Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Judgment reserved on
Date of pronouncement
Date of uploading
APHC010575532025
: 11.08.2026
: 09.09.2026
: 10.09.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3584]
WRIT APPEAL NO: 741 of 2026
Rithwik Projects Private Limited
...Appellant
Vs.
The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 09th September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellant:
MR.O.MANOHAR REDDY,
LEARNED SENIOR COUNSEL,
WITH Mr. M. SIVA KUMAR
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
GP FOR IRRI AND CAD,
GP FOR FINANCE & PLANNING
***
JUDGMENT : (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
The unsuccessful writ petitioner preferred this intra-Court appeal
assailing the order, dated 19.08.2025, in W.P.No.10835 of 2017, passed
by learned Single Judge, dismissing the writ petition.
2.
The writ petition was filed seeking following relief:
“…. to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, particularly
one in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring Memo.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
No.DWA/AP/HYD/Snl/A1/201617/10.217, dated 22.08.2016, issued
by the 2nd Respondent and G.O. Ms. No. 125, dated 29.12.2016,
insofar as it affects the petitioner’s rights issued by the 1st Respondent,
as illegal, arbitrary unconstitutional and consequently direct the
Respondents to desist from acting on the same….”
3.
Facts in brief are as follows:
(a) 1st respondent floated tender for earthwork excavation and
construction of CM & CD works of HNSS Main Canal from K.M. 230.000
to K.M.245.00 in Anantapur District, with an Estimated Contract Value
(“E.C.V.”) of ₹46,83,17,853/- with a completion period of 6 months.
Similarly, another tender was floated for earthwork excavation and
construction of CM & CD works of HNSS Main Canal from K.M.245 to
260 K.M. in Anantapur District with an E.C.V. of ₹109,89,45,961/- and
completion period of 6 months.
(b) The appellant stood highest bidder with 4.65% and 4.45% in
excess
of
E.C.V.
i.e.,
₹49,00,94,633/-
and
₹114,78,49,056/-,
respectively, which was accepted and accordingly, Agreement
No.06/2015-16 and Agreement No.07/2015-16, even dated 13.08.2015,
were executed between 4th respondent and appellant. The terms of
tender required tenderers to quote lump sum bids as a specific
percentage in excess/less than or rather put forth, at par with E.C.V.,
which does not depend on piece/component rate of input materials.
Though E.C.V. is arrived at based on the aggregate of various
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
components, which included sand, it is only a guiding estimate for the
purposes of determining the tender parameters. Thus, appellant quoted
lump sum bid which was accepted, and accordingly agreements were
concluded.
(c) That being so, first respondent, by memo dated 04.03.2016,
prescribed that sand shall be made available free of cost, with effect
from 02.03.2016, in pursuance to the revised sand policy. In furtherance
thereto, Board of Chief Engineers fixed revised costing for sand for the
purposes of SSR, which is to be adopted by computing the estimate for
tenders/ECV, relying on such minutes of Board of Chief Engineers, the
second respondent issued impugned memo, dated 22.08.2016, for
implementing revision of rates of sand with effect from 02.03.2016. The
revised rate of sand was fixed as ₹85.13ps. in place of ₹610/- per cubic
metre with respect to sand used for concrete and filtering items.
Likewise, the rate of sand used for filling was revised to ₹85.13ps. from
₹460/- per cubic metre, and the rate of sand used for mortar, plastering
and sand blasting items revised to ₹152.13ps. from ₹677/- per cubic
metre. The said memo, in turn, directed that the difference in cost of
sand shall be deducted from the bills. Acting on the said instructions, the
running bill No.10 of appellant, dated 10.10.2016, pertaining to
Agreement No.7/2015-16, when was processed, an amount of
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
₹28,84,003/- was withheld towards recovery of sand cost from all the
bills after 04.03.2016, up to RA Bill No.10. Similarly, even in respect of
further R.A. bills, the component of sand cost was withheld from the
monies due to the appellant.
(d) While so, 1st respondent, thereafter, issued impugned
Government Order in G.O.Ms.No.125, Water Resources (WRG-GRC)
Department, dated 29.12.2016, inter alia, directing recovery of the
difference in sand cost from the bills of existing agreements concluded
as per earlier rates, which continued to be in force after 02.03.2016. The
appellant objected to the withholding and recovery of the differential
sand cost by letters, dated 17.10.2016 and 21.10.2016, nevertheless,
the respondents continued to withhold the same, thus, appellant was
constrained to file the writ petition.
(e) In respect of other contracts as well, the differential sand cost
was withheld and sought to be recovered from the monies payable to
the appellant, therefore, the same was challenged in Writ Petition
Nos.10745 and 10779 of 2017. All these writ petitions, along with
connected writ petitions, were heard together.
4.
The respondents filed counter-affidavit, in which a preliminary
objection was raised on maintainability of writ petitions in view of
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
availability of an alternative remedy by way of arbitration in terms of
Clause 24.1 and Clause 24.2 of the contract. Further, the respondents
took stand that the E.C.V. was arrived at considering SSR rates of 201415 which factored the cost of sand, and thus, arrived at the E.C.V. of
₹49.0094 crores and ₹114.78 crores for both subject works, therefore,
now as there is a change in the sand policy and the cost has been
revised substantially, the differential cost thus is being adjusted which is
in accordance with the terms and conditions of contract. It is also
pleaded that the appellant, since is getting sand free of cost except
paying for excavation, loading and unloading, cannot enrich by not
incurring the cost as originally factored considering the SSR rates of
2014-15, therefore, the recovery was justified.
5.
Before the learned single Judge, appellant as well as other writ
petitioners, since represented that the issue involved in the writ petitions
is squarely covered by common order, dated 01.05.2023, passed in
W.P.No.35079 of 2018 and batch, and thus requested to pass similar
order. Considering the same, the writ petitions were accordingly
dismissed.
6.
Aggrieved by the same, appellant preferred present appeal and
also W.A.Nos.765 and 780 of 2026. Even before hearing the present
appeal, W.A.No.780 of 2026 was withdrawn, accordingly, the same was
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
dismissed, by order, dated 28.07.2026.
Even today, the appellant
withdrew Writ Appeal No.765 of 2026, and the same has been dismissed
as withdrawn. Therefore, the present appeal only remains before us for
consideration.
7.
Heard Mr.O.Manohar Reddy, learned senior counsel appearing
for Mr.M.Siva Kumar, learned counsel for appellant and learned
Government Pleader for Irrigation and Command Area Development
and learned Government Pleader for Finance and Planning appearing
for respondents.
8.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for appellant contended that
any revision of rate on account of revision in the cost of sand in
pursuance to impugned memo as well as Government Order would
amount to unilateral alteration of terms and conditions of contract, which
is impermissible. Learned Senior Counsel, while drawing our attention
to Clause 14.6.3 of the notice inviting tender, which deals with price
adjustment, would submit that adjustment of rates is permissible only in
such of those contracts where the E.C.V. was more than ₹2,00,00,000/and having completion period of more than 18 months, therefore, as in
the present case, the completion period is merely 6 months, the same
would not apply. In other words, it is stated that except for aforesaid
Clause, there are no other Clauses which contemplate price
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
adjustments, therefore, the respondents are precluded from recovering
the differential cost of sand. Further, it is also contended that
respondents could not have applied the revision of sand rates to the
existing contracts, particularly when there is no such price adjustment
clause provided in the agreement, therefore, the impugned action in
withholding and recovering the differential cost of sand is ex facie illegal
and arbitrary.
9.
Per contra, learned Government Pleaders appearing for
respondents, while supporting the impugned order of learned Single
Judge, contended that the very writ petition itself is not maintainable on
two counts, firstly, that the issues raised emanate from contractual
obligation and, secondly, that the contract provided for mechanism of
arbitration in case of any disputes among the parties, therefore,
appellant cannot maintain the writ petition bypassing such alternative
remedy. Further, it is also contended that the appellant cannot
selectively pursue the cases, inasmuch as, the very same issue which
is subject matter in W.A.Nos.765 and 780 of 2026, since were
withdrawn, the issues arising under the common order inter se parties
stand confirmed. Further, it is also contended that the common order in
W.P.No.35079 of 2018 and batch, since had not been challenged, the
same attained finality, therefore, the present appeal has to fail.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
10.
We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions
made above and also perused the material on record.
11.
The entire controversy boils down to whether the respondents are
within their contractual rights to adjust/recover the differential cost of the
sand on account of revision of rates of sand in pursuance to the State
policy.
12.
At the outset, it is to be noted that appellant filed three writ
petitions for the very same relief, though they emanate from different
contracts, which were dismissed by learned Single Judge, vide
impugned order. Aggrieved by which, appellant preferred W.A.Nos.741,
765 and 780 of 2026, out of which W.A.Nos.765 and 780 of 2026, were
withdrawn, barring the present appeal. As the order impugned in the
appeal is a common order, which yet again followed another common
order passed in W.P.No.35079 of 2018 and batch, dated 01.05.2023,
the core issue as to whether respondents were justified in
adjusting/recovering the differential cost of sand, qua the appellant, in
respect of other contracts attained finality. The appellant, therefore,
having accepted the said position in respect of other contracts, now
intends to pursue the present appeal by taking a divergent view.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
13.
Considering the facts and circumstances, including the aforesaid
inconsistent stand of appellant, for whatever reasons, we do not find any
ground for interference in exercise of appellate jurisdiction. That apart,
the appellant claims the impugned memo as well as Government Order
purporting to revise the rate of sand has been applied to the existing
contracts, even without there being any specific clause for price
adjustment. Clause 14.6.3 of the contract, which has been referred to,
would not get attracted, and dehors the same, there is no other clause.
As against the said stand, respondents tried to justify their action with
reference to other terms and conditions of the contract. Learned Single
Judge referred to General Condition No.13.8 of the Agreement to hold
that even sand would also be amenable for price adjustment. Therefore,
definitely there is serious dispute between the parties, which has to be
resolved within the framework of contract. Further, the memo, dated
22.08.2016, followed by G.O.Ms.No.125, dated 29.12.2016, whether at
all applies to existing contracts or not, having regard to the terms and
conditions of contract, is also one such dispute to be addressed. The
redressal mechanism agreed between the parties in terms of Clause 24
of the contract provides appropriate remedy to the appellant. We,
therefore, refrain from exercising our jurisdiction to decide these
contractual issues. Therefore, in the above facts and circumstances and
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.A.No.741 of 2026
having regard to our observations, we do not find any infirmity in the
impugned order passed by learned Single Judge.
14.
Accordingly, writ appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review