Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010266352017
2026:GAU-AS:12174
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5044/2017
RAKHAL CHANDRA DEB
S/O LT. SURENDRA CHANDRA DEB R/O BASBARI PATHAR P.S.
DIBRUGARH, DIST. DIBRUGARH, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE DIBRUGARH UNIVERSITY and 2 ORS.
REP. BY THE REGISTRAR, DIBRUGARH UNIVERSITY, DIBRUGARH.
2:EXECUTIVE COUNCIL
REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN
DIBRUGARH UNIVERSITY
DIBRUGARH
REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN.
3:THE REGISTRAR
DIBRUGARH UNIVERSITY
DIBRUGARH
Advocate for the Petitioner
DUTTA,MR.S DUTTA
: MS.N MODI, MR.C SHARMA,MR.N KALITA,MR.S
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. K GOGOI, SC, DIB. UNIVERSITY
Page No.# 2/15
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
:
:
:
Mr. Sishir Dutta, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Dutta, Advocate
Mr. K. Gogoi, Advocate
24th August, 2026
24th August, 2026
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part of
the judgment?
:
NA
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced
:
NA
Judgment and Order (ORAL)
Heard Mr. S Dutta, Learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. S Dutta,
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner. Also heard Mr. K Gogoi, Learned Standing
Counsel, Dibrugarh University, Assam.
2.
The Petitioner, by way of instituting the present Writ Petition, has
presented a challenge to an order dated 31.12.2004, issued towards imposing
upon him a penalty of Compulsory Retirement, w.e.f 31.12.2004, on
conclusion of a departmental proceeding instituted against the Petitioner.
3.
The facts, in brief, requisite for adjudication of the issue is noticed,
here-in-below:-
Page No.# 3/15
3.1.
The petitioner was initially recruited to the service of the Dibrugarh
University as a Typist on 15-03-1967. The Petitioner, advancing in his service
career, on promotion, came to hold the post of Section Officer, Examination
Branch, in the University, w.e.f. 31-12-2004. A show-cause notice dated 02-062003, came to be issued to the petitioner framing against him 05 (five) charges.
The charges, so framed, pertain to the manner in which the bills of a printing
press, viz. M/s Padmini Printing Press, Dibrugarh, were so cleared.
3.2.
The petitioner on receipt of the said show-cause notice, submitted
written statement, thereto, denying the charges levelled against him, as well as
placing his clarifications against the allegations so levelled against him. It is to
be noted that along with the petitioner, basing on similar allegations, showcause notices came to be issued to four other employees/ officials of the
University, working in the Examination Branch. The written statement off all the
delinquents involved, including the petitioner, being received and perused, the
same not being found to be satisfactory, the Disciplinary Authority of the
petitioner and the other delinquents, proceeded to constitute a three member
Enquiry Committee, to conduct a joint Departmental Enquiry into the charges
framed against the petitioner and the other delinquents. A Presenting Officer
was also appointed for the purpose. Thereafter, the Enquiry Committee
conducted the enquiry and the petitioner participated, therein.
Page No.# 4/15
3.3.
On conclusion of the enquiry, the Enquiry Committee submitted its
enquiry report on 14-07-2004. With regard to charges framed against the
petitioner, vide the show-cause notice dated 02-06-2003, in the enquiry report,
it was held that the charge Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5, stood established, while the
charge No. 3, was held to have not been established.
3.4.
The said enquiry report came to be placed before the Executive
Council, of the Dibrugarh University. The Executive Council, on consideration of
the enquiry report, with regard to the petitioner, directed for imposition of
penalty of Compulsory Retirement upon him. Accordingly, the Registrar of
Dibrugarh University, vide order dated 31-12-2004, proceeded to impose upon
the petitioner the penalty of Compulsory Retirement from service, with
immediate effect. The petitioner, thereafter, assailed the order dated 31-122004, before this Court, by way of instituting a writ petition being W.P.(C) No.
3051/2005. In the said Writ Petition, the order dated 31.12.2004, was also
assailed on the ground, that prior to consideration by the Disciplinary Authority
of the enquiry report and arriving at a decision with regard to the penalty
required to be imposed upon the petitioner, a copy of the enquiry report was
not forwarded to the petitioner for his comments. It is to be noted that two
further writ petitions being W.P.(C) No. 1750/2005 and W.P.(C) No. 2406/2005,
also came to be so instituted by other delinquent employees, who were also
Page No.# 5/15
involved in the joint enquiry held in the matter. This Court, vide order dated 0902-2015, proceeded to dispose of the said writ petitions, by holding that the
penalty imposed upon the petitioners, therein, stood vitiated, on the ground
that a copy of the enquiry report was not furnished to the Petitioners, before
the same was considered by the disciplinary authority. Accordingly, the order of
penalty dated 31-12-2004, insofar as, it concerns the writ petitioner, herein, was
set aside and the matter was remanded to the Disciplinary Authority for a fresh
decision. The petitioner, vide his representation dated 13-03-2015, placed the
judgment and order dated 09-02-2015, passed in W.P.(C) No. 3051/2005, before
the Registrar, Dibrugarh University.
3.5.
Thereafter, basing on a decision arrived at in the matter by the
Executive Council, the Registrar, Dibrugarh University, vide communication dated
19.09.2016, required the Petitioner to show cause, as to why the penalty of
Compulsory Retirement from service of the Dibrugarh University, as earlier
imposed upon him, be not retained. The petitioner submitted reply, thereto, on
04-10-2016. Thereafter, the matter was placed before the Executive Council of
the University in its meeting held on 24-10-2016 and under Resolution No. 26, a
decision was arrived at to impose the penalty of “Compulsory Retirement” w.e.f.
31-12-2004, upon the Petitioner.
Page No.# 6/15
Being aggrieved, the Petitioner has instituted the present Writ Petition.
3.6
The Learned Counsel for the Parties, during the hearing of this Writ
Petition, had apprised this Court that the Executive Council of the University, in
its 355th meeting held on 26.09.2023, had revisited the penalty imposed upon
the Petitioner. On such reconsideration, while maintaining the penalty of
“Compulsory Retirement”, as imposed upon the Petitioner, the Executive Council
of the University had modified the date of imposition of the penalty from
“31.12.2004” to “10.11.2016”.
4.
This Court had heard the matter and had reserved it for judgment.
However, during the passing of the judgment, it had come to the notice of this
Court, that the Petitioner, in the present Writ Petition, had retired from his
services on 30.04.2009. Accordingly, an issue had arisen as to whether, the
penalty of Compulsory Retirement could have been imposed upon the
Petitioner after his superannuation from his services. The matter was then
again listed for hearing and the Learned Counsel for the Parties were heard at
length.
5.
Mr. S Dutta, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submits that
the penalty of “Compulsory Retirement” was not permissible to be imposed
upon the Petitioner, after he had superannuated from his services. Mr. S Dutta,
Page No.# 7/15
Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submits that the Petitioner, in the
present Writ Petition, had retired from his services, on reaching the age of
superannuation, w.e.f 30.04.2009. Mr. S Dutta, Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioner, further submits that in terms of the provisions of the Dibrugarh
University Employees’ Service Condition Ordinance, 2000, the penalty of
“Compulsory Retirement” is a penalty that would be permissible to be imposed
upon an Officer/Employee of the University, during the currency of his service
in the University. He submits that the said penalty would not be permissible to
be so imposed after the Officer/Employee concerned had superannuated from
his services. Mr. S Dutta, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submits
that in the said Ordinance of 2000, no provision has been made for continuing
an employee in service after his superannuation, for the purpose of conduct of
a departmental proceeding against him. Accordingly, Mr. S Dutta, Learned
Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submits that the Petitioner having
superannuated from his service on 30.04.2009, the penalty of Compulsory
Retirement was not permissible to be so imposed upon him.
6.
Mr. S Dutta, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner in support of
his submissions, has placed reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of UCO Bank & Ors. v. Prabhakar Sadashiv Karvade
reported in (2018) 14 SCC 98.
Page No.# 8/15
7.
Mr. K Gogoi, Learned Standing Counsel, Dibrugarh University,
Assam, has submitted that in the said Ordinance of 2000, no provision has
been made for the purpose of facilitating imposition of a penalty upon an
Officer/Employee
of
the
University,
after
such
Officer/Employee
had
superannuated from his or her service. Mr. K Gogoi, Learned Standing Counsel,
Dibrugarh University, Assam, however, submits that the penalty, as imposed
upon the Petitioner, vide the order dated 10.11.2016, having been so imposed
with retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f 31.12.2004, the Petitioner being in service
as on 31.12.2004, the said penalty would not mandate an interference from
this Court. Mr. K Gogoi, Learned Standing Counsel, Dibrugarh University,
Assam, has further submitted that in the event, this Court is of the considered
view that the penalty, as imposed upon the Petitioner, vide order dated
10.11.2016, would not mandate an acceptance from this Court and the same
is interfered with, liberty be granted to the Respondent authorities of the
Dibrugarh University, Assam, to impose fresh penalty upon the Petitioner
following the procedure mandated, in this connection.
8.
I have heard the Learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the
materials available on record.
9.
It is not disputed that the Petitioner, on reaching the age of
Page No.# 9/15
superannuation, had retired from his services, w.e.f 30.04.2009. In pursuance
to the departmental proceeding instituted against the Petitioner, he was, vide
an order dated 31.12.2004, imposed that the penalty of “Compulsory
Retirement”, in accordance with the provisions of Clause 33 (vi)(f) of the said
Ordinance of 2000. The said penalty imposed upon the Petitioner was assailed
by him before this Court by way of instituting the Writ Petition being WP(C)
No. 3051/2005.
10.
This Court, vide order dated 09.02.2015, noticing that the prior to
imposition of the said penalty upon the Petitioner, the copy of the Enquiry
Report, was not furnished to him and he was not given an opportunity to
submit a representation, thereon, proceeded to interfere with the said order
dated 31.12.2004. This Court, however, had granted liberty to the Respondent
University, for proceeding in the matter and to take a fresh decision, basing on
the findings of the Enquiry Committee. The Petitioner was permitted to submit
fresh representation before the disciplinary authority against the said Enquiry
Report. After the passing of the said order dated, the Registrar, Dibrugarh
University, Dibrugarh, Assam, issued to the Petitioner, a notice dated
19.09.2016, requiring him to submit his written show-cause reply, as to why
the penalty of Compulsory Retirement from services imposed upon him earlier,
be not retained. The Petitioner submitted his response in the matter on
Page No.# 10/15
04.10.2016. Thereafter, the disciplinary authority of the Petitioner, i.e. the
Executive Council of the University, in its 332 nd meeting held on 24.10.2016,
resolved to impose upon the Petitioner, a penalty of “Compulsory Retirement”,
w.e.f 31.12.2004. In pursuance to the said decision arrived at by the
disciplinary authority of the Petitioner, the penalty, as imposed upon the
Petitioner, was communicated to him by the Registrar of the University, vide
issuance of an order dated 10.11.2016. In terms of the said order dated
10.11.2016, the penalty of “Compulsory Retirement” was imposed upon the
Petitioner, with retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f 31.12.2004.
11.
As noticed, hereinabove, during the pendency of the present Writ
Petition, the disciplinary authority of the Petitioner had again revisited the
penalty of “Compulsory Retirement” imposed upon the Petitioner vide the
order dated 10.11.2016, and on such consideration being made by the
Executive Council in its 355th meeting held on 26.09.2023, the penalty of
Compulsory Retirement was decided to be so imposed upon the Petitioner,
w.e.f “10.11.2016”, in lieu of “31.12.2004”. As already noticed hereinabove,
the Petitioner had retired from his services on 30.04.2009.
12.
Accordingly, it is to be examined by this Court, as to whether the
penalty, as imposed initially upon the Petitioner, vide the order dated
Page No.# 11/15
10.11.2016, would be permissible to be so imposed after he had
superannuated and also as to whether the said penalty was permissible to be
so imposed, with retrospective effect.
13.
This Court has perused the provisions of the Ordinance of 2000
and finds that, therein, there is no provision mandating the imposition of any
of the penalties, as specified under the provisions of Clause 33 (vi), upon an
Officer/Employee of the University, after he had superannuated from his
services. Accordingly, vide the order dated 10.11.2016, the penalty of
“Compulsory Retirement” could not have been imposed upon the Petitioner,
invoking the provisions of the Ordinance of 2000, after he had superannuated
from his services. Further, this Court notices that vide the order dated
10.11.2016, in terms of the decision arrived at in the matter by the disciplinary
authority of the Petitioner, i.e. the Executive Council of the University, the said
penalty was imposed, w.e.f 31.12.2004. The penalty of “Compulsory
Retirement”, as imposed upon the Petitioner, vide the order dated 31.12.2004,
was already interfered with by this Court, vide the judgment and order dated
09.02.2015 in WP(C) No. 3051/2005. This Court, on an interference made in
the said order, required the Respondent authorities to take fresh decision in
the matter, with regard to the penalty that would now be mandated to be
imposed upon the Petitioner. The said decision, as directed, was for the
Page No.# 12/15
purpose of imposing a penalty, if so mandated, with prospective effect and not
one which would have the effect of reviving the already interfered penalty of
“Compulsory Retirement” with retrospective effect. Further, this Court finds
that the provisions of Ordinance of 2000, also does not empower the
Respondent University to impose upon its Officer/Employee, a penalty, with
retrospective effect.
14.
Accordingly, for the above reasons, the order dated 10.11.2016,
cannot be sustained and accordingly, the same would mandate an
interference.
15.
Having drawn the above conclusions, this Court would now
examine the decision of the Executive Council arrived at in its 355 th meeting
held on 26.09.2023, deciding to impose the penalty of “Compulsory
Retirement” upon the Petitioner, w.e.f “10.11.2016”. The said decision in the
considered view of this Court, does not cure the infirmity existing in the order
dated 10.11.2016, and for the reasons assigned, hereinabove, the said penalty
would not be permissible to be so imposed upon the Petitioner, even, w.e.f
10.11.2016, inasmuch as, he had already superannuated from his services,
w.e.f 30.04.2009.
16.
This Court, in support of its conclusions, places reliance on the
Page No.# 13/15
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Prabhakar Sadashiv
Karvade (Supra). Under similar circumstances, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
had drawn the following conclusions :
“9. A reading of the plain language of Regulation 4 of the Discipline and b Appeal
Regulations and Regulation 20(3) (iii) of the 1979 Regulations makes it clear that any of
the penalties, whether major or minor can be imposed only on a serving officer employee
of the Bank. This necessarily implies that none of the penalties specified in Regulation 4
of the Discipline and Appeal Regulations can be imposed on an officer employee after his
retirement from service, though in terms of Regulation 20(3)(iii) of the 1979
Regulations, the disciplinary proceedings initiated against an officer employee before his
retirement can be continued and final order is passed and further that such officer
employee is not entitled to retiral benefits till the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings
and passing of final order. The only exception to this is that the officer is entitled to
receive his own contribution to CPF. However, there is nothing in the language of these
regulations from which it can be inferred that the disciplinary authority has the power to
impose a substantive punishment on retired officer employee. This becomes more more
explicit from a conjoint reading of Regulation 48 of the Pension Regulations which
empowers the competent authority to withhold or withdraw a pension or a part thereof
and order recovery from pension of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the
bank if in a departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty of grave
misconduct or negligence or criminal breach of trust or forgery or acts done fraudulently
during the period of his service. Second proviso to Regulation 48 contains a fiction and
lays down that if the departmental proceedings are instituted while the employee was in
service, the same shall be deemed to be proceedings under the regulations and
continued and concluded as if the employee had continued in service. The third proviso
imposes a bar on the initiation of departmental or judicial proceedings against an
employee after his retirement in respect of an event which took place more than 4 years
before such institution. The sum and substance of these regulations is that even though
a departmental inquiry instituted against an officer employee before his retirement can
continue even after his retirement, none of the substantive penalties specified in
Regulation 4 of 1979 Regulations, which include dismissal from service, can be imposed
on an officer employee after his retirement on attaining the age of superannuation.
Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that order dated 12-10-2004 passed by the
disciplinary authority dismissing the respondent from service, who had superannuated
on 31-12-1993 was ex facie illegal and without jurisdiction and the High Court did not
commit any error by setting aside the same.”
17.
Applying the said decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court to the
facts of the present case, it is clear that the order dated 10.11.2016, cannot be
sustained. Accordingly, the order dated 10.11.2016, along with the subsequent
decision of the Executive Council, as arrived at, in its 355 th meeting held on
26.09.2023, qua the Petitioner, stands set-aside.
Page No.# 14/15
18.
Having interfered with the penalty, as imposed upon the Petitioner,
this Court would now consider the reliefs that would be permissible to be
extended to the Petitioner. The order of penalty having been interfered with,
the Petitioner is deemed to have continued in his services till the date of his
superannuation, which had occasioned
on 30.04.2009. However,
the
interference with the penalty by this court, being on a technicality, this Court is
of the considered view that the Petitioner not having been exonerated from
the charges framed against him, the Petitioner would be deemed to have
continued under suspension, w.e.f the date the initial penalty of Compulsory
Retirement was imposed upon him, vide order dated 31.12.2004. Balancing
the equities in the mater, this Court directs that the Petitioner shall be deemed
to have remained under suspension, w.e.f 31.12.2004, till the date of his
superannuation, which had occasioned on 30.04.2009. The Petitioner,
accordingly, would be entitled to subsistence allowance for the period, he is
now deemed to have been placed under suspension. However, the period for
which the Petitioner is directed to be continued under suspension, would,
however, be reckonable for the purpose of computing the pension and other
pensionary benefits of the Petitioner.
19.
Accordingly, the Respondent/University shall fix the salary of the
Petitioner, as on the date of his superannuation, i.e. on 30.04.2009, by
Page No.# 15/15
notionally fixing the salary, w.e.f the date he was originally placed under
suspension.
20.
Basing on the pay now determined in respect of the Petitioner on
the date of his suspension, the Respondent authorities shall release to the
Petitioner, his due pension and other pensionary benefits, after deducting the
pension and other pensionary benefits, already released to him, in the
meanwhile, along with the arrears of the subsistence allowance, now
becoming due to the Petitioner, in terms of the directions passed, hereinabove.
21.
With the above observations and directions, the present Writ
Petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Mayuraksh
ee Kalita
Comparing Assistant
DN: c=IN, o=Personal, postalCode=781024, l=Kamrup Metro, st=Assam, street=54
AMBIKAGIRI NAGAR, Zoo Road, Dispur Assam India 781024 NEAR SHRISHTI
TAILORS, title=3914,
2.5.4.20=cc2c6557fa3d118dee5666b32bf91efbbbfcdb804fec6e2cfc90850eb73700
ce,
serialNumber=b7e79acf730e99904fe79eda21e1fc9af64f1ae076abe5f4e0713535b1
4482a3, email=mk.ghc25@gmail.com, cn=Mayurakshee Kalita
Date: 2026.08.28 17:13:46 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review