Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
!
! #
"
&
"
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$ "
"
$
#%
"
!
"
''
( ' )
"
"
''
"
"
''
! ! "#
$
%
&
'
!
(
)
(
"! % '
&
-2-
"
*
(
+
!!
(
"
#
! ! "#
(
!,
(
! !
(
)"
(
+
(
&
)
!
(
!)
(
!
,
(
&
)
(
(
(
#
(
! ! "#
#
(
(
#
! ! "#
$
%
!
)
#
'
-3-
+
,
&
% '
" "
&
" ""
.
(
(
! ! "#
%
&
'
!
(
(
(
"! % '
&
"
*
(
+
!
(
"
#
! ! "#
-4-
(
!
(
! !
(
)"
(
+
(
&
)
!
(
!#
(
!
,
(
&
)
(
(
(
(
! ! "#
#
(
(
! ! "#
%
'
% '
,
" "
&
&
" ""
.
(
-5-
(
(
(
)
.
! !
"
*
(
+
)
.
! !
! !
(
!,
.
(
%
! !
'
!
-6-
! !
"
(
)
.
! !
/
.
) )
(
!
.
! !
(
(
#
.
! !
!
(
&
(
(
&
(
.
!
%
&
"-
",
" ")
(
++++
,
'
" "
'
%1'
(
-7-
&
+++ +
"
" ""
&
&
'
'
&
(
&
$ !
4565 7885796 715 71:6:;< =>? =@ ?45
,
" "
=
=>1?
87665A
=;
" "" =; ?45 @:95 =@
=6
5;:=1
767B7C79D7; %@=1 6=1? E?45 1:79
"
"
1A51 A7?5A
7;A
:;
:B:9 &>A<5 7;A &
=>1?2'
=1 ?45 67C5 =@ F=;B5;:5;F5 ?45 871?:56 G:99 H5
15@5115A ?= 76 851 ?45:1 17;C:;< H5@=15 ?45 1:79
=>1?
45 1595B7;? @7F?6 @=1 7AI>A:F7?:=; =@ ?4565
7885796
=
?47?
?45
897:;?:@@6
47B5
815@5115A
" "" 7<7:;6? ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 655C:;< 159:5@ =@
871?:?:=; 7;A 658717?5 8=66566:=; :; 15685F? =@ ?45 6>:?
-8-
6F45A>95 81=851?:56
5@5;A7;?
=
:6 ?45 @7?451 =@ ?45
897:;?:@@6
45 897:;?:@@6 47B5 815@5115A
,
>95
7;A " =@
=
>;A51 =1A51
655C:;< :;?51:J J576>15 156?17:;:;<
?45 A5@5;A7;?6 ;=? ?= 79:5;7?5 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56
45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; F7J5 ?= H5 799=G5A HD ?45 1:79
?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 A7?5A
HD
?45
67J5
)
" "
="
!
,
A5@5;A7;?
5@5;A7;?
" "
7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A
=
=
=6 "
815@5115A
476 @:95A
:;?51:J J576>15 156?17:;:;< ?45 897:;?:@@
A5@5;A7;?
=>1? HD
=
=6
655C:;<
" 7;A
7;A
7;A ! @1=J :;?51@51:;< G:?4 ?45 6>:?
6F45A>95 81=851?:56 7;A ?45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; F7J5 ?= H5
A:6J:665A HD ?45
67J5
?45
="
")
)
1:79
A5@5;A7;?
=
815@5115A
" "
97:;?:@@6 47B5 @:95A
7;A " 157A G:?4
A5@5;A7;?
=>1? 7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A HD ?45
5F?:=;
= " >;A51
!
=@
1A51
,
>95
?= 156?17:; ?45
= ! @1=J :;?51@51:;< G:?4 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95
-9-
81=851?:56 7;A ?45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; F7J5 ?= H5 871?9D 799=G5A
HD ?45
1:79
=>1? 7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A HD ?45 67J5 ?45
897:;?:@@6 47B5 815@5115A
#
571A
1:
="
7F4:;
788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
,
" "
747I7;
=
1:
F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 897:;?:@@6 7;A
9571;5A F=>;659
7B:
7?:9 9571;5A
1:
71647B71A47;
79:87?:9 9571;5A F=>;659 @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
1:
7F4:;
788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
747I7;
=
=>1? 476 5115A :; 799=G:;<
=
9571;5A
F=>;659
F=;?5;A5A ?47? ?45
=6
1:79
7;A " @:95A HD ?45
897:;?:@@6 655C:;< 159:5@ =@ :;?51:J :;I>;F?:=; 7<7:;6? ?45
A5@5;A7;?6 ;=? ?= :;?51@515 G:?4 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56
HD ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 76 G599 76 156?17:;:;< ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 @1=J
79:5;7?:;< ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56
? :6 F=;?5;A5A HD ?45
9571;5A F=>;659 @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
?47? ?45
=
1:79
=>1?
:; ?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 6=959D H765A =; ?45 &>A<J5;? =@ ?4:6
=>1? :; ?45 F765 =@
158=1?5A :;
799=G5A ?45 7889:F7?:=;6 7;A @>1?451 F=;?5;A5A
- 10 -
?47? ?45 @:;A:;< 15F=1A5A HD ?45
15685F? ?= 8717<1784
?45
1:79
=
1:79
=>1? 871?:F>9719D G:?4
15K>:156 ?= H5 :;?51@515A G:?4 76
=>1? 476 ;=? 81=8519D 78815F:7?5A ?45 J7?51:79 =;
15F=1A 76 ?= ?45 @7F? ?47?
?45 A5@5;A7;?
=
H5:;< ?45
71?47 =@ ?45 I=:;? @7J:9D =@ ?45 897:;?:@@6 7;A ?45 A5@5;A7;?
=
=><4? ?= 47B5 ?7C5; F51?7:; 6?586 :;F9>A:;< ?= J7:;?7:;
7;A ?= ?7C5 F715 =@ ?45 7@@7:16 =@ ?45 97;A :; K>56?:=; 7;A ?45
67:A 7685F? =@ ?45 J7??51 G76 ;=? 81=8519D 78815F:7?5A HD
?45
1:79
=>1? 7;A 76 6>F4 :? :6 71<>5A ?47? ?45
511=;5=>69D 799=G5A
=6
1:79
=>1?
7;A " G4:F4 15K>:156 ?= H5
:;?51@515A G:?4 :; ?4565 7885796
,
? :6 796= F=;?5;A5A HD ?45 9571;5A F=>;659
788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
=
&>A<J5;? =@
=>1? :; ?45 F765 =@
=;2H95
>815J5
158=1?5A :;
A5@5;A7;?
!"#
=
H5:;< ?45
HD 15@511:;< ?= ?45
7;A F=;?5;A5A ?47?
?45
71?47 =@ ?45 I=:;? @7J:9D :;?5;A6
?= ?7C5 F715 =@ ?45 7@@7:16 =@ ?45 81=851?D @=1 95<79 ;5F566:?D
7;A :; ?47? 5B5;? ?4515 :6 7 :J85A:J5;? @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
=
?= A579 G:?4 ?45 81=851?:56 G4= :6 156:A:;< :; ?45 B:997<5
- 11 -
7;A ?7C:;< F715 =@ ?45 7@@7:16 =@ ?45 97;A :; K>56?:=; 7;A
7FF=1A:;<9D 6=><4? @=1 :;?51@515;F5 =@ ?4:6
51 F=;?17
1:
7B:
7?:9
=>1?
9571;5A F=>;659
788571:;< @=1 ?45 897:;?:@@6 F=;?5;A5A ?47?
?4515 G76 7
5719:51 871?:?:=; H5?G55; ?45 871?:56 76 ?= ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95
81=851?:56 :6 F=;F51;5A
7;A ?45 67:A 7685F? 476 H55;
7AJ:??5A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;?
=
=>1? 476 1:<4?9D 799=G5A
15K>:156 :;?51@515;F5 HD ?4:6
7;A ?4515@=15
=6
7;A " G4:F4 A= ;=?
7B:
= " :; 871? @:95A HD ?45
897:;?:@@6 :6 F=;F51;5A
1:
71<>5A ?47? ?45
=>1? 476 799=G5A
7<7:;6? A5@5;A7;?
1:79
=>1?
;6=@71 76 799=G:;< =@
1:79
?45
7?:9 9571;5A F=>;659 476
= " 871?9D =;9D
= ! G:?4=>? 78815F:7?:;< ?45 685F:@:F
7B51J5;?6 J7A5 :; ?45 G1:??5; 6?7?5J5;? =@ A5@5;A7;?
=
?47?
=!
J=15 685F:@:F799D ?45 97;A H571:;<
>1B5D
J576>1:;<
7F156 6?7;A:;< :; ?45 ;7J5 =@ ?45 897:;?:@@6 @=1
J=15 ?47; "
D5716 7;A ?4515@=15 6=><4? @=1 :;?51@515;F5 =@
?4:6
=>1?
- 12 -
"
1:
71647B71A47;
788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
79:87?:9 9571;5A F=>;659
=
:J8><;5A =1A51 87665A HD ?45 1:79
6=><4? ?= I>6?:@D ?45
=>1? =;
=
; ?45 9:<4? =@ ?45 6>HJ:66:=;6 J7A5 HD ?45
9571;5A F=>;6596 @=1 ?45 871?:56 :? :6 ;=? :; A:68>?5 ?47? ?45
897:;?:@@6 715 ?45 F4:9A15; =@ A5@5;A7;?
=
658717?5
=
45 6>:? :;
" "" :6 @:95A 655C:;< 159:5@ =@ 871?:?:=; 7;A
8=66566:=;
81=851?:56
:;
;A:68>?7H9D
15685F?
?45
=@
?45
6>:?
6F45A>95
897:;?:@@6 76 G599
76 ?45
A5@5;A7;?6 47B5 F=;6?1>5A ?45 @7F? ?47? ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95
81=851?:56 715 ?45 I=:;? @7J:9D 81=851?:56 :; ?45 7889:F7?:=;
; ?45 H7FCA1=8 =@ ?4565 7685F?6 6:;F5 ?45 897:;?:@@6 47B5
?7C5; 7 8957 76 ?= ?45 81:=1 871?:?:=; :; ?45 I=:;? @7J:9D 7;A
?45 67:A 7685F? 476 H55; F=;6:A515A :; ?45 G1:??5; 6?7?5J5;?
@:95A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;?
?47? ?45
1:79
=
7;A ?4515@=15
=>1? 476 1:<4?9D 799=G5A
7J =@ ?45 B:5G
=6
7;A " @:95A
HD ?45 897:;?:@@6 156?17:;:;< ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 @1=J 79:5;7?:;<
?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 76 G599 76 ;=? ?= :;?51@515 G:?4
?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 ?:99 ?45 F=;F9>6:=; =@ ?45
81=F55A:;<6 715 F=;F51;5A
? :6 796= ?= H5 ;=?5A ?47? :; 7
- 13 -
6>:? @=1 871?:?:=; ?45 A7><4?516 =1 ?45 6=;6 =@ ?45 81=8=6:?>6
715 47B:;< 64715 :; ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 7;A :; ?47?
B:5G =@ ?45 J7??51 ?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 87665A HD ?45
=>1? =;
=6
1:79
7;A " :6 I>6? 7;A 81=851 7;A ;=
:;?51@515;F5 :6 F7995A @=1 :; ?4565 7885796
4=><4
1:
7F4:;
788571:;< @=1 A5@5;A7;?
=
>99
=>1?
5;F4
=@
?4:6
747I7; 9571;5A F=>;659
15@516 ?= ?45 &>A<J5;? =@ ?45
:;
?45
7;A ?45 &>A<J5;? =@
=>1? :; ?45 F765 =@
?45
1:79
F765
=@
=;2H95
>815J5
%15@5115A 6>817' 4=G5B51
=>1? 47B:;< ?7C5; ;=?5 =@ ?45 @7F?>79 7685F?6 =;
15F=1A 76 ?= ?45 @7F? ?47? ?45 6>:? :6 =;5 @=1 871?:?:=; 7;A
658717?5 8=66566:=; :; 15685F? =@ ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?D
7;A :; ?47? B:5G =@ ?45 J7??51 ?45 F=;?5;?:=; 17:65A HD ?45
9571;5A F=>;659 @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;?
!
=
F7;;=? H5 7FF58?5A
;6=@71 76 ?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 87665A HD ?45 1:79
=>1? =;
=
A:6J:66:;< ?45 7889:F7?:=; @:95A HD ?45
A5@5;A7;?
=
>;A51
F=;F51;5A
G4515:;
1A51
,
>95
7;A " =@
:6
?45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; G76 @:95A HD ?45
- 14 -
A5@5;A7;?
=
A5@5;A7;?
=6 "
156?17:;:;< ?45 897:;?:@@
=6
"
7;A
7;A ! @1=J :;?51@51:;< 7;A =H6?1>F?:;<
?45:1 97G@>9 8=66566:=; 7;A 5;I=DJ5;? =@ ?45 A5@5;A7;?
:; 15685F? =@ 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?D
7?
7;A 64=8 81=851?:56 ?:99 A:68=679 =@ ?45 6>:?
=
: 5 4=>65
; ?4:6 15<71A
=; F715@>9 F=;6:A517?:=; =@ ?45 @:;A:;< 15F=1A5A HD ?45
=>1? 7? 8717<1784
6F45A>95
=6
! ?=
81=851?:56 7?
=
1:79
# J7C56 :? F9571 ?47? ?45 6>:?
=
:5
4=>65 7;A 64=8
81=851?:56 715 ?45 7;F56?179 81=851?:56 7;A 796= ?45 64=8
81=851?:56 715 F=;6?1>5A 76 F=871F5;516 81=851?:56 7;A :;
?47? B:5G =@ ?45 J7??51 ?7C:;< :;?= F=;6:A517?:=; 76 ?45 1:79
=>1? 476 711:B5A 7? 7 F=;F9>6:=; ?47? ?45 7AI>A:F7?:=; =@ ?45
6>:? 15K>:156 ?= A5?51J:;5 ?45 1:<4?6 =@ ?45 871?:56
7J =@
?45 B:5G ?47?
;= :;?51@515;F5 :6 F7995A @=1 :;6=@71 76
A:6J:66:;<
=
@:95A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;?
:J8><;5A =1A51 81=A>F5A 7?
)
;;5L>15
; ?47? B:5G =@ ?45 J7??51
=
76 851 ?45
?= ?45 788579
7J =@ ?45 B:5G ?47?
;= :;?51@515;F5 :6 F7995A @=1 :; ?4565 7885796 7;A 7FF=1A:;<9D
?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 87665A HD ?45 1:79
7;A
15K>:156 ?= H5 F=;@:1J5A
=>1? =;
=6
"
- 15 -
#
7C:;<
:;?=
F=;6:A517?:=;
?45
71<>J5;?6
7AB7;F5A HD ?45 9571;5A F=>;6596 788571:;< @=1 ?45 871?:56
?45
1:79
=>1? :6 15K>56?5A ?= 5L85A:?5 5719D 4571:;< @=1
156=9>?:=; =@ ?45 A:68>?5
1A515A 7FF=1A:;<9D
(
:6?
=
=
#
"
"*
!
$ !
" )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review