Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN
THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision : 19th March, 2026
%
+
RFA 251/2026, CM APPL. 17360-17363/2026
RASHID HUSSAIN
S/o Rehmat Hussain
R/o A-82, JJ Colony, Camp No.2,
Nangloi, Delhi-110041.
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Vishva Nath Kumar, Advocate
versus
MANJEET PATWA
S/o Sh. Vijay Pal Patwa,
R/o F-1422-D, Adhyapak Nagar,
Nangloi, Delhi-110041.
.....Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been
filed for setting aside the Impugned Judgment and Decree dated 26.03.2025
passed by Ld. District Judge, Tis Hazari, Delhi whereby the Suit of the
Plaintiff for Recovery of Rs.2,51,000/- along with interest @ 9% p.a. was
decreed.
2.
The Plaintiff/Respondent has filed a Suit bearing Civ.DJ No.
1134/2018 for recovery of Rs.5,02,000/- along with pendente lite and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
future interest @ 18% p.a., against the Appellant/Defendant.
3.
Brief facts are that the Defendant, Rashid Hussain, was the owner of
Property bearing No. 1, area admeasuring 31 sq. yards out of Khasra No.
40/16, situated in the area of Village Nangloi, Jat Colony known as
extension II D, Block-D, Nangloi, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Suit
Property”).
4.
The Plaintiff/Respondent entered into an Agreement to Sell dated
18.01.2018 for a total consideration of Rs.25,00,000/-. A sum of
Rs.2,51,000/- was paid to the Defendant on 18.01.2018, as earnest money in
terms of the Agreement dated 18.01.2018. In order to complete the payment
in respect of the aforesaid Agreement to Sell, the Plaintiff sold his
residential property R.Z.Q. 32 Nihal Vihar, Nangloi, Delhi. He then
requested the Defendant to provide him with the title documents of the Suit
Property, so as to get the draft of Sale Deed prepared. Despite repeated
requests, Defendant failed to provide the document, on one pretext or the
other.
5.
The Sale Deed was to be executed on or before 15.04.2018 and the
Plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the Agreement
and to pay the balance sale consideration of Rs.22,49,000/-, subject to the
Defendant fulfilling his requirement of supplying the copies of all requisite
documents.
6.
The Plaintiff reached the office of Sub-Registrar, Nangloi on
16.04.2018 for execution of the Sale Deed, but the Defendant failed to turn
up, nor did he respond to the phone calls made by the Plaintiff. Therefore,
the Plaintiff moved an Application in the office of Sub-Registrar intimating
his presence and the refusal of the Defendant to execute the Sale Deed. The
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
Plaintiff claimed that he was always ready and willing to perform his part of
the Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018.
7.
The Plaintiff requested the Defendant on various occasions, to return
his earnest money paid under the Agreement, but when the Defendant failed
to do so, the Plaintiff issued a Notice dated 01.08.2018 requesting the refund
of double the amount of earnest money i.e. Rs.5,02,000/- in terms of the
Agreement dated 18.01.2018.
8.
Thereafter, a Suit for recovery was filed by the Plaintiff for
Rs.5,02,000/- along with pendente lite and future interest @ 18% p.a.
9.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant/Appellant, who in his
Written Statement, claimed that there was no cause of action in favour of
the Plaintiff. In fact, it was the Plaintiff who failed to pay the balance sale
consideration by 15.04.2018, as per the terms and conditions of the
Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018; which thus stood terminated by the acts
of the Plaintiff himself.
10.
It was claimed that the Defendant had entered into the Agreement to
Sell dated 18.01.2018 on account of dire need of money. Since the Plaintiff
did not adhere to the terms of the Agreement and committed serious breach,
the Defendant had rightly forfeited the earnest money.
11.
On merit, all the averments made in the Plaint were denied and it was
stated that the Suit of the Plaintiff is liable to be rejected. It was further
asserted that a registered letter dated 28.03.2018 was sent by the
Defendant/Appellant, however, the Plaintiff/Respondent failed to come
forward to perform his part of the obligations. Consequently, upon expiry of
the stipulated period on 15.04.2018, the Agreement stood terminated, and
the earnest money paid by the Plaintiff stood forfeited vide the Defendant‟s
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
registered letter dated 16.04.2018.
12.
The Replication was filed by the Plaintiff/Respondent reiterating the
assertions made in the Plaint.
13.
The Issues were framed by the learned Trial Court on 21.01.2019, as
under:
“1. Whether plaintiff is entitled to decree of recovery of
Rs.5,02,000/- against the defendant? OPP
2. Whether plaintiff is entitled for pendente lite and future
interest @ 18% p.a. from the date of filing of the Suit till
realization? OPP
3. Whether the plaintiff has suppressed the material facts
and has not come to the court with clean hands? OPD.
4. Whether there is no cause of action for the plaintiff to
file the present suit? OPD.
5. Whether the agreement dated 18.01.2018 stood
terminated for the acts of the plaintiff and, therefore,
whether the defendant was justified in forfeiting the
amount? OPD.
6. Relief.”
14.
The Plaintiff in support of his case, examined himself as PW-1 and
tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex. PW-1/A, wherein he reiterated
the contents of the plaint and relied upon documents exhibited as Ex. PW1/1 to Ex. PW-1/5.
15.
PW-2, Sh. Vishal Shukla, Assistant Programmer, SR-IIA, produced
the Application submitted by the Plaintiff Ex. PW-1/2 (also referred to as
Ex. PW-2/1). PW-3, Sh. Amit Walia, Public Relations Inspector, produced
letter No. F-1/Summon-16/DHQ/2022-23, Ex. PW-3/1 (colly). PW-4, Sh.
S.B. Singh, produced letter bearing no. F/Misc/Court Notice/2022-23, Ex.
PW-4/1.
16.
The Defendant, in support of his case, examined himself as DW-1 and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.DW-1/A, wherein he reiterated
the stand taken in the Written Statement.
17.
The learned District Judge observed that both parties had failed to
establish their respective stands inasmuch as the Plaintiff could not prove his
readiness and willingness to perform his part of the Agreement, while the
Defendant failed to justify the forfeiture of the earnest money. It was thus,
held that neither party could be permitted to take advantage of its own
default and that the Plaintiff was entitled only to restitution of the amount
paid, without any claim to double the earnest money.
18.
Accordingly, the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent was decreed in
the sum of Rs.2,51,000/- along with interest @ 9% p.a.
19.
Aggrieved by the said judgment, the present Appeal has been
preferred by the Appellant/Rashid Hussain.
20.
The grounds of challenge are that the Plaintiff during the cross-
examination, had stated that he had only seen the GPA in favour of the
Appellant executed by the owner of the Suit Property, but did not see the
entire chain of ownership documents. He further claimed that the Defendant
had agreed to show the documents in the following week, but he was unable
to show any ownership documents, even thereafter. He is a practicing
Advocate and it is highly improbable that he would enter into an Agreement
to Sell without verification of the ownership of the Suit Property.
21.
The Plaintiff even stated in his cross-examination that he had
contacted property dealer, Shri Devender Rajoria, who was a Mediator in
Delhi and also asked him to request the Defendant to show him the entire
chain of ownership documents.
22.
It is asserted that Plaintiff had admitted in his evidence that he had
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
been searching for a residential property near DMRC. In the month of
January 2018, through a property dealer, he had seen the Suit Property
pursuant to which he entered into the Agreement to Sell, for a total sale
consideration of Rs.25 lakhs. The Plaintiff in his cross-examination stated
that he had sold his previous property in which he was residing in
December, 2017, for a sum of Rs.24-25 lakhs and had received the
consideration in cash, but in his affidavit of evidence, he stated that he had
sold the aforesaid residential property prior to entering into the Agreement
to Sell, without disclosing the availability of the balance consideration.
Moreover, the property, i.e. F-142D, Adhyapak Nagar, Nangloi, Delhi
where he is residing, was purchased on 01.04.2018,
for a total sale
consideration of Rs.15 lakhs.
23.
It is submitted that the Agreement to Sell qua the Suit Property was to
be executed on or before 15.04.2018. Since the plaintiff had already
purchased another property, he had no need to purchase the Suit Property
and had no sufficient funds to honour the Agreement dated 18.01.2018.
24.
Further, the Plaintiff had not filed any Account Statement or led any
evidence, to show his financial capacity. His suit for return of earnest
money, was only to extort money from the Defendant, under the garb of
Agreement dated 18.01.2018.
25.
It has not been appreciated that while the Plaintiff claimed that he had
visited the Office of Sub-Registrar on 16.04.2018 and had submitted an
Application Ex.PW-1/2, but in his cross-examination, he admitted that he
did not contact the mediator Devender Rajoria, but had tried to contact the
Appellant with whom he could not establish contact.
26.
He further stated that he had reached the Office of Sub-Registrar,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
Nangloi without contacting the Appellant, since he was under the impression
that in terms of written Agreement, he was obligated to pay the
consideration amount and get the sale executed, for which he approached the
Office of Sub-Registrar.
27.
The claim of the Plaintiff that he had contacted the Appellant before
going to the Office of said Registrar, is a false claim as he himself admitted
that he did not have any contact number of the Appellant/Defendant.
28.
The
defence of the Plaintiff that he had taken the balance sale
consideration of Rs.22,49,000/- in cash, to the Office of the Sub-Registrar, is
not tenable and also highly improbable, for the simple reason that no cash
transaction is allowed at the Office of Sub-Registrar in respect of sale
consideration. Furthermore, consideration amount was to be paid through
cheque, RTGS and not in cash.
29.
The Plaintiff further stated in his cross-examination that he had
several meetings with the Appellant/Defendant through Mediator in
January-February 2018, but the Defendant was not willing to fulfil the terms
of the Agreement dated 18.01.2018. The plaintiff had asserted that the suit
property was fetching more consideration amount and after the deal with
some person, Defendant agreed to return the earnest money, even though he
had never agreed for the same.
30.
It is submitted that Respondent/Plaintiff has stated two different
situations which are inconsistent to each other; on the one hand, he claimed
that he reached the Office of Sub-Registrar with the balance sale
consideration in cash, without any intimation or contact with the mediator or
the Appellant. On the other hand, he stated that Defendant was not
interested to sell the Suit Property, which was mentioned hereinabove.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
31.
Moreover, the Respondent/Plaintiff has admitted that he did not issue
any Legal Notice before 15.04.2018 to the Defendant, to accept the balance
sale consideration for execution of the Sale Deed.
32.
Also, the testimony of the Appellant as DW1, has not been
appreciated in the correct perspective. The Defendant had issued Letters
dated 28.03.2018 and 16.04.2018 for getting the Sale Deed executed, despite
which the Plaintiff failed to come forward to execute his part of the
Agreement.
33.
It is further contended that the Appellant had to sell the property for a
lesser amount of Rs.15,00,000/-, while he had entered into an Agreement
with the Plaintiff for sale of the property for Rs.25,00,000/-. The loss was
incurred by the Appellant, and therefore, he had rightly forfeited the earnest
amount.
34.
Hence, the Appeal be allowed and the impugned judgment, be set
aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
35.
It is the admitted case of the parties that the Defendant/Appellant
was the owner of the Suit Property and had agreed to sell the property to the
Plaintiff/Respondent vide Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018, for a total
sale consideration of Rs.25,00,000/-. The Plaintiff/Respondent paid
Rs.2,51,000/- as earnest money on 18.01.2018.
36.
It is further not in dispute that in terms of the Agreement to Sell, the
balance amount was to be paid up to 15.04.2018, on which date the Sale
Deed was to be executed. It is further a fact that, this Agreement to Sell was
not honored and the Defendant/Appellant forfeited the earnest money in the
sum of Rs.2,51,000/-.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
37.
The core issue is whether the Plaintiff was entitled to refund of his
earnest money, on account of non-performance of an Agreement to Sell.
Essentially, in such contracts, two distinct concepts arise, namely, earnest
money and advance payment, which are often used interchangeably. To
comprehend the controversy, it is pertinent to understand the two concepts.
I. Concept of “advance money” and “earnest money”:
38.
The term „advance‟ means money, in whole or in part, forming part of
the consideration of an Agreement, paid before the same becomes fully
payable. On the other hand, “earnest money” means a sum of money given
for the purpose of binding a contract, which is forfeited in case the contract
does not materialise.
39.
In the case of Charanjeet Singh vs. Har Swarup, AIR 1926 PC 1, the
nature of earnest money was explained in the terms, that it is part of the
purchase price when the transaction goes forward and it is forfeited when the
transaction falls through, by reason of the fault or failure of the purchaser.
40.
This concept of earnest money, was succinctly explained in the case
of Shree Hanuman Cotton Mills vs. Tata Air Craft Ltd., (1969) 3 SCC 522,
as under: “21.
…, the following principles emerge regarding
„earnest‟:
(i) It must be given at the moment at which the contract is
concluded.
(ii)
It represents a guarantee that the contract will
be fulfilled or, in the other words, “earnest” is given to
bind the contract.
(iii)
It is part of the purchase price when that
transaction is carried out.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
(iv)
It is forfeited when the transaction falls through
by reason of the default of failure of the purchaser.
(v)
Unless there is anything to the contrary in the
terms of the contract, on default committed by the buyer,
the seller is entitled to forfeit the earnest.”
41.
The Apex Court again in the case of Videocon Properties Ltd. vs.
Bhalchandra Laboratories, (2004) 3 SCC 711, examined the nature and
character of the earnest money deposit and observed that earnest money
fulfils a dual purpose; first, it operates as part-payment of the purchase
price and; secondly, as security for the performance of the contractual
obligations. Thus, its true character and purpose can only be examined on a
close reading of the agreement, and the relevant contextual factors. Further,
the words used in the agreement alone cannot be determinative of the true
nature of the amount advanced. Instead, the intention of the parties and the
surrounding circumstances serve as more apt indicators. The relevant
observations are reproduced herein below:
“14. […….] Further, it is not the description by words
used in the agreement only that would be determinative of
the character of the sum but really the intention of parties
and surrounding circumstances as well, that have to be
looked into and what may be called an advance may
really be a deposit or earnest money and what is termed
as „a deposit or earnest money‟ may ultimately turn out to
be really an advance or part of purchase price. Earnest
money or deposit also, thus, serves two purposes of being
part-payment of the purchase money and security for the
performance of the contract by the party concerned, who
paid it.”
(Emphasis supplied)
42.
While explaining these terms, the Apex Court again in the case of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
Satish Batra vs. Sudhir Rawal, (2013) 1 SCC 345 emphasised that to justify
the forfeiture of „advance money‟ being part of earnest money, the terms of
contract should be clear and explicit. The earnest money is paid or given at
the time when the contract is entered into, as a pledge for its due
performance by the depositor, to be forfeited in case of non-performance by
the depositor. There can be a converse situation also that if the seller fails to
perform the contract, the purchaser can also get double the amount, if it is so
stipulated. It is also the law that part-payment of purchase price cannot be
forfeited, unless it is a guarantee for the due performance of the contract. In
other words, if the payment is made only towards part-payment of
consideration and not intended as earnest money, then the forfeiture clause
shall not apply.
43.
These principles were reiterated and reconfirmed in the case of DDA
vs. Grihsthapana Coop. Group Housing Society Ltd., 1995 Supp (1) SCC
751 wherein it was observed that the specific covenant under the contract
must be seen to conclude whether the Respondent is entitled to forfeiture of
money paid under the contract. When the contract fell through by the default
committed by the Appellant as part of the contract, they are entitled to
forfeit the entire amount.
44.
The three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in the Case of Central Bank
of India vs. Shanmugavelu, (2024) 6 SCC 641, reiterated the difference
between the „earnest money‟ and the „advance money‟. It was held that if
earnest money is adjusted towards the sale consideration, it loses its
character of earnest money and becomes part-payment. It was held that the
earnest money can be treated as part-payment of sale consideration, only if
the contractual terms under the Agreement are honoured. An advance is a
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
part to be adjusted at the time of final payment. If the promisee defaults to
carry out the contract, he loses the earnest money, but may recover partpayment leaving untouched the promisor‟s right to recover the damages.
45.
Having defined the parameters for advance money and earnest money,
it becomes relevant to consider the facts of this case.
II. Whether the Entire Amount is liable to be forfeited:
46.
In this context, it is also pertinent to ascertain the extent of
permissible forfeiture. The principles underlying forfeiture clause was
considered in the case of Fateh Chand vs. Balkishan Dass, 1963 SCC
OnLine SC 49 wherein it was held that Section 74 of the Indian Contract
Act, 1872, would apply to every covenant involving a penalty; whether it is
for a future payment on breach of the contract or the forfeiture of the sum
already paid. It was held that evidence of loss incurred by a vendor on
account of breach of contract by the buyer, would be mandatory to justify
forfeiture and only a reasonable amount with such loss, can be forfeited. It
observed as under:“14.
[……….] The words “to be paid” which appear
in the first condition do not qualify the second condition
relating to stipulation by way of penalty. The expression
“if the contract contains any other stipulation by way of
penalty” widens the operation of the section so as to
make it applicable to all stipulations by way of penalty,
whether the stipulation is to pay an amount of money, or
is of another, character, as, for example, providing for
forfeiture of money already paid. There is nothing in the
expression which implies that the stipulation must be one
for rendering something after the contract is broken.
There is no ground for holding that the expression
„contract contains any other stipulation by way of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
penalty‟ is limited to cases of stipulation in the nature of
an agreement to pay money or deliver property on breach
and does not comprehend covenants under which
amounts paid or property delivered under the contract,
which by the terms of the contract expressly or by clear
implication are liable to be forfeited.”
47.
This aspect was again considered by the Supreme Court in the case
of Maula Bux vs. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 554 wherein it was held that
the forfeiture of earnest money, cannot be deemed as penal under Section 74
of the Contract Act, 1872 and would only apply where forfeiture is in the
nature of penalty. It was held that the forfeiture of reasonable amount paid
as earnest money, does not amount to imposing a penalty. But if forfeiture is
in the nature of penalty, Section 74 would apply. Where under the terms of
the contract, the party in breach, had undertaken to pay a sum of money or
to forfeit the sum of money, which is already paid to a party complaining of
a breach of contract, the undertaking is in the nature of a penalty.
48.
These judgments were considered by the Apex Court in the case of
Shanmugavelu (supra) and it was observed that a clause providing for
forfeiture of an amount, could fundamentally be in the nature of a penalty
clause or a statutory forfeiture clause in the strict sense or even both, and the
same has to be determined in the facts of every case, keeping in mind the
nature of contract and the nature of consequence envisaged by it.
49.
Thus, in the case of Maula Bux (supra), Fateh Chand (supra), and
Satish Batra (supra), it was held that ordinarily a forfeiture clause in the
strict sense will not be a penal clause, if the consequence is intended not as a
sanction for breach of obligation, but rather as security of performance of
the obligation. The forfeiture of earnest money is not a penal clause as its
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
deposit is intended to signify assent of the purchaser to the contract, and its
forfeiture is envisaged as a deterrent to ensure performance of the
obligation.
50.
Similarly, in the case of Lakshmanan vs. B.R. Mangalagiri, 1995
Supp (2) SCC 33, the Apex Court held that where the contract falls through
due to default on the part of the purchaser and the resulting loss suffered by
the vendors exceed the amount forfeited under the contract, the forfeiture
cannot, by any measure, be termed as unjustified.
51.
In the recent case of K.R. Suresh vs. R. Poornima & Ors., 2025 INSC
617, this entire law as detailed above, was considered in detail and it was
held that the fundamental principle is that the forfeiture of the money paid,
can be justified only if it is in the nature of earnest money, intended to
ensure the performance of the contract.
III. Whether the Appellant was entitled to forfeit Rs.2,51,000/- on account
of non-performance of Agreement to Sell Dated 18.01.2018:
52.
In the present case, as borne out from the pleadings of the parties, the
relevant terms of the Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018, insofar as they
pertain to dealing with the payment of the amount, reads as under:“1. That the second party have paid a sum of
Rs.2,51,000/- (RUPEES TWO LAKHS FIFTY-ONE
THOUSAND ONLY) to the first party on 18/01/2018, IN
CASH
……
4. that buyer second party along with the chain of
documents verified / inspected from S.D.M. or concerned
office and in case of any wrong, ambiguous, disputed
ownership title the first party will have to refund or
return the earnest money.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
........
12.
that in case the second party fails to complete
the sale bargain within the above said stipulated period
then the earnest money of the second party will be
forfeited by the first party.”
53.
Thus, the Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018 records that a sum of
Rs. 2,51,000/- was paid by the Plaintiff to the Defendant on 18.01.2018. It
further provides that the said amount was liable to be forfeited in the event
of default on the part of the purchaser. However, the Agreement to Sell does
not expressly classify the amount of Rs.2,51,000/- as either “earnest money”
or “advance payment”. Therefore, the nature of the said payment is required
to be ascertained from the terms of the Agreement, the intention and conduct
of the parties, and the surrounding circumstances.
54.
Subsequently, in Clause 12 of the Agreement, it was stipulated that if
the buyer failed to perform his part of the contract, the seller was entitled to
forfeit this amount. Likewise, if the seller did not perform his part of the
contract, the buyer shall be entitled to double the amount so paid by him.
55.
There is nothing in the Agreement to Sell indicating whether this
amount was an earnest money or an advance payment. The covenants of the
Agreement to Sell, do not clearly establish that it was intended to be earnest
money; rather, the terms reflect that it was an advance paid by the
Respondent, which was liable to be adjusted towards the sale consideration
in case the Agreement to Sell went through.
56.
The next aspect for consideration is the respective conduct and the
intention of the parties, which led to non-performance of the Agreement to
Sell dated 18.01.2018.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
Conduct of the Plaintiff/Respondent, Sh. Manjeet Patwa:
57.
It may be first considered whether it was the Plaintiff/Respondent
who was in breach of the Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018, and failed to
perform his part of the Agreement to Sell.
58.
The Plaintiff asserted that he was always ready and willing to
perform his part of the Agreement to Sell. His first ground taken for noncompliance of the Agreement to sell, was that he had not been shown the
complete chain of documents at the time of Agreement to Sell and despite
repeated requests to the Defendant, the chain of documents was not supplied
to him.
59.
Learned District Judge has considered the evidence of the parties
wherein the Plaintiff had deposed in his cross-examination as PW1, that he
had contacted the property dealer, Shri Devender Rajoria who was the
Mediator in the deal, and requested him to ask the Defendant to provide the
entire chain of ownership documents. He further admitted that he never
personally demanded from the Defendant the entire chain of documents.
60.
The learned District Judge thus, concluded that though Plaintiff had
asserted that despite requesting the supply of entire previous chain of
documents, but the Defendant did not do so, but from his cross-examination,
it emerged that he himself had never contacted the Defendant/Appellant.
The best person to prove this aspect was Devender Rajoria, who pertinently
was not been examined.
61.
The contention of the Defendant that the Plaintiff was a lawyer by
profession and it was difficult to accept that he would enter into an
Agreement to Sell without first checking the previous chain of documents,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
was accepted and the learned District Judge rightly held this ground of nonproviding of chain of documents, as not tenable.
62.
The second aspect was the readiness and willingness of the
Respondent, to perform his part of the Agreement to Sell. The Plaintiff, in
order to prove his willingness, deposed that in terms of the Agreement to
Sell, he had visited the office of Sub-Registrar on 15.04.2018 along with the
balance amount of Rs.22,49,000/- in cash, but the Defendant failed to
perform his part of Agreement to Sell to register the Sale Deed in favour of
the Plaintiff/Respondent. To corroborate his assertions, he had given a Letter
Ex. PW1/2 for marking his presence in the Office of Sub-Registrar which
was proved by PW-2, Sh. Vishal Shukla.
63.
Interestingly, PW-2 Sh. Vishal Shukla, Assistant Programmer at SR-
IIA Office, deposed that he did not accept the Application with the sample,
as mentioned in the Application, in his official capacity. He also clarified
that before registration of any document, an online appointment has to be
taken.
64.
The learned District Judge noted that the Plaintiff/Respondent
nowhere asserted that he had taken an online appointment for registration of
the Sale Deed, which was a mandatory requirement. He admittedly did not
give any Notice to the Defendant nor was there any draft Sale Deed prepared
of which the registration could have been done. Thus, his going to the office
of Sub-Registrar without any prior appointment and prior intimation to the
Defendant, was only a ploy to claim that he had performed his part of the
Agreement.
65.
Further, while the Plaintiff claimed that he had taken the balance of
Rs.22,49,000/- in cash to the office of sub-registrar, but there is no evidence
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
whatsoever to explain the source of income. In fact, he has also not been
able to show that there was any Agreement between the parties that the
balance amount would be paid to the Defendant in cash.
66.
An interesting fact to be observed is that as per the Plaintiff, he had
sold his Property where he was residing in December, 2017, and thereafter
he had entered into this Agreement to Sell in January, 2018 with the
Defendant/Appellant. Significantly, he thereafter, had purchased a new
Property on 01.04.2018, for a total sale consideration of Rs.15,00,000/-.
Once, the Plaintiff had already purchased another flat, neither was there any
need for him to go through the present Agreement to Sell transaction nor is
there any reflection that the cash obtained by him by sale of his flat, was still
available for the purchase of the Suit Property. It all reflects that the Plaintiff
having acquired another Property, had no interest to execute the present
Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018.
67.
Admittedly, the Plaintiff never ever issued any Notice to the
Defendant/Appellant, either before, on, or after 15.04.2018, i.e. the agreed
date of execution of the Sale Deed, for showing his willingness to perform
his part of the contract.
68.
Thus, the learned District Judge, therefore, rightly concluded that the
plaintiff failed to prove that he was ready and willing to perform his part or
take any steps towards the execution of the sale deed, pursuant to the ATS
dated 18.01.2018. Therefore, his claim that he was entitled to repayment
of double the earnest money, was absolutely not tenable.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
Conduct of the Defendant/Appellant, Sh. Rashid Hussain:
69.
The question which arises is whether the Defendant/ Appellant was
in breach of the Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018, who failed to perform
his part of the Agreement to Sell.
70.
The question for consideration is the readiness and willingness on the
part of Defendant/Appellant to perform his part of the Agreement, in order
to forfeit the earnest amount of Rs.2,51,000/-.
71.
The Defendant/Appellant in order to show that he was willing to
perform his part of the Agreement, relied upon his Letter dated 28.03.2018
Ex. DW1/X, which he had allegedly sent to the Plaintiff for execution of the
Sale Deed. The Defendant/Appellant admitted that the letter was sent to his
address at H.No. F-142-D, Adhyapak Nagar, Nangloi, but that was not the
address mentioned in the Agreement to Sell, where the Plaintiff was shown
as resident of H. No. RZQ-32, Nihal Vihar, Nangloi, Delhi, Delhi-110041.
72.
The Defendant did not give any explanation of sending the Legal
Notice to an address different from the one mentioned in the Agreement to
Sell. The learned District Judge thus, rightly observed that the Defendant
had not led any evidence and had not been able to discharge the burden of
proving that the Letter dated 28.03.2018, was ever served upon the Plaintiff.
73.
The second aspect was that the date for execution of the Sale Deed
was on or before 15.04.2018. The learned District Judge observed that
14.04.2018 and 15.04.2018 were government holidays, being Saturday and
Sunday. The parties could have either visited the Office of the Sub-Registrar
on 13.04.2018 or 16.04.2018. The Defendant had not adduced any cogent
evidence to show his willingness, to perform his part of the Agreement or
had ever made an endeavor to take an appointment with the Sub-Registrar.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
So much so, he never ever visited the Office of the Sub-Registrar on or
before 15.04.2018.
74.
The Defendant/Appellant had claimed that he had made several calls
to the Plaintiff to perform his part of the Agreement to Sell, but no such
suggestion was given to PW1, Plaintiff, in his cross-examination. Moreover,
there were no details or dates given on which the alleged calls were made.
75.
Moreover, the Defendant neither in his Written Statement nor in his
testimony, disclosed the dates when he visited the Plaintiff or the Mediator
for the purpose of execution of Sale Deed or to demand the balance sale
consideration. The learned District Judge also noted that the best person to
prove the nature of transaction between the parties was Devender Rajoria,
Mediator, but he had not been examined by either party.
76.
The Defendant had claimed that since he was in dire need of money
and he had to subsequently sell the Suit Property vide Sale Deed dated
18.09.2018, for a much less sale consideration of Rs.13,75,000/-. It is
asserted that on account of non-performance of the Agreement to Sell,
Defendant suffered a huge loss. In respect of this, it is pertinent to observe
that the Defendant/Appellant, as per his own testimony, had forfeited the
earnest amount on 16.04.2018 itself, when the Agreement to Sell did not
materialize.
77.
There is no cogent evidence to show that indeed the said property was
sold for Rs.13,75,000/-, the consideration amount mentioned in the Sale
Deed. The most pertinent person to prove the consideration amount for
which the property was sold was the subsequent purchaser, but he has not
been examined. Furthermore, at the time of forfeiture of the earnest money
in April, 2018, there is no evidence to show that he had suffered any kind of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
loss. Thus, his claim of having to sell the property at a lesser price, is not
tenable in order to ascertain his right to forfeit the earnest money.
78.
The Defendant/Appellant had asserted that he had issued Letter dated
28.03.2018 calling upon the Plaintiff, to honour his part of the Agreement.
However, it has emerged in the evidence that this Notice was sent by the
Defendant to the Plaintiff at an address where he was admittedly and to the
knowledge of the Defendant, was not residing.
79.
The Appellant had also sent a Legal Notice dated 16.04.2018 Ex.PW-
1/DX2, informing the Plaintiff in categorical terms, that despite the
stipulated date for execution of the Sale Deed expired on 15.04.2018 in the
Agreement to Sell dated 18.01.2018, the balance amount has not been paid
till 16.04.2018 i.e. the date of the Legal Notice and therefore, the amount is
forfeited.
80.
There is nothing to show that a delay of a day or two entitles the
Appellant, to forfeit the amount without first ascertaining the willingness
and readiness of the Plaintiff to execute the Sale Deed. The hurry in which
the Agreement was terminated on 16.04.2018 itself, shows that he himself
was not inclined to go through the deal. It may also be noted that in the
Legal Notice, it was stated that the Agreement has not been executed till
15.04.2018, while the Notice itself was stated 16.04.2018 thereby reflecting
the incongruity in the Legal Notice.
81.
It was thus, rightly concluded by the ld. District Judge that the onus
to prove his willingness was on the Defendant, which he had failed to prove.
82.
It can therefore, be concluded that it was a case where neither the
Plaintiff nor the Defendant had been able to prove their respective readiness
and willingness to perform their respective part of the Agreement to Sell.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
83.
It emerges that both, the Plaintiff as well as the Defendant, were not
serious in the performance of the Agreement to Sell and the Defendant,
immediately on the last date of the contract, rescinded the contract and
forfeited the amount.
Conclusion:
84.
It is quite evident that both the parties were equally responsible for
non-execution of the Agreement to Sell and therefore, the Defendant is
liable to return the amount of Rs.2,51,000/-, which had been taken under the
Agreement to Sell as part of the total sale consideration.
85.
In view of the aforesaid, the learned District Judge has rightly directed
the recovery of the earnest money of Rs.2,51,000/- along with interest at the
rate of 9% p.a., against the Appellant/Defendant.
86.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
MARCH 19, 2026
N/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:23:44
RFA 251/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review