Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 116 of 2017
Date of Decision: 09.08.2023
Shri. Ramnidawan Suchiang
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Dey, Adv.
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA. for R 1-4.
Mr. K.Ch. Gautam, Adv.
Ms. C.B. Sawian, Adv. for R 5, 6 & 9.
None for R 7 & 8.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
An advertisement appeared on 15.05.2016 in a Local Newspaper,
„Mawphor‟ issued by the Secretary, Saba Non-Government L.P. School,
West Jaintia Hills District indicating that a vacant post of Assistant Teacher
was required to be filled-up and for which, qualified applicants fulfilling
NCTE norms can apply for the same, the last date for receipt of such
applications being 27.05.2016 and the date of Interview being fixed on
30.05.2016.
2.
The petitioner herein accordingly applied for the same, claiming
to be qualified in all respects to be considered for such appointment. On
30.05.2016, the personal interview was held at the office of the respondent
No. 5, the Secretary of the School Managing Committee. According to the
petitioner, six candidates appeared during the said personal interview and
on 03.06.2016, the result of the said interview was published with the
petitioner securing the first position scoring 69 marks out of 100. One
Chanki Sumer who scored 68 marks was placed at Sl. No. 2 and kept in the
Waiting List. The respondent No. 9, who also appeared in the said
interview, was placed at serial number 4 in the merit list.
3.
The Managing Committee, vide communication dated 11.06.2016
addressed to the respondent No. 4, the Sub-Divisional School Education
Officer, Jowai, West Jaintia Hills has sought approval for the appointment
of the petitioner on the basis of the result of the selection process. Copy of
such letter is annexed as Annexure-10 of this petition. The respondent No.
7, the Headman of the Dorbar Shnong, Saba Village has also written to the
respondent No. 4 on 02.02.2017 requesting him to appoint the petitioner at
the earliest.
4.
The respondents No. 5 and 6 vide letter dated 16.03.2017, has
informed the respondent No. 9 that she has been declared as the successful
candidate for the post of Assistant Teacher in the said Saba NonGovernment L.P. School and was accordingly issued the appointment letter.
5.
Terming the said appointment of the respondent No. 9 as highly
illegal, arbitrary, tainted by malafide or oblique consideration and therefore
not fair, the petitioner has approached this Court by way of this instant writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a
writ of mandamus by declaring the said appointment letter dated
16.03.2017 as illegal and unconstitutional and therefore liable to be
quashed.
6.
Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner submitting that the
petitioner is able to make out a case of gross violation of natural justice,
arbitrariness and blatant irregularity, thereby depriving him of his right to
be appointed as an Assistant Teacher of the said Saba Non-Government
L.P. School, has referred to the entire process to say that till the stage where
the Managing Committee on being satisfied that the petitioner has secured
the first position in the merit list on the basis of the interview conducted, he
was accordingly recommended to be appointed.
7.
However, as pointed out, without any rhyme or reason, the
respondent/Managing Committee has issued the impugned letter dated
16.03.2017 appointing the respondent No. 9 who, apparently stood at serial
No. 4 in the select list in order of merit and was not even placed in the
Waiting List as far as the selection process and the result of the interview
dated 03.06.2016 is concerned.
8.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that without the
earlier selection process being scrapped or cancelled and, if it is done so,
without informing the petitioner of the same, the respondent/Managing
Committee, as has been pleaded in their affidavit-in-opposition has taken
the decision to reconduct the interview on 09.12.2016, for which
advertisement was floated on 07.12.2016 and the respondent No. 9 was
found qualified for the said post. Therefore, there is gross violation of
natural justice as far as the petitioner is concerned.
9.
The
learned
counsel
has
also
submitted
that
the
respondent/Managing Committee in their affidavit-in-opposition has stated
that in the interview wherein the petitioner and five others took part, that is,
on 30.05.2016, there were present some members of an NGO called the
Jaintia National Union (JNU) who, after the interview had allegedly taken
the interview scoresheet with them and have not returned the same to the
Managing Committee in spite of request made, even in writing. This
contention cannot be accepted as there is no evidence of any members of
such Organisation being present on the said date and even, if such an
incident had happened, it would be incumbent upon the Managing
Committee to take necessary steps even to the filing of an FIR in this
regard, but not having done so, therefore, the statement made in this regard
cannot be accepted.
10.
Again, to say that the said scoresheet was surreptitiously taken
away by the members of the said Organisation cannot be accepted, submits
the learned counsel as the Managing Committee vide letter dated
11.06.2016 addressed to the respondent No. 4 has sought for approval to the
appointment of the petitioner and in such communication, the scoresheet
was also annexed thereto.
11.
In view of the submission made, the learned counsel for the
petitioner has made a prayer before this Court that the second selection
process by which the respondent No. 9 was declared selected and duly
appointed, should be scrapped and the selection process wherewith the
petitioner was declared successful should be retained and appointment may
be accorded to the petitioner.
12.
Ms. C.B. Sawian, learned counsel for the respondent No. 5 and
6/School Managing Committee and also for the respondent No. 9 has
submitted that there is no denying the fact that the petitioner along with five
other candidates appeared for the interview conducted on 30.05.2016
pursuant to the selection process on the basis of the advertisement dated
15.05.2016.
13.
The learned counsel has however submitted that when the
interview was conducted by the School Managing Committee, some
members of the JNU and the Sordar/Headman of the village were also part
of the interview board. It is reiterated that after the interview was
conducted, the members of the JNU took the interview sheet with them and
as such, the result of the said interview could not be declared. The
Managing Committee has also addressed a letter dated 30.09.2016 to the
Secretary of the JNU requesting that the said interview sheet be handed
over to the Managing Committee, but it was not done so.
14.
It is further submitted that faced with this situation, the Managing
Committee in its meeting held on 23.11.2016 at the residence of the Village
Secretary took a decision to reconduct the interview on 09.12.2016 for
which an advertisement dated 07.12.2016 was issued. In the said
advertisement, application was invited from applicants having 45% marks
in HSSLC with D.El.Ed as the required qualification.
15.
The decision to reconduct the interview was also intimated to the
respondent No. 4 vide letter No. SBNGLPS/INTR/2016-17/3 dated
01.12.2016. Accordingly, the interview was conducted on 09.12.2016 in
which the respondent No. 9 was found qualified for the said post. On
12.12.2016, the School Managing Committee met in a meeting and decided
to approve the name of the respondent No. 9, for which a letter of even date
was sent to the respondent No. 4 seeking approval of such recommendation.
The
respondent
No.
on
14.03.2017
vide
letter
No.
SDSEO/PRY/NGS/APPV-69/2016-17/13792 dated 14.03.2017 has given
the necessary approval for appointment of the respondent No. 9 as Assistant
Teacher in the said Saba Non-Government L.P. School. The Managing
Committee in response to such approval has issued the appointment letter
dated 16.03.2017.
16.
On the contention of the petitioner that the respondent/School
Managing Committee has recommended the name of the petitioner for
appointment to the said post, the learned counsel has submitted that the
respondent/School Managing Committee was forced by the respondent No.
7 along with members of the JNU to forward the said letter to the
respondent No. 4. However, the learned counsel has submitted that a
facsimile of the said letter dated 11.06.2016 would show that it is a
prepared format with the name of the petitioner being noted by hand.
17.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the respondent No. 9
in her affidavit-in-opposition has contended that the School Managing
Committee had never declared the result of the interview conducted on
30.05.2016 and as such, the process for issuance of a fresh advertisement on
07.12.2016 and the consequent interview held on 09.12.2016, the said
respondent being called for the same and on being declared successful, the
receipt of the appointment letter issued by the School Managing Committee
cannot be doubted by the said respondent No. 9. The fact that the result of
the first round of interview conducted on 30.05.2016 was never declared
was also the stand of the respondent/School Managing Committee.
18.
The learned counsel has again stressed on the fact that the
respondent No. 9 was appointed on the basis of a fresh advertisement issued
and after proper interview was conducted and further, since her name was
recommended and approved by the competent authority, that is, the
respondent No. 4, therefore, there is no illegality or arbitrariness in the
process. The same may not be disturbed by this Court.
19.
It is further submitted that the respondent No. 9 has been
functioning in the post for the last six years or so and since the petitioner
has not been able to convince this Court for stay of such appointment, at
this juncture, the respondent No. 9 has acquired a legal right to function in
the said post. In this regard, the judgment dated 08.09.2022 passed by this
Court in the Division Bench in the case of Pynskhemlang Nongrang vs. The
Directorate of Soil and Water Conservation & Ors. in WA No. 26/2022 was
referred to, in support of this contention.
20.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing on behalf of the
respondents No. 1-4, particularly for respondents No. 2 and 4 respectively
has submitted that para 5 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by these
respondents dated 16.08.2019 would be relevant to the issue before this
Court.
21.
The learned GA has submitted that as far as the competent
authority is concerned, firstly, the said letter dated 11.06.2016 said to be the
prayer made by the respondent/School Managing Committee for approval
of the appointment of the petitioner herein, the same has never been
received by the office of the respondent No. 4. The respondent No. 4 has,
however, received a letter dated 14.12.2016 issued by the Headman of Saba
Dorbar Shnong with a request for approval for appointment of the petitioner
to the said post. Another letter dated 12.12.2016 issued by the
respondent/School Managing Committee was also received by the
respondent No. 4 wherein approval was sought for appointment of the
respondent No. 9 herein as an Assistant Teacher of the said Saba NonGovernment L.P. School.
22.
The respondent No. 4 has then addressed a letter dated
19.01.2017 to the respondent/School Managing Committee mentioning the
two proposals that was received by the respondent No. 4 to which the
School Managing Committee vide letter dated 03.02.2017, has clarified that
the only valid proposal is with regard to the proposal for appointment of
respondent No. 9 and the other proposal is to be treated as cancelled. The
learned GA has submitted that it was on this basis that the approval by the
respondent No. 4 to the appointment of the respondent No. 9 was accorded.
23.
This Court has taken into account pleadings of the parties as well
as the submission made. At the outset, however, it may be recorded that the
respondents No. 7 and 8 respectively have failed to join proceedings herein
and accordingly, the matter has proceeded exparte against them.
24.
Facts as enumerated above, need not be repeated except to
emphasise a point. The selection process initiated in the first instance got
underway with the issuance of the advertisement dated 15.05.2016, wherein
six applicants were found to be fit for the interview and were accordingly,
called for the same on 30.05.2016.
25.
The petitioner has contended that on the basis of the result of the
said interview published on 03.06.2016, copy of which is annexed as
Annexure-9 in this petition, he was shown to figure at serial No. 1 scoring
69 out of 100 marks with the remark that he is qualified. However, this
result sheet was disputed by the respondent/School Managing Committee
when it was contended that no results have been declared as regard the
interview dated 30.05.2016. This is certainly a dispute of facts which this
Court may not have the competency to confirm since the relevant records
have not been produced by the School Managing Committee. Questions
such as how the said copy of the result (Annexure-9) came to be in his
possession, whether the same has been published in the newspaper or in the
school‟s notice board or sent individually by post to all the candidates, have
not been fully answered herein.
26.
Be that as it may, it is well settled that a successful candidate in an
interview or an examination for employment or for filling up vacant post(s)
cannot demand to be appointed, even, if his or her name appears in the
select list, if such appointment requires approval of a competent authority
and in the absence thereof, it cannot be said that appointment to such
post(s) is an automatic progression. The petitioner, therefore, cannot claim
or demand to be appointed on the basis of the purported result of the said
interview.
27.
The petitioner has also referred to a letter dated 11.06.2016 said to
have been issued by the Chairman and Secretary of the School Managing
Committee addressed to the respondent No. 4/Sub-Divisional School
Education Officer, wherein by such letter, a prayer was made for approval
of the petitioner as an Assistant Teacher in the said school. This letter was
denied to have been ever received by the respondent No. 4. Again, this is
also a dispute of facts. In any case, since it is incumbent upon the SubDivisional School Education Officer to finally accord approval before
appointment is made to the post of an Assistant Teacher in the NonGovernment L.P. School, if the same has not been done, such successful
candidate(s) even, if his/her name appears in the select list, appointment
cannot be demanded.
28.
Now, coming to the appointment of the respondent No. 9, from
whatever is available on record, the pleadings of the parties, particularly
that of respondent/School Managing Committee would show that there was
a resolution by the school authorities to reconduct the interview on
09.12.2016. This information was sent to the respondent No. 4 on
01.12.2016. Therefore, this would, in effect, mean that the earlier selection
process has been cancelled. It is not incumbent upon the concerned
authorities to inform the petitioner of such cancellation.
29.
A fresh advertisement was accordingly floated on 07.12.2016 in
one Local Daily Newspaper „Mawphor‟. There is nothing on record to show
as to how many applicants have applied for the said post in response to the
said advertisement dated 07.12.2016, however, pursuant to the same, the
interview was conducted on 09.12.2016 and the score sheet of the said
interview, copy of which was annexed with the affidavit-in-opposition filed
by the respondent/School Managing Committee has indicated that only the
respondent No. 9 has appeared for the said test and had scored 63 marks for
which she was placed first in the list. Apparently, no other candidates have
appeared for the said interview, the reason may be that only one candidate
has applied for the said post.
30.
At this stage, what could be discerned is that the very fact that the
advertisement was issued in only one newspaper and that too giving only
one day as an opportunity to the applicants to apply with the date of
interview being fixed the next day thereafter speaks volume about the
intention of the school authority and arbitrariness and malafide writ large on
the face of such proceedings, since the scope to elicit a number of
applications from qualified aspirants has been literally shut because of
fixation of such a narrow timeframe.
31.
It is therefore apparent that there was no fair procedure adopted
by the school authorities in this regard since procedural fairness is a
safeguard against any arbitrary or malafide action which would in any case
invite judicial scrutiny, keeping in mind the provision of Article 14 and 16
of our Constitution.
32.
However, in the scenario of the case of the parties herein, the
respondent No. 9 cannot be made to suffer for any irregular or illegal action
by the school authority, vis-à-vis the said advertisement dated 07.12.2016
and the subsequent process by which she was declared successful and
eventually appointed to the said post, albeit, on a temporary basis, since the
selection process does not appear to be illegal, but as has been observed
was highly irregular.
33.
As has been submitted, it is now almost more than six years down
the line since that the respondent No. 9 was appointed, there being no stay
of her appointment, she is accordingly entitled to equitable relief.
34.
The authority cited by the respondent/School Managing
Committee, that is, the case of Pynskhemlang Nongrang (supra), would
indeed be relevant to the facts and circumstances of this case, particularly as
regard the appointment of the respondent No. 9. The relevant portion of
such judgment is reproduced herein below as:
“26. …However, once the appointments are firmed up and the
appointees are in place for several months, the Court is loath
to throw out the appointees. …However much it appears that
the private respondents may have been unfairly selected, yet
the private respondents have been occupying the position for
some 16 or more months and the appellant herein did not
enjoy any interim order since the inception of the writ
petition….”
35.
In view of the observations made hereinabove, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the petitioner cannot make out a case for
appointment to the said post of Assistant Teacher, primarily on the ground
that there is no approval for his appointment by the competent authority.
36.
The appointment of the respondent No. 9 to the said post, at this
juncture, cannot be upset.
37.
This petition is therefore devoid of merit, the same is accordingly
dismissed.
38.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
09.08.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review