Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010371372024
2026:CGHC:30146-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by ALOK
ALOK
SHARMA
2026.07.21
SHARMA Date:
16:41:04 +0530
CRA No. 2001 of 2024
Ritik Sona S/o Dhudhe Sona Aged About 20 Years R/o Village Shivaji Nagar
Dabrapara, Raipur P.S. Aamanaka Raipur And District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant(s)
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through P.S. Aamanaka Raipur And District Raipur
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Anway Tiwari, Advocate.
For State
:
Mr. Sangharsh Pandey, Govt. Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
16/07/2026
Per, Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice.
Though the matter was listed for consideration on I.A. No. 01/2024,
application for suspension of sentence and grant of bail, however, with
the consent of the parties the appeal is being finally heard as the
appellant is in jail since 13.09.2021. Accordingly, I.A. No. 01/2024, is
disposed of.
The present appeal under Section 415(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 has been filed by the appellant against the
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
20.08.2024 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Raipur, District
Raipur (C.G.), in Sessions Trial No.08/2022, whereby the appellant has
been convicted and sentenced in the following manner:Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 302 of Indian Life imprisonment for offence under
Penal Code
Section 302 of I.P.C. and fine of Rs.
500/- and in default of payment of
further R.I. for three months.
Brief facts of the case are that, on 12.09.2021 at about 08:45 p.m., at
Dabrapara, Veer Shivaji Nagar, Raipur, the appellant allegedly
assaulted Rinku @ Khuchkhuch Tandi with a sharp-edged scissor-like
weapon and a stone, as a result of which he sustained fatal injuries
and died on the spot. Nirmal Tandi (PW-2), father of the deceased,
lodged a Dehati Merg Intimation and Dehati Nalishi, on the basis of
which Merg No.53/2021 and FIR Ex.P/19 were registered at Police
Station Aamanaka, Raipur, for the offence punishable under Section
302 of the Indian Penal Code. During investigation, the Investigating
Officer prepared the inquest (Ex.P/11) over the dead body of the
deceased in the presence of witnesses and sent the dead body for
post-mortem examination to AIIMS Hospital, Raipur, where Dr. Pawan
Kumar Shukla (PW-7) conducted the post-mortem and submitted his
report (Ex.P/15). During the post-mortem examination, multiple antemortem injuries, including stab wounds on the chest and back, incised
wounds and abrasions on different parts of the body, were noticed. The
doctor opined that the death was caused due to a penetrating injury to
the heart resulting in hemorrhagic shock and that the death was
homicidal in nature. The Investigating Officer prepared the spot map
(Ex.P/9), seized plain soil, blood-stained soil and a blood-stained
cement stone from the place of occurrence vide seizure memo Ex.P/3,
and recorded the memorandum statement of the appellant (Ex.P/1).
Pursuant to the said memorandum statement, a blood-stained part of a
sharp-edged scissor was recovered and seized vide seizure memo
Ex.P/2. The blood-stained shirt and pant worn by the appellant at the
time of the incident were also seized vide seizure memo Ex.P/4. The
seized articles, including the weapon of offence, clothes of the
appellant, clothes of the deceased, blood samples, viscera and other
exhibits, were sent to the State Forensic Science Laboratory for
chemical examination. As per the FSL report (Ex.P/28), human blood of
'B' group was detected on the appellant's shirt, pant, the seized scissor
and the clothes of the deceased, whereas the viscera report (Ex.P/31)
revealed that no poisonous substance was detected. Upon completion
of investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code.
The statements of the witnesses under Section 161 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 were recorded during the course of
investigation. After completion of the usual investigation, charge-sheet
was filed against the appellant for the offence punishable under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code before the Court of the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Raipur. Since the offence was exclusively triable
by the Court of Sessions, the case was committed to the Court of
Sessions Judge, Raipur, where it was registered as Sessions Trial
No.08/2022 and tried by the learned Sessions Judge, Raipur, who, by
the impugned judgment, convicted and sentenced the appellant as
stated hereinabove.
The trial Court has framed charge against the appellant for the offence
under Section 302 of I.P.C. The appellant abjured his guilt and claimed
trial.
In order to establish charge against the appellant, the prosecution has
examined as many as 13 witnesses. The statement of the appellant
under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was also
recorded, wherein he denied all the incriminating circumstances
appearing against him, pleaded innocence and stated that he has been
falsely implicated in the case. In defence, the appellant examined two
witnesses, namely, Rambilas (DW-1) and Ramesh Bhoi (DW-2), to
substantiate his plea of innocence.
7 After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the trial Court has convicted the appellant and sentenced
him as mentioned in opening para of this judgment. Hence this appeal.
8 Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. It is contended
that the conviction rests mainly on the testimony of PW-2 Nirmal Tandi,
whose evidence is not wholly reliable and suffers from material
infirmities. It is further submitted that though the prosecution has
projected PW-2 as an eyewitness, his testimony does not inspire
confidence, particularly in view of his admission that his eyesight is
weak. It is argued that most of the independent witnesses, namely,
PW-6 Sunil Tandi, PW-8 Rajkumar Nishad and PW-10 Neetu Sahni,
have not supported the prosecution case and have been declared
hostile. Learned counsel would further submit that the alleged recovery
of the weapon of offence and other articles is also doubtful, as the
seizure witnesses have not supported the prosecution case. It is further
contended that the defence has examined DW-1 Rambilas and DW-2
Ramesh Bhoi, whose evidence probabilises the plea that the appellant
was elsewhere at the relevant time and had gone for hamali work and
was seen purchasing fish at about 10:00 p.m. on the date of the
incident. It is also argued that the prosecution has failed to establish an
unbroken chain of circumstances connecting the appellant with the
commission of the offence and that the forensic evidence, by itself, is
insufficient to sustain the conviction. Therefore, it is submitted that the
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence are
unsustainable in law and deserve to be set aside and the appellant is
entitled to be acquitted of the charge.
Per contra, learned counsel for the State supports the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence and submits that the
prosecution has proved its case beyond all reasonable doubt. It is
contended that the testimony of PW-2 Nirmal Tandi, the father of the
deceased and an eyewitness to the incident, is cogent, consistent and
inspires confidence. His evidence is duly corroborated by the prompt
lodging of the Dehati Merg Intimation, Dehati Nalishi and the First
Information Report, as well as by the medical evidence of PW-7 Dr.
Pawan Kumar Shukla, who has categorically opined that the death was
homicidal and was caused by a penetrating injury to the heart inflicted
by a sharp-edged weapon. Learned State counsel would further submit
that pursuant to the memorandum statement of the appellant, the
weapon of offence, namely, a sharp-edged scissor, was recovered, and
the Forensic Science Laboratory report establishes the presence of
human blood of 'B' group on the appellant's shirt, pant, the seized
scissor and the clothes of the deceased. The appellant has failed to
offer any explanation regarding the presence of the blood stains on his
clothes and the weapon recovered at his instance. It is further
submitted that the evidence of the defence witnesses does not
probabilise the plea of alibi, as it does not establish the appellant's
whereabouts at the time of occurrence, i.e., about 8:45 p.m. Therefore,
the prosecution has succeeded in proving the guilt of the appellant
beyond reasonable doubt by leading reliable ocular, medical and
scientific evidence. It is thus submitted that the learned trial Court has
rightly appreciated the evidence on record, and the impugned
judgment does not suffer from any illegality or perversity warranting
interference by this Court.
We have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the records of
the case.
The first and foremost question that arises for consideration would be
the nature of the death of the deceased as to whether his death was
homicidal or not.
PW-2 Nirmal Tandi, is the father of the deceased who lodged dehati
merg intimation Ex.P/7. He, being the eyewitness to the incident,
proved that the appellant assaulted his son Rinku by knife on his chest,
abdomen and waist. In the dehati merg intimation itself, the injuries
inflicted by the appellant upon the deceased is mentioned. Based on
the dehati merg intimation, the dehati nalishi Ex.P/8 was recorded at
Amanaka Police Station.
The witness to the inquest Ex.P/11 Nirmal Dandi PW-2, Vinod
Vishwakarma PW-3 have proved the inquest of the dead body of the
deceased, and injuries were noticed on various parts of the body.
PW-7, Dr. Pawan Kumar Shukla, conducted the post-mortem of the
dead body of the deceased. While conducting post-mortem on
13.09.2021 along with Dr. Roop Jyoti Medhi, he noticed the following
injuries on the dead body of the deceased:-
“(1) Incised wound of size 1.5cm x 0.3cm x bone
deep, present over right side of forehead,
obliquely placed. The lower medial end is sharp
and placed 2cm right of midline. The upper lateral
end is blunt and placed 2.7cm above right
eyebrow. Margins sharp and actively bleeding.
(2) Red coloured grazed abrasion of size 1.5cm x
1.5cm, placed across lower end of injury number
1. Direction of the abrasion is upwards and
medially.
(3) Three parallel red coloured scratch abrasion of
length 1.5cm, 7.5cm and 1.5cm each, from
upwards-down, obliquely placed, present over left
side of neck. The smaller scratches are placed
1cm above and below the lateral end of larger
middle scratch. The medial end of the middle
scratch is placed 5.5cm from midline and lateral
end placed 09cm below tip of left mastoid
process.
(4) Stab wound of size 02cm x 0.7cm x chest
cavity deep, vertically placed with slight obliquity
to the right, over front of chest just right to midline.
The upper lateral end is sharp, placed 1.5cm
below sternal angle and 23cm below chin. The
lower medial end is blunt, placed 24cm above
umbilicus and 130cm above right heel. The right
margin is bevelled and left margin is undermined.
On dissection, the sternum shows perforating
sharp cut of dimension 1.8cm x 0.7cm. On further
dissection along the tract of the injury, cuts are
seen in the anterior pericardium, anterior wall of
right ventricle, right atrio-ventricular septum,
posterior wall of right atrium, posterior
pericardium and terminating into lower lobe of left
lung, with dimensions 1.6cm x 0.7cm, 1.5cm x
0.7cm, 1.4cm x 0.6cm, 01cm x 0.4cm, 01cm x
0.4cm and 0.5cm x 0.3cm x 01cm respectively.
The total length of the track was about 15cm. The
direction of the track was right to left, upwards
and backwards. The Tee-Shirt was having cut
mark of size 1.8cm corresponding to the injury
described.
(5) Incised wound of size 0.6cm x 0.2cm x
subcutaneous deep present over the distal third of
left middle finger, postero-medial aspect. Both
angles sharp, margins sharp and bleeding
present.
(6) Two abrasion with fallen off scab at places, of
size 2cm x 1.5cm and 2cm x 1cm, present over
the front of right knee, placed 1cm apart.
(7) Red coloured abrasion of size 5.5cm x 1.7cm
present over the front of left leg, placed 2cm
below left knee.
(8) Red abraded contusion of size 12cm x 4cm
present over the front of left leg, placed 6cm
below injury no (7).
(9) Three red coloured abrasions, placed next to
each other, of sizes 0.5 cm x 0.2cm, 0.4cm x
0.4cm and 1.5cm x 1cm, present over right side of
upper back, just right to midline and 13cm below
hairline.
(10) Stab wound of size 2.2cm x 0.5cm x muscle
deep, obliquely placed, present over right side of
lower back. The upper medial end is blunt, placed
6cm to right of midline and 46cm below tip of right
shoulder. The lower lateral end is sharp, placed
5cm above right iliac crest and 108cm above
heel. The lower margin is bevelled and upper
margin is undermined. The total length of the
track is about 5cm and there is no penetration into
the abdominal cavity. The direction of the track
was medial to lateral, upwards, forwards.
The Tee-Shirt was having cut mark, at the back,
of size 2.3cm corresponding to the injury
described.”
He opined the injury no. 1 and 5 are caused by hard and sharp object,
injury no. 4 and 10 are caused by sharp pointed and single-edged
object and injuries no. 2, 6 to 9 are caused by a hard and blunt object
and opined that death was due to cardio temponent consequent upon
stab injury to the heart. Injury no. 4, along with its associated internal
injuries, is caused by a sharp, pointed, single-edged object and is
sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. He proved
the post-mortem report Ex.P/15. In his cross-examination, the only
suggestion given by the defence that if a person fell from the
motorcycle while in high speed and dashed with a pointed object then
the stab injury found on the body of the deceased can be caused,
which he denied and state that only one injury could be caused in such
condition. He also denied the suggestion that the stab injury could be
caused by iron rod.
From the evidence of the doctor who conducted the post-mortem of the
dead body of the deceased clearly suggests that the deceased was
died due to the injuries that were homicidal in nature, and we also
concur with the findings recorded by the learned trial Court.
So far as the involvement of the appellant in the offence in question is
concerned, the prosecution proved its case by examining PW-2, Nirmal
Tandi, who is the father of the deceased. He stated in his evidence that
the deceased Khuchkhuch Tandi alias Rinku was his younger son. On
the date of incident, his son Rinku came out from his house at about
07:00 PM, and after a short distance, he was assaulted by the
appellant with a knife. His son fell down on the ground he tried to
intervene, but the appellant fled away from there his son died on the
spot. He lodged dehati merg intimation Ex.P/7 Dehati Nalishi Ex.P/8,
and proved the spot and Ex.P/9 inquest Ex.P/11. In cross-examination,
he admitted that he knew the appellant because he is also a resident of
the same vicinity. He denied that on the date of the incident, he was
under the influence of liquor. He admitted that his eyesight was low. He
denied that there was previous quarrel between his son and brother of
the appellant. He was confronted with his police statement Ex.D/1
about a previous quarrel between his son and the brother of the
deceased, and he denied the same to disclose it before the police. He
denied that his since his vision is weak, he could not see the incident
as to who assaulted his son. He firmly stated that it is the appellant
who committed of his son. From the evidence of this witness, there is
nothing in his cross-examination to disbelieve him. He is the father of
the deceased, the incident occurred within a very short distance of his
house, and his presence is also quite natural on the spot. He tried to
intervene in the incident and immediately lodged dehati merg intimation
in which he named the appellant as the accused. His evidence remains
unshaken in his cross-examination and duly proved that the appellant
caused numerous injuries to the body of the deceased with a knife.
PW-1, Kamal Soni, was informed by the persons in the vicinity that the
appellant caused multiple injuries to the deceased, and then he gave
intimation to the police through his mobile phone. He was also the
witness to the memorandum Ex.P/, seizure of scissors Ex.P/2, bloodstained and plain soil Ex.P/3, clothes of the appellant Ex.P/4, and
arrest of the appellant Ex.P/5. In cross-examination, he admitted that
he signed the document at the instance of the police at the police
station.
PW-3, Vinod Vishwakarma, is the witness to the inquest Ex.P/11, and
seizure memos Ex.P/2 and Ex.P/3; however, he turned hostile and did
not support the prosecution case.
PW-4, Prafull Tandi, is the brother of the deceased. When he came to
know of the incident, he had gone to AIMS Hospital, and then his father
informed him that the appellant had murdered his brother. He was
neither an eyewitness to the incident nor a witness of any proceeding
during the investigation.
PW-5, Ashwani Sahu, is the Patwari who prepared the spot map
Ex.P/13.
PW-6, Sunil Tandi, is also the witness to the inquest but has turned
hostile and not supported the prosecution’s case.
PW-8, Rajkumar Nishad, was the witness of inquest Ex.P/11, but he
too has turned hostile and supported the prosecution case.
PW-10, Neetu Sahani, was the eyewitness to the incident, but she
completely turned hostile and did not support the prosecution’s case.
PW-9, S.K. Kar, PW-11, Daitari Ghoi, PW-12, Yakub Memon and PW13, Rajesh Singh are the witnesses to the investigation who proved
their part of the investigation which they did. They, being the procedural
witnesses, duly proved the part of the investigation and supported the
prosecution’s case.
From the aforesaid evidence, the prosecution has duly proved that the
appellant caused multiple injuries to the deceased, due to which he
died. The weapon of offence, as well as his clothes, i.e., scissors, has
been seized from the appellant.
The evidence of PW-2 cannot be discarded merely on the basis that he
is the father of the deceased and an interested witness.
Further, merely being closely related to the deceased or a relative of
the deceased cannot be a ground to disbelieve the evidence of an
eyewitness. In the case of Dharnidhar Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh
and others, (2010) 7 SCC 759, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
follows:“12.There is no hard-and-fast rule that family
members can never be true witnesses to the
occurrence and that they will always depose
falsely before the Court. It will always depend
upon the facts and circumstances of a given case.
In Jayabalan v. UT of Pondicherry, (2010) 1 SCC
199, this Court had occasion to consider whether
the evidence of interested witnesses can be relied
upon. The Court took the view that a pedantic
approach cannot be applied while dealing with the
evidence of an interested witness. Such evidence
cannot be ignored or thrown out solely because it
comes from a person closely related to the victim.
The Court held as under: (SCC p. 213, paras 2324)
“23. We are of the considered view that in cases
where the court is called upon to deal with the
evidence of the interested witnesses, the
approach of the court, while appreciating the
evidence of such witnesses must not be pedantic.
The court must be cautious in appreciating and
accepting the evidence given by the interested
witnesses but the court must not be suspicious of
such evidence. The primary endeavour of the
court must be to look for consistency. The
evidence of a witness cannot be ignored or
thrown out solely because it comes from the
mouth of a person who is closely related to the
victim.”
13. Similar view was taken by this Court in Ram
Bharosey v. State of U.P., (2010) 1 SCC 722,
where the Court stated the dictum of law that a
close relative of the deceased does not, per se,
become an interested witness. An interested
witness is one who is interested in securing the
conviction of a person out of vengeance or enmity
or due to disputes and deposes before the court
only with that intention and not to further the
cause of justice. The law relating to appreciation
of evidence of an interested witness is well
settled, according to which, the version of an
interested witness cannot be thrown overboard,
but has to be examined carefully before accepting
the same.”
The scissors seized from the appellant were sent for its query report to
the doctor who gave the query report Ex.P/17, in his detailed query
report describing the shape of the weapon of offence opined that “after
considering the characteristics of the wounds as noted in PMR No.
AIIMS/RPR/2021/203 and from the characteristics of the weapon
submitted to me, I am of the opinion that the wound found over the
body of the victim is likely to have been caused by such a weapon as
has been examined.” The said weapon was referred for FSL
examination for confirmation of the presence of blood.
The police sent the piece of cement brick (Article -A), blood-stained soil
(Article-B), Plain soil (Article-C), shirt of the appellant (Article -D), pant
of the appellant (Article-E), scissor seized from the appellant (Article-
F), t-shirt of the deceased (Article-G), jeans pant of the deceased
(Article-H), underwear of the deceased (Article-I) to the FSL for its
chemical examination and as per the FSL report Ex.P/28, ‘B’ group of
human blood was found on shirt of the appellant (Article -D), pant of
the appellant (Article-E), scissor seized from the appellant (Article-F), tshirt of the deceased (Article-G), jeans pant of the deceased (ArticleH), underwear of the deceased (Article-I) and human blood was found
on the cement brick (Article-A), blood has been found on blood stained
soil. Since the “B” blood group was found in the clothes of the appellant
as well as in the clothes of the deceased and also in the scissors
seized from the appellant, he has to explain the circumstances about
the presence of the same blood group in his clothes, which matched
the blood group of the deceased. When this incriminating circumstance
was put up before the appellant in his 313 Cr.P.C. statement under the
questions no. 118 to 122, he showed his ignorance about the same,
but could not explain it. It is necessary to notice the relevant part of his
statement recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., which is as under:"प्रश्न-118 इसके अनुसार प्रकरण में जप्त पत्थरनुमा टुकड़ा
खून आलूदा मिट्टी, सादी मिट्टी, तुम्हारी शर्ट, पैंट, तुमसे जप्त
कैं ची, मृतक रिकु उर्फ खुचखुच तांडी की शर्ट, जींस पैंट,
अण्डरवियर को पुलिस अधीक्षक के ज्ञापन प्र0पी0 26
सहित रासायनिक जाँच के लिये राज्य विधि विज्ञान
प्रयोगशाला रायपुर भेजे थे जिसकी प्राप्ति रसीद प्र0पी0 27
है एवं परीक्षण रिपोर्ट प्र0पी0 28 है। क्या तुम्हें कु छ कहना है
?
उत्तर- मालूम नहीं
प्रश्न-119 राज्य न्यायालयिक विज्ञान प्रयोगशाला रायपुर का
परीक्षण प्रतिवेदन प्र.पी. -25 के अनुसार मृतक रिकु तांडी
के गाजपीस प्रदर्श-ए, रक्त प्रदर्श-बी 1, रक्त प्रदर्श-बी 2 पर
मानव रक्त पाये गये। क्या तुम्हें कु छ कहना है ?
उत्तर- मालूम नहीं
प्रश्न-120 राज्य न्यायालयिक विज्ञान प्रयोगशाला रायपुर का
परीक्षण प्रतिवेदन प्र.पी. -28 के अनुसार घटनास्थल से जप्त
सीमेन्ट का टुकड़ा प्रदर्श-ए, मिट्टी प्रदर्श-बी, तुम्हारे शर्ट
प्रदर्श-डी, पैंट प्रदर्श-ई, कैं ची प्रदर्श-एफ, मृतक के टी शर्ट
प्रदर्श-जी, जींस पैंट प्रदर्श-एच, अंडरवियर प्रदर्श-आई में
रक्त पाया गया। क्या तुम्हें कु छ कहना है ?
उत्तर- मालूम नहीं
प्रश्न-121 राज्य न्यायालयिक विज्ञान प्रयोगशाला रायपुर का
परीक्षण प्रतिवेदन प्र.पी. -28 के अनुसार घटनास्थल से जप्त
सीमेन्ट का टुकड़ा प्रदर्श-ए, तुम्हारे शर्ट प्रदर्श-डी, पैंट प्रदर्शई, कैं ची प्रदर्श-एफ, मृतक के टी शर्ट प्रदर्श-जी, जींस पैंट
प्रदर्श-एच, अंडरवियर प्रदर्श-आई में मानव रक्त पाया गया।
क्या तुम्हें कु छ कहना है ?
उत्तर- मालूम नहीं
प्रश्न-122 राज्य न्यायालयिक विज्ञान प्रयोगशाला रायपुर का
परीक्षण प्रतिवेदन प्र.पी. -28 के अनुसार तुम्हारे शर्ट प्रदर्शडी, पैंट प्रदर्श-ई, कैं ची प्रदर्श-एफ, मृतक के टी शर्ट प्रदर्शजी, जींस पैंट प्रदर्श-एच, अंडरवियर प्रदर्श-आई में 'बी' समूह
(ग्रुप) का रक्त पाया गया। क्या तुम्हें कु छ कहना है ?
उत्तर- मालूम नहीं"
The non-explanation of incriminating circumstances by the accused in
313 Cr.P.C. statement is an additional link against him, pointing
towards the guilt of the accused.
Nevertheless, once the prosecution has independently established the
forensic
evidence
and
other
incriminating
circumstances,
the
appellant's failure to furnish any explanation regarding facts, especially
within his knowledge, assumes significance and constitutes an
additional link in the chain of circumstantial evidence. The law is well
settled that a false or evasive explanation under Section 313 CrPC
may be taken into consideration as an additional circumstance
reinforcing the prosecution case, though it cannot be made the sole
basis of conviction. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
“Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra” 2006 (10) SCC
681, has held that:-
“21. In a case based on circumstantial evidence
where no eyewitness a account is available,
there is another principle of law which must be
kept in mind. The principle is that when an
incriminating circumstance is put to the accused
and the said accused either offers no explanation
or offers an explanation which is found to be
untrue, then the same becomes an additional link
in the chain of circumstances to make it
complete. This view has been taken in a catena
of decisions of this Court. [See State of T.N. v.
Rajendrans b (SCC para 6); State of U.P. v. Dr.
Ravindra Prakash Mittal (SCC para 39: AIR para
40); State of Maharashtra v. Suresh 10 (SCC
para 27); Ganesh Lal v State of Rajasthan (SCC
para 15) and Gulab Chand v. State of M.P.12
(SCC para 4).]”
Further in the case of “Shivaji Chintappa Patil v. State of
Maharashtra” 2021 (5) SCC 626, it has been held that:-
“25. Another circumstance relied upon by the
prosecution is that the appellant failed to give
any explanation in his statement under Section
313 CrPC. By now it is well-settled principle of
law, that false explanation or non-explanation
can only be used as an additional circumstance,
when the prosecution has proved the chain of
circumstances leading to no other conclusion
than the guilt of the accused. However, it cannot
be used as a link to complete the chain.
Reference in this respect could be made to the
judgment of this Court in Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984)” 4 SCC
116: 1984 SCC (Cri) 487.”
The appellant has also examined two defence witnesses in the case
who stated about his absence on the place of the incident.
DW-1, Rambilas, has stated in his evidence that on the date of the
incident, the appellant Ritik Sona was with him up to 10:00 PM, and till
that time they were in their work of Coolie. In cross-examination, he
stated that at about 07:00 PM on the date of the incident, they had
gone to Mahoba Bajar to vacate a house there. On the same morning,
he had gone there, came back after some time and again went at
about 07:00 PM. He admitted that when the police arrested the
appellant, he had not gone to the police to inform them that the
appellant had been with him throughout the day and he had not
committed any offence. He admitted that he and the appellant were
working together and therefore he has a very good relationship with
him.
DW-2 Ramesh Hoi is the fish seller who stated in his evidence that on
the date of the incident, at about 10-10:30 PM, the appellant and
Rambilas came to his shop and after purchasing fish, they went back.
After 10-15 minutes, Tebu and Yaam informed him about the incident,
and then he informed the father of the deceased, who was in a
drunken condition at that time. In cross-examination, he admitted that
within the municipal area, the shops are normally closed up to 10:00
PM, and his shop also comes under the municipal area. He did not see
them as to where they came from. He himself has not informed the
police that the appellant had come to his shop at about 10:00 to
purchase fish he too has admitted that he has a good relation with the
appellant and his family.
These two witnesses tried to build the defence that the appellant was
with DW-1 Rambilas until 10:00-10:30 at night, and by that time, the
incident had already occurred. However, no suggestions were given to
PW-2, Nirmal Tandi, that the appellant was not there on the spot, but
he was at his work with DW-1, Rambilas. Further, these two witnesses
have never informed the police that the appellant has not committed
the offence despite the fact that they have a very good relationship with
the appellant and his family members. The defence could not produce
any witness with respect to his presence at his workplace, and these
two defence witnesses are related to the presence of the appellant in
the fish shop of DW-2, at 10:00 -10:30 PM. Both these places, i.e., the
place of incident and the fish shop of DW-2, are situated nearby, and in
such circumstances, it cannot be said that the appellant has
succeeded in imputing the probability of his defence that he was not
present on the spot. Therefore, the defence witnesses cannot be said
to be reliable on this point.
Having considered the entire facts and circumstances of the case,
evidence available on record, and the consideration of the learned trial
Court, we do not find any perversity or illegality in the judgment passed
by the learned trial Court holding the appellant guilty of the offence
under Section 302 of the IPC for committing the murder of the
deceased Rinku alias Khuchkhuch Tandi.
Accordingly, the appeal filed by the appellant fails and is hereby
dismissed.
The appellant is reported to be in jail since 13.09.2021, he shall serve
the entire sentence as awarded by the learned trial Court.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is undergoing his jail
sentence to serve the same on the appellant, informing him that he is
at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this court by
preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the
assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the Supreme
Court Legal Services Committee.
42 The records of the case along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
Alok
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review