Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:590-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1840 of 2022
Ranu Shukla Das @ Sandeep Das S/o Ratindra Shukla Das Aged About 24
Years R/o Dharmanagar, Near Water Tank, Police Station Dharmanagar,
District Ganganagar (Tripura), Presently Residing At Above Baba Moni Mobile
Shop, Vasulifata, Police Station Chakan, District : Pune, Maharashtra
... Appellant
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Kotwali, Korba, District : Korba,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Praveen Soni, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Priyank Rathi, Government Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Arvind Kumar Verma, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
06/01/2026
1. Challenge in this appeal filed under Section 374(2) of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973 is to the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 11.07.2022 passed in Sessions Trial No. 52/2019 by the
Sessions Judge, Korba, District Korba, by which the appellant has been
convicted for the offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for
short, the IPC) and sentenced to imprisonment for life with fine of
Rs.500/- and in default, to undergo additional rigorous imprisonment for
one month and Section 404 of the IPC and sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 2 years with fine of Rs. 500/- and in default to
undergo additional rigorous imprisonment for 1 month.
2. The appellant/convict Ranu Shukla Das alias Sandeep Das was charged
under Sections 302, 201, and 380 of the IPC alleging that on the
intervening night of 22/23.01.2019, at Krishna Nagar, Korba, at the
house of Supriya alias Priya Mallik (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
deceased), with the intention of causing her death, he strangled her and
murdered her. Thereafter, with the intention of concealing the offence of
murder, he wrapped the dead body of the deceased in a bedsheet, hid it
inside a Diwan of her house, locked the house from outside, and caused
disappearance of evidence. Further, from the residence of the deceased,
he dishonestly removed and committed theft of her property, namely a
mobile phone, gold and silver ornaments, ATM card, voter ID card,
driving licence, vehicle registration certificate, and almirah key, with the
intention of wrongful gain.
3. The case of the prosecution in brief is that the deceased was supposed
to travel to Kondagaon to her mother’s house. When she did not reach
Kondagaon and attempts were made to contact her on her mobile phone
number 9399304872, the phone was found switched off. Due to the
inability to contact her, the complainant Rupesh Haldar (PW-2), along
with the deceased’s mother Kajal Mandal (PW-3) and her daughter
Sania Mandal, came from Kondagaon to the deceased’s house at Korba.
They found the house locked. Thereafter, alongwith Hiralal Karsh
(PW-1), they went to Manikpur Police Outpost and informed the police.
Subsequently, attempts were made to open the lock on the door of the
deceased’s house. During this process, Hiralal Karsh (PW-1) tried to
open the lock using a key in his possession, upon which the lock opened.
A panchnama in this regard was prepared. Upon entering the house, a
foul smell was emanating from one of the rooms. When the Diwan bed in
that room was opened, the dead body of the deceased was found inside
the Diwan, wrapped in a bed-sheet and covered with a blue cloth. On the
spot, on the complaint of the complainant Rupesh Haldar (PW-2) alleging
that the deceased had been murdered and hidden inside the Diwan, a
Dehati
Merg intimation and Dehati Nalishi (First Information Report)
under Sections 302 and 201 IPC were registered. The lock afÏxed to the
house, bearing the inscription “Spider King (SK150)”, and the key used
by Hiralal (PW-1), bearing the inscription “Shangli”, were seized in the
presence of witnesses. A panchnama describing the visible condition of
the dead body was prepared, and a spot map of the place of occurrence
was drawn in the presence of witnesses. At Police Station City Kotwali,
Korba, Merg Intimation bearing No. 09/2019 and FIR bearing Crime No.
58/2019 were registered. The dead body was sent to the District
Hospital, Korba, for post-mortem examination along with an memo. The
doctor conducting the post-mortem preserved the viscera, uterus, and
vaginal swab slides and advised chemical examination.
4. During the investigation, statements of Kajal Mandal (mother of the
deceased) (PW-3), her daughter Sania Mallik, and witness Hiralal Karsh
(PW-1) were recorded, which revealed that the deceased and the
appellant were in a relationship and intended to marry each other, and
that the appellant-Ranu Shukla Das @ Sandeep Das had come from
Pune to Korba. Analysis of the Call Detail Records (CDR) of the
appellant’s mobile numbers 8197156285 and 6361333946 and the
deceased’s mobile number 9399304872 revealed that there was
continuous communication between the deceased and the appellant prior
to the incident. The deceased’s mobile phone with IMEI numbers
357278080996094 and 357278080996086 was not found in the house,
and it was found to be active on another mobile number from 25.01.2019.
Based on information received from the Cyber Cell, a police team was
sent to Pune (Maharashtra) to search for the suspect. On 04.01.2019,
from the possession of appellant, the deceased’s Nokia mobile phone
was recovered. Upon interrogation, the memorandum statement of the
appellant was recorded, wherein he confessed that he strangled the
deceased, hid her dead body inside the Diwan of her house, took her
mobile phone, gold and silver ornaments, wristwatch, ATM card, voter ID
card, driving licence, vehicle RC book, and almirah key, locked the door
of the deceased’s house and threw away the key, and stayed at a hotel in
front of Champa Railway Station on 23.01.2019.
5. On the basis of the memorandum statement, upon production by the
appellant, the above-mentioned articles were recovered from his house
at Vasuli Phata, Police Station Chakan, District Pune (Maharashtra) and
was seized. The appellant was arrested, and information of his arrest
was given to his family members. He was produced before the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Khed, Rajgurunagar, District Pune, and transit
remand was obtained. On 06.02.2019, he was produced before the Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Korba, and one day’s police remand was granted.
An identification parade was conducted by the Executive Magistrate,
Korba, wherein witness Hiralal Karsh (PW-1) identified the appellant and
an identification panchnama was prepared. The seized ornaments and
wristwatch were identified by the deceased’s mother Kajal Mandal (PW3) and her daughter Sania Mallik as belonging to the deceased, and
identification panchnamas were prepared. During the investigation, the
register of Hotel Shree Ganesh, located in front of Champa Railway
Station, showing the appellant’s stay, was seized from the hotel manager
and returned on Supurdnama. CCTV footage showing the appellant’s
arrival and stay at the hotel was copied onto a pen drive, which was
seized, and a certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act
was obtained regarding its authenticity. Customer profiles and CDRs
were obtained from the concerned telecom companies for the
deceased’s mobile number 9399304872, her mobile phone IMEI
numbers 357278080996094 and 357278080996086, the appellant’s
mobile number 8197156285 with IMEI numbers 352801089332510 and
352802089332519, and the appellant’s brother Rahuth Shukla Das’s
mobile number 9370946035, which was active on the deceased’s mobile
IMEI from 25101.2019.
6. The viscera of the deceased was sent to the Regional Forensic Science
Laboratory, Raipur. A letter was sent to the Tehsildar, Korba, and a spot
map was prepared by the Patwari. After completion of the investigation, a
charge-sheet under Sections 302, 201, and 380 IPC was filed against the
accused before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Korba, from where the
case was committed to the Sessions Court for trial.
7. When the charges under Sections 302, 201, and 380 IPC were framed
against the appellant, he denied the charges and prayed for trial.
8. In order to bring home the offence, the prosecution examined as many as
15 witnesses namely, Hiralal Karsh (PW-1), Rupesh Haldar (PW-2),
Kajal Mandal (PW-3), Mohan Lal (PW-4), Hemant Patle (PW-5),
Shailendra Pandey (PW-6), Durgesh Kumar Rathore (PW-7), C.S. Sidar
(PW-8), Dr.O.S.Kanwar (PW-9), Markandeya Mishra (PW-10), Guna
Ram Sinha (PW-11), P.S. Bhagat, (PW-12), Gurudatt Panchbhaye (PW13), Panchram Salame (PW-14), Rajesh Chandravanshi (PW-15).
9.
The statement of the appellant/convict under section 313 Cr.P.C was
recorded wherein he stated that he was innocent and has been falsely
implicated in this case. He expressed his ignorance with respect to some
of the questions and some of them were denied as well.
10.
The learned trial Judge, after considering the evidence on record,
convicted and sentenced the appellant/accused as detailed in the
opening paragraph of this judgment. Hence, the present appeal by the
appellant/convict.
11.
Mr. Praveen Soni, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the
appellant is innocent and has been falsely implicated in this case. There
is no eye witness to the incident and the conviction of the appellant is
based on circumstantial evidence. Though the prosecution has tried to
establish the motive, but there was no strong motive for the appellant to
commit murder of the deceased. Even the death of the deceased cannot
be conclusively said to be homicidal as no injury marks were found on
the body of the deceased nor any poisonous substance was found in the
body of the deceased in the FSL report. The dead body of the deceased
was found in her own house which was locked from outside and the lock
was opened with a key given by Hiralal Karsh (PW-1) and as such, the
said house was accessible to Hiralal Karsh also and it cannot be
conclusively said that it was the appellant alone who committed the
offence in question.
12.
Mr. Soni further submits that even if the prosecution story is taken on its
face value, then also the offence said to have been committed by the
appellant would not travel beyond the purview of Section 304 IPC as the
appellant is said to have caused death of the deceased on a spur of
moment and there was no premeditation and the appellant had not acted
cruelly. The appellant was enraged when he came to know that number
of persons come and visit the deceased and had found some
objectionable items in her mobile phone upon which a sudden quarrel
took place. As such, his conviction may be altered to Section 304 of the
IPC, instead of Section 302 of the IPC or may be acquitted of the
charges and this appeal may be allowed.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned counsel appearing for the
State/respondent submits that the learned trial Court has rightly arrived
at a finding with regard to the guilt of the appellant and the learned trial
Court was fully justified in convicting and sentencing the appellant for the
offences in question. The judgment is based on evidence available on
record and as such, the same does not warrant any interference and the
appeal deserves to be dismissed.
14.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival
submissions made herein-above and went through the records with
utmost circumspection.
15.
In the present case, the dead body was found after a week by which time
the entire body had started decomposing and foul smell was coming out.
The Doctor conducting the postmortem vide his report (Exhibit P/34) had
opined that the cause of death could be ascertained only after the FSL
examination. Though in the postmortem report, the nature of death was
not specifically written but on a query being made by the Police, in the
query report (Exhibit P/55), this witness had opined the nature of death to
be homicidal on the basis of the fact of recovery of the dead body from
inside the Diwan. In the FSL report (Exhibit P/56), no poisonous
substance has been found in the body of the deceased.
16.
P.S.Bhagat (PW-12), Senior Scientific OfÏcer, Scene of Crime, Mobile
Unit, Bilaspur, vide spot inspection report (Exhibit P/40) has opined that
it appeared that the deceased was done to death by throttling and
thereafter, the dead body was concealed inside Diwan after wrapping in
a bed sheet.
17.
From the evidence of the witnesses, it transpires that the deceased had
planned to go to Kondagaon on 23.01.2019 but when she did not reach,
her mother tried to contact the deceased over phone, no contact could be
made as the phone was switched off. On 25.01.2019, when Hiralal Karsh
(PW-1) reached the house of the deceased, he found the door locked
which was informed by him to the daughter of the deceased and also the
mother of the deceased. On 29.01.2019, Kajal Mandal (PW-3) mother of
the deceased, Saniya Mallik and Rupesh Haldar (PW-2) came from
Kondagaon and reached the house of the deceased where they found
the door locked. They intimated the police and when the door was
opened using another key, they entered the house from where foul smell
was coming out and on opening the Diwan, the dead body of the
deceased was found wrapped with a bedsheet.
18.
Even if the death was natural, the dead body would not have been found
wrapped in a bedsheet inside a Diwan. Further, it is not necessary that
there should be any signs on the body of the deceased if he is done to
death by throttling. The circumstances in which the dead body was found
inside the locked house and that too, from inside a Diwan wrapped in a
bedsheet goes to suggest that the death was not normal and it was done
with an intention of concealing the offence of murder.
19.
From the possession of the appellant, the mobile phone, ornaments, wrist
watch, ATM Card, Voter Card, Driving Licence, PAN Card, Debit Card,
RC Book of a vehicle has been recovered for which the appellant has not
been able to give any explanation as to how these articles belonging to
the deceased came to be in his possession. The articles seized have
been duly identified by the mother and daughter of the deceased vide
Exhibit P/8 and P/9 in presence of the Executive Magistrate, Korba.
20.
The deceased expired in the intervening night of 22/23.01.2019 but her
mobile phone was being used by the brother of the appellant and was
active in the area of Pune. The said mobile was also recovered at the
instance of the appellant. On 23.01.2019, the appellant stayed in Shree
Ganesh Hotel, Champa and in the register (Exhibit P/12) of the Hotel, he
concealed the fact that he had come from Korba. Even in the statement
under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the appellant had admitted that he had
arrived at Shree Ganesh Hotel on 23.01.2019 at about 4:30 p.m. and
stayed upto 7:30 a.m. of 24.01.2019. The police had also seized the
video footage of the hotel where the appellant stayed wherein the
appellant was
21.
So far as the contention of the appellant that the door of the house of the
deceased was opened with a key which was handed over by Heeralal
Karsh (PW-1), it is amply clear that the said key belonged to some other
lock but by chance the said key could open the lock which was afÏxed at
the door of the house of the deceased as the make of both the lock and
key were different.
22.
From the evidence of Sub-Inspector Rajesh Chandravanshi (PW-15), it is
clearly established that on 30.01.2019 he prepared and sent a notice
under Section 41 CrPC to the Cyber Cell, Korba, seeking call detail
records, location details, and other information related to mobile phone
numbers 9399304872, 8197156285, 7999075176, and 6260740801.
The said witness stated in his deposition that on 31.01.2019, on the
basis of the report received from the Cyber Cell, it was found that the
deceased’s mobile handset bearing IMEI numbers 357278080996094
and 357278080996086 was active with mobile number 9370946035.
Upon verification, the SIM of mobile number 9370946035 was found to
be registered in the name of Rahuth Shukla Das, son of Ratindra Shukla
Das, resident of 12, Om Sai Complex, Navlak Umbrej, Pune. Similarly, it
was found that mobile number 7999075176 belonged to Hiralal Karsh,
mobile number 8197156285 belonged to the appellant, and mobile
number 6260740801 belonged to the deceased. On examination of the
call detail records so obtained, it was revealed that the deceased was in
continuous telephonic contact with the convict Ranu Shukla Das on his
mobile number 8197156285, and that the convict had also been in
contact with Hiralal Karsh on his mobile number 7999075176. On the
basis of the location details of the said mobile phone, it was found that at
the time of the incident, the mobile location of the convict / appellant was
in Korba. This fact is further corroborated by the statement of PW-7,
Head Constable Durgesh Kumar Rathore, and by the documentary
evidence exhibited during his testimony.
23.
The evidence of Durgesh Kumar Rathore (PW-7), establishes that the
subscriber of mobile number 8197156285 is the appellant-Ranu Das,
son of Ratindra Shukla Das, resident of 35, Santhegate, BLR-1,
Karnataka. The location details of the said mobile phone show that on
19.01.2019, the phone travelled from Pune (Maharashtra) to Nagpur,
Rajnandgaon,
Durg,
Raipur,
Bilaspur,
Janjgir-Champa,
and
Salikhabhatha, Barpali. On 20.01.2019 at 21:42 hours, its location was
found at MP Nagar, Niharika Road, Korba, Manikpur, Korba, and on
21.01.2019 at 08:21 hours, it was located at Ravishankar Nagar, Korba,
as mentioned in Exhibit P-26. On 23.01.2019 at 12:36 hours, the last
recorded location of mobile number 8197156285 was found to be
Ravishankar Nagar, Korba, as mentioned in Exhibit P-26. It was further
found that mobile number 8197156285 (belonging to the convict) was in
continuous contact, from time to time, with mobile number 9399304872
(belonging to the deceased). The subscriber of mobile number
9399304872 is the deceased - Supriya Mallik, wife of Mantu Mallik,
resident of 119, Ward No. 23, Krishna Nagar, Korba, and the IMEI
number of her mobile handset is 357278080996094. As per the call
detail records obtained, mobile numbers 8197156285 and 9399304872
were in regular and continuous contact. Information regarding IMEI
number 357278080996094 of mobile number 9399304872 was received
through an ofÏcial email sent by the nodal ofÏcer. It was found that on
25.01.2019 at 14:12 hours, a Reliance Jio SIM card bearing mobile
number 9370946035 was activated on the said IMEI. The subscriber of
mobile number 9370946035 was found to be Rahuth Shukla Das, son of
Rathindra Shukla Das, resident of 12, Om Sai Complex, Navlakh
Umbari,
Talegaon,
Maval,
Pune
(Moffusil).
The
said
IMEI
357278080996094 was installed in the mobile handset of the deceased.
It was thus found that the deceased’s mobile handset was taken away by
the accused, and thereafter mobile number 9370946035 was activated
on the same handset and used by the accused.
24.
From the subscriber application form of Jio Company relating to mobile
number 9399304872, it is proved that the said mobile number was
allotted to the deceased upon her application to the company. From the
call detail records exhibited as Exhibit P-28, it is proved that the said
mobile number was active on a mobile handset bearing IMEI number
357278080996094. The call detail records further establish that mobile
number 9399304872 was continuously used on the handset bearing
IMEI number 357278080996094, and its location was consistently
shown as Korba. The deceased resided at Korba.
25.
From the subscriber application form of Airtel Company relating to mobile
number 8197156285, it is proved that upon application by the convict,
the said mobile number was allotted to him. From the call detail records
exhibited as Exhibit P-26, it is proved that the said mobile number was
active on a handset bearing IMEI number 352802089332510, and that
the said number was continuously used on that handset. Similarly, from
the subscriber application form of Jio Company relating to mobile
number 6361333946, it is proved that the said mobile number was
allotted to the convict. From the call detail records exhibited as Exhibit P30, it is proved that the said mobile number was active on a handset
bearing IMEI number 352801089332519, and that the said number was
continuously used on that handset. Both the aforesaid mobile numbers
were found to be continuously active within the residential area of the
accused. In his statement recorded under Section 313 CrPC, the convict
has also admitted that mobile numbers 8197156285 and 6361333946
belonged to him, and he also admitted the call detail records of mobile
number 8197156285 (Exhibit P-26). Thus, it is proved that both mobile
numbers 8197156285 and 6361333946 were being used by the
accused, and that the handsets in which these numbers were used bore
IMEI numbers 352802089332510 and 352801089332519, respectively.
26.
From the subscriber application form of Jio Company relating to mobile
number 9370946035 (Exhibit P-31), it is proved that the said mobile
number was issued in the name of Rahuth Shukla Das, son of Rathindra
Shukla Das, who is the brother of the appellant- Ranu Shukla Das. From
the call detail records exhibited as Exhibit P-32, it is proved that from
25.01.2019 onwards, mobile number 9370946035 was used in the
mobile
handset
of
the
deceased
bearing
IMEI
number
357278080996094, from within the residential area of the accused, and
such usage continued till 01.02.2019.
27.
From the above analysis, we are of the considered opinion that the view
taken by the learned trial Court with regard to conviction and sentence
awarded to the appellant is just and proper warranting no interference.
Accordingly, the appeal being devoid of merit is liable to be and is hereby
dismissed.
28. The appellant/convict is stated to be in jail. He shall serve out the
sentence awarded by the trial Court by means of the impugned judgment
of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned trial Court.
29.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is undergoing the jail term, to
serve the same on the appellant informing him that he is at liberty to
assail the present judgment passed by this Court by preferring an appeal
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the assistance of High Court
Legal Services Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services
Committee.
30. Let a certified copy of this order alongwith the original record be
transmitted to trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information
and action, if any.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
JUDGE
Amit
AMIT
KUMAR
DUBEY
AMIT KUMAR
DUBEY
Date: 2026.01.07
20:22:47 +0530
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review