
parties to file separate suit and see that the dispute between the
parties is decided finally. If the provision is interpreted in such a
way, to allow delayed filing of the counterclaim, the provision
itself becomes redundant and the purpose for which the
amendment is made will be defeated and ultimately it leads to
flagrant miscarriage of justice. At the same time, there cannot
be a rigid and hyper-technical approach that the provision
stipulates that the counterclaim has to be filed along with the
written statement and beyond that, the court has no power. The
courts, taking into consideration the reasons stated in support of
the counterclaim, should adopt a balanced approach keeping in
mind the object behind the amendment and to subserve the
ends of justice. There cannot be any hard and fast rule to say
that in a particular time the counterclaim has to be filed, by
curtailing the discretion conferred on the courts. The trial court
has to exercise the discretion judiciously and come to a definite
conclusion that by allowing the counterclaim, no prejudice is
caused to the opposite party, process is not unduly delayed and
the same is in the best interest of justice and as per the objects
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
sought to be achieved through the amendment. But however, we
are of the considered opinion that the defendant cannot be
permitted to file counterclaim after the issues are framed and
after the suit has proceeded substantially. It would defeat the
cause of justice and be detrimental to the principle of speedy
justice as enshrined in the objects and reasons for the particular
amendment to CPC.”
13.
Although the learned trial court had quoted Paragraph 21 of the
aforesaid judgement, it would be appropriate to reproduce the same in this
order also for better appreciation:
“21. We sum up our findings, that Order 8 Rule 6-A CPC does
not put an embargo on filing the counterclaim after filing the
written statement, rather the restriction is only with respect to
the accrual of the cause of action. Having said so, this does not
give absolute right to the defendant to file the counterclaim with
substantive delay, even if the limitation period prescribed has
not elapsed. The court has to take into consideration the outer
limit for filing the counterclaim, which is pegged till the issues
are framed. The court in such cases have the discretion to
entertain
filing
of
the
counterclaim,
after
taking
into
consideration and evaluating inclusive factors provided below
which are only illustrative, though not exhaustive:
(i) Period of delay.
(ii) Prescribed limitation period for the cause of action pleaded.
(iii) Reason for the delay.
(iv) Defendant's assertion of his right.
(v) Similarity of cause of action between the main suit and the
counterclaim.
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
(vi) Cost of fresh litigation.
(vii) Injustice and abuse of process.
(viii) Prejudice to the opposite party.
(ix) And facts and circumstances of each case.
(x) In any case, not after framing of the issues.”
14.
From the above, it is seen that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has made it
clear in illustration (x) that in any case, discretion to entertain filing of the
counter-claim cannot be exercised after framing of issues.
15.
It will also be necessary to refer to the judgment of Hon’ble Mohan M.
Shantanagoudar,J,
in
the
aforesaid
case.
His
Lordship
had
partly
supplemented and partly dissented to the judgment noted above. His
Lordship at paragraph 60 of the judgment observed as follows:
“60. Having considered the previous judgments of this Court on
counterclaims, the language employed in the rules related
thereto, as well as the intention of the legislature, I conclude
that it is not mandatory for a counterclaim to be filed along with
the written statement. The court, in its discretion, may allow a
counterclaim to be filed after the filing of the written statement,
in view of the considerations mentioned in the preceding
paragraph. However, propriety requires that such discretion
should
ordinarily
be
exercised
to
allow
the
filing
of
a
counterclaim till the framing of issues for trial. To this extent, I
concur with the conclusion reached by my learned Brothers.
However, for the reasons stated above, I am of the view that in
exceptional circumstances, a counterclaim may be permitted to
be
filed
after
a
written
statement
till
the
stage
of
commencement of recording of the evidence on behalf of the
plaintiff.”
WP(C)No. 43 of 2020
Roshan Giri & Anr. Vs. Rakesh Gurung & Anr.
16.
In the instant case, the counter-claim was filed after issues were
framed and the plaintiff and his constituted attorney had filed evidence and
therefore, there is no merit in this petition. Resultantly, the petition is
dismissed.
( Chief Justice )
Jk/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review