Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 13.01.2026
FAO (COMM) 236/2023 & CM APPL. 58716/2023(Stay)
RE CONNECT ENERGY TRADING
.....Appellant
Through: Mr Z A Siddiqui, Mr Akash Kumar
and
Ms
Amisha
Upadhyay,
Advocates.
versus
M/S DCM SHRIRAM INDUSTRIES LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr Bipul Kumar Mishra and Ms
Ankita Dwivedi, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
1.
This appeal under Section 37(1)(c) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 [‘the Act’] lays a challenge to the judgment dated
31.05.2023 [‘impugned judgment’] passed by the learned District Judge,
Saket Courts, New Delhi in OMP(Comm) No.1/2020 titled RE Connect
Energy Trading v DCM Shriram Industries Limited.
2.
The petition bearing OMP(Comm) No.1/2020 was filed by the
Appellant under Section 34 of the Act to challenge the Arbitral Award dated
14.10.2019 rendered by the Arbitral Tribunal1 in respect of the agreement(s),
both dated 18.12.2013 entered into between the parties herein. The
Comprising of a sole Arbitrator
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Appellant herein was the petitioner, and the Respondent herein was the
respondent in the proceedings under Section 34 of the Act of 1996.
3.
The arbitrator by its Arbitral Award dated 14.10.2019 [hereinafter
‘award’, for short] has granted compensation of Rs. 56 lakhs in favour of the
Respondent, with a direction to the Appellant to pay the said amount within
one [1] month from the period of award, failing which the Appellant shall be
liable to pay simple interest of 9% per annum on the compensation amount.
The Appellant herein was the respondent, and the Respondent herein
was the claimant in the arbitration proceedings.
4.
The learned District Judge vide impugned judgment dated 31.05.2023
has opined that the Arbitral Award dated 14.10.2019 is in consonance with
the law, well-reasoned and has therefore, held that the ground of Section
34(2)(b)(ii) of the Act of 1996 pressed into arguments by the Appellant is
not made out and dismissed the petition filed under Section 34 of the Act of
1996.
5.
For ease of reference, the parties are being referred to as per their rank
and status in the present appeal proceedings.
6.
Mr. Z A Siddiqui, learned counsel for the Appellant submits at the
outset, that the Appellant is not contesting the finding of the Arbitral
Tribunal at paragraph no. ‘60’ of the award holding the Appellant acted in a
negligent
manner
in
submitting
the
bids
on
behalf
of
the
Respondent/claimant on 25.04.2018 at the Exchange by selling all the
28,526 certificates at Rs. 1001/- contrary to the instructions to not sell them
at less than Rs. 1500/-, which constitutes violation of the terms and
conditions of the agreement dated 18.12.2013.
6.1.
He states that in this appeal the Appellant is however raising a limited
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
challenge to the quantum of the compensation awarded by the Arbitral
Tribunal in favour of the Respondent/claimant.
6.2.
He states that the Arbitral Tribunal has calculated the loss to the
Respondent at Rs. 199/- per Renewable Energy Certificates [hereinafter
‘RECs’, for short], whereas it is the contention of the Appellant that in law
the Arbitral Tribunal could have calculated the loss at maximum price of
Rs.9/- per REC. In this regard, he relies upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Trojan Co. Ltd. v. RMN Nagappa Chettiar2 for contending that
the basis of computation has to be in terms of the said judgment. He states
that the Arbitral Tribunal ought to have considered highest price of the REC
when it was sold next on the stock exchange and that price as per the
Appellant was Rs. 1010/-.
6.3.
He also relies upon the Clause 6.4 of the Trading Agreement executed
between the Appellant and the Respondent to contend that the maximum
compensation, which the Appellant can be held liable to pay is Rs. 4/- per
REC. He states that the Appellant was entitled to receive Rs. 4/- as fees per
REC and therefore this is the maximum that could have been awarded as
compensation.
6.4.
He states that therefore, the compensation that should have been
awarded by the Arbitral Tribunal ought to have been between the range of
Rs. 4/- to 9/- per REC. He states that awarding compensation at Rs. 199/per REC is contrary to the clause 6.4 of the Trading Agreement dated
18.12.2013 and the judgment of the Supreme Court in Trojan Co.
Ltd.(supra).
6.5.
No other ground has been pressed by the Appellant.
AIR 1953 SC 235
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Factual Matrix
7.
The brief facts relevant for deciding the dispute, culled out from the
award, are as under: 7.1.
The arbitration pertains to the dispute between Respondent/DCM
Shriram Industries Ltd. and Appellant/RE Connect Energy Trading
regarding sale of RECs made by the Appellant on behalf of the Respondent
at Indian Energy Exchange [‘IEX’] platform on 25.04.2018 in terms of two
agreements, both dated 18.12.2013 executed between the Appellant and the
Respondent.
7.2. The Respondent i.e., M/s DCM Shriram Industries Ltd [hereinafter
referred to as ‘DCM Industry’] is a company engaged, inter alia, in
generating renewable energy and for the same it is entitled for issue of RECs
by the National Load Dispatch Centre [‘NLDC’] under the provisions of
Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions for
Recognition and Issuance of Renewable Energy Certificate for Renewable
Energy Generation) Regulations, 2010, [hereinafter referred to as ‘REC
Regulations,2010’]. The said RECs can be sold on any of the two Power
Exchanges operating in India.
7.3. The Appellant/RE Connect Energy Trading [hereinafter referred to as
‘RE Connect’] is a company engaged, inter alia, in the business of trading of
REC and is registered as a member with IEX.
7.4.
The parties herein entered into an agreement dated 18.12.2013 with
respect of trading of REC, [hereinafter referred to as ‘Trading Agreement’].
According to this agreement, the Appellant have to trade RECs on behalf of
the Respondent/claimant based on their instructions. The Appellant also
undertook to provide trading support services like settlement support,
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
reconciliation support and other services to ensure smooth trading and
settlement, as may be required from time to time.
Another agreement dated 18.12.2013 [hereinafter referred to as ‘IEX
7.5.
Platform Agreement’] was also executed between the parties for trading of
RECs on the platform of IEX, as the Appellant was registered member of
IEX.
7.6.
RECs are traded on IEX platform on a prefixed day every month. For
the month of April 2018, the trading day for sale/purchase of RECs was
25.04.2018, being the last Wednesday of the said month.
7.7.
On 23.04.2018 at 11:33 AM, the Appellant sent an email to the
Respondent/claimant informing the floor price of Rs. 1000/- for both solar
and non-solar RECs and also asking the Respondent/claimant to inform
about the bid data by Tuesday, 24.04.2018, 11:00 AM to prevent any errors
or omissions in bid processing.
7.8.
The Respondent/claimant sent their bid for sale of RECs by email
dated 24.04.2018 at 01:16 PM to the Appellant thereby instructing them to
sell project wise RECs, ‘5’ from one project and ‘1275’ from another project
at a price of Rs. 1000/- per REC. Thus, the instructions were for sale of 1280
RECs at Rs. 1000/- per REC.
7.9.
The Respondent/claimant sent its revised bid for sale of RECs at
12:12 PM on 25.04.2018, instructing the Appellant to sell ‘5’ RECs from
one project and ‘28,521’ RECs from another project at a price of Rs. 1500/per REC. Thus, the revised instructions were for sale of of 28,526 RECs at
Rs. 1500/- per REC.
7.10. The trading window for buying/selling RECs on IEX platform
remains open from 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM on the trading day during which
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
period the members are required to submit their bids for selling/buying REC
and the Business Rules of IEX permit modification or cancellation of the
order on the instructions of client even after the bid has been entered in the
system by the member/Appellant during the bidding session. Thus, the
modified instructions issued by the Respondent could be implemented by
the Appellant on 25.04.2018.
7.11. On 25.04.2018, the Respondent/claimant received an email at 4:32PM
from the Appellant that due to lot of confusion with respect to solar trade,
they were not able to change price of RECs from Rs. 1000 to Rs. 1500/-.
Another mail was received by the Respondent/claimant from the Appellant
at on 25.04.2018 at 11:33 PM informing the results of the REC trading,
wherein it was indicated that the market clearing price for non-solar REC on
25.04.2018 at IEX was Rs. 1001/- per REC and that the entire RECs of
‘28,526’ [28521+5] had been sold at Rs. 1001/- per REC.
The sale of 28,526 RECs shows that the Appellant had duly received
the email dated 25.04.2018 issued by the Respondent modifying its
instructions as the Respondent had by its earlier email only instructed for
sale of 1280 RECs. Ex-facie, the Appellant had failed to act upon the
instruction to offer the REC at sale of Rs. 1500/- per REC, as against the
earlier instruction of Rs. 1000/- per REC. The Appellant in its email dated
25.04.2018 sent at 04:32 PM acknowledged its error.
7.12. On 30.04.2018 at 13:07 hrs., the Appellant sent an email to the
Respondent/claimant that they were unable to change the trade bid from
Rs.1000/- to Rs.1500/- on the trade day i.e. 25.04.2018 and bid was placed
on the basis of bid received on 24.04.2018, at Rs.1000/-.
However, this was exfacie incorrect as the Respondent had offered a
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
trade of 28,526 RECs and this instruction was issued by the Respondent
only on 25.04.2018.
7.13. On 30.04.2018, the Respondent/claimant sent a legal notice to the
Appellant seeking compensation for losses incurred on account of quoting
incorrect price for REC in the bidding process held on 25.04.2018 causing
financial loss to them to the tune of Rs 1,42,34,474/-. The Respondent
claimed the loss of Rs. 499/- per REC for 28,526 RECs.
7.14. In the aforesaid facts, a dispute arose between the parties regarding
the price at which the RECs owned by the Respondent/claimant were sold
by the Appellant in IEX on 25.04.2018.
7.15. Conciliation proceedings were held between the parties, but the
dispute could not be resolved. Pursuant to failure of Conciliation
proceedings, the Respondent/claimant in terms of letter dated 06.04.2019
requested IEX to initiate Arbitration proceedings. The agreement dated
18.12.2013 had a provision of resolution of dispute by arbitration under the
Act. On mutual consent of the parties, IEX approached Mr. Rakesh Nath,
former Chairperson, Central Electricity Authority and former Technical
Member, Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, to seek his consent to be the
sole Arbitrator by email dated 13.05.2019. Mr. Rakesh Nath conveyed his
acceptance on 13.05.2019.
Findings and Analysis
8.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the findings recorded in the impugned judgment as well as in the Arbitral
Award, material placed on record and considered the rival contentions of the
parties.
9.
The Supreme Court in its recent pronouncement Jan De Nul
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Dredging India (P) Ltd. v. Tuticorin Port Trust3, has reiterated that the
powers of the Appellate Court under Section 37 of the Act of 1996 are even
more restricted than the powers conferred by Section 34 of the Act of 1996,
opined as under: “36. The gist of the aforesaid decisions is that the jurisdiction of the
court under Section 37 of the Act is akin to the jurisdiction of the court
under Section 34 of the Act, and, therefore, the scope of interference
by the court in appeal under Section 37 cannot go beyond the grounds
on which challenge can be made to the award under Section 34 of the
Act. Moreover, the courts exercising powers under Sections 34 and
37, do not act as a normal court, and therefore, ought not to interfere
with the arbitral award on a mere possibility of an alternative view.
37. In other words, the scope of interference of the court with the
arbitral matters is virtually prohibited, if not absolutely barred. The
powers of the Appellate Court are even more restricted than the
powers conferred by Section 34 of the Act. The appellate power under
Section 37 of the Act is exercisable only to find out if the court
exercising power under Section 34 of the Act, has acted within its
limits as prescribed thereunder or has exceeded or failed to exercise
the power so conferred. The Appellate Court exercising powers under
Section 37 of the Act has no authority of law to consider the matter in
dispute before the Arbitral Tribunal on merits so as to hold as to
whether the award of the Arbitral Tribunal is right or wrong. The
Appellate Court in exercise of such power cannot sit as an ordinary
court of appeal and reappraise the evidence to record a contrary
finding. The award of the Arbitral Tribunal cannot be touched by the
court unless it is contrary to the substantive provision of law or any
provision of the Act or the terms of the agreement.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
10.
Keeping in view the aforesaid scope of limited jurisdiction of the
Appellate Court, this Court will not proceed to decide the issue in hand.
2026 SCC OnLine SC 33
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal
11.
To adjudicate the disputes, which arose between the parties, the
Arbitral Tribunal on the basis of the pleadings, framed the following issues:
“
a. Whether the Appellant has violated the terms and conditions
of the agreements between the parties hy selling all the 28526
RECs at the rate of Rs. 1001/- per REC against the directions
of the Respondent/claimant?
b. Whether the Appellant by defying the instructions of the
Respondent/claimant caused financial loss to the
Respondent/claimant?
c. Whether the Appellant is obligated to compensate the
Respondent/claimant for causing pecuniary loss?
d. If the answer to the question c) above is positive, what is the
compensation payable by the Appellant to the
Respondent/claimant?
e. Whether the Respondent/claimant is also entitled to get
interest on the aforesaid amount at 12% per annum from the
date of default committed by the Appellant i.e., 25.04.2018 till
the realization of amount?”
12.
To decide the said issues, the Arbitral Tribunal also framed
preliminary questions arising in the facts of the case, which are reproduced
herein as under: “I. What is the relationship of the Respondent with respect to the
Claimant?
II. What is the time limit by which the Claimant was required to
convey its sell bid to the Respondent for trading session on 25.04.2018
as per the agreement between the parties, the Regulations of the
Central Commission and the Rules and Bye-laws of IEX?
III. Whether the Respondent was bound to consider the revised bid
communicated by the Claimant on 25.04.2018?”
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
12.1. The Arbitral Tribunal has summarized its answers to the aforesaid
preliminary questions in a tabular manner, which is reproduced hereinbelow:
Question
My observation
What is the relationship of the The relationship between the
Respondent with respect to the Claimant and the Respondent
was that of Client and Agent.
Claimant?
What is the time limit by which
the Claimant was required to
submit its bid to the
Respondent for trading session
on
25.04.2018
as
per
Regulations of the Central
Commission or the Rules or
Bye-laws of IEX?
The Agreements between the
parties, the Regulations of the
Central Commission, Bye-laws
and Business Rules of IEX do
not provide for any time limit by
which the claimant was required
to submit its bid to the Member.
The Business Rules of IEX
provide that the bidding session
shall be from 13:00 to 15:00
hrs. on the specified trading day
and the Member can modify or
cancel its bid within the bidding
session, before closing of the
bidding session.
Whether the Respondent was In view of no provision of time
bound to consider the revised limit for submission of bid by
bid communicated by the the Claimant in the agreements
between the parties, specific
Claimant on 25.04.2018?
provision in the Business Rules
of IEX for revision of bid even
during trading hours and
admission of the Respondent of
accepting the practice of
entertaining the revised bids on
case to case basis and their
action of partly implementing
the revised bid of the Claimant,
the argument of the Respondent
that they were not bound to
consider the revised bid does
not hold water.
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
12.2. During the arguments, the Appellant has not disputed before us the
finding of the Arbitral Tribunal that the relationship between the parties is
that of principal/client and agent and the said has become final.
Issue (a)
13.
In view of the aforesaid findings returned on the preliminary issues,
thereafter, on issue (a), the Arbitral Tribunal returned the following finding:
“60 In view of above, I hold that the Respondent has acted in a
negligent manner in submitting the bids on behalf of the Claimant
and violated the terms and conditions of the Trading Agreement
between the parties by selling all the 28526 RECs @ Rs1001/-.”
[Emphasis supplied]
13.1. During the arguments before us, the Appellant has not challenged the
said finding of the Arbitral Tribunal, whereby the Arbitral Tribunal held that
the Appellant has acted in a negligent manner in submitting the bids on
behalf of the Respondent/claimant and thus, the same has attained finality.
Issues (b), (c), and (d)
14.
Issues (b), (c), and (d) were decided by the Arbitral Tribunal with
common
deliberation
and
the
Tribunal
determined
that
the
Respondent/claimant has indeed suffered real pecuniary loss due to the
negligence of the Appellant. The Arbitral Tribunal held that the Appellant is
liable to compensate the Respondent/claimant for the said pecuniary loss. It
referred to Sections 73, 211 and 212 of the Contract Act, 1872 [‘Act of
1872’] and the terms of the Trading Agreement executed between the parties
to
conclude
that
the
Appellant
is
liable
to
compensate
the
Respondent/claimant for this pecuniary loss. The Arbitral Tribunal
determined that minimum loss incurred by the Respondent/claimant is
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Rs.199/- per REC. Accordingly, the Arbitral Tribunal held that the
Respondent/claimant is entitled to the compensated at Rs. 199/- per REC on
the basis of the following deliberations: “73 Let me first examine if any loss has been caused to the
Claimant by the Respondent by not following the instructions
of the Claimant. To assess this, let me examine the date of
trading conducted by the Respondent on behalf of the
Claimant from May, 2018 onwards.
74 The detailed data for sale of RECs by the Respondent on behalf of
the Claimant on IEX from May,2018 onwards as furnished by the
Respondent is attached as Exhibit-I.
75 The position of clearing price per REC at the two Exchanges
namely, IEX and PXIL and the RECs sold by the Respondent on
behalf of the Claimant from May, 2018 to March,2019 has been
summarized as under:
Month
Power
Exchange
May, 18
June, 18
July, 18
Aug, 18
Sept, 18
Oct, 18
IEX
REC
Cleared
*
Clearin
g Price
**
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
Month
Power
Exchange
Nov. 18
Dec. 18
Jan. 19
Feb., 19
March,
Clearing
Price **
IEX
REC
Cleared
*
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
IEX
PXIL
76 It is seen that the clearing price of REC on IEX increased from
June, 2018. It is seen that in June,2018, the Respondent bid a
price of Rs 1500/- per REC on the instructions of the Claimant but
the same could not be sold as the clearing price on IEX was only
Rs 1150/per REC. From July, 2018 to January, 2019, the
Claimant has been offering to sell some RECs at price between Rs
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
1200 to 1250 and some RECs at price varying from Rs 1300 to Rs
1500 in slabs. It is also seen that the Claimant has not bid anytime
below Rs 1200/per REC. From July,2018 to March,2019, the
price per REC has remained between Rs 1200/- to' Rs 1500/except in September/2018 when the price went down to Rs 1100/-.
However, the Claimant did not sell any REC in September as it
had bid at Rs 1200/- and above. Similar rising trend has also been
seen at PXIL.
77 If the Respondent had revised the price to Rs 1500/- per REC along
with the quantity as per the revised instruction of the Claimant in
the bidding that took place on 25.04.2018, the 28526 RECs of the
Claimant would not have been sold on 25.04.2018. It is clear from
the above data that if the Claimant had sold these 28526 RECs
between July,2018 to March,2019, they would have received a
higher price. The minimum price they would have received per
REC would have been Rs 1200/- per REC and maximum price Rs
1555/per REC.
78 In view of above, it is clear that the Respondent by not strictly
complying with the revised instructions of the Claimant has
caused financial loss to the Claimant. The loss is not hypothetical
and imaginary as evident from the trend of the REC price in the
power exchanges between July,2018 to March,2019. It is also
seen that the Respondent had sold 36530 RECs on behalf of the
Claimant between July'2018 toJanuary,2019 at price ranging
from Rs1200/to Rs 1501/-. The price that the Claimant received
per REC for 28526 RECs in bidding held on 25.04.2018 was Rs
1001/- only. Therefore, the financial loss incurred by the Claimant
due to noncompliance of instructions of the Claimant by the
Respondent is real and is not imaginary or hypothetical and has
been caused directly due to the wrongful act of the Respondent.
…
88 …… In my view, the above judgments do not support the case of
the Respondent. The loss due to breach of agreement was foreseen
by the parties as they had included a clause in the Trading
Agreement regarding liability of the Respondent and Claim by the
Client/Claimant. According to Clause 8 of the Business Rules of
IEX, the Members shall be required to obtain insurance cover at
their own cost, so as to protect themselves from risks and hazards
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
relating to their business operations at the Exchange. Thus, the
Respondent should have known the risks and hazards of the
business of trading and the liability due to breach of agreement.
The loss caused to the Claimant due to negligence of the
Respondent is a direct loss as the price of the RECs went up from
July,2018 onwards. If the Respondent had quoted the price of Rs
1500/- in the bid held on 25.04.2018, these RECs had remained
unsold and could have been sold by the Claimant from July, 2018
onwards at a higher price. In fact, the Respondent sold 36,530
RECs on behalf of the Claimant at rate varying from Rs 1200 to
Rs 1500 per REC during the period from July,2018 to January,
2019. At no time, the Claimant quoted a rate less than Rs 1200
per REC. It is seen that the Claimant was quoting for rates from
Rs 1200 to 1500 per REC in slabs. I therefore, hold that the
Respondent is obligated to compensate for causing pecuniary loss
to the claimant due to their negligence in wrongly submitting the
price bid on behalf of the Claimant.
…
92 I find that the Claimant had been quoting the rates varying from Rs
1200 to Rs 1500 per REC in slabs from June,2018 to
January,2019 and the clearing price received by the Claimant
was in the range of Rs 1200 to Rs 1501 per REC. The weighted
average price received by the Claimant was Rs 1296 per REC
during the period July,2018 to January, 2019.
93 In my view, the compensation payable to the Claimant should be
calculated on the difference in price which the Claimant could
have received for 28526 RECs if they were sold during the period
from July, 2018 onwards and the price of Rs 1001 per REC
received in the bidding on 25.04.2018.
94 At selling price of Rs 1296/- per REC, i.e., the weighted average
price received by the Claimant for sale of RECs through the
Respondent from July,2018 to January, 2019, the compensation
for 28526 RECs would work out to be Rs 84.1 lacs. However,
deduction is required to be made for the interest on the amount
that the Claimant received due to sale of the RECs on 25.04.2018
@ Rs 1001/- per REC as the Claimant would not have received
the amount in April,2018 and would have received the sale
proceeds between July,2018 to January, 2019. However, it is not
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
possible to calculate the amount of interest as interest calculation
would require assumption of sale of the RECs in different months.
At a price of Rs 1200/- per REC, the minimum price received by
the Claimant during July,2018 to January, 2019 the compensation
would work out to be Rs 56.7 lacs. This is the minimum loss that
the Claimant has incurred. I also find that this is the minimum
price at which the Claimant has bid for its REC after April,2018.
In order to avoid any controversy of calculating the interest on the
basis of some assumptions, it will be fair if the compensation is
decided on the basis of difference between the sale price of Rs
1200 per REC received by the Claimant during July,2018 and Rs
1001/- per REC.
95 In view of above, I decide a compensation of Rs 56 lacs in favour
of the Claimant which is required to be paid by the Respondent
within one month of the date of this award.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
15.
The Appellant has during arguments not disputed the finding of the
Arbitral Tribunal that the Respondent/claimant indeed suffered real
pecuniary loss due to the negligence of the Appellant on 25.04.2018 in
selling 28,526 RECs at the rate of Rs. 1001/- in contravention of the
instructions of the Respondent/claimant. The Appellant has also not disputed
during arguments, the finding with respect to the liability of the Appellant to
compensate the Respondent/claimant for the pecuniary loss as per Sections
211 and 212 of the Act of 1872. The Appellant has also not disputed the
factual findings of the Arbitral Tribunal, which form the basis of
ascertaining the actual minimum loss at Rs. 199/- per REC at paragraph nos.
‘92’ to ‘94’ of the award. The issue of breach of duty, actual loss and
liability have therefore attained finality.
Further, as noted above, the Appellant during arguments has not
disputed the finding of the Arbitral Tribunal that the relationship between
the parties is of principal/client and agent, which creates a fiduciary
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
relationship between the parties. [Re. Chandrakantaben v. Vadilal
Bapalal Modi4]
16.
The only submission raised by the Appellant during the arguments is
that notwithstanding the aforesaid findings of negligence, actual loss, etc.,
the compensation could not have been awarded by the Arbitral Tribunal at
more than Rs. 9/- per REC. The Appellant contends that on 25.04.2018, the
REC was sold at Rs. 1001/- and on the next trading date in May, 2018 the
REC was sold at Rs. 1010/-. The Appellant states that it is this price of
Rs.1010/-, which could have been taken into consideration by the Arbitral
Tribunal for awarding Rs. 9/-. For this purpose, he relies upon by the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Trojan Co. Ltd. v. RMN Nagappa
Chettiar (supra).
Thus, the Appellant has during arguments only challenged the
quantum of compensation awarded at Rs. 199/- per REC in this Appeal on
the basis of the average price arrived after taking into consideration the sale
price, which the RECs fetched between May 2018 to March 2019.
17.
This Court finds that the facts in the said case were completely
different from the case in hand. The principle adopted in the Trojan Co.
Ltd. (supra) was appropriate for calculation of losses suffered by the
plaintiff therein. In Trojan Co. Ltd. (supra), the Court held that
defendant/broker mislead the plaintiff/client to purchase shares of a specific
company on 05.04.1937 at Rs. 77/- per share though the defendant/broker
was aware that the price of the said stock was likely to decline sharply the
next day. The plaintiff purchased the stock at Rs. 77/- per share and
immediately the price fell sharply compelling the plaintiff to sell on 20th and
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
22nd April, 1937 the stock at reduced price in the range of Rs. 42 - Rs. 47 per
share, leading to losses. The Supreme Court after examining the evidence
held that the true market price of the shares on 05.04.1937, when the
plaintiff purchased the 3,000 shares was Rs. 46/- per share. The Court held
that the plaintiff was entitled to the difference between Rs. 77/- and Rs. 46/i.e., Rs. 31/- per share from the defendant/broker. This was the measure of
computation of damages settled by the Supreme Court in the facts of the said
case. This fact situation in the judgment of Trojan Co. Ltd. (supra) is
inapplicable to the facts of this case. In this very judgment the Court at
paragraph no. ‘22’ clarified that no general principle can be laid down for
measuring the damages to be awarded in favour of the injured party and
every case has to be decided on its own circumstances.
18.
This Court finds that the method adopted by the Arbitral Tribunal for
calculating the actual loss in this case has been well documented in
paragraph nos. ‘74’ to ‘78’ and ‘92’ to ‘95’ of the award, as extracted
hereinabove. The price of Rs. 1200/- per REC adopted by the Arbitral
Tribunal by arriving at a weighted average for determining the loss and
computing the compensation in favour of Respondent is reasonable and
correct.
19.
The Respondent/claimant had issued instructions to the Appellant to
offer ‘28,526’ RECs at Rs. 1500/- each. The Appellant in contravention of
the unambiguous instruction by the Respondent/claimant sold ‘28,526’
RECs at Rs. 1001/- each, thereby selling the RECs at a price, which was
Rs.499/- less than the price instructed by the Respondent. The Respondent
therefore raised a claim of loss of Rs.499/- per REC in the arbitration
(1989) 2 SCC 630 [at paragraph no. 19]
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
proceedings. The data placed on record before the Arbitral Tribunal showed
that indeed RECs were sold at Rs. 1500/- in January 2019 and at Rs. 1555/in February 2019 on the exchange. The data also showed that the
Respondent/claimant has not sold the RECs in the next one year at a price
lesser than Rs. 1200/- per REC. The said sales and the behaviour of the
Respondent/claimant in the opinion of the Arbitral Tribunal substantiated
the claim of the Respondent for damages.
However, the Arbitral Tribunal adopted a reasonable and scientific
mechanism of determining the weighted average price at which the RECs
were sold by the Respondent between May 2018 to March 2019 for
determining the loss; further accounting for the interest component on the
price of Rs. 1001/- already received by the Respondent on 25.04.2018 in
favour of the Appellant; and thereafter arriving at figure of Rs. 199/- per
REC as the amount for which the Appellant was held liable to compensate
the Respondent/claimant. The principle/measure adopted by the Arbitral
Tribunal for calculating the damages is fair and has balanced the equities.
This Court therefore finds no merit in the submission of the Appellant
that the Arbitral Tribunal ought to have adopted the clearing price of
Rs.1010/-, which was the price prevailing in May 2018, when the next
transaction was executed on exchange. This is for the reason, the
Respondent/claimant was under no legal obligation to sell the RECs in May,
2018 and could have held on to the same until it got the desired price.
20.
The alternate contention of the Appellant is that its liability for losses
suffered by the Respondent/claimant should be limited to Clause 6.4 of the
Trading Agreement, which reads as under: “6.4 Limitation of Liability
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Save as otherwise determined by any court of law, arbitration or other
legal provisions, RET's total liability to Client due to any reason shall
not exceed the amount received in fees for services provided.
Client shall bring any claim relating to the Services or otherwise
under this Agreement within 12 months of completion of Services.
[Emphasis supplied]
21.
It is contended that the Appellant is entitled to a fee of Rs. 4/- per
REC and therefore the maximum compensation, which the Arbitral Tribunal
could have awarded in favour of the Respondent was Rs. 4/- per REC and
not Rs. 199/- per REC.
22.
With respect to reliance placed by the Appellant on Clause 6.4 of the
Trading Agreement to limit its liability, the Arbitral Tribunal duly
considered the same at paragraph nos. ‘83’ and ‘84’ and rejected the said
arguments, which reads as under: “83 Clause 6.6 of the Agreement provides for applicable law and
dispute resolution. It provides for arbitration in accordance with
the procedures in the agreement and Rules of Indian Council of
Arbitration ('Rules') or such rules and procedure as the parties
may agree.
84 Thus, the parties were aware about the consequences of any
breach of the agreement. The Clause 6.4 stipulates limitation of
liability of the Respondent to its Client to fees for services but
there is a saving clause for liability as determined by any court of
law, arbitration or other legal provisions. Therefore, a higher
compensation can be granted in the Arbitration.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
23.
The Arbitral Tribunal at paragraph no. ‘38’ of the award has also
recorded a categorical finding of fact that the Appellant duly received the
communication dated 25.04.2018 issued by the Respondent/claimant
revising its instructions to sell at Rs. 1500/- per REC and in fact the
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Appellant acted upon the said instruction, as it offered ‘28,526’ RECs for
sale based on the said instructions; albeit at Rs. 1001/- per REC, thereby
acting contrary to the written instructions of the Respondent/claimant
leading to an undisputed breach of its obligations under the Trading
Agreement and the Bye-Laws of IEX, causing real loss to the Respondent.
The Arbitral Tribunal held that the conduct of the Appellant in selling
‘28,526’ RECs at Rs.1001/- per REC on 25.04.2018 was negligent.
24.
In these facts, where the negligence of the Appellant stands
established beyond doubt, the Appellant’s attempt to limit its liability to
Rs.4/- per REC by relying upon Clause 6.4 of the Trading Agreement has
been rightly rejected by the Arbitral Tribunal by not only interpreting the
Clause 6.4 correctly but also by making reference to Sections 211 and 212
of the Act of 1872.
The conduct of the Appellant was not of a mere breach but negligence
of its fiduciary obligation towards the Respondent/claimant, who had relied
upon it and entrusted it with its RECs to trade the same on the Exchange at
the price specified in writing. The relationship between the Appellant and
the Respondent has been rightly held by the Arbitral Tribunal to be that of
principal and agent in view of Clause 2.1.14 of the Bye-Laws of IEX, and
the action of the Appellant in acting contrary to the written instructions of
the principal has been rightly held by the Arbitrator to make it liable for
damages as per Sections 211 and 212 of the Act of 1872.
25.
The phrase ‘save as otherwise determined by any court of law,
arbitration or other legal provisions’ appearing in Clause 6.4 of Trading
Agreement recognises the power of the Arbitral Tribunal and the Court to
determine the liability of the Appellant towards its client in accordance with
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
Sections 211 and 212 of the Act of 1872 so as to compensate the
Respondent/claimant for the actual loss suffered by it.
26.
If the submission of the Appellant is accepted and its liability is
capped at Rs. 4/- per REC, it would be putting a premium on its negligence
and breach of fiduciary obligation as well as it would be contrary to Sections
211 and 212 of the Act of 1872, which make the agent liable for
compensating the actual loss. The facts of the case pertain to breach of
fiduciary duty of the Appellant herein towards the Respondent while trading
for
the
RECs
on
the
Exchange
and
losses
suffered
by
the
Respondent/claimant due to the breach of such duty by the Appellant shall
make it liable for the losses suffered by the Respondent.
27.
It appears that the Appellant is seeking to invoke the principles of
Section 74 of the Act of 1872, though the same is not even pleaded in its
grounds of appeal. In this regard, we may observe that Sections 73 and 74
which fall in Chapter VI of the Act of 1872 deals with consequences of
breach of contract and stipulate payment of damages to the injured party.
However, Sections 211 and 212 fall in Chapter X of the Act of 1872 and
provide a separate and independent mechanism for holding an Agent liable
for losses suffered by the Principal consequent to its breach of duty. The
facts of this case are governed by Sections 211 and 212 of the Act of 1872
and therefore, the losses have been correctly computed on actual basis
without any limitation imposed in Clause 6.4 of the Trading Agreement.
28.
The interpretation given by the Arbitral Tribunal to Clause 6.4 of the
Trading Agreement is reasonable as well as in consonance with law and
would not merit any interference by this Court in its judicial review under
Section 34 or 37 of the Act of 1996.
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
29.
The award also notes that as per Clause 8 of the Bye-Laws of IEX, the
Appellant is required to obtain insurance to protect itself against the risks
and hazards relating to business operation at the exchange. It therefore
appears that the Appellant is obliged to take professional insurance; though
there is no disclosure by the Appellant in this regard on record and it is
unclear if the Appellant will be recovering this awarded amount from its
insurer.
30.
In these facts, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the
impugned judgment dated 31.05.2023 passed by the learned District Judge,
Commercial Courts, Saket Courts, New Delhi in OMP(COMM) No. 1/2020
and the Arbitral Award dated 14.10.2019 passed by the Arbitral Tribunal.
31.
In view of above, the appeal and pending applications, if any stands
dismissed. No Costs.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
JANUARY 13, 2026/hp/MG
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
11:48:38
FAO (COMM) 236/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review