Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 731 of 2012
With
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1359 of 2012
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK Sd/================================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
୰
================================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
KETANKUMAR GUNVANTBHAI PATEL & ANR.
================================================================
Appearance in Criminal Appeal No.731 of 2012
MS JYOTI BHATT ADDL. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR.HARDIK B SHAH(3751) for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 1,2
===========================================================
Appearance in Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012
MS ARCHANA ACHARYA for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR.HARDIK B SHAH(3751) for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 2,3
================================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK
Date : 18/09/2026
COMMON ORAL JUDGMENT
1. Since identical issues of law and fact arise for consideration
in the present appeals, and the appeals involve common
questions for determination, they are being heard and decided
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
together by this common judgment.
1.1 The Criminal Appeal No.731 of 2012 is filed by the State
of Gujarat and Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012 is filed by the
original complainant under the provisions of Section 378(1)(3)
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against the same
impugned judgment and order dated 13.03.2012 passed by
the learned Sessions Judge, Surat (hereinafter be referred to
as the “Trial Court”) in Sessions Case No.77 of 2007, whereby
the Trial Court has acquitted the respondents accused from
the charges under Sections 306, 498A and 114 of the India
Penal Code (hereinafter be referred to as the “IPC”).
2. The facts giving rise to present appeals are that the
complainant-
Rakeshkumar
Parbhubhai
Patel,
lodged
a
complaint at Rander Police Station, Surat, bearing C.R.
No.132/2006, for the offences punishable under Sections
498(A), 306 and 114 of the IPC, stating, inter alia, that about
one and a half years prior to the incident, his sister, namely
Manishaben, was married to respondent-accused and was
residing with him in a joint family along with respondentaccused No.2, who was her mother-in-law. After some time,
the matrimonial life of Manishaben did not remain cordial, as
the accused persons subjected her to mental and physical
harassment, and respondent -accused - husband also used to
beat her.
2.1
On the day of the incident, i.e. on 15.04.2006 at about
8:40 hours, the accused persons did not permit Manishaben to
attend her sister's marriage and subjected her to mental and
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
physical harassment by taunting her. Due to the continuous
harassment and ill-treatment meted out to her by the accused
persons, Manishaben could not tolerate the same and
committed suicide by hanging herself in toilet. It is, therefore,
alleged that the accused persons abetted and thereby
committed the offence of abetment of suicide, punishable
under Sections 498(A), 306 and 114 of the IPC. Hence, the
complaint was lodged against the accused persons.
2.2 On the basis of the said complaint, investigation was
initiated. Upon completion of a thorough investigation, as
sufficient evidence was found against the respondentsaccused, a charge-sheet was filed before the Learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Surat. Since the offences alleged
against the accused persons were exclusively triable by the
Court of Sessions, in accordance with Section 209 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, the Learned Magistrate was pleased to
commit the case to the Court of Sessions. Thereafter, the case
was transferred and placed for trial before the Trial Court and
was numbered as Sessions Case No.77 of 2007.
2.3 Thereafter, charge was framed at Exhibit 12 against the
accused persons for the offences punishable under Sections
498(A), 306 and 114 of the IPC. The accused persons pleaded
not guilty to the charges and claimed to be tried.
2.4 In support of its case the prosecution led oral as well as
documentary evidence which reads as under:-
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
ORAL EVIDENCE
Sr. No.
Name
Exhibit
Dr. Gaurang Somabhai Solanki
Rakeshkumar Parbhubhai
Azam Yusufbhai
Dahyabhai Dalpatbhai Vasiya
Prabhu Laxmanbhai Patel
Padmaben Prabhubhai
Nareshbhai Chhotubhai Patel
Dhameshbhai Bhagwanbhai Patel
Jayeshbhai Dhansukhbhai
Jashwantbhai Chunilalbhai Patel
Prahladbhai Jhinabhai Rathod
Ramesh Somabhai Patel (I.O.)
Somabhai Babarbhai Rawat (I.O.)
DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE
Sr.
No.
Description
Post-mortem Note of the deceased
Yadi for conducting the post-mortem
Complaint of the complainant, Rakesh Parbhubhai
Patel
Panchnama regarding the articles seized from the
dead body
Arrest Panchnama of the accused
Panchnama of the place of offence
Inquest Panchnama
Guardian Application No. 74/2006 (Exhibit 1) filed
before the Court of the Principal District Judge
Guardian Application No. 74/2006 (Exhibit 5) filed
before the Court of the Principal District Judge
Exhibit
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
Yadi submitted for registration of the complaint
Order of the IO
FSL Report regarding the visit to the place of offence
FSL Report regarding the visit to the place of offence
2.5 As referred above, the prosecution examined 13 witnesses
and produced 13 documentary exhibits on record. At the
conclusion of the trial and after hearing both the sides and
after evaluating the evidence placed on record the Trial Court
vide order dated 13.03.2012 passed in Sessions Case No. 77
of 2007 has acquitted the respondents accused persons from
the offences punishable under Sections 498(A), 306 and 114
of the IPC.
2.6 Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order of Trial
Court dated 13.03.2012 passed in Sessions Case No. 77 of
2007 the State has preferred Criminal Appeal No.731 of 2012
and the original complainant -Rakeshkumar Parbhubhai Patel
has filed Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012.
3. Heard Ms. Jyoti Bhatt, learned APP for the appellate-State
in Criminal Appeal No.731 of 2012, Ms. Archana Acharya,
learned counsel for the appellant-original complainant in
Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012 and Mr. Hardik Shah
learned counsel for the respondents accused in both the
appeals.
4. Learned APP and learned counsel for the appellants
submitted that the Trial Court while by passing the impugned
judgement and order of acquittal has committed serious error
of law and on facts both.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
4.1 It is submitted that the prosecution has duly proved the
charge against the respondents-accused with regard to the
cruelty
and
harassment
meted
out
to
the
deceased,
Manishaben. However, the Trial Court failed to properly
appreciate the said facts in their true and proper perspective
while passing the impugned judgment and order of acquittal.
4.2 It is further contended that the marriage between the
accused and the deceased subsisted for less than seven years
and, therefore, the Trial Court ought to have drawn the
statutory presumptions against the accused as contemplated
under Sections 113-A and 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act.
However, the Trial Court failed to draw such presumptions
against the accused as provided under the provisions of the
Indian Evidence Act.
4.3 It is further contended that respondent No.2 in Criminal
Appeal No.791 of 2012, who is also respondent No.3 in
Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012, was serving in the Police
Department.
It
is
therefore
submitted
that,
under
the
influence of the said respondent-accused, the Investigating
Officer did not conduct the investigation in its true and proper
manner. Thus, the investigation was faulty and the said aspect
was not properly appreciated or considered by the Trial Court.
4.4 In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is
submitted that both the appeals deserve to be allowed and the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal passed by the Trial
Court deserves to be quashed and set aside.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
4.5 It is submitted that the Trial Court ought to have properly
appreciated the evidence of PW-3 Azambhai Yusufbhai,
examined at Exh. 48; PW-4 Dahyabhai Dalpatbhai Vasiya,
examined at Exh. 50; PW-7 Nareshbhai Chhotubhai Patel,
examined at Exh. 58; PW-8 Dharmeshbhai Bhagwanbhai Patel,
examined
at
Exh.
63;
PW-9
Jayeshbhai
Dhansukhbhai,
examined at Exh. 64; PW-10 Jashvantbhai Chunilalbhai Patel,
examined at Exh. 65; and PW-11 Prahladbhai Zinabhai
Rathod, examined at Exh. 66. It is submitted that these
witnesses have substantially supported the case of the
prosecution as narrated by the complainant in her complaint,
produced at Exh. 32. It is further submitted that, in their
respective depositions, they have stated that the accused
subjected the deceased Manishaben to physical and mental
harassment.
4.6 It is submitted that the Trial Court has committed a grave
error in disbelieving the evidence of PW-5 Prabhubhai
Laxmanbhai Patel, father of the deceased, examined at Exh.
53, and PW-6 Padamaben Prabhubhai Patel, mother of the
deceased, examined at Exh. 57. It is submitted that both these
witnesses are the parents of the deceased and are natural and
trustworthy witnesses. It is further submitted that the Trial
Court failed to appreciate that the deceased was residing in
the house of the accused and that the prosecution case relates
to offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 306 and 114 of
the Indian Penal Code. In the facts and circumstances of the
present case, the evidence of the parents of the deceased
could not have been discarded merely on the ground of their
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
relationship with the deceased. It is submitted that from the
evidence of the parents read with the other oral and
documentary
evidence,
the
prosecution
has
sufficiently
established the prosecution case however, by disbelieving and
discarding their evidence without proper appreciation, the
Trial Court has committed a grave error, resulting in
miscarriage of justice. Hence, the impugned judgment and
order of acquittal deserves to be quashed and set aside.
4.7 It is submitted that the Trial Court has committed a grave
error in disbelieving the evidence of PW-1 Dr. Gaurang
Somabhai Solanki, examined at Exh. 19. It is submitted that
the said witness had produced the Post-Mortem Note and
clearly opined that the deceased died due to hanging. It is
further submitted that the Doctor had stated that, prior to the
suicide, the deceased had sustained injuries and had been
subjected to physical assault. This evidence supports the
prosecution case that the deceased was subjected to physical
and mental harassment by the accused, which ultimately led
her to commit suicide. It is submitted that the Trial Court
ought to have properly appreciated this medical evidence in
conjunction with the other oral and documentary evidence
available on record. Having failed to do so, the Trial Court has
committed a grave error in acquitting the accused. Therefore,
the impugned judgment and order deserves to be quashed and
set aside by this Hon'ble Court.
4.8 It is submitted that the Trial Court ought to have properly
appreciated the contents of the Panchnama of the scene of
offence
produced
at
Exh.
49,
the
Inquest
Panchnama
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
produced at Exh. 51, and the FSL Reports produced at Exhs.
70 and 71. It is submitted that the aforesaid documentary
evidence, coupled with the evidence of the Investigating
Officer, clearly establishes the circumstances surrounding the
death of the deceased in the house of the accused. It is further
submitted
that
the
evidence
on
record
supports
the
prosecution case that the deceased was subjected to cruelty
and harassment by the accused, which led to her committing
suicide. However, the Trial Court failed to properly appreciate
this material aspect of the case. Therefore, the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal is contrary to the evidence on
record and deserves to be quashed and set aside by this
Court.
4.9 It is submitted that the Trial Court ought to have
appreciated that the accused subjected the deceased to
continuous physical and mental harassment and cruelty and,
as a result thereof, she was unable to tolerate the same. It is
submitted
that
circumstances
the
conduct
clearly
of
indicate
the
that
accused
the
and
the
deceased
was
instigated and driven to commit suicide. Thus, the ingredients
of the offences punishable under Sections 498-A read with
Sections 306 and 114 of the IPC were made out against the
accused.
However,
the
Trial
Court
failed
to
properly
appreciate this material aspect of the matter. It is submitted
that the prosecution examined sufficient oral evidence in
support of its case and also produced ample documentary
evidence on record. It is submitted that the oral as well as
documentary
evidence,
when
considered
cumulatively,
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
supports the prosecution case. However, the Trial Court failed
to appreciate the evidence available on record in its true and
proper perspective and thereby arrived at an erroneous
conclusion.
4.10 It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to properly
appreciate the material evidence available on record. It is
submitted
that
the
reasons
assigned
in
the
impugned
judgment are erroneous, perverse and contrary to the
evidence on record. It is further submitted that there were
cogent and reliable circumstances and evidence supporting
the prosecution case and establishing the charges against the
accused. The findings recorded by the Trial Court are
therefore unsustainable in law and on facts. Hence, the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal deserves to be
quashed and set aside by this Hon'ble Court. It is submitted
that the Trial Court failed to appreciate the evidence of
Nareshbhai Chhotubhai Patel, examined at Exh. 58, in its true
and proper perspective. It is submitted that this witness has
clearly supported the case of the prosecution. However, the
Trial Court erroneously failed to give due consideration to his
deposition. It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to
appreciate the evidence of Dharmeshbhai Bhagwanbhai Patel,
examined at Exh. 63, in its true and proper perspective. It is
submitted that this witness has clearly stated in his deposition
that, when he had gone to the house of respondent Nos. 2 and
3, he found their behaviour to be abnormal. It is submitted
that this material circumstance supported the prosecution
case; however, the Trial Court failed to properly consider the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
same.
4.11 It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
the evidence of Jayeshbhai Dhansukhbhai, in its true and
proper perspective. It is submitted that the witness clearly
stated that, when he had gone to the house of respondents
accused to give an invitation card for the marriage of Nisha,
he found the deceased to be under tension. It is submitted
that this material circumstance goes to the root of the case
and clearly supports the prosecution case that the deceased
was
subjected
to
physical
and
mental
harassment
by
respondents accused. However, the Trial Court failed to
properly appreciate this important piece of evidence.
4.12 It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
the Post-Mortem Note at Exh. 20 in its true and proper
perspective. It is submitted that, as per the Post-Mortem
Note, the cause of death was recorded as "Asphyxia as a
result of pressure over the neck by ligature associated with
head injury." It is further submitted that, in his examinationin-chief, the Doctor admitted that injuries Nos. 2 to 6 were
possible if the deceased had been subjected to physical
cruelty shortly before her death. He further admitted that
injury No. 6 was possible if another person had caused nail
injuries and that injury No. 19 was possible by causing hurt
with a hard and blunt object. These material admissions of the
Doctor
were
directly
relevant
to
the prosecution
case
regarding physical cruelty and assault upon the deceased.
However, the Trial Court failed to properly appreciate this
material medical evidence while passing the impugned
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
judgment.
4.13 It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
that PW-1 Dr. Gaurang Somabhai Solanki, examined at Exh.
19, specifically admitted in paragraph 8 of his crossexamination that injury No. 1 mentioned in Column No. 19 of
the Post-Mortem Note was possible if a person attempted to
save herself after being hanged and, in the process, the left
side of her head struck against a wall. It is further submitted
that, upon perusal of the Scene Panchnama, it is clear that the
bathroom measured approximately 3 x 3 feet and was 6.5 feet
in height. In such circumstances, the possibility of sustaining
such a head injury while attempting to commit suicide
requires careful consideration. It is submitted that this
circumstance also lends support to the prosecution case that
the deceased had been subjected to physical cruelty and
assault before her death, which ultimately compelled her to
commit suicide. However, the Trial Court failed to properly
appreciate this material aspect of the evidence.
4.14 It is submitted that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
that the ingredients of Section 113-A of the Indian Evidence
Act were also attracted in the present case. It is submitted
that the marriage between the deceased and respondent No. 2
had subsisted for only about one and a half years. It is further
submitted that the evidence on record establishes that, within
about one month of the marriage, respondent Nos. 2 and 3
started subjecting the deceased to mental and physical
cruelty. Further, immediately prior to her death, the deceased
had
sustained
several
injuries,
which
corroborate
the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
prosecution case regarding physical and mental cruelty. Thus,
the statutory requirements for invoking the presumption
under Section 113-A of the Indian Evidence Act were satisfied.
However, the Trial Court failed to properly appreciate this
material aspect of the case, resulting in a serious miscarriage
of justice.
5. Ms. Archana Acharya, learned counsel for the appellantoriginal complainant in Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012 has
submitted following written submissions, which are taken on
record:5.1 It is submitted that the judgment and order of acquittal is
contrary to the provisions of law, facts and evidence in the
case and as such, deserves to be set aside and that the
respondent nos. 2 and 3 ought to have been convicted for the
offences punishable u/s. 306, 498(A) r/w. 114 of IPC.
5.2 It is submitted that the appreciation of facts, evidence and
circumstances of the case as well as established principles of
law as per the judgment and order dated 13.03.2012 is
neither reasonable, nor true and it is against the provisions of
law, which has ended in miscarriage of justice and therefore,
the order of Acquittal deserves to be set aside.
5.3 It is submitted that the oral evidence of Parbhubhai
Laxmanbhai Patel at Exh. 53 and Padmaben Parbhubhai Patel
at Exh. 57 i.e. the parents of deceased and of Nareshbhai
Chhotubhai
Patel
at Exh. 58
clearly the case of the
prosecution and suggest that that there was continuous
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
physical and mental torture meted out by respondent nos. 2
and 3 on the deceased.
5.4 It is submitted that the witness namely Dharmeshbhai
Bhagwanbhai Patel at Exh. 63 clearly stated in his deposition
that when he had gone to the house of respondent no.2 and 3,
he found their behaviour to be abnormal. That witness namely
Jayeshbhai Dhansukabhai at Exh. 66 has clearly stated in his
deposition that when he had gone to the house of respondent
no.2 and 3 to give the invitation card of marriage of Nisha, he
found the deceased to be under tension. This minute aspect
go to the root of the case and clearly suggest that there was
physical and mental harassment by respondent nos. 2 and 3
on deceased.
5.5 It is further submitted that the examination-in-chief of Dr.
Gaurang Somabhai Solanki at Exh. 19 clearly admitted the
following injuries on the deceased:(i) Ligature mark of size 30cm x 5.5cm seen present
around the neck, slight oblique ground whole
circumference of the neck, 7 cm below chin, brain red in
colour;
(ii) Abrasion of size 1.5 cm x 1.5 cm seen present over
below chin and 10 cm below right ear; brown red in
colour;
(iii) Abrasion of size of 0.8cm x 0.5 cm seen present over
back of abdomen in midline, brown red in colour.
(iv) Abrasion of size 1 cm x 1cm seen present over back
of left elbow, brown red in colour.
(v) Abrasion of size 1cm x 1 cm seen present over front
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
of left knee, brown red in colour.
(vi) Multiple scratch abrasion 5 in numbers. size ranging
from 0.1cm x0.5cm to 0.2 cm x 0.3 cm seen present on
back of right hand, brownish red in colour.
The above injuries are found to be ante-mortem in
nature and fresh. This witness has further admitted the
following internal injuries:i. Scalp hematroma of size 4cm x4cm seen present over
the left parital region. 12cm below left ear.
ii. Brain conguted. Subdura haumorage seen present
over right parital region. suboactinoid hemorage seen
present all over the brain surface.
5.6 It is furthered that the postmortem note at Exh. 20 clearly
states that the cause of death "Asphyxia as a result of
pressure over the neck by ligature associated with head
injury". Even in the examination-in-chief, the doctor has
admitted that the injuries nos, 2 to 6 are possible only if the
deceased was subjected to physical cruelty soon before her
death and that injury no.6 is possible only if the other person
causes nail injuries. The Doctor has also admitted that injury
no.19 is possible by causing hurt with hard and blunt object.
However,
this
material
aspect
has
not
been
properly
considered thoroughly.
5.7 It is submitted that the deceased was subjected to physical
cruelty soon before her death. This fact is corroborated by
Postmortem report and evidence of Dr. Gaurang Somabhai
Solanki at Exh. 19. It is also submitted that Dr. Gaurang
Somabhai Solanki has specifically admitted in para 5 of his
cross- examination that injury no.2 i.e. injury of scratches are
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
possible due to displacement of ligature. He has also admitted
that injury no.2 is possible by scrubbing with any article. If
this fact is read along with the physical situation, it is clear
that there is abrasion of size 1.5 cm x 1.5 cm over below chin.
When the dead body was removed down, there was wall
behind the dead body. Therefore, this injury no.2 is not
possible
after
the
deceased
hanged
herself
and
died.
Therefore, it is clear that this injury no.2 is also caused soon
before the death of deceased.
5.8 It is submitted that Dr. Gaurang Somabhai Solanki at Exh.
has
specifically
admitted
in
para
of
his
cross-
examination that injury no.6 is possible by khanjwalvathi,
whereas injury no.4 is possible upon rubbing any rough
article, while injury no.5 is possible upon slipping of stares
while climbing. This witness has clearly refused that injury
no.6 is possible by scratching through nails. Therefore, it is
clear that this injury no.6 is caused soon before the death of
deceased.
5.9 It is submitted that Dr. Gaurang Somabhai Solanki at Exh.
has
specifically
admitted
in
para
of
his
cross-
examination that injury no.1 of column no. 19 of PM note is
possible if any person tries to save herself after she is hanged
and if the left side head dashes with the wall. However, upon
perusal of panchnama of scene of offence, it is clear that the
size of bath room is 3x3 foot and height is 6.5 foot. If any
person tried to commit suicide in this situation, then, there
are no possibilities of receiving this kind of head injury. This
fact also corroborates the case of the appellant that the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
deceased was subjected to cruelty before her death which
compelled her to commit suicide. That it is also stated in his
cross- examination, the injury no. 2 to 6 is not possible if any
person tries to commit suicide. Therefore, it is undoubtedly
established that the deceased was subjected to compel the
deceased to commit suicide. cruelty before her death.
5.10 It is furthered that the deceased was having 6 months
child and no mother would commit suicide by leaving the 6
months child at the mercy of others, more so when the
deceased was going to attend the marriage of cousin sister
Nisha.
5.11 It is also submitted that the circumstantial evidence in
the case suggest that the conduct of accused before and after
the death of deceased smacks malafides. On the date of
incident, the respondent no.2 informed the appellant to come
at his house as the deceased was not coming out of the
bathroom even though more than an hour had passed and
after the appellant comes, the respondent no.2 will try to open
the door. However, it is pertinent to note that before the
appellant could reach and before the respondent no.2
informed the appellant, he had already made a call to the fire
brigade and police. Before the appellant could reach, the fire
brigade had broke the door and brought the deceased outside.
At that time, she was alive. If the respondent nos. 2 and 3 had
opened the door immediately without wasting time in making
calls to fire brigade, police and the appellant, the deceased
could have been survived. Though the respondent nos. 2 and 3
were personally present at the hospital, they did not inform
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
the appellant about the above facts of calling fire brigade and
police
for
removing
the
appellant,
this
is
a
case
of
circumstantial evidence and this material circumstance ought
to be considered.
5.12 It is submitted that it is pertinent to note the conduct of
the respondent nos. 2 and 3 as the respondent nos. 2 and 3
have not attended the funeral ceremony of deceased after the
death of deceased. This conduct on the part of respondent
nos. 2 and 3 also creates doubt.
5.13 It is further submitted that the present case clearly
attracts all the ingredients of Section 306 of IPC and that
there is sufficient evidence to show that there was physical
and mental cruelty meted out by respondent nos, 2 and 3 on
the deceased in the form of evidence of Witness No. 2 (Rakesh
Parbhubhai), Witness No. 4 (Dayabhai Dalpatsinh Vasiya),
witness no. 5 (Parbhubhai Laxmanbhai Patel), Witness no.6
(Padmaben Parbhubhai Patel) and witness no. 7 (Nareshbhai
Chhotubhai Patel) Therefore, the ingredients of Sec. 498(A) of
IPC are clearly made out against the respondent nos. 2 and 3accused.
5.14 It is furthered that as per Sec. 106 of Indian Evidence
Act, it is the burden of a person to prove the facts specially
within his knowledge. The deceased has committed suicide at
her in-laws house. The accused were present at the time and
place of incidence. Before the death of deceased, the
deceased has received injury nos. 2 to 6. However, though the
respondent nos. 2 and 3 had special knowledge about the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
same, they have not declared as required u/s. 106 of Indian
Evidence Act.
5.15 It is further submitted that the ingredients of Section 113
of the Indian Evidence Act are also satisfied in the instant
case as much as the marriage span of deceased and the
Respondent No. 2 was of only one and half years and there
should be cruelty as prescribed under Section 498(A) of IPC.
That in the present case, after one month of marriage itself,
the respondent no. 2 and 3 started treating the deceased with
mental and physical cruelty. Even before the deceased
committed suicide, there are number of injuries, which
suggests that there was physical and mental cruelty to the
deceased. Therefore, the ingredients of Section 113A of the
Indian Evidence Act are attracted.
5.16 It is further submitted that the ingredients of Section 8 of
the Indian Evidence Act are also satisfied in the instant case
as much as before the appellant could reach and before the
respondent no. 2 informed the appellant, the respondent no. 2
and 3 had already made call to the fire brigade and police.
Before the appellant could reach, the fire brigade had broke
open the door and had brought the deceased outside. At that
time, she was alive. If the respondent no. 2 and 3 had opened
the door immediately without wasting time in making calls to
the fire brigade, police and the appellant, the deceased could
have survived. Though the respondent nos. 2 and 3 were
personally present at the hospital, they did not inform the
appellant about the above facts of calling the fire brigade and
police
for
removing
the
deceased.
This
is
a
case
of
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
circumstantial evidence and the same ought to be considered.
5.17 It is submitted that the following judgments support the
case of the appellant:
i. 2006 (3) GLH 317 Janakbhai Kanubhai Thakkar Vs
State of Gujarat
ii. 2011 (2) SCC (Cri) 923 (Head Note H & I)
Brahmaswaroop and Anr. Vs State of Uttar Pradesh
iii. 2009 (1) GLR 488 Hika Jiva Gujariya Vs. State of
Gujarat
iv. 2011 (0) GLHEL_SC 49560 Sahebrao Mohan Berad
Vs. State of Maharashtra
v. 2010 (10) SCC 353 (Para 18, 19 & 21) Thanu Ram Vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh
vi. 2008 GLHEL SC 220772 (Para 12) Mustak Abubhai
Madha Vs. State of Gujarat
vii. 2007 (9) SCC 11 (Para 9 and 10) Virendra Vs. State
of Uttar Pradesh
viii. 2011 (1) SCC (Cri) 266 Ashok Kumar Vs. State of
Haryana
ix. 1994 (1) GLH 537 State of West Bengal Vs. Ori Lal
Jaiswal
x. 2011 (1) GLR 396 (Head note-B & C, Para 24 & 12)
Ram Narayan Vs. State of Gujarat Χ.
5.18 It is submitted that the order impugned is absolutely
illegal, unjust, improper, perverse, contrary to the material on
record,
palpably
wrong,
manifestly
erroneous
and
demonstrably unsustainable and therefore, the same deserves
to be interfered with by quashing and setting aside the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
impugned judgment and order of acquittal dated 13.03.2012
passed by the Ld. Sessions Judge, Surat in Sessions Case No.
77 of 2007 and the respondent nos. 2 and 3 maybe convicted
in accordance with law, in the interests of justice.
6. On the other hand, Mr. Hardik Shah, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents-accused in both the appeals,
has submitted that the prosecution witnesses have failed to
prove the charges against the respondents-accused with
regard to the cruelty and harassment allegedly caused to the
deceased
committed
and
that,
on
account
suicide.
He
has
thereof,
submitted
the
that
deceased
since
the
prosecution has failed to establish these facts beyond
reasonable doubt, the Trial Court has rightly passed the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal. He has further
submitted that there is no infirmity or illegality in the
impugned judgment and order passed by the Trial Court.
Therefore, both the appeals filed by the State as well as the
original complainant deserve to be dismissed.
6.1 Learned counsel for the respondents-accused has further
submitted that the present case is one of suicidal death, as the
deceased, Manishaben, committed suicide by hanging herself
in the toilet. He submitted that this fact has been established
through the evidence of an independent witness, namely, PW10, Jashvantbhai Chunilalbhai Patel, Exhibit 65, who was
serving in the Fire Brigade Department. He had received a
call from the concerned Police Station informing him that a
lady was trapped inside a toilet at the house. Upon receiving
the said message, he immediately reached the spot and found
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
that the door of the toilet was closed from inside and could
not be opened even by pushing it. Therefore, with the help of
a crowbar, the door was broken open and the deceased was
brought out of the toilet. At that time, she was unconscious
but still alive. Therefore, she was immediately taken to the
nearest hospital, where she was declared dead.
6.2
Learned
counsel
for
the
respondents
accused
has
submitted that, in the aforesaid circumstances, there is no
evidence to establish that the deceased was subjected to any
mental or physical torture by the respondents-accused. No
such evidence has been brought on record or proved by the
prosecution beyond reasonable doubt. Therefore, the Trial
Court has rightly appreciated the evidence on record and
passed the impugned judgment and order of acquittal.
6.3 Learned counsel for the respondents-accused has further
submitted that none of the prosecution witnesses, particularly
the complainant, who is the father of the deceased, or other
family members, has deposed before the Trial Court that the
accused-husband of the deceased was addicted to or had a
habit of consuming liquor. However, despite there being no
such evidence, the complainant and his family members, on
the basis of distorted and exaggerated facts, filed an
application before the competent Court seeking guardianship
of the minor son of the accused-husband, being Guardian
Application No.74 of 2006.
6.4 Learned counsel for the respondent has submitted that the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal passed by the Trial
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
Court is legal, just, and proper and has been passed after
thorough appreciation of the oral as well as documentary
evidence available on record. The Trial Court has assigned
cogent,
convincing,
and
well-reasoned
findings
while
acquitting the respondents–accused, and the same does not
warrant any interference by this Hon’ble Court.
6.5 Learned counsel for the respondent has submitted that the
prosecution has failed to prove the charges levelled against
the respondent beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence led by
the
prosecution
suffers
from
material
contradictions,
omissions, and inconsistencies, which create serious doubt
about the veracity of the prosecution case. The prosecution
has failed to establish the essential ingredients of the alleged
offences and has not produced reliable, trustworthy, and
corroborative evidence connecting the respondent with the
commission of the alleged offence.
6.6 It is a settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that the
presumption of innocence in favour of an accused is further
strengthened by an order of acquittal. Unless the findings
recorded by the Trial Court are shown to be perverse, illegal,
or contrary to the evidence on record, the Appellate Court
should be slow in interfering with an order of acquittal.
6.7 It is submitted that the appellant has failed to point out
any infirmity, illegality, perversity, or misreading of evidence
in the impugned judgment and order. The findings recorded
by the Trial Court are based upon proper appreciation of the
evidence and settled legal principles. The Trial Court has
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
rightly extended the benefit of doubt to the respondents–
accused, which is a substantive right flowing from the
fundamental principles of criminal law.
6.8 In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is
submitted that the present appeals are devoid of merits and
deserves to be dismissed. The impugned judgment and order
of acquittal passed by the Trial Court therefore deserves to be
confirmed.
6.9 In support of his arguments, Mr. Shah, learned counsel for
the respondents accused has referred and relied upon the
following decisions:1. Jayedeepsinh Pravinsinh Chavda and others vs. State
of Gujarat reported in 2024 (12) SCR 439
2. Gandadhipa Sahu vs. State of Odisha reported in 2026
(0) JX(SC) 566
3. Dara Lakshmi Narayana vs. State of Telangana
reported in 2025(3) SCC 735
7. Upon perusal of the impugned judgment and order of
acquittal, as well as the submissions advanced by the learned
APP, learned counsel for the respondents accused as well as
the written submissions of Ms. Acharya, learned counsel for
the appellant in Criminal Appeal No.1359 of 2012, the issues
that arises for consideration before this Court are as under:Whether the Trial Court committed any error in passing
the impugned judgment and order of acquittal?
Whether the Trial Court, while appreciating the evidence
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
of the prosecution witnesses, has committed any error of
law or fact?
Whether the impugned judgment and order of acquittal
suffers from any illegality or perversity?
8. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the
respective parties and having considered the issues framed by
this Court for determination, it would be appropriate to first
examine the facts of the present case. The deceased,
Manishaben, married the respondent-accused on 13.02.2005,
and after the marriage, she resided with her husband,
respondent No. 2 (mother-in-law), and grandmother-in-law.
During the said wedlock, the deceased Manishaben became
pregnant and, therefore, after completion of the shrimant
ceremony, she was brought to her parental home, where she
delivered a baby boy on 08.11.2005, namely, Dhruvil. The
doctor advised that, since the child was a newborn, he should
not be touched by any person other than the mother. After the
birth of the child, Manishaben was brought back home from
the nursing home. At that time, the respondent-mother-in-law
insisted on taking the child in her lap. However, the deceased
Manishaben refused to hand over the child to her, on account
of which an altercation took place between the respondentmother-in-law and the complainant and his family members.
Since then, the deceased resided at her parental home with
the minor baby. Later, at the instance of the respondenthusband, the deceased, Manishaben, along with the minor,
went to her matrimonial home. Due to the ill health of the
minor, they were immediately taken to a doctor for treatment,
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
where it was revealed that the minor had a congenital defect
in his private part and was suffering from coughing and a cold
due to congestion. He was advised to take complete rest,
prompting Manishaben to insist on staying at her parental
home. However, the accused respondents forcefully took the
deceased and the minor to their residence. Just two to three
days later, the deceased committed suicide by hanging herself
in the toilet at the residence of the accused respondents, and
the complainant was immediately informed and called.
9. In the presence of the complainant and his family members,
the door was broken open by PW-10, who was serving as a
Fire Officer in the Fire Brigade at Surat. He has also admitted
in his deposition that the door of the toilet was so strong that
it could not be opened by pushing or by applying any external
force. Therefore, the door had to be forcibly broken open with
the help of a crowbar.
10.
Now, if I examine the evidence of the witnesses, namely,
the deposition of Dr. Gaurang Solanki, who conducted the
post-mortem examination, it appears that he noticed certain
injuries on the body of the deceased. When he was crossexamined by the defence, he admitted that the injury noticed
on the body of the deceased could have been caused when a
person attempts to strangulate herself and, in the course of
writhing or struggling restlessly, she might dash against a
wall, thereby sustaining the injury mentioned in the postmortem note. Therefore, the allegation that the said injury
was caused by the respondent-husband to the deceased is
ruled out, and the prosecution has failed to prove beyond
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
reasonable doubt that the said injury was caused by the
respondent-husband.
11. Now, so far as the evidence of PW-1, who is a doctor, is
concerned, he has deposed that no injury was noticed on the
head of the deceased, either in the nature of a fracture or
otherwise. It was alleged that the respondent-husband had
physically assaulted the deceased prior to the incident and
that, as a result, various injuries were found on her body.
However, this allegation is not supported by the evidence of
the doctor. On the contrary, in his cross-examination, the
doctor has admitted the said fact. The deposition and cross
examination of the PW-1 read as under:Examination in Chief:
1)
On 15/04/2006, while I was on duty at the Civil
Hospital, Police Constable Ramesh Chabaram, Buckle No. 2335 of
Rander Police Station, brought the dead body of Manishaben, wife
of Ketankumar Gunvantbhai Patel, for the purpose of a postmortem examination at 4:00 PM, along with the yadi of the
Assistant Commissioner of Police, D-Division. We commenced the
said post-mortem examination on that day at 4:15 PM and
concluded it at 5:45 PM. This examination was conducted by a
panel comprising myself and Dr. Vinesh Shah.
2)
The description of the external appearance of the
dead body is recorded in Columns 7, 8, and 9 of the Post-Mortem
Note. Upon examining the dead body, rigor mortis was observed in
the neck and other parts. Furthermore, parts of the body such as
the tongue and nails were found to have a bluish. Furthermore,
bleeding from the left ear was also observed.
3) Upon external examination of the dead body, the following
injuries were observed:
(1)
(2)
A ligature mark around the neck measuring approximately
30 cm x 0.5 cm, encircling the entire neck, appearing
reddish-brown in colour. It was slightly oblique.
An abrasion measuring approximately 1.5 cm x 1.5 cm, light
reddish-brown in colour, was observed below the chin. Its
distance from the right ear was 10 cm.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
An abrasion measuring approximately 0.8 cm x 0.5 cm was
observed on the back of the abdomen, that is on the back, in
the middle portion. Its colour also appeared light brownishred.
Similarly, an abrasion measuring 1 cm x 1 cm was observed
on the back part of the left elbow. Its colour was also
brownish-red.
An abrasion measuring 1 cm x 1 cm was observed on the
front part of the left knee. Its colour was also brownish-red.
More than two, approximately 5 nail marks measuring from
0.1 cm x 0.3 cm to 0.2 cm x 0.3 cm were observed on the
back part of the left hand. Their colour was also brownishred.
During this entire examination, no bone fracture was
detected upon palpation. All the aforementioned injuries
were prior to death.
4) Upon internal examination of the dead body, a hematoma
measuring 4 cm x 4 cm was observed on the left parietal region of
the head. No bone fracture of any kind was detected in the skull,
but a hematoma was observed under the dura mater of the brain.
Furthermore, accumulation of blood that is hemorrhage was
observed throughout the entire brain under the arachnoid
membrane.
5) Upon internal examination of the neck, a contusion was
observed in the muscles underlying external injury no. 1. Both
lungs were found to be filled with blood and swollen (edematous).
Upon cutting these lungs, blood-stained froth was observed
emanating from them. No smell (odor) of any kind was detected in
the stomach.
6) All the organs of the body were found to be filled with blood
(congested). We issued a certificate indicating the primary cause of
death in this regard. We prepared the P.M. Note for the same. It is
in the handwriting of Dr. Vinesh Shah. It bears my signature as
well as the signature of Dr. Vinesh Shah. As stated in this P.M.
Note, the cause of death is asphyxia resulting from the pressure of
the ligature mark on the neck. Furthermore, a head injury is also
observed therein. The cause of death is due to the pressure on the
neck along with the head injury (associated with head injury).
7) The death of the deceased must have occurred 24 to 36 hours
prior to the dead body being brought for the Post-Mortem.
8) Injuries No. 2 to 6 must have been sustained within 36 hours
prior to death.
9) Muddamal Article No. 1, being a dupatta, is shown to me. Upon
examining it, I state that this dupatta could have been used as a
ligature material and by its use, the ligature mark mentioned as
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
injury No. 1 in Column No. 17 of the P.M. Note is possible. If
someone assaults a person prior to hanging, injuries such as No. 2
to 5 could be sustained.
10) In this case as well, if the deceased was assaulted prior to
being hanged by the neck, then injuries No. 2 to 5 are possible.
Whereas, if an opposing person inflicted scratches with their nails,
then an injury of the nature of injury No. 6 is possible.
11) All the injuries in Column No. 19 of the P.M. Note were
sustained 24 hours prior to death. If the deceased was struck with
a blunt object, the injuries mentioned in Column No. 19 could be
sustained.
12)
The P.M. Note prepared by me is produced at Mark 15/9. It
bears mine and Dr. Vinesh Shah signature. The facts stated therein
are true and correct. It is assigned Exhibit No-20.
13)
I have brought today the Yadi that was given to me by the
Police Constable of Rander Police Station. I produce the same on
record. It is assigned Exhibit No-21.
(14) I cannot state with certainty that during the internal
haemorrhage which was caused by the injury mentioned in column
no. 19, the deceased had hanged herself and died.
Cross-examination:
(1)
I was performing the P.M. of the dead body, and its notes
were being recorded by my panel doctor, Dr. Vinesh Shah. It did
not happen that I was performing the P.M. and narrating its details
to my panel doctor and he was writing them. My panel doctor, Dr.
Shah, was performing the post-mortem alongside me. I could not
give a diagnosis of death upon seeing the dead body prima facie.
(2)
I have noted in column no. 7 what clothes were on the dead
body of the deceased. There were no bloodstains on those clothes.
It is true that the name of the police constable who brought the
dead body is not written in column no. 2 of the P.M. note. The
police had provided the inquest panchnama along with the dead
body. I had not read the inquest panchnama before conducting the
P.M. It is true that I did not feel the need to read the inquest
panchnama before conducting the P.M. I had read the inquest
panchnama after performing the P.M. I did not feel the need today
to study the injuries mentioned in the inquest panchnama. It is true
that it is noted in the inquest panchnama that upon turning the
dead body of the deceased over and over and observing the back
and posterior (illegible) parts minutely.... At this stage, the Ld.
A.P.P. submits that since the details of the inquest panchnama have
been asked to the witness, it should be given an Exhibit Number.
The Ld. Advocate for the accused submits against this that the
panchas of the inquest panchnama should be examined before
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
examining the doctor. I believe that it can only be known whether a
panchnama according to this has been drawn up or not after
examining the panchas of the inquest panchnama. Merely by
asking the witness certain details of the inquest panchnama, the
entire panchnama cannot be given an exhibit number. And
regarding what the panchas saw in this respect, the inquest
panchnama should be given an exhibit number only after
examining them. Therefore, the inquest panchnama is not being
given an exhibit number.
(3)
I agree that the cause of death was due to asphyxia. If the
cause of death is syncope or coma, then it is not true.
(4)
I cannot state at which part of the neck the end of the
ligature mark terminated. The ligature mark could be of a rope. It
cannot be of hands. This ligature mark is also not of a wire. I follow
Medical Jurisprudence by Modi. I believe that the external
appearance at the P.M. is important for arriving at a preliminary
opinion. And in column no. 13 of the P.M. note, when the face is
pale, the face is calm and sudden, at that time the face appears
distorted and congested, and the lips and nails turn blue
(cyanosed). I have not noted such a thing.
(5)
It is not possible that injury no. 2, i.e., the abrasive injury, is
caused by the slipping of the ligature mark. It is true that the
abrasive injury (pertaining to injury no. 2) can be caused by
rubbing against any object.
(6)
I agree with the fact that injury no. ..... can also be caused by
scratching. It is true that injury no. 4 can be caused by rubbing
against some rough object. I agree with the fact that injury no. 5
can occur if a person falls while climbing stairs and the knee
touches, causing this type of contusion injury. I do not agree with
the fact that injury no. 6 can be caused by nail scratching, meaning
that there are more scratches than one.
(7)
It had come to my attention that before the dead body was
brought for the P.M., she was taken to Dr. Vijay Mehta's hospital
for treatment. The note made by Dr. Vijay Mehta had come to my
attention. It is true that in this certificate, the cause of death of the
deceased Manishaben was cardio-respiratory arrest. I cannot say
that this cause shows death due to syncope or coma.
(8)
Injury no. 1 of column no. 19 can be caused if a person is
hanged, makes convulsive struggles, and the left side of their head
strikes against a wall. I agree with the fact that when strangulation
is caused by a ligature mark on the neck, pressure is exerted on
other parts of the body and the veins are stretched.
(9)
There was no fracture at the neck part. Due to pressure on
the respiration process and the artery and vein, the brain does not
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
get a sufficient oxygen supply. And due to reduced oxygen,
haemorrhage cannot occur in the brain. I cannot say that if it is a
syncope or coma type of death, haemorrhage occurs.
(10) It is true that the death did not occur due to the head injury.
The main cause of death is asphyxia. It is true that I have not
written the age of the external injuries in the P.M. note. It is true
that external injuries no. 2 to 5 are not the cause of death.”
12.
Now, if I look at the evidence of PW-2, who is the
complainant and brother of the deceased Manishaben, it
appears that he was serving as a teacher at I.T. Nayak
Primary
School
at
Surat.
He
has
admitted
that
the
respondent-husband/accused was residing at Rang Avdhoot
Society, Part-3, Ramnagar, and that his brother-in-law, being
the husband of the deceased, was serving as a clerk at
Riverdale
School.
He
has
further
admitted
that
the
respondent-mother-in-law of the deceased was working as a
Police Constable at Ichhapur Police Station and that, most of
the time, she was on duty. The respondent-husband/accused,
who was serving as a clerk in a school, was also on duty.
Therefore, the allegations made against the respondents with
regard to ill-treatment, harassment, and cruelty meted out to
the deceased Manishaben are not supported by the evidence
of the very same witness. Further, in his cross-examination,
he has admitted that whenever he or any member of his family
visited the house of the deceased Manishaben, they had not
noticed any ill-treatment or harassment being caused to her.
The deceased had also not made any complaint to them with
regard to any ill-treatment or harassment caused to her, and
they had not lodged any complaint in that regard.
13.
It is further admitted that, when the deceased was
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
undergoing treatment, she was taken by her mother-in-law to
Dr. Sandhyaben and was also admitted to the gynaecologist
for the purpose of delivery. After the delivery, she was
brought by the complainant to his residence. Even during that
period, the deceased had not made any complaint with regard
to any ill-treatment or harassment. He has also admitted
before the Court that, so far as the alleged instruction
regarding not touching the minor child except by the mother
is concerned, no such instruction was given by the doctor,
either in writing or orally.
14.
Even from his evidence, PW-2 has not stated that the
respondent-husband had any habit of consuming liquor. Such
a fact was also not stated by the father of the deceased,
namely, PW-5, Parbubhai Lakshmanbhai Patel, at Exhibit 53,
nor by the mother of the deceased, namely, Padminaben
Parbubhai, PW-6, at Exhibit 57. However, such allegations
were made in the applications at Exhibits 54 and 55, thereby
portraying the accused as persons having such character as
mentioned in the said applications. Such careless statements,
in the absence of supporting evidence, cannot be relied upon
for establishing the allegations against the respondents.
15.
Under such circumstances, if I peruse the evidence of all
the three witnesses vis-à-vis the applications at Exhibits 54
and 55, it appears that the appellant-original complainant,
after the death of his sister, initiated the proceedings against
the present respondents and their family members with a view
to take revenge. The proceedings were initiated on the basis
of certain distorted facts, which were not even supported by
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
his oral evidence before the Court. Now, if I look at the
evidence of all the three witnesses, it clearly reveals that
there is not a whisper in their evidence that the respondents
had ever harassed or subjected the deceased to any mental or
physical torture. The fact that the deceased was not permitted
to participate in the engagement ceremony of her cousin by
the respondent-husband, due to the condition of their minor
son, cannot, by itself, be said to constitute a cause for the
deceased Manishaben to commit suicide. Even the other
witnesses, who are close family members of the complainant,
have not given any positive evidence with regard to any illtreatment or harassment caused to the deceased by the
present respondents.
16. In view of the aforesaid circumstances, the prosecution
has miserably failed to prove the charges against the
respondents-accused with regard to any ill-treatment or
harassment caused to the deceased, as contemplated under
Sections 306, 323, 498-A and 107 of the IPC. The allegation
regarding the injury allegedly caused by the respondenthusband to the deceased is also not supported by the evidence
of the doctor. Further, in his cross-examination, PW-2, the
complainant himself, has admitted before the Court that he
had not heard from the deceased herself about any illtreatment or cruelty meted out to her prior to the date of the
incident. Therefore, in the absence of such basic and
fundamental facts being established by the prosecution, the
charges under Sections 306 and 498-A read with Section 107
of the IPC cannot be said to have been proved.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
17.
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
Even the neighbours residing in the vicinity of the
deceased,
who
were
independent
witnesses,
have
not
supported the case of the prosecution. In such circumstances,
it is also relevant to consider the fact that, initially, an
Accidental Death Entry No. 22 of 2006 was registered before
the Rander Police Station under Section 174 of the Cr.P.C. on
15.04.2006. Initially, the deceased was taken to Dr. Vijay
Mehta for treatment. Although the prosecution relied upon
the fact that she was initially taken to the clinic of Dr. Vijay
Mehta, neither was the statement of Dr. Vijay Mehta recorded
nor was any documentary evidence collected from him. He
was also not examined as a witness by the prosecution to
prove the relevant facts. Now, if I look at the evidence of the
doctor and peruse the translated portion of his deposition, it
becomes clear that the prosecution has failed to establish the
charges against the respondents-accused even from such
evidence. In the absence of any cogent and clinching
evidence, while appreciating the evidence of close relatives,
the Court is required to carefully scrutinise their testimony. If
such evidence is found to be trustworthy and reliable, the
Court can certainly base a conviction upon such evidence.
However, in the present case, the prosecution has failed to
prove the charges against the present respondents even from
the evidence of the close relatives.
18.
The remaining witnesses were not in day-to-day contact
with the deceased or the respondents-accused, and from their
evidence, no fact has been brought on record to establish that
the respondents had ever caused any harassment or illPage 34 of 42
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
treatment to the deceased so as to provoke, instigate, or abet
her to commit the crime in question, as contemplated under
Sections 306 and 498-A read with Section 107 of the IPC and
Sections 113-A and 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act.
Therefore, in the absence of such cogent and clinching
evidence, the Trial Court was right and justified in passing the
impugned judgment and order. I do not find any illegality or
infirmity in the impugned judgment and order passed by the
Trial Court, whereby the respondents-accused came to be
acquitted of the charges.
19.
If I look at the reasoning recorded by the Trial Court
from paragraphs 9 to 18, it appears that, in paragraph 19, the
Court has also referred to the evidence of the doctor and
thereafter recorded its reasoning in paragraphs 20 and 21 as
to why the order of acquittal was required to be passed, based
upon the evidence discussed at length by the Trial Court.
Thus, the present appeals deserve to be dismissed, and no
interference is required to be called for with the impugned
judgment and order passed by the Trial Court.
20. At this stage it is appropriate to refer the provisions of
Section 498A, 306 and 107 of the IPC and 113A of the Indian
Evidence Act, which are reproduced hereunder :
Section 498A-Husband or relative of husband of a woman
subjecting her to cruelty.—
Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the husband of a
woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be punished with
imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and shall
also be liable to fine.
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
Explanation.— For the purpose of this section, “cruelty” means—
(a) any willful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive
the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to
life, limb or health (whether mental or physical) of the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a
view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any
unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on
account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet such
demand.
Section 306- Abetment of suicide.—
If any person commits suicide, whoever abets the commission of
such suicide, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall
also be liable to fine.
Section 107-Abetment of a thing.—
A person abets the doing of a thing, who—
(First)— Instigates any person to do that thing; or
(Secondly)— Engages with one or more other person or persons in
any conspiracy for the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal
omission takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy, and in order
to the doing of that thing; or
(Thirdly)— Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the
doing of that thing.
Explanation 1.— A person who, by wilful misrepresentation, or by
wilful concealment of a material fact which he is bound to disclose,
voluntarily causes or procures, or attempts to cause or procure, a
thing to be done, is said to instigate the doing of that thing.
Section 113-A. Presumption as to abetment of suicide by a
married woman. [Inserted by Act 46 of 1983, Section 7.]When the question is whether the commission of suicide by a
woman had been abetted by her husband or any relative of her
husband and it is shown that she had committed suicide within a
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
period of seven years from the date of her marriage and that her
husband or such relative of her husband had subjected her to
cruelty, the court may presume, having regard to all the other
circumstances of the case, that such suicide had been abetted by
her husband or by such relative of her husband.
Explanation. - For the purposes of this section, "cruelty" shall have
the same meaning as in section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code (45
of 1860).]
21.
So far as section 498-A of 306 IPC and 113 of Evidence
Act is concerned, it is also appropriate to refer the decision of
this Court in cases of State Of Gujarat Versus Ashvinbhai
Naginbhai Tandel reported in 2025 (0) GUJHC 20677, State
Of Gujarat Versus Bhaveshbhai Manilalbhai Patel reported in
2025 (2) GLR 923, State Of Gujarat Versus Haji Haroon
Meman reported in 2026 (0) GUJHC 7002 as well as the
decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the cases of Ramesh
Kumar Versus State Of Chhattisgarh reported in 2001 (9) SCC
618 and Ram Pyarey Versus State Of Uttar Pradesh reported
in 2025 (6) SCC 820.
Even, so far as the statutory
presumption under Sections 113A and 113B of the Indian
Evidence Act is concerned, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
recently held that before such a presumption can be drawn,
there must be at least some cogent material or evidence
giving rise to an inference against the accused. In the absence
of even the slightest evidence on record from which such an
inference can reasonably be drawn against the respondents
regarding the commission of the alleged offences, the
statutory presumption cannot be invoked.
22. There is neither direct nor indirect evidence produced by
the prosecution to establish that any act or conduct on the
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
part of the present respondent had driven the deceased to
such an extent that she was left with no alternative but to take
the extreme step of committing suicide. Therefore, under the
circumstances,
the
trial
Court
has
rightly
passed
the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal. No infirmity,
illegality, or perversity is found in the impugned judgment and
order of acquittal. Hence, the present appeals are devoid of
merits and deserves to be dismissed.
23. In these circumstances, the trial Court was justified in
concluding that the prosecution had failed to establish the
ingredients of the offence beyond reasonable doubt and,
therefore, rightly recorded an order of acquittal.
24. On perusal of the record of the appeals, it transpires that
the respondent-accused has established his innocence before
the Trial Court and that, after due appreciation of the oral as
well as documentary evidence and other material placed on
record, the Trial Court has rightly passed the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal. The findings recorded by the
Trial Court are just, proper and in accordance with the settled
principles of law and, therefore, no interference is warranted
by this Court.
25.
It is well settled by catena of decisions that the Appellate
Court has full power to review, re-appreciate and reconsider
the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is founded.
However, Appellate Court must bear in mind that in case of
acquittal there is double presumption in favour of the
accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
him under the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence
that every person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he
is proved guilty by a competent Court of law. Secondly, the
accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption of their
innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened
by the trial Court.
26.
Further, if two reasonable conclusions are possible on
the basis of the evidence on record, the Appellate Court
should not disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the
trial Court. Further, while exercising the powers in appeal
against the order of acquittal, the Court of appeal would not
ordinarily interfere with the order of acquittal unless the
approach of the lower Court is vitiated by some manifest
illegality and the conclusion arrived at would not be arrived at
by any reasonable person and, therefore, the decision is to be
characterized as perverse. Merely because two views are
possible, the Court of appeal would not take the view which
would upset the judgment delivered by the Court below.
However, the Appellate Court has a power to review the
evidence if it is of the view that the conclusion arrived at by
the Court below is perverse and the Court has committed a
manifest error of law and ignored the material evidence on
record. A duty is cast upon the Appellate Court, in such
circumstances, to re-appreciate the evidence to arrive to a
just decision on the basis of material placed on record to find
out whether the accused are connected with the commission
of the crime with which he is charged.
27.
The scope and principles are enunciated by the Hon’ble
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
Apex Court in case of Chandrappa and others Vs. State of
Karnataka reported in (2007) 4 SCC 415, more particularly
paragraph Nos. 42 and 43, which was subsequently reaffirmed by the Hon’ble Apex Court Rajesh Prasad Vs. State
of Bihar and another, reported in [2022] 3 SCC 471,
wherein, the Hon’ble Apex Court has enunciated the general
principles in case of acquittal, more particularly in paragraph
No. 26 the general principles are set out by the Hon’ble Apex
Court based upon various decisions of the Hon’ble Apex
Court. Then in case of Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar
Vs. State of Karnataka, reported in AIR 2024 SC 2252 =
(2024) 8 SCC 149, the Hon'ble Apex Court has dealt with
the similar issue, more particularly, in paragraph Nos. 37 to
40. Hence, I am in complete agreement with the findings
recorded by the trial Court.
28.
It is also worthwhile to refer to the recent decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ramesh vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in [2024] 9 SCC 169, wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held and observed in paras-20
and 21 as under:“20. At this stage, it would be relevant to refer to the general
principles culled out by this Court in Chandrappa and others vs.
State of Karnataka , regarding the power of the appellate Court
while dealing with an appeal against a judgment of acquittal. The
principles read thus:
“42. …. (1) An appellate court has full power to review,
reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the order of
acquittal is founded.
(2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no limitation,
restriction or condition on exercise of such power and an
appellate court on the evidence before it may reach its own
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
conclusion, both on questions of fact and of law.
(3) Various expressions, such as, “substantial and compelling
reasons”, “good and sufficient grounds”, “very strong
circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”, “glaring mistakes”, etc.
are not intended to curtail extensive powers of an appellate court
in an appeal against acquittal. Such phraseologies are more in the
nature of “flourishes of language” to emphasize the reluctance of
an appellate court to interfere with acquittal than to curtail the
power of the court to review the evidence and to come to its own
conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in case of
acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of the accused.
Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to him under
the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every
person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved
guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having
secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further
reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial court.
(5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the
evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the
finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court.
21. In Rajendra Prasad v. State of Bihar, a three-Judge Bench of
this Court pointed out that it would be essential for the High
Court, in an appeal against acquittal, to clearly indicate firm and
weighty grounds from the record for discarding the reasons of the
Trial Court in order to be able to reach a contrary conclusion of
guilt of the accused. It was further observed that, in an appeal
against acquittal, it would not be legally sufficient for the High
Court to take a contrary view about the credibility of witnesses
and it is absolutely imperative that the High Court convincingly
finds it well-nigh impossible for the Trial Court to reject their
testimony. This was identified as the quintessence of the
jurisprudential aspect of criminal justice. Viewed in this light, the
brusque approach of the High Court in dealing with the appeal,
resulting in the conviction of Appellant Nos. 1 and 2, reversing
the cogent and well-considered judgment of acquittal by the Trial
Court giving them the benefit of doubt, cannot be sustained.”
29.
Considering the entire evidence on record, it clearly
appears that there is no credible evidence to connect the
present accused with the alleged crime and the evidence on
record is not so convincing to prove beyond reasonable doubt
that the accused has committed the alleged crime. Therefore,
R/CR.A/731/2012(GJHC240434862012)
JUDGMENT DATED: 18/09/2026
the accused cannot be convicted on the evidence on record.
Even the judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the
appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1359 of 2012 do not come to
the aid of the appellant in defending the case.
30.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and order, it
clearly transpires that the trial Court has not committed any
error of fact and law in appreciating the evidence on record
and in acquitting the accused from the charges levelled
against them. Even on re-appreciation of the evidence, it
clearly transpires that the prosecution has miserably failed to
prove the charge levelled against the accused beyond
reasonable doubt. Therefore, the impugned judgment and
order of the trial Court is sustainable and the present appeals
are liable to be dismissed.
31.
In view of the above,
both the appeals are devoid of
merits and deserve to be dismissed. Resultantly, both the
appeals dismissed. The impugned judgment and order of
acquittal passed by the Trial Court is hereby confirmed. Bail
bond stands cancelled. Record and proceedings of both the
appeals be sent back to the concerned Trial Court forthwith.
(HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK,J)
SURESH SOLANKI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review