The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. It is also seen that the First Appellate Court independently reappreciated the oral and documentary evidence and arrived at a reasoned conclusion that Ex.A1 was not proved to be a genuine agreement of sale. The findings of the Courts below are based on the evidence available on record and cannot be said to be perverse or contrary to law. The appellant's contentions essentially seek a fresh appreciation of the evidence, which is not permissible in a Second Appeal unless a substantial question of law is involved. Further, the https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis SA No. 887 of 2026 First Appellate Court disposed of the appeal in the year 2009, whereas the present Second Appeal was instituted after a considerable lapse of time. However, irrespective of the delay, the appellant has failed to demonstrate any substantial question of law warranting admission of the Second Appeal. This Court finds no ground to interfere with the concurrent findings of the Courts below.
14. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed, as no substantial question of law arises for consideration. The judgment and decree passed by the First Appellate Court confirming the judgment and decree dated 25.01.2008 passed by the District Munsif Court, Nagapattinam, in O.S. No.217 of 2006, are hereby confirmed. There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions, if any, are closed. 09-10-2026 Pbl To
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 887 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 09-10-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE T.V.THAMILSELVI
SA No. 887 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA013001402009}
1. Revathi,
W/o Haridoss, North street,
Thirupugalur village, Nagapattinam TK
and Ditrict.
Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Abdul Raseedu
S/o Mohammed ismail residing at 126B Main Road, Thittacherry Village,
Nagapattinam TK and Dt
2.Rameeja Begum
w/o Abdul raseedu both residing at 126B Main Road Thittacheery village,
Nagapattinam Tk and District.
3.Rameeja Begum
W/o Abdul Raseedu, residing at 126-B
Main Road, Thittacherry Village,
Nagapattinam TK and Dt
Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This Second Appeal has been filed under Section 100 CPC praying
to prefer the following memorandum of Second Appeal against the judgment
and decree of Sub Court, Nagapattinam, dated 24/04/2009 made in AS.No.55
of 2008 confirming judgment and decree of District Munsif Court,
Nagapattinam dated 25.01.2008 made in O.S.No.217 of 2006.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
For Appellant(s):
Mr.B.Jawahar
For Respondent(s):
JUDGEMENT
The present Second Appeal is filed challenging the judgment and decree
passed by the First Appellate Court, dismissing the appeal and confirming the
judgment and decree dated 25.01.2008 passed by the District Munsif Court,
Nagapattinam, in O.S. No.217 of 2006. The suit was instituted by the plaintiff
seeking specific performance of the alleged sale agreement dated 10.08.2003 or,
alternatively, return of the advance amount of Rs.75,000/- with subsequent
interest at 12% per annum and costs. The Trial Court dismissed the suit, and the
First Appellate Court confirmed the same. Aggrieved by the concurrent findings
of the Courts below, the plaintiff has preferred the present Second Appeal.
2. The case of the plaintiff is that the first defendant agreed to sell the suit
property for a sale consideration of Rs.75,000/- and executed a sale agreement
dated 10.08.2003. According to the plaintiff, the entire sale consideration was
paid to the first defendant at his request and the original title documents were
also handed over. Despite repeated demands, the first defendant failed to
execute the sale deed. Consequently, the plaintiff issued an advocate notice
dated 01.12.2004, which was received by the first defendant on 03.12.2004. The
first defendant sent a reply notice dated 11.12.2004 denying the transaction and
alleging that the document was not a genuine sale agreement.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
3. The plaintiff specifically denied the allegation that her husband had
advanced a loan of Rs.30,000/- to the first defendant in June 1997 and obtained
his signature in blank stamped papers and revenue-stamped papers as security.
She also denied the alleged subsequent loan transaction of Rs.20,000/- in June
1999. According to the plaintiff, the first defendant had subsequently executed a
settlement deed dated 15.10.2003 in favour of his wife, the second defendant,
with a view to defeating the plaintiff's rights under the earlier sale agreement.
Since the said settlement deed was subsequent to the alleged sale agreement, the
plaintiff contended that it would not bind her. Hence, the second defendant was
impleaded and the suit was filed seeking specific performance or, alternatively,
refund of the advance amount.
4. The first defendant filed a written statement denying the execution of
the alleged sale agreement dated 10.08.2003. According to him, he had already
settled the suit property in favour of his wife, the second defendant, under a
settlement deed dated 15.10.2003 and was neither the owner nor in possession
of the property thereafter. He contended that the alleged sale agreement was a
forged and fabricated document created by the plaintiff's husband, who was
carrying on money-lending business. According to the first defendant, he had
borrowed Rs.30,000/- from the plaintiff's husband in June 1997 and another
sum of Rs.20,000/- in June 1999, and his signatures were obtained in blank
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
stamped papers and revenue-stamped papers as security for the said loans. He
alleged that those papers had subsequently been misused to fabricate the suit
agreement.
5. The second defendant also filed a written statement supporting the
defence of the first defendant. She contended that the suit property had been
settled in her favour under the settlement deed dated 15.10.2003 and that
possession had also been handed over to her. According to her, the plaintiff's
husband had been engaged in money-lending transactions and had obtained
blank signed papers from the first defendant in connection with the alleged loan
transactions. She therefore contended that the suit sale agreement was
fraudulently created using those papers and that the plaintiff was not entitled to
any relief. Both defendants sought dismissal of the suit.
6. On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Trial Court framed issues
regarding the genuineness of the sale agreement dated 10.08.2003, the plaintiff's
entitlement to specific performance, her entitlement to the alternative relief of
refund of the amount and other consequential reliefs. On the side of the plaintiff,
her husband was examined as P.W.1 and three other witnesses were examined as
P.W.2 to P.W.4. Ex.A1 to Ex.A4 were marked. On the side of the defendants,
both defendants were examined as D.W.1 and D.W.2 and Ex.B1 was marked.
After considering the oral and documentary evidence, the Trial Court dismissed
the suit with costs, holding that the plaintiff had failed to establish the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
genuineness of the alleged sale agreement.
7. Aggrieved by the dismissal of the suit, the plaintiff preferred an appeal
contending that the Trial Court had failed to properly appreciate the evidence
and had erroneously concluded that the suit agreement was fabricated. It was
contended that the suit was filed only in respect of the portion belonging to the
first defendant and not the entire extent in the survey number. The plaintiff
further argued that the Trial Court had failed to consider the subsequent written
statement and the non-production of the settlement deed dated 15.10.2003 by
the defendants. It was also contended that the first defendant had admitted his
signature in Ex.A1 and that the Trial Court ought to have accepted the sale
agreement and granted the relief sought for by the plaintiff.
8. The First Appellate Court considered the rival submissions and
formulated the points for consideration, namely, whether the first defendant had
executed the sale agreement dated 10.08.2003, whether the plaintiff was always
ready and willing to perform her part of the contract and whether she was
entitled to specific performance or alternatively refund of the advance amount.
Upon examining Ex.A1, the First Appellate Court noticed that the stamp paper
had been purchased in the name of the plaintiff as early as 22.07.1998, whereas
the alleged sale agreement was stated to have been executed only on
10.08.2003. The explanation offered by the plaintiff's witnesses that the stamp
paper had been purchased on the date of execution was found to be inconsistent
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
with the documentary evidence.
9. The First Appellate Court further observed that, though the first
defendant had admitted his signature in Ex.A1, the burden was upon the
plaintiff to establish that the document was executed as a genuine agreement of
sale on 10.08.2003. The plaintiff herself had not entered the witness box to
speak about the alleged transaction. Instead, her husband was examined as
P.W.1. Though the husband was competent to depose as a witness, he could not
substitute himself for the plaintiff in proving matters particularly within her
knowledge. The non-examination of the plaintiff was therefore considered a
relevant circumstance for drawing an adverse inference against her.
10.The First Appellate Court also scrutinised the evidence of P.W.2 to
P.W.4. P.W.2 was a village menial who had worked under P.W.1 and claimed to
have signed the agreement at the request of P.W.1. P.W.3 was a neighbour and
an acquaintance of P.W.1 for several years, while P.W.4 was the scribe of the
document and belonged to the same village. Their evidence regarding the
preparation and execution of Ex.A1 contained inconsistencies. The insertion of
the names of the witnesses in different ink and the circumstances surrounding
the preparation of the document also created serious doubts regarding its
genuineness. The First Appellate Court found that the witnesses were interested
in the case of the plaintiff and their evidence was insufficient to establish due
execution of the alleged sale agreement.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
10. The First Appellate Court further considered the defence that the first
defendant had borrowed money from the plaintiff's husband and had signed
blank stamped papers as security. It found that the plaintiff had failed to
satisfactorily establish that Ex.A1 was executed with the intention of creating an
agreement of sale. The Court also observed that the plaintiff could not avoid the
burden of proving her case merely by alleging that the defendants were denying
the agreement due to previous disputes arising out of other proceedings.
Accordingly, the First Appellate Court held that the sale agreement dated
10.08.2003 had not been proved as a genuine agreement of sale and dismissed
the appeal, confirming the judgment and decree of the Trial Court.
11.Challenging the concurrent findings of the Courts below, the appellant
has preferred the present Second Appeal. The learned counsel appearing for the
appellant was heard. The principal contention is that the first defendant had
admitted his signature in Ex.A1 and that the Courts below ought to have
accepted the document as a genuine agreement of sale. It is further contended
that the evidence of P.W.2 to P.W.4 establishes the execution of the agreement
and that the plaintiff was entitled either to specific performance or to refund of
the advance amount. The appellant also questions the adverse inference drawn
on account of the non-examination of the plaintiff.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
12. This Court has carefully considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the appellant and perused the judgments and records of the
Courts below. The material question is whether any substantial question of law
arises for consideration under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The
Courts below have concurrently found that the alleged sale agreement was not
established as a genuine document. The circumstances relating to the purchase
of the stamp paper in the year 1998, the alleged execution in the year 2003, the
inconsistencies in the evidence of the attesting witnesses and the nonexamination of the plaintiff were all taken into consideration. The admission of
the signature by the first defendant, by itself, does not establish that the
document was executed as an agreement of sale. The burden remained upon the
plaintiff to prove the nature and purpose of the document, which she failed to
discharge.
13. It is also seen that the First Appellate Court independently
reappreciated the oral and documentary evidence and arrived at a reasoned
conclusion that Ex.A1 was not proved to be a genuine agreement of sale. The
findings of the Courts below are based on the evidence available on record and
cannot be said to be perverse or contrary to law. The appellant's contentions
essentially seek a fresh appreciation of the evidence, which is not permissible in
a Second Appeal unless a substantial question of law is involved. Further, the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
First Appellate Court disposed of the appeal in the year 2009, whereas the
present Second Appeal was instituted after a considerable lapse of time.
However, irrespective of the delay, the appellant has failed to demonstrate any
substantial question of law warranting admission of the Second Appeal. This
Court finds no ground to interfere with the concurrent findings of the Courts
below.
14. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed, as no substantial
question of law arises for consideration. The judgment and decree passed by the
First Appellate Court confirming the judgment and decree dated 25.01.2008
passed by the District Munsif Court, Nagapattinam, in O.S. No.217 of 2006, are
hereby confirmed. There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petitions, if any, are closed.
09-10-2026
Pbl
To
1. The Sub Court, Nagapattinam
2. The District Munsif Court, Nagapattinam
3. The Section Officer, V. R Section, High Court, Madras.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 887 of 2026
T.V.THAMILSELVI J.
pbl
SA No. 887 of 2026
09-10-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review