Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:23351-DB
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Reserved for orders on : 30.03.2026
Order passed on : 14.05.2026
WPS No. 7027 of 2021
1 - Gorelal S/o Shri Latel Prasad Yadav Aged About 43 Years R/o Boudi
Para, Sagun Garden, Ambikapur, District Surguja Chhattisgarh. Pin No.
497001
2 - Rajbeer Das S/o Late Madhu Das Aged About 44 Years R/o Christ
Milan Para, Ward No. 10, Namna Kala, Ambikapur, District Surguja
Chhattisgarh. Pin No. 497001
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Blcok, New Delhi 110001.
2 - Central Board Of Direct Tases Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, Chhatisgarh 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan, Vyapar Vihar,
Bilaspur Chhattisgarh 495001
6 - Zonal Account Officer Aayakar Bhawan Hoshangabad Raod,
Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
7 - Rajeshwar Sonwani S/o Mangal Ram Aged About 30 Years R/o
Bhattapara, Bihand Hospita Ambikapur 497001
8 - Mohan Lal Mahanand (Died) Through Lrs.- (As Per Honble Court
Order Dated 17-12-2024)
8.1 - (A) Smt. Sukhni Bai W/o Mohan Lal Mahanand Aged About 50
Years R/o Sheetla Ward Shakti Para Near Karbala Ambikapur,
Chhattisgarh- 497001
9 - Sanjay Kumar Gupta S/o Shri Bhagirathi Samund Aged About 38
Years R/o Laxmipur, Bilaspur Chowk Ambikapur 497001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 1964 of 2026
1 - Deepak Shrivas S/o Shri Chetram Shrivas, Aged About 48 Years R/o
Amapara, Khapra Bhatti, Near Sai Mandir, Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code
492001
---Petitioner
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Pccit), Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Ccit), Central Revenue
Building, Civil Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (Cit), Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G., Pin No. 492001
6 - Director General Of Income Tax (Investigation), Aykar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (M.P.) 462016
7 - Additional Director Of Income Tax (Investigation Civil Line) Raipur
(C.G.) 492001
8 - Ravi Shripal S/o Late Vasudas Shripal @ Vasudev Shripal, Aged
About 42 Years R/o Behind Sbi Colony, Durga Nagar, Shanti Nagar,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) 492001
9 - Manjeet Soni S/o Shri Tirkar Soni, Aged About 43 Years R/o New
Shanti Nagar Road, Behra Colony City Pandri, Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code
492001
10 - Mahendra Kumar Sahu S/o Late Mallu Ram Sahu, Aged About 43
Years R/o Ramkund Para, Near Life Birth Hospital, Gangaram Nagar,
Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code 492001
11 - Jyoti Ram Khare S/o Shri Teeju Ram Khare Aged About 51 Years
R/o Durga-Para, Santoshi Nagar, Raipur (C.G.) 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 14002 of 2025
1 - Rewa Ram Gaykwad S/o Temsingh Gayakwad Aged About 46 Years
R/o Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax Bhilai Range Aykar
Bhawan New Civic Centre Bhilai Distt.-Durg (C.G.) 491001
2 - Rampal Sahu S/o Kunbul Sahu Aged About 59 Years C/o Additional
Commissioner Of Income Tax Bhilai Range Aykar Bhawan New Civic
Centre Bhilai Distt.- Durg (C.G.) 491001
3 - Bhagwat Prasad Yadava S/o Lakshman Prasad Yadav Aged About
49 Years C/o Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax Bhilai Range
Aykar Bhawan New Civic Centre Bhilai Distt.- Durg (C.G.) 491001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi – 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
6 - Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax Bhilai Range Aykar Bhawan
New Civic Centre Bhilai (C.G.) Pin No. 491-001
7 - Lalit Swami S/o Shri Ashok Swami Aged About 40 Years R/o 2/9
Income Tax Colony Sector-6 Bhilai Nagar District- Durg Village- Bodal,
Post- Kankot, Tehsil- Patan, District- Durg (C.G.) 491001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9710 of 2025
1 - Sanyasi Rao S/o Shri Mimadri Rao Aged About 46 Years R/o
Shankar Nagar Raipur Chhattisgarh 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (P C C I T) Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462011 (Not Impleaded In Original Application But Impleaded Herein)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (C C I T) Central Revenue
Building, Civil Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No.
492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (C I T) Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No. 492001
6 - Joint Commissioner Of Income- Tax Range- Ii, Field Pay, Unit
Central Revenue Building Civil Line Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
7 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal (M.P.) Pin No.- 462011
8 - Kalu Nayak S/o Late Guruji Nayak Aged About 28 Years R/o Bairan
Bazar, Near Kundrapara Hunman Bhakt Ram Mandir Raipur (C.G.)
492001
9 - Kumari Neema Masih D/o Shri Johnson Masih Kripal Aged About 35
Years R/o Noorani Chowk Raja, Talab Raipur C.G 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 14029 of 2025
1 - Ram Narayan Soni S/o Shri Late Atma Ram Soni Aged About 63
Years R/o Nathpara Subash Nagar, Raipur, C.G.- 492002
---Petitioner
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road, Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal (M.P.) Pin No.- 462-011
7 - Rajendra Yaduwanshi S/o Shri D.P. Yaduwanshi Aged About 56
Years Ro Sriram Chowk, Teekrapara, Raipur, (C.G.)- 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9480 of 2025
1 - Manoj Kumar Soni S/o Shri Gaya Ram Soni, Aged About 47 Years
R/o Gram Lakhra, Post- Lakhram Thana Ratanpur, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
2 - Ravi Kumar Bais, S/o. Shri Damodar Prasad Bais, Aged About 46
Years R/o Shri Krishna Goshala, Madhuvan Road, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
3 - Devchandra Nirmalkar @ Dev Chandra Nirmalkar, S/o Shri Uday
Ram Nirmalkar, Aged About 45 Years R/o Village And Post Office
Gadwar Thana, Ratanpur, District Bilaspur 495001
4 - Ramanchal Rana @ Rumanchal Rana, S/o Shri Achuch Rana, Aged
About 38 Years R/o Ward No. 04, Parijat Colony, Nehru Nagar, Bilaspur
(C.G.) 495001
5 - Sunl Dewangan @ Sunil Dewangan, S/o Melan Ram Dewangan,
Aged About 46 Years R/o Baniya Para, Bilaspur (C.G.) 495001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax, Ayakar Bhawan Vyapar Bihar,
Bilaspur (C.G.) Pin No.- 495001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road, Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal (M.P.) Pin No. 462011
7 - Joint Director Of Income Tax (Inv), Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
8 - Anil Yadav S/o Badri Prasad Yadav, Aged About 45 Years R/o Udai
Chowk, Katiya Para, Bilaspur (C.G.) 495001
9 - Vishnu Yadav S/o Rajaram Yadav, Aged About 45 Years R/o In Front
Of Sai Temple, Kranti Nagar, Bilaspur 495001
10 - Rukshna Begam, W/o Late Hanif Ali, Aged About 55 Years R/o
Marhimai Talapara, Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 14113 of 2025
1 - Manjeet Soni S/o Shri Tirkar Soni Aged About 43 Years R/o New
Shanti Nagar Road, Behra Colony City Pandri, Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin
Code 492001 (Father Name Wrongly Mentioned As Shri Virkar Soni)
2 - Mahendra Kumar Sahu S/o Late Mallu Ram Sahu Aged About 43
Years R/o Ramkund Para, Near Life Birth Hospital, Gangaram Nagar,
Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Pccit) Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P)
462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Ccit) Central Revenue Building,
Civil Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (Cit) Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No. 492001
6 - Director General Of Income Tax (Investigation) Aykar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal M.P. 462016
7 - Additional Director Of Income Tax (Investigation Civil Line) Raipur
Chhattisgarh 492001
8 - Ravi Shripal S/o Late Vasudas Shripal @ Vasudev Shripal Aged
About 42 Years R/o Behind Sbi Colony, Durga Nagar, Shanti Nagar,
Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh 492001
9 - Jyoti Ram Khare S/o Shri Teeju Ram Khare Aged About 51 Years
R/o Durga Para, Santoshi Nagar, Raipur Chhattisgarh 492001
10 - Deepak Shrivas S/o Shri Chetram Shrivas Aged About 48 Years
R/o Amapara, Khapra Bhatti, Near Sai Mandir, Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin
Code 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 101 of 2026
1 - Mannu Das S/o Shri Firanta Das Aged About 46 Years R/o Quarter
No. C/3 Canera Bank Colony, Durg Naka, Durg (C.G.). Current
Address- Daya Nagar Risali, Tehsil And District Durg Pin Code 491001,
(Wrongly Mentioned As Mannu Das S/o Shri Phiranta Das)
2 - Rakesh Diwedi S/o Shesh Narayan Dewedi Aged About 50 Years
R/o 3a Line No. 14 Sector No.2, Bhilai, Durg, Chhattisgarh Pin Code
491001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
6 - Indrajeet Gedam S/o Punara Gedam Aged About 47 Years Resident
At House No. 58, Near Gulab Talour, Sharda Para Bhilai, Durg (C.G.)
Pin Code 491001
7 - Pawan Kumar Verma S/o Shri Ramashya Verma Aged About 32
Years R/o Jantani Madol Town, West-4 Ward No.1, Bhilai, Durg (C.G.)
Pin Code- 491001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8186 of 2025
1 - Swaraj Kumar Shrivastava S/o Late Awadh Bihari Lal Shrivastava
Aged About 54 Years R/o Purani Basti, Kasthya Para, Raipur, DistrictRaipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi- 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (P C C I T), Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462011 (Not Impleaded In Original Application But Impleaded Herein)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (C C I T), Central Revenue
Building, Civil Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur C.G., Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (C I T), Central Revenue Building,
Civil Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur C.G., Pin No. 492-001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 10279 of 2025
1 - Ravi Shripal S/o Late Vasudas Shripal @ Vasudev Shripal, Aged
About 42 Years R/o Behind Sbi Colony, Durga Nagar, Shanti Nagar,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Pccit), Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462016
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income (Ccit) Central Revenue Building,
Civil Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (Cit), Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
6 - Director General Of Income Tax (Investigation), Aykar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal (M.P.) 462016
7 - Additional Director Of Income Tax (Investigation Civil Line) Raipur
(C.G.) 492001
8 - Jyoti Ram Khare S/o Shri Teeju Ram Khare Aged About 51 Years
R/o Durga- Para, Santoshi Nagar, Raipur (C.G.) 492001
9 - Deepak Shrivas S/o Shri Chetram Shrivas, Aged About 48 Years R/o
Amapara, Khapra Bhatti, Near Sai Mandir, Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code492001
10 - Mahendra Kumar Sahu S/o Late Mallu Ram Sahu, Aged About 43
Years R/o Ramkund Para, Near Life Birth Hospital, Gangaram Nagar,
Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code- 492001
11 - Manjeet Soni, S/o Shri Virkar Soni, Aged About 43 Years R/o New
Shanti Nagar Road, Behra Colony City Pandri, Raipur (C.G.) Pin Code492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 171 of 2026
1 - Khilawan Singh S/o Late Manrakhan Korse Aged About 58 Years R/o
Village- Bodal Post- Kankot, Tehsil Patan District- Durg (C.G.) 491001,
2 - Uttam Singh Gayakwad S/o Late Ram Chand Aged About 46 Years
R/o Village- Deori Post- Anda Teh- Gunderdehi District- Balod (C.G.)
491001, (Wrongly Mentioned As Uttam Ssing Gayakwad)
3 - Panchram Kosre S/o Manrakhan Kosre Aged About 53 Years R/o
Village Badal Post- Kanakot Tehsil Patan District- Durg (C.G.) 491001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through- The Secretary, Department Of Revenue
Ministry Of Finance North Block- New Delhi-110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through- Its Chairman North BlockNew Delhi, 11000.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan
Hoshangabad Road Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building Civil Lines
Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001,
5 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building Civil
Lines Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No-492001,
6 - Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax Bhilai Range Aykar Bhawan
New Civic Centre Bhilai (C.G.) Pin No. 491001,
7 - Sukhen Kumar Joshi S/o Beer Singh Aged About 55 Years R/o
Village Bodan Post- Kanakot Tehsil Patan District- Durg C.G. 491001
8 - Pawan Kumar Bogde S/o Gyaniram Bogde Aged About 48 Years R/o
Prem Nagar Durg C.G. 491001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9725 of 2025
1 - Sahabuddin S/o Sheikh Jamaluddin Aged About 42 Years R/o H. No.
- 35/2434, Near Jagannath Mandir Sector - 5, Vallabh Nagar, Pachpedi
Nak Raipur Chhattisgarh 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India R/o Village - Harfatrai, Po - Achouta, District Dhamtari Chhattisgarh 493773
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No. 492001
5 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin No. 492001
6 - Income Tax Officer Aykar Bhawan Shankardah Road Dhamtari,
District Dhamtari Chhattisgarh Pin 493773
7 - Kamal Kumar Ber S/o Late Shayam Lal Ber R/o Village - Harfatrai,
Po - Achouta, District - Dhamtari Chhattisgarh 493773
8 - Anil Kumar Rangari S/o Kartik Ram Rangari R/o Village Mathuradih, Post Office - Achouta, District - Dhamtari Chhattisgarh
493773
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 11768 of 2025
1 - Santosh Kumar Sahu S/o Hari Ram Sahu Aged About 57 Years R/o
Rawatpura Colony, Plaza- 2, Mathpurena, Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G.
) Pin No. 492-001 ( Address ) Wrongly Mentioned As Near Kalibadi,
Nehru Nagar, Raipur Chhattisgarh )
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India R/o Uttkal Nagar Kundrapara, Bairan Bazar Raipur
( C.G. ) 492001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Pccit ), Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal
( M.P. )462011 ( Not Impleaded In Orginal Application But Impleaded
Herein )
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax ( Cgit ) Central Revenue
Building, Civil Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G. ). Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax ( Cit ) Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur District- Raipur ( C.G. ). Pin No. 492-001
6 - Mayaram Nayak S/o Late Guru Ji Nayak Aged About 42 Years R/o
Uttkal Nagar Kundrapara, Bairan Bazar Raipur ( C.G. ) 492001
7 - Sekhar Singh Markam S/o Amar Singh Markam Aged About 51
Years R/do Old Pension Bada, Raipur ( C.G. ) 492001
8 - Murat Lal Sarpa S/o Punau Ram Aged About 57 Years R/o Near
Math Puraena Raipur ( C.G. ) 492001
9 - Ravindra Kumar Mahanand S/o Kartik Ram Mahanand Aged About
33 Years R/o Behind Primary School, Sadar Police Line, Raipur ( C.G. )
492001
10 - Tulsi Rao S/o Shri Narsalya Aged About 38 Years R/o New Pension
Wada Arvind Nagar Raipur ( C.G. ) 492001
11 - Janardan Rao. Mohite Shri Guhri Rao Mohite C/o Chand Rattan
Singh Jhanda Chowk Sanjay Nagar Tikra Para Raipur ( C.G. ) 492001
12 - Prahald Singh Yadav S/o Late Pardeshi Ram Aged About 43 Years
R/o Near Dr. Vadhwani, Durga Chowk, Katora, Talab, Raipur ( C.G. )
492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9706 of 2025
1 - Pawan Kumar Bogde S/o Gyaniram Bogde Aged About 48 Years R/o
Prem Nagar, Durg C.G. 491001.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001.
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi- 110001.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal M.P. 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001.
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001.
6 - Additional Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bhilai Range, Aykar
Bhawan New Civil Center Bhilai C.G. Pin No. 491001
7 - Khilawan Singh S/o Late Manrakhan Korse Aged About 54 Years R/o
Village- Bodal Post Kankot, Tehsil Patan, District Durg C.G. 491001.
8 - Uttam Sing Gayakwad S/o Late Ram Chand Aged About 54 Years
R/o Village- Deori, Post Anda, Teh- Gunderdehi, District Durg C.G.
491001.
9 - Sukhen Kumar Joshi S/o Beer Singh Aged About 52 Years R/o
Bodan Post Kankot, Tehsil- Patan, District Durg C.G. 491001.
10 - Panchram Kosre S/o Manrakhan Kosre Aged About 53 Years R/o
Village - Badal, Post Kankot, Tehsil- Patan, District Durg C.G. 491001.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9737 of 2025
1 - Rashtra Pal Vandre S/o Laxman Rao Vandre, Aged About 47 Years
R/o Shiv Chowk, Dr. Rajendra Nagar, Raipur (C.G.) 492001
2 - Sajendra Kumar Sahu S/o Late Baghirathi Sahu, Aged About 42
Years R/o Near Jaichandi Building Works, Tringa Chowk, Khushl Pur,
Raipur (C.G.) 492001
3 - Rakesh Kumar Mahanand S/o Kishan Lal Mahanand, Aged About 47
Years R/o Bairon Bazar, Kundra Para, Raipur (C.G.) 492001
4 - Vimal Kumar Louvanshi S/o Parashram Luvanshi, Aged About 48
Years R/o Near Lic Colony, Raipur (C.G.)- 492001, Mowa Raipur
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill Bhopal (M.P.) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
6 - Kesh Kumar Rajak S/o Late Goutam Rajak, Aged About 46 Years
R/o Near Resaimata Mandir, Ramsagar Para, Dhamtari (C.G.) 493773
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 14041 of 2025
1 - Kesh Kumar Rajak S/o Late Goutam Rajak Aged About 59 Years R/o
Near Resaimata Mandir, Ramsagar Para, Dhamtari C.G. 493773.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001.
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi- 110001.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001.
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001.
6 - Rashtra Pal Vandre S/o Laxman Rao Vandre Aged About 47 Years
R/o Shiv Chowk, Dr. Rajendra Nagar, Raipur C.G. 492001.
7 - Sajendra Kumar Sahu S/o Late Baghirathi Sahu Aged About 42
Years R/o Near Jaichandi Building Works, Tringa Chowk, Khushl Pur,
Raipur C.G. 492001.
8 - Rakesh Kumar Mahanand S/o Kishan Lal Mahanand Aged About 47
Years R/o Bairon Bazar, Kundra Para, Raipur C.G.- 492001.
9 - Vimal Kumar Louvanshi S/o Parashram Luvanshi Aged About 48
Years R/o Near L I C Colony, Raipur C.G.- 492001. Mowa Raipur C.G.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 10288 of 2025
1 - Vishnu Das Mahant S/o Shri C.D. Mahant Aged About 51 Years C/o
M/331 Ompur Roygmar Colony, P.O. Ompur Korba ( C.G. ). 495683
2 - Hirendra Kumar Lahre S/o Shri G.R. Lahre Aged About 47 Years C/o
M/331 Ompur Roygmar Colony O.P. Ompur Korba ( C.G. ). 495683
3 - Smt. Meena Nayak D/o Shri Dhaninag Aged About 52 Years R/o
Near River Side, Jabdapar New Korba ( C.G. )
4 - Smt. Sangeeta Soni @ Yogeshwari Soni D/o Shri S.L. Soni Aged
About 42 Years R/o Q. No. F-649, Block No. 82, Shanti Kranti Nagar
Oarri West Korba ( C.G. ). 495683 ( Name And Father Name Wrongly
Mentioned In Orginal Application )
5 - Naresh Kumar Yadav S/o S.L. Yadav Aged About 40 Years C/o
M/331 Ompur Roygmar Colony, P.O. Ompur Korba ( C.G. ). 495683
6 - Tulsi Ram Khairwar S/o Late Shri Kartik Ram Khairwar Aged About
48 Years C/o M/331 Ompur Roygmar Colony, P.O. Ompur Korba
( C.G. ). 495683 ( Name And Father Name Wrongly Mentioned In
Origional Application )
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through- The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through- Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal ( M.P. ). 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G. ). Pin 492-001
5 - Commssioner Of Income Tax Ayakar Bhawan, Vyapar Bihar, Bilaspur
( C.G. ). Pin No. 495-001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road, Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal ( M.P. ) Pin No. 462-011
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 10308 of 2025
1 - Shankar Lal Sahu S/o Shri Raj Kumar Sahu Aged About 48 Years
R/o Gram Ruchinda The Pusour, District Raigarh, C.G. 496001
2 - Hukum Singh Nishad S/o Shri Azad Singh Aged About 54 Years R/o
Hundi Chouk Near Gayatri Mandir District Raigarh, C.G. 496001
3 - Satish Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Jaggnnath Aged About 48 Years R/o
Near Sanjay Maidan, Raigarh, District Raigarh, C.G. 496001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi-110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal, M.P. 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur, C.G. Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan, Vyapar Vihar,
Bilaspur, District - Bilaspur, C.G. Pin No. 495-001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road, Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal, M.P. Pin No. 462-011
7 - Guru Prasad Namdeo S/o Shri Prasad Prasad Namdeo Aged About
40 Years R/o Chandni Chowk, Sonar Para, District Raigarh, C.G.
496001
8 - Radhi Kishan Nishad S/o Shri Yashvant Singh Nishad Aged About
39 Years R/o Ward No. 5, Dharamshala Gal Raigarh District Raigarh,
C.G. 496001
9 - Rajkumar Khapardha S/o Late Damodar Aged About 49 Years R/o
Nayaganj Behind Itwari Bazar, Raigarh District Raigarh, C.G. 496001
10 - Ajay Yadav S/o Laxmi Prasad Yadav Aged About 43 Years R/o
Beladula, Kamla Nagar, Raigarh District Raigarh, C.G. 496001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 11757 of 2025
1 - Santosh Mahanand S/o Bhim Raj Mahanand Aged About 49 Years
R/o Utkal Nagar, Civil Lines, New Akashwani, Raipur, District Raipur
C.G., Pin No. 492001.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block New Delhi- 110001.
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block
New Delhi- 110001.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (P C C I T), Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462011 (Not Impleaded In Original Application But Impleaded Herein)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (C C I T), Central Revenue
Building, Civil Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (C I T), Central Revenue Building,
Civil Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9736 of 2025
1 - Sanjay Kumar Gupta S/o Shri Bhagirathi Samund Aged About 52
Years R/o Laxmipur, Bilaspur Chowk Ambikapur C.G. 497001.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001.
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes, Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi- 110001.
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal M.P. 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District Raipur C.G. Pin No. 492-001.
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax, Ayakar Bhawan Vyapar Bihar,
Bilaspur C.G. Pin No. 495-001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road, Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal M.P. Pin No. 462-011.
7 - Gorelal S/o Shri Latel Prasad Yadav Aged About 43 Years R/o Boudi
Para, Sagun Garden, Ambikapur, District Surguja C.G. Pin No. 497-001.
8 - Rajeshwar Sonwani S/o Mangal Ram Aged About 30 Years R/o
Bhattapara, Bihand Hospita Ambikapur District Surguja C.G.497-001.
9 - Mohan Lal Mahanand (Died Represented Thrugh Smt. Sukhni Bai)
W/o Late Mohan Lal Mahanand Aged About 50 Years R/o Sheetla Ward
Shakti Para Near Karbala Ambikapur District Surguja C.G. 497-001
10 - Rajbeer Das S/o Late Madhu Das Aged About 44 Years R/o Christ
Milan Para, Ward No. 10, Namna Kala, Ambikapur, District- Surguja
C.G. Pin No. 497001.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 14134 of 2025
1 - Gopal Sahu S/o Manbodhram Sahu Aged About 43 Years R/o
Shivnagar, Handipara, Ward Tatyapara, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi – 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Pccit) Aayakar
Bhawan, Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.)
462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax (Ccit) Central Revenue Building,
Civil Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax (Cit) Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
6 - Joint Commissioner Of Income Tax Investigation Civil Lines Raipur
(C.G.) 492-001
7 - Additional Director Of Income Tax (Investigation) 9th Floor, Cbd
Building, Sector 21, Nawa Raipur District Raipur (C.G.) 492-001
8 - Joshi Shendre S/o Shri Badru Shendre Aged About 55 Years R/o
Pandri Gaganath Raipur (C.G.) 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 9746 of 2025
1 - Mayaram Nayak S/o Late Guru Ji Nayak Aged About 43 Years R/o
Utkal Nagar, Kundrapara, Bairan Bazar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492001
2 - Murat Lal Sarpa S/o Punau Ram Aged About 58 Years R/o Near
Math Puraena Raipur, Chhattisgarh, 492001
3 - Ravindra Kumar Mahananad S/o Kartik Ram Mahanand Aged About
45 Years R/o Behind Primary School Sardar Police Line, Raipur,
Chhattisgarh 492001
4 - Tulsi Rao S/o Shri Narsaiya Aged About 51 Years R/o New Pension
Wada, Arvind Nagar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492001
5 - Janardan Rao Mohite S/o Shri Guhri Rao Mohite Aged About 55
Years C/o Chand Ratan Singh, R/o Jhanda Chowk, Sanjay Nagar,
Tikrapara, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi, 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi, 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (Mp) 462011 (Added
Because Respondent Herein Is A Proper Party)
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh, Pin No. 492001
6 - Sekhar Singh Markam S/o Amar Singh Markam Aged About 40
Years R/o Old Pension Bada, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, 492001
7 - Santosh Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Hari Ram Sahu Aged About 43 Years
R/o Near Kalibadi, Nehru Nagar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, 492001
8 - Prahlad Singh Yadav S/o Late Pardeshi Ram Aged About 43 Years
R/o Near Dr. Vadhwani, Durga Chowk, Katora Talab, Raipur,
Chhattisgarh, 492001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8258 of 2025
1 - Sanjay Kumar Samund S/o Shri Kamlu Prasad Samund Aged About
42 Years R/o Shri Krishna Goshala, Madhuban Road, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
2 - Dharam Raj Patel S/o Shri Indramani Patel Aged About 42 Years R/o
House No.-146, Mini Mata Nagar, Talapara, Bilaspur (C.G.) 495001
3 - Dinesh Mishra S/o Shri R.K. Mishra Aged About 45 Years R/o Savitri
Bhawan, Near Pathak Bagicha, Jabdapara, Sarkanda, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi – 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi – 110001
3 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan, Hoshangabad
Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District - Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492-001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan, Vyapar Bihar ,
Bilaspur (C.G.) Pin No. 495-001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Aayakar Bhawan, Hosangabad Road,
Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) Pin No.- 462-011
7 - Shatruhan Yadav S/o Shri Judawan Yadav Aged About 41 Years C/o
Gakul Shriwas, Ramayan Chowk Tifra, Bilaspur (C.G.) 495001
8 - Prasna Singh S/o Shri Lt. Shri Govind Singh Aged About 32 Years
R/o Near River Side, Jabdapar, New Sarkanda, Bilaspur (C.G.) 495001
9 - Gokul Ram Verma S/o Dhani Ram Verma Aged About 26 Years R/o
Ram Nagar, In Front Of Sarkand Thana, Chingrajpara, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
10 - Vipin Kujur S/o Shri Nicolas Kujur Aged About 34 Years C/o
Rajkumar Yadav, Near Sheetlamata Mandir, Talapara, Bilaspur (C.G.)
495001
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 10293 of 2025
1 - Rajendra Yaduwanshi S/o Shri D.P. Yaduwanshi Aged About 56
Years Ro Sriram Chowk, Teekrapara, Raipur, (C.G.) 492001
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Union Of India Through The Secretary, Department Of Revenue,
Ministry Of Finance, North Block, New Delhi- 110001
2 - Central Board Of Direct Taxes Through Its Chairman, North Block,
New Delhi 110001
3 - Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Aayakar Bhawan,
Hoshangabad Road, Opposite Maida Mill, Bhopal (M.P.) 462011
4 - Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil
Lines, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
5 - Commissioner Of Income Tax Central Revenue Building, Civil Lines,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) Pin No. 492001
6 - Zonal Accounts Officer Ayakar Bhawan Hosangabad Road Opposite
Maida Mill Bhopal (M.P.) Pin No. 462011
7 - Ram Narayan Soni S/o Shri Late Atma Ram Soni Aged About 61
Years R/o Nathpara Subash Nagar, Raipur, C.G. 492002
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Anshuman Shrivastava, Advocate
and Ms. Rameshwari Kumari,
Advocate
For Union of India
:
Mr. Ramakant Mishra, Dy. Solicitor
General assisted by Mr. Rishabh Dev
Singh and Mr. Niraj Baghel,
Advocates
For Private
Respondents
:
Mr. Sunil Verma, Advocate
(Division Bench)
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Sanjay S. Agrawal
Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
CAV Order
07.04.2026
Per; Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
1.
Since the factual matrix and the core issues involved in the
present batch of writ petitions are substantially identical, all the
matters were heard analogously with the consent of learned
counsel for the parties and are being disposed of by this common
order.
2.
For the sake of clarity and convenience, the petitions have been
classified into two distinct categories. The first category comprises
those employees who were applicants in the Original Application
and, though they had not completed 10 years of service as on
10.04.2006, continue to remain in service. The second category
consists of those employees who were also part of the Original
Application, had not completed 10 years of service as on the said
date, and whose services were subsequently terminated abruptly.
This classification has been made to appropriately address the
nuances in their respective claims while adjudicating the common
issues involved in the present proceedings.
3.
The present batch of writ petitions has been filed by the
petitioners assailing the common order dated 11.10.2013 passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, whereby
their respective Original Applications were dismissed. The
petitioners, who were engaged as daily wage employees on
various posts such as Peon, Farrash, Sweeper, Waterman,
Chowkidar, and others between the years 1997 to 2008, contend
that despite long years of continuous service and repeated
recommendations made by the department for their regularization,
the respondents, instead of regularizing their services, issued
orders dated 04.07.2011 and 25.07.2011 introducing outsourcing
of services, followed by instructions dated 14.03.2012 for shifting
existing daily wage employees to a contractual employment
system through outsourcing agencies.
Aggrieved by the said
policy decision and consequential actions, the petitioners, along
with other similarly situated employees, approached the Central
Administrative Tribunal by filing various Original Applications,
seeking quashment of the outsourcing policy and a direction for
regularization of their services in light of the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi
(2006) 4 SCC 1, as well as on the ground that similarly situated
employees in other regions had been granted regularization.
However, all such Original Applications came to be dismissed by a
common order dated 11.10.2013. The petitioners have, therefore,
approached this Court by way of the present writ petitions
challenging the aforesaid order of the Tribunal as well as the
policy decisions dated 04.07.2011, 25.07.2011, and 14.03.2012,
contending that they are entitled to regularization from the date
they became eligible, and that the subsequent action of shifting
them to a contractual/outsourcing system is arbitrary, illegal, and
liable to be set aside. It is their case that such subsequent
developments ought to be treated as non est in the eyes of law.
4.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid repetition, the reliefs
sought in Writ Petition (S) No. 7027 of 2021 are taken as the
common reliefs prayed for by the petitioners in all the connected
matters, as the nature of grievances and the reliefs claimed
therein are substantially identical across the present batch of
petitions. In the said writ petition, the petitioners have prayed for
following reliefs :
“10.1 To call records pertaining to
Original
Application
(O.A.)
443/2012
decided
the
by
No.
Central
Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Bench at
Jabalpur;
10.2
To
pass
suitable
Direction(s)/Writ(s)/Order(s) to quash
impugned
order
dated
11.10.2013
passed in Original Application (O.A.)
No.
443/2012
passed
by
Central
Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Bench at
Jabalpur [ANNEXURE P-1);
10.3
To
pass
suitable
Direction(s)/Writ(s)/Order(s) to quash
orders dated 04.07.2011, 25.07.2011
and
instruction
dated
14.03.2012
[ANNEXURE P-2) for shifting the daily
wagers
(petitioners)
to
contractual
employment system;
10.4 To grant any other relief(s)/
order(s)/
direction(s)
in
favour
of
petitioners, which the Hon'ble Court
may deem fit and proper in the facts
and circumstances of the case, in the
interest of Justice.”
5.
The facts, as pleaded in the present bunch of petitions, reveal that
all the petitioners were initially engaged as daily wage employees
in the respondent-Income Tax department on different dates,
against Class-IV posts such. It is the consistent case of the
petitioners that they continuously discharged their duties for long
durations ranging from more than a decade to over fifteen years,
thereby rendering uninterrupted and satisfactory service to the
department. During the course of their engagement, the
respondent authorities, on several occasions, acknowledged the
services of the petitioners and even recommended their names
for regularization. In particular, reliance has been placed on
recommendation orders dated 24.01.2011, which, according to
the
petitioners,
demonstrate
a
legitimate
expectation
for
regularization of their services. It is further the common grievance
of the petitioners that in the year 2011–2012, the respondent
department initiated a policy shift by issuing orders dated
04.07.2011 and 25.07.2011, whereby services such as data entry,
typing, cleaning, and security were directed to be outsourced
through contractual agencies instead of engaging individual daily
wage workers. This was followed by a subsequent instruction
dated 14.03.2012 mandating the transition of existing daily wage
workers, including the petitioners, into a contractual employment
system through outsourcing agencies. The petitioners contend
that the aforesaid policy decisions were arbitrary, illegal, and
detrimental to their service conditions, as they effectively deprived
them of any opportunity for regularization despite long years of
service.
Aggrieved by the said orders and instructions, the
petitioners, along with similarly situated employees, approached
the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, by filing
Original Applications, challenging the validity of the outsourcing
policy and seeking directions for regularization of their services.
However, the Tribunal, by a common order dated 11.10.2013,
dismissed the said applications along with other connected
matters. The petitioners assert that despite dismissal of their
claims by the Tribunal, they did not abandon their demand for
regularization and continued to assert that the shift to a
contractual employment system through outsourcing agencies
was illegal and arbitrary. It is the further case of the petitioners
that, pursuant to the aforesaid policy, they were compelled to work
under contractors appointed by the respondent department, albeit
under protest. While some of the petitioners continued in such
contractual
arrangements
for
several
years,
others
were
subjected to adverse consequences. In certain cases forming part
of the present bunch, it is alleged that the petitioners were orally
and illegally terminated from service around April 2017, without
issuance of any formal order or adherence to due process of law.
Such termination, according to the petitioners, was punitive in
nature and a direct consequence of their resistance to the
outsourcing policy and their continued demand for regularization.
Following their alleged termination, the affected petitioners raised
industrial disputes under the provisions of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947. Conciliation proceedings were initiated by the
appropriate Government under Section 12 of the Act; however,
the same culminated in failure reports dated 20.06.2018.
Consequently, references were made under Section 10 of the Act
for adjudication of the disputes. The petitioners maintain that even
during this period, they consistently pursued their claim for
regularization, asserting that their long and continuous service
entitled them to such consideration. It has also been brought on
record that certain similarly situated employees, who were parties
to the earlier proceedings before the CAT, have challenged the
Tribunal’s order dated 11.10.2013 before the High Court of M.P.
and Chhattisgarh and thereafter, before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India, and such proceedings are stated to be pending
consideration.
6.
Thus, across the present group of writ petitions, the common factual
matrix discloses a uniform grievance arising out of long-term
engagement
of
recommendations
the
petitioners
made
for
as
their
daily
wage
employees,
regularization,
subsequent
introduction of an outsourcing policy replacing such engagement with
contractual employment, dismissal of their challenge by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, and continued assertion of their right to
regularization, coupled with allegations of illegal termination in certain
cases. The petitioners, therefore, filed these writ petitions before this
Court on the basis of the aforesaid common set of facts and
grievances.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits, at the outset, that the
petitioners have been continuously engaged by the respondent
department between the years 1997 and 2008 on daily wage
basis for performing essential and perennial duties such as
Waterman, Sweeper, Farash and Peon, which are indispensable
for the day-to-day functioning of the department. It is contended
that this foundational fact is not even disputed by the respondents
in their reply, particularly in paragraph nos. 2 and 3, thereby
establishing that the petitioners were not engaged for any
sporadic or temporary work but were discharging regular and
continuous functions akin to those performed by regular
employees. It is further submitted that despite extracting work of
permanent nature for long years, the respondent department
deliberately chose not to regularize the services of the petitioners
and, instead, in the year 2013, compelled them to work through
outsourcing agencies, thereby perpetuating their precarious
employment and denying them legitimate service benefits. The
learned counsel submits that the petitioners had approached the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, by filing Original
Applications in the years 2011 and 2012 seeking regularization of
their services. However, the Tribunal vide common order dated
11.10.2013 dismissed their claims solely on the ground that the
petitioners had not completed ten years of service as on
10.04.2006, as contemplated in paragraph 53 of the judgment in
State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi. It is submitted that the said
reasoning of the Tribunal is now no longer sustainable in view of
subsequent
authoritative
pronouncements
of
the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court, which have clarified and expanded the scope of
regularization,
particularly
in
cases
involving
long-serving
employees engaged in irregular, but not illegal, appointments.
Elaborating further, the learned counsel places strong reliance on
the recent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pawan
Kumar vs. Union of India, wherein the Apex Court has
categorically set aside a similar order passed by the Tribunal and
directed regularization of similarly situated employees, even
though they had not completed ten years of service as on
10.04.2006. It is submitted that the present petitioners stand on
identical footing and, therefore, are entitled to the same relief. The
learned counsel further submits that the benefit of such judgment
cannot be denied to the present petitioners, particularly when they
had already approached the Tribunal prior to the pronouncement
of the said judgment, and thus cannot be treated as fence-sitters
or persons seeking belated advantage. The learned counsel also
relies upon the principle of parity as laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Arvind Kumar
Shrivastava, more specifically paragraph 22.1 thereof, to contend
that when a set of employees similarly situated has been granted
relief by the Court, all other identically placed employees are
entitled to the same treatment. It is submitted that the present
petitioners had already asserted their rights by filing Original
Applications and, therefore, their case does not fall under any
exception to the said principle. The denial of similar benefit would
amount to hostile discrimination and violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. The learned counsel further submits that the
High Court of Madhya Pradesh, in a similar matter, has set aside
the impugned order of the Tribunal in Smt. Jayanti Nihal vs.
Union of India, relying upon the judgments in Ravi Verma vs.
Union of India and Ashok Kumar Verma vs. Union of India,
thereby granting relief to similarly placed employees. It is
submitted that these judgments clearly demonstrate a consistent
judicial approach towards granting regularization to long-serving
employees who have been subjected to unfair labour practices by
the State. On the issue of delay and laches, the learned counsel
submits that the petitioners cannot be non-suited on this ground,
as they had approached the Tribunal at the earliest point of time
when they were in service. It is further submitted that even after
dismissal of their Original Applications, the petitioners continued
to work under the respondent department through outsourcing
arrangements and were given oral assurances that their cases
would be considered for regularization. The petitioners, therefore,
never abandoned their claim and cannot be treated as having
acquiesced to their status. In support of this contention, reliance is
placed on the observations made by the High Court in Ashok
Kumar Verma vs. Union of India, wherein it has been held that
such petitioners cannot be categorized as fence-sitters merely
because they could not pursue litigation continuously.
The
learned counsel further submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Jaggo vs. Union of India has categorically held that long-
serving employees performing essential duties cannot be denied
regularization on technical grounds, and that the principles laid
down in Uma Devi’s case have often been misinterpreted to deny
legitimate claims. It is submitted that the Apex Court has drawn a
clear distinction between illegal and irregular appointments and
has held that employees in irregular appointments, who have
rendered long years of service, deserve to be regularized. The
learned counsel emphasizes that the petitioners’ appointments
were, at best, irregular and not illegal, and therefore fall within the
zone of consideration for regularization. Further reliance is placed
on the judgment in Raman Kumar vs. Union of India, wherein
the Hon’ble Supreme Court directed creation of supernumerary
posts for the purpose of regularization, thereby negating the
contention of the State regarding non-availability of sanctioned
posts. Similarly, in Jivanlal vs. Pravin Kishan, the Apex Court
has held that there cannot be a pick-and-choose policy in matters
of regularization and that similarly situated employees must be
treated alike. The learned counsel also places reliance on the
recent judgment in Bholanath vs. State of Jharkhand, wherein it
has been held that the State cannot rely upon contractual
stipulations or the nomenclature of engagement to deny
regularization after extracting work for long years, and that such
action is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
8.
It is submitted that the ratio of the said judgment squarely applies
to the present case, where the petitioners have been continued
for decades and then subjected to outsourcing without any
justification. On the issue of abrupt termination and its effect, the
learned counsel submits that similarly situated employee, namely
Naresh Kumar Yadav, who was terminated, was granted relief by
the High Court and subsequently regularized by the department.
This clearly establishes that the respondent department itself has
extended the benefit of regularization in identical circumstances,
and denial of the same to the present petitioners would amount to
discrimination. It is, therefore, prayed that the present petitions be
allowed and appropriate directions be issued to the respondents
to regularize the services of the petitioners with all consequential
benefits.
9.
Mr. Ramakant Mishra, Dy. Solicitor General, opposing the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners, would submit
that the present writ petitions are wholly misconceived, devoid of
merit, and deserves to be dismissed at the very threshold. It is
contended that the petitioners are seeking regularization of their
services in complete disregard of the settled constitutional and
legal principles governing public employment, as authoritatively
laid down by the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi, which continues to
hold the field as binding precedent under Article 141 of the
Constitution of India. At the outset, the learned counsel submits
that the petitioners do not fulfil the essential conditions for
regularization as carved out in
Uma Devi (supra) and
subsequently clarified in State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari. It is
submitted that the exception to the general rule against
regularization is extremely limited and applies only where (i) the
employee has completed ten years or more of continuous service
as on 10.04.2006, (ii) such service was rendered against duly
sanctioned posts, and (iii) the appointment was irregular but not
illegal. The respondents submit that none of these conditions are
satisfied in the present case. As per the undisputed record, the
petitioners were engaged between 2002 and 2004 and, therefore,
had not completed ten years of service as on the cut-off date i.e.
10.04.2006. Further, their engagement was not against any
sanctioned posts and was purely casual in nature. Consequently,
their appointments fall within the category of “illegal appointments”
as defined in Uma Devi (Supra), and thus are not amenable to
regularization under any circumstances.
The learned counsel
further submits that the issue raised by the petitioners is no longer
res integra, having already been adjudicated upon by the learned
Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, in Original
Application and connected matters, which were dismissed vide
order dated 11.10.2013. The Tribunal, after detailed consideration
of the law laid down in Uma Devi (Supra) and M.L. Kesari
(Supra), categorically held that the petitioners were not entitled to
regularization as they had failed to meet the prescribed criteria.
The present writ petition is nothing but a collateral challenge to
the said concluded adjudication, which cannot be permitted in law.
It is further submitted that the engagement of the petitioners was
purely temporary and on daily wage basis, made to meet
emergent and contingent requirements of the department, without
following any recruitment rules or constitutional procedure. Such
engagement was never intended to confer any right of
permanency. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Uma Devi (Supra)
has unequivocally held that adherence to the constitutional
scheme of public employment under Articles 14 and 16 is a basic
feature of the Constitution, and any appointment made dehors the
said scheme cannot be regularized by judicial fiat. The learned
counsel emphasizes that mere continuance in service, even for a
long duration, does not create any vested right to regularization,
particularly when the initial engagement itself was not in
accordance with law. The learned counsel further submits that
the Government of India, through the Department of Personnel
and Training (DoP&T), has issued clear and binding guidelines,
including Office Memoranda dated 11.12.2006 and 07.10.2020,
for implementation of the principles laid down in Uma Devi
(Supra)
and
M.L.
Kesari
(Supra).
These
instructions
categorically prohibit engagement of casual workers for work of
regular nature and mandate that regularization can only be
considered as a one-time measure for those who fulfil the strict
criteria laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is submitted
that the respondent department has duly complied with these
directions and undertook the one-time exercise in the year 2011 to
consider eligible cases. Since the petitioners did not satisfy the
eligibility conditions, their cases were rightly not considered. The
learned counsel also submits that the decision to outsource
certain services in the year 2013 was taken in accordance with
established
governmental
policy,
financial
prudence,
and
administrative efficiency. The same was in line with DoP&T
guidelines and provisions of the General Financial Rules, and
such policy decisions have consistently been upheld by Courts.
The
petitioners,
having
accepted
engagement
through
outsourcing agencies and continued to work under such
arrangements for several years, cannot now turn around and
challenge the same. The plea that they were working “under
protest” is vague, unsubstantiated, and devoid of any legal
consequence. Responding to the reliance placed by the
petitioners on subsequent judgments such as Pawan Kumar
(Supra), Ravi Verma (Supra), Jaggo (Supra), and others, the
learned counsel submits that none of these judgments dilute or
override the binding ratio of the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi
(Supra). It is a settled principle of judicial discipline that a
judgment rendered by a larger bench prevails over decisions of
smaller benches.
10.
The learned counsel submits that the Constitution Bench
judgment in Uma Devi (Supra) lays down the governing
principles on the issue of regularization, and any subsequent
decision must be read in conformity with the said binding
precedent. The petitioners cannot selectively rely on later
judgments to circumvent the clear mandate of Uma Devi (Supra).
The learned counsel further contends that the petitioners’
argument based on Articles 14 and 16 is misconceived. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has categorically held that there can be
no equality in illegality, and a claim for parity cannot be founded
on instances where others may have been granted relief
erroneously or under different factual circumstances. Similarly, the
doctrine of legitimate expectation is wholly inapplicable in the
present case, as the petitioners were fully aware of the temporary
and casual nature of their engagement at the time of acceptance,
and no promise of regularization was ever extended by the
respondents.
It is also submitted that the allegation of abrupt
termination is factually incorrect. Since the year 2013, the
petitioners were engaged through service providers, and any
discontinuation of their services was effected by such agencies in
terms of contractual arrangements. The petitioners were never
employees of the respondent department in the legal sense and,
therefore, cannot claim any right against the respondents. The
learned counsel further emphasizes that the constitutional
scheme does not envisage regularization as a mode of
recruitment. Any direction to regularize the petitioners would
amount to bypassing the established recruitment process, thereby
depriving other eligible candidates of their right to compete for
public employment. Such a course would be in direct violation of
Articles 14 and 16 and contrary to the rule of law. In conclusion,
the learned counsel submits that the petitioners have failed to
establish any enforceable legal right for regularization. Their
engagement being purely casual, not against sanctioned posts,
and not in conformity with the constitutional scheme, disentitles
them from any relief. The present petitions are, therefore, liable to
be dismissed as being devoid of merit, barred by settled principles
of law, and amounting to an impermissible attempt to reopen
issues already adjudicated by the Tribunal.
Finding and Decision on First Category i.e. employees who
continue to remain in service
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and upon
perusal of the pleadings, documents and material available on
record, this Court proceeds to adjudicate the present batch of
petitions, in so far as they relate to the first category of petitioners,
namely those who, though they had not completed ten years of
service as on 10.04.2006, are continuing in service till date, either
directly or through outsourcing arrangements.
12.
At the outset, it is not in dispute that the petitioners were engaged
between the years 1997 to 2008 and have been discharging
duties of perennial and essential nature such as Peon, Farrash,
Sweeper, Chowkidar, Waterman, etc. It is also an admitted
position that most of the petitioners are still working, albeit under
changed nomenclature or through outsourcing agencies. The
continuity of service, the nature of duties performed, and the
necessity of such work for the functioning of the department stand
established from the record. The principal ground on which the
Central Administrative Tribunal rejected the claim of the
petitioners was their failure to complete ten years of service as on
10.04.2006, as contemplated in paragraph 53 of the Constitution
Bench judgment in State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi, (2006) 4
SCC 1.
13.
The issue, therefore, which arises for consideration is whether
such a rigid application of the cut-off date still holds the field in
light of subsequent judicial pronouncements. This Court is
conscious of the law laid down in Uma Devi (supra), wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that regularization cannot be a mode
of recruitment and carved out a one-time exception for those who
had completed ten years of service as on 10.04.2006 in duly
sanctioned posts. However, the evolution of law post Uma Devi
demonstrates that the said judgment has been clarified, explained
and distinguished in several later decisions, particularly in cases
where employees have rendered long and continuous service in
irregular, but not illegal, appointments.
14.
In State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari, (2010) 9 SCC 247, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court clarified that the benefit of regularization
is not to be denied on hyper-technical grounds and that the onetime exercise contemplated in Uma Devi must be applied in a
pragmatic manner. The Court emphasized that if employees have
continued for long years and the State has taken work from them,
the authorities are under an obligation to consider their cases
fairly. It was held as under :
“5. The decision in State of Karnataka
v. 22 Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1 was
rendered on 10.04.2006. In that case, a
Constitution Bench of this Court held
that
appointments
made
without
following the due process or the rules
relating to appointment did not confer
any right on the appointees and courts
cannot
direct
their
absorption,
regularization or re- engagement nor
make their service permanent, and the
High Court in exercise of jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution
should not ordinarily issue directions for
absorption,
permanent
regularization,
continuance
unless
or
the
recruitment had been done in a regular
manner, in terms of the constitutional
scheme; and that the courts must be
careful in ensuring that they do not
interfere unduly with the economic
arrangement of its affairs by the State
or
its
instrumentalities,
themselves
facilitate
to
the
be
nor
lend
instruments
bypassing
of
to
the
constitutional and statutory mandates.
6. This Court in Umadevi (supra) further
held that a temporary, contractual,
casual or a daily-wage employee does
not have a legal right to be made
permanent
unless
he
had
been
appointed in terms of the relevant rules
or in adherence of Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution. This Court however
made one exception to the above
position and the same is extracted
below:
"53. One aspect needs to be
clarified. There may be cases where
irregular
appointments
(not
illegal
appointments) as explained in [S.V.
Narayanappa [1967 (1) SCR 128], R.N.
Nanjundappa [1972 (1) SCC 409] and
B.N. Nagarajan [1979 (4) SCC 507] and
referred to in para 15 above, of duly
qualified persons in duly sanctioned
vacant posts might have been made
and the employees have continued to
work for ten years or more but without
the intervention of orders of the courts
or
of
tribunals.
The
question
of
regularization of the services of such
employees may have to be considered
on merits in the light of the principles
settled by this Court in the cases
abovereferred to and in the light of this
judgment. In that context, the Union of
India, the State Governments and their
instrumentalities should take steps to
regularize as a one-time measure, the
services of such irregularly appointed,
who have worked for ten years or more
in duly sanctioned posts but not under
cover of orders of the courts or of
tribunals and should further ensure that
regular recruitments are undertaken to
fill those vacant sanctioned posts that
require to be filled up, in cases where
temporary employees or daily wagers
are being now employed. The process
must be set in motion within six months
from this date...."
7. It is evident from the above that there
is an exception to the general principles
against 'regularization' enunciated in
Umadevi, if the following conditions are
fulfilled:
(i) The employee concerned should
have worked for 10 years or more in
duly sanctioned post without the benefit
or protection of the interim order of any
court or tribunal. In other words, the
State Government or its instrumentality
should have employed the employee
and continued him in service voluntarily
and continuously for more than ten
years.
(ii) The appointment of such employee
should not be illegal, even if irregular.
Where the appointments are not made
or continued against sanctioned posts
or where the persons appointed do not
possess
the
prescribed
minimum
qualifications, the appointments will be
considered to be illegal. But where the
person
employed
prescribed
possessed
qualifications
the
and
was
working against sanctioned posts, but
had been selected without undergoing
the
process
selection,
of
open
such
competitive
appointments
are
considered to be irregular.
8. Umadevi (supra) casts a duty upon
the
concerned
Government
or
take
to
instrumentality,
to
regularize
services
the
steps
of
those
irregularly appointed employees who
had served for more than ten years
without the benefit or protection of any
interim orders of courts or tribunals, as
a one-time measure. Umadevi, directed
that such one-time measure must be
set in motion within six months from the
date of its decision (rendered on
10.4.2006).
9. The term 'one-time measure' has to
be understood in its proper perspective.
This would normally mean that after the
decision in Umadevi, each department
or
each
instrumentality
should
undertake a one-time exercise and
prepare a list of all casual, daily-wage
or ad hoc employees who have been
working for more than ten years without
the intervention of courts and tribunals
and
subject
them
to
a
process
verification as to whether they are
working against vacant posts and
possess the requisite qualification for
the post and if so, regularize their
services.”
15.
Besides the aforesaid aspects, we find that the law laid down by
this Court in Jaggo Vs. Union of India, reported in (2024) SCC
OnLine SC 3826 supports the case of the petitioners in their
prayer for regularization. In paragraphs 13, 20, 21 and 26, it has
been held as under:
“13. The claim by the respondents that
these were not regular posts lacks
merit, as the nature of the work
performed
by
the
appellants
perennial
and
fundamental
was
to
the
functioning of the offices. The recurring
nature of these duties necessitates their
classification
irrespective
as
of
regular
how
their
posts,
initial
engagements were labelled. It is also
noteworthy
that
subsequent
outsourcing of these same tasks to
private agencies after the appellants'
termination demonstrates the inherent
need for these services. This act of
outsourcing, which effectively replaced
one set of workers with another, further
underscores that the work in question
was neither temporary nor occasional.
20. It is well established that the
decision in Uma Devi (supra) does not
intend to penalize employees who have
rendered long years of service fulfilling
ongoing and necessary functions of the
State or its instrumentalities. The said
judgment sought to prevent backdoor
entries and illegal appointments that
circumvent constitutional requirements.
However, where appointments were not
illegal but possibly “irregular,” and
where
employees
had
served
continuously against the backdrop of
sanctioned functions for a considerable
period, the need for a fair and humane
resolution
becomes
Prolonged,
paramount.
continuous,
and
unblemished service performing tasks
inherently required on a regular basis
can, over the time, transform what was
initially ad-hoc or temporary into a
scenario demanding fair regularization.
In a recent judgment of this Court in
Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, it was
held
that
held
that
procedural
formalities cannot be used to deny
regularization of service to an employee
whose
appointment
was
termed
“temporary” but has performed the
same duties as performed by the
regular employee over a considerable
period in the capacity of the regular
employee. The relevant paras of this
judgment have been reproduced below:
“6.
The
application
of
the
judgment in Uma Devi (supra) by
the High Court does not fit
squarely with the facts at hand,
given the specific circumstances
under which the appellants were
employed and have continued
their service. The reliance on
procedural
outset
formalities
cannot
perpetually
be
deny
at
the
used
to
substantive
rights that have accrued over a
considerable
period
through
continuous
service.
Their
promotion
was
based
on
a
specific notification for vacancies
and
a
subsequent
circular,
followed by a selection process
involving
written
interviews, which
tests
and
distinguishes
their case from the appointments
through
back
door
entry
as
discussed in the case of Uma
Devi (supra).
7. The judgment in the case Uma
Devi (supra) also distinguished
between “irregular” and “illegal”
appointments underscoring the
importance of considering certain
appointments even if were not
made strictly in accordance with
the
prescribed
Rules
and
Procedure, cannot be said to
have been made illegally if they
had followed the procedures of
regular appointments such as
conduct of written examinations
or interviews as in the present
case…”
21. The High Court placed undue
emphasis on the initial label of the
appellants'
engagements
and
the
outsourcing decision taken after their
dismissal. Courts must look beyond the
surface labels and consider the realities
of employment : continuous, long-term
service,
indispensable
duties,
and
absence of any mala fide or illegalities
in their appointments. In that light,
refusing regularization simply because
their original terms did not explicitly
state so, or because an outsourcing
policy was belatedly introduced, would
be contrary to principles of fairness and
equity.
26. While the judgment in Uma Devi
(supra) sought to curtail the practice of
backdoor
entries
and
ensure
appointments adhered to constitutional
principles, it is regrettable that its
principles are often misinterpreted or
misapplied to deny legitimate claims of
long-serving employees. This judgment
aimed to distinguish between “illegal”
and
“irregular”
appointments.
It
categorically held that employees in
irregular
appointments,
who
were
engaged in duly sanctioned posts and
had served continuously for more than
ten years, should be considered for
regularization as a one-time measure.
However, the laudable intent of the
judgment is being subverted when
institutions
rely
on
its
dicta
to
indiscriminately reject the claims of
employees, even in cases where their
appointments are not illegal, but merely
lack
adherence
to
procedural
formalities. Government departments
often cite the judgment in Uma Devi
(supra) to argue that no vested right to
regularization
exists
for
temporary
employees, overlooking the judgment's
explicit
acknowledgment
of
cases
where regularization is appropriate.
This selective application distorts the
judgment's
spirit
and
effectively
weaponizing
employees
who
have
purpose,
it
against
rendered
indispensable services over decades.”
16.
In addition, in Pawan Kumar and Others vs. Union of India and
Others, reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 200, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, while considering the issue of regularization, has
considered and distinguished the law laid down in Uma Devi and
has granted relief to similarly situated employees, even though
they did not strictly fulfil the condition of ten years of service as on
10.04.2006. The said judgment clearly indicates that Uma Devi
cannot be applied in a mechanical or pedantic manner so as to
defeat the legitimate claims of employees who have rendered
long and continuous service. It was held thus :
“4. According
to
Department,
the
appellants
the
Income
services
are
not
liable
Tax
of
the
to
be
regularized since their eligibility in terms
of the decision of the Constitution Bench
in Umadevi (supra) of having rendered
continuous service for ten years or more
as on 10.04.2006 was not satisfied by
them. In absence of any sanctioned post
available at Gwalior, their services were
not
liable
to
be
regularized.
The
engagement of the appellants was
merely of a casual nature and their
services
were
subsequently
engaged
through
a
being
contractor
on
contractual basis. It is, thus, the case of
the Income Tax Department that the
Tribunal and thereafter, the High Court
having rightly denied relief to the
appellants, there was no reason to
interfere with that adjudication.
5. We have heard the learned counsel
for the parties and we have also
perused the documents on record.
Having considered the matter in detail,
we are of the view that the services of
the
appellants
are
liable
to
be
regularized as they are similarly
situated as other daily-wage workers
in the Income Tax Department, whose
services have been regularized pursuant
to various orders passed by this Court.”
17.
High Court of Madhya Pradesh in a similar matter of Jayanti
Nihal vs. Union of India and Others passed in Misc. Petition
No. 5182/2025 vide order dated 17.11.2025, considered and
allowed claim for regularization while setting aside order dated
11.10.2013 passed by C.A.T. in O. A. No. 713/2011.
18.
The cumulative effect of the aforesaid judgments is that where
(i) the employees have rendered long and continuous service, (ii)
their appointments are not illegal but at best irregular, (iii) the work
performed is of perennial nature, and (iv) similarly situated
employees have already been granted relief by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, denial of regularization would amount to hostile
discrimination and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
19.
The undisputed factual position which emerges from the pleadings
is that the petitioners were engaged between the years 1997 to
2008 and have continuously discharged duties of perennial and
indispensable
nature,
such
as
Peon,
Farrash,
Sweeper,
Chowkidar, Waterman, etc. It is equally not in dispute that the
work performed by them has not ceased; rather, the same
continues even today, albeit under the guise of outsourcing. The
continuity of work and the necessity of such functions for the dayto-day
functioning
of
the
department
stand
conclusively
established.
20.
The sole ground on which the claim of the petitioners came to be
rejected by the Central Administrative Tribunal was that they had
not completed ten years of service as on the cut-off date i.e.
10.04.2006, as contemplated in paragraph 53 of the Constitution
Bench judgment in Uma Devi (Supra). The question, therefore,
which arises for consideration is whether such a rigid and
mechanical application of the said cut-off date can be sustained in
law, particularly in light of subsequent judicial pronouncements.
21.
This Court is conscious of the binding nature of the judgment in
Uma Devi (supra), which laid down that regularization cannot be
a mode of recruitment and carved out a limited one-time
exception. However, it would be an incomplete reading of the said
judgment to treat the cut-off date of ten years as an inflexible and
absolute bar, divorced from the factual realities of each case. The
subsequent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in M.L.
Kesari (Supra), has authoritatively clarified that the one-time
exercise contemplated in Uma Devi is to be applied in a pragmatic
and purposive manner. The Court emphasized that the benefit of
regularization cannot be denied on hyper-technical grounds,
particularly where employees have been continued for long years
and the State has taken work from them without interruption. The
underlying principle is one of fairness and non-arbitrariness in
State action.
22.
The
jurisprudence
which
has
evolved
thereafter
clearly
demonstrates that the emphasis has shifted from a rigid cut-off
approach to a more equitable consideration of long and
continuous service.
23.
In the present case, the respondents have failed to demonstrate
that the initial engagement of the petitioners was tainted by
illegality in the sense of being contrary to statutory provisions or
vitiated by fraud. At best, the appointments can be termed as
“irregular”, having been made without following the full rigour of
recruitment rules. Such appointments, as recognized in Uma Devi
itself, fall within the permissible zone for consideration of
regularization. The reliance placed by the respondents on the
non-fulfilment of the ten-year condition as on 10.04.2006,
therefore, cannot be accepted as a determinative factor. The said
requirement cannot be read in isolation so as to defeat the
substantive rights which have accrued to the petitioners by virtue
of their long and continuous service extending over decades.
24.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the recent decision in Pawan
Kumar (Supra), has categorically held that even where
employees did not strictly satisfy the condition of ten years of
service as on 10.04.2006, they cannot be denied regularization if
they are otherwise similarly situated and have rendered long
service. The Court,
in
unmistakable
terms,
rejected
the
mechanical application of Uma Devi (supra) and granted relief to
such employees. The ratio of the aforesaid judgment squarely
applies to the facts of the present case. The petitioners herein
stand on identical footing, having rendered long years of service
and having been subjected to the same policy of outsourcing
instead of being regularized.
25.
The contention of the respondents that the petitioners have
accepted outsourcing arrangements and are therefore disentitled
to relief is devoid of merit. The material on record indicates that
such arrangements were imposed upon the petitioners, leaving
them with no real choice but to continue working in order to
sustain their livelihood. Acceptance under compulsion cannot be
equated with waiver of constitutional rights. Equally untenable is
the argument that the petitioners do not hold any sanctioned
posts.
26.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in cases involving similarly situated
persons, has passed orders directing regularization of services.
Further, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh as well as this Court
have also passed orders in line with the principles laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, thereby allowing the prayer for
regularization in analogous matters.
27.
Another significant aspect which cannot be ignored is that the
respondent department itself had recommended the names of the
petitioners for regularization, as evident from the documents
placed on record,
particularly the recommendation dated
24.01.2011. Such recommendation gives rise to a legitimate
expectation that their cases would be considered fairly and not
rejected on technical grounds. The action of the respondents in
introducing an outsourcing policy, despite the existence of longserving employees performing the same duties, also appears to
be arbitrary. As observed in Jaggo (supra), outsourcing of
perennial work after disengaging existing workers only reinforces
the fact that the work is of a permanent nature and cannot be
treated as casual or temporary.
28.
The cumulative effect of the aforesaid discussion leads this Court
to the inescapable conclusion that the ground of non-completion
of ten years of service as on 10.04.2006 cannot, by itself, be a
valid or sustainable ground to deny regularization to the
petitioners, particularly when they have rendered considerable
length of continuous service, their appointments are not illegal,
and the work performed by them is of perennial nature. The
approach adopted by the Central Administrative Tribunal in
rejecting the claims of the petitioners solely on the basis of the
aforesaid cut-off date is, therefore, found to be overly technical,
mechanical, and contrary to the evolved principles of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
29.
Accordingly, this Court holds that the petitioners belonging to the
first category are entitled to consideration for regularization of
their services, notwithstanding the fact that they had not
completed ten years of service as on 10.04.2006.
Finding and Decision on Second Category i.e. Employees
Whose Services Were Abruptly Terminated
30.
This Court now proceeds to examine the case of the second
category of petitioners, namely those employees who were initially
engaged in the same manner as the first category, had
approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, but whose
services were subsequently terminated abruptly, in many cases
without any written order, notice, or compliance with due process
of law.
31.
At the outset, it must be stated that the mere dismissal of the
Original Applications by the Tribunal cannot operate as an
absolute bar to the grant of relief in the present writ petitions,
particularly when the legal position has undergone substantial
evolution thereafter and when the impugned action of termination
itself gives rise to a fresh and independent cause of action.
32.
The principal contention advanced on behalf of the respondents is
that since the petitioners had already approached the Tribunal
and their claims stood rejected vide order dated 11.10.2013, the
issue has attained finality. This submission, though attractive at
first blush, cannot be accepted in law.
The Hon’ble Supreme
Court has consistently held that dismissal of earlier proceedings
does not preclude reconsideration where (i) subsequent events
have occurred, (ii) law has evolved, or (iii) the cause of action is
recurring or continuous in nature. In the present case, all three
conditions stand satisfied, particularly in view of the subsequent
judgments in Ravi Verma, Raman Kumar, and Pawan Kumar,
which have substantially clarified and expanded the scope of
regularization beyond the rigid interpretation adopted earlier.
33.
More importantly, the claim of the petitioners in this category is not
merely for regularization simpliciter, but is also founded upon the
illegality of their abrupt termination, which is alleged to have been
carried out orally and without adherence to any procedure known
to law. In this regard, the law is well settled that termination of
long-serving employees without due process is arbitrary and
violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Even in
cases of temporary or daily wage employees, the State is not
absolved of its obligation to act fairly, reasonably, and in
accordance with law.
34.
In Ravi Verma vs. Union of India, (2018 SCC OnLine SC 3860),
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while dealing with an identical
situation where the claims of employees had been rejected by the
Tribunal as well as the High Court, set aside both the orders and
granted regularization, holding that denial of such benefit despite
long years of service amounted to discrimination. The Court
observed:
13. In view of the aforesaid decision,
the circulars and regularization of the
similarly situated employees at other
places and various recommendation
that were made the services of the
appellants
ought
to
have
been
regularized
in
the
year
2006;
has
been
discriminatory
treatment
meted out to them. As per the decision
of Uma Devi (supra), they were entitled
to regularization of services; they did
not serve under the cover of court's
order. Illegality has been committed by
not directing regularization of services.
14. We direct that the services of the
appellants be regularised w.e.f. 1st July
2006 they are entitled to consequential
benefit also let the respondents comply
with the order in a period of three
months from today.
15. The judgments and orders of the
High Court and the CAT are set
aside. The appeals are allowed to the
aforesaid extent.”
35.
The aforesaid judgment is of direct relevance, as it unequivocally
demonstrates that an order of the Tribunal rejecting the claim
does not foreclose the jurisdiction of constitutional courts to grant
appropriate relief where injustice is demonstrated.
36.
The principle has been reiterated in Raman Kumar vs. Union of
India, (2023 SCC OnLine SC 1018), wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, following Ravi Verma, extended the benefit of
regularization to similarly situated employees and held that
selective denial of regularization is violative of Article 14. It was
held:
“8. Indisputably, the appellants herein
have completed service of more than
ten years. Even this Court in the case
of Ravi Verma v. Union of India (Civil
Appeal
No(s).2795-2796
of
2018)
decided on 13.03.2018 found that the
act of regularizing the services of some
employees and not regularizing the
services of the others is discriminatory
and violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.”
37.
This judgment clearly reinforces that substantive rights cannot be
defeated merely on the basis of earlier adjudication, particularly
when parity and equality principles are attracted.
38.
Further, in State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Arvind Kumar Srivastava,
(2015) 1 SCC 347, the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down the
doctrine of parity and non-discrimination, holding that once relief
is granted to one set of employees, the same cannot be denied to
others identically situated. The relevant principle are extracted as
under :
“22.1. The normal rule is that when a
particular set of employees is given
relief by the court, all other identically
situated persons need to be treated
alike by extending that benefit. Not
doing
so
would
amount
to
discrimination and would be violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
This principle needs to be applied in
service matters more emphatically as
the service jurisprudence evolved by
this Court from time to time postulates
that all similarly situated persons should
be treated similarly. Therefore, the
normal rule would be that merely
because
other
similarly
situated
persons did not approach the Court
earlier, they are not to be treated
differently.”
39.
High Court of Madhya Pradesh in the matter of Smt. Jayanti
Nihal vs. Union of India and Others passed in Misc. Petiton
No. 5182 vide order dated 17.11.2025, the Division Bench has
held as under :
“1. This petition has been filed against
the order dated 11.10.2013 (Annexure
P-1) passed in O.A No. 713/2011,
whereby
bunch
of
O.As
were
dismissed.
2. Arising out of the same common
order, some of the applicants have
approached this Court by M.P No.
1626/2024 (Ashok Kumar Verma Vs.
Union of India), M.P No. 1627/2024
(Krishna Swamy Vs. Union of India),
M.P
No.
1660/2024
(Shatrughan
Mahanand & others Vs. Union of India)
and M.P No. 1541/2015 (Sanjay Kumar
Tiwari Vs. Union of India & others). Vide
order dated 31st July, 2025 (Annexure
P-5), this Court has allowed the
miscellaneous petitions by directing the
respondents to grant the same benefit
as has been granted by the Apex Court
in case of Ravi Verma & others Vs.
Union of India in Civil Appeal No. 27952796
of
(Annexure
P-3);
therefore, the petitioner is also entitled
for the same benefit.
In view of the above, present petition is
allowed and impugned order dated
11.10.2013 (Annexure P-1) passed in
O.A No. 713/2011 is set aside. The
order passed in Civil Appeal No. 27952796 of 2018 (Ravi Verma & others Vs.
Union of India) shall also apply mutatis
mutandis in the present petition.”
40.
Further in the matter of Ashok Kumar Verma vs. Union of India,
the Division Bench of High Court of Madhya Pradesh, vide order
dated 31.07.2025 passed in Misc. Petition No. 1626 of 2024,
has held as under :
“10. The next judgment of the Supreme
Court that has been relied upon by
learned counsel for the petitioners is
Shripal and another vs. Nagar Nigam,
Ghaziabad (Civil Appeal No.8157/2024)
with specific reference to para no.14
where, the Supreme Court expressing
its views on the employers reliance on
the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Umadevi whereby a stand was taken
that the daily wage or temporary
employees cannot claim permanent
absorption in the absence of statutory
rules, the Supreme Court held that
Umadevi's
judgment
distinguishes
between appointments that are illegal
and those which are irregular and went
on to elucidate that those appointments
which are irregular were eligible for
regularization
if
conditions.
More
they
met
certain
importantly,
the
Supreme Court held "Umadevi cannot
serve as a shield to justify exploited
engagements
persisting
for
without
employer
undertaking
the
years
legitimate recruitment. The view taken
by the Supreme Court assumes great
importance in the Indian society when
the
State
appoints
persons
on
temporary basis in order to oversee
temporary. exigencies, but, which the
Supreme Court has observed, can take
on exploitative forms also. Therefore, in
view of what has been argued before
this
Court
and
considered
as
hereinabove, this Court is of the
opinion that though there is a delay
of almost 11 or 12 years from the
date
on
which
their
original
application before the Tribunal was
dismissed, the petitioners had at
least exercised their rights to seek
relief would demonstrate that they
had never acquiesced to their status
of temporary employment as daily
wagers and did desire regularization.
Their inability to go further up does not
make them fence-sitters as those would
fall in the category of persons who do
not even embark upon the first step in
the journey of seeking their rights
before Courts and Tribunals and merely
watch for a long period to those who
are similarly placed and then try to ride
piggy-back on those who get relief after
a long-drawn legal battle.”
41.
Aforesaid principle makes it abundantly clear that similarly
situated persons cannot be denied relief merely because they
were not successful earlier or did not obtain relief at that stage.
Applying the aforesaid principle, the petitioners in the present
category, who had already approached the Tribunal, stand on an
even stronger footing and cannot be treated as fence-sitters or
disentitled persons.
42.
This Court also finds considerable force in the submission that the
termination of the petitioners was not only illegal but also arbitrary,
inasmuch as it was effected without issuance of any written order,
no notice or opportunity of hearing was granted, and the work
itself continued, albeit through outsourcing agencies.
Such
action, in effect, amounts to replacing one set of workers with
another, which has been expressly frowned upon by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
43.
In Jaggo (Supra), the Apex Court held in paragraphs 13 and 21
that outsourcing the same work after termination of existing
workers establishes that the work is perennial… and denial of
regularization in such cases is contrary to fairness and equity.
44.
The factual matrix in the present case clearly reveals that the
petitioners had rendered long and continuous service, their work
was
perennial
and
indispensable,
their
names
were
recommended for regularization, and they were subsequently
terminated to facilitate outsourcing. Such a course of action, in
the considered view of this Court, amounts to an unfair labour
practice and cannot be sustained in law.
45.
The contention of the respondents that the petitioners were not
employees of the department post outsourcing is equally
untenable. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that
the State cannot evade its constitutional obligations by resorting
to contractual or outsourcing mechanisms, particularly when the
underlying work and control remain with the department.
46.
Another significant aspect which weighs with this Court is that
similarly situated employees, including one Naresh Kumar Yadav,
have already been granted relief and regularized. Once such
benefit has been extended, denial of the same to the present
petitioners would amount to hostile discrimination, which is
impermissible under Article 14.
47.
The argument that the petitioners are not entitled to relief due to
dismissal of their Original Applications also overlooks the settled
principle that writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is wide and
equitable, and can be exercised to remedy injustice, particularly
where the earlier adjudication is shown to be based on an
outdated or narrow interpretation of law, and subsequent
judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court have clarified the legal
position.
48.
In light of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the dismissal of the Original Applications by the
Tribunal does not extinguish the petitioners’ right to seek
regularization, the subsequent termination of their services gives
rise to an independent and continuing cause of action, and the
petitioners cannot be denied relief merely on technical or
procedural grounds when substantive injustice is evident.
49.
Consequently, this Court holds that the petitioners belonging to
the second category, i.e., those whose services were abruptly
terminated are entitled to parity with similarly situated employees,
cannot be denied consideration for regularization merely on
account of dismissal of their Original Applications, and are further
entitled to relief on account of the illegality and arbitrariness of
their termination.
50.
The action of the respondents in terminating the services of such
petitioners, while continuing the same work through outsourcing
agencies and while granting regularization to similarly situated
employees, is arbitrary, discriminatory, and violative of Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India, and therefore cannot be
sustained.
51.
Accordingly, the findings recorded by the Central Administrative
Tribunal, in so far as they relate to the present category of
petitioners, are held to be unsustainable in law, being based on a
mechanical application of the judgment in Uma Devi without
taking into account the subsequent evolution of law and the
factual realities of the case.
52.
The inevitable conclusion, therefore, is that the petitioners in the
second category stand on no lesser footing than those who have
continued in service, and their claim for regularization deserves to
be considered on merits, ignoring the technical objection arising
out of dismissal of their Original Applications.
Conclusion :
53.
In view of the foregoing analysis, this Court arrives at a
considered and unequivocal conclusion that the impugned
common order dated 11.10.2013 passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, cannot be sustained in
the eyes of law, as the same proceeds on an unduly rigid and
mechanical application of the principles laid down in Uma Devi
(supra), without appreciating the subsequent evolution of law and
the factual realities of the present case. The Tribunal has failed to
take into account the long, continuous and uninterrupted service
rendered by the petitioners, the perennial nature of duties
discharged by them, the recommendations made by the
department itself for their regularization, and the subsequent
authoritative pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
which have clarified that the doctrine laid down in Uma Devi
(Supra) cannot be applied in a manner so as to perpetuate
injustice or defeat legitimate claims of employees engaged in
irregular, but not illegal, appointments.
54.
So far as the first category of petitioners, namely those who
continue in service, is concerned, this Court holds that their claim
for regularization cannot be defeated solely on the ground that
they had not completed ten years of service as on 10.04.2006.
The material on record clearly establishes that they have
rendered long years of continuous service extending over
decades, are performing duties of a permanent and perennial
nature, and their engagement, at best, suffers from procedural
irregularity rather than illegality. The subsequent judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court have consistently emphasized that such
employees are entitled to fair and equitable consideration for
regularization and cannot be denied such benefit on hypertechnical grounds. Accordingly, the petitioners in this category are
held entitled to be considered for regularization, and the
respondents are directed to undertake a fresh exercise for
regularization of their services in a time-bound manner, keeping in
view the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
later decisions, and without being constrained by the rigid cut-off
date of 10.04.2006.
55.
In respect of the second category of petitioners, namely those
whose services were abruptly terminated, this Court finds that
their case stands on an even stronger footing. The termination of
their services, in many instances without written orders, notice, or
adherence to due process, is ex facie arbitrary, illegal, and
violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Such
action, coupled with the fact that the same work has been
continued through outsourcing agencies, clearly establishes an
unfair and discriminatory practice on the part of the respondents.
Furthermore, the dismissal of their Original Applications by the
Tribunal does not operate as a bar to grant of relief in the present
proceedings,
particularly
in
light
of
subsequent
judicial
developments and the continuing nature of the cause of action.
The principles of parity and non-discrimination, as consistently
upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, mandate that similarly
situated employees cannot be treated differently. Consequently,
the petitioners in the second category are also held entitled to
relief. The action of the respondents in terminating their services
is hereby declared illegal and unsustainable, and the respondents
are directed to reinstate such petitioners (wherever not already
reinstated) and to consider their cases for regularization on the
same footing as the petitioners who have continued in service.
Such consideration shall be undertaken expeditiously and in
accordance with law, keeping in view the principles laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the judgments referred to
hereinabove.
56.
In culmination, therefore, both categories of petitioners are held
entitled to succeed. The impugned order dated 11.10.2013
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal is hereby set aside.
The
policy
decisions
dated
04.07.2011,
25.07.2011
and
14.03.2012, to the extent they adversely affect the rights of the
present petitioners and operate to deny them fair consideration for
regularization, are also held to be arbitrary and unsustainable in
their application to the present case.
57.
Accordingly, all the writ petitions stand allowed, with the aforesaid
directions.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Sanjay S. Agrawal)
Judge
Shayna
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
HEAD – NOTE
Termination of the petitioners’ services, while continuing the same
work through outsourcing agencies and granting regularization to
similarly situated employees, is arbitrary and discriminatory. Such
action violates Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and
is therefore unsustainable in law.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review