Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA NO.152 OF 2022
Ratan Rudra Paul
Son of Sri Nikunja Rudra Paul,
Resident of village & P.O.- Konaban,
P.S.- Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala Tripura.
……Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary to the Department of Home,
Government of India, P.O.- New Delhi, Pin-110001.
2. The Director General,
Border Security Force, Government of India,
North Block, New Delhi, Pin-110001.
3. The Inspector General,
Border Security Force, Headquater at S.B. Jammu Frontier,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, Paloura Camp,
Jammu & Kashmir, Pin-181124.
4. The Commandant, 152nd Battalion,
Border Security Force, Haringhata P.O.- Mohanpur, DistrictNadia, West Bengal, Pin-741235.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B.N. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 26.02.2024.
Whether fit for reporting : No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
This present writ appeal has been filed under Rule 2 of
Chapter V-A of the Gauhati High Court Rules, read with Article 226
of the Constitution of India, against the impugned Judgment &
Order dated 09.12.2021, passed in WP(C) No.7 of 2019 whereby
the learned Single Judge has dismissed the said writ petition.
2.
The brief fact of this case is that the petitioner-
appellant herein was enrolled as a Constable (GD) under the Border
Security Force (BSF, for short) in the year 2011. While discharging
his duties as Constable, the petitioner was given punishment for
overstaying on leave for the month of November-December, 2012.
Again in the month of March 2013, the petitioner-appellant was
given punishment of quarter-guard for a period of 14 days.
Thereafter, the petitioner was found missing. The petitionerappellant had pleaded that during that period he lost his mental
stability. After the expiry of 30 days for his unauthorized absence
from the Force, a Court of Inquiry was held. It is pertinent to
mention here that before the Court of Inquiry, the Unit of the
petitioner-appellant had made their best efforts to look for him, and
having failed to trace him out, an FIR was lodged. Thereafter, the
Unit of the petitioner-appellant had sent several letters at his home
address through registered post directing him to resume his duties
immediately, but, he failed to report back in spite of repeated
reminders. So, after 30 days of his absence without due authority,
the Court of Inquiry was held as contemplated under Section 62 of
the BSF Act, 1968 (here-in-after referred to as the Act, 1968).
Since, neither the petitioner reported back to his duty nor any
communication was received by the respondents from him justifying
his absence without due authority, the matter was taken up by the
Commandant, and as per his remarks on the report of the Court of
Inquiry, an apprehension role was prepared through the Civil
Authority (District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala)
and was issued in compliance of the provision of Section 60 and 61
of the said Act, 1968, but, no response was received from the Civil
authority till the order of his dismissal. Ultimately, as mandated
under sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 of the BSF Rules, 1969, the petitioner
was given an opportunity to show cause vide no. Estt./AWL/ 152
Bn/2013/712-13 dated 2nd September, 2013 against his proposed
dismissal from service, but, the petitioner-appellant had failed to
respond to the said notice and did not submit any reply. Ultimately,
it had led the competent authority to decide the matter of the
continued illegal absence of the petitioner-appellant in its entirety
and
being
found
the
petitioner
non-responsive
to
the
correspondences made by the Unit and the competent authority
found the behaivour of the petitioner-appellant contrary to the
expected norms and detrimental to the Force discipline. It was
further opined that further retention of the petitioner-appellant in
the Force was undesirable. The competent authority also had taken
into consideration the fact that on earlier two occasions, the
petitioner was found to be absent from his duty without due
authority of law, and he was found to be a habitual offender of
absenting
himself
without
leave.
Accordingly,
the
petitioner-
appellant was dismissed from service and his name was struck off
from the Unit w.e.f. 11th October, 2013.
3.
Being aggrieved thereby, the appellant preferred a
statutory appeal there against, but the same was also rejected.
Situated thus, the appellant filed a Writ Petition[W.P(C) No.7 of
2019], before the learned Single Judge of this Hon’ble High Court,
praying for reinstatement, but by the impugned Judgment and
Order dated 09.12.2021, the same was dismissed.
4.
Hence this present writ appeal seeking the following
reliefs:“i) Admit this Writ Appeal;
ii) Call for the relevant records, pertaining to the impugned
Judgment & Order (Oral) dated 09.12.2021, passed in W.P.(C) No.7 of
2019;
iii) After hearing the parties, in terms of the GROUNDS set forth
above, be pleased to quash/set aside the impugned Judgment & Order
(Oral) dated 09.12.2021, passed in W.P.(C) No.7 of 2019, passed by
the Learned Single Judge, and thereafter, allow this Writ Appeal,
thereby quashing/setting aside the impugned Notices dated
30.05.2013 & 10.06.2013, the impugned Order of Dismissal dated
11.10.2013 & the impugned Appellate Order dated 05.11.2018
(Annexures-4, 5, 6 & 9 respectively to the WP), and thereupon,
reinstate the Appellant in service, with effect from the date of his
dismissal (i.e., w.e.f. 11.10.2013), alongwith all financial benefits;
iv) And pass any other Order(s) as may be deemed fit and
proper for ends of justice. “
5.
Heard Mr. Koomar Chakrabarty, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner-appellant as well as Mr. B. Majumder,
Deputy SGI appearing for the respondents-Union of India.
6.
Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant submitted that the petitioner-appellant was not in a fit
state of mind and the respondents had themselves lodged a missing
diary on the account of his missing. As such, there cannot be any
show cause notice against a person who is missing in the eye of
law. Accordingly, the entire action of the respondents in issuing the
alleged show cause notice under Rule 22(2) of the BSF Rules 1969,
and the consequent dismissal of the petitioner-appellant was wholly
illegal. The family members of the petitioner-appellant only received
the notices but the same could not be communicated with the
petitioner-appellant as he was missing due to his unfit mental
condition. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner-appellant
referred to a letter wherein the petitioner-appellant expressed his
intention to join his duties. Learned counsel also referred to
annexure-2 of the writ appeal wherein the father of the petitionerappellant submitted a prayer for conducting an inquiry of his
missing son to the Chief Minister of Tripura.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. B. Majumder, learned
Deputy SGI appearing for the Union respondents submitted that as
per Rule 22 of the BSF Act, 1969, a show-cause notice was properly
issued to the petitioner-appellant and before that also several
correspondences were made to the petitioner-appellant but he did
not turn up. Therefore, the question of issuing further notice does
not arise. Learned Deputy SGI submits that a bare reading of paras13 and 14 the impugned Judgment dated 09.12.2021 makes it aptly
clear that everything has been fulfilled as per Section 22 of the BSF
Act. Learned Deputy SGI further submits that the principle of
natural justice does not constitute the fact and the present situation
of this case.
To support his argument on the point of ‘principle
of natural justice’, learned counsel referred to the relevant portion
of Para-24 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment reported in
AIR 1989 SC 1321 titled as Sri Gouranga Chakraborty Vs.
State of Tripura and anr. The same is produced here-in-under:“ 24. ……….. The appellant did not avail of this
opportunity and he did not file any show cause to the said notice. Thus the
principle of natural justice was not violated as has been rightly held by the
High Court. No other point has been urged before us by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant.”
8.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
9.
Here the main contention as advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the appellant-petitioner is that the
petitioner was not given an proper opportunity to explain himself to
the show causes notice issued by the respondents at that point in
time as he was untraceable and was in unfit state of mind. His
family members who received the correspondences could not
communicate the same to him. As such, the termination that came
to be passed is in contravention of Rules 22(2) and (3) of Border
Security Rules, 1969 and in violation of the principles of natural
justice.
10.
The adjudicate the grievances of the appellant-
petitioner herein let was reproduced Rule 22 of the BSF Act, 1969
in its entirety:“22. Dismissal or removal of persons other than
officer on account of misconduct.— (1) When it is proposed to terminate
the service of a person subject to the Act other than an officer, he shall be
given an opportunity by the authority competent to dismiss or remove him,
to show cause in the manner specified in sub-rule (2) against such action:
Provided that this sub-rule shall not apply—
(a) where the service is terminated on the ground of conduct which has led
to his conviction by a criminal court or a Security Force Court; or
(b) where the competent authority is satisfied that, for reasons to be
recorded in writing, it is not expedient or reasonably practicable to give the
person concerned an opportunity of showing cause.
(2) When after considering the reports on the misconduct of the person
concerned, the competent authority is satisfied that the trial of such a
person is inexpedient or impracticable, but, is of the opinion that his further
retention in the service is undesirable, it shall so inform him together with all
reports adverse to him and he shall be called upon to submit, in writing, his
explanation and defence: Provided that the competent authority may
withhold from disclosure any such report or portion thereof, if, in his opinion,
its disclosure is not in the public interest.
(3) The competent authority after considering his explanation and defence if
any may dismiss or remove him from service with or without pension:
Provided that a Deputy Inspector-General shall not dismiss or remove from
service, a Subordinate Officer of and above the rank of a Subedar.
(4) All cases of dismissal or removal under this rule, shall be reported to be
Director-General.”
11.
To properly adjudicate the matter, let us also
reproduce the relevant portion of the impugned Judge passed by
the Hon’ble Single Judge:“13. Firstly, on plain reading of Rule 22 of the BSF Rules,
it becomes aptly clear that the competent authority i.e. the Commandant
after considering the reports of mis-conduct of the person concerned if
satisfied that the conduct of trial of such a person is inexpedient or
impracticable, but, in his opinion that his further retention in his service is
undesirable, the Commandant shall inform the same to the person
concerned alongwith all reports adverse to him, calling upon such person to
submit, in writing, his explanation and defence. The proviso of sub-section
(2) of Section 22 contemplates that the competent authority may also
refrain from disclosing any such report or portion thereof, if, in his opinion,
its disclosure is not in the public interest.
14. Now, on a bare perusal of the contents of the show-cause
notice, it comes to light that the Commandant while issuing the show-cause
notice had mentioned all the particulars of absence of the petitioner without
due authority. From para (iv) of the said show-cause notice, it further comes
to light that the show-cause notice was accompanied by a copy of the Court
of Inquiry alongwith other reports referred to in para-1 of the show-cause
notice for his reference.
15. In this situation, the contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner that the substance of imputation/adverse report were not
incorporated with the show-cause notice, is found to be bereft of any merit.
Hence, the submission of learned counsel for the petitioner in this regard is
repelled.”
12.
Here a bare perusal of the impugned judgment as
passed by the learned Single Judge reveals that while issuing the
show notice the same was accompanied by a copy of the Court of
Inquiry along with other reports and all the particulars of the
absence of the petitioner-appellant was mentioned.
This aptly
made it clear that provisions under Rule 22 of the BSF Rules were
adhered to while passing the show cause notice.
13.
The petitioner-appellant herein is a responsible
employee working in security service (BSF) and his unauthorized
absence from his duties is detrimental to the interest and security of
the nation. Further, though learned counsel for the petitionerappellant stated more than once in his argument that the
petitioner-appellant at the time of his unauthorised absence was in
an unfit-state of mind and due to such unfit condition of mind, he
could not communicate with the respondents, but, no
such
corresponding evidence of medical treatment or otherwise was not
proved to support his claim. This Court draws an adverse inference
against the conduct of the appellant-petitioner as he acted
irresponsibly.
14.
Accordingly,
the
Judgment
and
order
dated
09.12.2021 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.7 of
2019 is confirmed and this present appeal stands dismissed.
15.
As a sequel stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
suhanjit
signed
RAJKUMAR Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2024.03.04
SINGHA
12:50:52 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review