Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for judgment : 06.01.2026
Date of Pronouncement
: 29.01.2026
Date of Upload
: 29.01.2026
APHC010590032018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3545]
THURSDAY,THE TWENTY NINETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CENTRAL EXCISE APPEALS NO: 222/2018
Between:
1. RICHI MEN SILKS LIMITED, REP BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SHRI G. VITHAL, HAVING ITS OFFICE AT PLOT NO.12, RAOD NO.9,
JUBILEE HILLS,HYDERABAD
...APPELLANT
AND
1. THE COMISSIONER, Central Excise and Central Tax, Tirupathi
Commissionerate Tirupathi
...RESPONDENT
to allow the appeal by setting aside the Final Order No.A/31463/2017,
dated 04-09-2017 passed in Appeal No. C/446/2004 by the Customs, Excise
and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, South Zonal Bench, Bangalore and pass.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 76 days in representing the above appeal in the interest
of justice and pass.
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the Final Order No.A/31463/2017 in Appeal No.C/446/2004 passed
by the Learned CESTAT, Regional Bench, Hyderabad pending disposal of the
above appeal on the file of the this Hon'ble Court and pass.
IA NO: 3 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay the operation of the Final Order No. A/31463/2017 in Appeal No.
C/446/2004 passed by the learned CESTAT, Regional Bench, Hyderabad
pending disposal of the above appeal and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
take on record the Letter No.8/EOU/Adj-72/VSEZ/2019/3861, dt.10.05.2019,
issued by the office of the Development Commissioner, Ministry of Commerce
& Industry, Government of India and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. M SIVA KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. B V S CHALAPATI RAO
The Court made the following:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
&
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CENTRAL EXCISE APPEAL No.222 of 2018
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Battu Devanand)
This Central Excise Appeal is filed against the order passed by the
Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Regional Bench,
Hyderabad (for short “CESTAT) in Appeal No.C/446/2004, final order
No.A/31463/2017, dated 11.09.2017 in confirming the order in Appeal No.4 of
2004 (T) Cus, dated 10.08.2004 passed by the Commissioner of Customs and
Central Excise (Appeals), Guntur.
2. The case of the appellant:
(i) The appellant is an Export Oriented Unit (“hereinafter referred to as
“EOU”) established in 1987 to manufacture of silk fabric near Ananthapur,
Andhra Pradesh. The Department of Industrial Development, Secretariat of
Industrial Approvals granted permission for setting up the EOU in 1986. The
appellant was registered as 100% Export Oriented Unit and engaged in
manufacture of silk fabrics for exports. The appellant opted for de-bonding of
the unit in the year 1992 subject to payment of applicable customs duty in
terms of the Customs Act, 1962 and the EXIM policy, 1992-97 and the
conditions stipulated in the letter of intent issued by the Board of Approval. In
terms of the scheme, the appellant started the manufacturing activity of silk
yarn in 1988. However, due to liberal government policy, in 1990, China
started dumping its silk with one forth of rate then prevailing into India that
resulted severe problems to the silk industry in the country including the
appellant‟s unit. Thereafter, the appellant lost the domestic and export market
and sunk into losses. Thus, the appellant could not meet and achieve export
turnover which it obliged to fulfill and therefore the appellant opted to exit from
EOU scheme as it was not viable to continue in the scheme. The competent
authority i.e., the Development Commissioner granted “in principle approval”
to exit from the scheme on 09.06.1992 with conditions including payment of
full duties and payment of penalties in case of non-fulfillment of export
obligation.
(ii) The appellant intimated the “in principle approval” to the jurisdictional
Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise who intimated the duty liability to a
tune of Rs.3,94,48,924/- to be paid for exit. As it was financially impossible to
pay the huge amount of duty for the silk industry like that of the appellant and
in order to avail concessional rate of duty, the appellant applied to the Central
Silk Board to permit them to treat the de-bonding of goods as import under the
Project Import Regulations so as to clear the capital goods from bonding by
paying duty at 5% in terms of CTH 98.01. The Central Silk Board in its letter,
dated 27.02.1992 permitted the appellant to register under Project Import
Regulations, 1998 for availing confessional assessment of Customs Duty.
Basing on the permission granted by the Central Silk Board, and on the basis
of the “in principle approval” granted to the appellant by the Development
Commissioner by the jurisdictional Assistant Commissioner, issued a
provisional assessment order, dated 23.11.1992 demanding duties apart from
a penalty of 10% of the duties assessed under Foreign Trade (Development &
Regulation) Act, 1992 for the default to NFC (Net Foreign Exchange).
Thereafter, the Assistant Commissioner issued final assessment order, dated
15.12.1992 directing the appellant to deposit Rs.2,80,37,915/-.
(iii) Being aggrieved by the said assessment order, dated 15.12.1992
the appellant preferred an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals). The
Appellate Authority by its order, dated 23.07.1993 confirmed the duty amount
and declined the concessional rate of duty under Project Imports on the
ground that the imports are not contemporaneous and that the silk plants are
not included in the list of machinery under the Project Imports by ignoring the
letter issued by the Central Silk Board. Against the order, dated 23.07.1993 of
the Appellate Authority, the appellant approached the CESTAT. The appellant
also approached the High Court in W.P.No.1522 of 1993 and the said writ
petition was disposed of by order, dated 01.10.1993 directing the Government
may consider the request of the appellant subject to pre-deposit of an amount
of Rs.25,00,000/- by the appellant. The condition was complied with by the
appellant. Thereafter the appellant addressed a letter to the Secretary, SIA to
allow the goods to be assessed under heading 9801 under Project Import
Regulations. Meanwhile, the jurisdiction Assistant Commissioner issued
detention memo vide his order, dated 16.11.1997 detaining the plant and
machinery on the ground that the customs duty for de-bonding was not paid.
(iv) The appellant requested the Secretariat of Industrial Approval,
Government of India, New Delhi vide letter, dated 17.12.1997 to allow one
time de-bonding option for 100% EOU in terms of the Notification No.477(E),
dated 25.07.1991. As per which, compulsory licensing of silk industry has
been abolished and sale of 50% is allowed in Domestic Tariff Area (DTA). In
the EXIM policy for 1992-97, facility to opt for EPCG was also allowed. The
appellant worked out the duty liability on the capital goods and raw-materials
procured without payment of duty on the value of Rs.60,35,864/- (after
depreciation) and the duty payable worked out to Rs.6,03,586/- only. The
Development Commissioner, Vizag vide letter, dated 13.01.1998 granted “in
principle approval” to withdraw from 100% EOU subject to fulfillment of
standards stipulated in the letter of permission granted on 09.08.1992 by the
Secretariat of Industrial Approvals. In the appeal filed by the appellant before
the CESTAT
against
the order, dated 23.07.1993 passed by the
Commissioner (Appeals), the CESTAT passed its final order No.314 of 1998,
dated 17.02.1998 setting aside the Appellate Authority order with a direction
that the claim of the appellant that they are still 100% EOU till final de-bonding
takes place while requesting for refund. On 23.11.1998, the appellant
submitted an ex-bond bill of entry for home consumption for assessment of
duty and requested the Assistant Commissioner for de-bonding of the unit
since 10 year period had been completed by 04.04.1998.
jurisdictional
Assistant
Commissioner
passed
de
novo
But the
order,
dated
28.05.1999 confirming the duty liability of Rs.2,80,95,659/- with net liability of
Rs.2,55,95,659/- after deducting an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- deposited by
the appellant in terms of High Court order.
(v) Being aggrieved by the order, dated 28.05.1999 of the Assistant
Commissioner, the appellant preferred an appeal before the Commissioner
(Appeals) along with stay petition and the Commissioner (Appeals) granted
stay of further proceedings pending disposal of the appeal with a condition to
pre-deposit of an amount of Rs.2.50 crores. As the condition of pre-deposit
was not complied with by the appellant, the Commissioner (Appeals)
dismissed the appeal on 24.04.2000. Being aggrieved by the said order, the
appellant filed an appeal No.C/ST/231/2000 before the CESTAT and the
CESTAT set aside the O-I-A No.24/2000 (H-II) CUS in its final order No.1364
of 2000 and remanded the matter for de novo enquiry.
(vi) On being remanded, the Commissioner (Appeals) had confirmed
the demand of entire amount of duty in O-I-A No.4 of 2004 (T) Cus, dated
10.08.2004 holding that the order passed by the Executing Authority had
attained finality and he has no power to modify or over-rule the order and the
depreciation applied for and the right of duty adopted requires no modification
as found by his predecessor is correct on the ground that the appellant is not
100% EOU. The Appellate Authority ignored the direction of the CESTAT in
its final order No.1364 of 2000, dated 03.10.2000 while remanding the matter
to the Commissioner (Appeals) and the letter given by the competent authority
i.e., the Development Commissioner, Vizag confirming the status of the
appellant as 100% EOU. Aggrieved by the order, dated 10.08.2004 of the
Commissioner (Appeals), the appellant again preferred an appeal before the
CESTAT in Appeal No.C/446/2004. The CESTAT passed a final order
No.A/31463/2017, dated 11.09.2017 confirming the order, dated 10.08.2004
passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) in O-I-A No.4 of 2004. Aggrieved by
the final order No.A/31463 of 2017, dated 11.09.2017 passed by the CESTAT,
the appellant filed the present appeal.
3. While admitting the appeal, this Court has framed the following
substantial question of law:
“Whether the Hon‟ble CESTAT was right in deciding the appeal
without considering the matter not discussed by the Commissioner
(Appeals) as was directed by it in its Final Order No.314 of 1998,
dated 17.02.1998?”
4. On behalf of the respondent, a counter-affidavit has been
filed:
(i) It is averred in the counter-affidavit that the issue has originated in
Ananthapur Division which is earlier under the jurisdiction of Commissioner of
Industrial Excise and Customs, Tirupati Commissionarate and consequent on
re-organization in the Central Board of Excise and Customs, during October,
2014, the jurisdiction of the customs related work has been brought under the
jurisdiction of the Customs Commissionarate (Preventive), Vizag. The
appellant is registered as 100% EOU and are engaged in the manufacture of
silk fabrics for exports within India. He is opted de-bonding of their unit in the
year 1992. The Assistant Commissioner vide the de novo order No.2 of 1999
(CUS), dated 28.05.1999 confirmed the demand of Rs.2,80,95,659/- on
finalization of provisional assessment vide Assistant Commissioner‟s letter,
dated 21.11.1992 being the duty of customs i.e., Basic/AUX/CVD involved on
the capital goods, raw-materials/semi furnished goods/indigenous goods,
spares and components of machinery on account of de-bonding unit. The said
duty amount was payable in terms of Section 7 of Customs Act, 1992. The
EXIM policy 1992-97 r/w terms and conditions of the letter of intent given to
the appellant by the Board of Approval for 100% export oriented units. The
Assistant Commissioner appropriated a sum of Rs.25,00,000/- paid by the
appellant in compliance of the interim order of the Hon‟ble High Court of
Andhra Pradesh towards the duty amount of Rs.2,80,95,659/- demanded in
the assessment letter, dated 21.11.1992. The Assistant Commissioner also
demanded interest on the said outstanding duty amount @ 20% per annum
with effect from 26.05.1995 i.e., the date of inception of the interest clause
vide Section 28(A)(a) r/w notification No.33/1995 CUS (NT) dated 26.05.1995
which worked out to be Rs.2,08,60,461/- as on May, 1999. It is further averred
that after many rounds of litigation, the issue remanded to Commissioner
(Appeals), Guntur in A.No.30/2000 (H-II), CUS. The Commissioner (Appeals),
Guntur and after giving opportunities under principles of natural justice and
expressing his displeasure about the attitude of the appellant, passed ex parte
order, dated 10.08.2004 and dismissed the appeal and upheld the de novo
order, dated 28.05.1999 passed by the Assistant Commissioner.
(ii) It is further averred in the counter-affidavit that the appellant is
claiming 100% EOU as it was referring to the suo moto de-bonding letter
issued by VSEZ Development Commissioner, Visakhapatnam on 08.08.2006.
But this aspect has been properly and empathetically addressed by the
Appellate Authority vide O-I-A No.4 of 2004 (T) CUS, dated 10.08.2004 in
A.No.30/2000 (H-II) Cus. It is further averred that the CESTAT rightly upheld
the First Appellate Authority findings and categorically held that there are no
wrong findings in them. It is further averred that the CESTAT also
categorically stated the ratio of case laws cited by the appellant does not
applicable in the instant case as they are totally different from the facts of the
instant case eventually and the CESTAT dismissed the appeal as devoid of
merits and accordingly prayed this Court to dismiss the present appeal as
devoid of merits.
5. Submissions of the learned Senior Counsel for appellant:
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the department issued
a letter, dated 08.08.2006 wherein the Government has issued a cancellation
of letter of permission and suo-moto bonding from EOU scheme. In view of
de-bonding order issued on 08.08.2006 and the appellant was still an export
oriented unit as on that day, the condition 10 of the Standard Conditions
attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export Oriented Undertaking
would come into operation and the authority should have passed an order in
terms of the said clause. The learned counsel further contends that though the
CESTAT had extracted the contention of the appellant in para No.7 of the
order, without considering the same passed the impugned order. The learned
counsel further contends that during the pendency of the present appeal, the
appellant herein made a representation to the Government of India, Ministry of
Commerce and Industry, seeking clarification regarding suo-moto de-bonding
EOU.
(ii) The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant further contends that
by virtue of the clarification issued by the Government vide letter, dated
10.05.2009, it is clear that the suo-moto de-bonding order on 08.08.2006 is to
be treated as final date of exit of the unit and by virtue of the said clarification,
the condition 10 of the Standard Conditions attached to Industrial License in
respect of 100% Export Oriented Undertaking would come into play. In view
of the clarification issued in the letter, dated 10.05.2019 stated supra, the
Commissioner of Central Excise and Central Tax, Tirupati Commissionarate
has to pass an order in terms of the condition 10 f the Standard Conditions
attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export Oriented
Undertaking. In the light of the clarification letter issued by the Deputy
Development Commissioner, Vizag, dated 10.05.2019, the learned Senor
Counsel would contend that the matter may be remanded back to the
Commissioner (Appeals) for consideration of the appellant unit has exited
from EOU scheme by virtue of de-bonding order issued on 08.08.2006 by
allowing the appeal.
6. Submissions of the learned Senior Standing Counsel for
Respondent:
The learned Senior Standing Counsel would contend that the impugned
orders are well reasoned, lawful and based on settled facts. The learned
Senior Standing Counsel would contend that the CESTAT rightly dismissed
the appeal filed by the appellant observing that the appellant failed to fulfill
export obligations undertaken at the time of import and the plea of continue
EOU as it was passed suo-moto de-bonding in 2006 illusory and untenable.
The learned Senior Standing Counsel further contends that the appellant has
failed to establish any ground warranting interference of this Court in this
appeal, as the appeal devoid of merits and barred by limitation and sought to
dismiss this appeal directing the appellant to forthwith discharge the
outstanding amount along calculated interest in the interest of justice and
revenue.
7. Heard Sri O. Manohar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the appellant and Sri B.V.S. Chalapati Rao, learned Senior Standing Counsel
for Central Excise and Central Tax appearing for respondent and carefully
perused the material available on record.
8. Findings and reasons:
(a) The main contention raised by the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the appellant is that by virtue of the clarification issued by the
Deputy Development Commissioner, Government of India, Ministry of
Commerce and Industry vide letter, dated 10.05.2019, the unit was issued
suo-moto de-bonding order on 08.08.2006 and the same may be treated as
final date of exit of the unit and there upon condition No.10 of the Standard
Conditions attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export Oriented
Undertaking would come into play.
(b) The contention of the learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing
for the respondent is that the contention of the appellant that they are claiming
100% Export Oriented Unit by referring to the suo-moto de-bonding letter
issued by VSEZ, Development Commissioner, Visakhapatnam on 08.08.2006
has been properly and empathically addressed by the appellate authority in its
order, dated 10.08.2004 and as such the CESTAT rightly upheld the appellate
authority proceedings and there is no infirmity in the order of the appellate
authority as rightly confirmed by the order of the CESTAT.
(c) In view of the rival contentions, as noted herein above, in our
considered view, it is relevant and necessary to look into the contents of the
letter No.8/EOU/Adj-72/VSEZ/ 2019/ 3861, dated 10.05.2019 issued by the
Deputy Development Commissioner, Government of India, Ministry of
Commerce and Industry and the condition 10 of the Standard Conditions
attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export Oriented Undertaking
as extracted herein under for proper adjudication of the issue involved in the
present appeal:
Letter No.8/EOU/Adj-72/VSEZ/ 2019/ 3861, dated 10.05.2019:
“In view of the undertaking submitted by the unit and as per
the record of this office since the unit was defunct from 1999
onwards the unit was issued Cancellation of Letter of Permission/
„Suo-Moto‟ de-bonding from EOU scheme vide VSEZ letter dated
08.08.2006 in terms of Para 4(i) Appendix 14-G of Hand Book of
Procedure and as per the monitoring guidelines of Foreign Trade
Policy.
It is also mentioned that the unit was continued to be treated
as EOU till the date of final exit order, in terms of the Appendix 6K
of guidelines for exit of EOUs. In the instant case, the unit was
issued „Suo-Moto‟ de-bonding order on 08.08.2006 and the same
may be treated as final date of exit of the unit.
It is further mentioned that the Unit has to comply with the
provisions of the FTP and liable to pay all applicable duties and
taxes if any levied on them immediately.”
Condition 10 of the Standard Conditions attached to Industrial
License in respect of 100% Export Oriented Undertaking:
“10. On de-bonding after the period of export obligation, the undertaking
will be liable to pay will by the followings:(a) Customs duty on capital goods on the depreciated value but at
rates prevalent on the date of import.
(b) Customs duty on unused Imported raw-materials and
component on value at the time of Import and at the rates in on the
date of clearance and
(c) In respect of excisable goods, excise duty to be levied without
depreciation on such goods and at rates attracted as on the date
on clearance.”
9. The contention of the appellant is that though the CESTAT had
noted the contention of the appellant in para No.7 of its order, dated
17.09.2017 about applying the condition 10 of the Standard Conditions
attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export Oriented
Undertaking regarding the de-bonding order issued on 08.08.2006, there
is no discussion or finding on that aspect. Though the respondent has
stated in their counter that the claim of the appellant with regard to 100%
EOU was considered referring to the suo-moto de-bonding letter, dated
08.08.2006
issued
by
the
VSEZ,
Development
Commissioner,
Visakhapatnam by the appellate authority in its order, dated 10.08.2004, it
was not considered.
10. On careful examination of the order of the Commissioner
(Appeals), dated 10.08.2004, there is no mention about considering that
aspect. Even in the order, dated 11.09.2017 of the CESTAT also this
issue has not been considered. The Commissioner (Appeals) in its order,
dated 10.08.2004 held that the order passed by the Assessing Authority
had attained finality and he has no power to modify or over-rule the order
and the findings given by his predecessor. In fact, while the CESTAT
remanded the matter by its order for de-novo enquiry, it is directed the
Commissioner (Appeals) to take into consideration the pre-deposit
already made in terms of High Court‟s order and directed to hear the
appeal on merits. As and when the CESTAT remanded the matter for
fresh
consideration
and
to
conduct
de-novo
consideration,
the
Commissioner (Appeals) has to consider the entire issue on merits. As
such, the Commissioner (Appeals) finding that he would not entitle to
modify or over-rule the order of his predecessor (which was set aside by
the CESTAT while remanding for conducting de-novo enquiry) is illegal
and unsustainable. The CESTAT also without going into the merits of the
case simply extracted the findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) and
dismissed the appeal without assigning reason, which is illegal and
unjust.
11. The Commissioner (Appeals) and the Customs, Excise and
Service Tax Appellate Tribunal are exercising powers under the Central
Excise Act, 1944, as quasi-judicial authorities and they are obliged to
discharge satisfactory functions which by assessing the facts and
circumstances of the case which would show the application of judicial
mind. They have to weigh the material which has been placed before
them and they have to process it by the process of assessing the
credentiality of the contentions of the appellant. In the present case,
unfortunately, it appears that the appellate authority or Tribunal did not
consider the contentions raised by the appellant in proper manner. As
such, the order of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate
Tribunal assailed in this appeal would not sustain in the eye of law.
12. On careful perusal of the order, dated 11.09.2017 of the
CESTAT, it is established that without assigning any reasons for nonconsidering the claim of the petitioner in the light of the de-bonding order,
dated 08.08.2006 passed by the VSEZ, Development Commissioner,
Visakhapatnam and the application of the condition 10 of the Standard
Conditions attached to Industrial License in respect of 100% Export
Oriented Unit, in mechanical way dismissed the appeal filed by the
appellant. As such, the order, dated 10.08.2004 passed by the
Commissioner (Appeals) and the order, dated 11.09.2017 passed by the
Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal are unsustainable
under law and liable to be set aside.
13. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and in the
light of the clarification issued by the Deputy Development Commissioner,
Vizag, dated 10.05.2019 wherein it is clarified that that the suo-moto debonding order on 08.08.2006 is to be treated as final date of exit of the
unit, in our considered view, it is appropriate and reasonable to remand
the matter to the Commissioner (Appeals) for fresh consideration and for
passing appropriate orders in accordance with law by following due
process of law, to meet the interest of justice.
14. Accordingly, this appeal is disposed of with the following
directions:
(i) The order, dated 11.09.2017 passed by the Customs, Excise
and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Regional Bench, Hyderabad in
Appeal No.C/446/2004, final order No.A/31463/2017, in confirming the
order in Appeal No.4 of 2004 (T) Cus, dated 10.08.2004 passed by the
Commissioner of Customs and Central Excise (Appeals), Guntur, are
hereby set aside;
(ii) The matter remanded to the Commissioner (Appeals) for denovo enquiry and to pass orders afresh in accordance with law by
following due process of law, taking into consideration of the clarification
letter issued by the Deputy Development Commissioner, Vizag, dated
10.05.2019.
16. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
_________________________
JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
_________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Dated: 29.01.2026
PGR
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
&
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CEA.No.222 of 2018
Dt. 29.01.2026
PGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review