The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. For the foregoing reasons, the petition merits acceptance and is, accordingly, allowed. The order dated 25.11.2025 passed by the learned Trial Court is modified to the extent that, in addition to the articles/documents already directed to be released, all the seized articles/documents out of the 52 items, except those figuring at Serial Nos. 43 to 52, shall stand released on superdari in favour of petitioner No. 1, subject to her furnishing an undertaking before the learned Trial Court that the said articles/documents shall be preserved in their present form and shall be produced before the Investigating Agency or the Court, as and when required during the course of investigation or trial.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 8
Regular
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
CrlM No. (2013/2025)
…Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Razia And Ors.
Through:
Mr. Bhat Fayaz, Advocate with
Ms. Nighat Amin, Advocate
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K through SHO
Police Station SCW Crime Branch Srinagar
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Ms. Nowbahar Khan, Assisting Counsel
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
09.09.2026
1. The petitioners are aggrieved of the order dated 25.11.2025 passed by
the learned Trial Court, whereby their application seeking release of
certain articles/documents seized by the Crime Branch in connection
with FIR No. 09/2023, registered for offences under Sections 420,
467, 468 and 471 RPC, has been partly allowed. While some of the
seized articles/documents have been directed to be released, release of
the remaining articles/documents has been declined.
2. The case of the petitioners is that the Investigating Agency, during the
course of investigation, conducted a search of the residential premises
of accused Showkat Ahmad Mir, husband of petitioner No. 1 and
father of petitioner Nos. 2 and 3, and seized as many as 52
articles/documents. The accusation against the said accused is that he
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
had secured appointment in the Police Department as Assistant SubInspector in the year 1993 on the strength of fake and forged
documents and had, consequently, derived monetary benefits from
such appointment.
3. The grievance projected by the petitioners is that a substantial number
of the seized articles/documents, including passbooks, PLI passbooks,
cash certificates, bank-locker receipts and receipts pertaining to
purchase of jewellery, either belong to the petitioners or have no nexus
whatsoever with the allegations forming the subject matter of the FIR.
It is, accordingly, contended that continued retention of such
articles/documents serves no legitimate purpose of investigation and
causes unnecessary prejudice to the petitioners.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the prosecution, on the other hand,
supported the order passed by the learned Trial Court on the ground
that the investigation is still in progress and the charge-sheet is yet to
be laid before the competent Court. It was, thus, contended that the
articles/documents retained by the Investigating Agency may be
required for the purposes of investigation and trial.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the Case Diary.
6. During the course of hearing, Mr. Abdul Razak, Sub-Inspector, SCW
Crime Branch, Srinagar, appearing in person, fairly submitted that the
gravamen of the accusation against the accused is that he had secured
public employment on the strength of fake and forged documents. He
further identified the documents connected with the educational
qualifications, appointment and service record of the accused as being
material for investigation into the alleged offences.
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
7. For convenience of the disposal of the present petition, following
documents are listed below: -
S. No.
1.
2.
Description of
Description of
documents/articles/records seized
place where
Passbook of Shahzareen Showkat
1st Floor of the
bearing A/C No. 0367040100007501
house
original
Passbook of Deeba bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
0367040100007502
3.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
original
1st Floor
6009427644
4.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
J&K Bank pass book of Razia
1st Floor
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
Cheque book of Razia Mir bearing
A/C No. 6009427644
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
original
1st Floor
1043788
9.
original
020058848310
8.
original
bearing No. 0367040100004928
7.
original
010097966762
6.
original
6009427644
5.
Remarks
original
1st Floor
original
10.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
020165551830
11.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
original
1st Floor
020165551125
12.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
PLI Passbook bearing A/C No.
1st Floor
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
1st Floor
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
1st Floor
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
1st Floor
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
1st Floor
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
291026
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
original
1st Floor
291077
18.
original
291078
17.
original
291090
16.
original
291498
15.
original
020159647226
14.
original
020159646554
13.
original
1st Floor
original
19.
Cash certificate of Razia bearing No.
1st Floor
290918
20.
Property return statement for the
original
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
year 2023 of Razia vide form No.
93010
21.
Property return statement for the
year 2022 of Razia vide form No.
537686
22.
Bank locker receipt record vide No.
000058
23.
Receipt vide No. 1310 dated
02.07.2020
24.
Receipt bearing No. 555 dated
original
1st Floor
07.07.2015
25.
Receipt of Mizan Jewelers without
original
1st Floor
No. and date (14 in No.)
26.
Receipt of Nichal Jewelers bearing
14 No. in
original
1st Floor
No.’s 735, 734, 81, 49, 47, 46, 478,
09 No. in
original
45 & 48 (09 in No.)
27.
Receipt of Royal Jewelers bearing
1st Floor
No.’s nil dated 21.06.2012,
04 No. in
original
21.06.2012,27.01.2012 &05.08.2011
28.
Receipt of G.N Jewelers bearing
No.’s 331, 330, 336 & 332
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
1st Floor
04 No. in
original
29.
Receipt of Pratab Singh Jasbeer
1st Floor
Jewelers dated 04.02.2013
30.
Receipt of S. Tara Singh- Sukh
original
1st Floor
Chain Singh
31.
Receipt of Sethi ornaments
01 page
03 page
original
1st Floor
01 page
original
32.
Receipt of Mezan Jewelers amount
1st Floor
Rs. 5200/33.
Receipt of Sabdar Jewelers dated
original
1st Floor
24.06.2011
34.
Bank Receipt of A/C No.
Bank Receipt dated 08.04.2024 of
1st Floor
Xerox Adhaar Card No.
01 page
original
1st Floor
Shah Zareen A/C 7501
36.
01 page
original
790010110001199
35.
01 page
01 page
original
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
633554455007 of Razia
37.
Xerox Pan Card No. ARWPR8957Q
of Razia
38.
Xerox Adhar Card No.
495289864388 of Showkat Mir
39.
Xerox Passport No. R4522247 of
Showkat Mir
40.
Xerox Pan No. DACPM8837C of
Showkat Ahmad
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
41.
Xerox Pan No. OKKPS6156K of
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 Xerox
1st Floor
01 page
Deeba Showkat
42.
Xerox Aadhar Card No.
488886031751
43.
BA qualification Certificate bearing
reg. No. 17478-PR-84 dated
original
30.09.1988 of Showkat Ahmad Mir
original
44.
Matriculation certificate S.No. 4214
1st Floor
vide Roll No. 20597 of Showkat
01 page
original
Ahmad Mir in original
45.
Xerox Higher Secondary
1st Floor
examination Part 2 certificate vide
01 page
Xerox
Roll No. 6755 of Showkat Ahmad
Mir
46.
Character certificate bearing No. 818
1st Floor
issued by GHS Batamaloo of
01 page
original
Showkat Ahmad Mir in original
47.
Appointment order No. 167 C of
1st Floor
1993 issued vide endstt. No. Estt/M-
01 page
original
93/II/ADO dated 31.03.1993 issued
by DGP J&K camp office Srinagar
endorsed by administrative officer
(in original)
48.
Advertisement Notice of J&K Police
Hqrs Camp Srinagar in r/o post of
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
1st Floor
(typed 02
pages)
sub insepector stenography having
GB initials dated 23.01.1992
purportedly issued by G.N Saksana
DGP J&K (typed 02 pages)
49.
Call letter for short & type writing
1st Floor
test issued vide No. Estt/APPT-dated
(01 page
typed)
03.08.1989 issued by Administrative
officer J&K Police Hqrs Sgr. (01
page typed)
50.
Circular No. 42-GAD of 2014 dated
1st Floor
05 xerox
1st Floor
01 xerox
1st Floor
Shadow
04.10.2014 issued vide no.
GAD(Adm) 203-2014-1 dated
04.10.2014
51.
Certificate issued vide No.
Estt/MEC-07/2015/18769 dated
02.05.2015 by DPO Srinagar
52.
Shadow Service book bound of
Showkat Ahmad Mir S/O Gh.
Service
Mohammad Mir R/O Nursing Grah
book
Karanagar Srinagar comprising of
bound
(46) Lvs.
(46) Lvs
8. Significantly, the Investigating Officer also fairly conceded that, as on
date, the investigation has not yielded any material suggesting that the
accused had amassed assets disproportionate to his known sources of
income. The investigation, therefore, essentially pertains to the
allegation that the accused secured employment on the basis of fake
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
and forged documents and thereafter received salary and other
emoluments consequent upon such appointment.
9. Once the scope of investigation is viewed in the aforesaid backdrop,
there appears to be no justifiable reason for continued retention of
articles/documents having no nexus with the alleged fraudulent
appointment. The account statements, PLI passbooks, cash certificates,
property returns, bank-locker receipts, receipts pertaining to purchase
of jewellery and other personal documents of the petitioners cannot,
merely because they were recovered during the course of search, be
retained indefinitely when their relevance to the offence under
investigation is neither demonstrated nor otherwise discernible from
the record.
10. It is also pertinent to notice that the petitioners are immediate family
members of the accused and there is no allegation in the FIR that they
were privy to, or in any manner participated in, the preparation or use
of the allegedly forged documents. Their personal financial and other
records, therefore, cannot be retained merely on account of their
relationship with the accused, particularly when the prosecution itself
is unable to demonstrate any nexus between such documents and the
offences under investigation.
11. Sections 451 and 457 Cr.P.C. vest the competent Court with
jurisdiction to pass appropriate orders regarding custody and disposal
of property during the pendency of investigation or trial. Such
discretion is required to be exercised judiciously, keeping in view,
inter alia, the nature of the property, its relevance to the investigation
or trial, and the necessity of its continued retention.
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
12. In the present case, the learned Trial Court appears to have declined
release of a substantial part of the seized material without adequately
examining whether each such article/document had any bearing upon
the allegations forming the subject matter of the FIR. Mere pendency
of investigation, by itself, cannot constitute sufficient justification for
continued retention of documents which have no discernible nexus
with the offence under investigation.
13. The prosecution case is not one relating to acquisition or possession
of assets disproportionate to the known sources of income of the
accused. Consequently, the continued retention of cash certificates,
PLI passbooks, bank-locker receipts, jewellery-purchase receipts and
other similar documents cannot be said to advance the investigation
into the allegation that the accused had secured public employment on
the strength of fake or forged documents.
14. At the same time, the documents figuring at Serial Nos. 43 to 52 of
the seizure list pertain to the educational qualifications, appointment
and service record of the accused and have a direct bearing upon the
allegations under investigation. Their continued retention by the
Investigating Agency, at this stage, is therefore justified.
15. For the foregoing reasons, the petition merits acceptance and is,
accordingly, allowed. The order dated 25.11.2025 passed by the
learned Trial Court is modified to the extent that, in addition to the
articles/documents already directed to be released, all the seized
articles/documents out of the 52 items, except those figuring at Serial
Nos. 43 to 52, shall stand released on superdari in favour of
petitioner No. 1, subject to her furnishing an undertaking before the
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
learned Trial Court that the said articles/documents shall be preserved
in their present form and shall be produced before the Investigating
Agency or the Court, as and when required during the course of
investigation or trial.
16. The articles/documents figuring at Serial Nos. 43 to 52 shall,
however, continue to remain in the custody of the Investigating
Agency, subject to further orders of the competent Court.
17. The Case Diary, after perusal, be returned to the Investigating Officer.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
09.09.2026
Akhil Dev
Whether the order is speaking?
Yes
Whether the order is reportable? Yes
CRM(M) No. 791/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review