Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:203
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRR No. 1531 of 2025
1 - Raviram Netam S/o Hariguno Netam Aged About 73 Years R/o Village
Jhargaon P.S. Devbhog Distt. - Gariyaband Chhattisgarh
2 - Taruni Sen Netam S/o Raviram Netam Aged About 30 Years R/o Village
Jhargaon P.S. Devbhog Distt. - Gariyaband Chhattisgarh (Accused)
... Applicants
versus
Station House Officer, Police Station Devbhog, District - Gariyaband
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Applicants
:
None, even in the second round.
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Karan Kumar Baharani, Panel Lawyer
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal
Order on Board
02/01/2026
1.
Since no one appears in the case in repeated calls for hearing of the
case, this Court deems it appropriate to decide this revision by
invoking the provisions of Section 444 of the Bhartiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Section 403 of the CRPC). Though all the
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.01.13
15:13:09 +0530
procedural laws have as its foundation the maxim "Audi Alteram
Partem” and at all stages wherever the need be there are provisions
for issuance of notice and making sure that the party may be heard
before passing of any order, yet, as per the specific provisions of
Section 444 of BNSS (Section 403 of the CRPC), it is clear that a
party may or may not be heard, as the Court may decide while
exercising its power of revision. Since no one appeared on behalf of
the applicants on repeated occasions, this Court proceeds to decide
the criminal revision.
2.
The provisions of Section 444 of BNSS (Section 403 of CRPC) do
not violate the principles of natural justice. See "Mahabir Motor Co.,
Bhagalpur v. State of Bihar and Others (AIR 1956 Pat. 437), "Sau.
Ranjana Shivaji Rakhpasare v. Shivaji Bapu Rakhpasare and
Another" (2004 Cri.L.J. 145), and "Panatar Arvindbhai Ratilal Vs
State of Gujrat and others" (1991) 1 GLR 451.
3.
This is a criminal revision under Sections 438 and 442 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (in short ‘BNSS, 2023’)
against the impugned order dated 08-10-2025 passed by the
Additional Sessions Judge, Gariyaband, in Sessions Case No. 23 of
2025, whereby the charges against the applicants for the offence
under Sections 182, 211, 195 read with Section 34 of IPC has been
framed.
4.
The applicants are the accused persons in the Sessions Case No. 23
of 2025 pending before the Additional Sessions Judge, Gariyaband,
which arose out of the Istagasa No. 1 of 2024, registered at Police
Station Devbhog, District Gariyaband, for the offence under Sections
182, 211, 195, 34 of IPC. In the said Istagasa, it was alleged that on
02-01-2024, the accused persons were coming to his house by their
Activa scooter after having pledged their ornaments for Rs. 50,000/-
at Odisha, and on the way, the petrol in their vehicle ran out, and
they were forced to walk. At about 7:00 PM, near Tetalkhunti canal,
some persons assaulted them and looted Rs. 50,000/-, for which
they lodged a report to the police. Their complaint was inquired by
the SDO Police, Mainpur, and it was found that the present accused
persons have made a false complaint about the loot of Rs. 50,000/-,
and then the Istagasa has been prepared against the present
applicants, which has been filed before the Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Devbhog, and since the offence of Section 195 of the IPC was
triable by the learned Sessions Court, the same was committed to
the learned Sessions Court for its trial. Learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Gariyaband has framed charges against the applicants on
08-10-2025 for the offences under Sections 182, 211, 195 read with
Section 34 of IPC, which is under challenge in the present criminal
revision.
5.
I have perused the documents annexed with the present criminal
revision with respect to framing of charges by the learned trial Court.
6.
The document (Annexure A/3), which is the inquiry report submitted
by the SDO Police, Mainpur to the Senior Superintendent of Police,
District Gariyaband, dated 20-02-2024, in which he reported that, the
present applicants have made a false complaint with respect to the
loot of Rs. 50,000/- and as per the statement of the witnesses, the
presence of the present accused persons were not found on the
alleged place at the time of alleged incident, and there was no
commission of any offence with them, and it is only to avoid the
liability to repay the loan amount, the entire incident is framed by the
present applicants.
7.
After having gone through the inquiry report dated 20-02-2024 and
the statements of the witnesses annexed with the present criminal
revision, namely; Dumarlal Nagesh, Mansingh Sonwani, Nemichand
Jain, Maheshwar Dhruw, Jiran Singh Manjhi, Humendra Kumar
Durga and Hridyanand Pathar, there is sufficient material to frame
charges against the applicants, which has rightly been appreciated
by the learned trial Court and has framed charges vide order dated
08-10-2025.
8.
While considering the scope of Section 227 of the Cr.P.C., the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered in the case of “M.E.
Sivalingamurthy v. Central Bureau of Investigation, Bengaluru”,
(2020) 2 SCC 768, in Para 17 and 18 of its judgment, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has laid down the legal principles applicable in
regard to an application sitting discharge, which is as under :“17. This is an area covered by a large body of case
law. We refer to a recent judgment which has referred
to the earlier decisions viz. P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala
and discern the following principles:
17.1. If two views are possible and one of them
gives rise to suspicion only as distinguished
from grave suspicion, the trial Judge would be
empowered to discharge the accused.
17.2. The trial Judge is not a mere post office to
frame the charge at the instance of the
prosecution.
17.3. The Judge has merely to sift the evidence
in order to find out whether or not there is
sufficient ground for proceeding. Evidence
would consist of the statements recorded by
the police or the documents produced before
the Court.
17.4. If the evidence, which the Prosecutor
proposes to adduce to prove the guilt of the
accused, even if fully accepted before it is
challenged in cross- examination or rebutted by
the defence evidence, if any, "cannot show that
the accused committed offence, then, there will
be no sufficient ground for proceeding with the
trial".
17.5. It is open to the accused to explain away
the materials giving rise to the grave suspicion.
17.6. The court has to consider the broad
probabilities, the total effect of the evidence
and the documents produced before the court,
any basic infirmities appearing in the case and
so on. This, however, would not entitle the
court to make a roving inquiry into the pros and
cons.
17.7. At the time of framing of the charges, the
probative value of the material on record
cannot be gone into, and the material brought
on record by the prosecution, has to be
accepted as true.
17.8. There must exist some materials for
entertaining the strong suspicion which can
form the basis for drawing up a charge and
refusing to discharge the accused.
18. The defence of the accused is not to be looked into
at the stage when the accused seeks to be discharged
under Section 227 CrPC (see State of J&K v.
Sudershan Chakkar). The expression, "the record of
the case", used in Section 227 CrPC, is to be
understood as the documents and the articles, if any.
produced by the prosecution. The Code does not give
any right to the accused to produce any document at
the stage of framing of the charge. At the stage of
framing of the charge, the submission of the accused
is to be confined to the material produced by the
police (see State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi).”
9.
In the matter of “Ajay Singh and another v. State of Chhattisgarh
and others” (2017) 3 SCC 330, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para
9 of its judgment held that :
“9. Chapter XVIII CrPC provides for trial before a Court
of Session. Section 227 empowers the trial Judge to
discharge the accused after hearing the submissions
of the accused and the prosecution and on being
satisfied that there is no sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused. The key words of the
section are "not sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused". Interpreting the said provision,
the Court in P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala has held that
the Judge is not a mere post office to frame the charge
at the behest of the prosecution, but has to exercise
his judicial mind to the facts of the case in order to
determine whether a case for trial has been made out
by the prosecution. In assessing this fact, it is not
necessary for the court to enter into the pros and cons
of the matter or into a weighing and balancing of
evidence and probabilities which is really the function
of the court, after the trial starts. At the stage of
Section 227, the Judge has merely to sift the evidence
in order to find out whether or not there is sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused. In other
words, the sufficiency of ground would take within its
fold the nature of the evidence recorded by the police
or the documents produced before the court which ex
facie disclose that there are suspicious circumstances
against the accused so as to frame a charge against
him.”
10.
Further, in the matter of “Sajjan Kumar v. Central Bureau of
Investigation”, (2010) 9 SCC 368, in Para 21 of its judgment the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that :
“21. On consideration of the authorities about the
scope of Sections 227 d and 228 of the Code, the
following principles emerge:
(i) The Judge while considering the question of
framing the charges under Section 227 CrPC
has the undoubted power to sift and weigh the
evidence for the limited purpose of finding out
whether or not a prima facie case against the
accused has been made out. The test to
determine prima facie case would depend upon
the facts of each case.
(ii) Where the materials placed before the court
disclose grave suspicion against the accused
which has not been properly explained, the
court will be fully justified in framing a charge
and proceeding with the trial.
(iii) The court cannot act merely as a post office
or a mouthpiece of the prosecution but has to
consider the broad probabilities of the case, the
total effect of the evidence and the documents
produced
before
the
court,
any
basic
infirmities, etc. However, at this stage, there
cannot be a roving enquiry into the pros and
cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if
he was conducting a trial.
(iv) If on the basis of the material on record, the
court could form an 9 opinion that the accused
might have committed offence, it can frame the
charge, though for conviction the conclusion is
required to be proved beyond reasonable doubt
that the accused has committed the offence.
(v) At the time of framing of the charges, the
probative value of the material on record
cannot be gone into but before framing a
charge the court must apply its judicial mind on
the material placed on record and must be
satisfied that the commission of offence by the
accused was possible.
(vi) At the stage of Sections 227 and 228, the
court is required to evaluate the material and
documents on record with a view to find out if
the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face
value
disclose
the
existence
of
all
the
ingredients constituting the alleged offence.
For this limited purpose, sift the evidence as it
cannot be expected even at that initial stage to
accept all that the prosecution states as gospel
truth even if it is opposed to common sense or
the broad probabilities of the case.
(vii) If two views are possible and one of them
gives rise to suspicion only, as distinguished
from grave suspicion, the trial Judge will be
empowered to discharge the accused and at
this stage, he is not to see whether the trial will
end in conviction or acquittal.”
11.
Recently, in the matter of “Ram Prakash Chaddha v. State of Uttar
Pradesh”, AIR 2024 SC 3540, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
considered in Para 12 to 22 & 30 that :
“12. We have already considered the meaning of the
expression "the record of the case and the documents
submitted therewith" relying on the decision in
Debendra Nath Padhi's case (supra) only to re-assure
as to what are the materials falling under the said
expression and thus, available for consideration of an
application filed for discharge under Section 227,
Cr.PC. In the light of the same, there cannot be any
doubt with respect to the position that at the stage of
consideration of such an application for discharge,
defence case or material, if produced at all by the
accused, cannot be looked at all. Once "the record of
the case and the documents submitted therewith" are
before the Court they alone can be looked into for
considering
the
application
for
discharge
and
thereafter if it considers that there is no sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused concerned
then he shall be discharged after recording reasons
therefor. In that regard, it is only appropriate to
consider the authorities dealing with the question as
to what exactly is the scope of consideration and what
should
be
the
manner
of
consideration
while
exercising such power.
13. The decision in Yogesh alias Sachin Jagadish
Joshi v. State of Maharashtra' this Court held that the
words "not sufficient ground for proceeding against
the accused" appearing in Section 227, Cr.PC,
postulate exercise of judicial mind on the part of the
Judge to the facts of the case revealed from the
materials brought on record by the prosecution in
order to determine whether a case for trial has been
made out. In the decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. N.
Suresh Rajan and Ors. this Court held that at a stage
of consideration of an application for discharge, the
Court has to proceed with an assumption that the
materials brought on record by the prosecution are
true, and evaluate the materials to find out whether the
facts taken at their face value disclose the existence of
the ingredients constituting the offence. At this stage,
only the probative value of the materials has to be
gone into and the court is not expected to go deep into
the matter to hold a mini-trial.
14. In the decision in BK Sharma v. State of UP, the
High Court of judicature at Allahabad held that the
standard of test and judgment which is finally applied
before recording a finding of conviction against an
accused is not to be applied at the stage of framing
the charge. It is just a very strong suspicion, based on
the material on record, and would be sufficient to
frame a charge.
15. We are in agreement with the said view taken by
the High Court. At the same time, we would add that
the strong suspicion in order to be sufficient to frame
a charge should be based on the material brought on
record by the prosecution and should not be based on
supposition, suspicions and conjectures. In other
words, in order to be a basis to frame charge the
strong suspicion should be the one emerging from the
materials on record brought by the prosecution.
16. In the decision in Stree Atyachar Virodhi Parishad
v. Dilip Nathumal Chordia and Anr., this Court held that
the word 'ground' in Section 227 Cr.PC, did not mean a
ground for conviction, but a ground for put- ting the
accused on trial.
17. In P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala and Anr., after
extracting Section 227, Cr.PC, this Court in paragraph
Nos. 10 and 11 held thus: "10.
***********
...If two views are possible and one of them
gives rise to suspicion only, as distinguished
from grave suspicion, the trial Judge will be
empowered to discharge the accused and at
this stage he is not to see whether the trial will
end in conviction or acquittal. Further, the
words "not sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused" clearly show that the
Judge is not a mere post office to frame the
charge at the behest of the prosecution, but has
to exercise his judicial mind to the facts of the
case in order to determine whether a case for
trial has been made out by the prosecution. In
assessing this fact, it is not necessary for the
court to enter into the pros and cons of the
matter or into a weighing and balancing of
evidence and probabilities which is really the
function of the court, after the trial starts.
11. At the stage of Section 227, the Judge has
merely to sift the evidence in order to find out
whether or not there is sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused, In other
words, the sufficiency of ground would take
within its fold the nature of the evidence
recorded by the police or the documents
produced before the court which ex facie
disclose
that
there
are
suspicious
circumstances against the accused so as to
frame a charge against him."
18. In paragraph 13 in P. Vijayan's case (supra), this
Court took note of the principles enunciated earlier by
this Court in Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal
which reads thus: "10.…
(1) That the Judge while considering the
question of framing the charges under Section
227 of the Code has the undoubted power to
sift and weigh the evidence for the limited
purpose of finding out whether or not a prima
facie case against the accused has been made
out.
(2) Where the materials placed before the Court
disclose grave suspicion against the accused
which has not been properly explained the
Court will be fully justified in framing a charge
and proceeding with the trial.
(3) The test to determine a prima facie case
would naturally depend upon the facts of each
case and it is difficult to lay down a rule of
universal application. By and large however if
two views are equally possible and the Judge is
satisfied that the evidence produced before him
while giving rise to some suspicion but not
grave suspicion against the accused, he will be
fully within his right to discharge the accused.
(4) That in exercising his jurisdiction under
Section 227 of the Code the Judge which under
the present Code is a senior and experienced
court cannot act merely as a post office or a
mouthpiece of the prosecution, but has to
consider the broad probabilities of the case, the
total effect of the evidence and the documents
produced before the Court, any basic infirmities
appearing in the case and so on. This however
does not mean that the Judge should make a
roving enquiry into the pros and cons of the
matter and weigh the evidence as if he was
conducting a trial."
19. In the light of the decisions referred supra, it is
thus obvious that it will be within the jurisdiction of
the Court concerned to sift and weigh the evidence for
the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a
prima facie case against the accused concerned has
been made out. We are of the considered view that a
caution has to be sounded for the reason that the
chances of going beyond the permissible jurisdiction
under Section 227, Cr.PC, and entering into the scope
of power under Section 232, Cr.PC, cannot be ruled
lout as such instances are aplenty. In this con- text, it
is relevant to refer to a decision of this Court in Om
Parkash Sharmav. CBI. Taking note of the language of
Section 227, Cr.PC, is in negative terminology and that
the language in Section 232, Cr.PC, is in the positive
terminology and considering this distinction between
the two, this Court held that it would not be open to
the Court while considering an application under
Section 227, Cr.PC, to weigh the pros and cons of the
evidence alleged improbability and then proceed to
discharge the accused holding that the statements
existing in the case therein are unreliable. It is held
that doing so would be practically acting under
Section 232, Cr.PC, even though the said stage has not
reached. In short, though it is permissible to sift and
weigh the materials for the limited purpose of finding
out whether or not a prima facie case is made out
against
the
accused,
on
appreciation
of
the
admissibility and the evidentiary value such materials
brought on record by the prosecution is impermissible
as it would amount to denial of opportunity to the
prosecution to prove them appropriately at the
appropriate stage besides amounting to exercise of
the power coupled with obligation under Section 232,
Cr.PC, available only after taking the evidence for the
prosecution and examining the accused.
20. Even after referring to the aforesaid decisions, we
think it absolutely appropriate to refer to a decision of
the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Kaushalya Devi v.
State of MP. It was held in the said case that if there is
no legal evidence, then framing of charge would be
groundless and compelling the accused to face the
trial is contrary to the procedure offending Article 21
of the Constitution of India. While agreeing with the
view, we make it clear that the expression 'legal
evidence' has to be construed only as evidence
disclosing prima facie case, 'the record of the case
and the documents submitted therewith'.
21. The stage of Section 227, Cr.PC, is equally crucial
and determinative to both the prosecution and the
accused, we will dilate the issue further. In this
context,
certain
other
aspects
also
require
consideration. It cannot be said that Section 227,
Cr.PC, is couched in negative terminology without a
purpose. Charge sheet is a misnomer for the final
report filed under Section 173 (2), Cr.PC, which is not a
negative report and one that carries an accusation
against the accused concerned of having committed
the offence (s) mentioned therein.
22. In cases, where it appears that the said offence(s)
is one triable exclusively by the Court of Session, the
Magistrate shall have to commit the case to the Court
of
Session
concerned
following
the
prescribed
procedures under Cr.PC. In such cases, though it
carries
an
accusation
as
aforementioned
still
legislature thought it appropriate to provide an
inviolable right as a precious safe guard for the
accused, a pre-battle protection under Section 227,
Cr.PC. Though, this provision is couched in negative it
obligated the court concerned to unfailingly consider
the record of the case and document submit- ted
therewith and also to hear the submissions of the
accused and the prosecution in that behalf to arrive at
a conclusion as to whether or not sufficient ground for
proceeding
against
the
thereunder.
Certainly,
if
accused
the
is
answer
available
of
such
consideration is in the negative, the court is bound to
discharge the accused and to record reasons therefor.
The corollary is that the question of framing the
charge would arise only in a case where the court
upon such exercise satisfies itself about the prima
facie case revealing from "the record of the case and
the documents submitted therewith" against the
accused concerned. In short, it can be said in that
view of the matter that the intention embedded is to
ensure that an accused will be made to stand the
ordeal of trial only if 'the record of the case and the
documents submitted therewith discloses ground for
proceeding against him. When that be so, in a case
where an application is filed for discharge under
Section 227, Cr.PC, it is an irrecusable duty and
obligation of the Court to apply its mind and answer to
it regarding the existence of or otherwise, of ground
for proceeding against the accused, by confining such
consideration based only on the record of the case
and the documents submitted therewith and after
hearing the submissions of the accused and the
prosecution in that behalf. To wit, such conclusion on
existence or otherwise of ground to proceed against
the accused concerned should not be and could not
be based on mere suppositions or suspicions or
conjectures, especially not founded upon material
available before the Court. We are not oblivious of the
fact that normally, the Court is to record his reasons
only for discharging an accused at the stage of
Section 227, Cr.PC. However, when an application for
discharge is filed under Section 227, Cr.PC, the Court
concerned is bound to disclose the reason(s), though,
not in detail, for finding sufficient ground for rejecting
the application or in other words, for finding prima
facie case, as it will enable the superior Court to
examine the challenge against the order of rejection.
30. In the light of the records of the case and the
documents submitted therewith, it can only be found
that the said finding of the Trial Court on the ground to
proceed
against
the
appellant
is
based
on
suppositions and suspicions, having no foundational
support
from
the
materials
produced
by
the
prosecution. With respect to the first part of the above
extracted recital from the order of the Trial Court, it is
to be noted that it is nobody's case that the appellant
was in the Police Station or informed of the sufferance
from chest pain. As relates the second suspicion, it is
to be noted that the very Trial Court itself, in the very
order dated 19.04.2007 itself, stated that in Crime
No.351/1993 under Section 392. IPC the deceased Ram
Kishore was only a witness and that the amount in
cash and the draft involved was that of the appellant. It
is also the case of the prosecution that the said case
was registered, at the instance of the appellant against
unknown persons. Hence. when the appellant who lost
the money went to Police Station along with the
witness thereof, how can it be presumed by the Court
as a strong case for suspicion for commission of the
offence of criminal conspiracy. especially taking note
of the very case of the prosecution that causative
incident for the case occurred when Ram Kishore was
returning after collecting the business proceeds of the
appellant and that the appellant was informed of it
over telephone by Ram Kishore. When there is no case
for the prosecution that the appellant pointed the
fingers at Ram Kishore how the lodging of the
complaint, apprehending custodial death of Ram
Kishore who was appellant's clerk for about 13 years,
which caused the registration of custodial death case
under FIR No. 371/1993 can be taken as a ground for
framing charge against the appellant for the offences
punishable under Sections 302, IPC, 120-B with the aid
of Section 34, IPC.”
12.
In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, as well as the
aforesaid law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, I do not find
any infirmity or perversity in the impugned order of framing charge
against the applicants. Accordingly, the criminal revision is liable to
be and hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review