Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010198972024
2026:GAU-AS:105
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
CRP(IO)/374/2024
1.
2.
Rama Devi Himatsingka
Wife of late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka
Resident of Ramsai Hills, Kharguli,
P.S.- Latasil, Guwahati- 781004.
Represented
by
Shri
Kanishka
Himatsingka,
Son of Shri Rajesh Himatsingka
Resident of Ramsai Hills, Kharguli,
P.S. Latasil, Guwahati- 781004.
Rajesh Himatsingka
Son of Late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka
Resident of Ramsai Hills, Kharguli,
P.S.- Latasil, Guwahati - 781004.
Represented by Shri Kanishka
Himatsingka
Son of Shri Rajesh Himatsingka,
Resident of Ramsai Hills Kharguli
P.S. Latasil Guwahati- 781004.
-Versus1.
CRP(IO)/374/2024
…..Petitioners
Pawan Kumar Himatsingka
Son of Late Gauri Shankar Himatsingka
Resident of A-95, Malviya Nagar,
Page 1
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
New Delhi- 110017.
Kavita Himatsingka
Wife of Late Mukesh Himatsingka, who was the son of
Late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka Resident of 17 Dover
Road Dover Enclave Ballygunge
Kolkata- 700019.
Nitin Himatsingka,
Son of late Mukesh Himatsingka who was the son of
Late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka
Resident of 17 Dover Road Dover Enclave
Ballygunge Kolkata- 700019.
Rishab Himatsingka
Son of late Mukesh Himatsingka who was the son of
late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka
Resident of 17 Dover Road Dover Enclave
Ballygunge Kolkata- 700019.
Sunita Agarwal wife of Narendra Kumar Agarwal,
Daughter of Late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka Resident
of Layak Bhawan Hill Cart Road,
Siliguri West Bengal.
Harish Himatsingka
Son of Late Santosh Himatsingka
Resident of 2nd Floor 19b Mandevilla Garden
Kolkata- 700019.
……Respondents
For Petitioners
:
Mr. G. N. Sahewalla, Sr. Advocate
Mr. H. K. Sarma, Advocate
For Respondents
:
Mr. S. K. Singh, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Sundi, Advocate
Date of Judgment
Reserved
Date of Judgment
:
18.12.2025
:
06.01.2026
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 2
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard Mr. G. N. Sahewalla, the learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. H. K. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard
Mr. S. K. Singh, the learned senior counsel appearing through Video
Conferencing assisted by Mr. P. Sundi, learned counsel for the
respondent.
2. This application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been filed by the petitioners, namely, Rama Devi Himatsingka and
Rajesh
Himatsingka
impugning
the
order
dated
11.09.2024
passed in Title Suit No. 72/2014 by the Court of learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division), No. 2, Sonitpur, Tezpur, whereby the application
filed by the present petitioners under Section 63 of the Indian evidence Act, 1872 was rejected and the respondent was allowed to
exhibit the sale deed No. 1173/1961 dated 28.08.1961 as Exhibit-2.
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant Civil Revision
Petition, in brief, are that the present respondent No.1 as plaintiff
had instituted a title suit being Title Suit No. 72/2014 for declaration
of right, title and interest over the suit premises and also for relief
that the mutation of defendant No. 2 and that of his father in respect of the suit property is illegal.
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 3
4.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioners has submitted that in
the aforesaid suit, the respondent exhibited a certified copy of the
sale deed No. 1173/1961 dated 28.08.1961. The learned senior
counsel for the petitioners submits that since the original sale deed
was not produced by the respondent no. 1 before the Trial Court,
hence, the present petitioners had filed an application under Section
63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 objecting to the admissibility of
the said sale deed without following the requirement as prescribed
under Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
5.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioners has submitted that
however, by the impugned order the Trial Court held the Exhibit No.
2 to be a public document and erroneously held that there is no requirement of fulfilling the norms laid down in Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 before admitting the said sale deed.
6.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioners submits that the trial
court had erred in holding that the sale deed which is exhibited as
Exhibit No. 2 is a public document. He submits that the Apex Court
in the case of <Deccan Paper Mills Co. Ltd. Versus Regency
Mahavir Properties and Others=, reported in (2021) 4 SCC 786
have very clearly held that a sale deed which is a deed of conveyance is not a public document but a private document. He relies upon the following observations made by the Apex Court in the aforesaid case:
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 4
<22. Let us see whether Section 31(2) makes
any difference to this position in law. According to the judgment in Aliens Developers [Aliens Developers (P) Ltd. v. Janardhan
Reddy, 2015 SCC OnLine Hyd 370 : (2016) 1
ALT 194 (DB)] , the moment a registered instrument is cancelled, the effect being to remove it from a public register, the adjudicatory
effect of the court would make it a judgment in rem. Further, only a competent court
is empowered to send the cancellation decree
to the officer concerned, to effect such cancellation and <note on the copy of the instrument
contained in his books the fact of its cancellation=. Both reasons are incorrect. An action
that is started under Section 31(1) cannot be
said to be in personam when an unregistered
instrument is cancelled and in rem when a registered instrument is cancelled. The suit that is
filed for cancellation cannot be in personam only for unregistered instruments by virtue of the fact that the decree for cancellation
does not involve its being sent to the registration office 4 a ministerial action which
is subsequent to the decree being passed. In
fact, in Gopal Das v. Sri Thakurji [Gopal
Das v. Sri Thakurji, 1943 SCC OnLine PC 2 :
AIR 1943 PC 83] , a certified copy of a registered instrument, being a receipt dated 29-31881 signed by the owner, was held not to be
a public record of a private document under
Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act, 1872 for the
reason that the original has to be returned to
the party under Section 61(2) of the Registration Act, 1908 (see p. 87). This judgment has
been
followed
in Rekha v. Ratnashree [Rekha v. Ratnashree,
2005 SCC OnLine MP 364 : (2006) 1 MP LJ
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 5
103] by a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, in which it was held : (Rekha
case [Rekha v. Ratnashree, 2005 SCC OnLine
MP 364 : (2006) 1 MP LJ 103] , SCC OnLine
MP paras 8 and 9)
<8. A deed of sale is a conveyance. A
deed of conveyance or other document executed by any person is not an act nor record of an act of any sovereign authority or
of any official body or tribunal, or of any
public officer, legislative, judicial and executive. Nor is it a public record kept in a State
of any private documents. A sale deed (or
any other deed of conveyance) when presented for registration under the Registration Act, is not retained or kept in any public office of a State after registration, but is
returned to the person who presented such
document for registration, on completion of
the process of registration. An original registered document is not therefore a public
record kept by a State of a private document. Consequently, a deed of sale or other
registered document will not fall under either of the two classes of documents described in Section 74, as <public documents=. Any document which is not a public
document is a private document. We therefore have no hesitation in holding that a
registered sale deed (or any other registered document) is not a public document
but a private document.
9. This position is made abundantly clear
in Gopal
Das v. Sri
Thakurji [Gopal
Das v. Sri Thakurji, 1943 SCC OnLine PC 2 :
AIR 1943 PC 83] , wherein the Privy Council
considering the question whether a regisCRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 6
tered receipt is a public document observed
thus : (SCC OnLine PC)
>… It was contended by Sir Thomas
Strangman for the respondents that the
receipt comes within para 2 of Section
74, Evidence Act, and was a <public document=; hence under Section 65(e) no
such foundation is required as in cases
coming within clauses (a), (b) and (c) of
that section. Their Lordships cannot accept this argument since the original receipt of 1881 is not <a public record of a
private document=. The original has to
be returned to the party.… A similar argument would appear at one time to
have had some acceptance in India but it
involves a misconstruction of the Evidence Act and the Registration Act and
later decisions have abandoned it.?
We may also refer to the following passage from Ratanlal's Law of Evidence (19th Edn., p. 237):
>Public document [Clause (e)] 4 This
clause is intended to protect the originals
of public records from the danger to
which they would be exposed by constant production in evidence. Secondary
evidence is admissible in the case of
public documents mentioned in Section
74. What Section 74 provides is that
public records kept in any State of private documents are public documents,
but private documents of which public
records are kept are not in themselves
public documents. A registered document, therefore, does not fall under either clause (e) or (f) [of Section 65 of
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 7
the Evidence Act, 1872]. The entry in the
register book is a public document, but
the original is a private document.?=
(emphasis in original)
Thus, the factum of registration of what is
otherwise a private document inter partes
does not clothe the document with any higher
legal status by virtue of its registration.=
7.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioners submits that in view of
the aforesaid observations made by the Apex Court in the aforesaid
case, there remains no doubt that the observations made by the
Trial Court in the impugned order is contrary to settle proposition of
law and, hence, he submits that the impugned order is liable to be
set aside.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. S. K. Singh, the learned senior counsel for
the respondent has submitted that the sale deed, which was exhibited by the present petitioners in the aforementioned title suit as
Exhibit No.2 was executed by one Ajay Kumar Basu in favour of the
father of the present respondent No. 1, namely, late Gauri Shankar
Himatsingka and the aforesaid sale deed is in possession of the
present petitioners as the land documents in respect of the scheduled land was looked after by the predecessor in interest of the present petitioner, namely, late Santosh Kumar Himatsingka.
9.
He further submits that the present petitioners have also admitted in
their written statement filed before the Trial Court in the aforesaid
suit regarding the fact that late Gauri Shankar Himatsingka pur-
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 8
chased the suit land in 1961 from the original purchaser, namely,
Ajay Kumar Basu. He further submits that in view of the clear admission of the existence of the sale deed which was exhibited as exhibit
No. 2, the respondents? case is covered under Section 65 (b) of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
10. He further submits that in view of the clear admission of the execution of the sale deed in favour of the predecessor in interest of the
present respondent No. 1, he is even not required to adduce any
secondary evidence to that effect in view of clear admission to that
effect in the written statement filed by the present petitioners. He
also submits that the requirement of issuance of notice under Section 66 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is also not there in view of
the clear admission made by the petitioners in the written statement
filed by them before the Trial Court.
11. The learned senior counsel for the respondent further submits that
as regards whether the sale deed executed by private persons is a
public document or not, the question is not yet settled and there are
rulings of the Apex court to the contrary. He submits that it has been
observed by the Apex Court in the case of <Appaiya Versus Andi-
muthu@ Thangapandi and Others= reported in 2023 Supreme
SC 974 that a private sale deed which is kept and maintained by the
public authority is covered under Section 74 (2) of the Evidence Act,
1872.
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 9
12. He further submits that if any party to a suit has laid the foundation
of leading secondary evidence either in plaint or in evidence as has
been done by the respondents in this case, there is no requirement
that an application under Section 65 of the Evidence Act, 1872 has
to be filed separately by such a party. In support of his submission,
he has also cited a ruling of the Apex Court in the case of <Dhanpat
Versus Sheo Ram= through legal heirs reported in (2020) 16
SCC 209.
13. He submits that by pleading the existence of the sale deed which
has been exhibited as Exhibit-2 in the plaint, the respondent No. 1
has laid the foundation for exhibiting the said sale deed as Exhibit-2,
more so, when the said fact has not been controverted in the written
statement filed by the present petitioners rather, they have admitted
the execution of such a sale deed.
14. The learned senior counsel for the petitioner has further submitted
that the impugned order has been passed by the Trial Court within
the powers and jurisdiction exercised by the Trial Court after giving
opportunity of being heard to the present petitioners, therefore, in
the instant case, there is no dereliction of duty or flagrant violation
of the fundamental principles of law by the Trial Court while passing
the impugned order justifying the invoking of supervisory jurisdiction
by this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
15. He submits that the even if it is assumed that the observation made
by the Trial Court is erroneous, however, it cannot be regarded as
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 10
perverse, therefore, he submits that the invoking of supervisory jurisdiction by this court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
is not called for in this case. In support of his submission, the
learned senior counsel for the respondent has cited a ruling of the
Apex Court in the case of <M/S Estralla Rubber Versus Dass Es-
tate (Private) Ltd.< reported in (2001) 8 SCC 97.
16. He further submits that as the impugned order cannot be regarded
as a completely perverse order, hence, the invoking of supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is not justified in view of the observation made by the Apex Court in the case
of <Serosoft Solutions Pvt. Ltd. Versus Dexter Capital Advi-
sors Pvt. Ltd.= reported in 2025 Supreme Online SC 2025.
17. In reply to the submissions made by the learned senior counsel for
the respondents, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners submits that the observations made by the Apex Court in the case of
Appaiya Versus Andimuthu (Supra) appears to be contrary to
the observations of the larger Bench of the Supreme Court made in
the case of Deccan Paper Mills (Supra), therefore, same is not be
binding on this Court.
18. I have considered the submissions made by learned senior counsel
for both sides and have gone through the materials on record. I
have also gone through the rulings cited by learned counsel for both
sides in support of their respective submissions.
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 11
19. The grievance of the present petitioners, in this case, is mainly regarding the admissibility of the certified copy of the Sale Deed No.
1173/1961 as Exhibit No. 2 on the ground that the Trial Court by rejecting their application regarding admissibility of the said document
have made an observation that said sale deed comes within the purview of definition of a public document under Section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
20. The question as to whether a sale deed, which is an instrument of
conveyance may be regarded as a public document or not has been
discussed by the Apex Court, in the rulings cited by the learned
counsel for both sides, in different ways. However, this Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction, in the midst of a trial, is not inclined to examine the matter as to whether the Trial Court was correct in observing that sale deed is a public document under Section
74 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, or not. More so, because the
same is not necessary to decide the real controversy involved at this
stage i.e., whether the certified copy of the Sale Deed No.
1173/1961 as Exhibit No. 2 is admissible as evidence under the facts
and circumstances of the case.
21. It appears that in the written statement filed before the Trial Court
by the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 (present petitioners), they have categorically stated in paragraph No. 1 of the said written statement that
they admit to the fact that late Gauri Shankar Himatsingka purchased the suit land in 1961 from the original owner i.e., Ajay Kumar
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 12
Basu through a registered sale deed No. 1173/1961. The certified
copy of the said sale deed has been exhibited by the present respondents as Exhibit-2.
22. In view of clear admission regarding existence of the aforesaid sale
deed in their written statement by the petitioners, the secondary evidence of the said document is otherwise also admissible under Section 60 (b) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) 2023, hence,
the question as to whether the aforesaid document is a public document or not is not relevant to decide the question of admissibility of
the said document in the aforesaid title suit.
23. The Apex Court has observed in many of its judgments [for example,
in the case of <Shalini Shyam Shetty Versus Rajendra Shankar
Patil= reported in (2010) 8 SCC 329] that the High Courts cannot
on the drop of a hat, in exercise of its powers of superintendence
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, interfere with the orders of tribunal or courts inferior to it.
24. It is also well settled proposition that in exercise of its powers of superintendence, a High Court cannot interfere to correct mere errors
of law or fact or just because another view than the one taken by
tribunals or courts subordinate to it is a possible view. In other
words, the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
has to be very sparingly exercised.
25. In the instant case, as in view of clear admission by the present petitioners, in their written statement, regarding the existence of the
said sale deed, certified copy of the same would have been otherCRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 13
wise also admissible under Section 60 (b) of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam (BSA) 2023, hence, this Court does not find it necessary
to interfere with the impugned order whereby Trial Court had rejected the petition filed by the present petitioners under Section 63 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
26. For the discussion made in the foregoing paragraphs and the reasons stated hereinabove, this Civil Revision Petition (IO) is hereby
dismissed with cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
signed
Amita Digitally
by Amita
Sharma
Sharm Date:
2026.01.06
15:32:44 +05'30'
a
CRP(IO)/374/2024
Page 14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review