Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 72 of 2023
Date of Decision: 11.09.2023
Vs.
Smti Ridalin Law
Jaintia Hills Autonomous
District Council & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. with
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The instant writ petition is a second round of litigation
before this Court wherein, in the first round, the petitioner though
being the highest bidder to operate a check station at Mookyndur, the
same was rejected by the respondent District Council, and instead
was settled with one Rudolf G. Kyndiah. This Court on the challenge
to the rejection, had allowed the writ petition by quashing the
impugned order of settlement, and had further directed the
respondents to re-examine the requirements and norms for setting up
a revenue station before taking any further decision on the work
order. The respondents thereafter on a re-examination of the matter,
vide order dated 26.10.2022, allotted the check station to the
petitioner on the condition that the petitioner make arrangements for
suitable land to set up the check gate, which the petitioner contends
was duly complied with. However, the respondents purportedly due
to a legal notice issued by the earlier unsuccessful second highest
bidder namely; Rudolf G. Kyndiah, cancelled the order dated
26.10.2022. Further, the respondents then took a decision to run the
check gate departmentally by leasing a plot of land at Khliehtyrshi,
which was at some distance from Mookyndur the original location of
the check gate. The writ petitioner being aggrieved thereby, is before
this Court seeking appropriate directions.
2.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits
that the actions of the respondents was with a view to circumvent the
order of this Court, and even their own order dated 26.10.2022,
whereby the settlement had been made in favour of the petitioner. It
is also submitted that the reason for cancellation of the petitioner’s
allotment, based on the legal notice issued by Rudolf G. Kyndiah, is
without any basis, inasmuch as, as his settlement had been cancelled
by this Court, in the earlier round of litigation, he no longer had any
locus, to question the settlement made in favour of the petitioner. The
learned counsel has contended that the respondents to cover up this
illegality, have now sought to bring out additional reasons for
cancellation of the order of settlement of the petitioner in the
affidavit-in-opposition, when such grounds were never present in the
impugned order dated 16.03.2023. This he submits is impermissible
and has been done as an afterthought.
3.
On another limb of submission, it has been submitted that
as per the condition set by the respondents, the petitioner had
obtained on lease, the same plot of land, which had been found
suitable when the lease was settled with the said Rudolf G. Kyndiah,
and as such the cancellation has therefore been made with an oblique
motive to deprive the petitioner of the contract.
4.
The learned counsel has also questioned the entire
decision process, and submits that the intention of the respondents
was to frustrate the contract and to circumvent the orders of this
Court by removing the cause of action by relocating the site of the
check point to Khliehtyrshi. By this arbitrary decision he submits,
the intention was to make it appear that the tender had been
abandoned, and that the respondents, were operating the check station
departmentally at a different location. Moreover, it is submitted, the
petitioner was not afforded an opportunity of hearing before the
impugned order of cancellation dated 16.03.2023 was passed,
whereby the decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held
on 14.03.2023 was communicated. In support of his arguments, the
learned counsel had relied on the case of Mohinder Singh Gill &
Anr. vs. The Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi & Ors.
(1978) 1 SCC 405 and in the case of Uflex Limited vs. Government
of Tamil Nadu & Ors. (2022) 1 SCC 165.
5.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. S.
Rumthao, learned counsel on behalf of the respondents submits that
pursuant to the order dated 26.09.2022 passed in WP(C) No. 29 of
2022, as per the directions of this Court, on a re-examination of the
matter, the contract was settled in favour of the writ petitioner but
however, due to subsequent developments wherein the respondents,
received a legal notice from Rudolf G. Kyndiah, and it was
discovered that the plot of land offered by the writ petitioner was the
same land offered by the said Rudolf G. Kyndiah, it was decided to
recall the order dated 26.10.2022, to avoid fresh litigation. It has been
further submitted, that the said plot of land was later found not
feasible, due to increased traffic congestion and VIP movement on
the national highway. On this ground therefore, he submits, the
respondents took a decision to take on lease a plot of land at
Khliehtyrshi for setting of the check point and to run the same
departmentally, and in pursuance to this decision, had vide a
communication dated 24.03.2023, appointed an agent namely Shri
Sevenborn Tang to operate the check station for a period of 5 years.
With regard to the objections of the counsel of the petitioner to the
additional grounds taken in the affidavit to supplement the reasons for
cancellation, the learned Senior counsel has asserted that the same is
untenable, inasmuch as, a State within the meaning of Article 12 of
the Constitution is not required to give reasons at every stage, while
rejecting tenders and Courts must give ‘fair play in the joints’ in
matters of contract. In support of his arguments, the learned Senior
counsel has relied in the case of Silppi Constructions Contractors vs.
Union of India & Anr. reported in (2020) 16 SCC 489.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
7.
The complaint of the writ petitioner as to the shoddy
treatment that has been meted out to her, in spite of being the highest
bidder for the contract appear to be genuine and has some basis,
inasmuch as, the tender has been abandoned by the respondents,
divesting the petitioner of her valuable right to the contract. Judicial
review in such matters which are commercial in nature, only take
place when there is overwhelming evidence of arbitrariness, bias or
irrationality. In the instant case, it cannot help but be noticed that the
writ petitioner has surely been discriminated against by the actions of
the respondents.
8.
In this regard, first on the allotment being granted to her on 26-
10-2022, the petitioner as per the condition had leased out the plot of
land which had undeniably been found suitable in the earlier occasion
for establishment of the check station, but the same was withdrawn
on the basis of a legal notice of one Rudolf G. Kyndiah. The apparent
reason for the same was to avoid future litigation, which is absurd,
inasmuch as, the said Rudolf G. Kyndiah is not party to, or part of the
award of the contract to the petitioner, and therefore, lacks any locus
to question the same. Secondly, arbitrariness, is writ large as the writ
petitioner before the cancellation was not intimated nor, given any
opportunity to represent against the same. Thirdly, the decision to
abandon the entire contract and to operate the same departmentally by
appointing an agent does not appear to be rational, but rather as
contended by the petitioner, made with a view to circumvent the
entire process and to render the order of settlement useless and
redundant.
9.
In the backdrop of the facts as aforementioned, however,
certain other aspects have also to be taken into consideration. The reexamination, the settlement with the petitioner and the cancellation, it
is noted has been attributed only to the location of the check station
which was found unsuitable. The evaluation and the award of
contract are essentially commercial functions where the principles of
fairness and natural justice have limited applicability, as such, the
Courts therefore, have to discern on the facts of a particular case if
the decision regarding the award of contract is made in good faith and
public interest, and will refrain from exercising the power of judicial
review, even if there are certain procedural irregularities, evaluation
errors or potential loss to a tenderer.
10.
This Court in the earlier round of litigation i.e., WP(C). No. 29
of 2022, in its order dated 26-09-2022, while setting aside the
appointment of respondent No. 7 as agent for the check station at the
earlier location at Mookyndur, had directed that the respondents have
a relook at the requirements and specific criteria to meet the norms of
setting up toll stations. It now appears that, they by their impugned
actions have instead chosen to abandon the entire process of award of
contract to private individuals, by running the check station
departmentally at the new location at Khliehtyrshi, which is stated to
be at a distance of 5 km from Mookyndur.
11.
This subsequent development no doubt, has changed the entire
complexion of the case and has given rise to a new cause of action,
which is not covered by the pleadings made in the instant writ
petition, which are confined only to seeking directions to formally
appoint the writ petitioner as agent to operate the check station at
Mookyndur, and for execution of a formal agreement as per the
decision of the respondents dated 26-10-2022. The directions as
prayed in the considered view of the Court, inspite of the sequence of
events that reflects a flawed decision making process in awarding and
thereafter cancelling the settlement of the petitioner without hearing
her, are in the present circumstances however, no longer available for
consideration. Coupled with this fact, is the presence of the element
of disputed facts, especially with regard to the decision to relocate the
check station based on the evaluation as to its suitability, and the
operation thereof, departmentally by the respondents.
12.
What cannot be ignored, however, is the manner in which the
entire exercise which had commenced from the award of contract in
the initial stage to the second highest bidder, which was cancelled by
orders of this Court, the subsequent events of settlement of the
contract with the petitioner, and the recalling of the same by the
impugned orders, and finally the abandonment of the entire tender
process, by resorting to change of location and operation by the
respondents themselves, which does not bode well for a constitutional
authority such as the JHADC. The writ petitioner by the actions of
the respondents has therefore, been put to unnecessary harassment
and undoubtedly, also pecuniary loss. Though cost is normally
awarded against petitioners or plaintiffs who engage in frivolous or
vexatious litigation, the present case in the facts and circumstances
thereof, however, call for exemplary cost to be inflicted upon the
respondent JHADC, for the arbitrariness shown in the entire decision
making process.
13.
Accordingly, it is directed that the respondent JHADC through
the Secretary of the Executive Committee pay a cost of Rs. 2(two)
lakhs to the writ petitioner within a period of 15(fifteen) days from
the date of this order.
14.
As ordered above, the writ petition stands closed and disposed
of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
11.09.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review