Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010405932024
2026:CGHC:44139
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No.2088 of 2024
The date when
The date when
The date when the
the judgment is
the judgment is
judgment is uploaded on
reserved
pronounced
the website
30.09.2026
Operative
Full
--
14.10.2026
13.10.2026
1 - Parasram Baiga S/o Shri Lamu Baiga Aged About 35 Years R/o
Village Bhedagarh, P.S. Kukdur, District Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
Appellant (s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Kukdur, District
Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
Respondent(s)
For Appellant (s)
:
For Respondent (s) :
Mr. Mahesh Kumar Mishra, Advocate
Mr. Vivek Mishra, PL
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi
CAV Judgment
Digitally
signed
by R
NIRALA
1.
This criminal appeal has been preferred by the appellant under
Section 415 (2) of BNSS, 2023 challenging the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 09.10.2024 passed by
the learned Special Judge (Electricity Act), District Kabirdham
(C.G.) in Special Electricity Case No.869/2021, whereby the
appellant has been convicted and sentenced as under:Conviction
Sentence
u/S 135 (1) (A) of the RI for 6 months and fine of Rs.300/Electricity Act, 2003
and in default of payment of fine,
u/S 304 (A) of IPC
additional RI for 15 days
RI for 6 months and fine of Rs.300/and in default of payment of fine,
additional RI for 15 days
Both the sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
2.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the informant
Tirathram lodged a report on 30.08.2020 at the Police Station
concerned to the effect that on 30.08.2020 at about 9.00 am,
his uncle Baishakhu's daughter Ku. Neha, aged about 7 years,
had gone to Panihari drain with her friends, where an electric
wire for the motor pump was drawn by the appellant allegedly
from electric pole to his agricultural field for farming, but the
wire got broken and fell into the drain as such electricity
spread in the drain and while taking bath Ku. Neha came into
contact with electricity and she died due to electric current.
During investigation, it was found that appellant/accused was
using a single phase 1.5 HP mono block motor for agriculture
work directly hooking 10 S.W.G. aluminum wire with the help
of bamboo and poles through Panihari drain to his farm
located at 250 meters away. Thereafter, an FIR was registered
against the appellant for the offence under Section 304-A of
IPC. During the course of investigation, inquest report of dead
body (Ex-P/4) was prepared and postmortem was conducted
by Dr. Prasangina Sadhu (PW-8). The spot map was prepared
by the Police and Patwari and two bundles of aluminum wire,
length about 280 metres, and one monoblock motor pump was
seized from the appellant vide seizure memo (Ex-P/6). The
statement of witnesses was recorded and report (Ex-P/9) was
received from the Junior Engineer of Chhattisgarh State Power
Distribution Company Limited, Distribution Centre, Kukdur.
Another report (Ex-P/11) was also received from the Office of
Assistant Engineer (Safety) and Assistant Electrical Inspector,
Sub Division, Rajnandgaon. After investigation, charge sheet
was filed before the Special Court (constituted under the
Electricity Act), District Kabirdham (henceforth referred as
‘Special Court’) for the offence under Section 304-A of IPC and
Section 135 (1) (A) of the Electricity Act, 2003. The appellant
abjured the guilt and claimed trial.
3.
In order to bring home the charges, the prosecution examined
10 witnesses and exhibited 17 documents. Examination of
accused was recorded, in which he denied all the incriminating
circumstances appearing against him. He has not examined
any witness in his defence.
4.
The learned Special Court after appreciating the evidence
available on record convicted and sentenced the appellant, as
has been mentioned in opening paragraph of this judgment.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that it is
alleged that the appellant had taken illegal electric connection
from electric pole situated near Panihari drain to his
agricultural field, but it has not been proved by the prosecution
that the said agricultural field was owned and possessed by
the appellant/accused, whereas Baisakhu (PW-4), who is the
father of the deceased, himself has admitted in his crossexamination
that
various
persons
had
taken
electric
connection in their agricultural field situated near the drain,
therefore, the prosecution ought to have proved conclusively
that the appellant had taken electric connection in his own
agricultural field, which resulted into death of the deceased. He
further submits that the incident had taken place on
30.08.2020 but no such article was seized from the appellant
from his agricultural field on the date of the incident, rather
mono block motor pump and electric wire were seized from the
appellant after 2 months of the incident, hence those belated
seizure cannot be connected with crime in question. He further
submits that there is no lawful evidence to convict the
appellant for the aforesaid offence and only on the basis of
vague and baseless statement of the prosecution witnesses,
the learned Special Court has convicted and sentenced the
appellant. Hence he prays that the appeal be allowed and the
appellant be acquitted of all the charges.
6.
Per contra, learned State counsel supports the impugned
judgment and submits that the Assistant Engineer Samir
Kumar Niyogi (PW-6) had submitted his report (Ex-P/9) that
the appellant had not taken valid electric connection from the
Agriculture Department for the purpose of running electric
pump, which shows that the said connection was taken by the
appellant illegally from electric pole, which resulted into death
of the deceased. This fact has also been supported by the
witnesses. Hence the appeal deserves to be rejected.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record including the record of the learned Trial
Court.
8.
PW-4 Baisakhu is father of deceased Neha. He has stated in
his deposition that on the date of incident, her daughter Neha,
aged about 6 years, suffered electrocution near Panihari drain
and thereafter died. This fact also gets support from deposition
of Tirath Ram Dhurve (PW-1), who after receiving information
had gone to the place of occurrence and had seen deceased
Neha lying in the water of drain. The aforesaid fact has also
been supported by Bhagat Ram Dhurve (PW-2), Bhanwar
Singh Baiga (PW-3), Kotwar Shriram (PW-5) and the Inspector
Ram Kishan Markam (PW-10), who prepared inquest report
(Ex-P/4) of dead body of deceased and recorded merg report
(Ex-P/1). Nothing has been elicited in the cross-examination of
the aforesaid witnesses to disbelieve the aforesaid fact.
9.
Dr. Prasangina Sadhu (PW-8) conducted postmortem of
deceased on 30.08.2020 i.e. on the date of incident. She
opined vide postmortem report (Ex-P/10) that cause of death
of deceased was respiratory failure due to electric current. She
also opined that nature of death of deceased was accidental.
10.
Thus, from the aforesaid evidence, it is proved that on
30.08.2020, the deceased Neha died in drain of her village due
to electrocution.
11.
Now the question to be considered is, as to whether the
deceased Neha electrocuted from electric wire illegally taken
by the appellant from electric pole to his agricultural field or
not?
12.
In this regard, Baisakhu (PW-4) has stated in his deposition
that the appellant had taken electric connection/wire from
electric pole to his agricultural field for its irrigation, that electric
wire was broken and fell in the drain, therefore, deceased had
suffered electrocution. His statement has also been supported
by Tirath Ram Dhurve (PW-1), Bhagat Ram Dhurve (PW-2)
and Bhanwar Singh Baiga (PW-3). These witnesses have also
admitted in their cross-examination that there were agricultural
fields of residents of other villagers also near Panihari drain.
Father of deceased Baisakhu (PW-4) has also admitted in para
5 of his cross-examination that his relatives, whose agricultural
filed was near the said drain, have also taken electric
connection/wire in their agricultural field for its irrigation.
13.
Though Tirath Ram Dhurve (PW-1), Bhagat Ram Dhurve (PW2) and Bhanwar Singh Baiga (PW-3) have denied the
suggestion that they have also taken electric connection to
their agricultural field, but it appears from the admission of
Baisakhu (PW-4) in para 5 of his cross-examination that the
other villagers have also taken electric connection from the
electric pole into their agricultural field. In such situation, the
prosecution ought to have proved the fact that the alleged
electric connection, which was broken and fell into the drain,
was the electric connection which was taken by the appellant
in his agricultural field. Except verbal statement of aforesaid
witnesses, nothing is there to prove that the said agricultural
field was owned/possessed by the appellant, no revenue
document etc. has been filed/proved by the prosecution. Even
Patwari Virendra Kumar Pusam (PW-7), who prepared spot
map (Ex-P/8), has also not demonstrated in patwari map (ExP/8) about the aforesaid fact. In the spot map (Ex-P/2)
prepared by the Police, it has been shown that the said electric
wire was taken in the field of appellant from electric pole, but it
has not been proved by the prosecution that what was the
khasra number of that agricultural field and who is the
owner/possessor of that agricultural field. In this regard, the
prosecution ought to have filed and proved revenue document
i.e. khasra/B-1, but no such document has been filed/proved.
Therefore, verbal statement of aforesaid witnesses cannot be
relied upon.
14.
It has been stated by the prosecution witnesses in their
deposition that the appellant had taken illegal electric
connection from the electric pole to his agricultural field for
irrigation of the same, but Bhagat Ram Dhurve (PW-2) has
stated in his examination-in-chief that the said electric
connection was taken from the house of Bhanwar Singh Baiga
(PW-3), which contradicts the statement of other prosecution
witnesses that the said electric connection was taken from the
electric pole.
15.
The incident had occurred on 30.08.2020 at about 9 am, but
two bundles of aluminum wire and one monoblock motor pump
were allegedly seized from the house of the appellant on
30.10.2020 i.e. after 2 months from the date of incident.
Having considered such a long delay in seizure of aforesaid
article, that seizure cannot be connected with the crime in
question. Hence, it is not helpful for the prosecution.
16.
The Assistant Engineer Samir Kumar Niyogi (PW-6) has stated
in his deposition that on the query of Police of Police Station
Kukdur, he had given information vide Ex-P/9 that the
appellant had taken electric connection for domestic purpose,
but he had not taken any type of electric connection from
Electrical Department i.e. permanent or temporary for
agriculture purpose.
17.
The Sub Engineer Tikendra Kumar Deshmukh (PW-9) had
inspected the place of incident on 10.12.2020. He has stated
in his deposition that on inspection, he found that the appellant
had taken illegal electric connection through two open wire
with the help of wooden/bamboo pole from 4th pole of
transformer and distance of that was 120 metres, by which he
used to run mono block motor pump of 1.5 HP to irrigate his
agricultural field, but Tikendra Kumar Deshmukh (PW-9) has
admitted in his cross-examination that he had not examined as
to the title of the said land, rather in enquiry, he was informed
that the said agricultural field was of the appellant. The incident
occurred on 30.08.2020, but this witness conducted spot
inspection on 10.12.2020 and submitted report (Ex-P/11) dated
22.03.2021. Further, he has not examined ownership of the
said land where broken electric connection was taken.
Therefore, looking to his vague and baseless statement, the
report (Ex-P/11) based on belated inspection is not found to be
reliable to hold that the appellant was the owner/possessor of
the said agricultural field.
18.
In view of the above discussions of oral and documentary
evidence adduced by the prosecution, it cannot be held
beyond reasonable doubt that the alleged electric wire from
the electric pole was taken by the appellant to his agricultural
field, rather evidence adduced by the prosecution in this
regard against the appellant is not found to be sufficient to hold
him guilty for the charges levelled against him. Hence, the
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence
deserve to be set aside/quashed.
19.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence passed by the Special Court
against the appellant are hereby set aside/quashed. The
appellant is acquitted of the charges under Section 135 (1) (A)
of the Electricity Act, 2003 and Section 304 (A) of IPC.
20.
The appellant is reported to be in jail. He be released forthwith,
if he is not required to be detained in any other offence.
21.
Keeping in view the provisions of Section 481 of BNSS 2023,
the appellant is directed to furnish a personal bond for a sum
of Rs.25,000/- before the Court concerned forthwith, which
shall be effective for a period of six months along with an
undertaking that in the event of filing of Special Leave Petition
against the instant judgment or for grant of leave, the aforesaid
appellant on receipt of notice thereof, shall appear before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
22.
The trial Court record along with a copy of this judgment be
sent back immediately to the trial Court concerned for
compliance and necessary action.
23.
Interim application, if any, stands disposed of.
Sd/-
(Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Judge
Nirala
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review