Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1099
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 90 of 2023
Date of Decision: 02.12.2024
Shri. Regeenal Shylla
S/o Smti. Shintirise Shylla,
R/o Moolang, East Jaintia Hills District
Meghalaya – 793160
-Vs1. State of Meghalaya
Through the Chief Secretary,
Office at: The Secretariat,
MG Road, Secretariat Hills,
Shillong, Meghalaya – 793001
2.Commissioner and Secretary,
Government of Meghalaya Mining
and Geology Department, The Secretariat,
MG Road, Secretariat Hills, Shillong,
Meghalaya – 793001
3.The Secretary, Forest and Environment
Department, Government of Meghalaya
The Secretariat, MG Road, Secretariat Hills,
Shillong, Meghalaya
4.Principal Chief Conservator of Forest(HoFF)
Government of Meghalaya, Sylvan House,
Lower Lachumiere, Shillong
:::Petitioner
2024:MLHC:1099
5.Secretary/Executive Committee of the KHADC
(Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council),
Shillong
6.Secretary/Executive Committee of the JHADC
(Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council),
Jowai
7.Secretary/Executive Committee of the GHADC
(Garo Hills Autonomous District Council),
Tura
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. L.M. Sangma, Adv.
Ms. D. Pala, Adv.
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mrs. N.G.Shylla, Sr. GA
Mr. A. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
Mr. J.N. Rynjah, GA(For R 1-4)
Mr. V.G.K. Kynta, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. C. Nongkhlaw, Adv. (For R 5)
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv. (For R 6)
Ms. L. Langi, Adv. vice
Mr. S. Dey, Adv. (For R 7).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:1099
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner by way of the instant writ application has assailed the
impugned Office Memorandum being No. MG.60/2014/Pt/398 dated
05.03.2021, whereby the same has prescribed at clause – E(6), that an
application for prospecting license for coal shall be for an area not less than
100 hectares. The contentions of the petitioner are that the said clause in
the Office Memorandum dated 05.03.2021, is not in consonance with the
Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act 1957, hereinafter
referred to as the MMDR Act, the Mineral Concession Rules 1960, and
also not in conformity with the Meghalaya Mines and Mineral Policy 2012,
the Meghalaya Minor Minerals Concession Rules, 2016, and the
Meghalaya Minerals (Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and
Storage) Rules, 2022.
2.
The basic ground or contention is that the impugned Office
Memorandum has been issued against the principles of delegated
legislation and the land ownership system of the State of Meghalaya.
3.
Mr. L.M. Sangma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has submitted that the State respondents do not have any
jurisdiction to issue their stipulation, inasmuch as, firstly, Section 6 of the
MMDR Act though providing for maximum area for prospecting, the said
2024:MLHC:1099
Act does not prescribe the minimum area nor does the Mineral Concession
Rules, 1960 prescribe the minimum area 100 hectares for grant of
prospecting license or mining lease for coal. In his submissions the learned
counsel has referred to Section 6 of the MMDR Act, and has also taken the
Court to Sections 15, 15-A and 23-C of the MMDR Act, that deals with the
powers of the State Government to make rules, with regard to mines and
minerals. The learned counsel has contended that in these provisions, there
is nothing to show that the limit prescribed of not less than 100 hectares, is
based on any provision of law, and that even in the Meghalaya Mines and
Minerals Policy, 2012, at clauses – 5.1 and 5.2., which deals with grant of
permission for prospecting licenses, the same does not empower the
respondents to prescribe the minimum area. It has been further argued that
even in the Meghalaya Minor Minerals Concession Rules, 2016 framed by
the State Government in exercise of powers conferred by Section 15 of the
MMDR Act, at Section 13 thereof, which deals with the area of mining
lease, no provision of a minimum area of 100 hectares is present.
4.
It is also submitted that in addition to the arbitrary fixation of the
minimum area, the impugned memorandum dated 05.03.2021, also
mandates a declaration of ownership and in the check list provided therein,
the requirement of furnishing a certificate with regard to exemption from
payment of income tax is also not in consonance with Section 10(26) of the
2024:MLHC:1099
Income Tax Act. On another aspect, it has been submitted that the hilly
terrain of the State and the location of the deposit of coal in seams which
were not sizeable, compact or contiguous was not taken into consideration,
and the memorandum by fixing the minimum area for prospecting, apart
from being contrary to the Acts and Rules, has also deprived interested
persons from being eligible to apply for prospecting licenses for smaller
areas. In concluding his submissions, the learned counsel has submitted
that the Supreme Court in the case of State of Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa
Students Union, Dima-Hasao District Committee & Ors. reported in
(2019) 8 SCC 177, had observed that there is no lack of jurisdiction in the
State to frame policy, but the same was to be confined to the jurisdiction
conferred on it by the MMDR Act, whereas the impugned memorandum
has however exceeded this jurisdiction. He therefore prays that the
impugned clause in the memorandum prescribing the minimum area be set
aside and to allow prospecting licenses for persons who have coal bearing
land in an area less than 100 hectares.
5.
Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General with Mrs. N.G. Shylla,
learned Senior Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the State
respondents No. 1-4, in reply has submitted that the Standard Operating
Procedure (SOP) was arrived at as per the requirements of the MMDR Act,
and the Mineral Concession Rules, while keeping in mind the object of
2024:MLHC:1099
achieving scientific and legal compliant mining of coal in the State of
Meghalaya. It is submitted that the contention of the petitioner is
misconceived, inasmuch as, the Supreme Court in the case of State of
Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa Students Union(supra), has recognised the fact
that under the MMDR Act, 1957, as well as the Mineral Concession Rules
1960, several statutory obligations/jurisdictions have been conferred in the
State of Meghalaya, and that when under a parliamentary enactment, the
State has been given some statutory obligations, there is no lack of
jurisdiction in the State to frame policy to give effect to or implement such
jurisdiction. It is then submitted that Entry 23 of the Seventh Schedule to
the Constitution also confers power on the State Government to frame
regulation of mines and mineral development subject to the extent to which
such regulation and development is under the control of the Union.
6.
The contention he submits that the State respondents cannot lay
down the SOP for coal mining is totally devoid of merit and contrary to the
statutory provisions, as also the judgment in the case of State of
Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa Students Union (supra). Learned Advocate
General has referred to para – 195.13 of the judgment to advance his
arguments as to the power of regulation and control by the State of
Meghalaya over such mining activities, and submits that after the judgment
of the Supreme Court, the Ministry of Coal convened a meeting of all
2024:MLHC:1099
stakeholders for starting scientific coal mining in the State of Meghalaya.
In the said meeting held on 16.02.2021, he submits that though it is clearly
recorded that normally the minimum area required for coal mining is 10 sq.
km., given the topography and nature of deposits, it was suggested that
prospecting be allowed in an area of 1 sq. km., and it was on this
consideration that as per the discussions, the minimum area of 1 sq. km.,
for prospecting license purposes was prescribed. The learned Advocate
General while concluding his arguments has strongly asserted that the SOP
notified by the impugned memorandum is in terms of the directions issued
by Ministry of Coal and is not violative of any statutory provisions, as
alleged.
7.
Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties, the only point in
issue in the instant writ petition is whether the State Government is vested
with the power and jurisdiction to issue the impugned SOP, whereby the
prescription of minimum area of 100 hectares or 1 sq. km. was notified. To
examine the source of power, it is necessary therefore to discuss the various
statutory provisions as given in the MMDR Act 1957, the Mineral
Concession Rules, 1960 and the other allied enactments and policies of the
State, as well as the landmark judgment of the Supreme Court rendered in
the case of State of Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa Students Union(supra).
2024:MLHC:1099
8.
The MMDR Act 1957, has mandated at Section 4(2), that no
prospecting license shall be granted otherwise than in accordance with the
provisions of this Act, and rules made therein under, and Section 5(a) and
(b) thereof, laid down as follows:
“5. Restrictions on the grant of prospecting licenses or
mining leases.(1) A State Government shall not grant a reconnaissance
permit, prospecting license or mining lease to any person
unless such person(a) is an Indian national, or a company as defined in
clause (20) of section 2 of the Companies Act, 2013
(18 of 2013); and
(b) satisfies such conditions as may be prescribed:
[Provided that in respect of any mineral specified in Part
A and Part B of the First Schedule, no reconnaissance
permit, prospecting license or mining lease shall be granted
except
with
the
previous
approval
of
the
Central
Government.]”
Section 5(b) it can be seen has cast a duty upon the State
Government to not grant such license, unless one satisfies such conditions
as may be prescribed. Section 6 which has also since been amended,
prescribes only the maximum area, for which a prospecting license or a
mining lease may be granted.
2024:MLHC:1099
9.
Coming to the bone of contention that is the impugned Office
Memorandum, it is seen that the same contains the SOP for grant of
prospecting license, as well as, mining lease, and at clause – 6, with regard
to prospecting license, it is reiterated that area not to be less than 100
hectares. The SOP, it appears was formulated taking into consideration the
MMDR Act, 1957, and more importantly the judgment of the Supreme
Court passed in State of Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa Students
Union(supra). A perusal of the said judgment shows that the Supreme
Court had discussed the nature of rights including mineral rights of private
owners or communities, the applicable law and the approval procedure, and
it was held that in view of Section 2 of the MMDR Act, the Central
Government has power of control, regulation and development of minerals
and further that the State of Meghalaya had ample powers to ensure
compliance with the statutory schemes. This would mean therefore the
State of Meghalaya has jurisdiction and power to ensure that no mining of
coal should take place, except when the mining lease is granted under the
Mineral Concession Rules. In this perspective it would be useful to refer to
Para – 90 and 91 of this judgment, which has cast several statutory
obligations on the State of Meghalaya, and the same are reproduced herein
below:
2024:MLHC:1099
“90. There can be no dispute to the proposition that in view
of the MMDR Act, 1957, the legislative competence of State
of Meghalaya under Schedule VII List II Entry 23
stands denuded. However, under the MMDR Act, 1957 as
well as the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960, several statutory
obligations/jurisdictions have been conferred on the State of
Meghalaya, which shall be referred to later in this judgment.
91. When under a parliamentary enactment, the State has
been given some statutory obligations, there is no lack of
jurisdiction in the State to frame policy to give effect to or
implement the jurisdictions conferred on the State by
parliamentary enactments. It is true that Mining Policy to be
framed by the State has to confine to the jurisdiction
conferred on it as per the MMDR Act, 1957 and the Rules
framed thereunder. There are other related issues concerning
mining like protection of environment and forests for which
the State has to declare its policy for implementation of its
objective. Several other aspects relating to mining, like
rehabilitation, reclamation and restoration have to be
effectively implemented by the State for which also, it may be
required to frame a policy. We may further notice that the
Meghalaya Mines and Minerals Policy, 2012 was already
framed by the State of Meghalaya, even before directions
were issued by NGT. In pursuance of the NGT directions, it
was draft guidelines of 2015, which were prepared by the
State of Meghalaya. We, thus, are of the view that direction
of NGT to declare Mining Policy by the State of Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:1099
cannot be said to be without jurisdiction. However, the State
in its Mining Policy can only include those areas where it has
jurisdiction under the MMDR Act, 1957 and the Rules
framed thereunder.”
10.
Further, at Para – 122 thereof, it has been directed that while
implementing the statutory regime for carrying on mining operations in the
hill districts of the State of Meghalaya, the State has to ensure compliance
of not only the MMDR Act 1957, but the Mines Act 1952, as well as the
Environment (Protection) Act 1986, and at Para – 195.13, had also directed
as follows:
“122. While implementing statutory regime for carrying
mining operations in the Hills District of the State of
Meghalaya, the State of Meghalaya has to ensure compliance
of not only MMDR Act, 1957 but the Mines Act, 1952 as well
as the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.”
11.
At this juncture, the Office Memorandum dated 17.02.2021,
containing the minutes of a stakeholders meeting held on 16.02.2021, to
discuss applications received from the State of Meghalaya by the Ministry
of Coal, is relevant to be referred to. The importance of this meeting is that
the same had examined and discussed the applications received especially
with regard to the small size of plots for mining purposes ranging between
2024:MLHC:1099
40 hectares and 140 hectares. In this meeting, it was then considered
prudent in the interest of all concerned, to prepare an SOP to examine all
aspects thereof, and that the same was to be notified by the Government of
Meghalaya. This meeting which was at the instance of the Ministry of
Coal, was the genesis of the impugned SOP, by which the minimum mining
area of 1 sq. km. was arrived at. The minute of this meeting being of the
extreme importance is reproduced in its entirety.
Minutes of stakeholders’ meeting to discuss applications
received from State Government of Meghalaya for scientific
and safe mining of coal held on 16th February, 2021
A meeting of stakeholders to discuss sixteen applications of
private
landowners
regarding
prior
approval
of
Central
Government for grant of Prospecting License-cum- Mining Lease
for Coal received from State Government of Meghalaya and
scientific, safe and environmentally sustainable coal mining in the
State was held on 16th February, 2021. The meeting was chaired by
Joint Secretary (P&S) in Ministry of Coal.
2. A list of participants is enclosed as Annexure I.
3. A list of applications received in Ministry of Coal is enclosed as
Annexure II.
2024:MLHC:1099
4. JS (P&S) informed the participants that as per judgement dated
3rd July, 2019 of Hon’ble Supreme Court, the private and
community landowners in the State of Meghalaya which is
governed by provisions of Schedule VI of the Constitution of India,
have the surface rights as well as sub-soil rights and Tribals owned
the land and also owned the minerals. They can lease out their
lands to an eligible person for mining of coal therefrom. He also
briefed the participants about the peculiar features of applications
received, such as small size of plots for mining purposes – ranging
between 40 Ha and 140 Ha. He also informed that many similar
applications may be received in future from Meghalaya or any
other Schedule VI States. As it would be prudent in the interest of
all concerned to prepare a standard operating procedure (SOP) to
examine all aspects of scientific, safe and environmentally
sustainable coal mining in private plots of land by the State
Government as well as in the Government of India, he invited
comments from all participants. The SOP would be notified by the
Government of Meghalaya.
5. Director (P&D), CMPDIL stated that normally minimum area
required for coal mining is ten square kilometers. Even in the
scenario under consideration, the size of mining area should be at
least one square kilometer i.e. 100 Ha. He informed that though
the quality of coal in these areas is good, yet large scale mining is
not possible as coal seams are about 1-2 meter thick and
discontinuous. He also suggested to adopt suitable mining methods
which are small scale with small investment and economical to
2024:MLHC:1099
owners. He also stated that prospecting license should be given
first for exploration and preparation of Geological report, based on
which Mining plan should be prepared. CMD, CMPDIL added
that GSI has not done exploration in Meghalaya for over a decade
and Government of Meghalaya should take up the matter with
them. He also suggested that State and land owners may engage
entity like CMPDIL, MECL, GSI etc., as they as can take up
prospecting operation as under section 4(1) without obtaining any
prospecting license or lease.
6. Director (T), CIL suggested that a call on mining lease in these
areas may be taken only on the basis of prior prospecting GM, CIL
suggested to undertake a pilot project.
7. Shri. Piyush Kumar, GM, CIL in the O/o Director (Technical) in
Ministry of Coal suggested that the State Government should
consult DGMS, Ministry of Labour for safety aspects. He
suggested for prospecting in one square kilometer mining area for
conducting coal exploration down to the minimum depth of 250
meters. He added that mining plan can be approved by the
competent authority by following MoC guidelines.
8. Secretary (Mining and Geology), Government of Meghalaya
expressed his thanks for this very important meeting. The State is
rich in coal deposits with 570 million tonnes proven, good quality
of coal deposit in Meghalaya and the State Government has
already discussed with various stake holders to evolve suitable coal
2024:MLHC:1099
mining methods and has empaneled companies for exploration,
prospecting, preparation of Geological reports and Mining plan.
With regards to minimum area, he informed that many owners
have coal mine areas of about 50 hectares or less. He emphasized
that once the Geological Reports and mining plan are prepared for
100 hectares, proposal to reduce the minimum area to 50 hectares
may be examined technically in future. He emphasized that it is
important to start coal exploration and requested cooperation from
CIL and CMPDIL for that.
9. In view of the discussion held during the meeting, JS (P&S)
stated that the State Government would prepare an SOP for
processing of these cases by including the following (not
necessarily in this order), among other steps to be decided by the
State Government:
A. Application details and scrutiny:
a. First, applications should be made for previous approval of
Central Government for prospecting license as per rule 42 of
MCR, 1960.
b. maps of the proposed mining areas should be plotted on Survey
of India map of 1:50,000 scale, adequate and duly verified by
an appropriate authority in the State Government.
c. Sketch plan of the proposed mining area should be made on a
1:4000 scale on which coordinates of all vertices of the mining
area should be indicated in latitude-longitude as well as in
2024:MLHC:1099
UTM and duly endorsed by an appropriate authority in the
State Government.
d. State Government would also forward soft copies of
applications along with KML files of mining areas.
e. State Government would certify that as per the provisions of the
6th schedule, applicants are the owners of lands and that the
minerals vest with owner of lands.
f. it should be indicated on the applications that these are
submitted under the provisions of Chapter V of the Mineral
Concession Rules, 1960.
g. non-forest land certificate and English version of land
documents etc., should also be made available to Ministry of
Coal, along with applications.
h. Applications for a mining lease of less than 20 years as per
Section 7 of MM(DR), Act, 1957 need not be entertained.
B. Scientific and safe mining:
a. As per discussion, minimum mining area of one square
kilometer should be considered for prospecting license
purposes. State Government may consider to do this with the
consolidation of two or more adjoining coal bearing plots. State
Government may make efforts to sensitize landowners
appropriately.
b. Mining plan should be prepared strictly as per the guidelines of
Ministry of Coal.
c. State Government would consult DGMS on safety issues and
stick to the advice/directions of DGMS throughout the period of
mining.
2024:MLHC:1099
d. O.M. of Government of Meghalaya may be amended in
accordance with amendments to Acts/Rules and MoC’s revised
guidelines of 29th May, 2020.
10. JS (P&S) concluded with the remarks that the State
Government would prepare an SOP and forward to Ministry of
Coal within 7 days along with the applications/proposals of private
and community landowners as revised on re-examination by the
State Government in the light of the SOP. It should be given top
priority.
11.Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.
12.
A perusal of the said minutes as above quoted, would show that
though the area by the SOP has been fixed at 1 sq. km. that is 100 hectares,
the proposal to reduce the minimum area to 50 hectares, was left open to be
examined technically in future, as such, it is not that the prescription of 100
hectares is final, and not subject to review by the State Government.
13.
Therefore, in the considered view of this Court, the SOP which was
notified vide the impugned Memorandum dated 05.03.2021, does not suffer
from any lack of jurisdiction or is incompetent in any manner, as the same
has been made in furtherance and in compliance of the judgment of the
Supreme Court, in State of Meghalaya vs. All Dimasa Students
Union(supra), the stipulations of the MMDR Act, and Mineral Concession
2024:MLHC:1099
Rules, and as per the directions of the Ministry of Coal. The other
submissions of the petitioner with regard to the provisions of the
Meghalaya Mines and Minerals Policy 2012, or the Meghalaya Minor
Rules 2016, and also the Meghalaya Minerals (Prevention of Illegal
Mining, Transportation and Storage) Rules 2022, are disregarded as they
have no application or relevance to the issue at hand.
14.
Accordingly, in the facts and circumstances of the case, and as
discussed above, the instant writ petition is devoid of merit and is
dismissed.
15.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
02.12.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2024.12.02 15:42:37 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review