Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC040008872025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/246/2025
Ram Sewak Mahato
son of Late Timal Mahato, resident of Sagum Village, PO and PS Srirampur, Chapra
District, Thana Parsa, Bihar, presently residing at PWD Colony, Jairampur, PO and
PS Jairampur, Changlang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 6 Ors
represented by its Commissioner and Secretary, Public Works Department, Itanagar,
Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh 791111
2:The Superintending Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Jairampur Circle
Public Works Department
Jairampur
PO Jairampur
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh 792120
3:The Executive Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Jairampur Division
Public Works Department
Jairampur
PO Jairampur
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh 792120
4:The Assistant Engineer
Age: 0
Page No.# 2/9
Occupation :
Nampong Sub Division
Public Works Department
Nampong
PO Nampong
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh 792123
5:The Director of Audit and Pension
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
Arunachal Pradesh 791110
6:The Assistant Auditor
Age: 0
Occupation :
Directorate of Audit and Pension
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
Arunachal Pradesh 791110
7:The Finance And Accounts Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Directorate of Audit and Pension
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
Arunachal Pradesh 79111
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Niranjan Sarma, Vijay Jamoh
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
26.03.2026
Heard Mr. N. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. N. Lowang,
learned Senior Government Advocate for the State respondents.
Page No.# 3/9
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has challenged:(i)
the letter No. Pen/AP/38416/23-24/199/905-07, dated 04.07.2023,
issued by the respondent No. 7 on behalf of the respondent No. 5,
seeking clarification and re-fixation of his pay scale;
(ii)
the
letter
No.
Pen/AP/38416/23-24/199/10258-260,
dated
16.11.2023, issued by the respondent No. 7 on behalf of the
respondent No. 5, seeking second time clarification and re-fixation of
his pay scale;
(iii)
the Office Order No. JD/WC-13/2024-25/344-46, dated 08.07.2024,
issued by the respondent No. 3 re-fixing his pay and allowances in
accordance with the observation made in the letters dated
04.07.2023 and 16.11.2023, issued by the respondent No. 7 on
behalf of the respondent No. 5; and
(iv)
the Order No. JD/PF-251(a)/2024-25/608-09, dated 16.08.2024,
issued by the respondent No. 3, intimating his excess drawal,
amounting Rs. 12,03,830/- and requiring him to deposit the same
through Treasury Challan for settlement of the pension.
3.
Mr. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner
was appointed as Work Charged Assistant (WCA hereinafter) Mason, in the PWD
Department, Jairampur Division, in the district of Changlang, Arunachal Pradesh,
on 06.02.1987. Thereafter, he had superannuated on 31.10.2022, from the
office of the respondent No. 4 and after his superannuation, his service book
and other documents were submitted to the respondent No. 3, for taking
necessary steps for settlement of his pension.
Page No.# 4/9
3.1. Accordingly, the respondent No. 3 forwarded the pension papers and the
service book of the petitioner to the respondent No. 5. But, the respondent No.
5 returned the same to the respondent No. 3, along with a letter dated
04.07.2023, stating discrepancies in the pay scale of the petitioner and sought
for clarification in this regard from the respondent No. 3 and also requisitioned
the relevant Recruitment Rules, so that the admissibility of the pay scale may be
ascertained.
3.2. Thereafter, the respondent No. 3 resubmitted the pension papers and the
service book of the petitioner to the respondent No. 5. But, the respondent No.
5 again returned the same, vide letter dated 16.11.2023, observing that the
petitioner was appointed as WCA Mason at a higher pay scale of Rs. 950 –
1400/- (revised pay scale of Rs. 3050 – 4590/-) in contrast to the cases of some
other persons appointed in the same post at the pay scale of Rs. 775 – 1025/(revised pay scale of Rs. 2610 – 3540/-) and further observed that as per the
OM dated 13.08.2007, the pay scale of the Assistant Mason is Rs. 2610 – 3540/corresponding to the pre-revised scale of Rs. 775 – 1025/-.
3.3. In the said letter, dated 16.11.2023, also sought for a clarification for
confirming the pay scale of the petitioner and the respondent No. 3, in response
to the said letter, resubmitted the pension papers and the service book of the
petitioner, vide letter dated 15.03.2024, stating that the petitioner was
appointed as WCA Mason in the pay scale of Rs. 950 – 1400/- and in the same
pay scale, the pension case of the same grade, as that of the petitioner, was
finalized by the respondent No. 5.
3.4. Thereafter, the respondent No. 3 re-fixed the pay and allowances of the
petitioner in terms of the observation pointed out by the respondent No. 5 in its
letter dated 04.07.2023 and 16.11.2023, and further prepared the pay drawal
Page No.# 5/9
statements of the petitioner w.e.f. 06.02.1987 up-to 31.10.2022. And as a
result, the petitioner is found to have drawn an excess pay of Rs. 9,98,072/-.
Thereafter, the respondent No. 3, vide its impugned order dated 16.08.2024,
intimated the petitioner about the excess drawal amounting Rs. 12,03,830/-.
3.5. Being aggrieved with the impugned order dated 16.08.2024, by which
excess drawal of pay and allowances and retiral benefits like gratuity, Leave
Encashment, etc. are required to be deposited by the petitioner through
Treasury Challan for settlement of his pension, the petitioner has approached
this Court by filing the present petition.
3.6. Mr. Sarma further submits that in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of State of Punjab vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer),
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334, recovery is not permissible in few situations,
which are reflected in paragraph No. 18 of the said decision and those situations
are:(i)
Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and
Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order of
recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment
has been made for a period in excess of five years,
before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has
been paid accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an inferior
post.
(v)
In any other case, where the court arrives at the
Page No.# 6/9
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.
3.7. Mr. Sarma has also referred to a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Thomas Deniel vs. State of Kerala and Others, reported in
2022 SCC Online SC 536, especially paragraph No. 9, wherein it is stated as
under:“9.
This Court in a catena of decisions has consistently
held that if the excess amount was not paid on account
of any misrepresentation or fraud of the employee or
which is subsequently found to be erroneous, such
excess payment of emoluments or allowances are not
recoverable. This relief against the recovery is
granted not because of any right of the employees but
in equity, exercising judicial discretion to provide
relief to the employees from the hardship that will be
caused if the recovery is ordered. This Court has
further held that if in a given case, it is proved
that an employee had knowledge that the payment
received was in excess of what was due or wrongly
paid, or in cases where error is detected or corrected
within a short time of wrong payment, the matter being
in the realm of judicial discretion, the courts may on
the facts and circumstances of any particular case
order for recovery of amount paid in excess,”
to contend that the petitioner herein was a Group – ‘D’ employee and he has no
role in fixation of his pay nor he has misrepresented himself to get undue
benefit and on such count, the recovery, that too, after almost two years of
retirement is impermissible.
3.8. Referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent authorities,
Mr. Sarma submits that the respondent authorities have admitted that the
excess drawal is due to incorrect and wrong fixation of pay scale of the
Page No.# 7/9
petitioner and due to erroneous grant of increment by the respondent
authorities and in that view of the matter, the impugned orders may be set
aside and quashed and respondents may be directed not to recover the excess
drawal, which is not on account of fraud or misrepresentation on the part of the
petitioner and to settle the pension of the petitioner in a time bound manner.
4.
Per-contra, Mr. Lowang, learned Senior Government Advocate for the State
respondents, referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent Nos.
2, 3 & 4 and also respondent No. 5, 6 & 7, submits that there was excess drawal
amounting Rs. 12,03,830/-, under different heads and as such, the impugned
orders were passed by the respondent authorities and there is no illegality or
infirmity in the same and therefore, the same requires no interference of this
Court.
4.1. However, to a pointed query of this Court, as to whether the case of the
petitioner is covered by the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of
Rafiq Masih (supra) and Thomas Daniel (supra), Mr. Lowang fairly
submits that the case of the petitioner covers by the aforesaid decisions.
5.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition as well as the documents placed
on record and also gone through the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
cases of Rafiq Masih (supra) and Thomas Daniel (supra).
6.
The basic facts of this case are not in dispute. The petitioner was appointed
as WCA Mason in the PWD Department, Jairampur Division, in the district of
Changlang,
Arunachal
Pradesh,
on
06.02.1987.
Thereafter,
he
had
superannuated on 31.10.2022 and then, the respondent No. 4 has submitted
the service book along with pension papers of the petitioner to the respondent
Page No.# 8/9
No. 3. But, the same was returned on two occasions, vide letter dated
04.07.2023 and 16.11.2023, on account of discrepancies being noticed in
respect of his pay scale. Subsequently, when the respondent No. 4 resubmitted
the pension papers along with the service book of the petitioner, then vide
impugned order dated 16.08.2024, it was directed to recover excess drawal
amounting Rs. 12,03,830/- from the petitioner by the respondent No. 3.
7.
It is to be noted here that since the petitioner’s post belongs to Group – ‘D’
category and since the petitioner retired on superannuation on 31.10.2022 and
excess drawal was discovered only in the year 2024, the case of the petitioner is
coverd by the situation mentioned in the Clause Nos. (i) & (ii) of the decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra).
8.
Further, the respondent authorities in their affidavit-in-opposition have
admitted the excess drawal is on account of incorrect and wrong fixation of pay
and erroneous grant of increment. Indisputably, being an employee of Group –
‘D’ category, the petitioner has no role in fixation of pay and allowances and in
granting increment. There is nothing in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent authorities to show any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of
the petitioner in excess drawal. In that view of the matter, the case of the
petitioner is squarely covered by the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Thomas Daniel (supra).
9.
In view of the given factual and legal position as discussed herein above,
this Court is of the view that the impugned order dated 16.08.2024, failed to
withstand the legal scrutiny and accordingly, the same stand set aside and
quashed.
10. By a mandamus of this Court, the respondent authorities, more particularly
Page No.# 9/9
respondent Nos. 3, 4 & 5, are directed to settle the pension papers and service
book of the petitioner, within a period of 3 (three) months from the date of
receipt of the certified copy of this order.
11. The petitioner shall obtain a certified copy of this order and place the same
before the respondent authorities, more particularly respondent No. 3, within a
period of one week from today.
12. It is further provided that in the event of failing to settle the pension
papers and the service book of the petitioner, within the stipulated time, then
the pension and pensionary benefit including the arrear amount of the petitioner
shall carry interest @ 9% per annum from the date of its due, till realization.
13. In terms of above, this writ petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review