Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
#
!
" $
!
' #
#
$%
!
&!
"
#
#
#
((
) * "+
#
#
((
) * "+
!
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
! "
#$%
&
'
(
!
!
"
!
# * &
(
+
# $
!
*,, )
)
-2-
+
! "
#$%
&
'
(
!
)
!
+
!
+
+
!
-
,*( )
"
+
+
+
%&
&
$
! "
& ,
! "
!
+
+
!
&
! "
#$%
(
!
+
&
!
)
"
,
&
! "
#$%
&
-3-
*
!
,
#
(
+
# $
(
+
!
* &&
!
#*,, )
!
!
&
*
+
++
+
)
,*( )
+
!
"
$
& ,
"
! "
!
%&
&
+
+
"
!
.
"
' "
/010 2330241 250 2561678 9:; 9< ;/0 ":=8>07;
27= 2?25= =2;0=
;/0 <640 9< ;/0
$
& , 32110= 67
9;95
!6B2C23:5 (<95 1/95; D;/0
@@6=07;1
!
426>1
9 %&
56A:724
&
9*
56A:724E) 2?25=678 @9>30712;697
;9 ;/0 @426>27;1
+95 ;/0 12F0 9< @97G07607@0 ;/0 325;601 ?644 A0
50<0550= ;9 21 305 ;/065 527F678 A0<950 ;/0 56A:724
-4-
*
/0
<2@;1
7:;1/044
<95
;/0
3:53910
2=B:=6@2;697 9< ;/010 2330241 250 ;/2; 97 *&
=0@0210= "6G27
2:;9
A025678
56@F1/2?
;9?25=1
0;594
2>2@/27=52
&
& $ ;/0
27=50 ?21 =56G678 ;/0
50861;52;697
# * H#*$$&
2>276 G644280 27= ?/07 /0 502@/0= 7025
:>3
278942# 27=/253:5 592=
99=1 G0/6@40 A025678 50861;52;697
9<
# $
2G2=0
@0
#*,, @2>0 67
2 521/ 27= 70846807; >27705 27= =21/0= ;9 ;/0 2:;9
56@F1/2? 27= 97 2@@9:7; 9< ;/0 126= 6>32@; ;/0 =0@0210=
"6G27 1:<<050= 8560G9:1 67B:5601 27= ?21 ;2F07 ;9 ;/0 702501;
/9136;24
/9?0G05
/0 1:@@:>A0= ;9 67B:5601
!
56A:724 100F678 @9>30712;697
7 105G6@0 9< 79;6@0 ;/9:8/
501397=07;
/0 50>2670= 2A107; 27=
?21 105G0=
&
;/0
@426>27;1 <640= @426> 30;6;697 67
9 %&
07@0
A0<950 ;/0
2@@95=6784C 342@0= 0I#325;0
/0 501397=07;
# 71:527@0 @9>327C /21
<640= =0;2640= 9AB0@;6971 27= ;2F07 130@6<6@ 3402 ;/2; 21 ;9 ;/0
67G94G0>07;
9<
;/0
G0/6@40
27=
;/0
244080=
2@@6=07;
@@95=6784C ;/0 71:527@0 @9>327C /21 19:8/; <95 =61>61124
9< ;/0 @426> 30;6;697
-5-
$
7 95=05 ;9 01;2A461/ ;/065 @210
/2G0 0I2>670= ;?9 ?6;701101 6 0
>25F0= *
;9
I
;/0 @426>27;1
27=
27= 89;
=9@:>07;1 27= ;/0 12>0 ?050 >25F0= 21
*
I
7 ;/0 9;/05 /27= ;/0 71:527@0 @9>327C /21
2==:@0= 0G6=07@0 9< 6;1 2?
970 =9@:>07; 6 0
<<6@05 21
71:527@0 3946@C
27= 89; >25F0=
/0
56A:724 2<;05
@9716=05678 ;/0 >2;05624 97 50@95= AC 6;1 ":=8>07; 27= 95=05
=2;0=
$
& , 2?25=0= @9>30712;697 9<
24978 ?6;/ 67;0501; 2; ;/0 52;0 9<
1 $ ,& &&& #
J 305 277:> <59> ;/0
=2;0 9< 30;6;697 ;644 ;/0 =2;0 9< 50246K2;697 +004678 288560G0=
AC ;/0 12>0
;/0
71:527@0 @9>327C /21 350<0550=
+
+
&&
&
& %
@/244078678
&&
$
& %
<640=
AC
;/0
;/0
462A646;C
27=
@426>27;1
100F678
07/27@0>07; 9< @9>30712;697
025= ;/0 402570= @9:71041 <95 ;/0 325;601
,
27G07=52
0==C 402570= @9:7104 233025678
<95 ;/0 71:527@0 @9>327C 258:0= 21 ;9 ;/0 67G94G0>07; 9<
;/0 G0/6@40 67 L:01;697 27= /0 <:5;/05 1:A>6;;0= ;/2; ;/0
G0/6@40 67 L:01;697 /21 A007 <24104C 6>346@2;0= ;9 80; :7B:1;
-6-
8267 <59> ;/0
71:527@0 @9>327C 27= ;/050<950
@97;07=0=
;/0
AC
402570=
@9:7104
233025678
6; 61
<95
71:527@0 @9>327C ;/2; ;/0 <67=678 50@95=0= AC ;/0
;/0
56A:724
50L:6501 ;9 A0 67;05<050= ?6;/ 67 ;/61 233024
%
<95 ;/0
; 61 2419 258:0= AC ;/0 402570= @9:7104 233025678
71:527@0 @9>327C ;/2;
342@0 97 *&
&
;/0 2@@6=07; /2= ;2F07
& $ 27= ;/0 =0@0210= =60= 97 &$
& $
27= 2<;05 2 42310 9< 70254C ;?9 >97;/1 ;/0 @9>34267; ?21
49=80= 97
& $ ?/6@/ ?9:4= >2F01 6; @4025 ;/2; ;/0
G0/6@40 67 L:01;697 /21 A007 <24104C 6>346@2;0= 27= ;/0 126=
2130@; /21 79; A007 @9716=050= AC 499F678 67;9 ;/0 >2;05624
97 50@95= AC ;/0
67;05<0507@0 AC ;/61
56A:724 27= 2@@95=6784C 19:8/; <95
9:5;
05 @97;52
278272A212G2
2;64 402570=
@9:7104 233025678 <95 ;/0 @426>27;1 23304427;1 67
&&
$
& % AC 67G6;678 2;;07;697 9< ;/0
9:5; ;9
+
I
%
1:A>6;;0= ;/2; ;/0 >0=6@9#40824 @210 ?21 50861;050= 21 1997
21 ;/0 2@@6=07; /21 9@@:550=
27=/2523:5
0=6@250
/2F;6
?/05067 ;/0 67B:50= /21 A007 86G07
-7-
>0=6@24 26= 27= ;/0 126= 2130@; >2F01 6; @4025 ;/2;
<67=678 50@95=0= AC ;/0
;/0
56A:724 21 ;9 ;/0 67G94G0>07; 9< ;/0
G0/6@40 67 L:01;697 61 B:1; 27= 359305 27= 2@@95=6784C 19:8/;
<95 =61>61124 9< ;/0 233024 350<0550= AC ;/0
@9>327C
71:527@0
; 61 2419 258:0= AC ;/0 402570= @9:7104 233025678
<95 ;/0 23304427;1 @426>27;1 100F678 07/27@0>07; 9< ;/0
@9>30712;697
&
2G678 /025= ;/0 402570= @9:71041 <95 ;/0 325;601
;/0 @950 L:01;697 61 ;9 A0 271?050= 67 ;/010 2330241 21 ;9
;/0 67G94G0>07; 9< ;/0 G0/6@40 67 L:01;697 27= ;/0 @426>
30;6;697 350<0550= AC ;/0 @426>27;1 100F678 @9>30712;697 97
2@@9:7; 9< ;/0 =02;/ 9< "6G27 67 ;/0 244080= 2@@6=07; 9@@:550=
97 *&
&
& $
7 ;/0 468/; 9< ;/0 1:A>611697 >2=0 AC ;/0
402570= @9:7104 <95 ;/0 325;601 97 @250<:4 @9716=052;697 9<
I
% ?/05067 6; 61 1;2;0= ;/2; D
97 *&
& & $E
; 61
2419 ;9 A0 79;0= <59> ;/0 50@95=1 ;/2; +
?21 50861;050=
3:51:27; ;9 ;/0 @9>34267; 97
; 61 2419 ;9 A0
& $
79;0= <59> ;/0 50@95=1 ;/2; ;/0 0C0?6;7011 ;9 ;/0 67@6=07;
-8-
?21 0I2>670= 21
< 2; 244 ;/0 126= 2@@6=07; /2=
9@@:550= 21 305 ;/0 2G05>07;1 >2=0 67 ;/0 @426> 30;6;697
;/050 ?21 79 6>30=6>07; <95 ;/0 0C0?6;7011 95 ;/0 @426>27;1
;9 50861;05 ;/0 @9>34267; 21 1997 21 ;/0 9@@:5507@0 9< ;/0
244080= 67@6=07; 97 *&
&
& $
; 61 2419 <95;/@9>678 <59>
;/0 >2;05624 50@95= 325;6@:4254C 21 ;9 ;/0 72552;697 9< ;/0
244080= 2@@6=07; 61 @97@0570= 2 =9:A; /21 A007 @502;0= 67
;/0 >67= 9< ;/0
9:5; 21 ;9 ;/0 9@@:5507@0 9< ;/0 2@@6=07; 67
?/6@/ ;/0 =0@0210= ?21 244080= ;9 /2G0 A007 =56G678 ;/0
2:;9 56@F1/2? 21 1;2;0= AC ;/0 @426>27;
32528523/
9< ;/0 =03916;697 9<
;/0 9@@:5507@0 9< ;/0 2@@6=07; ;/0
; 61 2419 79;0= <59>
;/2; 21 1997 21
G616;0= ;/0 2@@6=07;
139; 27= 2419 2; ;/2; ;6>0
;/0 3946@0 /2= @9>0 ;9 ;/0
2@@6=07; 139; <95 67G01;682;697
< 1:@/ A0678 ;/0 @210 ;/050
?9:4= 79; /2G0 A007 6>30=6>07; <95 ;/0 3946@0 2:;/956;601 ;9
50861;05 ;/0 @210 6>>0=62;04C
21 =03910= AC
/0
126= 2130@; ?9:4= @502;0 2 =9:A; 21 ;9 ;/0 9@@:5507@0 9< ;/0
2@@6=07; 27= ;/0 67G94G0>07; 9< ;/0 G0/6@40 67 L:01;697
2419 ;9 A0 79;0= ;/2;
0I2>672;697 =2;0=
; 61
/21 =03910= 67 ;/0 @5911#
&*
& ,
;/2; ;/0 3946@0 /2G0 79;
-9-
07L:650= /6> 21 ;9 ;/0 2@@6=07;
/9:8/ ;/0
=03910=
;9 A0 27 0C0?6;7011 ;9 ;/0 126= 2@@6=07; /9?0G05 /21 79;
=03910= 21 ;9 ;/0 350107@0 9< ;/0
946@0
06;/05 67 ;/0
0I2>672;697#67#@/60< 795 67 ;/0 @5911#0I2>672;697
9@:425 0G6=07@0 9<
/0 126=
>2F01 6; @4025 ;/2; ;/0 G0/6@40 67
L:01;697 /21 A007 <24104C 6>346@2;0= 19 21 ;9 3:; ;/0
>2@/6705C 67;9 2@;697 21 ;9 @426> @9>30712;697
7 ;/61
50825= 6; 61 70@01125C ;9 <9449? ;/0 =0@4252;697 9< 42? >2=0
AC ;/0
6G61697
07@/ 9< ;/61
9:5; 67 ;/0 @210 9<
50395;0= 67
?/05067 ;/61
9:5; 2<;05 @9716=05678 ;/0
>2;05624 97 50@95= 21 ;9 ;/0 67G94G0>07; 9< ;/0 G0/6@40 67
L:01;697 /21 /04= ;/2; 02@/ @210 /21 ;9 A0 =0@6=0= 97 ;/0
<2@;1 97 50@95= 19 21 ;9 2?25= @9>30712;697 :7=05 ;/0
!0/6@401
@;
9;95
7 ;/2; G60? 9< ;/0 >2;;05 ;/0 <2@;:24 2130@;1
97 50@95= ?9:4= >2F01 6; @4025 ;/2;
;/0 +
/21 A007
50861;050= 70254C 2<;05 ;?9 >97;/1 27= 67 ;/0 >027?/640 21
6; 61 =03910= AC
;/2; ;/0
946@0 /2G0 24502=C G616;0=
;/0 139; 9< ;/0 2@@6=07; 27= 1:@/ 9524 0G6=07;625C G24:0 /21
;9 A0 ?068/0= 24978 ?6;/ ;/0 5040G27; >2;05624 97 50@95=
- 10 -
;9 ;/0 =2;0 9< 50861;52;697 9< ;/0 +
>2F01 6; @4025 ;/2; 97
A9;/ @9:7;1 9< 9524 27= =9@:>07;25C 0G6=07@0 ;/0 @426>27;
/21 79; 233592@/0= ;/0
G60? 9< ;/0 >2;;05
56A:724 ?6;/ @4027 /27=1
7 ;/2;
<67= <95@0 67 ;/0 1:A>611697 >2=0 AC
;/0 402570= @9:7104 233025678 <95 ;/0 71:527@0 @9>327C 19
$
;9
67;05<050
?6;/
;/0
":=8>07;
27=
2?25=
=2;0=
& ,
7 ;/0 501:4; ;/0 3967;1 <95 @9716=052;697 50<0550=
;9 2A9G0 61 271?050= 67 <2G9:5 9< ;/0 71:527@0 @9>327C 19
21 ;9 =0@4670 ;9 2@@03; ;/0 @426> 30;6;697 350<0550= AC ;/0
@426>27;1
*
7 ;/0 501:4; ;/0 <9449?678
"
(6)
+
&&
$
& %
<640=
AC
;/0
&
& %
<640=
AC
;/0
@426>27;1 61 =61>6110=(66)
+
&&
71:527@0 @9>327C 61 2449?0=(666)
$
/0
& , 67
@@6=07;1
426>1
":=8>07;
27=
!
&
9 %&
56A:724
2?25=
=2;0=
32110= AC
9;95
9 * !6B2C3:5 61 /050AC
- 11 -
10;
216=0-
;/0
@426>
30;6;697
2@@95=6784C
=61>6110=(6G)
;/0
/0 2>9:7; 67 =03916; A0 50<:7=0= ;9
23304427;# 71:527@0
&&
&
%
#,
"
' "
# +
& %
)
!
61;
@9>327C
#
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review