Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 99
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.2788/2022
CM Nos. 7754 & 7807/2022,
4537/2023, 6344, 2152 & 5201/2024
& 4525/2026
Reserved on: 24.07.2026
Pronounced on: 12.08.2026
Uploaded on: 12.08.2026
Operative part or Full judgment: Full
Rohit Sharma (Aged 38 years)
S/O Sh. Ashok Kumar
R/O 55-F, Lower Shiv Nagar,
Behind AG Office, Jammu
Through: Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Adv with
Mr. Parimoksh Seth, Advocate.
Vs
1. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
through Chief Secretary,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
2. Financial Commissioner,
Home Department
Civil Secretariat, Jammu
3. Director General,
Jammu & Kashmir Police,
Police Headquarters, Jammu/Srinagar.
4. Director, Anti-Corruption Bureau,
J&K, Jammu
5. Sr. Superintendent of Police,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, Jammu.
6. Incharge, Anti Corruption Bureau,
Rajouri.
7. Sh. Dalip Kumar,
Sr. Superintendent of Police,
Anti-Corruption Bureau,
Jammu Range, Jammu.
8. Sh. Joginder Singh,
Sr. Superintendent of Police,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, PR Range.
9. Sh. Sunny Gupta,
Dy. Superintendent of Police,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, PR Range.
10. Sh. Jatinder Raina, Inspector,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, PR Range.
…..Petitioner(s)
11. Sh. Raj Kumar Dhar, Inspector,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, PR range.
12. Sh. Shamim Bhat, Inspector,
Anti-Corruption Bureau, PR Range.
13. Sominder Singh @ Sourav
S/O Darshan Singh
R/O Village Nari, Tehsil R S Pura.
14. Central Bureau of Investigation
Anveshan Bhawan, Rail Head Complex,
Panama Chowk, Jammu-180012.
Through: Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, AC for R-1 to 12
Mr. P N Raina, Sr. Adv with
Mr. J A Hamal, Advocate for R-8&9.
Mr. D. S. Saini, Advocate for R-13.
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. Nazia Fazal, AC for R-14.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MA CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Petitioner, a Tehsildar born on the cadre of J&K Administrative
Services, found to be involved in corrupt practice, on the basis of a trap laid by
Anti-corruption Bureau (ACB) of J&K, regarding which a case was registered
vide FIR No.02/2022 dated 14.11.2022, U/S 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act
(for short ‘P.C. Act’), through the medium of this petition, under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, has prayed for the following reliefs:i)
An appropriate writ, order or direction in the nature of writ of
mandamus commanding the respondents to constitute a Special
Investigating Team (SIT) consisting of officers of undisputed
reputation, honesty and professional brilliance to be headed by
an officer not below the rank of Dy. Inspector General of
Police for investigating a highly dramatized, false and
fabricated trap case made by police officers of Anti-Corruption
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
Bureau in which petitioner has been wrongly and falsely
implicated;
ii) An appropriate writ, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus directing respondent Nos.1 to 3 to immediately seize
the electronic devices/records of CCTV installed in the premises
where the office of Tehsildar, Bahu, Jammu is located and
which is in possession of owner of the building and sent the
same for evaluation by Central Forensic Science Laboratory
and for production of the FSL report before this court in a
sealed cover; and
iii) An appropriate writ, order or direction in the nature of writ of
certiorari quashing FIR No. 02/2022 dated 14.11.2022
registered with Police Station, Anti-Corruption Bureau,
Rajouri (Camp Jammu) under Section 7 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988 against the petitioner.
02.
Brief facts of the case are that a written complaint was received by
ACB Rajouri (Camp Jammu) on 01.11.2022 from one-Saminder Singh @
Sourav regarding demand of bribe of Rs.2.00 lakh, from him by Tehsildar Bahu
namely Rohit Sharma, (petitioner herein), in lieu of issuance of a fard intikhab
in the name of complainant’s mother Kuldeep Kour; that the complainant, not
ready and willing to pay the bribe to the petitioner, approached the ACB for
taking necessary action into the matter; that the allegation of demand of bribe
was verified by respondent No.8, through an officer of the ACB, who perused
the voice recording of conversation held between the complainant and the
petitioner and submitted his report on 14.11.2022, and based on the complaint
and report of verifying officer, prima facie, commission of offence punishable
u/s 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act 1988, was found made out against the
petitioner and accordingly, formal case FIR was lodged and the investigation
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
was entrusted to respondent No.9, who was also nominated as the trap laying
officer (TLO); that a trap team was constituted, which after completing the pretrap proceedings laid a trap in presence of independent witnesses in Tehsil
Office Bahu, Jammu on 14.11.2022, and caught the petitioner red handed
alongwith the bribe amount of Rs.50,000/-, that the petitioner was formally
arrested and lodged in P/S Pacca Danga, Jammu; that search of the residential
house of the petitioner was also conducted; that the accused was admitted to bail
by this court vide order dated 21.11.2022; that the investigation of the case,
which was initially registered at P/S ACB PR (Camp Jammu) was thereafter
transferred to P/S ACB JSK Range by the ACB Hqrs, however, later Govt. of
J&K vide its order No. GAD-VIGOSP/7/2023-04-GAD dated 18.01.2023
transferred the investigation of the case from ACB to Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI), Jammu.
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE
03.
In the aforesaid backdrop of the case, the petitioner has approached
this court seeking the reliefs as prayed for, on the following grounds:
(i)
That the impugned FIR lodged against the petitioner has no
sanctity in the eyes of law as well as under the Code of
Criminal Procedure;
(ii)
That ACB, Rajouri Poonch Range does not have jurisdiction to
register the complaint or lodge FIR in the matter when neither
the complainant belongs to District Rajouri nor the petitioner
was serving in District Rajouri or District Poonch;
(iii)
That the investigation in FIR No.02/2022 dated 14.11.2022
registered with Police Station Anti-Corruption Bureau, Rajouri
(Camp Jammu) being carried out by the respondent is totally a
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
sham investigation just to punish the petitioner in a highly
motivated trap case;
(iv)
That the CCTV camera footage, which is in the public domain,
clearly indicates that the whole trap was a farce as the trap was
laid down only to falsely implicate the petitioner; and
(v)
that to avenge from petitioner, the impugned FIR is lodged,
which does not sustain in the eye of law and requires to be
quashed.
REPLY/OBJECTIONS
04.
In the objections filed by respondents no.1 to 12, it is contended that
the petition is non maintainable as the same is against the provisions of Criminal
Procedure Code; that the petition has been filed with mala fide intentions; that
the petitioner has been caught red handed while demanding and accepting bribe
from complainant for issuance of revenue extracts; that the impugned FIR was
registered after verifying the allegations of complaint through verifying officer
regarding demand of bribe by accused/petitioner; that the petitioner has not
approached the court with clean hands as there is suppression and concealment
of material facts; that the petitioner has raised various disputed questions of
facts, which cannot be adjudicated in the instant petition; that the ACB has
proceeded strictly in accordance with law and there is no abuse of any process of
law; that the allegations mentioned in the complaint and subsequent preliminary
pre-trap verification do, prima facie, established a case of demand of bribe in
lieu of issuance of the revenue extract from the complainant and thus constituted
an offence under the provisions of J&K PC Act, 2006 against the petitioner; that
the petition is completely devoid of any merit and substance; that the allegations
leveled against ACB for its connivance with the complainant to falsely implicate
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
him are bald and farce allegations; that there is no truth in the assertions made
by the petitioner against the ACB; that the CBI has also found commission of
alleged offences against the petitioner, which has vindicated the stand of ACB;
that all the factual and legal grounds raised by the petitioner can be raised before
the Trial Court; `that the petitioner cannot ask for changing the Investigating
Agency or do investigation in the particular manner including for court
monitored investigation. Finally, it is prayed that instant petition be dismissed in
the interest of justice.
05.
In his reply/objections, respondent No.13-complainant, has contended
that the investigation in FIR No.02/2022 registered with Police Station, Anti
Corruption Bureau, Rajouri (Camp Jammu) against the petitioner has been
transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation and the Agency has conducted
a fair investigation, which does not call for any interference by this court; that
the petitioner has levelled false allegations against the complainant that he has
forged the signatures of the Deputy Commissioner regarding attestation of
mutation for land measuring 26 kanals 11 marlas comprising of khasra No.6,
situate at Bahu Rakh Narwal, Jammu, however, forensic analysis of forged
signatures and that of the complainant conducted by J&K FSL, Jammu has no
resemblance; that the petitioner has demanded and accepted bribe from the
complainant, and therefore, he be brought to justice. Lastly, it is prayed that
petition be dismissed and the CBI be directed to proceed against the petitioner in
accordance with law.
06.
Respondent No.14-CBI has filed reply/objections, wherein, it has
been, inter alia, stated that petitioner does not have any authority to dictate the
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
manner in which the investigation is to be conducted; that the writ petition filed
by the petitioner is non-maintainable and deserves to be dismissed, outrightly, as
the investigation stands completed and the CBI is under a legal obligation to
prosecute the petitioner; that the choice of investigative techniques and
procedure fall under the purview of the investigating agency; that the case
RC0042023A0006 was re-registered by CBI on the reference of Govt. of J&K
transferring the investigation of impugned FIR No.2/2022 of PS ACB Rajouri
registered against the petitioner at the instance of complainant-Saminder Singh
@ Gourav; that the Govt. Order transferring the investigation from ACB to CBI
and RC registered by the CBI thereafter, were never assailed by the petitioner.
Finally, it is prayed that the writ petition be dismissed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETITONER
07.
Mr. Sunil Sethi, learned Sr. Counsel assisted by Mr. Parimoksh Seth,
Adv. appearing on behalf of the petitioner, argued that the Anti Corruption
Bureau, Rajouri Poonch Range has no jurisdiction to register the complaint or
lodge FIR in the instant case, as neither the complainant nor the petitioner was
serving in District Rajouri or District Pooch; that the petitioner has been falsely
implicated in the farce trap, which is no trap in fact but a tool employed by the
complainant in connivance with govt. officials to take revenge, for, the
petitioner, as Tehsildar Bahu, who was asked to enquire with respect to a forged
mutation pertaining to land measuring 26 Kanal 06 marlas falling in Khasra
No.06 (old) /32 (new) attested in favour of complainant, had reported to the
Deputy Commissioner, Jammu against the complainant that no such mutation
exists on record and further requested enquiry in the matter; that the
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
complainant, who filed the complaint against the petitioner, is absconding due to
his alleged involvement in FIR No.276/2019 dated 26.10.2019, registered at P/S
Bahu Fort against the complainant, at the instance of petitioner herein; that the
petitioner has been made scapegoat at the instance of the vested interests.
Finally, it is prayed that impugned FIR be quashed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF ACB
08.
Mr. Raman Sharma, learned AAG assisted by Ms. Saliqa Sheikh,
Advocate appearing for respondents no.1 to 12 has submitted that all the factual
and legal grounds raised by the petitioner, in support of his case, can be raised
before the Trial Court and no prejudice has been caused on jurisdictional aspects
of lodging FIR, to the petitioner, so as to warrant quashing of FIR, particularly,
so when the premier national investigating agency Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI), on transfer of the case to it, during investigation has found
merit and substance and concluded the investigation into a charge sheet against
the petitioner, as has been submitted by learned CBI counsel. He further submits
that the allegations of connivance of the ACB officers, with the complainant to
frame and falsely implicate the petitioner, who had reported against the
complainant, in a departmental enquiry to have forged signatures of DC Jammu,
with regard to attestation of mutation in the name of complainant’s mother, get
evaporated, for the reason that CBI has also found commission of alleged
offences against the petitioner. Had there been any truth in petitioner’s CBI
would have taken note of the same. And even complainant has been chargesheeted in the case registered against him, as such, there cannot be case of any
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
connivance of the ACB, as alleged. He finally prayed that the petition be
dismissed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENTS 8 & 9
09.
Mr. P N Raina, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. J.A. Hamal,
also appearing for respondents 8 and 9 submitted that complaint was lodged
with SSP, ACB, which disclosed cognizable offence, as such, after preliminary
verification, a case was registered; that, even if, respondents 8 and 9 had no
jurisdiction, however, lodging of FIR with cognizable offences not having
jurisdiction, cannot be quashed in the instant petition; that conversation of
complainant and petitioner recorded was confirmed and that there was no mala
fide; that in trap, money received with their scientific proof was recovered; that
the Vigilance Organization has taken extraordinary caution in the matter; that
the voice samples were proved by the FSL; that Section 156(2) CrPC bars to
throw challenge in such a situation as has been held in Supreme Court in its
judgment reported as (1999) 8 SCC 720; that the case was transferred to the
concerned police station the very next day on 15.11.2022; that during
investigation by the ACB, the matter got transferred to the CBI, who reregistered RC and that very RC has not been challenged, anywhere, by the
petitioner; that neither the government order transferring the investigation to
CBI nor RC registered with CBI were challenged; that in that view of the matter,
constitution of an SIT is infructuous; that an accused cannot demand specific
investigating agency or a court monitored SIT, in view of the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported as (2018) 10 SCC 753; that the FIR lodged
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
against complainant to have forged signatures of DC Jammu has also been
transferred to the CBI. Finally, it is prayed that the petition be dismissed.
Submissions on behalf of respondent No.13-complainant
10.
Mr. D S Saini, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent
no.13-complainant argued that FIR No.02/2022 has rightly been registered
against the petitioner under the relevant provisions of J&K PC Act, 2006, as he
was found demanding and accepting bribe from the complainant red handed, in
a trap case, in the presence of independent witnesses; that it is a bald allegation
that complainant forged signatures of the then Deputy Commissioner, as is
evident from the FSL report, which, in unequivocal terms, indicated that the
forged signatures are not that of the complainant; that no cameras were installed
in the office room of the petitioner; that the investigation of FIR No.2/2022
registered with Police Station Anti Corruption Bureau, Rajouri (Camp Jammu)
was got transferred to CBI, who has completed the investigation in a fair and
impartial manner; that a false case vide FIR No.276/2019 was registered against
the complainant at Police Station Bahu Fort, Jammu; that factually incorrect
assertions have been made by the petitioner in his petition against the
complainant. Lastly, it is prayed that the writ petition be dismissed and the
petitioner-accused, be brought to justice.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF CBI-respondent No.14.
11.
Mrs. Monika Kohli, learned Sr. Adv. assisted by Ms. Nazia Fazal,
Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent No.14-CBI argued that the
petition has become infructuous with the handing over of the investigation to
CBI; that the manner of investigation cannot be dictated by the accused as has
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
been urged in this petition; that the CBI was impleaded as respondent No.14 on
07.08.2023; that the investigation in the instant case is complete and the CBI is
under legal obligation to prosecute the accused; that the allegation of ‘sham trap’
was also looked into by the Agency but has found nothing worth consideration;
that shielding of ACB officers by the CBI is a false and baseless allegation; that
petitioner has neither challenged the investigation conducted by the CBI nor it
has thrown challenge to the Government Order, transferring investigation or to
the Regular Case registered by the CBI; that no relief can be granted beyond the
pleadings and prayers contained in the writ petition; that the petitioner is barred
by the doctrines of approbation and reprobation, acquiescence and estoppel,
from challenging the investigation conducted by the CBI; that a statutory duty is
cast upon the CBI to submit the charge sheet upon completion of the
investigation and in this regard, as such, it may be permitted to lay charge sheet.
Lastly, it is submitted that the petition be dismissed. In support of her
contentions, Mrs. Kohli has referred and relied upon judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the following cases:
‘Romila Thapar V. Union of India’ [(2018) 10 SCC 753]; and
‘P. Chidambaram V. Directorate of Enforcement’ [(2019) 9 SCC 24].
12.
In rebuttal, Mr. Sethi, learned senior counsel would argue, that the
CBI investigation is merely a continuation of the ACB investigation and,
therefore, challenge to the original FIR is sufficient without assailing transfer of
the case from J&K ACB to CBI or/and re-registration of the case by the CBI;
that completion of investigation is no bar for this court to order investigation
afresh by constituting an SIT; that it is not forthcoming from record that who
took the voice recording of the petitioner; that voice recording between the
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
complainant and accused cannot be certified; that whole of the investigation had
already been conducted by the ACB before transferring the case to CBI; that the
complainant has not stated any good reason as to why he approached
respondents 6 and 7, who had no territorial jurisdiction; that the complainant has
been charged by the CBI for having forged the signatures of Deputy
Commissioner, Jammu, for which two challans were filed against him; that in
the case relied upon is not applicable, since the Magistrate had ordered the filing
of case, therefore, police cannot decide jurisdiction; that role of ACB officers
requires to be looked into.
13.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length, perused the record and
considered.
14.
From the pleadings and the rival submissions made by the learned
counsel for the parties, the two main questions fall for consideration of this
court: first, that whether the impugned FIR and the proceedings arising out of it
are liable to be quashed for the reason that the case was registered with P/S ACB
Rajouri (Camp Jammu) beyond its territorial jurisdiction, and second, that the
petitioner had been falsely implicated by the complainant in the case, due to
enmity, as a result of the enquiry conducted by the petitioner as Tehsildar Bahu,
with regard to Mutation of land, measuring more than 26 kanals, comprising of
Khasra No.6, situated at Bahu Rakh Narwal, Jammu under the forged signatures
of Deputy Commissioner Jammu, regarding which an FIR No. 276/2019 dated
26.10.219 at P/S Bahu Fort, was registered against the accused, including
respondent no.1/complainant in this case, in order to wreak vengeance against
the petitioner, who had not succumbed to his temptations and withstood all
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
temptations and formulated a report against all the accused persons including the
complainant.
15.
The first question which requires to be addressed by this court is with
regard to the fact that the impugned FIR was lodged and case was registered at
P/S ACB Rajouri camping at Jammu, which had territorial jurisdiction over the
districts of Poonch and Rajouri, as such, whether in a matter relating to Jammu
District, the Police Station concerned had no territorial jurisdiction.
16.
It will be relevant to reproduce Section 156 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, which deals with powers of an investigating agency to investigate the
matter in cognizable cases. The same is reproduced as under:
“156. Police officer’s power to investigate cognizable case.—
(1) Any officer in charge of a police station may, without the order
of a Magistrate, investigate any cognizable case which a Court
having jurisdiction over the local area within the limits of such
station would have power to inquire into or try under the
provisions of Chapter XIII.
(2) No proceeding of a police officer in any such case shall at any
stage be called in question on the ground that the case was
one which such officer was not empowered under this section
to investigate.
(3) Any Magistrate empowered under Section 190 may order such
an investigation as above-mentioned.”
17.
A case registered even beyond the territorial jurisdiction, cannot be
quashed on that ground, in view of provision of sub section (2) of Section 156
CrPC. The matter relating to registration of the case at the police station beyond
the jurisdiction of the place of occurrence has been dealt with by the Apex Court
in many judgments. It is settled by a long course of decisions of the Apex Court
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
that for purposes of exercising the power under Section 482 CrPC to quash an
FIR or complaint, the High Court would have to proceed entirely on the basis of
the allegations made in the complaint or the documents accompanying the same
per se and it had no jurisdiction to examine the correctness or otherwise of the
allegations. The Apex Court in a case titled ‘Satvinder Kaur V. State (Govt. of
NCT) of Delhi reported as 1998 (8) SCC 728 held that ‘police officer cannot
refuse to register an FIR or investigate an offence on the sole ground of lack of
territorial jurisdiction and that if the Investigating Officer (IO) later finds that
no part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of the police station,
the FIR is to be forwarded to the competent police station’.
18.
The Apex Court in ‘Rhea Chakraborty V. State of Bihar’ reported as
2020 (20) SCC 184 referred and relied upon by the learned counsel for the
ACB, while discussing the scope of Section 406 CrPC and structural
investigations, held that ‘Section 406 CrPC allows for the transfer of cases or
appeals but not pending investigations, while reiterating that the accused has no
fundamental right to choose or substitute any specific investigating agency,
wherein with regard to death of actor-Shushant Singh Rajput in Mumbai, the
Mumbai police had proceeded for inquest proceedings, in the matter, in terms of
Section 174 CrPC to enquire into the cause of his death, whereas a case was
registered at Patna in Bihar’. The Apex Court held in paragraph 30 of the
judgment that ‘having regard to the law enunciated by this court as noted above,
it must be held that the Patna police committed no illegality in registering the
complaint and at the stage of investigation, the police was not required to
transfer the FIR to Mumbai Police and for the same reason, the Bihar
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
government was competent to give consent for entrustment of investigation to
the CBI and as such the ongoing investigation by the CBI is held to be lawful.’
19.
Even the Apex Court in earlier cases has also taken the same view. In
Rasiklal Dalpatram Thakkar V. State of Gujarat [2010 (1) SCC 1], it has been
held that the SHO cannot refuse to investigate or transfer a court-ordered
enquiry under the guise of territorial limitations. The territorial jurisdiction is an
issue to be settled at the stage of inquiry or trial, not at the threshold of
investigation. In ‘Naresh Kavarchand Khatri v. State of Gujarat’ reported as
2008 (8) SCC 300, it was held that ‘High Courts should not interfere at the
initial stage of an investigation to reassign or shuffle police stations without
exceptions justification’.
20.
Even on a bare perusal of the provision contained under Section 156
CrPC, sub section (2) of which provides that no proceeding by a police officer in
any such case shall at any stage be called in question on the ground that the case
was one which such officer was not empowered under this section to investigate.
In view of the afore-stated law laid down by the Apex court with regard to
investigation by a police station having no territorial jurisdiction, particularly, in
the face of sub section (2) of Section 156 CrPC, the first contention that has
been made on behalf of the petitioner that the case registered against him with
Police Station ACB, Rajouri (Camp Jammu) is liable to be quashed on the basis
of lack of territorial jurisdiction is, thus, misplaced. The Police Station
concerned of the ACB on receipt of information was under an obligation to
register and enquire into the matter, the police station concerned on receipt of a
written complaint on 01.11.2022 and after verifying the facts, particularly, with
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
regard to the recorded conversation between the complainant and the petitioner
as an accused, registered the case on 14.11.2022.
21.
The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the CBI has been very
candid to disclose that the CBI had looked into all aspects and the objections
raised by the petitioner as an accused with regard to recording of call between
the complainant and the accused, CCTV footage of the Revenue Complex,
where the petitioner was holding his office and other aspects of the matter,
including registration of the case, against the complainant, which had also been
transferred to the CBI; therefore, after investigation of the case, a charge sheet
was laid against the accused, including the complainant.
22.
The ACB Headquarters, on receipt of information, with regard to
registration of the case and the trap conducted in the matter finding that it was
the Police Station of ACB Jammu, which had the territorial jurisdiction,
transferred the investigation to that police station on the very next day on
15.11.2022. In a later development, the Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir in its
wisdom transferred the case to the premier investigating agency Central Bureau
of Investigation (CBI) vide Govt. Order GAD-VIGOSP/7/2023-04-GAD dated
18.01.2023. The case initially registered with P/S ACB Rajouri was reregistered with the CBI as RC0042023A0006-CBI and after investigation of the
case, as per the status report filed and on perusal of the CD of the case, CBI has
completed the investigation, concluding into a charge sheet, ready to be laid,
before the court of law. It is also a fact that the petitioner, after transfer of the
investigation into the impugned FIR registered with ACB Rajouri (Camp
Jammu), which was ultimately transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
by the Government of Jammu & Kashmir, has neither challenged the order of
transfer of investigation or the case registered afresh by the CBI, which also
goes to the root of the petitioner’s case.
23.
As per the fresh status report filed by respondent No.14-CBI ACB
Jammu, that as per the version of the J&K ACB, the case was registered at their
police station of Rajouri Division under the orders of Director J&K ACB to
maintain the secrecy till trap was conducted and that immediately, thereafter, the
case was transferred to the jurisdictional Jammu Division; that after transfer of
the investigation by the Govt. of J&K, the respondent- CBI ACB conducted
further investigation, complied with the directions passed by this court from
time to time and that samples of the voice record of the complainant and the
accused were found matched by forensic experts, CCTV footage was also
examined and that finally it had been concluded that there was sufficient
evidence indicating demand, motive and recovery of illegal gratification by the
accused/petitioner- Rohit Sharma, for which, sanction for prosecution has been
requested. The CBI, thus, has concluded the investigation for the commission of
the alleged offences by the petitioner herein, on the basis of its independent
investigation, without having been influenced by any external influence from
any of the quarters, including the J&K ACB. Therefore, the first contention
raised on behalf of the petitioner, being untenable, is rejected.
24.
The second contention raised on behalf of the petitioner that the
complainant due to some enmity with regard to a finding of fact recorded by the
petitioner herein as Tehsildar with regard to manipulating the mutation in favour
of the complainant’s family of a big chunk of land on the basis of the forged
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
signatures of the Deputy Commissioner Jammu, lodged the complaint against
the petitioner. Since this aspect has also been looked into by the CBI and also
being a factual aspect of the case, on this plea alone, the case otherwise having
been proved against the petitioner as an accused in an independent investigation,
in the considered opinion of this court, is not liable to be quashed. The second
contention is also, thus, overruled.
25.
The Apex Court in ‘Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi V. State of Andhra
Pradesh’ reported as 2024 (10) SCC 489 held that ‘a key protocol under the
Prevention of Corruption Act, a trap laying officer (TLO) must make reliable
efforts to verify the factum of a bribe demand, such as, recording a telephonic
conversation before initiating a trap and straightaway organizing a trap without
verification makes the prosecution’s case suspect.’
26.
The Apex Court in ‘The State of Lokayukta Police v. Sri K Rangayya
& Anr.’ [2026 INSC 574], while setting aside the impugned order passed by the
High Court of Karnataka, during investigation of a case under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, held that it is contrary to the settled principles governing
Section 7 of the PC Act and also the exercise of powers of quashing an FIR, that
the High Court had practically conducted a mini trial, which is impermissible at
the threshold. The contention of learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioner that the impugned FIR was motivated by prior hostilities and on the
basis of the retaliatory and mala fide complaint lodged by the complainant
arising out of the petitioner’s enquiry into the case of the complainant’s family
with regard to attestation of a mutation over a big chunk of land within the
territorial jurisdiction of Tehsil Bahu based on forged signatures of the Deputy
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
Commissioner, the question as to whether the complaint was motivated by mala
fides, is itself a matter of evidence and trial, and that the mere allegation of preexisting hostilities does not render the allegations in the impugned FIR so
inherently improbable or manifestly absurd, so as to justify quashing, especially,
in light of the presence of recording of conversation between the complainant
and the petitioner. The complainant’s motive, if any, is a matter, that can be
tested by the defense in the course of trial, by way of cross examination or
otherwise. The existence of pre-existing dispute between the parties does not, in
and of itself, constitute a ground for quashing the FIR, particularly, when the
allegations taken at face value disclose a prima facie cognizable offence.
Therefore, no merit is found in this contention. The third ground of challenge is
also, thus, rejected.
27.
The petitioner, besides, seeking quashment of the FIR had also prayed
that a Special Investigating Team (SIT) be ordered to be constituted so that the
petitioner is not wrongly and falsely implicated. In view of the case having been
transferred to the premier investigating agency of India, CBI, this relief pales
into insignificance. In ‘Romila Thapar V. Union of India’ reported as 2018 (10)
SCC 753, a three Judge bench of the Apex Court held that ‘accused cannot
dictate the choice of the agency that investigates them, nor can they demand a
court-monitored investigation, as a matter of right’. A similar view had been
taken in case titled ‘Narmada Bai V. State of Gujarat and Ors’ reported as 2011
(5) SCC 79, wherein it was held in paragraph 64, extracted as under:
‘64. ……………. It is trite law that accused persons do not have a say
in the matter of appointment of Investigating Agency. The accused
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
persons cannot choose as to which investigating agency must investigate
the alleged offences committed by them.’
The Apex Court again in a case ‘Divine Retreat Centre V. State of Kerala and
Ors’ reported as 2008 (3) SCC 542 held that the accused cannot ask for
changing the investigating agency or to do investigation in a particular manner
including for court monitored investigation.
28.
Another relief, which had been prayed in this petition, is with regard
to a direction to the respondents to seize the electronic devices/records of CCTV
installed in the premises of the Tehsildar Office Bahu Jammu, for CFSL
evaluation, CCTV footage was stated to have been secured in terms of the
interim order passed by this court earlier and the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the CBI has also submitted that the CCTV footage has been seized
and made part of the investigation by the CBI.
29.
Having regard to the discussion made hereinabove and the reasons
assigned in the preceding paragraphs, this court, is of the considered opinion that
the petitioner has failed to make out a case warranting interference by this court
into the investigating of the case against him, initially registered with the J&K
ACB, and later transferred to CBI.
30.
Viewed thus, the petition is, found to be without any merit and
substance and is liable to be rejected. As a result, petition is, dismissed, along
with application(s).
WP(C) No. 2788/2022
31.
Interim direction, if any, shall stand vacated. The CBI shall be at
liberty to lay the charge sheet before the competent court.
32.
CD File of the case is ordered to be returned to the respondent- CBI
ACB Jammu through its counsel.
(MA CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
12.08.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
Raj Kumar
2026.08.12 15:02
No.
I attest to the WP(C)
accuracy
and2788/2022
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review