Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on:30th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 24th March, 2026
+
RFA 847/2024,CM APPL. 71003/2024, CM APPL. 71006/2024
ROHAN BOOK COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED
Through its Authorized Representative
NITIN
S/o- Late Madan Pal
R/o-C-178, First Floor,
Anand Vihar, Delhi- 110092
Email id: rohanbooks@gmail.com
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Aishwarya Raj, Advocate
Versus
SACHIN TYAGI
R/o House No. 666
D-Block, Street No.-4
Ashok Nagar, Shahdara
New Delhi-110093
Email id: sachintyagi.ind@gmail.com
Mobile: 07303375354
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Anshul Sharma, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CM APPL. 71003/2024 (delay of 132days in filing the appeal)
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
1.
This application has been filed seeking condonation of delay of 132
days in filing the Appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the Application, the delay of 132 days in
filing the Appeal, is condoned.
3.
The Application is disposed of, accordingly.
CM APPL. 71006/2024 (delay 18 days in re-filing appeal)
4.
This Application has been filed seeking condonation of delay of 18
days in re-filing the Appeal.
5.
For the reasons stated in the Application, the delay of 18 days in re-
filing the Appeal, is condoned.
6.
The said Application is disposed of, accordingly.
RFA 847/2024:
7.
The Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) has
been preferred by the Appellant challenging the Order dated 08.02.2024,of
the learned Additional District Judge, Delhi, whereby the Suit of the
Appellant seeking damages for defamation, was rejected under Order VII
Rule 11(a) of the CPC, as not disclosing anycause of action.
8.
A Civil Suit bearing CS No. 950/2023, was filed by the
plaintiff/Appellant, seeking damages in the sum of Rs. 10,00,000/-, on
account of defamation.
9.
Briefly stated, the averments made in the Suit were that the
Appellant/Plaintiff, Rohan Book Company Pvt. Ltd., is a Company engaged
in the business of publication and distribution of books across Delhi and
other parts of the country. The Respondent/Defendant was issued an
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
Appointment letter dated 16.08.2019 for the post of Zonal Sales Manager,
which was accepted by the Respondent on 06.09.2019. The Respondent also
executed a Non-Disclosure Agreement, Non-Compete Agreement, NonSolicitation Agreement and an Employment Bond dated 16.08.2019, in
favour of the Appellant Company.
10.
Under the terms of Appointment the responsibilities of the
Respondent included developing and maintaining relationships with schools
within his assigned zone and reporting to the Accounts Department
regarding monies received from such clients. He was placed on Probation
and his employment was never confirmed.
11.
According to the Appellant, during the course of his employment, the
Respondent began neglecting his duties and failed to comply with various
obligations stipulated in the Appointment Letter, including submission of
weekly work Reports and adherence to the Company’s protocols.
Complaints were also allegedly received by the Management regarding
instances of misbehaviour by the Respondent with female employees.
12.
In March, 2020, due to the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, the
Appellant’s business operations were severely affected. Consequently, by
Letter dated 11.05.2020, the Appellant informed its employees including the
Respondent, that their salaries would be temporarily reduced. The
Respondent acknowledged the same and continued to work, under the
revised salary structure.
13.
On
28.11.2020,
the
Plaintiff
came
to
know,
that
the
Respondent/Defendant had met representatives of competing Companies,
including Next Education India Pvt. Ltd. and Orange Education, and had
disclosed confidential information relating to the Appellant’s clientele and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
business practices.
14.
Upon receiving this information, the Appellant convened a Meeting
with the Respondent on 01.12.2020, during which he was confronted with
the allegations regarding disclosure of confidential information and his
declining work performance.
15.
On 02.12.2020, the Respondent addressed an email to the
Management of the Plaintiff and was also marked to Nitin, an employee of
the Appellant, seeking clearance of his alleged pending salary and travelling
allowances with effect from 01.03.2020, stating that he was facing financial
difficulties and would be able to perform his official responsibilities
effectively, only after receipt of the outstanding dues. The Respondent also
referred to the difficulties caused during the COVID-19 pandemic and
expressed grievance regarding the manner in which he was treated in the
office.
16.
The Appellant/Plaintiff asserted that the Respondent had earlier
acknowledged the Appellant’s communication dated 11.05.2020, whereby
he had been informed of a reduction in salary on account of the closure of
business activities during the COVID-19 pandemic, and had continued to
work thereafter. According to the Appellant, the said communication
amounted to a resignation, without serving the mandatory Notice period.
17.
The Appellant thereafter, called upon the Respondent to report to the
office on 03.12.2020 to hand over Company documents and assets; however,
he allegedly failed to do so.
18.
The Plaintiff asserted that the Respondent began communicating with
certain employees of the Appellant, namely, Deepali Mahajan, Gulzar Khan
and Anup Bhardwaj, with a view to mislead and influence them, against the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
Appellant and its management.
19.
It was further alleged that the Respondent made defamatory and
derogatory statements against the Appellant firm and its Directors. The
Appellant claimed to have learnt from other employees, that the Respondent
had been contacting them and making such statements with the intent to
lower the reputation of the Appellant and its management.
20.
In view of the above, the Appellant issued a Legal Notice dated
05.12.2020
asking the
Respondent, to cease making defamatory
communications. Despite receipt of the said legal Notice, the Respondent
continued to make derogatory statements against the Appellant and its
Directors and communicated the same to employees of the Appellant as well
as to competing Companies.
21.
The Appellant also alleges that the Respondent, in his email dated
14.12.2020 sent in response to the Legal Notice, admitted that he was in
contact with certain former employees of the Appellant Company. The
Respondent also sent complaints through email, to the District Magistrate,
Ghaziabad, the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ghaziabad, as well as to the
Labour Authorities, making false allegations against the Appellant and its
Director, and circulated copies of such communications to employees of the
Appellant company.
22.
The Appellant claimed that by making such allegations and
communications to employees, clients, authorities and other stakeholders,
the Respondent had damaged the reputation and goodwill of the Appellant
Company, which had been built over several years in the publication and
distribution sector.
23.
The Plaintiff/Appellantthus, instituted a Suit for damages of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
₹10,00,000 on 21.01.2021 before the Court of the learned Additional
District Judge, Delhi.
24.
The Suit was initially registered as CS No. 73/2021, however, vide
Order dated 09.02.2021, the learned Additional District Judge directed that
the matter be placed before the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge
for determination as to whether the Suit was of a commercial nature.
Thereafter, vide Order dated 16.02.2021, it was directed that the matter be
filed as a commercial Suit.
25.
The Suit was sent to Commercial Court and registered as CS (Comm.)
No. 94/2021. Subsequently, the Respondent filed an Application under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC. By Order dated 02.03.2023 passed in, the learned
District Judge, Commercial Court-01, held that the Commercial Court
lacked jurisdiction and returned the Plaint under Order VII Rule 10 of CPC
for presentation before the court of competent jurisdiction.
26.
Pursuant thereto, the plaint was presented before the learned
Additional District Judge, Shahdara District and registered it as CS No.
950/2023 titled “Rohan Book Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Sachin Tyagi”.
27.
The learned Trial Court, in the Impugned Order dated 08.02.2024,
held that averments made in the plaint, did not disclose cause of action for
defamation and that permitting the suit to proceed would amount to an
abuse of the process of the Court, and the Suit was rejected.
28.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Order, the present Appeal has been
preferred by the Appellant. The grounds of challengeare that the learned
Trial Court erred in holding that no serious allegation amounting to
defamation, was made against the Appellant. According to the Appellant,
the Plaint disclosed that the Respondent had spread false and derogatory
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
remarks against the AppellantCompany and its directors amongst its
employees, competitors and clients, thereby causing damage to the
Appellant’s business and reputation.
It is further urged that the ingredients of defamation as envisaged
29.
under Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as
“IPC”), namely publication of an imputation, falsity of such imputation, and
knowledge of its harmful effect, stand satisfied from the averments in the
plaint.
30.
The Appellant asserts that the plaint, when read as a whole, discloses
a cause of action inasmuch as the Respondent was in touch with employees,
clients, and competitors of the Appellant and allegedly made false
imputations with an intent to harm its reputation.
31.
Reliance is placed on an earlier Order dated 02.03.2023, passed in CS
(Comm.) No. 94/2021, wherein the learned District Judge had observed that
the cause of action persisted in favour of the plaintiff for claiming damages
of ₹10 lakhs. It is urged that the Impugned Order dismissing the Suit as
frivolous and vexatious, was passed without adequate reasoning.
32.
The Appellant has relied upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Kamala & Ors. vs. K.T. Eshwara Sa &Ors 2008 12 SCC 661,
Liverpool & London S.P. & I Association Ltd. vs. M.V. Sea Success I&Anr.
2004 9 SCC 512 and Hardesh Ores (P.) Ltd. v. Hede & Co. 2007 5 SCC
614, to contend that for the purpose of Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the plaint
must be read as a whole and its averments treated as correct at that stage,
without embarking upon an enquiry into the truth of the allegations.
33.
It is submitted that the learned Trial Court contrary to the settled law,
erred in examining the merits of the plaint, instead of confining itself to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
whether the plaint disclosed a cause of action.
34.
The Appellant, thus, seeks setting aside of the Impugned Order dated
08.02.2024.
Submissions heard and record perused.
35.
The short question which arises for consideration in the present
Appeal is:whether the plaint, read as a whole and assuming the averments
therein to be correct, disclose a cause of action for defamation, so as to
warrant interference with the Order passed by the learned Trial Court,
rejecting the Plaint under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC.
36.
It is well settled that while considering an Application under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court must confine its examination to the averments
contained in the plaint and the documents relied upon therein. The defence
taken by the Defendant is not to be examined, at this stage. The Supreme
Court in Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. (supra) explained that the Plaint can be
rejected only when on a meaningful reading of the averments, without
addition or subtraction, the Court finds that no cause of action is disclosed.
37.
In order to constitute a cause of action for defamation, as envisaged
under section 499 IPC, the Plaint must disclose firstly, the existence of a
defamatory imputation, secondly, that such imputation refers to the Plaintiff,
and thirdly, its publication to a third party is done in a manner capable of
lowering the reputation of the Appellant/Plaintiff in the estimation of others.
38.
A careful reading of the plaint along with the documents relied upon
therein, indicates that the case of the Appellant is essentially founded on
allegations of misconduct arising out of the employment relationship, which
have been sought to be clothed as a claim for defamation. The series of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
allegations attributed to the Respondent, may be broadly summarised as
under:
i)
The Respondent’s work performance had declined and he failed to
discharge his obligations under the Appointment Letter;
ii)
The Respondent/Defendantmet representatives of competing
Companies, including Next Education India Pvt. Ltd. and Orange
Education, and disclosed confidential information relating to the
Appellant’s clientele and business practices;
iii)
The Respondent began communicating with certain employees of
the Appellant, namely Deepali Mahajan, Gulzar Khan and Anup
Bhardwaj, with a view to mislead and influence them, against the
Appellant and its management;
iv)
The Respondentmade defamatory and derogatory statements
against the Appellant firm and its Directors and contacted
employees with the intent to lower the reputation of the Appellant
and its management;
v)
Lastly, despite receipt of a Legal Notice dated 05.12.2020 calling
upon him to desist from making defamatory communications, the
Respondent continued to make derogatory statements against the
Appellant and its Directors and communicated the same to
employees of the Appellant as well as to competing Companies.
39.
With respect to allegation (i), regarding decline in work performance
and failure to discharge obligations under the Appointment Letter, it relates
purely to the inter se employment relationship between the parties. These
assertions neither constitute nor disclose any imputation capable of lowering
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
the reputation of the Appellant, in the estimation of third parties.
40.
The allegation (ii) is that the Respondent met representatives of
competing Companies, including Next Education India Pvt. Ltd. and Orange
Education, and disclosed confidential information, the plaint relies upon the
Appointment Letter and the accompanying Agreements, including the NonDisclosure
Agreement,
Non-Compete
Agreement,
Non-Solicitation
Agreement,etc. to substantiate this allegation. Even if the said allegation is
assumed to be correct, it pertains to an alleged breach of confidentiality and
contractual obligations arising out of the employment relationship and such
conduct does not, by itself, disclose any defamatory imputation. At best, it
may give rise to contractual or employment-related claims, but does not
disclose any defamatory imputation published to a third party so as to
constitute a cause of action for defamation.
41.
The
allegation (iii), is that the Respondent communicated with
certain employees of the Appellant, including Deepali Mahajan, Gulzar
Khan and Anup Bhardwaj, with a view to mislead or influence them.
42.
These allegations are not supported by any particulars. The Plaint
does not disclose what was communicated, to whom it was communicated,
or in what context. The plaint, fails to disclose the contents or substance of
any such communication. Mere contact or communication with employees,
in the absence of specific defamatory statements, does not constitute
publication of a defamatory imputation to a third party.
43.
The email dated 02.12.2020, relied upon by the Appellant, merely
raises issues relating to pending salary and allowances and reflects personal
grievances of the Respondent.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
44.
The Appellant itself relied upon the Reply dated 14.12.2020 sent by
the Respondent in response to the Legal Notice dated 05.12.2020, to assert
that the Respondent himself admitted that he was in contact with certain
former employees of the Appellant Company.
45.
The Appellant has placed reliance on para 8 of the Reply, wherein the
Respondent stated:
“Point 8: I have never used any vulgar language with any
of your employees ever, but do not worry I'll give you
proof that how professionally you and your other
stakeholders behaves. I'll also show you how your old
employees use pathetic language for you.”
46.
The Reply dated 14.12.2020, on a plain reading, contains a denial of
allegations levelled against the Respondent and raises grievances relating to
his employment, including non-payment of dues. The contents of the Reply
do not disclose any statement capable of lowering the reputation of the
Appellant or its Directors in the estimation of others. It primarily reflects
disputes arising out of the employment relationship between the parties.
47.
The mere fact that the Respondent was in contact with former
employees does not, by itself, disclose any defamatory imputation or
publication capable of lowering the reputation of the Appellant. In law, there
is nothing to prevent an employee from remaining in touch with former
colleagues, and such contact, without the pleading of particular defamatory
words or their publication to third parties, cannot constitute defamation.
48.
In relation to allegations (iv) and (v), namely that the Respondent
made defamatory and derogatory statements against the Appellant and its
Directors, contacted employees and competitors to lower its reputation, and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
continued to do so even after receipt of the Legal Notice dated 05.12.2020,
the Plaint fails to disclose the necessary particulars.
49.
The Appellant has relied upon the Legal Notice dated 05.12.2020, the
Reply dated 14.12.2020, the email dated 02.12.2020 and the alleged
Complaints addressed to public authorities. However, no specific statement,
imputation, or words alleged to be defamatory have been set out or
reproduced, either in the plaint or in any of the aforementioned
documents.
50.
The Legal Notice dated 05.12.2020 sets out the allegations of the
Appellant and cannot, by itself, establish any defamatory communication by
the Respondent.
51.
Likewise, the alleged complaints addressed to the District Magistrate,
Chief Judicial Magistrate and Labour Authorities, have neither been
reproduced nor particularised in the plaint. The Defendant/ Respondent, on
the other hand, has annexed the same, but they cannot be looked into at
this stage in view of Order VII Rule 11 CPC. In any event,
communications made to lawful authorities in the course of raising
grievances, ordinarily fall within the ambit of qualified privilege, unless
specific malice is pleaded. The Plaint, however, does not contain any
pleading of malice nor does it disclose how such Complaints would per se,
constitute defamatory imputations. The mere fact that Complaints were
made to public authorities cannot, by itself, give rise to a cause of action for
defamation.
52.
The Appellant alleges that the Respondent spoke to employees of the
Company with the intent to mislead and influence them, approached certain
clients and made complaints to authorities. Yet, the plaint does not
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
reproduce the contents of any such email, complaint or communication.
No specific clients are named and no date-wise defamatory statements, are
extracted. In the absence of precise statements and particulars of their
publication, the essential ingredients of defamation are not disclosed from
the pleadings. Though certain individuals have been named, the plaint does
not set out or reproduce what was allegedly communicated to them, nor are
any such statements annexed. A bare assertion that “defamatory and
derogatory statements” were made, without specifying the words used or
showing how they were conveyed to a third party, is insufficient in law to
sustain a cause of action for defamation.
53.
Furthermore, the reliance placed by the Appellant on Kamala & Ors.
(supra) and Liverpool & London S.P.(supra), does not advance its case.
While those decisions reiterate that the averments in the plaint must be taken
as correct at the stage of Order VII Rule 11 CPC, they equally require that
the plaint must nonetheless, disclose a cause of action. In the present case,
even assuming the averments in the Plaint to be true, the essential
ingredients of defamation are not made out.
54.
The reliance placed by the Appellant on the Order dated 02.03.2023
passed in CS (Comm.) No. 94/2021, is also misconceived. The said Order
merely directed return of the Plaint on the ground that the Commercial Court
lacked jurisdiction to entertain the Suit. Any observation made therein
regarding the subsistence of a cause of action, was only incidental to the
issue of jurisdiction and was not a conclusive determination that the Plaint
disclosed a legally sustainable claim for defamation. The observations made
vide Order dated 02.03.2023, were neither final nor determinative of the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
existence of a legally sustainable cause of action, and were made only in
the context of deciding the issue of jurisdiction.
55.
To sum up, apart from the bald assertion of reputational injury, no
particulars are provided regarding loss of clients, cancellation of contracts,
revenue decline, or any specific financial injury suffered by the Appellant.
In cases alleging injury to corporate reputation, ordinarily at least some
factual foundation demonstrating reputational or commercial harm, must be
disclosed.
56.
Upon a meaningful reading of the plaint, along with the documents
relied upon therein, this Court finds that the allegations are vague and
general in nature and devoid of the necessary particulars required to
constitute a cause of action for defamation. The plaint neither discloses the
precise defamatory statements allegedly made by the Respondent, nor how
such statements were allegedly published, or the manner in which the
reputation of the Appellant was harmed.
57.
The pleadings oscillate between allegations of misconduct and
assertions of defamation, but never descend into the concrete particulars
required to sustain a cause of action in law.
58.
Even if the averments contained in the Plaint are assumed to be
correct, the essential ingredients necessary to constitute a cause of action for
defamation, are not disclosed.
59.
The learned Trial Court rightly applied the principle laid down in T.
Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal (1977) 4 SCC 467, that clever drafting
cannot substitute for a clear right to sue, and that vexatious pleadings must
be nipped in the bud. The Plaint, even if taken at face value, does not
disclose a cause of action in law.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
60.
The learned Trial Court was therefore, justified in concluding that the
Plaint did not disclose a cause of action and in rejecting the same under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
Conclusion:
61.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no infirmity in
the Impugned Order dated 08.02.2024 of the learned Additional District
Judge, in rejecting the Suit of the Plaintiff/Appellant.
62.
The Appeal is accordingly, dismissed. Pending Applications, if any,
are also disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 24, 2026
JYH
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:04:00
RFA 847/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review