Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-ordinary Jurisdiction)
Dated: 21st AUGUST, 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAI KUMAR BIST, CJ.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------W. P. (C) No. 75 of 2017
Shri Ravi Chandra Dhakal,
S/o Late Padam Lal Dhakal,
Aged about 56 years,
R/o Churibotey, Central Pandam,
P.O. & P.S. Singtam, East Sikkim.
…
Petitioner
- Versus 1.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim.
2.
The Secretary,
Human Resource Development Department,
Near Old Secretariat, Tashiling,
Government of Sikkim.
3.
The Secretary,
Department of Personnel,
Manan Kendra, Development Area,
Government of Sikkim.
… Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sunil Rai, Advocate for the petitioner.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Addl. Advocate General, Mr. S.K.
Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Govt. Advocates, Mr.
Zigmee P. Bhutia, Standing Counsel (HRDD) for the
respondents.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Chief Justice
Petitioner
has
approached
this
Court
seeking
following reliefs:-
2.
Primary
“a)
A writ of and /or in nature of mandamus
directing the respondent(s) their agents,
and subordinate to withdraw, rescind,
cancel or quash the early retirement order
dated 15.12.2014.
b)
A writ of or in the nature of mandamus
commanding the Respondents to take up
necessary steps to correct the date of birth
of the aggrieved Petitioner;
c)
A writ of in the nature of mandamus
commanding the respondent to reinstate his
service for the remaining period of 5 (Five)
years or pay compensation for giving early
retirement;
d)
An ad interim Order directing the
Respondents, to take necessary steps to
make Compensation or to reinstate the
aggrieved Petitioner’s service until the final
disposal of the Writ Petition;
e)
An explanation from the Respondents as to
the cause for their negligence or inaction on
their Part form the year 2004 till date.”
Facts, in brief, are that the petitioner was appointed as a
Teacher
under
the
Human
Resource
Development
Department, Government of Sikkim vide OfÏce Order No. 826/Est/Edn.
dated 22.04.1981 and was posted at Khanigaon Primary School, East
Sikkim. In the service book prepared at the time of entering into the
service, his date of birth was recorded as 07.09.1956. It is the case of
the petitioner that the same was incorrectly recorded though he had
supplied the correct date of birth, i.e. 20.09.1961 along with the
supporting documents. When the petitioner came to know about the
incorrect date of birth recorded in the service book, the petitioner
made representation to the respondent no.2 with the plea that at the
time of joining the service, his date of birth was incorrectly recorded in
the service book by the concerned department.
He requested for
correction of date of birth recorded in his service record. The petitioner
also submitted matriculation certificate bearing his correct date of
birth. The first representation made by the petitioner for correction of
date of birth was in the month of February, 2004. Thereafter, several
representations were made by the petitioner but his date of birth was
not corrected. Only reply given by the concerned department was that
in his service book, his date of birth was recorded as 07.09.1956.
Petitioner also served legal notice on the respondent-department but
when nothing was done, the present writ petition is filed.
3.
Contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that
the respondent-department is duty bound to correct the date of birth
as the petitioner had supplied the matriculation certificate issued by
the Central Board of Secondary Education (for short CBSE) in time. He
submitted that matriculation certificate issued by the Board cannot be
questioned and that is the best document which can be relied for
correction of date of birth of the petitioner.
4.
Per contra, the Learned Additional Advocate General
submitted that the petitioner’s case deserves to be dismissed simply
on the ground of delay and laches.
The petitioner did not file writ
petition during his service period but he filed it after three years of his
superannuation.
She submitted that the petitioner could have filed
writ petition in the year 2004 itself when his first representation was
not considered. She submitted that the petitioner joined service in the
year 1981 but he kept mum for 24 years and approached the
respondent-department only in 2004 for the correction of date of birth.
The department gave reply to his representation and informed him
that his date of birth recorded in the service book is 07.09.1956 and
the same cannot be corrected. The Learned Additional Advocate
General referred letter dated 01.05.2013 written by the petitioner to
the Chief Minister in which he himself has stated that at the time of
joining service, he recorded his date of birth as 07.09.1956.
She
submitted that petitioner is not illiterate person and he consciously
recorded his date of birth in his service record. Therefore, he should
not be permitted to raise the issue of date of birth after a very long
period. She submitted that in service record, certificate regarding date
of birth of the petitioner (07.09.1956) is also mentioned as kept at CP124 but that certificate is not found on record. She also referred the
transfer certificate filed by the petitioner which was issued in the year
2000.
According to her, the transfer certificate should have been
issued by the school at the time of leaving the institution as every
institution gives school leaving certificate/transfer certificate at the
time of leaving the institution. She submitted that this is done by the
petitioner to improve his case. She also referred a photocopy of one
admission register submitted by the petitioner in which the name of
one Mukul Balaram Dhakal has been cut and the name of the
petitioner is written. She also submitted that at the top of this paper
(copy of admission register), the Darbhanga Examination Board, Rajput
Colony, Laheriasarai is written whereas the petitioner passed his
matriculation Examination from Central Pendam and therefore, this
paper is not a genuine paper. She submitted that this document is a
forged document and petition deserves to be dismissed on this count
also.
5.
The Learned Counsel for the respondent referred the Rule
96 of the Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974 which
is as follows:“96.
Date of birth.-
(1)
Every person newly appointed to a service or
post under the Government shall at the time of appointment
declare the date of birth by the Christian era with as far as possible
confirmatory documentary evidence such as school leaving
certificate, municipal birth certificate and so on. If the exact date is
not know, an approximate date shall be given.
(2)
The actual date or the assumed date determined
under rule 97 shall be recorded in the history of service, service
book or any other record that may be kept in respect of the
Government servant’s service under the Government and once
recorded, it cannot be altered, except in the case of a clerical error,
without the previous orders of the Head of the Department
concerned.”
6.
By
referring
Rule
of
the
Sikkim
Government
Establishment Rules, 1974, the learned Additional Advocate General
submitted that since at the time of joining service the petitioner
himself entered his date of birth in the service record and the same is
not a clerical error, the same cannot be corrected.
7.
On the question of delay, the learned counsel for the
respondent referred paragraph 2 of the judgment reported in (1996) 7
SCC 421: Union of India Vs. Ram Sula Sharma and submitted that
when a person wakes up after a long time, he cannot claim correction
in his date of birth. Paragraph 2 of the judgment is quoted below:“2.
The controversy raised in this appeal is no longer res
integra. In a series of judgment, this court has held that a court or
tribunal at the belated stage cannot entertain a claim for the
correction of the date of birth duly entered in the service records.
Admittedly, the respondent had joined the service on 16-12-1962.
After 25 years, he woke up and claimed that his correct date of
birth is 2-1-1939 and not 16-12-1934. That claim was accepted by
the Tribunal and it directed the Government to consider the
correction. The direction is per se illegal.”
8.
She also referred paragraph 10 and 12 of the Judgment
reported in (1955) 4 SCC 172: Burn Standard Co. Ltd. And
Others, which are quoted below:“10. Entertainment by High Courts of writ applications made by
employees of the Government or its instrumentalities at the fag
end of their services and when they are due for retirement from
their services, in our view, is unwarranted. It would be so for the
reason that no employee can claim a right to correction of birth
date and entertainment of such writ applications for correction of
dates of birth of some employees of Government or its
instrumentalities will mar the chances of promotion of his juniors
and prove to be an undue encouragement to the other employees
to make similar applications at the fag end of their service careers
with the sole object of preventing their retirements when due.
Extra-ordinary nature of the jurisdiction vested in the High Courts
under Article 226 of the Constitution, in our considered view, is not
meant to make employees of Government or its instrumentalities
to continue in service beyond the period of their entitlement
according to dates of birth accepted by their employers, placing
reliance on the so called newly found material. The fact that an
employee of Government or its instrumentality who will be in
service for over decades, with no objection whatsoever raised as to
his date of birth accepted by the employer as correct, when all of a
sudden comes forward towards the fag end of his service career
with a writ application before the High Court seeking correction of
his date of birth in his Service Record, the very conduct of nonraising of an objection in the matter by the employee, in our view,
should be a sufÏcient reason for the High Court, not to entertain
such applications on grounds of acquiescence, undue delay and
laches. Moreover, discretionary jurisdiction of the High Court can
never be said to have been reasonably and judicially exercised if it
entertains such writ application, for no employee, who had
grievance as to his date of birth in his `Service and Leave Record'
could have genuinely waited till the fag end of his service career to
get it corrected by availing of the extraordinary jurisdiction of a
High Court. Therefore, we have no hesitation, in holding, that
ordinarily High Courts should not, in exercise of its discretionary
writ jurisdiction, entertain a writ application/petition filed by an
employee of the Government or its instrumentality, towards the fag
end-of his service, seeking correction of his date of birth entered in
his `Service and Leave Record' or Service Register with the avowed
object of continuing in service beyond the normal period of his
retirement.
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
12.
When a person seeks employment, he impliedly agrees with
the terms and conditions on which employment is offered. For
every post in the service of the Government or any other
instrumentality there is the minimum age of entry prescribed
depending on the functional requirements for the post. In order to
verify that the person concerned is not below that prescribed age
he is required to disclose his date of birth. The date of birth is
verified and if found to be correct is entered in the service record. It
is ordinarily presumed that the birth date disclosed by the
incumbent is accurate. The situation then is that the incumbent
gives the date of birth and the employer accepts it as true and
accurate before it is entered in the service record. This entry in the
service record made on the basis of the employee's statement
cannot be changed unilaterally at the sweet will of the employee
except in the manner permitted by service conditions or the
relevant rules. Here again considerations for a change in the date
of birth may be diverse and the employer would be entitled to view
it not merely from the angle of there being a genuine mistake but
also from the point of its impact on the service in the
establishment. It is common knowledge that every establishment
has its own set of service conditions governed by rules. It is equally
known that practically every establishment prescribes a minimum
age for entry into service at different levels in the establishment.
The first thing to consider is whether on the date of entry into
service would the employee have been eligible for entry into
service on the revised date of birth. Secondly, would revision of his
date of birth after a long lapse of time upset the promotional
chances of others in the establishment who may have joined on the
basis that the incumbent would retire on a given date opening up
promotional avenues for others. If that be so and if permitting a
change in the date of birth is likely to cause frustration down the
line resulting in causing an adverse effect on efÏciency in
functioning, the employer may refuse to permit correction in the
date at a belated stage. It must be remembered that such sudden
and belated change may upset the legitimate expectation of others
who may have joined service hoping that on the retirement of the
senior on the due date there would be an upward movement in the
hierarchy. In any case in such cases Interim injunction for
continuance in service should not be granted as it visits the juniors
with irreparable injury, in that, they would be denied promotions a
damage which cannot be repaired if the claim is ultimately found to
be unacceptable. On the other hand, if no interim relief for
continuance in service is granted and ultimately his claim for
correction of birth date is found to be acceptable, the damage can
be repaired by granting him all those monetary benefits which he
would have received had he continued in service. We are,
therefore, of the opinion that in such cases it would be imprudent
to grant interim relief.”
9.
the parties.
I have considered the submission of the learned counsel for
No doubt, petition for correction of date of birth in the
service record should not be entertained at highly belated stage and in
such matter discretionary jurisdiction of the High Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India should be exercised reasonably and
judiciously. Ordinarily, High Court should not exercise its discretionary
jurisdiction while entertaining a writ petition filed by the government
employee at belated stage or at the fag end of his service, seeking
correction of his date of birth entered in his service record. But at the
same time it cannot be said that a government servant who has
declared his age at the time of his appointment in the service record
should not be permitted to seek correction of his date of birth in the
service record. It is open for a government servant to claim correction
of his date of birth if he is in possession of a valid proof relating to his
date of birth, which is different from the one which was recorded at the
time of his entering in the service. Correction of date of birth in the
service record of an employee can be made even at the fag end of his
service or at highly belated stage, if proof relating to his date of birth is
valid, genuine and was in existence at the time of his joining of service.
But, in such matter, the Court is required to be very careful.
10.
In the present case, the petitioner was appointed in the
year 1981. At the time of joining, he recorded 07.09.1956 as his date
of birth.
The case of the petitioner is that though he submitted a
correct date of birth at the time of joining but the same was recorded
wrongly.
When he came to know about the incorrect date of birth
being recorded in his service record, he immediately approached the
respondent-department. According to him, his first representation was
given in the year 2004, whereas as per the respondent-department his
representation was received in the year 2000. He also submitted his
matriculation certificate issued by the CBSE.
The respondent-
department did not consider the certificate issued by the CBSE and no
change was made in his service record. In my view, the respondents
should have considered the case of the petitioner and corrected his
date of birth as recorded in the matriculation examination, carries a
greater evidential value than other certificates or documents issued by
any other authority as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
matter of State of MP Vs. Mohanlal Sharma : (2002) 7 SCC 719.
11.
The next point to be considered by the Court is whether on
the basis of matriculation certificate submitted by the petitioner, his
date of birth in the service record should be corrected. Present case is
not a case where the petitioner applied for correction of date of birth at
the fag end of his service career.
In fact, he represented 10 years
before his retirement with valid documentary proof. The matriculation
certificate issued by the CBSE is of the year 1980 whereas the
petitioner joined the service in the year 1981.
Therefore, the
genuineness of the certificate issued by the CBSE cannot be doubted.
Moreover, it is not the case of the respondents that the matriculation
certificate issued by the CBSE and submitted by the petitioner is not a
genuine certificate.
Rather they admit the same.
If a person is in
possession of valid certificate, why will he enter wrong date of birth in
his service record. In such matter, inference is to be drawn that wrong
date of birth was entered by him inadvertently. In such circumstances,
in my view, the certificate issued by the CBSE should have been
considered by the respondent-department for correction of date of
birth. The petition filed by the petitioner cannot be dismissed on the
ground of delay and laches.
In case claim of the petitioner is not
permitted to be allowed, which is based on valid and genuine
matriculation certificate, in that event, injustice will be done to him.
12.
One argument of the learned counsel for the respondent-
department is that the transfer certificate filed by the petitioner was
issued in the year 2000 and that should not be relied. She rightly says
that generally transfer certificate/school leaving certificate is issued at
the time of leaving the school by the student. But on the basis of this
argument, it cannot be said that transfer certificate/school leaving
certificate issued many years after leaving the school is not genuine.
In fact, later on, only a copy of the same can be obtained when a
student misplaces the certificate and applies for a fresh copy. Copy
issued many years thereafter is also relevant document as fresh copy
issued subsequently cannot change the relevant record which is in
existence in the record of the school.
13.
Another argument of the learned Additional Advocate
General is that the correction could be made as per Rule 96 of the
Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974 and since the case of
the petitioner cannot be said clerical error, therefore, the date of birth
cannot be changed. This argument is also not correct in view of the
fact that matriculation certificate submitted by the petitioner is issued
by genuine body, i.e. CBSE, and was issued prior to joining in service
by the petitioner.
Therefore, on the basis of that certificate the
correction could be made in the service record.
14.
In view of above discussion, the Writ Petition is allowed.
The OfÏce Order vide O.O. No.2870/HRDD/E dated 15.12.2014 issued
by respondent no.2- Human Resource Development Department,
Government of Sikkim is quashed.
The respondents are directed to
take necessary steps for correction of date of birth of the petitioner as
prayed by him on the basis of the matriculation certificate issued by
the CBSE. The petitioner shall be treated in continuous service till the
date of his retirement by treating his date of birth as 20.09.1961. So
far salary from 01.01.2015 is concerned, the petitioner shall not be
paid salary from 01.01.2015 till he rejoins the post as he has not
worked during this period. However, this period will be counted by the
department for the purpose of other benefits including the pension.
The department shall grant him annual increment every year from
2014 on notional basis for the purpose of fixation of pension.
Respondents are further directed to permit the petitioner to join the
service on or before 01.09.2019. In case he is not permitted to join the
service on or before 01.09.2019, in that event the petitioner will be
entitled for salary from 01.09.2019 till the date of his retirement, which
according to his matriculation certificate and as per relevant rule, will
be 30.09.2019.
15.
No order as to costs.
Chief Justice
21.08.2019
Index : Yes
Internet : Yes
pm/sid
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review