Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1071
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 463 of 2024
Date of Decision: 11.11.2025
Shri. Rishan Pariat
Proprietor of City Lights Bar & Lounge,
S/o Smti. Lutina Pariat
:::Writ Petitioner
-Vs1.State of Meghalaya represented by its
Chief Secretary
2.The Commissioner of Excise, Government
of Meghalaya
3.The Deputy Commissioner (Excise), East
Khasi Hills District, Shillong
4.The Deputy Secretary to the Government
of Meghalaya, Excise, Registration, Taxation
and Stamps Department
5.Inspector of Excise, East Khasi Hills
District, Shillong
6.Dorbar Shnong, represented by the
Secretary, Nongkhyriem, Nongthymmai,
Shillong – 14
:::Respondents
2025:MLHC:1071
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. N. Syngkon, GA with
Mr. J.N. Rynjah, GA(For R 1-5)
Mr. H.R. Nath, Adv. (For R 6).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The brief facts of the case are that the writ petitioner holds a bar
license, which was granted by the respondents No. 2, 3 and 4, issued on
22.12.2023, and renewed on 16.05.2024 under the Meghalaya Excise Act,
after meeting all statutory requirements, including obtaining of an NOC from
the respondent No. 6 i.e. the Dorbar Shnong of Nongkhyriem, through the
Headman. However, the respondent No. 6, thereafter cancelled the NOC
which resulted in the writ petitioner being unable to lift the liquor from the
bonded warehouse, inspite the bar license being valid. Aggrieved with the
2025:MLHC:1071
action of the respondent No. 6, which the petitioner contends has resulted in
disruption of his business operation and has caused financial losses, he is
before this Court by way of this instant writ petition seeking appropriate
directions.
2.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. T. Dkhar,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the respondent No. 6, to the
setting up of the bar had issued a No Objection Certificate dated 31.07.2023,
in favour of the writ petitioner, conveying the No Objection of the Executive
Committee of the Dorbar Shnong. Thereafter, he submits a rental agreement
was executed on 02.08.2023, with the proprietor of the building, where the
bar was to be situated, at a monthly rate of Rs.30,000/- only, and the
respondent No. 5 (Inspector of Excise) had also conducted an enquiry on
04.09.2023, with regard to the application of the writ petitioner for grant of
license or ‘IMFL’ On License. The respondent No. 4, he submits then vide
letter dated 22.12.2023, conveyed the approval for grant of license for a
period upto 31.03.2024, subject to the observance of the rules and payment
of the prescribed fees, to which the petitioner complied, and on 22.03.2024
deposited the required fees vide Challan on 23.02.2024. However, he
submits when the writ petitioner failed to receive the permit for lifting the
liquor, and on his enquiry, was informed by the respondent No. 3 vide letter
dated 01.10.2024, that in order to operate the bar, he was to revisit the
2025:MLHC:1071
respondent No. 6, and co-ordinate with them for conducting a fresh public
meeting for local public opinion.
3.
The petitioner he submits thereafter, came to learn that inspite of the
issuance and renewal of license being as per prescribed procedure and due
process followed, the NOC had been recalled by the respondent No. 6, for
the reason that it had been issued hastily. The learned Senior counsel submits
that though the petitioner requested for a review of the decision, and a
meeting was also held with the respondents No. 1-5, on 05.11.2024, the
respondent No. 6, had conveyed their stand that its members were not willing
to revoke the cancellation of the NOC. This situation he submits, persisted
and even on the request of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi
Hills, Shillong for a joint inspection cum meeting, with regard to the NOC
for the bar, the respondent No. 6 categorically conveyed that the decision
taken to revoke the NOC was non-negotiable. The petitioner’s rights he
submits, due to the arbitrary action of the respondent No. 6, has been
violated, and he has been made to suffer substantial financial loss. As such,
he prays that directions be issued to the State respondents to issue and renew
the permit to allow the petitioner to lift the liquor from the bonded warehouse
for retail sale in his bar premises.
4.
From the side of the State respondents, Mr. N. Syngkon, learned GA
has submitted that the residents of Nongkhyriem, had submitted a complaint,
2025:MLHC:1071
opposing the establishment of a bar by the licensee, and that similar petitions
had also been submitted to the Chief Secretary, Government of Meghalaya,
on the ground that the Headman of the locality had initially issued the NOC
arbitrarily without the consent and approval of the General Village Dorbar,
which is why directions were issued to conduct fresh meetings and
inspection with regard to the matter. It is then submitted that inspite of the
enquiry, the official respondents were informed by the respondent No. 6, that
the decision taken in the Dorbar held on 25.05.2024, was to oppose the
establishment of the bar of the writ petitioner, and this was why the official
respondents kept the matter of issuance of the lifting permit in abeyance. It
is also submitted, that the decision to withhold the permit does not stem from
any procedural oversight by the official respondents, but from the need to
address the concern raised by the respondent No. 6, responsibly, inasmuch
as, despite best efforts and the holding of multiple meetings between the
complainants and the writ petitioner, the respondent No. 6, was adamant not
to allow the operation of the bar of the petitioner in the locality.
5.
Learned GA further submits that though an NOC from a local
authority is not mandatory, it is a prerequisite for engaging local public
opinion and that it is more than a procedural formality, as it acts as a
safeguard ensuring that businesses like bars operate with the community’s
support. Reference has then been made to the Meghalaya Excise Act and
2025:MLHC:1071
Rules, as adapted from the Assam Excise Act, 1910, wherein it is submitted
Section 28 provides for the ascertainment of local public opinion before
grant of license, and Rule 191 stipulates that opening, shifting, amalgamation
and closure of any licensed premises shall not be granted sanction, unless it
has been satisfactorily established by local enquiry that the proposed action
is necessary in interest of the public. It is submitted that since formal
complaints had been lodged by the respondent No. 6 and the local public, the
permit has thus been kept pending, keeping in mind the maintenance of law
and order and public safety. The petitioner it is contended cannot allege
discrimination, inasmuch as, there are no other retail vends of foreign liquor
or bars currently in operation in the said location.
6.
Mr. H.R. Nath, learned counsel on behalf of the respondent No. 6 has
submitted that though the NOC was initially issued in respect of the writ
petitioner establishment and another bar in the locality, however, due to the
serious objections raised by the residents before the respondent No. 2, vide
a complaint dated 13.05.2024, with a copy to the answering respondents, the
same was placed before the Annual General Dorbar of the locality held on
25.05.2024, which took the decision to revoke the NOC granted to the writ
petitioner. The learned counsel submits that in view of the decision taken by
the General Dorbar, the Executive Committee of the Village Dorbar was
2025:MLHC:1071
duty bound to cancel the NOC, considering the public opinion and for the
maintenance of peace and tranquility in the locality.
7.
In reply, to the submissions of the respondents, it has been countered
by the learned Senior counsel on behalf of the writ petitioner, that the license
had been granted after due process had been followed and, in this regard,
while seeking the NOC, the respondent No. 6, had directed for the deposit of
Rs. 5 Lakhs as fees, for issuing the NOC, which was duly complied with by
the writ petitioner, who had transferred the said amount vide cheque in
favour of the respondent No. 6 on 31.07.2023. He submits that the said
amount was then withdrawn by the said respondent and the NOC issued. The
learned Senior counsel thus submits that notwithstanding any other
circumstance, the fact that remains is the license was issued after all the
conditions had been satisfied including the NOC, as per the mandate of
Section 28 and Rule 191 of the Meghalaya Excise Act and Rules, and as
such, the action of the respondent No. 6 in cancelling the NOC, is arbitrary
and unreasonable.
8.
In the course of hearing this matter, this Court by order dated
06.08.2025, on the issue of grant of NOC, had allowed the prayer of the
respondent No. 6, to produce the minutes of the Dorbar, wherein the decision
had been taken to grant the NOC to the writ petitioner. However, on
01.09.2025, the counsel for the respondent No. 6 submitted that there were
2025:MLHC:1071
no recorded proceedings of deliberations or resolution, for grant of NOC to
the writ petitioner, but however, the resolution taken to withdraw the NOC
had been recorded and accordingly, the proceedings of the Dorbar held on
27.05.2024, were produced before the Court, which showed that the decision
was taken based on a complaint of the residents of the locality on 13.05.2024.
A perusal of the complaint dated 13.05.2024, annexed to the affidavit of the
State respondents, lodged by some residents of the locality, however reflects
that a copy of the same was not marked to the writ petitioner, and only a
copy of the minutes of the meeting dated 05.11.2024, chaired by the
Additional Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi Hills, Shillong, along with
other official respondents, and the representative of the respondent No. 6,
was given, wherein the decision to recall the NOC was taken.
9.
In these circumstances, this Court is therefore to examine as to
whether any rights of the writ petitioner have been violated or whether a
mandamus can issue to direct the respondents to allow the lifting of the
liquor, and the petitioner to operate his business as per the license granted.
Concisely put, the issue crystallizes only on the point of the grant and recall
of the NOC by the respondent No. 6. Though this Court had made an attempt
to obtain the proceedings or records which culminated in the decision to
grant NOC, which is evidenced by the acceptance of a fee to the tune of Rs.5
Lakhs, by the respondent No. 6, the same not being made available, has
2025:MLHC:1071
hampered this Court from arriving at a clear decision on the question of
whether public opinion had been sought. No doubt, proceedings to recall the
NOC by the Dorbar have been made available, however, in the absence of
the records of the contrary decision, the decision arrived at by the Dorbar
therefore, in the considered view of this Court, needs to be revisited.
10.
In the context of the necessity of public opinion in such matters, it
would be necessary to refer to the provisions of the Meghalaya Excise Act
(Assam Excise Act of 1910) as adopted by Meghalaya, which has laid down
procedural safeguards in the issue of licenses for retail liquor shops. The
relevant Sections and Rules are reproduced hereinbelow:
“Section: 28. Ascertainment of local public opinion.Before the licenses are granted in any year of the retail
sale of any intoxicant, the Collector shall take
measures, in accordance with rule to be made by the
State Government in this behalf, as may best enable him
to ascertain local public opinion in regard to the
licensing and location of shops.”
“Rule: 191. The opening, shifting, amalgamation and
closure of any licensed premises shall be done by the
District Collector with the previous sanction of the State
Government. Such opening, shifting, amalgamation
and closure shall not be granted- (a) unless it has been
satisfactorily established by local enquiry that the
2025:MLHC:1071
proposed action is necessary in the interest of public;
and (b) until any objections, which may have been filed
on the subject have been considered by the District
Collector.
Objections from local bodies and from the following
persons will be considered(i)
In the case of Corporation, Municipality or Town
Committee areas- The Corporation, Municipality
or Town Committee concerned to which such
proposal relates;
(ii)
In the case of areas not situated in a Corporation,
Municipality or Town Committee(a) The Gaon Panchayat concerned.
(b) The
owners
or
occupiers
of
the
neighbourhood of the premises involved.
(c) Managers of the tea estates or factories in
which more than 100 persons are employed:
Provided that the whole or any part of the jurisdiction
of the Gaon Panchayat or land owned or occupied by
tea estate or factory is situated within 5 Kms. of the site
of the shop or any of the shops concerned.”
11.
A perusal of the above noted provisions, thus clearly mandates the
ascertainment of local public opinion, with regard to licensing and location
of retail establishments, as also, the opening, shifting or closure, wherein
objections from local bodies are to be considered and consent obtained
2025:MLHC:1071
before grant of license. In the instant case, the mandate of the above noted
provisions had been complied with in the grant of the bar license to the writ
petitioner, which however, due to later events has resulted in the same being
kept in abeyance on the ground of recall of the NOC. It is noted that in the
recall of the NOC, the writ petitioner was not afforded any opportunity to
put up his side of the story, and was only informed on his query about the
developments, which has now resulted in the suspension of business
activities, apart from causing heavy financial losses.
12.
Thus, as observed earlier it is only on the objection of the community
that has resulted in the deadlock. However, it must be kept in mind that trade
in liquor is not an enforceable fundamental, or absolute right and the right to
trade is considered a privilege granted by the State under relevant law, as the
same is a State subject and not an inherent right of a citizen. Any trade in
liquor therefore, can only be carried out under the specific terms and
conditions of a license granted by the State respondents, which are subject
to stringent control.
13.
In the totality of the circumstances therefore, taking into consideration
the facts discussed hereinabove, moreover, the legitimate expectation of the
writ petitioner to operate his business on the license being obtained after due
process, notwithstanding the settled position that there is no vested right
2025:MLHC:1071
involved in the trade of alcohol, this Court to balance the equities, deems it
fit to direct as follows:
(i)
The respondents Nos. 2-5, under the chairmanship of the
Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi Hills, Shillong or his
nominee, shall convene a meeting with the respondent No. 6,
and the writ petitioner to re-visit the cancellation of the NOC
especially with regard to the opinion of the residents in this
regard.
(ii)
The same shall be by convening a Village Dorbar, on a suitable
date arrived at in the meeting aforementioned, wherein the
entire facts i.e. the initial grant of NOC, the payment of fees for
the same and the issue of re-issuing the NOC shall be
deliberated upon and a decision arrived at. Further, the writ
petitioner is also given an option to attend the same, if necessary
to put across his point of view, before the residents.
(iii)
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of 6(six)
weeks from the date the official respondents are served with a
copy of this order.
(iv)
On the said exercise being completed, the Respondents 2 to 5
shall then on the outcome thereof, act, or issue orders
accordingly with regard to the permit of the writ petitioner.
2025:MLHC:1071
14.
The abovenoted directions, have been passed by this Court, in view of
the fact that the writ petitioner, was in possession of a license duly issued, in
accordance with law, which however, for the reasons aforementioned, has
resulted in a stalemate, leaving him remedy less. It is also expected that when
the Respondent No. 6, in considering this aspect with the community or local
residents, keep these facts in mind.
15.
Accordingly, this writ petition in terms of the directions and
observations made hereinabove stands closed and is disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
11.11.2025
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2025.11.11 15:46:15 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review