The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In the above view of the matter, without commenting on the respective claims of the parties, this Court is of the considered view that this writ petition can be disposed of with a direction to the respondent no. 2 to take the representations already submitted by the petitioner on board and after consideration of the representations and the reports submitted Page No.# 6/6 by the respondent no. 6 and the respondent no. 7 and verifiable records, the respondent no. 2 should dispose of the representations on their own merits and in accordance with law by passing a speaking order. While passing the speaking order, the respondent no. 2 shall also consider the re-fixation of the settlement amount due to delayed handing over the possession of the Fishery, if any. The respondent no. 2 while considering the representations shall also afford a personal hearing to the petitioner, if the petitioner requests for such personal hearing in writing. It is accordingly directed. The speaking order shall be passed as expeditiously as possible, but, within an outer limit of 6 [six] weeks from the date of submission of a certified copy of this order by the petitioner before the respondent no. 2.
16. This order disposes of the writ petition. No cost. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/6
GAHC010156902025
2026:GAU-AS:2916
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4052/2025
RATAN BISWAS
S/O GURU DAS BISWAS R/O SAMAGURI GRANT PO AND PS SAMAGURI
PIN 7872140 DIST NAGAON ASSAM
VERSUS
ASSAM FISHERIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD AND ORS
BEING REP BY ITS CHAIRPERSON CHACHAL VIP ROAD GUWAHATI 36
KAMRUP METRO ASSAM
2:THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
ASSAM FISHERIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD CHACHAL VIP
ROAD GUWAHATI 36 KAMRUP METRO ASSAM
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
NAGAON
PIN 782001 ASSAM
4:THE PROJECT MANAGER
ASSAM FISHERIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD UPPER ASSAM
AND MIDDLE ASSAM ZONE NAGAON PIN 782001 ASSAM
5:THE ASSISTANT DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
NAGAON
PIN 782001 ASSAM
6:THE DISTRICT FISHERY DEVELOPMENT OFFICER
NAGAON DISTRICT NAGAON PIN 782001 ASSAM
7:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
SAMAGURI REVENUE CIRCLE SAMAGURI PIN 782140 DIST NAGAON
Page No.# 2/6
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. M K CHOUDHURY, MR S KHOUND,MR D J MEDHI
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, AFDC,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHOUDHURY
ORDER
Date : 24.02.2026
The petitioner who is the existing leasee/settlement holder of a fishery named Samaguri
Beel [‘the Fishery’, for short] has approached this Court by the instant writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India raising inter-alia a plea of waiver of revenue for a
period of 216 days on the ground of delayed handing over of possession of the Fishery to
him. A direction in the nature of mandamus has also been sought for to the respondent
authorities in the Assam Fishery Development Corporation [AFDC] Limited to take a decision
as regards the petitioner’s plea of re-assessment of revenue of the Fishery due to reduction in
the fishing area due to natural calamities and other supervening circumstances.
2.
The Fishery named Samuguri Beel is under the aegis of the AFDC Limited By a Tender
Notice no. 9/2022, bids were invited for settlement of the Fishery located in District - Nagaon.
Pursuant to the bidding process so initiated and upon evaluation of the bids, the petitioner
emerged as the successful bidder.
3.
By way of a settlement proposal dated 10.10.2022, the petitioner was offered
settlement of the Fishery from the Financial Year : 2022-2023 for a period of seven years up
to the Financial Year : 2028-2029, that is, 31.03.2029. In the settlement proposal, it was
mentioned that the Fishery would be settled for an amount of Rs. 19,67,862.33 for the
Financial Year : 2022-2023 up to 31.03.2023, and for the remaining six years from the
Financial Year : 2023-2024 to Financial Year : 2028-2029, that is, up to 31.03.2029 for a total
amount of Rs. 1,98,60,000. In other words, the petitioner was offered the settlement of the
fishery for a total amount of Rs. 2,18,27,862.30. While offering the settlement proposal, the
Page No.# 3/6
petitioner was asked to accept the same by depositing the installment amounts mentioned
therein and by executing a contract agreement within a period of seven days therefrom.
4.
Responding to the settlement proposal dated 10.10.2022, the petitioner deposited the
requisite amounts asked for, and executed the contract agreement by completing the
formalities. Thereafter, the Settlement Order was passed on 05.11.2022. As per the
Settlement Order, the area of the Fishery consisted of 60.00 Hectares of land area and 60.00
Hectares of water area. It was mentioned in the Settlement Order that the possession of the
fishery would be handed over as per the AFDC Limited’s rules and regulations in order to
enable the petitioner as the settlement holder to operate the fishery.
5.
After the Settlement Order dated 05.11.2022, the possession of the Fishery was
handed over to him on 05.11.2022. On and from 05.11.2022, the petitioner started to
operate the Fishery.
6.
As the possession of the Fishery was handed over belatedly, the petitioner on
14.11.2022 submitted an application before the respondent no. 2 with a request to exempt
the petitioner from depositing the proportionate amount out of the settlement amount of Rs.
19,67,862.33 for the period in the Financial Year : 2022-2023 from 01.04.2022 to the date of
handing over the possession of the Fishery, 05.11.2022. After being handed over the
possession of the Fishery, the petitioner came to learn that a large area of the Fishery was
covered by water hyacinth and due to accumulation of water hyacinth, the water in the
Fishery became stagnant. Due to reduced area for fishing, the petitioner started incurring
losses as against the settlement amount he had offered by considering the area of the
Fishery mentioned in the Tender Notice and the Settlement Order.
7.
According to the petitioner, such reasons compelled him to submit representations
before the respondent no. 2 from time to time requesting the respondent no. 2 to take
appropriate measures expediently so as to enable the petitioner to do fishing in the entire
area of the Fishery as projected in the Tender Notice and the Contract Agreement. The
petitioner had also brought to the notice of the respondent no. 2 that there have been
encroachment within the area of the Fishery. Though for a period of time the respondent no.
Page No.# 4/6
2 did not act on those representations, the respondent no. 2 had subsequently requested the
District Commissioner, Nagaon on 09.07.2024 to take necessary action on the basis of the
representations submitted by the petitioner.
8.
On the basis of a direction of the District Commissioner, Nagaon and in reference to
the Office Letter dated 09.07.2022 of the respondent no. 2, the jurisdictional Circle Officer,
that is, the Circle Officer, Samaguri Revenue Circle [the respondent no. 5] made an enquiry
and submitted a report before the District Commissioner, Nagaon [the respondent no. 3] on
16.07.2024 recording his findings about the area of the Fishery. The District Fishery
Development Officer, Nagaon had also submitted a report to the Circle Officer, Samaguri
Revenue Circle [the respondent no. 6] on 19.08.2024 making an assessment as regards the
damage caused to the Fishery by flood. As per the report of the respondent no. 6, the Fishery
was severely affected by recent flood and as a result, there are significant ecological changes
causing habitat disruption, increased sedimentation, etc. As per the report dated 16.07.2024
of the Circle Officer, due to breaking of the embankment by the flood water a substantial area
of the Fishery was covered by water hyacinth.
9.
As the subsequent representations of the petitioner submitted before the respondent
no. 2 on the basis of the said reports seeking waiver/remission and re-assessment of the
Fishery’s revenue are found to have evoked no response, the petitioner is before this Court by
the present writ petition seeking the above reliefs.
10.
I have heard Mr. M.K. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. D.J. Medhi,
learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. P. Sharma, learned Standing Counsel, Fishery
Department & AFDC Limited for the respondent nos. 1, 2, 4 & 6; and Mr. G. Bokolial, learned
Junior Government Advocate for the respondent nos. 3, 5 & 7.
11.
Mr. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that
despite repeated approaches and representations, as annexed to the writ petition, by the
petitioner seeking waiver/remission and re-assessment of the revenue of Samaguri Beel the
respondent no. 2 has not taken any discernible action till date for consideration of the
representations. He has submitted that it is well within the authority and jurisdiction of the
Page No.# 5/6
respondent no. 2 to grant waiver/remission and re-assessment of the revenue of the Fishery
by taking into account the relevant factors like reduction in the area fishing, encroachment
into the fishery area, delayed handing over the possession, etc. As the aspects highlighted by
the petitioner in the representation are within the domain of the respondent no. 2, the
respondent no. 2 ought to have given to such representations.
12.
Mr. Sharma, learned Standing Counsel, Fishery Department & AFDC Ltd. appearing for
the respondent nos. 1, 2, 4 & 6 has submitted that in view of terms and conditions of the
contract agreement entered into at the time of settlement of the Fishery and the Tender
Notice, it would not be open for the petitioner to seek such benefits as highlighted in the
representations. He has further submitted that as the representations are stated to be
pending, the respondent no. 2 can give a fair consideration to them.
13.
In so far as the contention regarding delayed handing over of possession of the Fishery
is concerned, if an amount the petitioner had offered was for a whole Financial Year : 20222023 for operating the Fishery and if for any reason beyond his control like delayed handing
over of possession of the Fishery by the settlement authority then it may be open for the
settlement holder to seek re-fixation of the settlement amount for such reduced period for
which he was able to operate the fishery.
14.
In so far as the other aspects projected by the petitioner, it is for the respondent no. 2
as the settlement authority to take such aspects into consideration. As the representations of
the petitioner highlighting the factors for which the petitioner is seeking waiver/remission and
re-assessment of the revenue of the Fishery are yet to be given consideration, the respondent
no. 2 shall give a consideration to the representations, more particularly, when there are
reports on such aspects from two authorities, that is, the respondent no. 6 and the
respondent no. 7.
15.
In the above view of the matter, without commenting on the respective claims of the
parties, this Court is of the considered view that this writ petition can be disposed of with a
direction to the respondent no. 2 to take the representations already submitted by the
petitioner on board and after consideration of the representations and the reports submitted
Page No.# 6/6
by the respondent no. 6 and the respondent no. 7 and verifiable records, the respondent no.
2 should dispose of the representations on their own merits and in accordance with law by
passing a speaking order. While passing the speaking order, the respondent no. 2 shall also
consider the re-fixation of the settlement amount due to delayed handing over the possession
of the Fishery, if any. The respondent no. 2 while considering the representations shall also
afford a personal hearing to the petitioner, if the petitioner requests for such personal hearing
in writing. It is accordingly directed. The speaking order shall be passed as expeditiously as
possible, but, within an outer limit of 6 [six] weeks from the date of submission of a certified
copy of this order by the petitioner before the respondent no. 2.
16.
This order disposes of the writ petition. No cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review