Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 32 of 2018
Date of Decision: 25.05.2023
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Shri. Ramesh Chander & 10 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv.
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI. with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioners who are employees under the Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs are personnel of the Assam Rifles which
is a Central Para Military Force (CPMF) and now posted as Warrant
Officer (Draughtsman) have approached this Court with this instant
petition seeking exercise of the power under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
2.
Heard Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioners who
has submitted that the petitioners No. 1, 2, 5, 6, 9, 10 & 11 respectively,
joined service in the Assam Rifles as Riflemen/GD, their initial date of
appointment being as under: -
Sl. Petitioner
No No.
Name of Petitioner
Date of
appointment
Cadre
Shri Ramesh Chander
02.05.1989
Rifleman/GD
Shri Rama Sankar Singh 01.06.1997
Rifleman/GD
Shri Anil BR.
26.10.1996
Rifleman/GD
Shri Santhosh Kumar V. 26.10.1996
Rifleman/GD
Shri Satish
21.09.2001
Rifleman/GD
Shri Ashok Kumar
25.09.2001
Rifleman/GD
Shri Dhananjay Kumar 25.09.2001
Vishwakarma
Rifleman/GD
3.
The following petitioners were initially appointed as Havildar
Draughtsman on the date indicated against their names:Sl. Petitioner Name of
No No.
Petitioner
Date of
Cadre
appointment
Shri Roy P.A
19.11.1988
Havildar/Draughtsman
Shri K.
Gopakumar
01.12.1989
Havildar/Draughtsman
Shri Jinojith AP
25.03.1998
Havildar/Draughtsman
Shri Jayachandran 25.03.1998
K.
Havildar/Draughtsman
4.
On the issue of pay scale and rank status, similarly situated
Draughtsman including the writ petitioners, have approached the Hon‟ble
Gauhati High Court, Shillong Bench (as this Court then was), whereby
this Court vide judgment and order dated 10.08.2012 passed in WP(C)
No. 19(SH) of 2010 and judgment and order dated 09.04.2013 passed in
WP(C) No. 268(SH) of 2012 has directed the Union of India to redesignate the post occupied by the writ petitioners as Warrant
Officer/Assistant Sub-Inspector with a replacement scale of ₹ 40006000/-. Accordingly, the post of all the writ petitioners was re-designated
as Warrant Officer and placed in the relevant pre-revised scale of ₹ 40006000/- from the date of their respective initial appointment.
5.
The learned counsel has further submitted that since then the
petitioners herein have not been promoted and are stagnated in the same
post of Havildar Draughtsman/Warrant Officer for more than 20 years or
so without a single promotion during that period.
6.
The learned counsel has also pointed out that in the meantime,
the Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs, vide
communication No. II.13015/3/96/PF.IV dated 26.08.2003 (Annexure-3
to this petition), under the subject „Restructuring of Peace Establishment
of Assam Rifles‟, has conveyed to the Director General, Assam Rifles,
Shillong the creation of 917 posts for Support and Supervisory
Infrastructure, including the sanction of 13 posts of Naib Subedar
Draughtsman, 1 post of Subedar Draughtsman and 1 post of Subedar
Major Draughtsman. However, against these posts, the petitioners herein,
since they belonged to the cadre of Draughtsman, the authorities have not
taken any steps to consider promotion of the petitioners herein to the said
post, initially as Naib Subedar and consequently, for higher promotion
therefrom.
7.
The learned counsel has again submitted that the respondents in
their Affidavit-in-opposition, particularly at para 4 of the same has
admitted that the Government has sanctioned 13 posts of Naib Subedar
Draughtsman, 1 post of Subedar Draughtsman and 1 post of Subedar
Major Draughtsman. However, it is also the stand of the respondents that
the Ministry of Home Affairs and Department of Personnel and Training
was intimated as to the requirement of framing of the relevant
Recruitment Rules in this regard, for which till date, no response has been
received from the Ministry.
8.
In this regard, the order dated 20.05.2020 passed by this Court
in this case was referred to, in which this Court has remarked that even
after 17 years, it is unfortunate that the Draft Recruitment Rules have not
been finalized and accordingly, it was directed that the same be finalized
within a period of 8(eight) weeks. But yet again, the same has not
materialized, till a few weeks ago, when the respondents have claimed
that the relevant Recruitment Rules have been finalized and have
accordingly produced in Court copy of the “Assam Rifles Warrant
Officer(Draughtsman) Group „C‟ combatised post Recruitment Rules,
2022”. However, these rules are not at all relevant to the case of the
petitioners, submits the learned counsel as nothing has been specified as
regard the promotional avenues to the post of Naib Subedar, Subedar and
Subedar Major, etc.
9.
Stressing on the fact that promotion is an incident of service and
that it is the legitimate expectation of the petitioners to be promoted, the
learned counsel has submitted that it is well settled that in the matter of
consideration of promotion, a year wise panel of eligible personnel must
be prepared by a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) and clear
vacancies ought to be filled up accordingly which was not done so in the
case of the petitioners herein.
10.
Finally, the learned counsel has submitted that the present writ
petitioners are legally entitled to be promoted retrospectively with all
consequential benefits including seniority in the grade of Naib Subedar
(Draughtsman),
Subedar
(Draughtsman)
and
Subedar
Major
(Draughtsman).
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has cited a number of
judgments compiled in two volumes, to which only the relevant authority
will be cited in due course.
12.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI while resisting the contention
made by the petitioners have submitted that the petitioners were initially
appointed in Assam Rifles in trades other than Engineers such General
Duty, Carpenter and Sapper. They were later remustered in the trade of
Draughtsman and were promoted to the rank of Havildar. Again, by
virtue of the order dated 09.04.2013 passed by this Court in WP(C) No.
268(SH)/2012, they were re-designated as Warrant Officer w.e.f.
10.10.1997 in terms of the Office Memorandum No. 27011/103/97PF.1/56 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
13.
The learned DSGI has however admitted that as per the
Restructured Peace Establishment, 2003 for Assam Rifles, 13 posts of
Naib Subedar Draughtsman, 1 post of Subedar Draughtsman and 1 post
of Subedar Major Draughtsman were sanctioned, but the petitioners could
not be promoted to the next higher rank in absence of the relevant
Recruitment Rules which was not yet framed by the Ministry of Home
Affairs. In the absence of such Recruitment Rules, the petitioners have
been granted pay scale of Naib Subedar, Subedar and Subedar Major as
applicable to them under the Assured Career Progression (ACP) Scheme
and the Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) Scheme and as
such, there is no stagnation in service as they have not been deprived of
any career progression.
14.
It is further submitted that since the entry grade has to be at the
level of Warrant Officer, the authority concerned has felt it necessary to
frame the Recruitment Rules for direct recruitment in the cadre of
Warrant Officer (Draughtsman). Accordingly, the “Assam Rifles Warrant
Officer (Draughtsman) Group „C‟ combatised post Recruitment Rules,
2022” were framed as on 26.07.2022. It is again admitted that the
Recruitment Rules for promotion from the post of Warrant Officer to the
next higher post of Naib Subedar, etc. has not yet been framed.
15.
The final limb of argument advanced by the learned DSGI is
that since no Recruitment Rules have been framed, which rules would
govern the mode and manner of recruitment of the petitioners in the cadre
to consider for promotion not being a matter of right of the employees,
therefore, the petitioners herein have no right to demand for promotion
more so retrospectively.
16.
In support of the respondents‟ case, the case of Union of India v
Chandrika Thakur: Writ Appeal No 11/2019 was cited wherein a Division
Bench of this Court vide order dated 01.04.2021 in a similarly situated
case involving the issue of consideration of retrospective promotion as
per the recruitment rules passed in the year 2006 has observed as under:
“Admittedly and as observed hereinbefore, the relevant
rules, being the Assam Rifles Subedar Major Store Keeper
Technical (Engineers), Group „B‟ (Combatised) Recruitment
Rules, 2015, came into effect on and from 5 th December,
2015. In such a fact situation, we are unable to comprehend
as to how the learned Single Judge could have issued a
direction for giving the writ petitioner benefits as per the
rules w.e.f. 2006, when, in fact, the rules came into effect on
and from 5th December, 2015, only.”
“………since there were no rules in existence in the year,
2006. Inspite of non-existence of any applicable rule, the
leaned Single Judge has proceeded to issue such a direction
as reproduced hereinabove.”
17.
On the ratio of the case cited above, the learned DSGI has
submitted that same being squarely applicable to the case of the
petitioners herein, even if, the petitioners are entitled to promotion, the
same can be allowed to them prospectively, that too after the Recruitment
Rules in this respect have been framed.
18.
On the basis of what has been submitted by the learned counsels
for the rival parties, the admitted facts as related hereinabove need not be
reiterated. Suffice it to say that the status of the petitioners as Warrant
Officers (Draughtsman) in the service of the Assam Rifles is not in
question. That the next promotional posts in the hierarchy are that of Naib
Subedar, Subedar and Subedar Major respectively.
19.
The issue which arises now is whether the petitioners have
acquired the vested right to be promoted to the next higher post
retrospectively, their initial promotion not having been considered or
affected at the time when the said 13 posts of Naib Subedar was created
in the year 2003.
20.
In the context of the case of the petitioners, it may be proper to
examine the concept and principle of promotion. Promotion is one of the
methods of recruitment, apart from direct recruitment, deputation,
absorption, etc. It is also a method of recruitment from a feeder post to a
higher post or grade with a higher pay scale. It is therefore a legitimate
expectation for every employee in a department or service to be promoted
in due course during their career.
21.
Promotion can either be by seniority or by merit or in
accordance with the provisions of the Relevant Rules governing the
particular service. However, there are also other criteria to be fulfilled
before one is eligible for promotion to the next higher post. These
eligibility criteria are mostly enunciated in the Relevant Recruitment or
Service Rules.
22.
There are relevant notifications which prescribed that a post is
to be filled by promotion where the Recruitment Rules so provide. In
making promotions, it should be ensured that suitability of the candidates
for promotion is considered in an objective and impartial manner. For this
purpose, Departmental Promotion Committees (DPCs) should be formed
whenever a case arises for making promotion, etc.
23.
The fact situation in the case of the petitioners is that since the
time they were re-designated to the rank of Warrant Officer w.e.f.
10.10.1997, though the relevant order of the Court was made in the year
2013, they have remained in the same post without any promotion being
considered to them. The answer to this as given by the respondent
authorities is that the rules to this effect have not been able to be made
out in this regard.
24.
At the hearing, however, the learned DGSI has produced a copy
of the “Assam Rifles Warrant Officer (Draughtsman) Group „C‟
Combatised Post Recruitment Rules, 2022”, but has candidly admitted
that no specific rules as far as promotion of Warrant Officer
(Draughtsman) to the next higher posts of Naib Subedar, Subedar and
Subedar Major has been brought out, much less published.
25.
It is an accepted proposition of law that promotion is an incident
of service. However, it is also well settled that there is no vested right to
promotion, but there is a right to be considered for promotion and that too
in accordance with the relevant rules which existed at the time of
occurrence of the vacancies. In the case of the petitioners herein,
admittedly, when there are vacancies available, it is a legitimate
expectation for the petitioners to be considered for promotion.
26.
On the contention of the learned DSGI that the petitioners have
since been granted relief and benefits as per the ACP/MACP Scheme,
therefore, they cannot claim promotion at this stage, the accepted position
on this aspect is that an employee being benefited by the ACP/MACP
Scheme, that, however, would not be considered as a regular promotion.
In the case of Director, Directorate of Enforcement & Anr. v. K.
Sudheesh Kumar & Ors: (2022) 3 SCC 649, at para 9 of the same, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court has observed that:
“9. It is specifically observed and held by this Court in the
aforesaid decision in M.V. Mohanan Nair, (2020) 5 SCC 421
that MACP has nothing to do with the next promotional post
and what the employee would be entitled to would be the
immediate next higher grade pay in the hierarchy of the
recommended revised pay bands and grade pay as given in
the CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. As per Clause 8.1 of the
MACP Scheme “consequently upon the implementation of
sixth CPC‟s recommendations, grade pay of PB-2 and PB-3
would be Rs 5400. It specifically provides that the grade pay
of Rs 5400 in PB-2 and Rs 5400 in PB-3 shall be treated as
separate grade pays for the purpose of grant of upgradations
under the MACP Scheme”. Therefore, Respondents 1 & 2 as
PB-2 shall be entitled to the next grade pay of Rs 5400 as
per Clause 8.1 and as per Section 1, Part A of the First
Schedule of the CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. The High
Court has allowed the grade pay of Rs 6600 by considering
the next promotion post of Assistant Director i.e. Deputy
Director which carries a grade pay of Rs 6600. However, the
aforesaid interpretation would be contrary to the MACP
Scheme.”
27.
This proposition was asserted yet again in a recent case, wherein
vide order dated 25.04.2023, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of
Amresh Kumar Sinha & Ors. v. The State of Bihar & Ors: SLP (C)
Nos. 8219-8226 of 2019, at para 13, has held as follows:
“13. At the cost of repetition, it must be borne in mind that
the object of ACP is to avoid stagnation where no
promotional avenues are available. The grant of ACP is not
technically a grant of promotion but increase in the pay scale
to the next higher grade retaining the employee on the post
held by him. This is only to accord monetary benefit without
disturbing any seniority or actually effectuating promotion to
any higher post to avoid stagnation on a particular post or
pay scale for a very long period.”
28.
The only hindrance to the petitioner to assert their right to be
considered for promotion is the absence of the relevant Recruitment
Rules, specifically indicating the mode and manner of promotion in the
cadre.
29.
In this regard, the learned counsel for the petitioners has cited
the case of State of Mizoram & Anr. v. Mizoram Engineering Service
Association & Anr: (2004) 6 SCC 218, wherein extract of para 6 would
reveal the observation of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court when it is remarked
that:
“6. …Who is responsible for not framing the recruitment
rules? Are the members of the Engineering Service
responsible for it? The answer is clearly “No”. For the
failure of the State Government to frame recruitment rules
and bring Engineering Service within the frame work of
organised service, the engineers cannot be made to
suffer….”
30.
In the case of P.N. Premachandran v. State of Kerela & Ors:
(2004) 1 SCC 245, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dealing with a case of
grant of promotion, wherein the private respondents therein were
temporarily promoted as Assistant Directors (Soil Survey) since there
was a delay in convening the DPC and later, after the DPC was convened,
the said respondents were shown promoted retrospectively, on their
promotion being challenged before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, the
appeal was rejected. At para 7 of the said judgment, it was observed as
follows:
“7. It is not in dispute that the posts were to be filled up
by promotion. We fail to understand how the appellant,
keeping in view the facts and circumstances of this case,
could question the retrospective promotion granted to the
private respondents herein. It is not disputed that in view of
the administrative lapse, the Departmental Promotion
Committee did not hold a sitting from 1964 to 1980. The
respondents cannot suffer owing to such administrative lapse
on the part of the State of Kerala for no fault on their part. It
is also not disputed, that in ordinary course they were
entitled to be promoted to the post of Assistant Director, in
the event, a Departmental Promotion Committee had been
constituted in due time. In that view of the matter, it must be
held that the State of Kerala took a conscious decision to the
effect that those who have been acting in a higher post for a
long time, although on a temporary basis, but were qualified
at the time when they were so promoted and found to be
eligible by the Departmental Promotion Committee at a later
date, should be promoted with retrospective effect.”
31.
The above would only reinforce the fact that promotion can be
considered retrospectively, however, only if there are relevant rules
prevailing then. In the absence of any rules for promotion, there is no
basis on which the incumbent could be promoted retrospectively. The
case of P.N. Premachandran (supra) cited by the petitioners in support of
their contention may not be applicable to their situation.
32.
However, since it is the fault of the authorities concerned for
not bringing out any relevant Recruitment Rules to facilitate the
promotion of the petitioners when the said 13 posts of Naib Subedar and
other posts were sanctioned, thereby convening of a DPC could not be
affected, for the fault of the authorities, the petitioners should not be
made to suffer.
33.
In this regard, para 12 of the case of Food Corporation of India
& Ors. v. Parashotam Das Bansal & Ors: (2008) 5 SCC 100, cited by
the learned counsel for the petitioners would be applicable to the case of
the petitioners. The same reads as follows:
“12. When employees are denied an opportunity of
promotion for long years (in this case 30 years) on the
ground that they fell within a category of employees
excluded from promotional prospect, the superior court will
have the jurisdiction to issue necessary direction.”
34.
The petitioners herein having been denied to be considered for
promotion for about 20 years or so, their grievances have to be addressed
accordingly. On the authority of the case of Food Corporation of India
(supra), this Court coming to the conclusion that the petitioners have
made out a case to be considered for promotion, accordingly, the
competent authority is hereby directed to bring out the relevant
Recruitment Rules, indicating the mode and manner wherewith the
petitioners may be promoted to the next higher post. The exercise is
directed to be completed preferably within a period of 3(three) months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and order.
35.
Keeping in mind the fact that the petitioners have been deprived
of their right to be considered for promotion for a considerable length of
time, the authorities may look into this aspect while bringing out the
relevant rules.
36.
With the above, this petition is hereby disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
25.05.2023
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review