Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 29 of 2022
Date of Decision: 26.09.2022
Smti. Ridalin Law
Vs.
J.H.A.D.C & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Sen, Adv.
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. T. Sutnga, Adv. (For R 1-6)
Mr. H. Abraham, Adv. (For R 7).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner pursuant to an NIT dated 18th October, 2021, floated by
the respondents, calling for bids for operation of a check station at
Mookyndur, West Jaintia Hills, came out as a highest bidder after evaluation
by the Tender Committee, but however, the respondent No. 3 by a decision
taken on 08.02.2022, rejected the appointment of the writ petitioner as agent,
on the ground that the check station was situated on the right side of the
highway from Jowai to Shillong, which did not have enough space for
vehicles to stop for checking, and that the quoted rate was unrealistic and
inflated, amongst other reasons. The respondents then vide impugned letter
dated 09.02.2022, appointed the private respondent No. 7, who was the
second highest bidder as the agent to operate the check station at Mookyndur.
Being aggrieved thereby, the writ petitioner is before this Court.
2.
The undisputed fact in this matter is that, the petitioner is the highest
bidder in a tender process, which consisted of a Technical Bid and a Financial
Bid. By all accounts, the Bids having been scrutinized and examined by a
duly constituted Tender Committee, which had found the petitioner to be the
most suitable, she should have been called by the respondents to formalize an
agreement, to operate the said check station.
3.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the denial
of the contract to the petitioner inspite of being the highest bidder is illegal
and motivated. He submits that the respondent No. 3, once the Tender
Committee had recommended the petitioner had no jurisdiction to sit on top
of the findings and award, the contract to the second highest bidder. It is
contended that, the reasons stated by the respondent No. 3 in its decision dated
08.02.2022, is misplaced, inasmuch as, the Tender Committee before
finalizing the Technical Bids had conducted a physical verification of the site
for the check station offered by the petitioner, and had found the same to be
suitable. He further submits that, the award of the contract to the private
respondent is therefore, illegal and that the respondents are liable to be
directed to settle the contract with the petitioner without any further delay.
4.
The learned counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions to
impress upon the points that though the authority has the right not to accept
the highest bid, the said decision should be free from arbitrariness or
favoritism. The judgments are:i)
Meerut Development Authority versus Association of
Management Studies and Another (2009) 6 SCC 171.
ii)
Municipal Corporation, UJJain and Another versus BVG
India Limited and Others. (2018) 5 SCC 462.
iii)
Tata Cellular versus Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651.
iv)
Manohar Lal Sharma versus Narendra Damodardas Modi
and Others (2019) 3 SCC 25.
v)
Sam Built Well Private Limited versus Deepak Builders
and Others (2018) 2 SCC 176.
5.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. T. Sutnga,
learned counsel for the respondent JHADC, submits that though admittedly
the petitioner was the highest bidder, on the reassessment of the site of the
check point proposed by the petitioner, it was found that the same was
unsuitable due to the reasons recorded in its Executive Committee decision
dated 08.02.2022. The learned Senior counsel submits that the non-settlement
of the contract of the petitioner was made on the basis of cogent and valid
grounds and to buttress this contention, has read out the relevant extracts of
the said decision dated 08.02.2022. He further submits that the petitioner
cannot claim any enforceable right, merely because she is the highest bidder,
as there are good reasons for not awarding the contract to the petitioner. In
support of his case, the learned Senior counsel for the respondents has cited
the following decision:
i)
ERA Infra Engineering Limited vs. Delhi Development
Authority & Anr. 2010 (114) DRJ 569 (DB).
6.
Mr. H. Abraham, learned counsel on behalf of the respondent No. 7
has endorsed and supported the submissions made by the counsel for the
respondents No. 1-6, but further submits that due to the interim order of this
Court, the respondent No. 7 is not operating the check station as it is being
run departmentally.
7.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties. Shorn of all the other
facts, the only question to be determined is the reasonableness of the decision
by the respondents, to not award the contract to the highest bidder but to
award the same to the second highest i.e., the respondent No. 7. It is settled
law that there is no enforceable right for the highest bidder to be awarded a
contract, if there exist good and sufficient reasons, based on factors which
make the said bid unviable, but such decision in this regard, must be free from
any arbitrariness and should be reasonable.
8.
In the instant matter, undisputedly the writ petitioner is the highest
bidder, and if all conditions stood fulfilled as submitted, by all rights should
have been settled with the contract. It is noted that the bid system adopted in
the tender process was in two parts i.e., Technical Bid followed by a Financial
Bid. It was also stipulated in the NIT that the bids were to be opened and
evaluated by the Tender Committee and that the decision was final and
binding on the tenderers. The reason for non-settlement of the contract with
the petitioner is contained in the extract copy of a decision dated 08.02.2022,
which is appended at Annexure – 6 to the affidavit. For the sake of
convenience this document being crucial to the adjudication of the matter is
reproduced hereinbelow.
“OFFICE OF THE JAINTIA HILLS AUTONOMOUS DISTRICT
COUNCIL, JOWAI
EXTRACT COPY OF DECISIONS PASSED BY THE EXECUTIVE
COMMITTEE IN ITS MEETING HELD ON 08-02-2022 AND
AUTHENTICATED BY THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE MEMBER,
JAINTIA HILLS AUTONOMOUS DISTRICT COUNCIL, JOWAI
1. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE DECISION NO. 1 DT. 08-02-2022
Views and Opinion of Legal Adviser regarding Check Point at
Mookyndur:- The Chief Executive Member placed the agenda in the
Executive Committee. He informed all the Members about the legal
opinion on the legal notice regarding Check Point at Mookyndur and
inspection report of the Department concerned. He then sought the views
and opinion of the Members.
The Assistant Licensing Officer briefed the Executive Committee
that the Office of the Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council had
issued Re-Tender Notice vide No. JHADC/TAX/9/2021/61 dated 18th
October, 2021 with respect to Check Point at Mookyndur and AmlaremDawki respectively. Thereafter the Tender Committee who was tasked to
oversee the bidding process, had vide letter no. JHADC/TC/1/2021/58
dated 20th December, 2021 have recommended to the Executive
Committee, the name of Smt. Ridalin Law as the successful bidder. She
also briefed that the Executive Committee had directed Shri. W Lyngdoh,
Trading Inspector Taxation Department and Check Point to inspect the
land proposed by Smt. Ridalin Law to set up Check Point at Mookyndur
and to submit report forthwith to the Executive Committee. The Inspector
had submitted his report with findings as follows:1. That the land where Ridalin Law proposed to set up the Check Point
is situated in the right side of the Highway from Jowai to Shillong.
2. If the Check Point is set up in the said land, the staff have to cross
over to check the trading license of the vehicle.
3. The land where the check point is proposed to be set up does not have
sufficient space to stop vehicles to check the trading license and if
the land is used as Check Point and if vehicles are stopped it will
result in traffic jam thereby causing inconvenience to the vehicle in
the highway.
The Members pointed out that the Annual Premium quoted by
Smt. Ridalin Law for a single Check Point only at Rs. 77,60,800/- is
an illusion as it is far beyond the Annual Premium quoted by the Ex
agent at the rate of Rs. 32,00,100/- for three Check Points.
The Executive Member incharge Taxation pointed about the
instruction received from the District Council Affairs Department,
Government of Meghalaya, hereinafter referred to as District
Council Affairs that gate should not be on the Highway but away
from the highway having lay bye. He also mentioned about the
revenue leakage faced by this Office due to non-collection of fines
from trucks without trading license and mentioned that after scrutiny
of the land it is found that the land proposed by Smt. Ridalin Law is
not feasible and does not have sufficient space for the Check Point
as such it is not expedient to appoint Smt. Ridalin Law as the agent
for operating Check Point at Mookyndur.
In consideration of all points mentioned above, the Executive
Committee after a thorough discussion and deliberation,
unanimously decided to stand by its earlier decision i.e. to appoint
Shri Rudolf G. Kyndiah the second highest bidder as Lessee/Agent
of the Mookyndur Check Station. Consequently the representation
dated 20-12-2021 is hereby disposed off.
(NO. JHADC)
Secretary,
Executive Committee, Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council,
Jowai”
9.
The decision it is noted, has detailed five points for non-acceptance of
the tender of the petitioner on these considerations namely the location,
availability of space and the annual premium quoted. This Court is now to
examine as to whether the decision as given meets the test of it not being
unreasonable or arbitrary and whether the respondents No. 3 can sit over the
decision of the Tender Committee, which had declared the petitioner the
highest bidder after scrutiny of the Technical and Financial Bid.
10.
A perusal of the tender document shows that, Clause – 8(vi) thereof,
has stipulated that the land document, such as land holding certificate, lease
agreement of the land where the check station is proposed to be set up, was
to be furnished. It has been stated in the writ petition, that the Tender
Committee had conducted an inspection of all the site locations of the bidders,
to determine the suitability of each site and that only after such satisfaction,
the Technical Bids had been opened. However, the site inspection report does
not find place in any of the records before this Court. The impugned decision
on the other hand, has set out reasons for non-acceptance of the tender of the
petitioner and the reasons as given, being based on facts as they pertain on
the ground, it is not possible therefore for this Court to render a finding as to
its reasonableness or unreasonableness. It cannot also be held that, the
decision taken by the respondent No. 3 is arbitrary or made for a collateral
purpose, inasmuch as, apart from the observation on the inflated rate quoted
by the petitioner, and the instructions received from the District Council
Affairs Department, Government of Meghalaya with regard to the location of
the check station, that it should be away from the highway with a lay bye, the
rest is based on factual considerations of the feasibility of the location for the
check station.
11.
Scrutiny of the award of tenders and contracts by the Courts, as has
been held by various decisions, is basically confined to the decision-making
process on the question of reasonableness and mala fides. The scope of
judicial review in such matters as has been enunciated in the case of Tata
Cellular versus Union of India (supra) wherein at Paras – 70, 71 and 94, the
Supreme Court has held as follows:
“70. It cannot be denied that the principles of judicial review
would apply to the exercise of contractual powers by
Government bodies in order to prevent arbitrariness or
favouritism. However, it must be clearly stated that there are
inherent limitations in exercise of that power of judicial
review. Government is the guardian of the finances of the
State. It is expected to protect the financial interest of the State.
The right to refuse the lowest or any other tender is always
available to the Government. But, the principles laid down
in Article 14 of the Constitution have to be kept in view while
accepting or refusing a tender. There can be no question of
infringement of Article 14 if the Government tries to get the
best person or the best quotation. The right to choose cannot
be considered to be an arbitrary power. Of course, if the said
power is exercised for any collateral purpose the exercise of
that power will be struck down.
71.
Judicial quest in administrative matters has been to find
the right balance between the administrative discretion to
decide matters whether contractual or political in nature or
issues of social policy; thus they are not essentially justifiable
and the need to remedy any unfairness. Such an unfairness is
set right by judicial review.
94.
The principles deducible from the above are :
(1) The modern trend points to judicial restraint in
administrative action.
(2) The court does not sit as a court of appeal but merely
reviews the manner in which the decision was made.
(3) The court does not have the expertise to correct the
administrative decision. If a review of the administrative
decision is permitted it will be substituting its own decision,
without the necessary expertise which itself may be fallible.
(4) The terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open to
judicial scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in the realm
of contract.
Normally speaking, the decision to accept the tender or award
the contract is reached by process of negotiations through
several tiers. More often than not, such decisions are made
qualitatively by experts.
(5) The Government must have freedom of contract. In other
words, a fair play in the joints is a necessary concomitant for
an administrative body functioning in an administrative
sphere or quasi-administrative sphere. However, the decision
must not only be tested by the application of Wednesbury
principle of reasonableness (including its other facts pointed
out above) but must be free from arbitrariness not affected by
bias or actuated by mala fides.
(6) Quashing decisions may impose heavy administrative
burden on the administration and lead to increased and
unbudgeted expenditure.
Based on these principles we will examine the facts of this case
since they commend to us as the correct principles.”
12.
The above noted judgment, has become the benchmark on which such
matters are considered by Courts and has been followed by various other
judicial pronouncements, including the authorities cited by both the parties
herein. Accordingly, therefore, by applying the said principles, in the
considered view of this Court, the non-settlement of the contract with the
petitioner cannot be said to be affected by bias or mala fides, inasmuch as,
the reasons ascribed in the decision dated 08.02.2022, appear to be based on
factual considerations. However, the only element of concern is the fact that
the respondent No. 3, after the finalization of the bids had embarked upon the
exercise to ascertain the viability of the offer of the petitioner. No doubt, the
findings reflect the complications that would arise in the operation of the
check station by the petitioner, but however, the fact that the decision to not
settle the contract with the petitioner, when essentially the petitioner had met
the criteria as prescribed by the NIT deserves to be re-looked at by the
respondent No. 3.
13.
Though the Principles of Equity and Natural Justice do not operate in
the field of commercial transactions and whenever, a decision has been taken
in public interest, courts do not interfere, in the instant case, however, to strike
a balance, limited interference is called for. Accordingly, the impugned letter
No. JHADC/TAX/9/2021/86 dated 09.02.2022 issued by the respondent No.
4, appointing the respondent No. 7, as the Council’s agent for the check
station at Mookyndur, West Jaintia Hills is set aside and quashed.
14.
It is further provided that as the NIT did not prescribe specific criteria
and requirements to meet the norms of setting up toll stations, the respondent
No. 3 is directed to have a re-look at the decision especially the process
thereof, before any decision of allotment is taken.
It has also been brought to the notice of the Court that there have been
subsequent developments whereby the State Government have issued certain
orders which have a bearing on the operation of such check stations. All these
considerations, shall also be taken into account when the respondents review
the decision. As at the initial stage itself, this Court had by order dated
16.02.2022, suspended the settlement of the check station and directed that if
any checking need be done, the same be done so departmentally, the same
shall continue till the matter is finally decided.
15.
With the above noted directions, and for the reasons as stated, the writ
petition is partially allowed and disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
26.09.2022
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review