Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
INDRAJEET
SAHU
Digitally signed
by INDRAJEET
SAHU
Date: 2026.01.31
11:19:04 +0530
2026:CGHC:4379-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1900 of 2025
1 - Ravishankar Panariya S/o Lt. Suresh Panariya, Aged About 29 Years R/o
Ward No. 4, Fataktola Village, Sarbahra P.S. Gourela, Distt. Gourela- PendraMarwahi (C.G.).
... Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through District Magistrate, Raigarh Distt. Raigarh
(Now Sarangarh- Bilaigarh) C.G.
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
For State
:
:
Ms. Megha Mishra, Advocate.
Shri Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ramesh Sinha, CJ
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Order on Board
27.01.2026
Per, Ramesh Sinha, CJ.
Though the matter was listed for orders on application for suspension
of sentence and grant of bail to the appellant, however, with the
consent of the parties, the matter is heard finally.
2 This appeal has been filed by the appellant under Section 415(2) of
BNSS, 2023 against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 31.07.2025 passed by the Special Judge (NDPS),
Raigarh, in Special Criminal Case (NDPS) No.24 of 2022 whereby the
appellant has been convicted for the offence under Section 20(b)(ii)(C)
of the NDPS Act and sentenced for RI for 12 years with fine of
Rs.2,00,000/-, in default of payment of fine, additional RI for one year.
3 The prosecution case in brief is that, on 14.03.2022 the police of Police
Station Baramkela received a secret information that TATA Super (S)
Pickup (Chhota Hathi) vehicle is coming from Sohela-Baramkela Main
road and transporting Ganja in it. The secret information was recorded
in Rojnamcha Ex.P/45 and two independent witnesses were called
through Constable. When the independent witnesses came to police
station, police informed them about the secret information and
proceeded
towards
the
place
of
incident.
Secret
information
Panchnama and necessity to search without warrant Panchnama was
also prepared and copies of both these Panchnamas were forwarded
to SDO(P) Sarangarh. When the police reached on the spot at Birnipali
barrier, the suspected vehicle came there. The police party intercepted
the vehicle and driver of vehicle disclosed his name Ravishankar
Panariya. A notice under Section 50 of the NDPS Act was given to him
and he was informed his right to be searched by the Gazetted officer,
Magistrate or by the police himself. The accused person gave his
consent to be searched by the police officers and thereafter the police
party also gave their own search to the accused person but nothing
incriminating articles were seized from police party and Panchnama
Ex.P/6 to P/9 were prepared. On being search of the vehicle of the
accused, from a secret chamber prepared in the Dala of the vehicle, 30
packets wrapped with brown coloured tape were found which were
kept under the bags of Ginger. Talasi Panchnama Ex.P/10 and
recovery Panchnama Ex.P/11 were prepared. The contents of packets
were identified by smell, taste and rubbing and was found to be Ganja
and identification Panchnama Ex.P/12 was prepared. A notice under
Section 67 of NDPS Act was also given to the accused, but he did no
produce any document with respect to its possession. Weighment
witness Subham Sahu was also called along with electronic weighment
apparatus and physical verification Panchnama of weighing machine
Ex.P/13 was prepared. On being weight, total Ganja was found to be of
150 KG and weighment Panchnama Ex.P/14 was prepared. The
contents
of
packets
were
homogenized
on
the
spot
and
homogenization Panchnama Ex.P/15 was prepared. Two samples of
100 gram each were separated. The weighment Panchnama of sample
packets were also prepared which is Ex.P/16. The remaining Ganja
was refilled in 5 white cloloured plastic bag which were marked as A,
A1,A2,A3 and A4 and two sample packets were marked as A5 & A6.
The specimen seal Panchnama Ex.P/17 was prepared and it has been
sealed with the seal of Police Station. The sealing Panchnama Ex.P/18
and specimen seal Panchnama Ex.P/19 were prepared. Four bags of
30 KG each and one bag of 29.800 KG Ganja, two sample of 100
Gram each, one TATA Super (S) Pickup vehicle and its RC Book have
been seized vide seizure memo Ex.P/20. Dehati Nalisi Ex.P/48 was
recorded on the spot and the accused was arrested. The arrest of
accused was informed to his mother through mobile phone and
statement of witnesses were recorded on the spot. The police party
along with seized articles and accused came back to police station
where FIR Ex.P/51 was recorded. The seized articles were kept in safe
custody of Malkhana and obtained its acknowledgment Ex.P/52. The
details of proceeding were sent to SDO(P) Sarangarh which is Ex.P/32.
Spot map Ex.P/54 was prepared. The inventory was done by the
Executive Magistrate, Baramkela and physical verification Panchnama
Ex.P/28, sample and seal Panchnama Ex.P/36 and inventory
photography Ex.P/38 and P/39 were prepared by him. Along with
memo of Superintendent of Police, Raigarh, the sample packets were
sent for its chemical examination to regional FSL Bilaspur from where
report Ex.P/57 was received in which the contents of sample packets
were found to be ganja.
4 After completion of usual investigation, charge sheet was filed against
the appellant before the trial court for the offence under Section 20(b)
of the NDPS Act. The trial court framed charge against the appellant for
the offence under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act. The appellant
denied the charge and claimed trial.
5 In order to prove the charge against the appellant, the prosecution has
examined as many as 12 witnesses. Statement of the appellant under
Section 313 CrPC have also been recorded in which he denied the
circumstances that appears against him, pleaded innocence and have
submitted that he has been falsely implicated in the offence.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the trial court has convicted the appellant and sentenced
him as mentioned in the earlier paragraph of this judgment. Hence this
appeal.
Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are
material omissions and contradictions in the evidence of prosecution
witnesses which cannot be made basis to convict the appellant for the
alleged offence. There are non compliance of the mandatory provisions
of Section 42, 50, 52, 52-A, 55 and 57 of the NDPS Act. The appellant
is a Driver of the vehicle and he was not in knowledge that a secret
chamber was prepared inside the Dala of said vehicle in which Ganja
was kept. He was assigned the duty to transport Ginger which was
loaded in the Dala. The owner of the vehicle has not been made as an
accused in the case. The independent witnesses have not supported
the case of prosecution and conviction has been made only on the
basis of evidence of investigating officer. All the documents have been
prepared in the police station and not on the spot and the investigation
carried out by the police is tainted. There are material irregularities in
the search and seizure proceeding. There are major discrepancies in
the evidence of investigating officer. In absence of any cogent and
clinching evidence against the appellant, he cannot be convicted,
therefore, he is entitled for acquittal.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State opposes and have
submitted that the entire procedure as prescribed under the NDPS Act
and Rules have been followed in its letter and spirit and after
considering the evidence available on record, the learned trial Court
has rightly convicted and sentenced the appellant for the alleged
offence. The appellant was found in possession of the vehicle and he
was driving the same in which the huge quantity of Ganja i.e. 150 KG
of Ganja was being transported by the appellant which was kept in a
secret chamber in the Dala under the bags of Ginger. No explanation
has been offered by the appellant as to how he came into the
possession of such a huge quantity of Ganja in his vehicle. Merely
saying that he is only a Driver and working under the instructions of his
owner would not absolve him from the liability. All the mandatory
provisions have been duly complied with and there is no irregularity or
infirmity in the impugned judgment passed by the trial court and the
appeal of the appellant is liable to be dismissed.
We have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record of
trial court with utmost circumspection.
10 PW-12, Jitendra Assaiya, is the Investigating officer of the case. He
has stated in his evidence that on on 14.03.2022 he received a secret
information that an numbered TATA Super (S) Pickup (Chhota Hathi)
vehicle is coming from Sohela-Baramkela Main road having loaded
with Ganja. The secret information was recorded in Rojnamcha Sanha
No.2 which is Ex.P/45. Two independent witnesses were called through
Constable Jayman Ekka and his duty certificate is Ex.P/33. The
independent witnesses Uttam Sarthi and Dolamani Sagar and
weighment witness Shubham Sahu were called and informed about the
secret information and secret information Panchnama Ex.P/2 was
prepared. Secret information Panchnama and necessity to search
without warrant Panchnama were forwarded to SDO(P) Sarangarh
through Constable Jayman Ekka. Thereafter the police party along with
investigation
Kit
sealing
article,
candle,
electronic
weighment
apparatus, bags, laptop, printer and other relevant articles proceeded
to conduct raid on the spot by government vehicle. When the police
reached on the spot i.e. Birnipali barrier, they intercepted the vehicle
and driver of vehicle disclosed his name Ravishankar Panariya. A
notice under Section 50 of the NDPS Act was given to him and he was
informed about his right to be searched by the Gazetted officer,
Magistrate or by the police himself, to which the accused person gave
his consent to be searched by the police officers which is recorded in
writing in Ex.P/5. On his own search, nothing incriminating could be
found and Panchnama Ex.P/6 was prepared. Thereafter the police
party also gave their own search to the accused person but nothing
incriminating articles were found and Panchnama Ex.P/7 was
prepared. Even in police vehicle search, nothing incriminating article
were found. On being search of the vehicle of the accused, from a
secret chamber prepared in the Dala of the vehicle, 30 packets
wrapped with brown coloured tape were found. Above the said secret
chamber, the bags of Ginger were loaded. Talasi Panchnama Ex.P/10
and recovery Panchnama Ex.P/11 were prepared. The contents of
packets were physically identified by smell, taste and rubbing and was
found to be Ganja and identification Panchnama Ex.P/12 was
prepared. A notice under Section 67 of NDPS Act was also given to the
accused, but he did no produce any document with respect to its
possession. The electronic weighment apparatus was physically
verified vide Ex.P/15.
On being weight, total Ganja was found to be of 150 KG and
weighment Panchnama Ex.P/14 was prepared. The contents of
packets were homogenized on the spot and homogenization
Panchnama Ex.P/15 was prepared. Two samples of 100 gram each
were separated and sample packets weighment Panchnama Ex.P/16
was prepared. The remaining Ganja were refilled in 5 plastic bags
which were marked as A, A1,A2,A3 and A4 and two sample packets
were marked as A5 & A6. The specimen seal Panchnama Ex.P/17 was
prepared. The sealing Panchnama Ex.P/18 and specimen seal
Panchnama Ex.P/19 were also prepared. The Ganja, its sample
packets, vehicle and its RC Book were seized vide seizure memo
Ex.P/20. Dehati Nalisi Ex.P/48 was recorded on the spot and the
accused was arrested and his arrest was informed to his mother
through mobile phone. The statement of witnesses were recorded on
the spot. The police party along with seized articles and accused came
back to police station where FIR Ex.P/51 was registered. The seized
articles were handed over to Malkhana Moharri to kept in safe custody
and obtained its acknowledgment Ex.P/52. The details of proceeding
were sent to SDO(P) Sarangarh which is Ex.P/32. Spot map Ex.P/54
was prepared. The application to conduct inventory was sent to
Executive Magistrate, Baramkela which is Ex.P/55 and in pursuance
thereof the inventory was conducted by him and physical verification
Panchnama Ex.P/28, sample and seal Panchnama Ex.P/36 and
inventory photography Ex.P/38 and P/39 were prepared. Along with
memo of Superintendent of Police, Raigarh, the sample packets of
Ganja were sent for its chemical examination to regional FSL Bilaspur
from where report Ex.P/57 was received in which the contents of Ganja
were found. After completion of usual investigation, charge sheet was
filed before the trial court.
In cross examination, this witness remain firm in search and
seizure proceeding and proved each and every procedure which he
adopted. Though in some places he admits that there is no mentioning
of time in the notice issued under Section 160 CrPC to the witnesses
and there is no mention of the name and seal of issuing authority, but
this does not affect the prosecution case when the other documents
duly supported calling of witnesses and their presence at the time of
search and seizure proceeding. But for minor omissions and
contradictions, his evidence remain intact with that of search and
seizure proceeding. He denied the suggestions given by the defennce
with respect to non compliance of mandatory provisions.
11 PW-11, Ajib Kumar Beck, is the Sub Inspector of Police who conducted
further investigation after transfer of PW-12 Jitendra Assaiya. He has
stated in his evidence that when he received the case diary for further
investigation, he wrote a letter to the RTO, Veerbhumi, West Bengal for
details of the owner of the vehicle which is Ex.P/40 and as per the
information furnished by the said RTO, the vehicle was registered in
the name of Paras Bhakat and the said information is Ex.P/41. Paras
Bhakat was also made an accused, but he is absconding and after
obtaining permission from the concerned police authority Ex.P/43, the
charge sheet was filed against the present appellant showing the said
accused Paras Bhakat absconding. He also proved Malkhana register
Ex.P/44 and Rojnamcha Sanha Ex.P/45. He too remain firm in his
cross examination about his part of investigation and defence could not
extracted any material to hold the investigation tainted.
12 PW-1, Uttam Sarthi and PW-2 Dulamani Sagar, are independent
witnesses. Though they have not supported the case of prosecution,
but have admitted their signatures over documents Ex.P/1 to P/21
which were prepared during search and seizure proceeding.
13 PW-3, Shubham Sahu, is the weighment witness. He too have turned
hostile, however have admitted his signature over document Ex.P/25 to
P/28.
14 PW-4, Santram Kewat, is the Constable who took the sample packets
from Police Station to FSL Bilaspur. In cross examination, though he
could not state at what time he reached at Bilaspur to deposit the
sample packets at FSL, but he stated that in the morning he proceeded
from Police Station to FSL and reached at Bilaspur at 2:30-3:00 PM.
He deposited the sample packets to the Dispatch Section of FSL.
15 PW-5, Ram Kumar Manikpuri, is the Assistant Sub Inspector, who had
gone to RTO, Veerbhumi, West Bengal in search of the owner of the
vehicle Paras Bhakat, but he could not found at the given address and
Farari Panchnama Ex.P/31 was prepared.
16 PW-6, Anil Kumar Sahu, is the Head Constable and Reader of SDO(P)
Sarangarh. He received the secret information Panchnama and
necessity to search without warrant Panchnama and also received the
details of proceeding Ex. P/32. He is also a procedural witness and
duly supported the prosecution case that while posted at the office of
SDO(P) Sarangarh he received the aforesaid documents and issued
acknowledgment for the same.
17 PW-7, Rambharos Sidar, is the Patwari who prepared the spot map
Ex.P/33.
18 PW-8, Jagjivan Jolhe, is the Constable and member of police party. He
too have duly supported the search and seizure proceeding which they
did on the spot. In his cross examination also nothing could be
extracted by the defence to disbelieve the case of prosecution. He
substantively supported the prosecution’s case.
19 PW-9, Jayman Ekka, is the Constable who called the independent
witnesses at the instance of investigating officer Jitendra Assaiya, PW12.
20 PW-10, Anuj Kumar Patel, is the Executive Magistrate who conducted
inventory and proved the documents Ex.P/28 and Ex.P/36 to P/39. He
stated in his evidence that he received a memo from the Station House
Officer, Police Station, Dongripali and conducted the inventory. Two
sample packets of 100 gram each Ganja were separated after
homogenization of the Ganja and remaining Ganja were refilled in 5
bags which were marked as A and A1 to A4 which were kept in
Malkhana. The said bags of Ganja were weigh and were found to be
correct weight of 30 KG each of 4 bags and 29.800 KG in another bag.
Photography was also done and Panchnamas were prepared. In cross
examination, he too remain firm in conducting the inventory
proceeding.
21 In the present case the secret information Panchnama Ex.P/2 was
prepared by the police in presence of witnesses PW-1 & PW-2. They
admitted their signature over the said Panchnama. A copy of secret
information Panchnama was forwarded to the office of SDO(P)
Sarangarh by PW-9, Jayman Ekka on the same day which was
received in the office of SDO(P) by PW-6 Anil Kumar Sahu, Head
Constable, posted as Reader in the office of SDO(P). He also proved
acknowledgment of secret information Panchnnama on 14.03.2022. He
also proved the details of search and seizure proceeding Ex.P/32
which he received on 15.03.2022.
22 On the query of counsel for the appellant that provisions of Section 42
of the NDPS Act have not been complied with, the witnesses have
explained that the Ganja was seized while transporting through the
vehicle, yet they have complied with the provisions of Section 42 of the
NDPS Act.
23 Section 43 of the NDPS Act provides the powers of seizure and arrest
in public place which towards as under:
“43. Power of seizure and arrest in public place- Any officer of any
of the departments mentioned in section 42 may:(a) seize in any public place or in transit, any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance or controlled substance in respect of which he
has reason to believe an offence punishable under this Act has been
committed, and, along with such drug or substance, any animal or
conveyance or article liable to confiscation under this Act, any
document or other article which he has reason to believe may furnish
evidence of the commission of an offence punishable under this Act or
any document or other article which may furnish evidence of holding
any illegally acquired property which is liable for seizure or freezing or
forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act;
(b) detain and search any person whom he has reason to believe to
have committed an offence punishable under this Act, and if such
person has any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance or controlled
substance in his possession and such possession appears to him to
be unlawful, arrest him and any other person in his company.
Explanation- For the purposes of this section, the expression public
place" includes any public conveyance, hotel, shop, or other place
intended for use by, or accessible to, the public.”
The facts of the case as well as evidence available in the case makes
it clear that the vehicle was being stopped near Birnipali barrier on
Sohela-Baramkela main road. While checking the vehicle, it was found
contained with cannabis (Ganja) kept in its secret chamber prepared in
Dala of the vehicle. Admittedly it was being checked on the public
place i.e. on the main road and the said Ganja was seized/recovered
in transit which was being carried by the appellant on his vehicle.
Therefore, the issue of non-compliance of Section 42 is not applicable
in the present case and the police authority have acted under Section
43 of the NDPS Act when the place of occurrence was a public road
and accessibility to the public and therefore it fell within the ambit of
the public place. In view of the provisions of explanation to Section 43,
Section 42 of the NDPS had no application. Despite that the copy of
secret information was forwarded to the SDO(P) Sarangarh on the
same day which has been proved by the witnesses. The Ganja was
recovered and seized while in transit as the contraband were
recovered and seized during transit in the Scorpio vehicle, as
contemplated in Section 43(a) i.e. "Seize in any public place or in
transit", this Court is of the considered opinion that Section 43 of the
NDPS Act is applicable and as such, recording for reason for belief
and for taking down of information received in writing with regard to
the Commission of offence before conducting search and seizure, is
not required to be complied with under Section 43 of NDPS Act.
In the matter of Firdoskhan Khurshidkhan vs. State of Gujarat and
Another dated 30.04.2024 reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 680 has
held in para 18 as under:
"18. Section 42 of the NDPS Act deals with search and seizure from a
building, conveyance or enclosed place. When the search and seizure
is effected from a public place, the provisions of Section 43 of the
NDPS Act would apply and hence, there is no merit in the contention
of learned counsel for the appellants that non-compliance of the
requirement of Section 42(2) vitiates the search and seizure. Hence,
the said contention is noted to be rejected."
In the matter of State of Haryana vs. Jarnail Singh and Others
reported in 2004 (5) SCC 188 in Para 9 and 10 of its judgment the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that:
"9. Sections 42 and 43, therefore, contemplate two different situations.
Section 42 contemplates entry into and search of any building,
conveyance or enclosed place, while Section 43 contemplates a
seizure made in any public place or in transit. If seizure is made under
Section 42 between sunset and sunrise, the requirement of the proviso
thereto has to be complied with. There is no such proviso in Section 43
of the Act and, therefore, it is obvious that if a public conveyance is
searched in a public place, the officer making the search is not
required to record his satisfaction as contemplated by the proviso to
Section 42 of the NDPS Act for searching the vehicle between sunset
and the sunrise.
10. In the instant case there is no dispute that the tanker was moving
on the public highway when it was stopped and searched. Section 43
therefore clearly applied to the facts of this case. Such being the
factual position there was no requirement of the officer conducting the
search to record the grounds of his belief as contemplated by the
proviso to Section 42. Moreover it cannot be lost sight of that the
Superintendent of Police was also a member of the searching party. It
has been held by this Court in M. Prabhulal vs. Assistant Director,
Directorate of Revenue Intelligence : (2003) 8 SCC 449 that where a
search is conducted by a gazetted officer himself acting under Section
41 of the NDPS Act, it was not necessary to comply with the
requirement of Section 42. For this reason also, in the facts of this
case, it was not necessary to comply with the requirement of the
proviso to Section 42 of the NDPS Act."
In the matter of Kallu Khan vs. State of Rajasthan reported in 2021
(19) SCC 197 in Para 12, 13 and 16 of its judgment the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that:
“12. After hearing and on perusal of record and the evidence brought,
it is apparent that on apprehending the accused, while making search
of the motor cycle, 900 gm of smack was seized to which seizure and
sample memos were prepared, as proved by the departmental
witnesses. In the facts of the case at hand, where the search and
seizure was made from the vehicle used, by way of chance recovery
from public road, the provisions of Section 43 of the NDPS Act would
apply. In this regard, the guidance may be taken from the judgments
of this Court in S. K. Raju (supra) and S.K. Sakkar (supra). However,
the recovery made by Pranveer Singh (PW6) cannot be doubted in
the facts of this case.
13. Now reverting to the contention that the motor cycle seized in
commission of offence does not belong to accused, however seizure
of the contraband from the motor cycle cannot be connected to prove
the guilt of accused. The Trial Court on appraisal of the testimony of
witnesses, Constable Preetam Singh (PW1), Constable Sardar Singh
(PW2), S.I. Pranveer Singh (PW6) and ConstableRajendra Prasad
(PW8), who were members of the patrolling team and the witnesses
of the seizure, proved beyond reasonable doubt, when they were on
patrolling, the appellant came driving the seized vehicle from opposite
side. On seeing the police vehicle, he had taken back the motor cycle
which he was riding. However, the police team apprehended and
intercepted the accused and made the search of vehicle, in which the
seized contraband smack was found beneath the seat of the vehicle.
However, while making search at public place, the contraband was
seized from the motor cycle driven by the accused. Thus, recovery of
the contraband from the motor cycle of the appellant was a chance
recovery on a public road. As per Section 43 of NDPS Act, any officer
of any of the departments, specified in Section 42, is having power of
seizure and arrest of the accused from a public place, or in transit of
any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance or controlled substance.
The said officer may detain in search any person whom he has reason
to believe that he has committed an offence punishable under the
provisions of the NDPS Act, in case the possession of the narcotic
drug or psychotropic substance appears to be unlawful. Learned
senior counsel representing the appellant is unable to show any
deficiency in following the procedure or perversity to the findings
recorded by the Trial Court, affirmed by the High Court. The seizure of
the motor cycle from him is proved beyond reasonable doubt,
therefore, the question of ownership of vehicle is not relevant. In the
similar set of facts, in the case of Rizwan Khan (supra), this Court
observed the ownership of the vehicle is immaterial. Therefore, the
argument as advanced by learned senior counsel is of no substance
and meritless.”
The next submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that
Section 50 of NDPS Act has also not been complied with as the right to
the appellant about their search have not been informed by the police
authority as provided under Section 50 of the NDPS Act. The
provisions of Section 50 is applicable to the present search of the
accused persons whereas in the present case the cannabis (Ganja)
was recovered from the vehicle belongs to the accused persons which
cannot said to be his personal search. The search of a vehicle does not
comes under the requirement of Section 50 of the NDPS Act and
search of a person is distinguished from search of any vehicle etc.
In the matter of Kallu Khan (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court
has also considered the applicability of Section 50 of NDPS Act in
search of the vehicle. In Para 16, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held
that:
"16. Simultaneously, the arguments advanced by the appellant
regarding non−compliance of Section 50 of NDPS Act is bereft of any
merit because no recovery of contraband from the person of the
accused has been made to which compliance of the provision of
Section 50 NDPS Act has to follow mandatorily. In the present case, in
the search of motor cycle at public place, the seizure of contraband
was made, as revealed. Therefore, compliance of Section 50 does not
attract in the present case. It is settled in the case of Vijaysinh (supra)
that in the case of personal search only, the provisions of Section 50
of the Act is required to be complied with but not in the case of vehicle
as in the present case, following the judgments of Surinder Kumar
(supra) and Baljinder Singh (supra). Considering the facts of this
Court, the argument of non−compliance of Section 50 of NDPS Act
advanced by the counsel is hereby repelled."
In the matter of State of Punjab vs. Baldev Singh reported in 1999
(6) SCC 172 in Para 12 of its judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
held:
"12. On its plain reading, Section 50 would come into play only in the
case of a search of a person as distinguished from search of any
premises etc. However, if the empowered officer, without any prior
information as contemplated by Section 42 of the Act makes a search
or causes arrest of person during the normal course of investigation
into an offence or suspected offence and on completion of that search,
a contraband under the NDPS Act is also recovered, the requirements
of Section 50 of the Act are not attracted."
In the matter of Kulwinder Singh and Another vs. State of Punjab
reported in 2015 (6) SCC 674 in Para 18 and 21 of its judgment the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that:
18. In Dharampal Singh v. State of Punjab, it has been ruled that the
expression “possession” is not capable of precise and complete logical
definition of universal application in the context of all the statutes.
Recently, in Mohan Lal v. State of Rajasthan11, after referring to
certain authorities, this Court has held as follows:“21. From the aforesaid exposition of law it is quite vivid that
the term “possession” for the purpose of Section 18 of the
NDPS Act could mean physical possession with animus,
custody or dominion over the prohibited substance with
animus or even exercise of dominion and control as a result of
concealment. The animus and the mental intent which is the
primary and significant element to show and establish
possession. Further, personal knowledge as to the existence
of the “chattel” i.e. the illegal substance at a particular location
or site, at a relevant time and the intention based upon the
knowledge, would constitute the unique relationship and
manifest possession. In such a situation, presence and
existence of possession could be justified, for the intention is
to exercise right over the substance or the chattel and to act
as the owner to the exclusion of others.
22. In the case at hand, the appellant, we hold, had the
requisite degree of control when, even if the said narcotic
substance was not within his physical control at that moment.
To give an example, a person can conceal prohibited narcotic
substance in a property and move out thereafter. The said
person because of necessary animus would be in possession
of the said substance even if he is not, at the moment, in
physical control. The situation cannot be viewed differently
when a person conceals and hides the prohibited narcotic
substance in a public space. In the second category of cases,
the person would be in possession because he has the
necessary animus and the intention to retain control and
dominion."
21. In State of H.P. v. Pawan Kumar, it has been held that:
“10. We are not concerned here with the wide definition of the
word “person”, which in the legal world includes corporations,
associations or body of individuals as factually in these type of
cases search of their premises can be done and not of their
person. Having regard to the scheme of the Act and the
context in which it has been used in the section it naturally
means a human being or a living individual unit and not an
artificial person. The word has to be understood in a broad
common-sense manner and, therefore, not a naked or nude
body of a human being but the manner in which a normal
human being will move about in a civilised society. Therefore,
the most appropriate meaning of the word “person” appears to
be — “the body of a human being as presented to public view
usually with its appropriate coverings and clothing”. In a
civilised society appropriate coverings and clothings are
considered absolutely essential and no sane human being
comes in the gaze of others without appropriate coverings and
clothings. The appropriate coverings will include footwear also
as normally it is considered an essential article to be worn
while moving outside one’s home. Such appropriate coverings
or clothings or footwear, after being worn, move along with the
human body without any appreciable or extra effort. Once
worn, they would not normally get detached from the body of
the human being unless some specific effort in that direction is
made. For interpreting the provision, rare cases of some
religious monks and sages, who, according to the tenets of
their religious belief do not cover their body with clothings, are
not to be taken notice of. Therefore, the work 'person' would
mean a human being with appropriate coverings and clothings
and also footwear.
11. A bag, briefcase or any such article or container,
etc. can, under no circumstances, be treated as body
of a human being. They are given a separate name
and are identifiable as such. They cannot even
remotely be treated to be part of the body of a human
being. Depending upon the physical capacity of a
person, he may carry any number of items like a bag, a
briefcase, a suitcase, a tin box, a thaila, a jhola, a
gathri, a holdall, a carton, etc. of varying size,
dimension or weight. However, while carrying or
moving along with them, some extra effort or energy
would be required. They would have to be carried
either by the hand or hung on the shoulder or back or
placed on the head. In common parlance it would be
said that a person is carrying a particular article,
specifying the manner in which it was carried like hand,
shoulder, back or head, etc. Therefore, it is not
possible to include these articles within the ambit of the
word “person” occurring in Section 50 of the Act."
From the evidence of PW-12 Jitendra Assaiya, it comes on record that
when he detained the vehicle near Birnipali barrier, he issued a memo
to the Executive Magistrate for inventory and verification of the seized
Ganja which is Ex.P/55. On being served a memo upon the Executive
Magistrate, PW-10, Anuj Kumar Patel conducted the inventory and
proved the inventory proceeding and Panchnamas Ex.P/36 to P/39.
Recently in the matter of Bharat Aambale vs. The State of
Chhattisgarh in CRA No. 250 of 2025, order dated 06.01.2025, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that irrespective of any failure to
follow the procedure laid under Section 52-A of the NDPS Act if the
other material on record adduced by the prosecution inspires
confidence and satisfies the Court regarding both recovery and
possession of the contraband from the accused, then even in such
cases the Courts can without hesitation proceed for conviction
notwithstanding any procedural difficulty in terms of Section 52-A of the
NDPS Act.
In the matter of Bharat Aambale (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Para
25 to 37 has held as under:
25. In Noor Aga (supra) the order of conviction had been set-aside
not just on the ground of violation of Section 52A but due to several
other discrepancies in the physical evidence as to the colour and
weight, and due to the lack of any independent witnesses. In fact, this
Court despite being conscious of the procedural deficiencies in the
said case in terms of Section 52A observed that the matter may have
been entirely different if there were no other discrepancies or if the
other material on record were found to be convincing or supported by
independent witnesses. The relevant observations read as under: “107. The seal was not even deposited in the malkhana. As no
explanation whatsoever has been offered in this behalf, it is
difficult to hold that sanctity of the recovery was ensured. Even
the malkhana register was not produced.
xxx xxx xxx
108. There exist discrepancies also in regard to the time of
recovery. The recovery memo, Exhibit PB, shows that the time
of seizure was 11.20 p.m. PW 1 Kulwant Singh and PW 2 K.K.
Gupta, however, stated that the time of seizure was 8.30 p.m.
The appellant's defence was that some carton left by some
passenger was passed upon him, being a crew member in this
regard assumes importance (see Jitendra para 6). The
panchnama was said to have been drawn at 10 p.m. as per
PW 1 whereas PW 2 stated that panchnama was drawn at
8.30 p.m. Exhibit PA, containing the purported option to
conduct personal search under Section 50 of the Act, only
mentioned the time when the flight landed at the airport.
xxx xxx xxx
111. In a case of this nature, where there are a large number
of discrepancies, the appellant has been gravely prejudiced by
their non-examination. It is true that what matters is the quality
of the evidence and not the quantity thereof but in a case of
this nature where procedural safeguards were required to be
strictly complied with, it is for the prosecution to explain why
the material witnesses had not been examined. The matter
might have been different if the evidence of the investigating
officer who recovered the material objects was found to be
convincing. The statement of the investigating officer is wholly
unsubstantiated. There is nothing on record to show that the
said witnesses had turned hostile. Examination of the
independent witnesses was all the more necessary inasmuch
as there exist a large number of discrepancies in the
statement of official witnesses in regard to search and seizure
of which we may now take note.”
(Emphasis supplied)
26. Non-compliance or delayed compliance with the procedure
prescribed under Section 52A of the NDPS Act or the Rules /
Standing Order(s) thereunder may lead the court to draw an adverse
inference against the prosecution. However, no hard and fast rule can
be laid down as to when such inference may be drawn, and it would
all depend on the peculiar facts and circumstances of each case.
Such delay or deviation from Section 52A of the NDPS Act or the
Standing Order(s) / Rules thereunder will not, by itself, be fatal to the
case of the prosecution, unless there are discrepancies in the
physical evidence which may not have been there had such
compliance been done. What is required is that the courts take a
holistic and cumulative view of the discrepancies that exist in the
physical evidence adduced by the prosecution and correlate or link
the same with any procedural lapses or deviations. Thus, whenever,
there is any deviation or non-compliance of the procedure envisaged
under Section 52A, the courts are required to appreciate the same
keeping in mind the discrepancies that exist in the prosecution’s
case. In such instances of procedural error or deficiency, the courts
ought to be extra-careful and must not overlook or brush aside the
discrepancies lightly and rather should scrutinize the material on
record even more stringently to satisfy itself of the aspects of
possession, seizure or recovery of such material in the first place.
27. In such circumstances, particularly where there has been lapse
on the part of the police in either following the procedure laid down in
Section 52A of the NDPS Act or the prosecution in adequately
proving compliance of the same, it would not be appropriate for the
courts to resort to the statutory presumption of commission of an
offence from the possession of illicit material under Section 54 of the
NDPS Act, unless the court is otherwise satisfied as regards the
seizure or recovery of such material from the accused persons from
the other material on record. Similarly, irrespective of any failure to
follow the procedure laid under Section 52A of the NDPS Act, if the
other material on record adduced by the prosecution inspires
confidence and satisfies the court regarding both the recovery and
possession of the contraband from the accused, then even in such
cases, the courts can without hesitation proceed for conviction
notwithstanding any procedural defect in terms of Section 52A of the
NDPS Act.
28. In Khet Singh v. Union of India reported in (2002) 4 SCC 380
this Court held that the Standing Order(s) issued by the NCB and the
procedure envisaged therein is only intended to guide the officers and
to see that a fair procedure is adopted by the officer-in-charge of the
investigation. It further observed that there may, however, be
circumstances in which it would not be possible to follow these
guidelines to the letter, particularly in cases of chance recovery or
lack of proper facility being available at the spot. In such
circumstances of procedural illegality, the evidence collected thereby
will not become inadmissible and rather the courts would only be
required to consider all the circumstances and find out whether any
serious prejudice had been caused to the accused or not. Further it
directed, that in such cases of procedural lapses or delays, the officer
would be duty bound to indicate and explain the reason behind such
delay or deficiency whilst preparing the memo. The relevant
observations read as under: “5. It is true that the search and seizure of contraband article is
a serious aspect in the matter of investigation related to
offences under the NDPS Act. The NDPS Act and the Rules
framed thereunder have laid down a detailed procedure and
guidelines as to the manner in which search and seizure are to
be effected. If there is any violation of these guidelines, the
courts would take a serious view and the benefit would be
extended to the accused. The offences under the NDPS Act
are grave in nature and minimum punishment prescribed
under the statute is incarceration for a long period. As the
possession of any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance by
itself is made punishable under the Act, the seizure of the
article from the appellant is of vital importance.
xxx xxx xxx
10. The instructions issued by the Narcotics Control Bureau,
New Delhi are to be followed by the officer-in-charge of the
investigation of the crimes coming within the purview of the
NDPS Act, even though these instructions do not have the
force of law. They are intended to guide the officers and to see
that a fair procedure is adopted by the officer-in-charge of the
investigation. It is true that when a contraband article is seized
during investigation or search, a seizure mahazar should be
prepared at the spot in accordance with law. There may,
however, be circumstances in which it would not have been
possible for the officer to prepare the mahazar at the spot, as
it may be a chance recovery and the officer may not have the
facility to prepare a seizure mahazar at the spot itself. If the
seizure is effected at the place where there are no witnesses
and there is no facility for weighing the contraband article or
other requisite facilities are lacking, the officer can prepare the
seizure mahazar at a later stage as and when the facilities are
available, provided there are justifiable and reasonable
grounds to do so. In that event, where the seizure mahazar is
prepared at a later stage, the officer should indicate his
reasons as to why he had not prepared the mahazar at the
spot of recovery. If there is any inordinate delay in preparing
the seizure mahazar, that may give an opportunity to tamper
with the contraband article allegedly seized from the accused.
There may also be allegations that the article seized was by
itself substituted and some other items were planted to falsely
implicate the accused. To avoid these suspicious
circumstances and to have a fair procedure in respect of
search and seizure, it is always desirable to prepare the
seizure mahazar at the spot itself from where the contraband
articles were taken into custody.
xxx xxx xxx
16. Law on the point is very clear that even if there is any sort
of procedural illegality in conducting the search and seizure,
the evidence collected thereby will not become inadmissible
and the court would consider all the circumstances and find
out whether any serious prejudice had been caused to the
accused. If the search and seizure was in complete defiance
of the law and procedure and there was any possibility of the
evidence collected likely to have been tampered with or
interpolated during the course of such search or seizure, then,
it could be said that the evidence is not liable to be admissible
in evidence.” (Emphasis supplied)
29. A similar view as above was reiterated in the decision of State of
Punjab v. Makhan Chand reported in (2004) 3 SCC 453 wherein this
Court after examining the purport of Section 52A of the NDPS Act and
the Standing Order(s) issued thereunder, held that the procedure
prescribed under the said order is merely intended to guide the
officers to see that a fair procedure is adopted by the officer in charge
of the investigation and they were not inexorable rules. The relevant
observations read as under: “10. This contention too has no substance for two reasons.
Firstly, Section 52-A, as the marginal note indicates, deals with
“disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances”. Under sub-section (1), the Central Government,
by a notification in the Official Gazette, is empowered to specify
certain narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances, having
regard to the hazardous nature, vulnerability to theft,
substitution, constraints of proper storage space and such
other relevant considerations, so that even if they are material
objects seized in a criminal case, they could be disposed of
after following the procedure prescribed in sub-sections (2) and
(3). If the procedure prescribed in sub-sections (2) and (3) of
Bharat Aambale vs The State Of Chhattisgarh on 6 January,
2025 Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/94312390/
27 Section 52-A is complied with and upon an application, the
Magistrate issues the certificate contemplated by sub-section
(2), then sub-section (4) provides that, notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained in the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 or the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, such inventory,
photographs of narcotic drugs or substances and any list of
samples drawn under sub-section (2) of Section 52-A as
certified by the Magistrate, would be treated as primary
evidence in respect of the offence. Therefore, Section 52-A(1)
does not empower the Central Government to lay down the
procedure for search of an accused, but only deals with the
disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances. 11. Secondly, when the very same Standing
Orders came up for consideration in Khet Singh v. Union of
India this Court took the view that they are merely intended to
guide the officers to see that a fair procedure is adopted by the
officer in charge of the investigation. It was also held that they
were not inexorable rules as there could be circumstances in
which it may not be possible for the seizing officer to prepare
the mahazar at the spot, if it is a chance recovery, where the
officer may not have the facility to prepare the seizure mahazar
at the spot itself. Hence, we do not find any substance in this
contention.” (Emphasis supplied)
30. Thus, from above it is clear that the procedure prescribed by the
Standing Order(s) / Rules in terms of Section 52A of the NDPS Act is
only intended to guide the officers and to ensure that a fair procedure
is adopted by the officer- in-charge of the investigation, and as such
what is required is substantial compliance of the procedure laid
therein. We say so because, due to varying circumstances, there may
be situations wherein it may not always be possible to forward the
seized contraband immediately for the purpose of sampling. This
could be due to various factors, such as the sheer volume of the
contraband, the peculiar nature of the place of seizure, or owing to
the volatility of the substance so seized that may warrant slow and
safe handling. There could be situations where such contraband after
being sampled cannot be preserved due to its hazardous nature and
must be destroyed forthwith or vice-verse where the nature of the
case demands that they are preserved and remain untouched. Due to
such multitude of possibilities or situations, neither can the police be
realistically expected to rigidly adhere to the procedure laid down in
Section 52A or its allied Rules / Orders, nor can a strait-jacket formula
be applied for insisting compliance of each procedure in a specified
timeline to the letter, due to varying situations or requirements of each
case. Thus, what is actually required is only a substantial compliance
of the procedure laid down under Section 52A of the NDPS Act and
the Standing Order(s) / Rules framed thereunder, and any
discrepancy or deviation in the same may lead the court to draw an
adverse inference against the police as per the facts of each and
every case. When it comes to the outcome of trial, it is only after
taking a cumulative view of the entire material on record including
such discrepancies, that the court should proceed either to convict or
acquit the accused. Non- compliance of the procedure envisaged
under Section 52A may be fatal only in cases where such noncompliance goes to the heart or root of the matter. In other words, the
discrepancy should be such that it renders the entire case of the
prosecution doubtful, such as instances where there are significant
discrepancies in the colour or description of the substance seized
from that indicated in the FSL report as was the case in Noor Aga
(supra), or where the contraband was mixed in and stored with some
other commodity like vegetables and there is no credible indication of
whether the Bharat Aambale vs The State Of Chhattisgarh on 6
January, 2025 Indian Kanoon -http://indiankanoon.org/doc/94312390/
28 narcotic substance was separated and then weighed as required
under the Standing Order(s) or Rules, thereby raising doubts over the
actual quantity seized as was the case in Mohammed Khalid
(supra), or where the recovery itself is suspicious and uncorroborated
by any witnesses such as in Mangilal (supra), or where the bulk
material seized in contravention of Section 52A was not produced
before the court despite being directed to be preserved etc. These
illustrations are only for the purposes of brining clarity on what may
constitute as a significant discrepancy in a given case, and by no
means is either exhaustive in nature or supposed to be applied
mechanically in any proceeding under the NDPS Act. It is for the
courts to see what constitutes as a significant discrepancy, keeping in
mind the peculiar facts, the materials on record and the evidence
adduced. At the same time, we may caution the courts, not to be
hyper-technical whilst looking into the discrepancies that may exist,
like slight differences in the weight, colour or numbering of the
sample etc. The Court may not discard the entire prosecution case
looking into such discrepancies as more often than not an ordinarily
an officer in a public place would not be carrying a good scale with
him, as held in Noor Aga (supra). It is only those discrepancies which
particularly have the propensity to create a doubt or false impression
of illegal possession or recovery, or to overstate or inflate the potency,
quality or weight of the substance seized that may be pertinent and
not mere clerical mistakes, provided they are explained properly.
Whether, a particular discrepancy is critical to the prosecution’s case
would depend on the facts of each case, the nature of substance
seized, the quality of evidence on record etc.
31. At the same time, one must be mindful of the fact that Section
52A of the NDPS Act is only a procedural provision dealing with
seizure, inventory, and disposal of narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances and does not exhaustively lay down the evidentiary rules
for proving seizure or recovery, nor does it dictate the manner in
which evidence is to be led during trial. It in no manner prescribes
how the seizure or recovery of narcotic substances is to be proved or
what can be led as evidence to prove the same. Rather, it is the
general principles of evidence, as enshrined in the Evidence Act that
governs how seizure or recovery may be proved.
32. Thus, the prosecution sans the compliance of the procedure
under Section 52A of the NDPS Act will not render itself helpless but
can still prove the seizure or recovery of contraband by leading
cogent evidence in this regard such as by examining the seizing
officer, producing independent witnesses to the recovery, or
presenting the original quantity of seized substances before the court.
The evidentiary value of these materials is ultimately to be assessed
and looked into by the court. The court should consider whether the
evidence inspires confidence. The court should look into the totality of
circumstances and the credibility of the witnesses, being mindful to
be more cautious in their scrutiny where such procedure has been
flouted. The cumulative effect of all evidence must be considered to
determine whether the prosecution has successfully established the
case beyond reasonable doubt as held in Noor Aga (supra).
33. Even in cases where there is non-compliance with the procedural
requirements of Section 52A, it does not necessarily vitiate the trial or
warrant an automatic acquittal. Courts have consistently held that
procedural lapses must be viewed in the context of the overall
evidence. If the prosecution can otherwise establish the chain of
custody, corroborate the seizure with credible testimony, and prove its
case beyond reasonable doubt, the mere non-compliance with
Section 52A may not be fatal. The Bharat Aambale vs The State Of
Chhattisgarh
on
January,
Indian
Kanoon
-http://indiankanoon.org/doc/94312390/ 29 emphasis must be on
substantive justice rather than procedural technicalities, and keeping
in mind that the salutary objective of the NDPS Act is to curb the
menace of drug trafficking.
34. At this stage we may clarify the scope and purport of Section 52A
sub-section (4) with a view to obviate any confusion. Sub-section (4)
of Section 52A provides that every court trying an offence under the
NDPS Act, shall treat the inventory, photographs and samples of the
seized substance that have been certified by the magistrate as
primary evidence.
35. What this provision entails is that, where the seized substance
after being forwarded to the officer empowered is inventoried,
photographed and thereafter samples are drawn therefrom as per the
procedure prescribed under the said provision and the Rules /
Standing Order(s), and the same is also duly certified by a
magistrate, then such certified inventory, photographs and samples
has to mandatorily be treated as primary evidence. The use of the
word “shall” indicates that it would be mandatory for the court to treat
the same as primary evidence if twin conditions are fulfilled being (i)
that the inventory, photographs and samples drawn are certified by
the magistrate AND (ii) that the court is satisfied that the entire
process was done in consonance and substantial compliance with the
procedure prescribed under the provision and its Rules / Standing
Order(s).
36. Even where the bulk quantity of the seized material is not
produced before the court or happens to be destroyed or disposed in
contravention of Section 52A of the NDPS Act, the same would be
immaterial and have no bearing on the evidentiary value of any
inventory, photographs or samples of such substance that is duly
certified by a magistrate and prepared in terms of the said provision.
We say so, because sub-section (4) of Section 52A was inserted to
mitigate the issue of degradation, pilferage or theft of seized
substances affecting the very trial. It was often seen that, due to
prolonged trials, the substance that was seized would deteriorate in
quality or completely disappear even before the trial could proceed,
by the time the trial would commence, the unavailability of such
material would result in a crucial piece of evidence to establish
possession becoming missing and the outcome of the trial becoming
a foregone conclusion. The legislature being alive to this fact, thought
fit to introduce an element of preservation of such evidence of
possession of contraband in the form of inventory, photographs and
samples and imbued certain procedural safeguards and supervision
through the requirement of certification by a magistrate, which is now
contained in sub-section (4) of Section 52A. In other words, any
inventory, photographs or samples of seized substance that was
prepared in substantial compliance of the procedure under Section
52A of the NDPS Act and the Rules / Standing Order(s) thereunder
would have to mandatorily be treated as primary evidence,
irrespective of the fact that the bulk quantity has not been produced
and allegedly destroyed without any lawful order.
37. Section 52A sub-section (4) should not be conflated as a rule of
evidence in the traditional sense, i.e., it should not be construed to
have laid down that only the certified inventory, photographs and
samples of seized substance will be primary evidence and nothing
else. The rule of ‘Primary Evidence’ or ‘Best Evidence’ is now well
settled. In order to prove a fact, only the best evidence to establish
such fact must be led and adduced which often happens to be the
original evidence itself. The primary evidence for proving possession
will always be the seized substance itself. However, in order to
mitigate the challenges in preservation of such substance till the
duration of trial, due to Bharat Aambale vs The State Of Chhattisgarh
on
January,
Indian
Kanoon
http://indiankanoon.org/doc/94312390/
pilferage,
theft,
degradation or any other related circumstances, the legislature
consciously incorporated sub-section (4) in Section 52A to bring even
the inventory, photographs or samples of such seized substance on
the same pedestal as the original substance, and by a deeming
fiction has provided that the same be treated as primary evidence,
provided they have been certified by a magistrate in substantial
compliance of the procedure prescribed. This, however, does not
mean that where Section 52A has not been complied, the prosecution
would be helpless, and cannot prove the factum of possession by
adducing other primary evidence in this regard such as by either
producing the bulk quantity itself, or examining the witnesses to the
recovery etc. What Section 52A sub-section (4) of the NDPS Act does
is it creates a new form of primary evidence by way of a deeming
fiction which would be on par with the original seized substance as
long as the same was done in substantial compliance of the
procedure prescribed thereunder, however, the said provision by no
means renders the other evidence in original to be excluded as
primary evidence, it neither confines nor restricts the manner of
proving possession to only one mode i.e., through such certified
inventory, photographs or samples such that all other material are
said to be excluded from the ambit of ‘evidence’, rather it can be said
that the provision instead provides one additional limb of evidentiary
rule in proving such possession. Thus, even in the absence of
compliance of Section 52A of the NDPS Act, the courts cannot simply
overlook the other cogent evidence in the form of the seized
substance itself or the testimony of the witnesses examined, all that
the courts would be required in the absence of any such compliance
is to be more careful while appreciating the evidence.”
In the present case the entire search and seizure proceedings have
found genuine and the correct procedure have been drawn by the
police persons. Though, the independent witnesses have not
supported the prosecution case, but they have admitted their signature
over the documents and Panchnamas prepared on the spot which has
also been proved duly proved by the investigating officer. The seizure
of cannabis (Ganja) and its weight and sampling were proved by the
witnesses as well as Executive Magistrate and nothing adverse could
be found to disbelieve their evidences which further proves that the
appellant was found in possession of such a huge quantity of Ganja in
his vehicle which was kept in a secret chamber prepared in the Dala of
the vehicle. The appellant did not able to impute any palpable to make
good his case that there has been non-compliance of any mandatory
provisions of the NDPS Act.
There is no material available on record so as to arrive at a finding that
the appellant been falsely implicated in this case. Section 20 of the
NDPS Act provides that whoever in contravention of any provisions of
the Act or any Rule made thereunder possess Ganja shall be punished
in accordance with the said provisions. Section 20 (b) uses the
"possess". In the present case the appellant was found in possession
of 150 KG of Ganja in his TATA Super (S) (Chhota Hathi) vehicle which
he was carrying at the relevant time. The judgment passed by learned
trial Court is quite detailed judgment which has dealt with every aspect
of the matter and the analysis made therein clearly proves that the
appellant has committed the offence in question and was transporting
Ganja weighing 150 KG. He could not give any suggestion as to how
that huge quantity of Ganja came to be found in the vehicle in which he
was the driver.
The FSL report Ex.P/57 further proves that the sample packets of
Ganja which were drawn from the total quantity of Ganja were found to
be contained with Ganja contents and further corroborates the
allegation against the appellant.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the judgment passed by learned trial Court is based on proper
appreciation of evidence which is neither perverse nor contrary to the
record as well as law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the
same needs no interference as such the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence awarded to the appellant is hereby affirmed.
38 So far as the sentence awarded to the appellant is concerned, considering
the fact that appellant is presently aged about 30 years having various
responsibilities of his family; the offence of Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS Act
does not provide any minimum sentence and also considering the ratio of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mohammad Giasuddin Vs.
State of Andhra Pradesh, 1977 (3) SCC 287 as also in Rajabala Vs. State
of Haryana & Others, 2016 (1) SCC 463, we are of the considered opinion
that ends of justice would meet if the sentence awarded to the appellant is
reduced.
Accordingly, while maintaining conviction of the appellant for the offence
under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act, the sentence and fine amount
awarded to the appellant is reduced from RI for 12 years & fine of
Rs.2,00,000/- to RI for 10 years with fine of Rs.1,00,000/-. In default of
payment of fine amount, he shall further undergo additional RI for three
months.
With the aforesaid alteration/modification, the appeal is partly allowed.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is undergoing his jail
sentence to serve the same on the appellant informing him that he is at
liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this Court by
preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the
assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the Supreme
Court Legal Services Committee.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review