Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010375832019
2026:CGHC:27925
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2018 of 2019
1 - Rikhman Lal S/o Jain Lal Yadav Aged About 40 Years R/o Sanjay Nagar,
Kumhari, District - Durg Chhattisgarh., District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Babloo S/o Shravan Goud, Permanent R/o Post Office And Police Station
- Rudrapur, District - Devariya ( U. P. ) At Present R/o Through - Santosh
Singh Jaswant Singh Sandhu, 161 / A, 11th Chal, Vikholi Park, Aanandgarh,
Road No. - 16, Near Pani Tanki, Vikholi Mumbai ( Maharastra ) Pin Code 400079 ( Driver Of Truck No. M. H. - 04 / D.S. / 1913 ), District : Mumbai, Maharashtra
2 - Santosh Singh Jaswant Singh Sandhu 161/a, 11th Chal, Vikholi Park,
Aanadgarh, Road No. 16, Near Pani Tanki, Vikholi Mumbai ( Maharastra ) Pin
Code - 400079 ( Owner Of Truck No. M. H. - 04 / D.S. / 1913 ), District :
Mumbai, Maharashtra
3 - Bajaj Alianj General Insurance Co. Ltd., Through - In Charge Officer, Bajaj
Alianj General Insurance Co. Ltd. Shiv Mohan Bhawan Pandri, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh. ( Insurer Of Truck No. M. H. - 04 / D.S. / 1913 ),
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant
: Mr. Rakesh Kumar Thakur, Advocate
For Respondent No. 3
: Mr. Raj Awasthi, Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Sanjay K. Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
07.07.2026
Digitally
signed by
JYOTI JHA
Date:
2026.07.08
16:52:45
+0530
1. This appeal has been filed by the appellants/claimants under Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “Act of 1988”) seeking
enhancement in the compensation amount, against the impugned
award dated 17.12.2018 passed by the Fifth Additional Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Raipur, Chhattisgarh (for short “Claims Tribunal”) in
Claim Case No. 152/2012, whereby the Claims Tribunal allowed the
claimant’s application and awarded Rs. 6,48,000/- along with interest.
2. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the Claims Tribunal has
erred in awarding inadequate compensation. It is further submitted that
although the Claims Tribunal assessed the appellant's permanent disability at 60% (Ex.P/9), it failed to appreciate that the appellant's right
leg has been amputated, which has severely impaired his functional
capacity and adversely affected his future prospects. It is contended
that, considering the nature of the injury and its impact on the appellant's earning capacity and day-to-day life, the functional disability
ought to have been assessed at 100%, and the compensation determined accordingly. In support of his submission learned counsel placed
his reliance upon a decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of M. Paramesh Vs. VRL Logistics Ltd., and Another 1, Shankar
Dutt Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd and Others 2 and Gauribai
Vs. Savitadev and Others3. Learned counsel for the appellant would
further submit that under the heads of loss of medical treatment, pain
and suffering, transportation expenses, special diet and attendant less
amount has been awarded by the Claims Tribunal which is liable to be
enhanced and even under the heads of future earning capacity, loss of
amenities & enjoyment compensation has not been awarded by the
Claims Tribunal which is liable to be awarded.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant would further submit that the Claims
Tribunal has erred in exonerating the Insurance Company from its liability on the ground of absence of a valid permit. It is submitted that the
appellant is a third-party victim and, even if there was any breach of the
2026 SCC OnLine SC 1188
2026 SCC OnLine SC 1193
2024 ACJ 2017
policy condition regarding the permit, the Insurance Company ought to
have been directed to satisfy the award in the first instance with liberty
to recover the amount from the owner and driver of the offending vehicle in accordance with the settled principle of "pay and recover."
Therefore, the finding exonerating the Insurance Company deserves to
be set aside.
4. Learned counsel for the respondent No. 3 submits that the Claims Tribunal has already taken a liberal view by assessing the appellant's permanent disability at 60%, and there is no justification for treating the
functional disability as 100%. It is submitted that the appellant's functional disability, if at all, cannot exceed 80%, and therefore, the compensation awarded by the Claims Tribunal does not warrant any enhancement.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival submissions made herein above and gone through the records with utmost
circumspection.
6. The Claims Tribunal has assessed the appellant's permanent disability
at 60% on the basis of the disability certificate (Ex.P-9), despite recording a categorical finding that the appellant's right leg had been amputated below the knee. The Tribunal, however, failed to appreciate the
distinction between physical disability and functional disability. The law
is now well settled that the percentage of permanent physical disability
cannot be mechanically equated with the percentage of loss of earning
capacity. In the matter of M. Paramesh (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reiterated the principles laid down in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar 4
and held that although the claimant had suffered only 70% physical disability, his functional disability was required to be assessed at 100%,
since the above-knee amputation rendered him incapable of continuing
his avocation as a mason. The Court observed that compensation in
permanent disability cases cannot be determined by mechanically applying the percentage of medical disability and that what is material is
the extent to which the disability destroys the earning capacity of the in4
(2011) 1 SCC (Civ) 164
jured. The Court, therefore, recalculated the loss of future earning by
treating the functional disability as 100% and also enhanced compensation towards future medical expenses for artificial limb and prosthesis.
7. A similar principle was reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
matter of Shankar Dutt (supra), wherein the claimant, a carpenter, had
suffered amputation of his right leg. Though the medical disability was
assessed at 70%, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the claimant
had suffered 100% functional disability, observing that functional disability has to be assessed with reference to the nature of the claimant's
occupation, age, socio-economic circumstances and the actual effect of
the injury on his earning capacity. The Court held that where the injury
renders the claimant incapable of pursuing the vocation by which he
earned his livelihood, the loss of earning capacity has to be treated as
complete irrespective of the percentage of medical disability.
8. Likewise, in the matter of Gauribai (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has been held that in cases involving amputation of a limb and
consequent inability to continue the previous occupation, the assessment of compensation must be based on the claimant's functional disability and not merely on the percentage of physical disability certified
by the Medical Board. The Court emphasized that where the injury effectively deprives the claimant of the capacity to earn his livelihood in
the vocation in which he was engaged, the loss of earning capacity has
to be treated as total.
9. In the present case, the appellant was working as a salesman in private company. The Claims Tribunal itself has recorded a finding that
the appellant's right leg was amputated below the knee, resulting in
permanent disability. The duties of a salesman necessarily require continuous standing, walking and mobility. The amputation of the right leg
has rendered the appellant incapable of effectively performing the duties attached. Therefore, although the medical disability has been assessed at 60%, the appellant has suffered 100% functional disability so
far as his earning capacity is concerned. Consequently, the loss of fu-
ture earning deserves to be computed by treating the functional disability at 100%, in consonance with the principles laid down by the
Supreme Court in the aforesaid decisions.
10.Furthermore, under the heads of loss of medical treatment, pain and
suffering, transportation expenses, special diet and attendant amount is
liable to be enhanced and also under the heads of future earning capacity, loss of amenities & enjoyment amount is liable to be awarded.
11. Thus, in light of the aforesaid discussion and in light of the judgments
of the Supreme Court rendered in the matters of National Insurance
Company Ltd. V. Pranay Sethi5, Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Ors6 and Magma General Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram & Ors.7, this Court is computing the
compensation as below:Sr.
No
Heads
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Compensation
awarded by this
Court
1.
Income
6000x12=72,000/-
7000x12= 84,000/-
2.
Future Prospect
NIL
(+)40% 33600;
Total 1,17,600/-
3.
Multiplier
72000x15=10,80,0 (x) 15 ; 117600x15
00/= 17,64,000/-
4.
Functional Disabil- 60% =6,48,000/ity (loss of Future
earning)
100% = 17,64,000/-
6.
Pain and suffering
+50,000 = 1814000
7.
Transportation,
NIL
Special Diet, Attendant
+100,000
19,14,000/-
=
8.
Medical Expenses
+100,000/20,14,000
=
9.
For other non-pecu- NIL
niary loss
+50,000
=20,64,000/-
10.
Cost of
Limb &
nance
+100,000/21,64,000/-
Total
5(2017) 16 SCC 680
6 (2009) 6 SCC 121
7(2018) 18 SCC 130
NIL
NIL
Artificial NIL
Mainte6,48,000/-
21,64,000/-
=
12.In view of the aforesaid analysis, the amount of compensation of Rs.
6,48,000/- awarded by the Claims Tribunal is enhanced to Rs.
21,64,000/-. Hence, after deducting the amount of Rs. 6,48,000/-, the
appellant is held to be entitled to an additional amount of Rs.
15,16,000/-.
13.So far as the liability of the Insurance Company is concerned, the
Claims Tribunal exonerated the respondent No. 3 Insurance Company
on the ground that the offending vehicle did not possess a valid permit.
However, the appellant is an innocent third-party victim and cannot be
deprived of just compensation on account of the breach of the policy
condition committed by the owner of the vehicle. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Amrit Paul Singh v. Tata AIG General Insurance Co. Ltd8.
has held that in cases where there is a breach of the permit condition,
the principle of "pay and recover" would apply. Accordingly, respondent No.3/Insurance Company is directed to satisfy the award in the
first instance and shall thereafter be at liberty to recover the amount
from respondent Nos.1 and 2, the owner and driver of the offending vehicle, in accordance with law.
14.The concerned respondent No. 3 is directed to deposit the amount of
compensation as enhanced by this Court within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of copy of this order. The additional
amount of compensation shall carry interest @6% per annum from the
date of filing of claim application before the Tribunal till its realization.
Rest of the conditions of the impugned award shall remain intact.
15.Accordingly, this appeal is allowed in part and the impugned award is
modified to the extent as indicated herein-above.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
Jyoti
(2018) 7 SCC 558
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review