Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.03.16
17:47:51
+0530
2026:CGHC:12558-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WA No. 752 of 2024
Ramgulam Singh Thakur S/o Late Shri Gangu Singh Thakur, Aged
About 74 Years R/o Danteshwari Chowk, Raipur, Raipur Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary General Administration
Department Government of Chhattisgarh P.S. And Post Rakhi, New
Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - The Collector And District Magistrate Raipur, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
: Mr. Manoj Kumar Dubey, Advocate
For State/Respondents
: Mr. Shashank Thakur, Additional Advocate
General
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
16.03.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Manoj Kumar Dubey, learned counsel for the appellant
as well as Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional Advocate
General appearing for the State/respondents.
2.
The present intra Court appeal has been filed against the order
dated 30.08.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in WPC
No.1046/2015, whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant/writ
petitioner has been dismissed.
3.
In the present writ appeal, the appellant has sought setting aside
of the impugned order dated 30.08.2024 passed by the learned
Single Judge of this Court in WPC No.1046/2015 and has further
prayed for a direction to the respondents to release the Samman
Nidhi to the petitioner from the same date on which it was
extended to other beneficiaries, along with interest @ 12% per
annum till the date of actual payment; and in the alternative, to
declare the expression “Rajnaitik ya Samajik Karno Se Niruddha
Byakti” as ultra vires in the interest of justice.
4.
The brief facts projected before the learned Single Judge were
that the appellant/writ petitioner claims himself to be a sociopolitical worker who was actively involved in various public
movements. At the relevant time, he was a student of Government
Hemraj Laxmichand Arts & Commerce College, Bagbahra, District
Mahasamund, and had also been elected as the President of the
Student Union of the said college. It was stated that in the year
1975, during a Kisan Movement organized against the levy policy
of the State Government, the appellant/writ petitioner participated
in the said agitation and was arrested along with several leaders
of the area.
5.
Thereafter, upon the declaration of Emergency by the Central
Government on 25.06.1975, several social workers, political
leaders, trade union leaders and student leaders were detained,
and in that connection the appellant/writ petitioner was also
arrested and lodged in Central Jail, Raipur along with other social
and political workers from the Chhattisgarh region.
6.
It was further case of the appellant/writ petitioner that he remained
under detention from 31.08.1975 to 10.01.1977. Subsequently,
the State Government framed the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash
Narayan (MISA/D.I.R. Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Niruddha
Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, notified on 05.08.2008, for
providing financial assistance to those social and political persons
of the Chhattisgarh region who were detained under the
provisions of MISA/DIR during the period from 25.06.1975 to
31.03.1977. Claiming entitlement under the said Rules, the
appellant/writ
petitioner
submitted
an
application
dated
24.03.2009 before respondent No.2 – Collector, Raipur seeking
grant of Samman Nidhi. However, the said application came to be
rejected by the Collector vide communication dated 22.05.2010
on the basis of a report of the Superintendent of Police, Raipur
dated 09.12.2009 indicating that several criminal cases were
registered against the appellant/writ petitioner, and therefore he
was not entitled to the benefit of the Samman Nidhi under Rule 6
of the Notification dated 05.08.2008.
7.
Being aggrieved, the appellant/writ petitioner preferred an appeal
before the State Government challenging the communication
dated 22.05.2010, but the same was also rejected. Feeling
aggrieved, the appellant/writ petitioner preferred the writ petition
bearing WPC No.1046/2015 before the learned Single Judge,
which was dismissed vide order dated 30.08.2024.
8.
Calling in question the legality and propriety of the order dated
30.08.2024, the appellant/writ petitioner has approached this
Court by filing the present appeal.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant/writ petitioner submits that the
impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge is arbitrary,
illegal and contrary to the settled principles of law applicable to
the facts of the present case. It is contended that the learned
Single Judge failed to appreciate that under Section 3 of the
Maintenance of Internal Security Act, 1971 (MISA), there is no
reference to detention on the basis of “Rajnaitik ya Samajik Karno
Se Niruddha Vyakti”. According to the learned counsel, the
detention under MISA was ordered under Section 3(1)(a)(ii) of the
Act for reasons relating to security of the State or maintenance of
public order, and therefore the introduction of the expression
“Rajnaitik ya Samajik Karno Se Niruddha Vyakti” in the Rules of
2008 is inconsistent with the provisions of the parent statute.
10.
It is further submitted that the words “Rajnaitik ya Samajik Karno
Se Niruddha Vyakti” incorporated in Section 2(g) of the
Notification dated 05.08.2008 are ultra vires the provisions of the
Maintenance of Internal Security Act, 1971, as the said Act does
not contemplate detention on such grounds. Learned counsel
contends that all persons who were detained during the period
from 25.06.1975 to 31.03.1977 under the provisions of MISA/DIR
are entitled to the benefit of Samman Nidhi under the Lok Nayak
Jai Prakash Narayan Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, and therefore
the appellant/writ petitioner cannot be singled out and denied the
benefit on the basis of an interpretation which is not supported by
the parent legislation.
11.
Learned counsel also submits that the respondents have adopted
a pick-and-choose approach while granting the benefit of
Samman Nidhi, thereby acting in a biased and arbitrary manner. It
is contended that at the time of his detention under MISA, the
appellant/writ petitioner was a student leader actively participating
in various student and farmers’ movements in the Chhattisgarh
region, and his detention during the period of Emergency is
undisputed. Therefore, he is equally entitled to the Lok Nayak Jai
Prakash Narayan Samman Nidhi which has been extended to
other similarly situated MISA detainees in the State.
12.
It is lastly submitted that the learned Single Judge has erred in
relying upon the decision of the Committee constituted under the
Rules of 2008, which had rejected the claim of the appellant/writ
petitioner on the ground that several criminal cases were
registered against him. Learned counsel points out that the cases
referred to by the Committee pertain to the period between
01.05.1977 and 09.07.1982 and that presently no criminal case is
pending against the appellant/writ petitioner, nor has any
conviction been recorded against him by any competent court of
law. Therefore, denial of the benefit of Samman Nidhi to the
appellant/writ petitioner on such grounds is wholly unjustified and
unsustainable in law.
13.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the State
supports the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge
and submits that the writ petition filed by the appellant was rightly
dismissed. It is contended that the appellant had sought grant of
Samman Nidhi under the provisions of the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash
Narayan (MISA/DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Nirudhdha
Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, however his claim was found
to be not in conformity with the requirements of the said Rules. He
further submits that as per Rule 6 of the Rules, 2008, the benefit
of Samman Nidhi is to be extended only to those persons who
were detained under the provisions of MISA/DIR purely for
political or social reasons and who do not have any criminal
antecedents or involvement in anti-social activities. It is submitted
that in compliance with the directions of the Court, the State has
placed on record the relevant information obtained from the
concerned police authorities which indicates that several criminal
cases were registered against the appellant during the period
from 1974 to 1986 at different police stations in the State. It is
therefore contended that in view of the criminal antecedents
attributed to the appellant, he does not satisfy the eligibility criteria
prescribed under the Rules, 2008. On that basis, the competent
authority rejected his claim for Samman Nidhi, and the learned
Single Judge, upon consideration of the material placed on
record, has rightly declined to interfere with the said decision.
14.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned order as well as materials available on record.
15.
After appreciating the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties as also the materials on record, learned Single Judge has
passed the impugned order in following terms:“9. From perusal of the record, the petitioner
is questioning Annexure P/2 dated 22.05.2010
and order dated 06.05.2015. The order of
22.05.2010 is an communication of the
Collector to the notice dated 10.05.2010
which was issued by the Advocate of the
petitioner. In fact the same is not an order,
only intimation has been provided to the
petitioner’s counsel about the fact that the
claim of the petitioner was not sustainable as
there
are
several
criminal
cases
were
registered against the petitioner, in fact the
decision of the committee constituted under
Rules 2008 i.e. dated 17.03.2011/30.03.2011,
by which the committee has decided that
against the petitioner several criminal cases
were registered and hence his application is
rejected as he is not entitled for the Lok
Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan (MISA/D.I.R.
Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Nirudha
Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008. The
petitioner has not challenged the decision of
the Committee constituted under Rules 2008
and only the communication of the Collector
has been challenged by the petitioner. In
absence of challenge to the decision of the
Committee and the rejection of application,
the writ petition itself is not maintainable and
even as there are several criminal cases were
pending against the petitioner during the
period of emergency i.e. 25.06.1975 to
31.05.1977. The application of the petitioner
has rightly been rejected by the Committee
Constituted under Rules 2008 and the writ
petition filed by the petitioner is liable to be
and is hereby dismissed.”
16.
From perusal of the record, it transpires that the Sub Divisional
Officer, Revenue, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) has filed his
personal affidavit, relevant portion of which, reads as under :“2. That, the present writ appeal has been filed
by the appellant against the order dated
30/08/2024 passed by the Hon'ble Single
Bench in WPC No. 1046/2015 by which the writ
petition filed by the appellant to release the
Samman Nidhi to him under the provisions of
the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan (MISA /
DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Nirudhdha
Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, was
dismissed.
3. That, the matter was taken up by the Hon'ble
Court for hearing on 14/11/2024 and upon the
request being made by the State, the Hon'ble
Court was pleased to direct the State to file
counter affidavit showing that 25 cases which
have been referred in the case for which the
petitioner has been denied the benefit under
provision of Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan
(MISA /DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se
Nirudhdha Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008
(hereinafter referred to as the Rules, 2008)
pertain to the year 1975 and were other than
the criminal activities than that of the benefit
which the petitioner claims.
4. That, in compliance of the order dated
14/11/2024 passed by the Hon'ble Court, the
deponent, having the highest regards and great
respect for the lawful authority of this Hon'ble
Court, respectfully submits as under :a. That, Rule 6 of the Rules, 2008 specifically
provides that the honour would be bestowed
only upon the persons who are arrested
under the MISA or D.I.R. law only for political
or social reasons and there should be no
separate offences or record of having been
engaged in criminal / anti social activities.
Rule 6 of the Rules further specifically
provides that the honour is to be bestowed
only on such persons who are not of criminal
disposition.
b. It is submitted that in the instant case, the
appellant states himself to be a MISA
detainee who was detained under Section
3(1)(A)
(2)
of
the
MISA
from
31/08/1975 to 10/01/1977. It is submitted that
against the petitioner, as many as 32 cases
of criminal and anti social nature are
registered at various Police Stations of State
of Chhattisgarh between the period from
1974 to 1986 and to demonstrate this fact,
copy of the chart alongwith the covering
letter of the Superintendent of Police, Raipur
is being filed herewith as Annexure A/1.
c. That, the deponent respectfully submits
that the information about the status of the
criminal
cases
registered
against
the
petitioner has been obtained Police, District
by
the
Superintendent
Superintendent
of
Mahasamund,
Police,
District
Balodabazar Bhatapara, Sr. Superintendent
of Police, District Raipur, Superintendent of
Police (Rail), District Raipur respectively and
in the information supplied by the aforesaid
authorities, it has been categorically reported
that the offences registered against the
petitioner is of criminal in nature and not of
political and social nature. To demonstrate
this fact, copies of the communications
received from the Superintendent of Police,
District
Mahasamund,
Police,
District
Superintendent
Balodabazar
of
Bhatapara,
Superintendent Sr. District Raipur, Police, of
Superintendent
of
Police
(Rail),
District
Raipur respectively are filed herewith as
Annexure A/2. Further it is submitted that as
of now the name of the petitioner is enlisted
in the list of current surveillance and to
demonstrate this, copy of the letter dated
14/08/2025 is filed herewith as Annexure A/3.
d. That, upon perusal of the aforesaid
records and police records, it appears that
not only the demure of the petitioner is of anti
social nature but he was arrayed as an
accused in many criminal offences also
which itself renders the petitioner ineligible
for being bestowed with the honour as per
the Rules, 2008.
5. That, the contents of this affidavit have been
drafted according to my instructions and the
contents thereof are true and correct to the
best of my personal knowledge and belief,
based on the official records.”
17.
A bare perusal of the affidavit filed by the Sub-Divisional Officer,
Revenue, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.), reveals that the present
writ appeal has been filed by the appellant against the order dated
30.08.2024 passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge in WPC No.
1046/2015, whereby the writ petition seeking release of the
Samman Nidhi under the provisions of the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash
Narayan (MISA/DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Niruddha
Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, was dismissed. It transpires
from the affidavit that pursuant to the directions of this Court dated
14.11.2024, the State has placed on record that Rule 6 of the
Rules, 2008, provides that the Samman Nidhi is to be conferred
only upon persons detained under MISA/DIR for purely political or
social reasons, without any separate offences or criminal record,
and who are not of criminal disposition.
18.
The affidavit further discloses that the appellant, who claims to be
a MISA detainee from 31.08.1975 to 10.01.1977 under Section
3(1)(A)(2) of MISA, is reported to have 32 criminal and anti-social
cases registered against him between 1974 and 1986 at various
police stations in Chhattisgarh, as evidenced by communications
from the Superintendent of Police of Raipur, Mahasamund,
Balodabazar Bhatapara, and Rail, Raipur (Annexures A/1 and
A/2). The affidavit also states that the appellant’s name is enlisted
in the current surveillance list (Annexure A/3), and upon review of
these records, it is evident that the appellant was involved in
activities of a criminal and anti-social nature, which, according to
the State, renders him ineligible for the honour under the Rules,
2008. The deponent has affirmed that the contents of the affidavit
are true and based on official records.
19.
By
filing
the
rejoinder-affidavit,
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant/writ petitioner submits that the reply filed by the
respondents fails to establish that the appellant is a person with
criminal antecedents or that his detention under MISA was on
account of any criminal activity. It is submitted that the so-called
25–32 criminal cases referred to by the respondents either did not
exist at the time of the appellant’s detention between 31.08.1975
and 10.01.1977 or, if filed later, the records pertaining to such
cases are missing, destroyed, or otherwise unavailable, as
evident from the correspondence placed on record from the
various police stations and courts (Annexures A/2–A/3, letters
dated 12.08.2025, 13.08.2025, 18.10.2017, 25.10.2017). He
further submits that the records show that no criminal proceedings
are currently pending against the appellant and no conviction has
been recorded, which demonstrates that the appellant’s detention
during the Emergency was purely under the provisions of MISA
for political or social reasons. It is, therefore, submitted that the
appellant satisfies all the criteria prescribed under Rule 6 of the
Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan (MISA/DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik
Karno Se Niruddha Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008, and is
entitled to the benefit of the Samman Nidhi. As such, he prays
that the writ appeal be allowed and respondents are directed to
release the Samman Nidhi to the appellant from the date on which
it was granted to other similarly situated MISA detainees, along
with interest for the delayed payment, and also award the costs of
the proceedings in favour of the appellant.
20.
It is an admitted fact that the appellant/writ petitioner was detained
under the provisions of the Maintenance of Internal Security Act,
1971 (MISA), specifically under Section 3(1)(A)(2), during the
period from 31.08.1975 to 10.01.1977. The appellant claims that
his detention was purely for political or social reasons arising out
of his active involvement in student and farmers’ movements and
other socio-political activities in the Chhattisgarh region during the
Emergency. The appellant also claims entitlement to the Samman
Nidhi under the provisions of the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan
(MISA/DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se Niruddha Vyakti)
Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008 (hereinafter referred to as the “Rules,
2008”).
21.
The State, however, has placed on record details of criminal and
anti-social cases allegedly registered against the appellant
between the years 1974 and 1986 at various police stations,
supported by communications from the Superintendents of Police
of Raipur, Mahasamund, Balodabazar Bhatapara, and Rail,
Raipur (Annexures A/1–A/3). These records indicate that certain
cases of criminal or anti-social nature are attributed to the
appellant, and that his name is currently enlisted in the
surveillance list maintained by the police. The Committee
constituted under Rule 2008, after considering the material placed
before it, concluded that the appellant did not satisfy the
conditions prescribed under Rule 6 of the Notification dated
05.08.2008, which requires that the Samman Nidhi be granted
only to persons detained under MISA/DIR purely for political or
social reasons and who do not have any criminal antecedents.
22.
While the appellant contends that the alleged criminal cases
either did not exist at the time of his detention or that the records
have since been destroyed, the Court notes that the eligibility for
Samman Nidhi under Rule 2008 is not determined solely by the
timing or availability of records but by the considered opinion of
the competent Committee regarding compliance with the statutory
criteria. The appellant has not challenged the decision of the
Committee
independently
communication
of
the
but
Collector,
has
only
which
is
assailed
the
essentially
an
administrative intimation. In the absence of a challenge to the
Committee’s decision, this Court cannot substitute its own opinion
for that of the statutory authority.
23.
The Court has also considered the appellant’s submissions
regarding the alleged arbitrary or biased conduct of the State in
selectively granting Samman Nidhi to other detainees. On
examination of the materials on record, there is no evidence to
indicate any mala fide or discriminatory conduct on the part of the
State or the Committee. The grant of Samman Nidhi is a matter of
statutory discretion exercised in accordance with Rule 6 of the
Notification dated 05.08.2008, and the Court finds no ground to
interfere with the considered decision of the competent authority.
24.
The appellant has further argued that the expression “Rajnaitik ya
Samajik Karno Se Niruddha Vyakti” in the Rules, 2008, is ultra
vires the provisions of MISA, 1971. While this Court expresses no
opinion on the vires of the Rules in abstract, it is noted that the
present writ appeal is primarily directed against the administrative
rejection of the appellant’s claim for Samman Nidhi. The
appellant’s contention regarding ultra vires does not, in the
present context, provide a sufficient basis for interfering with the
impugned order of the learned Single Judge.
25.
In conclusion, upon a careful evaluation of the facts, documents,
and submissions of the parties, it is evident that the learned
Single Judge has rightly dismissed the writ petition in WPC
No.1046/2015 dated 30.08.2024. The appellant has failed to
demonstrate any manifest illegality, error of law, or violation of
principles of natural justice in the decision of the competent
authority under the Rules, 2008. The appellant’s detention under
MISA, the subsequent proceedings, and the evaluation of
eligibility for Samman Nidhi by the Committee have been
considered in accordance with the applicable law, and no ground
exists to interfere with the impugned order.
26.
Accordingly, the writ appeal filed by the appellant is dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Head Note
Failure to satisfy the requirement of detention solely for political or
social reasons is fatal to a claim for Samman Nidhi under the Lok Nayak
Jai Prakash Narayan (MISA/DIR Rajnaitik Ya Samajik Karno Se
Niruddha Vyakti) Samman Nidhi Niyam, 2008.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review