The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Having regard to the discussion made hereinabove and aforestated reasons, the impugned award is ordered to be modified as under: Loss of future income Rs.32,52,640/- Rs. 28,22,400/- For pain and suffering Rs. 1,00,000/- Rs. 1,00,000/- Loss of amenities of life Rs. 1,00,000/- Rs. 1,00,000/- Cost of artificial limb Rs. 1,50,000/- Rs. 1,50,000/- Medical expenses Rs. 1,77,040/- Rs. 1,77,040/- RS.37,52,600/- Rs. 33,49,440/- With the above modification in the impugned order, the same shall be enforced with the interest granted therein, in terms of the impugned award. The awarded amount, if deposited in this court, is ordered to be paid to the claimant and the excess, if any, shall be refunded to the appellant under rules.
17. The appeal is partly allowed and the impugned award is modified as above.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Mac App No.2/2024
CM No. 43/2024
Reserved on:
30.01.2026
Pronounced on: 09 .02.2026
Uploaded on: 09 .02.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced- Full Judgment
Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd,
4th Floor, Chintamani Avenue,
Off Western Express Highway
Near Virwani Industrial Estate Goregaon (East)
Mumbai-400063.
…..Appellant
Through: Ms. Himani Uppal, Advocate.
Vs
1. Rajni Devi W/O Ajay Kumar
R/O H. No. 111, Mohalla Indira Colony,
Shastri Nagar, Jammu
2. Firdous Ahmed Zargar
S/O Mohammad Ramzan Zargar
R/O Behrampora, Baramulla,
Srinagar (Pin 193101) J&K (Owner)
3. Ishfaq Ahmed Khan alias Katri
S/O Sh. Abdul Rashid Khan alias Katri
R/O Rampora, Chattabal,
Srinagar (Pin 190010) (Driver)
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. S. Hakumat Singh, Advocate for R-1.
Respondent Nos. 2&3 Exparte.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
On the strength of case set up in the appeal, the appellant-Insurer has prayed
for setting aside the impugned award dated 02.11.2023 passed by the learned
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jammu (for short ‘the Tribunal’), in Claim
Petition No.291/C, titled ‘Rajni Devi. V. Reliance General Insurance Company
Ltd. & Ors.’, whereby respondent No.1-Rajni Devi hereinafter called as claimant
Mac App No.2/2024
was granted compensation to the tune of Rs.37,52,640/- for her disability in a
motor accident.
2.
The impugned award has been assailed on the following grounds:I. That the impugned award passed by the learned Tribunal below is
against the law and facts of the case and the same is not sustainable
in the eyes of law and as such deserves to be quashed and set aside;
II. That the impugned award dated 02.11.2023 is based merely on
surmises and conjectures, without appreciating the documents
which were filed by the parties and as such the same deserves to be
quashed and set aside;
III. That the learned Tribunal has not considered the law on the subject
properly while passing the impugned award obviously for the
reason that claimant had to establish that what her monthly income
was. No income proof has been filed by the petitioner. In these
circumstances, the income of the injured can very well be assessed
on the basis of the chart available in the Minimum Wages Act in
2019;
IV. The Tribunal has not insisted on definite proof as regards the
income of the injured and relied on mere statement of Respondent
No.1;
V. It is furthermore contended that no proof of income of the claimant
having been brought on record; the tribunal committed a serious
error in holding that his income was Rs.12000/ per month;
VI. That the injured/Respondent No.1 suffered 85% disability of her
right upper limb, the learned Tribunal has passed the award of
Rs.37,52,640/- along with interest @ 7.5% P.A except the amount
under the head ‘Loss of Future Income’ throughout till realization to
respondents No.1, by holding the permanent disability 85% on
whole body, which is incorrect and against the facts of the case,
although it is evident that the Respondent No.1 suffered 85%
disability of her right upper limb only and Doctor in his statement
opined that ‘She can perform day to day activities as the disability is
Mac App No.2/2024
with respect to the right upper limb only not with regard to the
whole body. When compared to the whole body the disability
decreases by 1/3 and comes to 28.03% of the whole body, which is
permanent’, but the learned Tribunal while passing the award has
fallen in error and considering the permanent disability 85% with
respect to the whole body and functional disability 100%;
VII.
That the learned Tribunal has also not appreciated the evidence
and cross examination of the witnesses. It is worthwhile to mention
here that the petitioner is residing at Jammu and alleged to run her
business at Dinanagar Punjab, which is not possible for a person
who has mentioned that her occupation is that of a Tailor. Moreover
the witnesses stated that the claimant/respondent No.1 was
performing her job of tailoring from her home whereas the claimant
in her own statement before the Tribunal has deposed that she was
owned a Tailor Shop at Dinanagar, which are ambiguous statements
of claimant and her witnesses;
VIII.
That the claimant does not know the basis of tailoring, this fact
is evident from the statement of the claimant and the learned
Presiding Officer has not appreciated this fact and held that the
claimant was a tailor by profession;
IX. That the learned Tribunal has also awarded Rs.1,00,000/- each for
pain and suffering and for loss of amenities of life, which is at
higher side;
X. That the learned Tribunal has also awarded Rs.1,50,000/- as cost of
artificial limb, which is available free of cost at the Govt. Hospitals
as stated by the expert witness Doctor; and
XI. That the learned Tribunal has exceeded its jurisdiction in passing
the award impugned.’
3.
Succinctly stated the facts of the case which led to the filing of this appeal
are that on 17.04.2019, respondent No.1-Rajni Devi while standing by the side of
parked scooty (PB06AQ/5761) at Kunjwani Chowk, Jammu was hit by the
offending vehicle (JK05B-7161) driven in a rash manner, causing serious injuries
Mac App No.2/2024
to the respondent no.1, which resulted in loss of her right arm right from the
shoulder; that the respondent no.1 had to be shifted to GMCH, Jammu, wherefrom,
after initial treatment, she was taken to Amandeep Hospital Amritsar for further
treatment, where she underwent two surgeries and suffered excruciating pain; that
based on the aforesaid accident, a case came to be registered vide FIR No.33/2019
in Police Station Gangyal, Jammu and after investigation, challan was produced
against driver of the offending vehicle U/Ss 279/337/338 RPC in the court of law,
for judicial determination.
4.
The respondent No.1-Rajni Devi (hereinafter called as ‘claimant’) filed a
claim petition before the Tribunal, seeking compensation in terms of Motor
Vehicle Act, for her disability, on various counts, pleading that she suffered
disability as her right arm was amputated, resulting into loss of income; that she
before her accident was in the job of Tailoring and Embroidery with monthly
income of Rs.30,000/- to Rs.40,000/-.
5.
The appellant/insurer filed its objections before the Tribunal and opposed the
claim petition while respondents 2 and 3-registered owner and driver of the
offending vehicle on their failure to respond to the notices, were proceeded ex parte
vide order dated 12.10.2021; that the learned Tribunal vide its judgment dated
02.11.2023 directed the appellant-Insurance Company to pay Rs.37,52,600/- as
compensation in favour of the claimant-Rajni Devi. Aggrieved of the award
impugned, the appellant/insurer has filed the present appeal before this court on the
grounds as indicated in para 2 of this Judgment.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/insurer argued that the income of the
claimant was accepted wrongly by the Tribunal below, as Rs.12,000/- per month
from her work of tailoring. She has argued that the claimant, being a resident of
Mac App No.2/2024
Jammu, had met with an accident at Jammu had, however, shown that she had a
tailoring shop at Dinanagar in Punjab; that the Tribunal has relied upon the
improbable evidence produced by the claimant with regard to her income; that the
husband of the claimant, a Carpenter, was shown having maximum monthly
income of Rs.6000/-, whereas the claimant herself has claimed that she had
monthly income of more than Rs.30,000/-, however, the Tribunal without any
reliable evidence wrongly accepted the same as Rs.12,000/- notionally, and thus,
the Tribunal has committed an error in computing and assessing the compensation
awarded to the claimant. She, further, argued that though there was no reliable
proof with regard to the avocation of the claimant with regard to tailoring,
however, even if, it is assumed that she was having a profession of tailoring, her
income, at the most, could have been taken and accepted as per the Minimum
Wages Act, notified by the Government in the year when she had met with an
accident.
7.
She has also argued that the Tribunal has granted cost of artificial limb to the
claimant in the amount of Rs.1,50,000/- without any evidence as the claimant has
failed to produce any evidence so as to show as to how much is the cost of the
artificial limb required by her. She drew the attention of this court towards the
statement of the doctor examined by the claimant in support of her claim, who had
stated that the artificial limb is available free of cost to the needy persons in govt.
hospitals, as such, no amount of compensation should have been granted under the
heading ‘Cost of Artificial Limb’. She has, finally, argued that the compensation as
awarded by the Tribunal be reviewed and re-assessed so that fair and just
compensation is granted to the claimant, instead of exorbitant amount granted by
the Tribunal.
Mac App No.2/2024
8.
The learned counsel for the respondent-Claimant, ex adverso, argued that the
appellant has unnecessarily filed this appeal against the claimant, a poor lady, who
was rendered disabled, as she had lost her right arm in the accident after receiving
injuries in the accident, involving the offending vehicle insured with the appellant,
her right arm had been amputated right from the shoulder, as such, she was
incapacitated 100% in her functional capacity to work as a tailor or to do any of the
household activities. He argued that the Tribunal had rightly accepted the income
of the claimant as Rs.12000/- per month from the work of tailoring based on the
evidence led by the claimant and, without there being any evidence in rebuttal, it
cannot be stated that the claimant had income less than Rs.12000/- per month as
accepted by the Tribunal. He further argued that Dr. Suhail Bashir, who had been
examined with regard to injuries by the claimant had stated that the petitioner
suffered 85% permanent disability, however, the Tribunal has taken the functional
disability as 100%, in view of amputation of the right arm, incapacitating the
claimant to perform the work of tailoring/embroidery.
9.
Heard learned counsel for both the sides, perused the record and considered
the matter.
10.
The notional income of the petitioner as a skilled worker was accepted at
Rs.12000/- per month by the Tribunal. The income was added with 40 % following
the principle laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Prannoy Sethi’s case (AIR
2017 SC 5157) under the principle of future prospects. Having regard to the age of
the claimant at the time of accident as 34 years, the multiplier of 16 was used to
assess the loss of future income of the claimant, in view of principles laid down by
the Apex Court in Sarla Verma’s case (AIR 2009 SC 3104), besides granting
compensation on account of ‘pain and suffering’, ‘loss of amenities of life’, ‘cost of
Mac App No.2/2024
artificial limb’ and ‘medical expenses. As such, the total compensation was granted
to the tune of Rs.37,52,600/- along with interest @ 7.5 per cent per annum.
11.
The respondent-Rajni Devi in her statement had claimed that as she was
doing the job of tailoring and embroidery at Dinanagar, Punjab and she was having
monthly income of Rs.30,000/- pm to Rs.40,000/- and that because of losing her
right arm from the level of shoulder due to the accident, she had lost her 100%
earning capacity. The other witnesses examined by her had also supported her on
these aspects.
12.
The Tribunal below had accepted the monthly income of the claimant at
Rs.12,000/- per month based on Minimum Wages Act. The learned counsel for the
parties on persistent asking could not produce any notification of the Labour and
Employment Department of Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir, with regard to minimum
wages. This Court has, however, found a notification (SRO 460) dated 26.10.2017
whereby the daily minimum wages for semi-skilled workers had been fixed by the
Government at Rs. 350/- per day. In the considered opinion of this court, income
was to be assessed at the minimum wages notified by the Government, when there
is no conclusive proof with regard to the income of the claimant.
13.
In the present case, the claimant except making bald statement with regard to
her income ranging from Rs.30,000/- to Rs.35,000/-, had not produced any
document in support of her claim as at least she could have shown her bank pass
book to substantiate her claim. In absence of any definite and conclusive proof with
regard to income, it was incumbent upon the Tribunal below to accept the
minimum wages notified by the Government. The income is thus, accepted of the
claimant as per the Minimum Wages notified as Rs.350/- per day for a semi-skilled
worker. Having accepted the monthly income of the claimant as Rs.10,500/- per
Mac App No.2/2024
month, the loss of future income of the claimant is required to be computed afresh,
besides maintaining the amount of compensation granted under the other heads as
it is, there being no illegality.
14.
The next contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the amount
of Rs.1,50,000/- granted under the head of ‘cost of artificial limb’ should not have
been granted as such an artificial limb is provided to the victims free of cost in
Govt. hospitals as had been stated by the doctor examined by the claimant herself
before the court below. This contention of the learned counsel is not worth
consideration for the simple reason that it is for the victim to decide as to
wherefrom and what kind of medical aid she or he has to receive and the victim
cannot be made to approach the govt. hospital only as he/she may require the best
services if may be available in the private sector. On a rough estimate, an amount
of Rs.1,50,000/- by no stretch of imagination, can be stated to be on higher side as
granted by the Tribunal below under the head of ‘cost of artificial limb. The
contention, on this count, of the learned counsel for the appellant is, thus, rejected.
15.
The claimant as per evidence led by her and there being no rebuttal, had a
shop of tailoring and embroidery, as such, with amputation of her right arm from
shoulder, it can be safely held that she suffered 100% loss of income, having been
permanently disabled. By applying the principles laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Sarla Verma’s case and also Pranay Sethi’s case, the multiplier of 16
and an addition of 40% to the income of the self employed person of the age group
of the claimant is applied as such, the loss of future income of the petitioner is
required to be computed afresh. Monthly income of Rs.10,500/- with addition of its
40%, comes to (10,500+4200) Rs.14,700/- and annually as (14,700 x 12)
Rs.1,76,400/-. Having regard to the age of the claimant, multiplier of 16 is required
Mac App No.2/2024
to be applied to work out future loss of income, with 100% functional disability.
With application of 16 as Multiplier, the total loss of future income comes to
(176400 x 16) Rs.28,22,400/-. There is no illegality in grant of compensation under
the other heads, which are maintained.
16.
Having regard to the discussion made hereinabove and aforestated reasons,
the impugned award is ordered to be modified as under:
HEADS
GRANTED
MODIFIED
Loss of future income
Rs.32,52,640/-
Rs. 28,22,400/-
For pain and suffering
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Loss of amenities of life
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Cost of artificial limb
Rs. 1,50,000/-
Rs. 1,50,000/-
Medical expenses
Rs. 1,77,040/-
Rs. 1,77,040/-
RS.37,52,600/-
Rs. 33,49,440/-
TOTAL
With the above modification in the impugned order, the same shall be enforced
with the interest granted therein, in terms of the impugned award. The awarded
amount, if deposited in this court, is ordered to be paid to the claimant and the
excess, if any, shall be refunded to the appellant under rules.
17.
The appeal is partly allowed and the impugned award is modified as above.
18.
Trial court record, along with copy of this judgment be sent back.
(M A CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Jammu
09.02.2026
Raj Kumar
Raj Kumar
2026.02.09 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Mac App No.2/2024
Whether the order is reportable?:
Whether the order is speaking?:
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review