Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: WP(C) No. 2817/2021
c/w
WP(C) No.2818/2021
Reserved on : 11.09.2026
Pronounced on : 18.09.2026
Uploaded on:18 .09.2026
Roshan Begum and others
a/w connected matter(s).
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Gagan Basotra, Sr. Advocate with Ms.
Purvehi Khajuria, Advocate
Mr. M.Nadeem Bhat, Advocate
Vs.
UT of J&K and others
…. Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Eishaan Dadhichi, CGSC
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG with Mr. Vishal
Gupta, Advocate
Ms. Sagira Jaffar, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioners, through the medium of these petitions, have inter alia
challenged the acquisition proceedings initiated by the respondents
pursuant to Notification No. 94-100/SDM/G/Gref dated 27.10.2016
issued under Section 4 of the Jammu and Kashmir Land Acquisition
Act, 1990, for construction of the Gool-Budhan road under GREF.
Challenge has also been thrown to Award No. 86-93/SDM/G/Gref
dated 04.07.2018 passed by respondent No. 3 in respect of land
measuring 136 Kanals and 3½ Marlas situated at Village Gool. The
petitioners have also sought a direction for initiation of fresh land
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
acquisition proceedings in respect of their proprietary land, which has
come under acquisition.
2. According to the petitioners, the Government decided to construct a
road from Gool to Budhan of Village Gool, District Ramban. For the
said purpose, they proposed to acquire the private land, houses, and
shops possessed by different persons, including the petitioners. In this
regard, a Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1990 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) came to be issued on
27.10.2016 for acquisition of land measuring 136 Kanals and 3½
Marlas, and possession of the said land was taken over by GREF. It
has been submitted that the Notification under Section 4 of the Act
has not been issued by adhering to the said provision, inasmuch as it
has not been published in accordance with the requirements thereof.
According to the petitioners, a declaration under Section 6 of the Act
was issued on 16.08.2017, and even at that stage, the mandate of law
was not followed. Thereafter, Notifications under Sections 9 and 9-A
of the Act came to be issued on 23.08.2017. It has been submitted that
the impugned tentative award dated 04.07.2018 came to be issued, but
thereafter, no final award has been passed by the Collector till date.
Thus, in terms of Section 11-B of the Land Acquisition Act, the
acquisition proceedings have lapsed. The petitioners have admitted
that they have received 80% of the compensation for the land, but the
same was received by them under protest.
3. The contention of the petitioners is that, because the Collector has not
passed the award within the stipulated period of two years from the
date of publication of the declaration under Section 6 of the Act, the
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
proceedings have lapsed, and the respondents are legally obliged to
initiate fresh land acquisition proceedings under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act of
2013”).
4. The respondent-Collector, in reply to the petition, has submitted that
the road was constructed way back in the year 1960 by the PWD.
However, in the 1990s, the GREF took over the said road for defence
purposes, and the same was upgraded by the GREF from time to time.
It has been submitted that, in the year 2012-2013, the landowners
approached different authorities and also served a notice under
Section 80 CPC, with the demand that the land underlying the road be
acquired under the J&K Land Acquisition Act, so that they could
receive compensation.
5. Accordingly, in the year 2016, the land acquisition proceedings were
initiated, and a Notification under Section 4 of the Act was issued. It
has been submitted that the contention of the petitioners that they
were unaware of the issuance of the Notification under Section 4 of
the Act is misleading. It has been submitted that the landowners
remained present on the spot at the time of preparation of the revenue
papers. According to the Collector, all the mandatory provisions
envisaged under the J&K Land Acquisition Act were followed, and
the award was passed on 04.07.2018. It has been submitted that the
assessment of two structures could not be made by the PWD, R&B, as
the landowners resisted the taking of measurements of these
structures, due to which the final award could not be issued. It has
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
also been submitted that, due to the outbreak of COVID-19 in the year
2020-2021, the assessment of the structures was delayed. It has been
submitted that the intending department could not make the funds
available due to paucity of funds. It is being submitted that the period
of 2020-2021 needs to be excluded for computing the period of two
years in terms of Section 11-B of the Land Acquisition Act, as the
COVID-19 pandemic was prevailing during the said period. It has
been submitted that 80% of the payment has been made to the
landowners.
6. The intending department-respondent No. 4 has also filed objections
to the writ petition. In the objections, it has been submitted that, in the
year 1995, the existing road was approved for improvement and is
presently being maintained under Scale-II maintenance grant by 110
RCC/31 TF Project Sampark. It has been submitted that the width of
the road is presently 18.30 metres and that compensation has already
been paid for the stretch between Budhal and Budhan in respect of
this width of the road.
7. According to respondent No. 4, a draft award amounting to Rs.
9,97,56,675/- was submitted by the Collector, Gool, vide his
communication dated 04.07.2018, and a tentative amount of Rs.
210.00 lakhs on account of compensation for structures was also
submitted vide letter dated 08.09.2018. It has been submitted that
respondent No. 4 expressed his inability to prepare the estimate for
release of funds for want of the final award. Ultimately, the final
award was issued by the Collector vide his communication dated
22.12.2018, without being accompanied by supporting documents,
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
and the issue was again taken up with the Collector vide
communication dated 05.01.2019. The final award for the balance
stretch from Budhan to Gool, along with all the documents, was
issued by the Collector, Gool, vide his communication dated
29.01.2019.
8. It has been submitted that, in terms of the said award, a projection for
funds amounting to Rs. 9,97,56,675/- was made to the Headquarters
vide communication dated 18.07.2019. It has been submitted that the
projected estimate was re-costed to Rs. 9,96,37,910/- as some portion
of the State land was also included in the apportionment statement,
and a fresh projection was forwarded to the Headquarters on
12.02.2021. It has been submitted that, vide Cheque No. 066943 dated
13.03.2021, an amount of Rs. 9,96,37,908/- on account of
compensation for 136 Kanals 3½ Marlas of land was deposited with
the Collector for disbursement to the rightful claimants.
9. It has been submitted that the compensatory payment in respect of 13
structures will be processed as soon as the valuation sheet from the
Collector is received, and a demand in this regard was made to the
Collector vide communication dated 28.07.2022. According to
respondent No. 4, the petitioners have admitted receipt of 80% of the
compensation amount and, as such, they are estopped from
questioning the validity of the award.
10.I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of
the case including the record produced by the Collector.
11.There is no dispute as to the legal position that, if the award is not
made by the Collector within two years of the issuance of the
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
declaration under Section 6 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act, the
provisions of Section 11-B of the said Act come into play, and the
entire acquisition proceedings lapse, whereafter fresh acquisition
proceedings have to be initiated. The question that arises for
determination in the present case is whether the Collector has failed to
make the final award within the stipulated period of two years from
the date of issuance of the declaration under Section 6 of the Act. In
the present case, the declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued
by the Government on 16.08.2017. The award, which is termed by the
petitioners as a “tentative award” and by the intending department as a
“final award”, was issued on 04.07.2018. The determination of the
issue as to whether the land acquisition proceedings have lapsed
would depend upon the determination of the question as to whether
the award dated 04.07.2018 is a tentative award or a final award.
12.If we have a look at the award dated 04.07.2018, it is recorded therein
that the Deputy Commissioner, Ramban, vide his communication
dated 31.03.2017, has mentioned the stamp duty rates in respect of
Village Gool as Rs. 3,78,000/- per kanal pertaining to the un-irrigated
type of land. It has been further noted in the award that a meeting of
the Collector Committee was fixed on 27.09.2017 under the
Chairmanship of the District Collector, Ramban, and all the Collectors
unanimously adopted the rates of Rs. 4,50,000/- per kanal for the unirrigated type of land. The award goes on to record that the
compensation for land measuring 136 Kanals and 3½ Marlas, which is
equivalent to 88 Kanals 10 Marlas, has been worked out at Rs.
3,98,25,000/-. Besides this, the compensation for the structures has
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
been worked out at Rs. 4,22,34,000/-. However, the compensation in
respect of the structures has been assessed on a tentative basis, as it is
recorded in the award that the assessment of structures has been
received from the PWD in part and that the assessment of structures in
respect of 13 owners is pending with the PWD. It has been further
recorded that the final award will be issued after receiving the pending
assessment of the structures from the PWD.
13.Thus, insofar as the compensation for the land is concerned, a final
decision has been taken by the Collector vide award dated 04.07.2018.
The final decision with regard to compensation on account of
structures has not been taken and to that extent, award dated
04.07.2018 is provisional in nature. Insofar as the compensation for
the land, including Jabarana and incidental charges, is concerned, a
final decision has been taken by the Collector, and to this extent, the
award can be termed a “final award”, notwithstanding the fact that in
the concluding paragraph, the Collector has used the words “tentative
proposal”. This is so because to the extent of assessment of land
compensation, the Collector was not required to get any further
information or approval.
14.Section 11 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act deals with the award of
the Collector. The competent authority to make the award is the
Collector. It provides that the Collector, after making inquiries into
the objections received pursuant to the notice given under Section 9,
the measurements made under Section 8, the value of the land and the
data published in the notification under sub-section (1) of Section 4,
and the respective interests of the persons claiming compensation, as
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
also the objections of the Head of the Department or his nominee
pursuant to the notice given under Section 9-A, shall tentatively assess
the compensation which, in his opinion, should be allowed for the
land. Sub-section (2) of Section 11 mandates that, if the compensation
tentatively assessed by the Collector under sub-section (1) exceeds the
amount specified by the Government by notification, he has to refer
the record of the case, along with a statement of the tentative
assessment of compensation, for approval of the Revenue Minister or
an Officer specially empowered by him in this behalf. Section 12 of
the Land Acquisition Act makes the award of the Collector final and
conclusive between the Collector and the persons interested, except in
cases as provided in the said Act.
15.In the present case, the rate of compensation assessed by the Collector
did not exceed the amount specified by the Government by any
Notification. Therefore, once the Collector decided to adopt the
particular rates for assessing the compensation for the land, the same
was not required to be sent to the Revenue Minister or any other
authority for approval. In fact, in the award dated 04.07.2018, the
Collector has nowhere stated that he was sending the rates assessed by
him for approval of any higher authority, meaning thereby that the
award in question, insofar as it related to the compensation for the
land, was final and had become binding between the parties, subject to
its challenge by way of reference or otherwise.
16.In fact, the term “tentative award”, which has been used by the
petitioners in the writ petitions and by the Collector in his reply, is a
misnomer and does not find mention in any of the provisions of the
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
Land Acquisition Act. Once the competent authority, i.e. the
Collector, has finalized the rates of compensation, the award of
compensation in terms of the said rates becomes a final award, unless
it requires approval by a higher authority in the situation contemplated
under Section 11 of the Act. As already stated, in the present case,
there was no requirement of approval of rates by a higher authority
insofar as the compensation for the land is concerned, as such, the
award, to the extent of compensation for the land, had become final.
17.Pursuant to the passing of the aforesaid award, the petitioners have
admittedly accepted 80% of the compensation for the land. They have
stated that they accepted the compensation under protest, but the
record produced by the Collector does not suggest so.Once they have
accepted the land compensation, they cannot turn around to challenge
the award under which they have received the compensation without
demur.
18.A similar question came up for consideration before the Supreme
Court in the case of Mohanji and another Vs. State of U.P. and
others, reported as 1995 JT (SC) 8 599. In the said case, a contention
was raised that the award passed was only in respect of the vacant
land and not in respect of the building constructed thereon and,
therefore, no award had been made within the specified period as
required under Section 11-A of the Central Act. Since a piecemeal
award is not contemplated thereunder, the Supreme Court, while
considering this aspect observed as under:“5. It is no doubt true that the entire award which is
contemplated u/s 11 of the Act by virtue of the prescription in
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
Section 11A has to be made within the period of two years
failing which the entire proceeding shall lapse. The question is
whether it can be said in the present case that no award has
been made u/s 11 of the Act in this proceeding? In our view it
cannot be said that no award u/s 11 has been made for the land
acquired. Admittedly, compensation has been determined in the
award so made for the entire area of 0.99 acres. In view of the
fact that no piecemeal award by making a subsequent award
after the expiry of the period of two years is contemplated in
law, the award dated 23.9.1986 must be construed as the whole
award made u/s 11 awarding compensation for the entire area
of 0.99 acres with no compensation awarded for the building.
The Appellants, therefore, had the right to claim compensation
for the building by seeking a reference u/s 18 of the Act treating
the award as one in which compensation had been determined
and awarded only for the entire land measuring 0.99 acres but
no compensation was awarded for the building therein. The
Appellants had the remedy to claim compensation for the
building in accordance with law treating the award made as
not awarding any compensation for the building. That is,
however, a different matter and it does not require any further
consideration in this context. It is sufficient to say that the
award dated 23.9.1986 made within the period specified in
Section 11A of the Act must be construed as an award u/s 11 in
the proceedings for acquisition of the Appellants' land bearing
Plot No. 1311 having a total area of 0.99 acres. The contention
that the entire proceeding for acquisition of the land has lapsed
by virtue of Section 11A cannot, therefore, be accepted.”
19.Again, the Supreme Court, in State of Punjab and others Vs.
Sharan Pal Singh, reported as 1996 (11) SCC 683, after relying upon
the ratio laid down in Mohanji’s case (supra), held that an award in
respect of the land, where the determination of compensation for the
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
superstructures and trees standing thereon was left to be made
separately, has to be construed as a complete award in terms of
Section 11 of the Act, and the contention to the contrary cannot be
sustained.
20.In view of the aforesaid legal position, it is clear that, even if the
award dated 04.07.2018 passed by the Collector-respondent is not
final to the extent of compensation in respect of the superstructures
existing on the land, nonetheless, it is an award in terms of Section 11
of the Act insofar as it pertains to the assessment of compensation for
the acquired land. The said award has to be construed as an award
under Section 11 of the Land Acquisition Act, and it cannot be stated
that the land acquisition proceedings have lapsed in the present case.
The writ petitioners cannot challenge the award after having received
80% of the compensation under the said award without any protest.
21.For the foregoing reasons, I do not find any merit in these writ
petitions, which are accordingly dismissed. The respondent-Collector
is directed to disburse the balance amount to the rightful claimants
and he shall also proceed to conclude the assessment of compensation
in respect of the left-out structures by passing a supplementary award
as expeditiously as possible.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
18.09.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
WP(C) No. 2817/2021 c/w
WP(C) No. 2818/2021
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.09.18 16:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review