Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:28-DB
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM, GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------D.B. : HON’BLE SHRI SUNIL KUMAR SINHA, C.J. &
HON’BLE MRS. MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, J.
--------------------------------------------------------------W.P. (PIL) No. 39/2012
Shri Rinzing Chewang Kazi,
Son of Late Rinzing Namgyal Kazi,
Permanent resident of Lachen, North Sikkim,
P.O. & P.S. Lachen, North Sikkim.
...
PETITIONER
Versus
1.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
2.
The Secretary,
Health & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
Union of India,
Through its Secretary,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Nirman Bhawan, Maulana-Azad Road,
New Delhi – 110 001.
...
RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance :
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia and Ms. Mina Bhusal, Advocates for
the Petitioner.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Addl. Advocate General with Mr.
Santosh Kr. Chettri, Asstt. Govt. Advocate for StateRespondents 1 and 2.
None for Respondent No. 3/Union of India.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:28-DB
JUDGMENT
(05.04.2016)
Following
Judgment
of
the Court was delivered
by
SUNIL KUMAR SINHA, CJ.
1.
By way of introduction, it may be stated here that this is
a Public Interest Litigation seeking effective implementation of the
National Rural Health Mission (for short NRHM) in the State of Sikkim
by issuing appropriate orders to provide for required facilities and
personnel in remote rural villages of the State, focussing in particular
on the health of Women, Children and Senior Citizens being
Marginalised Groups of society. It is also concerned with the violation
of Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution alleging failure on the
part of the Respondents to provide adequate facilities to women in
terms of reproductive and child health services.
2.
Before proceeding further, it may be elucidated here that
the National Health Mission (NHM), whose vision is the “Attainment of
Universal Access to Equitable, Affordable and Quality health care
services, accountable and responsive to people’s needs, with effective
inter-sectoral
convergent
action
to
address
the
wider
social
determinants of health.” (See Framework for Implementation, National Health
Mission, 2012-17), encompasses two Sub-Missions being the National
Rural Health Mission (NRHM) which was launched on 12.4.2005 and
the National Urban Health Mission (NUHM). The NHM aims at guiding
states towards achieving health care through strengthening of health
2016:SHC:28-DB
systems, institutions and capabilities.
The objective of the NRHM,
inter alia, is to reduce maternal mortality rate, infant mortality rate
and total fertility rate. Within the ambit of the NRHM is the Janani
Suraksha Yojana (JSY), a scheme, which is a 100% Centrally
Sponsored and “…..integrates the cash assistance with antenatal care
during the pregnancy period, institutional care during delivery and
immediate post partum period in a health centre by establishing a
system of coordinated care by field level health workers.” (See Janani
Suraksha Yojana Guidelines for Implementation, Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare, Government of India).”
The vision of the scheme besides being
to reduce maternal mortality and the infant mortality rate, seeks to
increase institutional deliveries in women belonging to the Below
Poverty Line (BPL) households of the age of 19 years or above, up to
two live births. Along with the Scheme of Janani Suraksha Yojana, is
the Janani-Shishu Suraksha Karyakram (JSSK) which assures that
pregnant women and new borns do not have to incur pocket
expenses
in
all
Government
institutions
and
lays
down
the
entitlements for pregnant women and sick new born till 30 days of
the birth.
3.
Under the NRHM, Accredited Social Health Activists
(ASHA) are to be appointed in each village and trained to act as an
interface between the community and the public health systems.
They are to assist the pregnant women belonging to households
Below Poverty Line (BPL) in obtaining the use of health services by
inter
alia
undertaking
certain
responsibilities,
which
include
2016:SHC:28-DB
identifying
pregnant
women,
providing
them
with
checkups,
counseling them for institutional deliveries, etc.
4.
This Writ Petition, as already stated has been filed
seeking proper implementation of the NRHM.
5.
In view of the facts put forth in the Writ Petition, this
Court vide an Order on 24.8.2012, observed as follows:“...From the perusal of the averments made in the
Writ Petition, we find that various Govt. Sponsored
Schemes, namely, National Rural Health Mission (NRHM),
Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY) and other schemes have not
been implemented in right spirit. There are also
averments regarding non-availability of life saving drugs
in most of the Government Hospitals/Health Centres both
at District and Sub-Divisional level. State Respondents will
furnish details of the facilities available at District and
Sub-Divisional level Hospitals and Primary Health Centres
including Dispensaries with details of the number of such
Centres. The availability of life saving drugs with its
names/brand and quantity with the expiry dates will also
be disclosed in the Affidavit so filed.
In the meantime we further direct that the State
will ensure availability of life saving drugs in all the
Hospitals/Health Centres within a period of 2(two) weeks,
if not already available...”
6.
On 21.11.2012, Counter Affidavit was filed by the
Respondents No.1 and 2, which was taken up on 23.11.2012 vide
which “Details of Essential and Life Saving Drugs...” issued to the
various hospitals and health centres were enumerated as follows:-
Sl.
No.
District Hospitals
Sl.
No.
Primary
Health
Centres (PHCs)
Sl.
No.
STNM on 5.9.2012 &
7.9.2012
District Hospital
Gyalshing on
5.9.2012
District Hospital
Singtam on
6.9.2012
Chungthang
PHC
during September
Dikchu PHC 201213
Primary
Health
Sub
Centres
(PHSCs)
Gor PHSC 2012
Lingdong PHSC 2012
Hee Gyathang PHC
on 4.9.2012
Tingbong PHSC 2012
2016:SHC:28-DB
Namchi District
Hospital on
5.9.2012
District
Hospital
Mangan on 6.9.2012
Sakyong Pentyong
PHSC 2012
Lingthem PHSC 2012
Lingdem PHSC 2012
Phensong
PHSC
Kabi PHSC 2012
Ramthang
PHSC
Namok PHSC 2012
Loom PHSC 2012
Tingchem
PHSC
Naga PHSC 2012
Salem Pockel PHSC
Singhik PHSC 2012
Ship Ger PHSC 2012
Lachen PHSC 2012
Lachung PHSC 2012
*22 PHC’s of East, 19
**128
PHSC’s
of
West
&
South
East, West & South
Districts
during
Districts
during
September, 2012.
September, 2012.
27 PHCs
146 PHSCs
( * & **: Names of 22 PHC’s and 128 PHSC’s are not mentioned )
7.
Passidong
PHC
during September,
Phodong PHC on
27.9.2012
The details supra reveal only a total of 4 (four) numbers
of District Hospitals, 5 (five) numbers of Primary Health Centres
(PHCs) and 18 (eighteen) numbers of Primary Health Sub Centres
(PHSCs), while as per the Counter Affidavit, there is one Referral
Hospital at STNM, four District Hospitals (Namchi, Gyalshing, Singtam
and Mangan), a total of 26 Primary Health Centres and 146 Primary
Health Sub Centres in the State, thus indicating that the required
details have not been furnished for all the PHC’s and PHSC’s in the
State.
8.
to
It was also stated in the Affidavit of the Respondents that
facilitate
better
management
and
to
ensure
community
participation in the daily working of the Primary Health Centres, “Rogi
Kalyan Samitis” have been registered for the existing 24 (twenty-
2016:SHC:28-DB
four) Primary Health Centres, while for the 2 (two) newly notified
Primary Health Centres (being Hee Gyathang in North District and
Tokal Bermoik in South District) the matter is under process.
9.
It has further informed that there is a proposal for
reconstruction of the Lachen and Lachung Sub Centres with provision
of a Doctor’s Clinic and accommodation.
10.
It was admitted that in terms of the population of Sikkim
which stands at 6,07,000 as per the 2012 Census Report, the total
requirement of beds in the hospitals and health centres is 1840, while
at present there are 1440 beds only. That, this shortfall will be met
up by construction of a 575 bedded Multi Specialty Hospital at
Gangtok, which was to be completed by 10.9.2013. It was brought
on record that, subsequently, the bed strength of the Multi Speciality
Hospital was revised from 575 to 1000 and the date of completion
was extended from 08.09.2013 to June, 2016. Status of the work as
on 30.05.2015 was shown to be 86.50% completed.
11.
On 23.11.2012, it was observed by this Court while
referring to the Order dated 24.8.2012 that
“....One of the directions contained in the order was
regarding availability of life saving drugs.
Though list of the life saving drugs has been
appended with the affidavit as Annexure 1-3, however, in
the affidavit no details are given about the availability of
such life saving drugs in the hospitals and any health
centres in the State of Sikkim.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Addl. Advocate General
seeks one week’s time to file additional affidavit regarding
the availability of these drugs in the hospitals and various
Public Health Centres in the State of Sikkim.
List on 10.12.2012.”
2016:SHC:28-DB
12.
This direction was complied in C.M. Appl. No. 160 of
2012. The said details are appended as Annexure A-1 from Page 264
to Page 300, being the same details as submitted in above Annexure
A-3 (colly.).
13.
The Respondent No. 3 chose not to file a Counter Affidavit
as reflected in Order dated 30.4.2013.
14.
In response to the Rejoinder filed by the Petitioner on
28.3.2013, the State Respondents filed a Counter Affidavit/Report on
29.5.2013 which dealt with “Lapses as Projected by the Petitioner in
the Rejoinder” in one column and “Remedial Measures”, ostensibly,
taken by the Government in the next column.
15.
To this Counter Affidavit/Report of the Respondents No.1
and 2, the Petitioner filed a Rejoinder on 26.6.2013 annexing
Newspaper cuttings from local Newspapers indicating deficiencies in
the STNM Hospital and the Namchi District Hospital. The attention of
this Court was also drawn to the problem of Tuberculosis in Lachen
village and the non availability of either doctors or medicines in the
Primary Health Sub Centre.
The Court consequently directed the
Additional
to verify
Advocate General
the
correctness
of
the
statements, as the Court Prima facie found the statements in the said
Rejoinder to be correct.
16.
A “Brief Fact Finding Report of the Ground” (sic) was filed
by the Petitioner.
In terms of the said Report, this Court vide its
2016:SHC:28-DB
Order dated 23.9.2013, observed that the Petitioner has inter alia
pointed out the condition of Gynaecology Department, STNM Hospital
at Gangtok, where the patients were facing great hardship on account
of dearth of sufficient number of toilets. Admitting this in substance,
the State Respondents undertook to explore possibilities to build new
toilets for the OPD patients and attendants accompanying the ailing.
The
Court
directed
the
State
Respondents
to
expedite
the
construction of at least one more toilet on each of the floors of the
building where Gynaecology Wards were situated, with a further
direction that a report be submitted within 30 days regarding the
progress. In compliance thereof, the State Respondents No. 1 and 2
informed that space had been identified for construction of 4 unit
general toilet and for an additional toilet each on the first floor and
ground floor of the Gynaecology block in addition of the existing 2
toilets on each floor.
17.
In response to the Report of Tuberculosis in Lachen and
Lachung, the Respondents informed the Court that 8 (eight) such
patients were registered from Lachen of whom 2 (two) had completed
treatment, while 5 (five) patients were found in the Lachung area and
all were taking treatment as per the Revised National Tuberculosis
Control Programme (RNTCP).
The household survey conducted
reveals no further case of Pulmonary Tuberculosis in the said area.
That, medication for Tuberculosis at the DOTs Centre and Primary
Health Centres were being assessed and patients also followed up on
a regular basis.
2016:SHC:28-DB
18.
In reply, it was contended by the Petitioner that besides
medication for Tuberculosis, medicines for other diseases were not
available.
Learned Additional Advocate General sought a list of
diseases and medicines which were not available, from the Petitioner.
On the same date, Learned Additional Advocate General also
informed that the construction of the toilets were in progress. This
was on 12.12.2013.
19.
On 14.3.2014, the Respondents informed the Court that
the construction of the 4 unit toilet was to be completed by
20.3.2014.
No final report in this regard was submitted.
It is
assumed that the construction is completed.
20.
Reverting back to the Order dated 23.9.2013, this Court
had directed that there should be construction of at least one more
toilet on each of the floors of the building where the Gynaecology
Wards are situated. Vide an Affidavit filed by the Respondents No.1
and 2 on 6.3.2014, it has been stated that so far as providing
additional toilets on the first floor and the ground floor of the
Gynaecology block, same have been completed and is being used by
the patients.
Photographs were submitted to substantiate this
submission and have been marked as A-2 (colly.).
However, while
going through Annexure A-2 (colly.), it indicates that two toilets have
been modified and opened at the ground level and two toilets have
been made available at level-1 by modifying the existing toilets.
Clearly, there has been no construction of an additional toilet each on
2016:SHC:28-DB
either floor as directed but only modification of the existing toilets
have been carried out.
21.
On 26.4.2014, the Petitioner filed an Affidavit furnishing
details of medicines which are to be provided by the Respondents,
which was accordingly taken on record on 2.5.2014.
22.
On 7.8.2014, a second “Fact finding Report” was filed by
the Petitioner, which dealt with a fact finding conducted by Advocate,
Sarita Bhusal and one Maya Sikan (Health Right Activist from Delhi)
on 20-21 May, 2014 concerning the implementation of the NRHM on
the ground in the State, wherein it was alleged that most pregnant
and lactating women were made to purchase basic medicines like
Iron, Folic Acid, Calcium Pills and necessities, such as cotton, gloves,
etc.
That, basic instruments like ECGs were not available either in
the Primary Health Centres of District Hospitals. Pregnant women
were made to sleep in the corridors near the toilet, new born babies
were kept in rooms without proper ventilation. No incubator facilities
were available for new born children, neither was there an Operation
Theatre in the District Hospital at Mangan, while both Hospitals at
Mangan and Singtam had no Blood Banks and that there was lack of
proper sanitation and toilet facilities in Primary Health Centres, hence
the NRHM Scheme is not being implemented as envisaged.
23.
A response to the Fact Finding Report was filed by the
State. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, thereafter, on 13.10.2014,
prayed that she may be granted some time to go through the
2016:SHC:28-DB
response to the Fact Finding Report and find out remaining core
issues, on which, directions may be required from this Court.
24.
The Petitioner then filed CMA No.387/2014 and CMA
No.251/2015 by which core issues were identified and directions from
this Court were required.
25.
It is thus clear that this Court had issued various
directions in public interest on different dates and had monitored and
compliance reports were filed by the State.
26.
Now, we would like to concentrate on the core issues
highlighted
by
the
Petitioner
in
CMA
No.387/2014
and
CMA
No.251/2015.
27.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, learned Counsel appearing on behalf
of the Petitioner, has firstly contended that Maternal Death Reviews
(MDRs), as per the Government of India Guidance Manual on
maternal death, are not being regularly done and the reviews are not
being published in the website of the National Health Mission (NHM)
of Sikkim, therefore, immediate directions should be issued. She has
also argued that immediate steps be taken to ensure accountability
for inadequate services and decentralization of health services and
direction may be issued to publish community reports in the website
of the NHM. Mr. J. B. Pradhan, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing on behalf of the State, has argued that Maternal Death
Reviews, as per the Government of India Guidance Manual on
2016:SHC:28-DB
maternal death are being done regularly.
However, the material is
not being uploaded in the website which the State is inclined to do.
28.
Having heard Counsel for both the parties, we are of the
view that there is no harm if the above materials are uploaded in the
website.
On the contrary, they would be helpful for awareness as
also leading to transparency and would further show the real picture
at a glance for self evaluation.
The Maternal Death Reviews and
Community based monitoring should be done regularly in the larger
public interest and necessary materials should be uploaded in the
website of the NHM and we direct accordingly.
29.
Dr. Bhutia then contended that the State be directed to
create blood banks and blood storage facilities as also arrange
sufficient number of oxygen cylinders in every district to prevent
maternal deaths related to bleedings. Let us firstly see what is the
contention of the State regarding blood banks and blood storage
facilities. It has been stated by the Additional Advocate General that
blood bank facilities are available in the STNM Hospital at Gangtok
and District Hospital at Namchi, whereas blood storage facilities are
available in District Hospitals at Gyalshing and Singtam.
It was
contended vide affidavit dated 30.03.2015 that blood storage facility
has also been put in place in District Hospital at Mangan, which would
be operationlised by April, 2015.
To provide health care to the
people, the State Government has 147 Primary Health Sub-Centres
(PHSCs) at the village level, 24 Primary Health Centres (PHCs) at the
2016:SHC:28-DB
block level, 4 district hospitals at each of the District Headquarters
and a State level Referral Hospital at Gangtok (see p.3 of the
comprehensive report issued by the Government). Besides the above health
infrastructure, we find from Table-1 of the reply to CMA No.251/2015
that two Community Health Centres (CHCs) are also there in South
District and East District. The State has a long term goal to update
all 4 district hospitals to Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS).
However, it requires that these institutions have to first function as
First Referral Units (FRUs) with a minimum provision of facilities for
Emergency
Obstetric
Care
including
surgical
interventions
like
Caesarean Sections, New-born Care and Emergency Care of sick
children and blood storage facility.
This, we also get from the
comprehensive report. Leaving it apart, if we go through the service
guarantees for health care under NRHM, we would find that various
topics have been covered to be given as facilities in PHSCs, PHCs and
CHCs. In CHCs, apart from various facilities guaranteed, it has also
been shown that there should be blood storage facilities, essential
laboratory services and referral (transport) services.
Thus, even
according to the NRHM, blood storage facility should be there in a
CHC. Apart from the above, if we look into the services guaranteed
for the health care, it is a matter of common knowledge that blood
transfusion would be necessary in many health services proposed.
Thus, taking guidelines from the NRHM, we are of the view that there
should be a blood bank in every district hospital and there should also
be blood storage facility at least in CHCs. We are conscious that we
are not experts, however, the view which we have taken, is based
2016:SHC:28-DB
upon the documents of NRHM as also the comprehensive report
issued by the State Government. We, therefore, direct that the State
Government shall make all endeavour to establish a blood bank in
each district and also to establish blood storage facility in each CHC in
near future.
30.
Dr. Bhutia has also contended that enough number of
oxygen cylinders should be available in the hospitals.
She quoted
example that many times only one cylinder caters the need of entire
ward where number of patients/new-born children are very high. We
have no data about the number of oxygen cylinders usually deployed
in different hospitals.
Mr. Pradhan has contended that sufficient
number of oxygen cylinders have been put in all the district hospitals,
which we also find in reply to CMA No.387/2014. We trust that there
would not be any crisis in this regard and the things would go
smoothly.
31.
Dr. Bhutia then contended that the State should initiate a
free emergency transport system for referrals in compliance with
Janani Sishu Surakshya Karyakram (JSSK).
Mr. Pradhan has
contended that JSSK was started since the year 2011 and under the
JSSK, free transport, free drugs and diet for pregnant mothers and
infants are provided. The IPHS guidelines would show that JSSK was
an initiative to assure free services to all pregnant women and sick
neonates accessing public health institutions. The scheme envisages
free and cashless services to pregnant women including normal
deliveries and caesarean section operations and also treatment of
2016:SHC:28-DB
sick new-born (up to 30 days after birth) in all Government health
institutions across the States.
This initiative supplements the cash
assistance given to pregnant women under the Janani Surakshya
Yojana (JSY) and is aimed at mitigating the burden of out of pocket
expenditure incurred by pregnant women and sick newborns. (see p.9
of the IPHS guidelines). Under various entitlements for pregnant women,
one is free transport from home to health institutions, between
facilities in case of referrals and drop back from institutions to home.
The
State
has
filed
two
quarterly
status
reports
regarding
implementation of JSSK (April to June, 2014 and July to September,
2014). In the said reports, it has been mentioned that there are 34
ambulances/referral vehicles in the State, which are also fitted with
GPS.
It is thus clear that the State has already initiated free
emergency transport system for referrals under the JSSK and no
directions are required to be issued in this regard.
32.
Dr. Bhutia next contended that a Committee should be
constituted to investigate, report and find out solutions for poor
implementation of JSY. We find that there is no pleading in the Writ
Petition making ground for constitution of such a Committee and
direct investigation, as prayed for.
Even, the Petitioner has never
sought any relief in this regard. It appears that while the Counsel for
the Petitioner expressed to sort out remaining core issues after
various interim directions, the said point was taken up in CMA
No.387/2014 and a direction was sought.
2016:SHC:28-DB
33.
In State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Narmada Bachao
Andolan & other connected matters : (2011) 7 SCC 639, after
referring to many earlier judgments, it was held vide paragraph 13
that strict rules of pleading may not apply in PIL, however, there
must be sufficient material in the petition on the basis of which the
court may proceed. The PIL litigant has to lay a factual foundation
for his averments on the basis of which such a person claims the
reliefs. The information furnished by him should not be vague and
indefinite. Proper pleadings are necessary to meet the requirements
of the principles of natural justice. Even in PIL, the litigant cannot
approach the court to have a fishing or roving enquiry.
claim to have a chance to establish his claim.
He cannot
However, the
technicalities of the rules of pleading cannot be made applicable
vigorously.
Pleadings prepared by a layman must be construed
generously as he lacks the standard of accuracy and precision
particularly when a legal wrong is caused to a determinate class.
(Vide A. Hamsaveni v. State of T.N. : (1994) 6 SCC 51; Ashok
Kumar Pandey v. State of W.B. : (2004) 3 SCC 349; Prabir
Kumar Das v. State of Orissa : (2005) 13 SCC 452 and A. Abdul
Farook v. Municipal Council, Perambalur : (2009) 15 SCC
351.). We have scrutinized various documents filed along with the
Writ Petition and we do not find that the Petitioner even has made a
foundation to show that there was poor implementation of JSY. The
State has brought on record various facts with relation to its
implementation which would show that the scheme has been
implemented and the persons are getting benefits thereof. JSY has
2016:SHC:28-DB
been implemented in the State since 2005 to promote preference for
institutional delivery over home deliveries. There has been increase
in the institutional deliveries.
occurring on large scale.
The disbursal of JSY funds is also
The funds are disbursed at all level of
facilities, i.e. Urban Family Welfare Centre (UFWC), District Hospitals,
PHCs and PHSCs. Awareness regarding the promotion of scheme is
done through IEC (publicity) wing of the Department. ASHA is the
key person to implement the scheme effectively with support of
AWWs, ANMs and Medical Officers of the PHCs.
Village Health
Nutrition Days (VHNDs) are used as the main platform to disseminate
information about JSY. Following is the table showing number of JSY
Beneficiaries year wise from 2005-2006: Year
Home delivery Institutional delivery Total
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
2011-12
2012-13 up to 1st
Ort.
(see p.11 of the comprehensive report referred to above)
34.
It is, therefore, clear that there are no sufficient reasons
before us to constitute a Committee for the above purposes and to
take a view that there is poor implementation of JSY and a
Committee is immediately required to be constituted to investigate all
these.
We, accordingly, reject the said argument advanced by Dr.
Bhutia.
35.
Dr. Bhutia then contended that all vacant posts of
Doctors and Staff Nurses be directed to be filled up immediately.
2016:SHC:28-DB
Mr. Pradhan has contended that process for filling of vacancies is
already going on. He referred to the Orders recorded by this Court
on 20.05.2015, 01.06.2015, 26.06.2015 and 28.07.2015.
These
orders would show that 64 posts of Medical Officers and 428 posts of
Staff Nurses (GNM) under the State Health Department are lying
vacant. We were informed that files for filling up these vacancies, i.e.
64 posts of Medical Officers and 32 posts of Staff Nurses (in phase
manner) were already moved and were pending with the Sikkim
Public Service Commission and Law Department, Government of
Sikkim and later on advertisement No.5/2015 dated 24.07.2015 in
relation to appointment of 73 posts of General Duty Medical Officers
(Junior Grade) was issued by the Sikkim Public Service Commission
and applications were invited.
For Staff Nurses, advertisement
No.6/2015 dated 05.08.2015 was also issued later on.
It is, thus,
clear that the Government has already taken steps to fill up the
existing vacancies in the above manner
when
it
was
being
monitored by this Court. Dr. Bhutia has also argued that Doctors
and Nurses posted in rural areas should be given incentives. About
the incentives of the Doctors and Nurses posted in the rural areas,
statement has been made in CMA No.387/2014 that the Doctors and
Nurses appointed under NHM posted in difficult areas are paid higher
remuneration as compared to the others.
As such, no further
directions are required in these matters.
36.
Dr. Bhutia then contended that directions may be issued
for improved hygiene, increased staff and increased bed capacity in
2016:SHC:28-DB
STNM Hospital, Gangtok. It was brought to our notice that additional
room with 10 beds was established for post natal care mother at the
ground floor of Gynae building and ill-hygienic conditions which were
on account of over-crowding have now improved.
It was also
brought to our notice that Department is creating 10 bedded post
natal ward within 2-3 months by shifting School Health and National
Blindness Control Programme Room situated at ground floor of Gynae
complex.
This will further improve the ill- hygienic situation.
Additional toilet has also been constructed near Gynae complex.
Additional two staff nurses from NHM have also been deployed.
Besides the above, vide Affidavit dated 30.05.2015, it was stated by
the Additional Secretary that construction of a Multi Speciality
Hospital at Sichey, Gangtok is under progress and its bed strength
was revised from 575 to 1000.
It was also stated that date of
completion of the Multi Speciality Hospital for the above reason was
extended from 08.09.2013 to June, 2016 and the status of the work
as on 22.05.2015 was 86.50% completed. It is, thus, clear that after
the aforesaid Multi Speciality Hospital becomes operational, the
scenario would be quite different and the position regarding scarcity
of beds would be quite improved. We are of the view that when a
1000 bedded Multi Speciality Hospital is coming up in June, 2016, no
further direction is required so far as increase of bed strength in
STNM Hospital is concerned.
We also trust that the hygienic
condition in the newly constructed hospital would be up to the mark.
2016:SHC:28-DB
37.
issued
Dr. Bhutia also contended that a direction should be
to
the
State-Respondents
to have
emergency
helpline
numbers and emergency Doctors’ cell numbers in all the four districts
to address health related issues in distress/emergency situation. In
reply to the above issue, it was submitted by Additional Advocate
General that emergency helpline numbers are already there.
The
details of those numbers, as contained in reply to CMA No.387/2014,
are as follows:“ i.
STNM hospita
03592-202944
ii.
District Hospital, Mangan
234244
iii.
District Hospital, Gyalshing
250632/251082
iv.
District Hospital, Namchi
264890/263830
v.
District Hospital, Singtam
235379”
Therefore, nothing is required to be done on the said aspect.
38.
Dr. Bhutia lastly contended that directions may be issued
to upgrade the PHSCs of Lachen and Lachung into PHCs.
Indian
Public Health Standard (IPHS) for PHCs, in its introduction, provides
that there should be one PHC for every 30,000 rural population in the
plains and one PHC for every 20,000 population in the hilly, tribal and
desert areas for more effective coverage. However, as the population
density in the Country is not uniform, the number of PHCs would
depend upon the case load. We find from the record that this matter
was taken up in an earlier PIL, i.e. W.P. (PIL) No. 47/2012 and by an
Order dated 23.04.2013, a Division Bench of this Court made
following directions:“We, therefore, direct the respondents No.1, 3 and 4 to
take immediate steps for up-gradation of the Primary
Health Sub-Centres at Lachung and Lachen immediately.”
2016:SHC:28-DB
It appears that, thereafter, C M Appl. No.53/2013 was filed for
modification of the Order dated 23.04.2013 passed in W.P. (PIL)
No.47/2012 and some new facts were brought to the notice of this
Court and this Court immediately directed the State to implement
certain suggestions made in the CMA for the time being as a
temporary measure.
However, it was directed that for future,
necessary steps be taken by the State Government to upgrade the
PHSCs at Lachen and Lachung to full-fledged PHCs in terms of Order
dated 23.04.2013 and some other directions were also issued. This
shows that there is already a direction of the Division Bench in W.P.
(PIL) No.47/2012 and C M Appl.No.53/2013 filed in the said PIL after
its disposal and no further directions are required in this regard.
39.
After conclusion of the arguments, on the last date,
learned Additional Advocate General made some suggestions to be
implemented immediately. They are (i) free medicine counter in all
district hospitals/STNM; (ii) all free medicines as per the list provided
to this Court to be made available in the said counter; (iii) separate
OPD card centre at STNM Hospital, Gangtok viz. male, female and
senior citizens; (iv) Out Patient Duty (OPD) morning and afternoon at
STNM Hospital should be regular.
Afternoon OPD should be
maintained strictly and (v) an inquiry desk to be made available at
STNM
Hospital
which
should
be
easily
visible
to
assist
the
patients/parties. PIL is not in the nature of adversary litigation but it
is a challenge and an opportunity to the Government and its officers
to make basic human rights meaningful to the deprived and
2016:SHC:28-DB
vulnerable sections of the community and to assure them social and
economic justice (vide Bandhua Mukto Morcha v. Union of India, AIR
1984 SC 802). Therefore, any good suggestions coming from either
side can be taken up for consideration and if it appears to be
permissible under the law, the same may be directed to be
implemented. We are of the view that the above suggestions coming
from
the
Additional
Advocate
General
can
be
accepted
for
implementation and we do it accordingly.
40.
On the discussions made above, we dispose of this PIL
along with CMA Nos.387/2014 & 251/2015 on following terms: -
(1)
The State will ensure availability of life saving drugs in all
the hospitals/health centres.
Interim direction in this
regard vide Order dated 24.08.2012 is made absolute.
(see Order dated 24.08.2012)
(2)
Other interim directions on which compliance reports
have not been filed shall also be taken as absolute.
(3)
JSY and JSSK shall be implemented in their letter and
spirit so that the eligible women and children derive
proper benefits from these schemes.
(4)
The Maternal Death Reviews and Community Based
Monitoring
shall
be
done
regularly
and
necessary
materials shall be uploaded in the website of the NHM.
(see paragraph 28)
(5)
The State Government shall make all endeavour to
establish a Blood Bank in each district and also to
establish Blood Storage facility in each CHC in near
future.
(see paragraph 29)
2016:SHC:28-DB
(6)
State will create a free medicine counter in all district
hospitals.
(7)
(see paragraph 39)
All free medicines, as per the list provided to this Court,
shall be made available in the said counters. (see para 39)
(8)
There shall be separate OPD card centres at STNM
Hospital, Gangtok viz. male, female and senior citizens.
The Out Patient Duty (OPD) morning and afternoon at
STNM Hospital shall be regular and afternoon OPD should
be maintained strictly.
(9)
(see paragraph 39)
An inquiry desk shall be made available at STNM Hospital,
Gangtok, which would be easily visible to assist the
patients/ their attendants.
41.
(see paragraph 39)
In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be
no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Index
pm
:
Yes/No.
Internet :
Yes/No.
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review