Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
()*+, , ,-
()*+, , ,-
/0
!" (.
., ,(
#$
!% " *. ., ,(
"
/ '
.
&
&
)( 2
1 3
) ((3
'
44444
&
'0 . 1 2 $3
.56
) #$#
$#6 7
!"
9*
65'
$
#$#
$#6)
6$#) 6#5) 6$') #$ )
#$%
" &
'#%(
(
+
:
;<
( ) - .7
) #$#$**
&
)
=
&
,
,
#- $ #$#
$#.
=
)
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
)
$6 # #$#>
)
#
()*+, , ,#
=
,
!"
&
A
<
)
+
?
=
&2
) +
B
) ,
,
)
)
) $
#$#6))
) ,
,
),
)
,
)
?
:@
)
@
" ,
@
?
)
:
)
@
,
B
?
#$#
$#6)
) ,
%
%
$-
,
) !"
)
,
,
,
)
,
,
2 2
)
?
?
)
2 ,
)
6$# " & ,
,
6$
6$. " & ,
:
)
,
?
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(
@
)
()*+, , ,-
C
!"
,
?
?
C
%
(
@
)
,
)
?
(
)
!"
!"
,
<
,
,
(
),
?
"
)
?
)
!
)
,
%
2 2
?
C
(
%=
#$#
),
,
#$#6 (
)
,
"
,
,
)
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
?
=
()*+, , ,-
.
,
2 ,
, "
#- $# #$#.
#$
!
,
)
&
:
C
$>
,
D
,
<
"
)
)
,
=
&
)
,
,
&
,
B
)
.
?
,
C
)
D
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
,
2 2
()*+, , ,-
>
?
(
)
,
%
,
)
2 2
?
2 2
C
%
,
,
?
!
2 2
)
!"
),
<
,
?
&
C
)
>
"
E
" ,
:
&
F
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
,
%
()*+, , ,-
E
!
"
#$
!
%
!
! $ &'
(
"
)
*
,*
*
+*
!
$
,-
"
!
! %
+
,-
.
!
!
*
'/#
!
!
+
#
,
0 1
*
!
!
"
0 1
*
!
*
!
,
!
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-
()*+, , ,-
'
'
%
+
+
,-
+
+
+
+
,,%
%
%
%
!
$7
"
*
+
,-
*
+
,+
+
+
,-
+
+
%
+
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
,-
()*+, , ,,-
:
%
+
;
!
+
,-
:
!
+
,-
+
,-
!
+
+
,<
=
'
(
,
,F
, 2 )
?
"
,
,
=
,
,
=
,
,
,
#- $ #$#.
=
$6 # #$#
$#>
, 2 )
,
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
<
,
:
)
&
,
,
()*+, , ,-
-
=
&
F
,
, 2 )
<
)
:
,
:
G
)
<
)
&
=
&
,
(
)
,))
)
,
)
)
&
)
!
)
,
:
,
(
:
!"
! # $ %
&
'(
(
) *
&
%
'&
!* (
,
=$3
,> , > , >, > , >, -
> , >
,
-
,
+ )% ,
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2! 3
%
-. /
.
"
.,
(
/ #00 .
' (
"
/
-. /
/% '&
-$01
-$
()*+, , ,!* (
$
! -0$- ?
?
. /
.
(
/
.
/
.0/
%
1 8A
%
%
"
>
@
3 !
5*
!
.
/
.#/
.
(
/1 -.
/
,
" %
. /
$1
!
-. /
##1 <
!
(
=
3'&,$-, 33'
,
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!
!
-
.
%
(
-. /
(
/
()*+, , ,-
A
.-/
.
," (
(
/ 0-
.
%
/
.-/ '* 7
.#/
(
- #%
#-$
#
!
=
<
-
"
)
=
,
)
)
=
!"
A
?
,
B
)
!"
,
,
2 2
)
,
,
?
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
"
!"
,
?
,
),
)
()*+, , ,-
#
"
,
&
,
%
#$%
" &
6$#)) 6#5
,
'#%(
(
:
,
;<
(
=
$
=
2 2
?
,
=
)
)
<
?
2 2
=
!"
?
)
)
)
,
,
?
2 )
) ,
"
2 2
=
,
=
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
,
()*+, , ,-
)
,
)
)
,
)
!
)
:
)
,
?
&
(
)
=
2 2
?
!
)
=
,
=
,
,
"
)
)
(
)
)
,
"
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
)
()*+, , ,-
.
&
#
)
)
(
)
&
&
=
,
&
=
,
>#
>#5
) #$#6
,
&
,
)
:
&
,
< )
&
,
&
,
F
)
:
&
)
=
,
=
,
,
)
"
%
, 7 *)
,
,
,
)
,
, 7*
,0&
:
,
,
)
,
"
G
,
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
),
,
&
&
,
)
,
,
,
, 7*
&
=
),
()*+, , ,(
>
&
,
<
)
,
,
&
,
)
=
:
:
)
)
, 7*
<
,)
:
,
, 7*
&
:
,
F
F
)
:
,)
)
>#
>#5
) #$#6
)
"
,
,
,
:
),
)
?
)
,)
:
F
&
2 <
,
:
,
:
6#
(
:
)
:
,
,!
)
&
! # #)
=$7
%
# '&
!* (
,
%
*
3'
!
!
)
!
!
B!
*
!
*
;
"
,
=!
C
?
#$3
<-
$$
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
C
()*+, , ,-
E
!
$#
*
"
!
!
!
!
"
##/
##&
##/
##&
!
"
!
!
, -+
@
#7#' *!! . D
J * 0
,-
!
F
*! 3$'
$'
=47 "
!
##/
%
E
:
":
@
4&'
F
*
*
*
?
!
,$ /#- $ *!@
*!
D
,#77H- # *!!
!! 3$
G
*
!
!
)
!
%2
=
< I
-
@
*
$ &3 *! 444K
##&
C ,
,$ &3- 3 *!! ' 8 " @
%
"
!
*
J
" G
"
,
-
%
<$' @
!
+
*
3'
!
>
!
+
<
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
##/
#
!
()*+, , ,=
!
&+
+
'
!
&
"
&
:
)
6 5(
8'
86 5 (
' %
-='4
?
"
!
!
<
13.4
The chronic protraction of ccriminal proceedings serves
es as a
systemic
mic b
blight that transcends thee indi
individual interest of the accused
ccused,
inflicting
ting a highly deleterious impactt upon the collective consciencee of the
th
society.
ty. W
While legal discourse frequently
uently centers on the hardship of the
th
incarcerated
cerated, it is a grave juridical error
ror to overlook the active suffering
ing and
an
anguish
ish vis
visited upon the victim. For the aaggrieved; an interminable trial is
i
not merely
erely a procedural delay but a form
orm oof secondary victimization leading
leadin
to a state of
o perpetual emotional purgatory
gatory where the wounds of offense
nse are
ar
kept raw by
b the lack of finality. A Thre
Three Judge Bench of the Hon’bl
on’ble
Supreme
eme Court
C
in Rattiram and Other
thers Vs. State of M.P. throug
rough
Inspector
tor of
o Police; 2012 AIR Supremee C
Court 1485 while appreciating
ting the
th
observation
rvation in Mangal Singh and Anothe
other Vs. Kishan Singh and Others
thers;
2009 AIR
IR S
Supreme Court 1535; observed
erved aas under:
“47.
While delineating on the facets of speedy trial, it cannot
ot be
b
regarded as an exclusive rightt of the accused. The right of a victim
im has
h
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
()*+, , ,-
been given recognition in Mangal
ngal Singh and Anr. v. Kishan Singh
h and
an
ors., AIR 2009 Supreme Court 1535 wherein it has been observed thus
us ::
“Any inordinate delay
ay in conclusion of a criminal trial
tri
undoubtedly has highly deleteriou
erious effect on the society generally
ly and
an
particularly on the two sides off the case. But it will be a grave mistake
take to
assume that delay in trial doess no
not cause acute suffering and anguish
ish to
the victim of the offence. In many
any cases the victim may suffer even more
mo
than the accused. There is, therefo
refore no reason to give all the benefits
fits on
o
account of the delay in trial to th
the accused and to completely deny
ny all
a
justice to the victim of the offence.”
ce.”
The fundamental principle
nciple of an ever-evolving liberty
libert
jurispruden
prudence dictates that prolonged
ed inc
incarceration, absent any realistic
realisti
prospect
ect of a near-term conclusion off trial, renders continued pre-convictio
viction
detention
tion cconstitutionally impermissible.
ible. U
Under the umbrella of Article
ticle 21
of thee Constitution,
Co
the right to a spe
speedy trial is recognized as an
a
indispensab
pensable facet of the guarantee of lif
life and personal liberty. The
he prepre
trial incarc
incarceration must not, by meree flux of time, be permitted to assume
assum
the charact
haracter of punishment, as thee state cannot be allowed to achieve
achiev
through
gh pro
procedural delay what it hass not yyet achieved through a verdict
rdict of
o
guilt.. However,
Howe
this Constitutional promise
romise is not an absolute or unregulate
gulated
license,, rather
rat
it ensures that deprivations
ations of liberty are neither arbitrary
rbitrary,
unconscion
nscionable nor unfair.
13.5
Where relief is being sough
sought, solely upon the ground
und of
o
procedural
edural delay, the Court must adopt a golden mean approach, where
here the
th
rightss of the
th accused/incarcerated person
rson are protected without reducing
cing the
th
criminal
inal ju
justice system to a state of toothl
toothlessness. Ergo, the Constitutiona
tutional
inquiry
iry into delay must be a contextual
al asse
assessment of whether the continue
ntinued
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
detention
tion re
remains constitutionally permiss
ermissible under the specific penumbr
numbra
()*+, , ,-
-
of thee case.
case Unless the delay is so inord
inordinate that it shocks the judicial
judicia
conscience,
cience, it cannot be treated as a solitar
solitary determinant for enlargement.
ment. A
plea of de
delay cannot be examined in a legal vacuum or an abstraction
raction;
instead
ad it m
must be weighed against thee grav
gravamen of allegations; specific
ific role
rol
attributed
uted to the applicant; trajectory
tory oof the trial; risks involved
lved in
i
enlargemen
gement of the applicant on bail,
il, etc
etc. A profitable reference in this
thi
regard
d can be made to the dicta passed
ssed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt in
i
Gulfisha
ha F
Fatima vs. State (Govt. of Del
Delhi), SLP (Crl.) No.13988-2025
2025,
relevant
ant wh
whereof reads thus:
=#/
"
%
%%%
%%%
'7
"
#$
'$ "
%
"
=
#$
<
%%%
%%%
%% <
A justice delivery system
m res
rests on a simple promise; fairness
fairnes
delivered
ered iin reasonable time. Any proced
rocedural protraction does not merely
merel
delay the verdict;
v
it actively erodes the ed
edifice of public confidencee in the
th
judiciary.
iary. W
When a trial is allowed too lang
languish, it transcends the aphorism
horism
that ‘justice
stice delayed is justice denied’ and enters the more perilous territor
erritory
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
#$
()*+, , ,-
tice doubted’. In the constitutional
onal sscheme of Article 21, the Right
ight to
of ‘justice
a Speedy
eedy tr
trial is not a unilateral concessio
cession to the accused, but a collectiv
llective
entitlement
lement shared by the victim & the
he Sta
State, ensuring that Scales of justic
ustice
do nott rust through inaction.
13.6
Ergo, in cases where, notwit
notwithstanding the lapse of time,
me, the
th
Courtt in its judicious wisdom finds that oth
other factors preclude grant of bail,
bai
a proactive
active approach to prevent travesty
esty of justice must be adopted. In such
suc
cases,, the refusal to grant on bail must be coupled with a peremptor
mptory
mandate
ate of expeditious conclusion of trial (or in appropriate cases a timetime
bound
d conclusion
conc
of trial). A profitable
ble refe
reference in this regard can bee made
mad
to the dicta
dict passed by the Hon’ble Supre
Supreme Court in Tarun Kumar
ar Vs.
V
Assistant
nt D
Director, Directorate of Enforc
nforcement; SLP (Crl.) No. 9431
31 of
o
2023, relevant
relev whereof reads thus:
“#'
%%%%
%%%%
%%%%
?
!
%
"
6'
#$
!
<
,
>
F
&
<
.
" 2 ,
7*
=
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
,
7*
<
,
,
7*
%
)
()*+, , ,=
7 *
#
&
,
<
<
,
)
)
,
, "
&
% %
86 5 (
7 *
'
&
6 5(
&
)
,
,) ,
,
7 2*
7 *)
)
1&
'3
$E) #$#E
"
G
G
AJAY KUMAR
2026.03.09 10:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
8'
*
(
)
+ 0
+ 0
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review