Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Arb.P. No.02/2024
Ram Kripal Singh Construction Private Limited, 702, 7th Floor, Panchwati
Plaza, Kutchery Road, P.O.-G.P.O., P.S.-Kutchery, Distt.-Ranchi-834001.
Represented by Shri Alok Kumar, Site In-Charge, International Cricket
Stadium, Narsingarh, Agartala.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Tripura Cricket Association through its Hony. Secretary-cum-Employer,
Tripura Cricket Stadium, Agartala, West Tripura-799001.
2. President, Tripura Cricket Association, Agartala, West Tripura-799001.
3. Engineer-in-charge-cum-Executive Engineer, Tripura Cricket Association,
Agartala, West Tripura-799001.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Paramartha Datta, Advocate,
Mr. Tanmay Debbarma, Advocate,
Mr. P. Tripura, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
14/08/2024
Heard Mr. Tanmay Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents-Tripura Cricket Association (TCA, for short).
2.
Petitioner approached this Court for appointment of an
independent Arbitrator in connection with agreement dated 10.04.2017
(Annexure-1) entered into between the parties under Section 11(6) read with
Section 12 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
3.
The case of the parties is captured in the order dated 12.07.2024
which is extracted hereunder:
"Heard Mr. Tanmay Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
and Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-Tripura
Cricket Association (TCA, for short).
2.
Petitioner has invoked Clause-22.2 for appointment of an independent
arbitrator in respect of the dispute arising out of the agreement dated 10.04.2017 (Annexure1) entered into with the respondent No.1 for construction of International Cricket Stadium at
Narsingarh, Agartala, Tripura bearing agreement No.01/TCA/AGT/TEC/17-18 for an agreed
value of Rs.185,13,18,958/- to be completed within a stipulated period of 24 months from
the date of commencement of the said work, i.e. 22.08.2017.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that petitioner is a
construction company engaged in Government Civil Contracts and other road, building
construction projects, highway and bridge projects etc. The first Running Account (RA) bill
along with GST was submitted by the petitioner vide letter dated 15.03.2018 and after
payment of 1st and 2nd RA bills of additional work, the respondent authority stopped the
payment of RA bills without any valid reason. After long persuasion, the respondent paid the
said pending RA bills up to 8th RA bill, but the 9th and 10th RA bills are still pending
amounting to Rs.16,89,24,475/- though the petitioner has completed the work within the
time limit. The construction work is still pending due to complete inaction on the part of the
respondents such as pendency of bills, availability of work, funds, design and drawing etc.
By letter dated 05.12.2018 issued by the respondent-Association, the work was stopped.
After the Covid-19 pandemic, the progress of work got interrupted and came to a standstill
till May, 2021. Though the petitioner has approached the Executive Engineer-cum-Engineerin-Charge seeking payment of pending bills and in connection with long pending disputes
comprising administrative, financial and technical in nature vide letter dated 05.11.2021 and
also invoked Clause 22.1 of the Conditions of Contract, but the Executive Engineer-cumEngineer-in-Charge failed to give any response within the stipulated period of 20 days.
Thereafter, the petitioner was compelled to invoke Clause 22.2 of the Conditions of Contract
which provides for an arbitration clause by requesting the respondent-President, TCA,
Agartala, West Tripura for appointment of an arbitrator for adjudicating the matters in
dispute as reflected in their financial claims at para-2.0. This letter also remained totally
unresponded. Thereafter, petitioner sent a reminder letter to the General Secretary of the
Association with a request to release the outstanding payments. However, since the request
of the petitioner made in terms of Clause-22.2 of the agreement dated 10.04.2017 remained
unresponded, petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court for appointment of an
independent arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
4.
Respondents have appeared on notice. A counter affidavit has been filed by
respondents No.1 to 3 inter alia, making the following statements:
In reply to paragraphs-1 to 6 of the petition, it has been stated that separate
work order was issued for all the additional works awarded to the petitioner whose value
was not included in the Agreement for construction of the International Cricket Stadium at
Narsingarh. However, payments had already been done to the petitioner for undertaking
such additional works separately.
With regard to statements made at paragraphs-7 to 9 of the petition, it is
stated that first advance payment against bills submitted by the petitioner for an amount of
Rs.10,00,00,000/- was made on 15.10.2018. The Association took up the matter of full
payment of the 1st and 2nd R.A. bills. The agency had submitted its 3rd bill on 03.12.2020 for
an amount of Rs.3,26,24,392/- at that stage. Certain observations were made while disposing
the bills.
Accordingly, respondents had started recording measurements by TCA
officials in MB. Till action in that respect matured, payments of running bills were allowed
on the basis of submission of the petitioner-company. The action matured at the stage of 5th
RA bill and thereafter the respondents started bill verification in terms of the agreement and
those recorded in MB and undertook adjustment of excess payments. Statement of payment
of running bills has been furnished under paragraph-4 in a tabular chart against 3rd RA, 4th
RA, 5th RA, 6th RA, 7th RA and 8th RA on different dates between 20.02.2021 till 03.03.2023.
Respondents further state that during disposal of 9th RA bill, it was found that there was an
advance payment of Rs.12.99 crores against extra item of LED light high mast proposed by
the petitioner-company vide letter dated 17.02.2023 and approval communicated by the
Secretary, TCA vide letter dated 10.03.2023 with a condition of 50% advance as against
agreement item value of Rs.25.986 crores. General Body had taken a decision to refer the
matter to Special Investigation Team constituted by the High Court of Tripura to examine its
correctness, authority and to exercise due scrutiny. Therefore, in the review meeting dated
12.03.2024 it was decided to keep the execution of this item stayed until further decision. It
was also decided to continue the construction work of stadium as per agreement items.
Accordingly, 75% of net payable amount against 9th RA bill has been paid for an amount of
Rs.2,33,68,952/- and only Rs.77,89,651/- is due as on date. Regarding 10th RA bill, it is
stated that the bill statement submitted to TCA on 03.12.2023 has not been found in the
office of the respondents. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that this bill is dated
02.12.2023 instead of 03.12.2023.
It is further stated that this bill statement has been received for the first time
as an enclosure to the petition of arbitration submitted before this Court. In the review
meeting dated 12.03.2024 the matter of payment against 10th RA bill was also discussed.
Petitioner's authorized representative has not come to the office of the respondents for its
verification. The bill has been examined and recorded in the MB by the respondent's
officials on the basis of actual work done and entitlement as per agreement. All other
miscellaneous claims including some portion which were specifically rejected earlier would
remain as not entitled and rejected.
Respondents further state that after issuance of the letter dated 08.04.2024,
the authorized representative of the petitioner had attended office of the respondents and put
their signatures in concurrence to the measurement accorded by respondent's officials and
bill prepared thereon and the payment so released.
Learned counsel for the respondents submits that the payment against RA
bills has been delayed for which respondents are not responsible at all. Respondents have
given relaxation to the petitioner by making payments against RA bills beyond the condition
of the contract, such as Clause-43: Schedule of payment-The value of RA bills shall not be
less than 10% of the amount of agreement value. However, the decision of the Association
in this regard will be final and binding for smooth progress of the work.
In reply to paragraph-10 of the arbitration petition, it is stated that there is no
pendency of bills. Preparation of RA bills and disbursement of payment from TCA has
already been done as per progress of the work. There is no shortage of working funds with
the respondents. The respondent is financially sound and in a position to complete the work
as per agreement. There is no shortage of design and drawing at site to continue the work as
per agreement. It is also mentioned that due to poor labour strength the work is progressing
sluggishly.
In a tabular chart under paragraph-6 of the Counter Affidavit, the respondents
have given their response to the different claims raised by the petitioner and as considered
by the respondents on 05.11.2020. It is also stated that even after submission of the letter
dated 05.11.2021, the petitioner preferred to continue the work under constant monitoring
from the respondent side and regular running payments inclusive secured advance were
given at different intervals.
Learned counsel for the respondents has also referred to Clause-22.1 and
Clause-22.2. Clause-22.1 relates to request before the Engineer-in-Charge for adjudication
which should be responded within 20 days time of the date of written notice. It is contended
that petitioner submitted his letter on 05.11.2021 way back in the year 2021 under Clause22.1 but in the absence of any decision by the Engineer-in-Charge in writing within the
period of 20 days, the petitioner had submitted a letter on 06.12.2021 invoking Clause-22.2
of the agreement beyond the 15 days appeal period as per Clause-22.2. The respondents
have sent a reply on 12.01.2022 responding claim-wise to the petitioner. Petitioner had again
after two years made a request on 02.12.2023 to the General Secretary wherein he had only
put forward his claim before the respondents and nowhere referred to his request for
appointment of arbitrator which is contrary to the agreement. Therefore, the present
reference by the petitioner for seeking arbitration by linking the letter dated 05/06.11.2021 is
not maintainable at the present stage. If the petitioner has any legitimate point of dispute, he
can complete the work or determine the contract and make fresh application for the
arbitration under Clause-22.1. That will provide equal opportunity for presenting claims and
counter claims on issues of disputes, if any, by both the parties.
Respondents have under paragraph-9 of the counter affidavit given their
comments on the total number of 11 claims submitted by the petitioner which are extracted
hereunder:
Sl.
No.
1.
Description
Claim Amount
Comments of the Respondents
Balance payment
of 9th RA
Payment against
10th RA
Rs.03,48,72,333.00
3.
Payment against
Secured Advance
Rs.08,56,80,112.00
4.
Payment against
Rs.02,16,23,702.00
As on date only Rs.77,89,651.00 is
balance
Bill submitted by RKSCPL has
been verified in terms of actual
measurement and entitlement in
terms of Agreement. Correct value
of bill is Rs.6.68 crores. After
adjustment of recoveries payable
amount is Rs.3.29 crores. 80%
payment already done. As on date
only Rs.65,90,405.00 is due.
This claim is on extra item of work
on LED light installation in
substitution of Agreement item for
Metal Halide light, of course, for
the same level of illumination/
brightness as essential for cricket
matches. The validity of this extra
item is under question on
correctness in terms of the
agreement. The matter would be
reviewed towards correctness in
terms of the agreement and referred
to
Special Investigation Team
constituted by the High Court of
Tripura.
Pending Investigation by SIT
and review toward correctness the
execution of this extra item has
been kept stayed.
An advance for an amount of
Rs.12.99 crores has been paid
against the extra item, as put under
question as said above, the advance
payment is much higher than this
claim of secured advance by
RKSCPL. So, there are 3 issuesi) Approval of the item itself is
not tenable in terms of
the
Agreement.
ii) The advance payment already
made
is
recoverable
from
RKSCPL.
iii) Work has to be executed as
per agreement item specification.
LED light may be taken back by
RKSCPL.
Rust removal is already included in
2.
Rs.13,40,52,142.00
rust removal
5.
Payment against
SD
6.
Payment
against Rs.01,18,80,990.00
wrong calculation
of account section
of TCA
Payment
against Rs.41,16,59,835.00
GST
7.
Rs.04,22,35,245.00
8.
Payment
against Rs.24,78,91,297.00
Escalation as per
10CC & 10CA
9.
Payment
against Rs.21,29,81,316.00
Idle charges
10.
Payment
against Rs.51,57,26,877.00
Opportunity losses
11.
Payment
against Rs.12,45,01,955.00
other claims
the compensation allowed for idle
time for suspension of work. The
total agreed compensation value
has already been paid, though
RKSCPL yet to give final statement
of actual work loss.
As per decision taken in the
meeting dated 05.11.2020, TCA
reviewed the matter and found that,
the circular of GOI is not applicable
for TCA. Hence, TCA denied the
request.
It is under examination in accounts
section of TCA.
As per provision of the Agreement
all taxes and levies are included in
the rate quoted by RKSCPL.
Hence, this item also not eligible
for payment. It is mis claim.
Compensation due to price
variation for 15 months of work
suspension period has already been
allowed. The agreement is for fixed
and firm price. Therefore, price
variation is not eligible in terms of
the agreement. The agreement has
no provision for 10CA & 10CC as
used by RKSCPL in its claim.
An amount of Rs.5.50 crores has
been paid to RKSCPL for idle of
resources for held up of work for
15 months. After that there is no
idling of resources, only there is
delay of work for reasons
attributable to RKSCPL.
TCA has not withdrawn from the
contract. RKSCPL has already
executed work for an amount of
Rs.114.00 crores out of total
tendered amount of Rs.185.00
crores and on work for the rest of
work slowly. So, there is no
question of opportunity loss on the
part of RKSCPL. Rather TCA has
suffered opportunity loss.
This is a fictitious claim without
any foundation.
At paragraph-10 of the counter affidavit, they have also given a brief counter
claim against the petitioner which are as under:
(i)
Penalty for delayed performance under clause no.46 (GCC)-Rs.18,51,31,896.00
(ii)
Return of compensation paid against agreement
dated 05.11.2020 as performance schedule has
not been maintainedRs.13,00,00,000.00
(iii)
Opportunity loss by losing scope of 2(two) international
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
matches and 2 IPL matchesDue interest on mobilization advancePayment of consultant due to holding of workLoss of income tax relief for such delayed payment-
(vii)
Loss due to idle investment loss of interest-
(viii)
Loss due to underutilization of TCA Staff,
vehicle & monitoring expenses-
Rs.70,00,00,000.00
Rs. 1,14,51,900.00
Rs. 1,50,00,000.00
Rs.11,00,00,000.00
(approx.)
Rs.27,65,00,000.00
(approx.)
Rs. 5,00,00,000.00
Total=Rs.147,80,83,796.00
Based on these averments, learned counsel for the respondents submits that
the instant arbitration petition has been preferred after two years of the invocation of Clause22.2 by the petitioner on 06.12.2021 before the President, TCA. As such, the claim is not
alive. This Court in such circumstances should not exercise its jurisdiction under Section
11(6) of the Act to appoint an arbitrator as there is no explanation for invoking the
jurisdiction of this Court after about two years of delay. Learned counsel for the respondents
further submits that certain claims have been added in the request letter dated 06.12.2021
which were not initially claimed. As such, those claims are beyond the purview of reference
to the learned arbitrator. Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the work
has not yet been fully executed. Payments have been made in favour of the petitioner from
time to time. The respondents have also taken steps to address the grievances and claims
raised by the petitioner which are genuine over a period of time. As such, the cause of action
is not ripe for reference of the dispute to an independent arbitrator. After about two years of
issuance of a letter of request made under Clause-22.2 to the President, TCA, petitioner has
made a representation to the General Secretary, TCA instead of the appropriate authority. As
such, petitioner is himself not clear as to the arbitrability of the disputes being raised.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has, in reply, straightway relied upon the
decision rendered by the Apex Court on the question of delay in approaching the Court
rendered in the case of M/S Arif Azim Co. Ltd. Vrs. M/S Aptech Ltd. [Arbitration Petition
No.29 of 2023 decided on 01.03.2024]. He has referred to paragraphs-52 and 53 of the
judgment wherein the Apex Court has dealt with the issue as to when does the right to apply
under Section 11(6) accrue. It has been held that the limitation period for filing an
application seeking appointment of arbitrator commences only after a valid notice invoking
arbitration has been issued by one of the parties to the other party and there has been either a
failure or refusal on the part of the other party to make an appointment as per the
appointment procedure agreed upon between the parties. It has been further held that since
no specific period of limitation has been prescribed for making a request under Section 11(6)
to the Court to take the necessary measure for appointing an arbitrator, therefore, Article 137
of the Limitation Act, 1963 which provides the limitation period of three years for filing any
other application for which no period of limitation is provided elsewhere being a residuary
article can be applied. The present arbitration petition was filed on 25.01.2024 which was
well within the time period of 3 years provided by Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963
from the date of the first notice invoking Clause-22.2 on 06.12.2021 to the respondentPresident, TCA. He submits that the present case is fully covered by the ratio rendered in the
case of M/S Arif Azim Co. Ltd. (supra) by the Apex Court. It is further submitted that the
averments in the counter affidavit filed by the respondents only give an indication that the
dispute arising out of the agreement dated 10.04.2017 exists. Since the agreement under
Clause-22.2 provides for an arbitration clause, which the petitioner has invoked vide letter
dated 06.12.2021, the present petition is wholly maintainable. It is further submitted that this
Court in an application under Section 11(6) of the Act is not required to enter into the merits
of the dispute between the parties as it lies within the sole jurisdiction of the arbitrator.
Parties are at liberty to raise their claims and counter claims which have to be determined in
accordance with law on the basis of the pleadings and evidence produced by the parties.
Therefore, this Court may appoint an independent arbitrator to decide the dispute between
the parties in terms of Clause-22.2 of the agreement.
6.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and also
taken note of the pleadings placed from the record in the foregoing part of the order.
The agreement dated 10.04.2017 was executed between the parties for
construction of an International Cricket stadium at Narsingarh, Agartala, Tripura for agreed
value of Rs.185,13,18,958/- to be completed within a stipulated period of 24 months from
the date of commencement of the said work is accepted by both the parties.
7.
Clause-22 relates to settlement of disputes and is extracted hereunder:
"22. Settlement of disputes:
22.1 If any dispute or difference of any kind whatsoever arises
between the department and the Contractor in connection with, or arising out
of the Contract at stage, whether during the progress of the works or after
their completion and whether before or after the termination, abandonment or
breach of the contract, it shall in the first place, be referred to and settled by
the Engineer-in-charge who shall, within a period of twenty days after being
requested by the Contractor to do so, give written notice of his decision to the
Contractor. Upon receipt of the written notice of the decision of the Engineerin-Charge the Contractor shall promptly proceed without delay to comply
with such notice of decision.
22.2 If the Engineer-in-Charge fails to give notice of his decision in
writing within a period of twenty days after being requested or if the
Contractor is dissatisfied with the notice of the decision of the Engineer-inCharge, the Contractor may within fifteen days after receiving the notice of
decision appeal to the concerned President, Tripura Cricket Association who
shall refer the matter or matters in dispute to the arbitrator & the arbitrator
will be appointed by the President, Tripura Cricket Association.
22.3 It is also a term of contract that the party in invoking
arbitration shall specify the dispute or disputes to be referred to arbitration
under this clause together with the amount or amounts claimed in the respects
of each such dispute."
8.
The pleadings of the parties clearly indicate existence of a dispute on the
claims raised by the petitioner and also certain counter claims raised by the respondents
which have been extracted hereinabove. This Court in exercise of the powers conferred
under Section 11(6) of the Act is not required to get into the merits of the disputes, claims or
counter claims raised by the parties. If an arbitrable dispute exists and the procedure for
invoking the arbitration clause has been followed, the Court exercising powers under
Section 11(6), on being satisfied, is required to appoint an independent arbitrator to
adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
9.
A plea has been raised by the respondents that the petitioner had invoked the
arbitration clause 22.2 vide letter dated 06.12.2021 before the President, TCA (Annexure-5)
after the Engineer-in-charge had failed to take any decision on his request in terms of
Clause-22.1 made through letter dated 05.11.2021 within the stipulated period of 20 days.
Petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court under Section 11(6) of the Act of 1996
after two years by way of this application filed on 31.01.2024. Therefore, and also for the
reason that petitioner had later on made a request for settlement of his claim before the
General Secretary of the Association on 02.12.2023, the instant application is barred by
time. In the case of M/S Arif Azim Co. Ltd. (supra), while dealing with the issue relating to
the period for filing an application for appointment of arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the
Act from the date of the request made under the arbitration clause under the agreement to the
respondents for appointment of an arbitrator, it has been held that since no period of
limitation has been provided therein, the period of limitation should be held as 3 years as per
Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 i.e. the residuary clause. Going by the ratio rendered
by the Apex Court in the case of M/S Arif Azim Co. Ltd. (supra), the instant petition cannot
be said to be barred by delay as it has been filed within 3 years period from the date of
invocation of Clause-22.2 vide letter dated 06.12.2021 addressed to the President, TCA for
appointment of an arbitrator in respect of the claims raised by the petitioner. As such, this
plea is fit to be rejected.
10.
Respondents have also taken a plea that against the RA bills raised by the
petitioner, payments have been made from time to time. The work has not yet been
completed. As such, the instant petition is premature. A bare reference to Clause-22.1
relating to settlement of disputes extracted above leaves no room for doubt that dispute or
difference of any kind whatsoever as arises between the department and the Contractor in
connection with, or arising out of the contract at stage, whether during the progress of the
work or after their completion and whether before or after the termination, abandonment or
breach of the contract, shall be in the first place referred to and settled by the Engineer-incharge who shall within a period of twenty days of such request being made, give written
notice of his decision to the contractor. Clause-22.2 provides that if the Engineer-in-Charge
fails to give notice of his decision in writing within a period of twenty days after being
requested or if the contractor is dissatisfied with the notice of the decision of the Engineerin-Charge, the contractor may within 15 days after receiving the notice of decision, appeal to
the concerned President of the TCA who shall refer the matter in dispute to the arbitrator and
the arbitrator will be appointed by the President of the TCA. As such, the contention raised
by the respondents that certain payments have been made from time to time against the
Running Account bills and that the work has not yet been completed and, therefore, the
dispute being raised for arbitration is premature, is not in accordance with the agreed terms
laid down under Clause-22.1 of the agreement between the parties. Dispute or difference, if
any, arising out of the contract of any kind at a stage even during the progress of the work or
after completion of the work or even before or after the termination, abandonment or breach
of the contract can be raised by the contractor by following the procedure prescribed under
Clause-22.1 followed by Clause-22.2 of the agreement. As such, the instant plea is also fit to
be rejected. Since the arbitration clause under the agreement between the parties provides for
adjudication of the dispute through arbitration and there exists an arbitrable dispute between
the parties as borne out from the pleadings referred to hereinabove and that the petitioner has
followed the procedure prescribed under Clause-22.1 followed by Clause-22.2 of the
agreement and further that the instant arbitration petition has been filed within 3 years of the
date of request made by the petitioner for appointment of an arbitrator in terms of Clause22.2 vide his letter dated 06.12.2021, this Court is satisfied that all the ingredients for
invocation of jurisdiction of this Court for appointment of an independent arbitrator for
adjudication of the dispute between the parties is made out.[See SBI General Insurance Co.
Ltd. Vs. Krish Spinning, reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1754].
11.
As indicated above, Clause-22.2 relates to appointment of an arbitrator.
Respondents in their counter affidavit have while referring to Clause-22.2 at page-108 also
made a statement that minutes of the Pre-bid meeting held on 17.10.2016 has been made a
part of the contract. It states that there shall be 3 arbitrators, out of which one each shall be
appointed by both the parties and the two so appointed arbitrators shall appoint a third
arbitrator/ principal arbitrator on mutual agreement. Copy of the agreement at Annexure-1 at
page-11 refers to the nature of work, the agreement number and other clauses relating to the
estimated cost, agreement amount, the stipulated time for completion as also the contents of
the agreement which is as under:
"THIS AGREEMENT CONTAINS 3(THREE) PART.
Part-A Containing Volume-I-General bid document, Minutes of the
Pre-bid Meeting, Amendment and queries, Technical bid submitted by the
Agency, work programme submitted by the Agency.
Containing 954 Pages.
Part-B Containing Section-V-Technical Specification and Drawings.
Containing 398 Pages.
Part-C Volume-III-(Amended Price bid submitted by Agency),
Amendment and queries, Letter No.RKSCPL/TCA/16-17/002 dated 28th
March, 2017 of Agency offering rebate, acceptance letter, Volume-III (Pricebid before Amendment).
Containing 645 Pages."
12.
Since the entire minutes of the Pre-bid meeting which are contained in
Volume-I of the agreement were not annexed to the arbitration application, the respondentAssociation has produced the Part-A of the agreement which is Volume-I, i.e. General bid
document, Minutes of the Pre-bid Meeting, Amendment and queries, Technical bid
submitted by the Agency, work programme submitted by the Agency. Minutes of the Prebid meeting held on 17.10.2016 at TCA office complex with the representatives of the
different firms are at pages-93 and 95 thereof. The relevant queries and the
replies/clarification and the amendment thereof to be treated as part of the agreement are
annexed in the subsequent pages of this Part-A. The minutes dated 21.10.2016 are also
extracted hereunder:
"No.F.29/TCA/AGT/607
Dated:-Agartala, 21/10/2016.
Minutes of pre-bid meeting was held on 17/10/2016 at TCA office
Complex in-connection with "Construction of International Cricket
Stadium at Narshingarh, Agartala, Tripura".
At the outset the President, TCA, for and on behalf of the TCA,
welcomed all the representatives of different firms for attending the pre-bid
meeting and expressed gratitude for taking keen interest in implementing the
project "Construction of International Cricket Stadium at Narshingarh,
Agartala" and seeking Co-operation from all concerned.
Queries received/raised by different agencies were discussed in the
meeting and it was informed that the reply to the queries will be uploaded in
the Website of TCA and also be communicated to the agencies/ representative
of agencies who have attended the pre-bid meeting.
One of the prime decision taken in the pre-bid meeting considering
the Diwali holidays that dropping/receiving dates of Tender shall be from
09/11/2016 to 16/11/2016 instead of 24/10/2016 To 02/11/2016 (Between
11:00 Hrs. To 15:00 Hrs. on working days only). Places for receiving Bids is
unchanged i.e. (1) office of the Tripura Cricket Association, Post Office
Chowmuhani, Agartala, Tripura, PIN-799001. (2) Office of the Chief
Resident Commissioner, Tripura Bhawan, Kautilaya Marg, Chanakyapuri,
New Delhi-21. (3) Office of the Addl. Resident Commissioner, Tripura
Bhawan, 1-Pretoria Street, Kolkata-700071. Also it has been decided that
queries on the Bid Document shall be received upto 24/10/2016 and TCA
shall furnish the clarification on 31/10/2016 (if possible) including
amendment if any.
The period of sale of bidding documents has also been extended up-to
14/11/2016 up-to 16.00 hours and place of sale of Bidding document is Office
of the Tripura Cricket Association, Post Office Chowmuhani, Agartala, Pin799001, Tripura.
The date of opening of Technical Bid shall be on 21/11/2016 on 15:30
hours at the office of TCA.
Regarding Earnest money deposit it has been clarified that the
Tenderer shall furnish requisite Earnest money deposit along with the Tender
in the form of a Bank demand draft on any scheduled Bank/Nationalised
Bank in favour of Hony. General Secretary, TCA (Earnest money other than
bank demand draft shall not be accepted).
The Minutes of the pre-bid meeting and reply of queries/ clarification
and the amendment will be part of the agreement.
The pre-bid meeting ended with thanks to all.
Sd/-(21/10/2016)
(Sourav Dasgupta)
Hony. General Secretary
Tripura Cricket Association
Agartala, Tripura."
13.
The relevant query relating to Clause-22.2 is at page-119 of this Volume-I
relating to the number of arbitrators to be appointed under Clause-22.2. The clarification of
the respondent-TCA thereunder in the last column of the query No.85 clearly indicates that
the arbitration shall be conducted as per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by
appointing 3(three) arbitrators-one each by both the parties and third arbitrator/principal
arbitrator shall be appointed by the two arbitrators on mutual agreement. The seat of
arbitration shall be in Agartala. Regarding settlement of disputes, other conditions under
Clause 22 page 46 shall prevail. The query and its clarification by TCA at query No.85 and
its clarification by the TCA at page-119 of Part-A of the agreement is also extracted
hereunder:
Clause
Sl. Referenc
No e
.
85. Conditio
n of
Contract
CL-22.2
Pa Tender
ge Clause
No.
Arbitrati
on
Existing Clause/
Description/Provi
sion as per BidDocument
Sole arbitrator
will be appointed
by TCA.
Queries/Request for
Amendment
Clarificati
on of TCA
The arbitration shall
be
conducted
in
accordance with the
provisions of the
Arbitration
and
Conciliation
(Amendment)
Act,
2015 (No.3 of 2016)
or
any
statutory
modifications or reenactment thereof and
the
rules
made
thereunder.
There
shall
be
three
Arbitrators, one each
would be appointed by
both the parties and
third arbitrator would
be appointed by other
two whose decision
will be final and
binding on both the
parties.
Please
confirm.
The
arbitration
shall be
conducted
as per the
arbitration
&
conciliatio
n act, 1996
by
appointing
03 (three)
arbitratorone each
by the both
party and
third
arbitrator/
principal
arbitrator
shall be
appointed
by the two
arbitrator
on mutual
agreement.
The seat of
arbitration
shall be in
AGARTA
LA.
Regarding
settlement
of disputes
other
conditions
under
clause 22
page 46
shall
prevail.
14.
It, therefore, follows that the mechanism provided under arbitration clause
22.2 has to be read along with the pre-bid queries and clarification which form Part-A of the
agreement contained in Volume-I. As such, this Court proposes to appoint two independent
arbitrators who shall thereafter appoint the third arbitrator/principal arbitrator by their
mutual agreement.
15.
I, therefore, propose to appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya,
former Judge of the Supreme Court of India and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Permod Kohli, former
Chief Justice, Sikkim High Court as the arbitrators to decide the dispute between the parties.
The proposed arbitrators are requested to submit their consent and a
declaration in terms of Section 12 read with Schedule VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996.
The Registry shall communicate this order to the proposed arbitrators.
As per the stipulated procedure between the parties, upon obtaining their
consent and appointment as arbitrator, both the arbitrators are required to appoint the third
arbitrator by their mutual consent.
Let Part-A of the agreement containing Vol-I-General bid document, Minutes
of the Pre-bid meeting, Amendment and queries, Technical bid submitted by the Agency,
work programme submitted by the Agency as produced by the respondents be kept along
with the record.
Let the matter appear on 09.08.2024."
4.
Pursuant to the order dated 12.07.2024, this Court proposed to
appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya, former Judge of the Supreme
Court of India and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Permod Kohli, former Chief Justice,
Sikkim High Court as arbitrators. The proposed Arbitrators have submitted
their consent along with declaration under Schedule-VI of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
5.
Learned counsel for the parties, therefore, submit that this Court
may appoint them as arbitrators who may appoint the third Arbitrator so that
the dispute between the parties may be adjudicated by the three member panel
of Arbitrators as per the terms of the Agreement.
6.
In view of the consent and declaration submitted by the proposed
Arbitrators, I, hereby, appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya, former
Judge of the Supreme Court of India and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Permod Kohli,
former Chief Justice, Sikkim High Court, as Arbitrators to adjudicate the
dispute between the parties. Learned Arbitrators are requested to take into
consideration the Schedule of Model Fee prescribed under Schedule IV and the
timeline prescribed under Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 as amended. Learned Arbitrators would also proceed to appoint the third
Arbitrator so that the dispute can be adjudicated by the panel of three
Arbitrators as per the terms and conditions of the agreement arrived at between
the parties.
7.
Learned counsel for the parties have supplied the e-mail address
and phone number of the respective parties. These are indicated hereunder for
convenience of the learned Arbitrators in conducting the proceedings:
Petitioner:
e-mail i.d.
:
Phone no. :
Respondent:
e-mail i.d.
Phone no.
8.
:
:
ynathrai@gmail.com
3aaa3group@gmail.com
8638916270
tcaagt@yahoo.com
9774144215
Registry is directed to communicate the instant order along with a
copy of the entire pleadings of the instant application to the Learned
Arbitrators forthwith.
9.
The instant petition stands allowed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
SIDDHARTHA LODH
LODH
Date: 2024.08.16 15:56:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review