The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 08.2021 is set aside. The application filed by the petitioner for leading evidence is restored to the file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate who shall examine the application and the materials placed afresh as per law and pass appropriate orders after giving an opportunity to the respondents to rebut the evidence sought to be produced and after hearing the parties. Needless to say the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate shall also consider the genuineness and authenticity of the evidence, including as to whether the contents thereof have been proved by the party relying W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021 Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr. thereon. In view of the judgment the application for stay filed by the petitioner is rendered infructuous and accordingly disposed.
18. The petition is allowed. No order as to cost. ( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan ) Judge Approved for reporting Internet to/ : Yes/No : Yes/No
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Smt. Rekha Jain,
W/o Shri. Anil Jain,
R/o D.P.H. Road, Near Janta Bhawan,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
….. Petitioner
Versus
1.
Shri Anil Jain,
S/o Babulal Jain,
R/o Sudarshan Telecom,
Serial no.208,
Daisy Building Neco Garden Comples,
Opp. Zee5 experience LOFT, Vimar Nagar,
Pune-411014.
2.
Smt. Pista Devi Jain,
Wife of Babulal Jain,
R/o Sudarshan Telecom,
Serial no. 208,
Daisy Building Neco Garden Complex,
Opp. Zee5 experience LOFT
Vimar Nagar,
Pune-411014.
.... Respondents
Application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Karma Tshering Tamang, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Ms. Gita Bista, Advocate for the respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing
:
11.03.2022 & 01.04.2022
Date of Judgment
:
01.04.2022
J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
The
present
petition
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India seeks to challenge an order dated
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
20.08.2021 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
rejecting the petitioner’s application for leading evidence.
2.
The petitioner had preferred a petition under section 12
of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act,
2005 (Domestic Violence Act) seeking reliefs under Section
17, 18, 19 (f), 20 and 21 thereof.
3.
On 24.09.2019 the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
passed interim orders of protection in favour of the
petitioner.
4.
On 23.07.2021, during the proceedings, the petitioner
moved an application to place certain electronic evidence
(the application) through witness no.2 (Promod Jain) and to
re-examine the petitioner on the limited aspect. The
application also disclosed the type of evidence the petitioner
was seeking to lead, its relevancy as well as the fact that she
had recently traced the same. The relevant print outs of the
electronic evidence was also placed for perusal before the
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate.
5.
On 20.08.2021 the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
disposed of the application for leading evidence on the
ground that neither the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(Cr.P.C.) nor the Domestic Violence Act allows a witness to
file documents on behalf of the aggrieved party and
therefore, even though these records may prove necessary
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
for proper adjudication of the case, in the absence of any
provision that can allow a witness of a party to file
documents, the application was rejected. The petitioner is
aggrieved.
6.
Heard Mr. Karma Tshering Tamang, learned counsel for
the petitioner as well as Ms. Gita Bista, learned counsel for
the respondents.
7.
Mr. Tamang took this court through the provisions of
the Domestic Violence Act as well as the Cr.P.C. and
submitted that the procedure that ought to have been
followed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate was the
summary procedure under the Cr.P.C. which provides for
taking evidence in the manner provided in those provisions.
It is his submission therefore, the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate was not correct in holding that there was no
provision to take evidence. Ms. Gita Bista on the other hand
vehemently opposed the present petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India. She submits that the petition is
not maintainable and if the procedure to be followed in
domestic violence cases is the criminal procedure, the
petitioner ought to have approached this court under section
482 Cr.P.C. and not under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. She further submits that the application for seeking to
lead evidence is grossly delayed in as much as it was filed 18
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
months after the petition under section 12 of the Domestic
Violence Act had been filed. It is also her submission that
the petitioner has not approached this court with clean
hands and material facts have been suppressed. Further, the
learned counsel submits that the application lacks the
necessary pleadings.
8.
Sub-section (1) of section 28 of the Domestic Violence
Act provides that proceedings under section 12, 18, 19, 20,
21, 22 and 23 and offences under section 31 shall be
governed by the provisions of the Cr.P.C. Sub-section (2) of
section 28 provides that nothing in sub-section (1) shall
prevent the court from laying down its own procedure for
disposal of an application under section 12 or under subsection (2) of section 23.
9.
In Kunapareddy Alias Nookala Shanka Balaji vs. Kunapareddy
Swarna Kumari1 the Supreme Court examined whether a
court dealing with the petition/complaint filed under the
provisions of the Domestic Violence Act has power to allow
amendment to the petition/complaint originally filed. The
appellant therein had raised an objection that there was no
power with the court to allow amendment to such a petition
in the Cr.P.C. The Supreme Court examined the Domestic
Violence Act and held that the very purpose of enacting it
(2016) 11 SCC 774
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
was to provide for a remedy which is an amalgamation of
civil rights of the complainant i.e. the aggrieved person.
Intension was to protect women against violence of any kind,
especially that occurring within the family as the civil law
does not address these phenomena in its entirety. The
purpose of enacting the law was to provide a remedy in the
civil law for the protection of women from being victims of
domestic violence and to prevent the occurrence of domestic
violence in the society. It is for this reason, that the scheme
of the Domestic Violence Act provides that in the first
instance, the order that would be passed by the Magistrate,
on a complaint by the aggrieved person, would be of civil
nature and if the said order is violated, it assumes the
character of criminality.
10. The Supreme Court thus concluded that:
“16.
We understood in this backdrop, it
cannot be said that the court dealing with the
application under the DV Act has no power and/or
jurisdiction to allow the amendment of the said
application. If the amendment becomes necessary
in view of subsequent events (escalation of prices in
the instant case) or to avoid multiplicity of litigation,
court will have the power to permit such an
amendment. It is said that procedure is the
handmaid of justice and is to come to the aid of the
justice rather than defeating it. It is nobody's case
that Respondent 1 was not entitled to file another
application claiming the reliefs which she sought to
include in the pending application by way of
amendment. If that be so, we see no reason, why
the applicant be not allowed to incorporate this
amendment in the pending application rather than
filing a separate application. It is not that there is a
complete ban/bar of amendment in the complaints
in criminal courts which are governed by the Code,
though undoubtedly such power to allow the
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
amendment has to be exercised sparingly and with
caution under limited circumstances. ................”
11. Rule 6 of the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Rules, 2006 (Domestic Violence Rules) provides for
procedure for dealing with applications to the Magistrate
under section 12. Rule 6(5) of the Domestic Violence Rules
provides that the applications under section 12 shall be
dealt with and the orders enforced in a same manner laid
down under section 125 of Cr.P.C. Section 125 of Cr.P.C.
deals with orders for maintenance of wives, children and
parents. An order of maintenance as provided under section
125 of Cr.P.C. can be passed by a Magistrate of the I st class
“upon proof of such neglect or refusal”. Sub-section (2) of
section 126 provides that all “evidence” to such proceedings
under section 125 shall be taken in the presence of the
person against whom an order for payment of maintenance
is proposed to be made, or, when his personal attendance is
dispensed with in the presence of his pleader, and shall be
recorded in the manner prescribed for summons-cases.
Under the proviso thereof if the Magistrate is satisfied that
the
person
against
whom
an
order
for
payment
of
maintenance is proposed to be made is willfully avoiding
service, or willfully neglecting to attend the Court, the
Magistrate may proceed to hear and determine the case ex
parte.
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
12. The Supreme Court in Dwarika Prasad Satpathy vs.
Bidyut Prava Dixit2 held that validity of the marriage for the
purpose of summary proceedings under section 125 of
Cr.P.C. is to be determined on the basis of the evidence
brought on record by the parties. The standard of proof of
marriage in such proceedings is not as strict as is required
in a trial of offence under section 494 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (IPC).
13. Section 262 Cr.P.C. provides that summary trials shall
follow the summons case trials procedure. The summons
cases procedure under Chapter XX of Cr.P.C. provides for
taking evidence in the manner prescribed.
14. Evidence is vital in any adjudication. The courts should
not normally shun evidence without examining its relevance.
The fact that the legislature itself has provided in subsection (2) of section 28 that nothing in sub-section (1) shall
prevent the court from laying down its own procedure for
disposal of an application under section 12 of the Domestic
Violence Act makes it evident that the Magistrate has been
given wide discretion to ensure procedural justice. While
appreciating an application or a petition the courts are
obligated to examine the substance of the application and
the grievance of the applicant. A perusal of the application
(1999) 7 SCC 675
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
makes it evident that the petitioner was seeking to lead
evidence before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate took a
decision on the merits of the petition filed by her. It was filed
during the subsistence of the proceeding under section 12 of
the Domestic Violence Act. It was not grossly delayed as
suggested. It transpires that the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate was more focused on the technical flaw in the
petition and could not find any provision allowing a witness
to file documents on behalf of the aggrieved party. That was
not what was sought for in the application. The petitioner
was simply seeking to lead evidence which she thought
would be relevant for her to succeed in the proceedings.
15. The procedure to be followed in dealing with a petition
under section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act is the
summons case trials summary procedure as provided in
Cr.P.C. which permits the court to take evidence.
16. Article 227 of the Constitution of India provides the
jurisdictional High Court with the power of superintendence
over all courts subordinate to it. The courts of the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrates within the territory of Sikkim are
subject to the power of superintendence of this court. In
Shalini Shyam Shetty vs. Rajendra Shankar Patil3 relied upon
by the learned counsel for the respondents, the Supreme
(2010) 8 SCC 329
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
Court, on an analysis of its earlier judgments, laid down
certain principles for the exercise of the High Court’s
jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. It
held that the High Court can also interfere in exercise of its
power of superintendence when there has been patent
perversity
in
the
orders
of
the
tribunal
and
courts
subordinate to it or where there has been a gross and
manifest failure of justice or the basic principles of natural
justice have been flouted. In the present case there has been
manifest failure of justice by not examining the application
for leading evidence on the ground that there is no provision
to do so even though those materials may prove necessary
for proper adjudication.
17. In the circumstances, the impugned order dated
20.08.2021 is set aside. The application filed by the
petitioner for leading evidence is restored to the file of the
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate who shall examine the
application and the materials placed afresh as per law and
pass appropriate orders after giving an opportunity to the
respondents to rebut the evidence sought to be produced
and after hearing the parties. Needless to say the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate shall also consider the genuineness
and authenticity of the evidence, including as to whether the
contents thereof have been proved by the party relying
W.P. (Crl.) No. 02 of 2021
Rekha Jain vs. Anil Jain & Anr.
thereon. In view of the judgment the application for stay filed
by the petitioner is rendered infructuous and accordingly
disposed.
18. The petition is allowed. No order as to cost.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes/No
: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review