Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
MOTOR ACCIDENTS CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.334 of 2017
Between:
# Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
...APPELLANT
AND
$ Kurella Rahul and 3 Others
...RESPONDENTS
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON 31.07.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be marked to
Law Reporters/Journals
Yes/No
3. Whether Their Ladyship/Lordship wish to see the fair
copy of the Judgment?
Yes/No
_____________________________
JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENTS CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.334 of 2017
% 31.07.2026
# Between:
# Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
...APPELLANT
AND
$ Kurella Rahul and 3 Others
! Counsel for the Appellant
...RESPONDENTS
:
Sri D.Sumanth for Sri D.Ravi Kiran
! Counsel for the 1st Respondent :
Sri Sazid Kallur
! Counsel for the 2nd Respondent :
Sri P.Raj Kumar
<Gist :
>Head Note:
? Cases referred: 1. 2014 SCC OnLine P&H 6036
2. (1977) 2 SCC 441
3. (2016) 16 SCC 590
4. (2004) 4 ALD (NOC 313) 33
5. (2009) 6 SCC 121
6. (2017) 16 SCC 680
7. 2014 SCC OnLine AP 1592
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
APHC010559082017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3548]
FRIDAY, THE 31st DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 334/2017
Between:
1. RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,, REP. BY ITS
DIVISONAL MANAGER,'VIJAYAWADA, D.NO. 36-14-1, 5TH FLOOR,
VEERAMACHANENI PRAKASA RAO COMPLEX, JAMMICHETTU
CENTER,
MOGHALRAJAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA,
ANDHRA
PRADESH,
...APPELLANT
AND
1. KURELLA RAHUL AND 3 OTHERS, S/O. K NATHANIYEL RAJU, 26
YEARS, STUDENT, R/O. D.NO. 26-27-190, FATHIMA NAGAR, AT
AGRAHARAM, GUNTUR.
2. KURELLA VIJAYA RAJU, S/O. K NATHANIYEL RAJU, 25 YEARS,
PRIVATE EMPLYEE, R/O. D.NO. 26-27-190, FATHIMA NAGAR. AT
AGRAHARAM, GUNTUR.
3. CH SUBBA RAMIREDDY, S/O. CHANNA REDDY, D.NO. 3-34 B,
KALANUTHALA,
ONGOLE,
PRAKASAM
DISTRICT,
ANDRA
PRADESH. (OWNER OF CAR NO. AP 07AE 0054.)
4. SK KHASIMSHA, S/O. BIKARI SAHEB, 27 YEARS, D.NO. 15-7-30,
PANASATHOTA, NARASARAOP3T, GUNTUR DISTRICT. (DIRVER
OF CAR NO. AP 07AE 0054).
...RESPONDENT(S):
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court against the
impugned order and the decree of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-II
Additional District Judge, Guntur, passed in OP No.129 of 2015 dt.30.11.2016
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(MACMAMP 612 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay all further proceedings in pursuance of the order and the decree
dt.30.11.2016 passed in MVOP No.129 of 2015 by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal-cum-II Additional District Judge, Guntur, pending disposal of the
above appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. D RAVI KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P RAJKUMAR
2. SAZID KALLUR
The Court made the following:
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Mr.D.Sumanth, learned counsel representing Mr.D.Ravi Kiran, learned
counsel for the appellant, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited,
Mr.Sazid Kallur, learned counsel for respondent No.1, and Mr.P.Raj Kumar,
learned counsel for respondent No.2.
2.
The appeal is filed by Reliance General Insurance Company
Limited, represented by its Divisional Manager, against the Order and Decree,
dated 30.11.2016, in M.V.O.P.No.129 of 2015, passed by the Chairman,
Motor Vehicles Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-II Additional District Judge,
Guntur (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”), in partly allowing the petition
by awarding compensation of Rs.17,83,576/- to the petitioners 1 and 2.
3.
The parties are arrayed as arraigned before the Tribunal.
4.
The conspectus of facts leading to the filing of the petition before
the Tribunal are as follows:
i.
The deceased, Janapatla Vijaya Durga, used to work as Senior
Assistant in the RTO office, Markapur, Prakasam District. On 30.11.2023, the
deceased, aged about 46 years, went to Hyderabad on her official work in a
Car bearing registration No.AP07AE0054, where she received telephonic
information that after completion of office work, she should return to Markapur
via Kurnool. On her way, she went to her friend‟s house at Pebbair. On
01.12.2013, while she was travelling along with her friends Bhulakshmi, driver
khasim and Pebbair villagers, at about 13:40 hours, the car driver drove the
car at a high speed and applied the brakes suddenly, as a result, the right
back tyre of the car burst and dashed to the roadside culvert and turned turtle,
resulting in the deceased receiving bleeding injuries and died on the spot.
ii.
In the complaint, it is also the claim of the petitioners that the
deceased used to earn Rs.18,960/- per month as salary, and due to the
accident and the premature death of the deceased, the claimants lost their
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
present and future dependency in addition to the mental agony and sufferings.
The owner of the vehicle involved in the accident is vicariously liable for the
negligent act of the driver, and the 1st respondent is liable to pay the
compensation. The 3rd respondent, being the insurer of the said car, is also
liable to make good compensation claimed by the petitioners. Accordingly, the
petitioners sought compensation of Rs.23,48,520/-.
5.
In retaliating to the said contentions, respondent Nos.1 and 2
before the Tribunal remained ex parte. The 3rd respondent-insurer filed its
written statement with the averments contending that the driver of the car
bearing registration No.AP07AE0054 was not holding a valid and effective
driving licence at the time of the accident and was not qualified for holding or
obtaining such driving licence, and had not satisfied the requirements of Rule
No.3 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989. The insurer further contended
that the owner had willfully violated the terms and conditions of the policy and,
as such, the insurance company is not liable to pay any sort of compensation
to the petitioners. Also denied the age of the deceased as 46 at the time of
accident and earning Rs.18,960/- per month. The written statement further
contends that both the petitioners were majors and were not depending upon
the earnings of the deceased and therefore, were not entitled for the claim,
and prayed to dismiss the petition.
6.
Taking into consideration the adversaries of both sides, the
Tribunal framed the following issues:
i.
Whether there is rash or negligence on the part of the 1st
respondent‟s driver?
ii.
Whether the driver of the 1st respondent has no valid and
effective driving licence at the time of accident?
iii.
Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation as
prayed for?
iv.
To what relief?
7.
Before the Tribunal, the 1st petitioner got himself examined as
PW.1 and got examined K.V.Raviteja, S.Naga Malleswara Rao, Nelamalli
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
Bhulakshmi, Shaik Khasim Sha and Ch.Subbasamireddy as PWs.2 to 6 and
got marked Exs.A1 to A5 and Exs.X1 to X4. On behalf of the 3rd respondent,
RW.1, the Legal Assistant, was examined and got marked Ex.B1 policy.
8.
The Tribunal, while answering issue Nos.1 and 2, has taken note
of the evidence adduced on behalf of PW1 and the other witnesses and also
the averments contained in the petition in support of the claim. The Tribunal
has held that the 3rd respondent failed to elicit anything contra to the version of
the petitioners with regard to the manner of the accident. PW.4 reiterated the
manner of occurrence of the accident. The Tribunal has also taken note of
Ex.A3, charge sheet, which discloses the name of PW.4, who was crossexamined during investigation by the police in C.C.No.118 of 2014 in Crime
No.149 of 2013, dated 02.12.2013. PWs.5 and 6 also corroborated the
evidence of PW.4 and the claim of PW.1 as to the nature of the accident. The
Tribunal has taken note of the fact that, even during the examination of PWs.5
and 6, the 3rd respondent failed to elicit anything in negative/in support of its
case. The charge sheet, which is filed after thorough investigation by the
police of Manopad, clearly fixes the offences punishable under Sections 304-A
and 338 of IPC against the driver. Ex.A2, inquest report also corroborated with
the petitioners‟ version and considered that the accident has not occurred due
to any mechanical defect of the vehicle through the evidence of Ex.A4.
9.
The Tribunal, while deciding the issues, has considered the
decision of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana relied upon by the
petitioners/claimants in Roshan Lal vs. Jarnail Singh1, wherein it was held
as follows:
“A tyre burst on the road is result of poor upkeep of one of the
most important parts in a four wheeler. It shall be no defence for an
owner to plead that a burst of tyre that makes the driver lose his control
over the vehicle to result in an inference that there was no negligence.
When a contention is taken before the Tribunal that there was a
negligent driving by the driver and it is sought to be explained by the
driver that he was careful in his driving and he had kept the vehicle in a
state of repair, he was bound to bring before the Tribunal all the
2014 SCC OnLine P&H 6036
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
evidence of the care that he had taken for the regular upkeep of the
tyres. A tyre that is properly maintained is not expected to burst or if it
burst, and the driver was unable to control the steering and let it go into
a ditch, it is illustrative of the principle of res ipsa loquitur.
In Darshan Kumari and others Versus State of Punjab and
others 2007 (4) PLR 219, a bench of this court held that bursting of tyre
cannot be taken as an act of God to enable the driver or the owner to
escape liability. In this regard, we may refer the Motor Vehicle Laws
14th Edition, Lexis Nexis, Volume 2 pages 1578-1579 that deal with the
cases from every High Court of India taking homogeneously similar
view casting the liability on the owner or the driver for any mechanical
failure or bursting of tyres.”
10.
The Tribunal relied on the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in Minu B. Mehta and another vs. Balakrishna Ramchandra Nayan
and another 2 , to fortify that the burden of proving that the accident was
caused due to any mechanical or other defect in the vehicle lies on the owner.
It is the duty of the owner to show that all reasonable care had been taken and
that, despite such care, the defect remained hidden.
11.
The
Tribunal,
after
considering
the
aforesaid
judgments,
categorically observed that there is no evidence forthcoming from the owner
or the insurer that adequate road safety measures and reasonable care and
caution was taken by the owner or the driver and held that the car was in
perfect condition.
12.
The decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court relied upon by the
petitioners/claimants was also taken note by the Tribunal in Gian Chand and
others vs. Gurlabh Singh and others3, wherein it was held as follows:
“In the circumstances, there is no escape from the conclusion
that the bus was driven in a rash and negligent manner by its driver.
Apart from that merely a mechanical failure is not enough to exonerate
the transport undertaking from its liability in the absence of evidence
being adduced that the vehicle was maintained properly”.
13.
On behalf of the 3rd respondent, to substantiate its claim/
argument that merely because a charge sheet is filed, it cannot be construed
that the evidence is conclusive, as the decision of the criminal court is not
(1977) 2 SCC 441
(2016) 16 SCC 590
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
binding and the Tribunal has an independent nature to proceed with, and on
this count, the judgment of this Court was taken note in APSRTC rep. by its
Managing Director, Hyderabad vs. D.Sasikala and others4, wherein it was
held as follows:
“In this case the High Court of A.P. held that merely because the
police charge sheeted R.W.1, it cannot be presumed that the allegations
therein are true.
Investigating Officers duty in all motor accidents cases,
Panchanama and sketch of the scene of accident are very important as
they would show where actually the accident occurred and would assist
the court in coming to a correct conclusion – Picking and choosing
witnesses and investigating officers filing charge sheet solely on the
basis of those statements even without taking the trouble of going to
scene of accident is improper and deprecated.”
14.
Coming to issue Nos.1 and 2, the Tribunal answered in favour of
the petitioners/claimants and against the respondents.
15.
While coming to issue No.3, the Tribunal observed that there is
no dispute with regard to the status of relationship between the petitioners/
claimants and the deceased. The Tribunal also observed that as there is no
rebuttal evidence on behalf of the insurer videlicet the answer regarding
dependency on the deceased and the age was also taken note of. The
Tribunal thereafter took note of the salary being drawn by the deceased at the
time of the accident, which was Rs.18,960/- per month. The salary certificates
were marked as Exs.X2 to X4. Ex.X2 discloses the pay slip for the month of
November, 2013, issued by the Deputy Transport Commissioner, Ongole,
Prakasam District. Ex.X4 is the salary certificate for the month of November,
2013, issued by the Deputy Transport Commissioner, Ongole, to establish her
claim regarding the drawing of a monthly salary of Rs.18,960/-.
16.
The Tribunal, while discussing whether the net salary or gross
salary of the deceased to be taken into consideration, Rs.20,077/- was taken
as salary of the deceased at the time of death by taking into consideration the
salary certificates issued by the Deputy Transport Commissioner, Ongole.
(2004) 4 ALD (NOC 313) 33
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
Since the said salary certificates were issued by the competent authority, the
Tribunal has taken note that the salary drawn by the deceased was
Rs.20,077/- per month. After deducting the amount towards Provident
Fund (PF), the net salary drawn by the deceased was Rs.19,927/- per month.
Accordingly, the net salary was taken as Rs.19,927/- per month. The annual
income thus works out to Rs.2,39,124/- (Rs.19,927/- x 12).
17.
Now, coming to the multiplier, the Tribunal has taken „11‟, as the
deceased was aged about 53 years, in view of the age mentioned in her
Aadhaar card. Since there is no other material placed by the claimants
regarding the age of the deceased, the age mentioned in the Aadhaar card
was taken note of by the Tribunal. Adopting the multiplier of „11‟, the
compensation towards loss of dependency was calculated at Rs.26,30,364/(Rs.2,39,124/- x 11). After deducting 1/3rd towards personal and living
expenses of the deceased, as per the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in Sarla Verma and others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and another 5,
the amount towards loss of dependency was arrived at Rs.17,53,576/(Rs.26,30,364 - Rs.8,76,788). The other heads of compensation which the
Tribunal has taken note are Rs.20,000/- towards funeral expenses and
Rs.10,000/- towards love and affection, which comes to Rs.17,83,576/(Rs.17,53,576/- + Rs.20,000/- + Rs.10,000/-).
18.
Heard both the learned counsel.
19.
Mr.Sazid Kallur, learned counsel for respondent No.1, would
argue that the ratio laid down by the Constitution Bench of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has to be taken note of and the very contention of the
claimants before the Tribunal was that they had lost their present and future
dependency due to the accident. In view of the said specific claim of the
claimants before the Tribunal, and also by applying the ratio laid down by the
Constitution Bench in National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
(2009) 6 SCC 121
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
Sethi6, wherein it was observed that Rs.40,000/- is to be awarded towards
loss of consortium, Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses, the compensation under the said heads requires to
be modified. In paragraph 59.8, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held as follows:
“59.8. Reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely,
loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be
Rs. 15,000/-, Rs. 40,000/- and Rs. 15,000/- respectively. The
aforesaid amounts should be enhanced at the rate of 10% in every
three years.”
20.
In the present case, since there are two dependants, the amount
towards loss of consortium would be Rs.80,000/- (Rs.40,000/- x 2). In view of
the aforesaid ratio laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, the Tribunal
ought to have awarded Rs.80,000/- towards loss of consortium (love and
affection), instead of Rs.10,000/-, and Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses,
instead of Rs.20,000/- awarded by the Tribunal. The Tribunal ought to have
further awarded Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate to the claimants. Adopting
the said ratio, the total compensation would be Rs.18,63,576/- (Rs.17,53,576/+ Rs.80,000/- + Rs.15,000/- + Rs.15,000/-).
21.
While coming to the argument advanced by the learned counsel
for the appellant/Insurance Company regarding the employment of the
dependants, who are private employees, the Tribunal, after taking note of the
evidence adduced, came to the conclusion that there is no evidence adduced
fortifying that they would not fall within the definition of „dependants‟. Relying
upon the judgment of this Court in United India Insurance Company Limited
vs. Shyam Rao Metre and others7, the Tribunal concluded that the major
sons also come within the purview of dependents. This Court, in Shyam Rao
Metre‟s case (supra 7), at paragraph 18, held as follows:
“In the result, the appeal is partly allowed while holding that
being the legal representatives, the claimants as major sons of the
deceased, though not dependants on the deceased, entitled to
(2017) 16 SCC 680
2014 SCC OnLine AP 1592
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.334 of 2017
compensation arrived from taking of their means also in fixing the
contribution of the deceased and arrived the compensation of
Rs.1,90,000/- out of which for the overloading contributed to the
accident for fixing 20% exclusively on the owner of the vehicle
comes to Rs.38,000/- and remaining 80% comes to Rs.1,52,000/fixed on the insurer to indemnify the owner with interest at 7.5% p.a.
on respective sums from the date of claim petition till the date of
realization which they have to deposit within one month, failing
which the claimants can execute and recover. Rest of award/decree
terms of the Tribunal holds good. There is no order as to costs in the
appeal.”
22.
As per the reasoning of this Court regarding the enhancement of
compensation as per the ratio laid down by the Constitution Bench in Pranay
Sethi‟s case (supra 6), the Order and Decree of the Tribunal is modified to the
extent of enhancing the compensation from Rs.17,83,576/- to Rs.18,63,576/-.
The 3rd respondent is directed to deposit the aforesaid enhanced amount of
compensation before the Tribunal within a period of eight weeks from the date
of receipt of a copy of this judgment, after deducting the amount, if any,
deposited earlier. The enhanced amount shall carry interest @ 6% per annum
from the date of this order till date of realization. On such deposit, the
claimants are entitled to withdraw the said amount by filing an appropriate
application before the Tribunal.
23.
Resultantly, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal
No.334 of 2017 filed by Reliance General Insurance Company Limited is
dismissed, modifying the Order and Decree to the extent indicated above.
There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
Date : 31-07-2026
Note : L.R. copy be marked
B/o
BMS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review