Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:827
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 291 of 2024
Date of Decision: 09.09.2024
RMSI Private Limited
… Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. State of Meghalaya,
Represented by the Chief Secretary
to the Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
2. The Development Commissioner
to the Government of Meghalaya,
Planning, Investment Promotion and
Sustainable Development Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. The Meghalaya Basin Management Agency,
Represented by its Chief Executive Officer,
C /o Meghalaya State Housing Financing
Cooperative Society, Upper Nongrim, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya-793003.
4. The Project Director,
Community-Led Landscape Management Project (CLLMP)
C /o Meghalaya State Housing Financing
Cooperative Society, Upper Nongrim, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya-793003.
5. The Additional Project Director,
Community-Led Landscape Management Project (CLLMP)
C /o Meghalaya State Housing Financing
Cooperative Society, Upper Nongrim, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya-793003.
… Respondent(s)
2024:MLHC:827
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
Mr. A Mishra, Adv.
Mr. N. Rewalia, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner company being aggrieved with the
impugned order dated 25.07.2024 issued by the respondent No. 5,
blacklisting the petitioner company for a period of 3 years w.e.f
01.07.2024 to 30.06.2027, cancelling all existing contracts and seeking
refund of the entire contract amount is before this Court for issuance of a
writ of mandamus and a certiorari and set aside and quash the impugned
order.
2024:MLHC:827
2.
The brief facts are that the respondent No. 3 had floated
request for Expression of Interest in June 2019 for development and
deployment of ICT based MIS to support the implementation of the
Meghalaya Community Led Landscapes Management Project under
MBMA. The petitioner then was awarded the project and a contract
signed between the parties. As per the petitioner, the project proceeded
smoothly during the inception, design, development and deployment
phases and all the deliverables were accepted without any disputes, and
invoices raised were accordingly paid. During the year 2022 it appears,
certain issues had then cropped up which resulted in a serious gap in the
project execution and understanding and it appears that on these issues,
the respondent No. 5, issued a letter dated 23.02.2023 to the petitioner,
alleging breach of various terms of the contract. The petitioner to the said
letter, then filed a detailed response and in-person meeting was also held
to discuss the matter. The respondent No. 5 by letter dated 30.03.2023
however, expressed his dissatisfaction and raised several issues, such as
the working of the mobile application for the MIS, and also the date of
raising of invoices which he alleged was in contravention to the agreed
terms as laid down in the contract. That thereafter, after a period of more
than a year the respondent No. 5 issued the impugned order dated
25.07.2024, blacklisting the petitioner company. Hence, the writ petition.
2024:MLHC:827
3.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner company has
submitted that as per the timelines from the date of signing the contract
on 16.12.2019 up to the deliverable stage 4, which was completed on
21.12.2020, there is no dispute that the works have been completed, and
in this context has referred to the first show cause notice dated
23.02.2023, and has drawn the Court’s attention to the table given
therein, showing the date of acceptance of completion of stage 4, and the
factum of release of payment on 29.11.2021. The learned Senior counsel
submits that the dispute which arose was with regard to the stage 5
deliverables and the time stipulated therein, which he submits were
unclear and ambiguous and has led to the misunderstanding. It is
contended that the stage 5 time schedule of which the deliverable was
‘handholding and maintenance for after commissioning of the MIS,’ was
given in the contract to be 36 months from the acceptance and full stream
operationalization of the application, after the completion of the first year
of operations for the application which was duly adhered to by the
petitioner. Learned Senior counsel has also highlighted the fact that as per
the terms, up to stage 5 which is from the effective date i.e. 16.12.2019
(T) plus 7(seven) months, 70% of the contractual amount was to be paid
and the same was also accordingly release to the petitioner. Elaborating
on this aspect, learned Senior counsel has submitted that due to COVID
2024:MLHC:827
restrictions and other factors there was a slight time overrun, inasmuch
as, for deliverable stage I after the date of signing the contract
(16.12.2019), the date of completion i.e. (T+1) would have been
16.01.2020, but the actual date of completion was 09.03.2023, for which
invoice was accordingly raised thereafter. Similarly, he submits for stage
1, (T+2), the actual date of completion was 09.06.2020, stage 3,
19.10.2020 (T+6) and stage 4 (T+7) 21.12.2020. He submits that taking
21.12.2020 as the base line, the deliverable stage 5 i.e. after 36 months
therefore was to conclude on 20.12.2023. As such, he submits the
allegation that invoices had been raised before they were due i.e. in the
period from 15.02.2022 to 23.09.2022 are misplaced. The learned Senior
counsel also contends that prior to the commencement of the contract, a
query had been raised as to when the 36 months of handholding and
maintenance period (stage 5) would start and that to the petitioner’s
understanding, it should be immediately after the 7(seven) months period
i.e. after completion of stage 4. This the learned Senior counsel submits,
had been raised in the pre-proposal conference held on 22.08.2019, where
this query finds place at Sl. No. 32 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition). In
the reply thereto, the learned Senior counsel submits as can be seen from
the minutes of the meeting, the respondent had stated that the
maintenance period starts immediately after the successful completion of
UAT life production. Further the learned Senior counsel reiterates that
2024:MLHC:827
with regard to the 30% of the remaining works where issues have arisen,
even if the same has or could have been caused by a shortfall in the
development of the applications and its workability after stage 4, the
same cannot warrant the penalty of blacklisting of the petitioner by the
respondent No. 5, as has been resorted to.
4.
To the allegations that the MIS system delivered to the
respondent failed to meet the contractual requirements and that the
application had several critical issues, such as synchronization failures
and frequent apps crashes, the learned Senior counsel had taken this
Court to certain e-mails dated 19.01.2022 and 21.04.2022 showing the
respondents’
and the World Banks’ appreciation with regard to the
progress of work, and submits that the allegations made by the
respondents are without any basis, as the system put in place by the
petitioner is still being used by the respondents in their project. It is then
contended that blacklisting will cause the civil death of the company,
inasmuch as, they will be stigmatized, apart from being made ineligible
from participating in future contracts with other entities. The contract
itself he submits, in the event of such disputes at clause 44 and 45
thereof, has provided for a dispute resolution mechanism, which any
party aggrieved can take recourse to. The respondent he submits, in spite
of the availability of adequate remedy under the contract has however
2024:MLHC:827
taken the extreme step of blacklisting which will cause grievous injury to
the company’s’ existence.
5.
Learned senior counsel has also argued that the dispute if
any, amounts to an ordinary breach of contract, which in this case, is
primarily due to the ambiguity with regard to the stage 5 timeline, and on
these circumstances, blacklisting is a penalty that should not have been
resorted to. In support of his submissions, the learned Senior counsel has
placed reliance on the following judgments: -
6.
i)
The Blue Dreamz Advertising Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. Vs. Kolkata
Municipal Corporation & Ors. SLP (CIVIL) No. 11682 of
2018.
ii)
Kothati Filaments & Anr. Vs. Commissioner of Customs
(Port) Kolkata & Ors. (2009) 2 SCC 192
iii)
Sahara India (Firm) Lucknow Vs. Commissioner of Income
Tax, Central-I & Anr. (2008) 14 SCC 151
iv)
Secretary and Curator, Victoria Memorial Hall Vs. Howrah
Ganatantrik Nagrik Samity (2010) 3 SCC 732
v)
Union of India Vs. Tantia Construction Pvt. Ltd. (2011) 5SCC
Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General assisted by Ms. A.
Thungwa, learned GA for the respondents at the outset, has submitted
that the services and products rendered by the petitioner being far from
satisfactory in a project of public utility has already caused loss of public
2024:MLHC:827
benefit. It is then submitted that the respondents were compelled to issue
the impugned order dated 25.7.2024, after multiple show cause notices
had been issued, and the petitioner provided with ample and sufficient
opportunity to address and rectify the critical and fundamental issues that
had arisen. The respondents he submits, had repeatedly requested for
correction of the basic functionalities of the system, but the petitioner
failed to address the issues, and no steps were taken to make the system
functional. It is submitted that the petitioner in the meeting held on
17.03.2023, had acknowledged various issues, such as the mobile
application not working as intended for the field functionaries, which led
to the disruption of work and a consequent delay in the progress of the
project, and that the petitioner had wrongfully raised invoices before
completion of key milestones in contravention to the terms of the
contract. The impugned order the learned Advocate General contends, is
proportionate to the conduct of the petitioner for providing a completely
unusable application that was neither utilized, nor can be utilized in the
future. In this regard the learned Advocate General has taken this Court to
various communications from the years 2021 and 2022, downloaded
from various platforms showing the difficulties of the users and field
functionaries in using the mobile application of MIS, provided by the
petitioner. A letter dated 14.02.2023 has also been highlighted to
substantiate the allegations, where in the said letter, it is shown that
2024:MLHC:827
though the petitioner had been duly informed on earlier occasions, there
was no response from the petitioner nor any steps taken. The learned AG
has also raised the aspect of fraud being perpetuated in collusion with the
Addl Project Director of MBMA, in the release of certain payments on
invoices that were presented allegedly before they were due. He then
concludes his submissions by maintaining that the petitioner had failed
miserably in the execution of the contract and had sought undue
advantage from the contract and the penalty of blacklisting was therefore
justified and commensurate. In support of his submissions the Learned
Advocate General has placed the following decision in support thereof.
i)
7.
Kulja Industries Limited vs. Chief General Manager, Western
Telecom Project Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited & Ors
reported in (2014) 14 SCC 731
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, from the
narration of facts and submissions advanced, it can be discerned that the
only issue for consideration is whether in the stated circumstances
thereof, blacklisting of the petitioner was justified. This Court on
examination of the materials as placed finds that apart from the multitude
of operational glitches that had been raised by the respondents in using
the MIS developed by the petitioner in the commission of the project,
however, as can be seen from the first show cause notice dated
23.02.2023, till stage 4, the date of completion had been accepted and
payments were released to the petitioner. Serious dispute between the
2024:MLHC:827
parties arose only in the calculation and computation of the timelines for
commencement and completion of stage 5 and the alleged contravention
of the terms with regard to raising of invoices for stage 5. In this context,
it would be relevant to reproduce the table contained in the first show
cause notice hereinbelow as it portrays the timelines and the dispute that
had arisen and noted therein with regard to the deployment of stage 5.
Sn
Particulars
1.
2.
Date of Signing of contract (T)
Date of raising of invoice for State 4
Date of acceptance of completion of
State 4 by MBMA
4.
Date of start of 1 year Deployment
phase
Date of end of 1 year Deployment
phase
Date of commencement of State 5
(starting of the 36 months of
Handholding and maintenance)
Expected date of 1st half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
Expected date of 2nd half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
Expected date of 3rd half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
Expected date of 4th half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
Expected date of 5th half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
Expected date of 6th half yearly
report and raising of corresponding
invoice
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Expected dates as per
the Contract terms
16-Dec.2019
10-Feb-2021
18-Nov.
(Payment released on
29- Nov. 2021.)
19-Nov. 2021
Actual Dates of
raising invoice
18-Nov. 2022
19-Nov. 2022
After 19-May-2023
15th Feb. 2022
After 19-Nov-2023
15th Feb. 2022
After 19-May-2024
23rd Sep. 2022
After 19-Nov-2024
23rd Sep. 2022
After 19-May-2025
After 19-Nov-2025
2024:MLHC:827
8.
It would be also useful to extract hereinunder Appendix A,
clause (C) (V) (D) which has provided the milestone and deliverable of
stage 5.
Milestone
Deliverable
Time schedule from the date
of signing (T) (as of signing
of contract)
%
of
the
contract
amount to the
paid
Remaining 30%
in equal half
yearly
instalments
after approval
of
the
half
yearly reports.
State 5
Handholding and
maintenance for
after
commissioning of
the MIS
36 months from the
acceptance and full stream
operationalization of the
application,
after
the
completion of first year of
operations
for
the
application. In the first year,
maintenance and associated
costs would need to be built
into the Deployment phase.
9.
A perusal of the aforementioned table would suggest that by
application of the deliverable of stage 5, invoices had been raised by the
petitioner before they were due, which the respondents maintained was in
violation of the terms and warranted the infliction of the penalty of a
blacklisting. This issue as to the period of the commencement of 36
months as noted earlier had been raised by the petitioner and recorded in
the minutes of a pre-proposal conference held on 22.08.2019, the extract
of the minutes whereof is reproduced hereinbelow:Sl.
No
.
RFP Clause
Page
No.
Queries
MBMA
Response
2024:MLHC:827
Section 7/D: Reporting
Requirements, Time Schedule
and Payment Terms for
Deliverables/Completion of
Tasks/Stage 5-36 months form
the acceptance and full stream
operationalization of the
application, after the completion
of first year of operations for the
application …………
10.
It is not clear when the
36 months of
handholding and
maintenance period
(stage 5) starts. To our
understanding it
should be immediately
after 7th month, after
completion of Stage 4.
Kindly confirm.
Maintenance
period starts
immediately
after the
successful
completion of
UAT in live
production
The response from the respondents to the said query as given
above, however, does not specify or clarify the exact timeline as
according to the petitioner the deliverable stage 5 (handholding and
maintenance) as stipulated was to be of 36 months from the completion
of the deliverable stage 4, and this if counted from the date of actual
completion of stage 4 i.e. 21.12.2020 as submitted, stage 5 was to
conclude on 20.12.2023 and therefore the invoices had been raised, when
they were due. The petitioner in reply to the first show cause has also
offered explanations as to the complaints about the operability of the
mobile app, which had been flagged by the respondents attributing it to
server issues and had also maintained that the mobile app was functional
and assured that due diligence would be done again with regard to onsite
performance testing. It is also seen that in the reply itself, a table had also
been provided by the petitioner regarding the milestones and invoicing
schedule made on the basis that the total duration of the project being 43
months from the date of signing the contract on 16.12.2019 with the
2024:MLHC:827
limited time overruns the date of commencement of stage 5 would be
21.10.2020 on the completion of stage 4 on 20.10.2020.
11.
The illustration of the sequence of events as detailed above
clearly reveals that notwithstanding certain glitches, the project was
progressing with due acknowledgement by the respondents till stage 4.
The nature of dispute between the parties as can be discerned from the
entire transaction and commissioning of the project is only with the
deficiency in the services provided by the petitioner, which as alleged by
the respondents was a breach of the contract and misconduct which has
caused harm to public interest, which warranted the blacklisting of the
petitioner.
12.
At this juncture, it would be necessary to refer to the
pronouncements of the Supreme Court on blacklisting. In the case of
Kulja Industries Limited (supra), it has been held that a decision on
blacklisting is subject to judicial review on grounds of principles of
natural
justice,
doctrine
of
proportionality,
arbitrariness
and
discrimination. The same judgment itself has dealt elaborately with the
legal position on the effect and nature of blacklisting as also the right that
a petitioner possesses when such action is taken by the State or any
2024:MLHC:827
authority, in India and also in UK and USA. Paragraphs 20 to 25 being
relevant are reproduced hereinbelow:“20. It is also well settled that even though the right of the
writ petitioner is in the nature of a contractual right, the
manner, the method and the motive behind the decision of
the authority whether or not to enter into a contract is
subject to judicial review on the touchstone of fairness,
relevance, natural justice, non-discrimination, equality and
proportionality. All these considerations that go to
determine whether the action is sustainable in law have
been sanctified by judicial pronouncements of this Court
and are of seminal importance in a system that is
committed to the rule of law. We do not consider it
necessary to burden this judgment by a copious reference
to the decisions on the subject. A reference to the following
passage from the decision of this Court in Mahabir Auto
Stores v. Indian Oil Corpn. should, in our view, suffice:
(SCC pp. 760-61, para 12)
“12. It is well settled that every action of the State or an
instrumentality of the State in exercise of its executive
power, must be informed by reason. In appropriate cases,
actions uninformed by reason may be questioned as
arbitrary in proceedings under Article 226 or Article 32 of
the Constitution. Reliance in this connection may be placed
on the observations of this Court in Radhakrishna
Agarwal v. State of Bihar . … In case any right conferred
on the citizens which is sought to be interfered, such action
is subject to Article 14 of the Constitution, and must be
reasonable and can be taken only upon lawful and relevant
grounds of public interest. Where there is arbitrariness in
State action of this type of entering or not entering into
contracts, Article 14 springs up and judicial review strikes
such an action down. Every action of the State executive
authority must be subject to rule of law and must be
informed by reason. So, whatever be the activity of the
public authority, in such monopoly or semi-monopoly
dealings, it should meet the test of Article 14 of the
Constitution. If a governmental action even in the matters
of entering or not entering into contracts, fails to satisfy the
2024:MLHC:827
test
of
reasonableness,
the
same
would
be
unreasonable……. It appears to us that rule of reason and
rule against arbitrariness and discrimination, rules of fair
play and natural justice are part of the rule of law
applicable in situation or action by State instrumentality in
dealing with citizens in a situation like the present one.
Even though the rights of the citizens are in the nature of
contractual rights, the manner, the method and motive of a
decision of entering or not entering into a contract, are
subject to judicial review on the touchstone of relevance
and reasonableness, fair play, natural justice, equality and
non-discrimination in the type of the transactions and
nature of the dealing as in the present case.
21. The legal position governing blacklisting of suppliers in
USA and UK is no different. In USA instead of using the
expression ‘Blacklisting’ the term “debarring” is used by
the Statutes and the Courts. The Federal Government
considers ‘suspension and debarment’ as a powerful tool
for protecting taxpayer resources and maintaining integrity
of the processes for federal acquisitions. Comprehensive
guidelines are, therefore, issued by the government for
protecting public interest from those contractors and
recipients who are non-responsible, lack business integrity
or engage in dishonest or illegal conduct or are otherwise
unable to perform satisfactorily. These guidelines prescribe
the following among other grounds for debarment:
a) Conviction of or civil judgment for -(1) Commission of fraud or a criminal offense in
connection with obtaining, attempting to obtain, or
performing a public or private agreement or transaction;
(2) Violation of Federal or State antitrust statutes,
including those proscribing price fixing between
competitors, allocation of customers between competitors,
and bid rigging;
(3) Commission of embezzlement, theft, forgery, bribery,
falsification or destruction of records, making false
statements, tax evasion, receiving stolen property, making
false claims, or obstruction of justice; or
2024:MLHC:827
(4) Commission of any other offense indicating a lack of
business integrity or business honesty that seriously and
directly affects your present responsibility;
(b) Violation of the terms of a public agreement or
transaction so serious as to affect the integrity of an agency
program, such as—
(1) A wilful failure to perform in accordance with the terms
of one or more public agreements or transactions;
(2) A history of failure to perform or of unsatisfactory
performance of one or more public agreements or
transactions; or
(3) A willful violation of a statutory or regulatory provision
or requirement applicable to a public agreement or
transaction;
(c)
*
*
*
(d) Any other cause of so serious or compelling a nature
that it affects your present responsibility.
22. The guidelines also stipulate the factors that may
influence the debarring official’s decision which include
the following:
a) The actual or potential harm or impact that results or
may result from the wrongdoing.
b) The frequency of incidents and/or duration of the
wrongdoing.
c) Whether there is a pattern or prior history of
wrongdoing.
d) Whether the
contractor has been excluded or
disqualified by an agency of the Federal Government or
has not been allowed to participate in State or local
contracts or assistance agreements on the basis of conduct
similar to one or more of the causes for debarment
specified in this part.
(e) Whether and to what extent did the contractor plan,
initiate or carry out the wrongdoing.
2024:MLHC:827
(f) Whether the contractor has accepted responsibility for
the wrongdoing and recognized the seriousness of the
misconduct.
(g) Whether the contractor has paid or agreed to pay all
criminal, civil and administrative liabilities for the
improper activity, including any investigative or
administrative costs incurred by the government, and has
made or agreed to make full restitution.
(h) Whether the contractor has cooperated fully with the
government agencies during the investigation and any
court or administrative action.
(i) Whether the wrongdoing was pervasive within the
contractor’s organization.
(j) The kind of positions held by the individuals involved in
the wrongdoing.
(k) Whether the contractor has taken appropriate corrective
action or remedial measures, such as establishing ethics
training and implementing programs to prevent recurrence.
(l) Whether the contractor fully investigated the
circumstances surrounding the cause for debarment and, if
so, made the result of the investigation available to the
debarring official.
23. As regards the period for which the order of debarment
will remain effective, the guidelines state that the same
would depend upon the seriousness of the case leading to
such debarment.
24. Similarly in England, Wales and Northern Ireland,
there are statutory provisions that make operators ineligible
on several grounds including fraud, fraudulent trading or
conspiracy to defraud, bribery etc.
25. Suffice it to say that ‘debarment’ is recognised and
often used as an effective method for disciplining deviant
suppliers/contractors who may have committed acts of
omission and commission or frauds including
misrepresentations, falsification of records and other
breaches of the regulations under which such contracts
2024:MLHC:827
were allotted. What is notable is that the ‘debarment’ is
never permanent and the period of debarment would
invariably depend upon the nature of the offence
committed by the erring contractor.”
13.
Further in the case of Blue Dreamz (supra) the Supreme
Court has held that where the case is of an ordinary breach of contract
and the explanation offered raises a bonafide dispute, blacklisting as a
penalty ought not to be resorted, as debarring a person for a certain
number of years tantamount to civil death and that invoking the
debarment for ordinary breach of contract where there is a bonafide
dispute is not permissible. The relevant paragraphs thereof i.e. Para 25,
26, 27, 37 & 38 are reproduced hereinbelow:“25. What is significant is that while setting out the
guidelines prescribed in USA, the Court noticed that
comprehensive guidelines for debarment were issued there
for protecting public interest from those contractors and
recipients who are non-responsible, lack business integrity
or engage in dishonest or illegal conduct or are otherwise
unable to perform satisfactorily. The illustrative cases set
out also demonstrate that debarment as a remedy is to be
invoked in cases where there is harm or potential harm for
public interest particularly in cases where the person’s
conduct has demonstrated that debarment as a penalty
alone will protect public interest and deter the person from
repeating his actions which have a tendency to put public
interest in jeopardy. In fact, it is common knowledge that in
notice inviting tenders, any person blacklisted is rendered
ineligible. Hence, blacklisting will not only debar the
person concerned from dealing with the concerned
employer, but because of the disqualification, their dealings
with other entities also is proscribed. Even in the terms and
conditions of tender in the present case, one of the
2024:MLHC:827
conditions of eligibility is that the agency should not be
blacklisted from anywhere.
26. In other words, where the case is of an ordinary breach
of contract and the explanation offered by the person
concerned
raises
a
bona
fide
dispute,
blacklisting/debarment as a penalty ought not to be resorted
to. Debarring a person albeit for a certain number of years
tantamounts to civil death inasmuch as the said person is
commercially ostracized resulting in serious consequences
for the person and those who are employed by him.
27. Too readily invoking the debarment for ordinary cases
of breach of contract where there is a bona fide dispute, is
not permissible. Each case, no doubt, would turn on the
facts and circumstances thereto.
37. The Division Bench having noticed the fact that any
decision to blacklist will be open to scrutiny on the anvil of
the doctrine of proportionality has failed to apply the
principle to the facts of the case in the correct perspective.
The Division Bench has also failed to correctly appreciate
the ratio of the decision in B.S.N. Joshi (supra).
38. There has been no enquiry by the Division Bench as to
whether the conduct of the appellant was part of the
normal vicissitudes in business and common place hazards
in commerce or whether the appellant had crossed the
rubicon warranting a banishment order, albeit for a
temporary period in larger public interest.”
Apart from the pronouncements quoted above, which have
detailed the circumstances that would warrant blacklisting, the above
quoted case has also analyzed the judgment rendered in the case of Kulja
Industries Limited (supra) where the party blacklisted were alleged to
have fraudulently withdrawn huge amount of money not due to it. The
2024:MLHC:827
other judgments cited by the petitioner having limited application, are not
discussed.
14.
In the instant case, the General Conditions of Contract itself
has in the Appendix thereto at Clause 2 under the caption ‘Fraud and
Corruption’ defined what would amount to corrupt practice, fraudulent
practice, collusive practice etc. The same is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“2. Requirements
2.1 The Bank requires that Borrowers (including beneficiaries of
Bank financing); bidders (applicant/proposers), consultants,
contractor and suppliers; any sub-contractors, sub-consultant,
service providers or suppliers; any agents (whether declared or
not); and any of their personal, observed the highest standard of
ethics during the procurement process, selection and contract
execution of Bank-finance contracts, and refrained from Fraud
and Corruption.
2.2 To this end, the Bank:
a. defines, for the purposes of this provision, the terms set forth
below as follows:
i) “corrupt practice” is the offering, giving, receiving or
soliciting, directly or indirectly of anything of value to influence
improperly the actions of another party;
ii) “fraudulent practice” is any act or omission, including
misrepresentation, that knowingly or recklessly misleads, or
attempts to mislead a party to obtain financial or other benefit or
to avoid an obligation;
iii) “collusive practice” is an arrangement between two or
more parties designed to achieve an improper purpose,
including to influence improperly the actions of
another party;
2024:MLHC:827
iv)
v)
“coercive practice” is impairing or harming, or
threatening to impair or harm, directly or indirectly,
any party or the property of the party to influence
improperly the actions of a party;
“obstructive practice” is;
a. deliberately destroying, falsifying, altering, or
concealing of evidence material to the investigation
or making false statement to investigators in order to
materially impede a Bank investigation into
allegations of a corrupt, fraudulent, coercive or
collusive practice; and/or threatening, harassing, or
intimidating any party to prevent it from disclosing
from its knowledge or matters relevant to the
investigation or from pursuing the investigation; or
b. acts intended to materially impede the exercise of
the Bank’s inspection and audit rights provided for
under paragraph 2.2.e. below.
b. Rejects of proposal for award if the Bank determines
that the firm or individual recommended for award,
any of its personal, or its agents, or its subconsultants, sub-contractors, service providers,
suppliers and/or their employees, has, directly or
indirectly, engaged in corrupt, fraudulent, collusive,
coercive or obstructive practices in competing for
the contract in question;
c. In addition to the legal remedies set out in the
relevant Legal Agreement, may take other
appropriate
actions,
including
declaring
misprocurement, if the Bank determines at any time
that representatives of the borrower or of a recipient
of any part of the proceeds of the loan engaged in
corrupt, fraudulent, collusive, coercive or
obstructive practices during the procurement
process, selection and/ or execution of the contact in
question, without the Borrower having taken timely
and appropriate action satisfactory to the Bank to
address such practices when they occur, including
by failing to inform the Bank in a timely manner at
the time they knew of the practices;
d. Pursuant to the Bank’s Anti-Corruption Guidelines
and in accordance with the Bank’s prevailing
sanctions policies and procedures, may sanction a
form or individual, either indefinitely or for stated
2024:MLHC:827
period of time, including by publicly declaring such
firm or individual ineligible (i) to be awarded or
otherwise benefit from a Bank-financed contract,
financially or in any other manner; (ii) to be a
nominated sub-contractor, consultant, manufacturer
or supplier, or service provider of an otherwise
eligible firm being awarded a Bank-financed
contract; and (iii) to receive the proceeds of any loan
made by the Bank or otherwise to participate further
in the preparation or implementation of any Bankfinanced project;
e. Requires that a clause be included in
bidding/request for proposals documents and in
contracts financed by a Bank loan, requiring (i)
bidders
(applicants/proposers),
consultants,
contractors, and suppliers and their sub-contractors,
sub-consultants, service providers, suppliers, agents,
personnel, permit the Bank to inspect all accounts,
records and others documents relating to the
procurement process, selection and/or contract
execution, and to have them audited by auditors
appointed by the Bank.”
15.
A perusal of the impugned order dated 25.07.2024, does not
however, make any allegation as to any fraud being committed or that
there was any collusion, but the entire alleged infraction is based on the
breach of the agreed terms of reference, non-fulfilment of minimum
deliverables, non-remediation of deficiencies, delay in delivery and an
attempt to take undue advantage in the bills raised for services in advance
of the payments being made. Placing the facts of the instant case against
the judgments which have been quoted above, the dispute between the
parties cannot be said or held to be fraudulent or affected public interest
to such an extent as to warrant the blacklisting or debarment of the
2024:MLHC:827
petitioner. No doubt issues have arisen which has caused a setback to the
project but in the considered view of this Court the blacklisting of the
petitioner is disproportionate to the infractions as alleged.
16.
To the mind of the Court and in the backdrop of the facts and
circumstances that have been set forth, the nature of dispute therefore, is
not one which cannot be resolved by resorting to the terms contained in
the contract itself, which has already provided for an inbuilt dispute
resolution mechanism. Clause 45.1 thereof, has mandated that disputes
shall be settled by arbitration and has provided for the manner and
procedure to be adopted.
17.
As such in view of the observations and discussions made
hereinabove and on the given facts and circumstances of the case, the
penalty of blacklisting inflicted upon the petitioner is deemed
unreasonable and disproportionate and the impugned order dated
25.07.2024 is accordingly set aside and quashed, leaving the parties to
avail alternate dispute resolution as contained in the terms of the contract
itself.
18.
The writ petition is allowed and stands disposed of.
2024:MLHC:827
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
09.09.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.09.09 17:31:18 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review