Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A.T (MV) 555 of 2025
With
IA No.: CAN/2/2025
Ranjit Shil @ Ranjit Sill & Ors.
VERSUS
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.
For the appellants/claimants:
For
the
Companies:
respondent/Insurance
Mr. Jayanta Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Sandip Bandyopadhyay, Adv.
Ms. Ruxmini Basu Roy, Adv.
Ms. Gopa Das Mukherjee, Adv.
Last Heard on: February 11, 2026
Judgment on: February 27, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury,J:
The appellant before this Court was a claimant in a case under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 and is aggrieved by the Judgment and
Award dated 14-02-2025 passed by Learned Additional District Judge 3rd Court
Krishnanagar Nadia in MAC case No. 124 of 2016.
The case of the claimants/appellants before the Learned Trial Court may
be summed up thus;
On 19-01-2016 at about 00.30 hours while the deceased the pillion rider
of a motorcycle bearing No. WB-52E/2503 was going to Ranaghat from
Santipur through NH-34 near Habibpur Kalabagan a truck bearing No-WB57/7814 coming from Krishnanagar side running at a very high and excessive
speed and proceeding towards Kolkata side i.e. same direction lost control and
dashed behind the said motorcycle at that time in the trickling of an eye
another vehicle bearing No. WB-23B/1705 heavy truck coming from opposite
direction running also at a very high and excessive speed lost control and
dashed behind the said motorcycle also the stationary truck as a result of
which motorcyclist and the pillion rider both of them were thrown off the road
and rolled over by the wheels of the said heavy truck bearing No. WB23B/1705 resulting in grievous injuries on their person. They were taken to
Ranaghat S.D. Hospital where the MO. declared both of them as dead. The
autopsy over the dead body was held at that hospital on 19-01-16 bearing PM.
No. 29/16 dt. 19.01.16 in connection with Ranaghat PS. U/D. Case No.
12/2016 dt. 19-01-16.
The accident was the result of rash and negligent driving of the vehicle
trucks. There was no negligence on the part of the deceased pillion rider as well
as the motorcyclist who was driving motorcycle at a slow moderate speed and
very cautiously.
The deceased was the skilled mechanic of 87 power looms of Village
Aistala Ranaghat and its surrounding areas. He used to earn Rs. 3,000/- per
month from each power loom for maintaining smoothly running condition.
The offending vehicle bearing No. WB-57A/7814 truck at first dashed
behind the motorcycle but at the time of lodging FIR before Ranaghat P.S.
Nadia the informant due to inadvertence mentioned the vehicle bearing No.
WB-57B/7814 but Ranaghat Police during investigation seized the offending
vehicle WB-57A/7814 instead of FIR mentioned vehicle along with its all
connected papers arrested the driver of the offending vehicle and after
completion of investigation finally submitted charge sheet against the drivers of
both the vehicles trucks.
Pursuant to filing of this case notice was issued upon the opposite
parties. The opposite parties vehicle owners did not contest the case. Opposite
parties The New India Assurance Company Ltd. contested the case by filing
written statement ISSUES were framed and evidence was adduced. By
Judgment and Award dated 14th day of February 2025 the Learned Trial Judge
disposed the claim case by observing and directing as follows:
‘Hence it is ORDERED that the instant application registered as MAC
Case No. 124 of 2016 u/s-166 of the MVAct 1988 is allowed on contest against
the OP No-2 without cost.
The OP/Insurance Companies Ltd. i.e. New India Assurance Company
Ltd. and the Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd. directed to pay Rs.
1,92,500/-
each.
(i.e.
in
equal
proportion
of
Rs.
3,85,000/-)
to
claimants/petitioners.
The New India Assurance Company Ltd shall pay an amount of Rs.
48,125/- each to the petitioners/claimants namely 1) Ranjit Sill 2) Manika
Sheal 3) Minor Avijit Sill @ Seal, 4) Minor Konika sill. Similarly The Reliance
General Insurance Company Ltd. shall pay an amount of Rs. 48,125/- each to
all the above named petitioners/claimants vide four separate cheques.
The amount of compensation shall be paid by both the OP/Insurance
Companies Ltd. within two months from this day along with interest @6% per
annum from the date of filing of this instant application till the realization of
the award. However O.P./Insurance Companies Ltd. are exempted from paying
the interest for the period between 25-04-2020 to 31/12/2021 due to Covid-19
Pandemic. In respect of the minor claimants i.e. the petitioner No-3 namely
Avijit Sill @ Seal and Petitioner no. 4 Kanika Sill the petitioner no. 1 Ranjit Sill
who is representing the minor claimants as next friend/guardian being the
eldest son/guardian being the eldest son of the deceased shall collect the
cheques in respect of the compensation, awarded to the minor claimants and
shall deposit the same in the name of the minor claimants in a nationalized
Bank or Post Office in a fixed deposit within 15 days from receipt of the
cheques
till
the
minors/claimants
attains
majority
and
shall
submit
documents in respect of such deposits in the name of minor claimants and
thereafter the cheque issued in the name of petitioner no-1 shall be
issued/given to him.
The petitioners/claimants are entitled to receive the cheque on payment
of deficit Court fees as per rules if not already paid.’
The appellants/claimants being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
passed by the Learned Trial Judge has come up with the instant application.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellants and Learned Advocate for the
respondent no. 1 and 2 perused the materials on record.
Learned Advocate for the appellants submits that the appellant was a
skilled mechanic and he was engaged by employers of 87 different power
looms. Thus the victim cannot earn less than Rs. 26,000/- Per month.
Learned Advocate for the appellant further submits that the claimants
deposed that age of the victim was 50 years which ought to have been
considered but the Learned Trial Judge considered the age in post mortem
report which is 60 years. Learned Advocate also submits that the interest on
compensation awarded is low.
Learned Advocate for the respondent no-1 and 2 Insurance Companies
submits that the claimants did not produce any document to support the
income of the victim thus the Learned Trial Judge rightly proceeded to assess
compensation on the basis of notional income of Rs. 5,000/- Learned Advocate
further submits that the claimants could not produce any documents with
regard to age of victim thus the Learned Trial Court rightly proceeded on the
basis of the age stated in Post Mortem Report. Learned Advocate also submits
that the compensation awarded is just and should not be interfered with.
As the ground of challenge in this appeal is with regard to the quantum
of compensation awarded by the Learned Trial Court it is necessary to consider
the evidence adduced by the claimants with regard to the income of victim.
It is an admitted position that no documents were furnished with regard
to the income of the victim. Thus it is necessary to consider the occupation in
which the victim was engaged. It appears from claim petition that the
claimants have stated that the victim was skilled mechanic of the power looms.
It is further stated that Dilip Ghosh and other power loom proprietors received
his services. The specific statement of P.W. 1 with regard to occupation cannot
be disbelieved. Although there was no fixed salary but considering the fact that
the victim from the District of Hooghly came to Nadia to earn his livelihood and
run his family at Hooghly it is not unnatural to earn atleast Rs. 12,000/- per
month. Thus Rs. 12,000/- per month should be the notional income on which
compensation should be computed. However with regard to the use of
multiplier regarding age as there was no document regarding proof of age
Learned Trial Judge had to consider age as per post mortem report and apply
the multiplier, which should not be interfered with.
Now if the monthly notional income is Rs. 12,000/- annual income
comes to Rs. 1,40,000/-. 1/4th should be deducted on account of personal
expense. Thus upon deducting personal expenses annual dependency loss
comes to Rs. 1,08,000/-. Multiplier of 7 applied to annual dependency loss the
total dependency loss comes to Rs. 7,56,000/-. Further the claimants are
entitled to get Rs. 30,000/- on account to funeral expenses and loss of estate.
Thus Rs. 7,86,000/- is the total compensation by arithmetical calculation
which the appellants are entitled to from the Respondent no-1 and 2.
Insurance Companies. However this Court is of the view that compensation of
Rs. 800,000/- is just and reasonable. Thus the appellants/claimants are
entitled to compensation of Rs. 4 lakh each from New India Assurance
Company Limited and Reliance General Insurance Company Limited along with
interest @6% p.a. from the date of filing claim case till today.
Hence FMAT-(MV) 555 of 2025 stands disposed. The Judgment and
Award dated 14th February 2025 passed by Learned Additional District Judge
3rd
Court
Krishnanagar
Nadia
is
modified
to
the
extent
that
the
Appellants/claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs. 400,000/- each from
respondent no-1 and 2. New India Assurance Company Limited and Reliance
General Insurance Company Ltd. respectively along with interest @6% p.a.
from date of filing claim case till today. Such payments shall be made by
depositing the same before the Registrar General High Court Calcutta within 8
weeks from the date of communication of this Order. In the event amount
awarded by Learned Trial Court is already deposited balance amount shall be
deposited.
The claimants/appellants are entitled to withdraw the amount upon
compliance of necessary formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review