The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. 07.2017 and decree dated 21.07.2017, has observed thus: “In view of my findings under aforementioned points, this appeal is partly allowed. The judgment dated 12.07.2017 and decree dated
21. 07.2017 passed by the learned Court below in suit bearing T.S.06 of 2015 is hereby set aside. Parties are to bear their own costs of the suit Prepare appellate decree accordingly.” [13] Being highly aggrieved by and dissatisfied against the appellate judgment and decree dated 26.09.2018 and 03.10.2018 passed b y the learned District Judge, Dharmanagar, North Tripura in Title Appeal No.02 of 2018, the present appeal has been preferred by the appellant. [14] Having appreciated the facts and circumstances of the case in brief, the observations made by both the courts below also the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and on consent of the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the considered opinion that, justice would be met if the matter is remand back to the appropriate authority setting aside the orders passed by the Appellate Court as well as the trial Court for afresh adjudication. Accordingly, the matter is remand back to the appropriate authority with the following observations and directions: [15] The plaintiff shall file an application seeking appointment of a Survey Commissioner for identifying, fixing up the boundaries and demarcating the suit schedule properties and also file a sketch plan of the suit schedule properties belonged to the plaintiff as well as the property of the defendant-respondents herein to show whether th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
RSA. No. 54 of 2018
Sri Rakesh Rn. Sharma
.....Appellant
VERSUS
Sri Mahitosh Sharma & Others.
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Nandi, Advocate.
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Advocate.
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
15/02/2022
Heard Mr. A. Nandi, learned counsel appearing for the appellant.
Also heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel and Mr. A. Tilak Paul, learned
counsel, appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-100 of the CPC against
the judgment and appellate decree dated 26.09.2018 and 03.10.2018
respectively passed by the learned District Judge, North Tripura District
Judiciary, Dharmanagar in Title Appeal No.02 of 2018 allowing the appeal
preferred by the respondent-defendants setting aside the original judgment
dated 12.07.2017 and decree dated 21.07.2017 passed by the learned Civil
Judge (Jr. Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura in Title Suit No.06 of 2015.
At the time of admitting the appeal, the following substantial questions of
law were formulated by this Court:
(i)
Whether the appellate decree in violation of provision of Order-VII
Rule-3 of CPC is sustainable in law?
(ii) Whether the decree as to title confirmed by the sale deed and finally
published mutation record can be interfered by appellant forum?
[3]
The facts and circumstances leading to this appeal may be
stated in a nut shell as follows:
The appellant as plaintiff has instituted original suit bearing
number Title Suit 06 of 2015 in the court of the learned Civil Judge (Jr.
Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura for declaration of right, title and
interest and recovery of possession as consequential relief and have also
claimed for perpetual injunction wherein, he impleaded the respondents
as defendants.
[4]
The plaint case in short compass is that the original plaintiff
had purchased the landed property measuring 20 satak i.e. 0.20 acre by a
registered sale deed No.1-3586 dated 05.10.1983 for valuable
consideration money from one Sri B irendra Singha and Shri Dhrendra
Singha son of late Radha Mohan Singha and thereafter he had been owing
and possessing the purchased landed property by constructing residential
hut and residing therein with his family.
[5]
After purchase of the landed property measuring 0.20 acre,
the plaintiff, the appellant herein, has sold a land measuring 0.06 acre.
For widening of road further, land measuring 0.04 acre was also taken by
the competent authority. The remaining 0.10 acres of land was mutated in
his name and a separate khatian No.1584 of Mouja and Teheshil
Kameswar, North Tripura was also created. The description of the suit
property is clearly mentioned in the plaint by showing separate schedule.
[6]
Further, the case of the appellant is that on last 20th January,
2008, the father of the defendants got possession of land measuring 0.06
acres with the consen4t of plaintiff for temporary erection of party office,
otherwise would be handed over in favour of the plaintiff as soon as the
State Election is over. The said portion in the occupation of defendants
have shown more particularly in schedule-B otherwise the part and parcel
of schedule-A as inserted in the plaint. The defendants, the respondents
herein, did not fulfill their assurance and on the expiry of term so
stipulated they have declined to surrender/vacate/handover the possession
of land measurin0.06 acre otherwise asked for recovery by the plaintiff in
the suit instituted by him before the Court of Civul Judge, Jr. Division,
Dharmanagar, registered as T.S. No.06 of 2015. Thereafter, the plaintiff
relied the necessary documents like sale deed No.1-3586 dated
05.10.1983, finally published khatian No.-1584 of Mouja Kameswar,
trace map etc. exhibited at the time of recording of his deposition.
[7]
It is also the further case of the appellant that at one point of
time he had made a prayer for demarcation of his land before the SDM,
Dharmanagar and in response to his prayer, the land holdings of the
appellant was properly demarcated by the competent authority followed
by posting of pillars covering the entire holding.
[8]
As per the plaint, the appellant is the owner having right,
title and interest over the land. The respondents are illegal occupier of the
suit land more particularly described in the schedule-B of the plaint. The
appellant has sought relief in the nature of declaration of right, title and
interest and have also sought for recovery of khas possession as
consequential relief as per provision of the relevant Act.
[9]
The respondents have contested the suit by filing written
statement stating inter alia that they have denied the claim of purchase of
landed property for valuable consideration by the plaintiff on the strength
of a registered sale deed No.1-3586 dated 05.10.1983 and have also
denied the claim of enjoying peaceful possession of the purchased land.
The respondents have further stated in their written statement that the suit
land as described in schedule-B of the plaint (T.S. 06 of 2015) was all
along in their possession since 1952 A.D. they have also disputed the
boundary shown b y the appellant.
[10]
The respondents have also stated that the plot numbers like
plot No.1950 and 2183 of Khatian No.1584 of Mouja Kameswar, SubDivision and revenue circle Dharmanagar District, North Tripura was
wrongly inserted in the khatian created in the name of the appellant. The
respondents did not made any attempt for correction before any
competent authority at any point of time. The respondents have also took
the plea that they are entitled to title perfected by provisions of adverse
possession. The respondents have also relied the documents like Electric
Pass Book, Enquiry report of Teheshildar dated 26.04.2014, registered
Deed No.1-1331 of 1952.
[11]
After hearing both sides, the learned trial court decreed the
original suit by judgment dated 12.07.2017 observing thus:
“In the result the suit of the plaintiff is decreed on contest with cost with
a declaration that the plaintiff has right, title and interest over the suit
land. The plaintiff is entitled to recover the possession of the B-Schedule
land by removing the belongings of the defendants at their own cost.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up for signature before me within
fourteen days from today, latest on 24.07.2017.”
[12]
Having taking into consideration of the rival contentions of
the parties and in view of the observation made by the learned court
below, learned District Judge, North Tripura District Judiciary, Dharmanagar
in Title Appeal No.02 of 2018, setting aside the original judgment dated
12.07.2017 and decree dated 21.07.2017, has observed thus:
“In view of my findings under aforementioned points, this appeal is
partly allowed. The judgment dated 12.07.2017 and decree dated
21.07.2017 passed by the learned Court below in suit bearing T.S.06 of
2015 is hereby set aside.
Parties are to bear their own costs of the suit
Prepare appellate decree accordingly.”
[13]
Being highly aggrieved by and dissatisfied against the appellate
judgment and decree dated 26.09.2018 and 03.10.2018 passed b y the learned
District Judge, Dharmanagar, North Tripura in Title Appeal No.02 of 2018, the
present appeal has been preferred by the appellant.
[14]
Having appreciated the facts and circumstances of the case in
brief, the observations made by both the courts below also the submissions
advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and on consent of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the considered opinion that,
justice would be met if the matter is remand back to the appropriate authority
setting aside the orders passed by the Appellate Court as well as the trial Court
for afresh adjudication. Accordingly, the matter is remand back to the
appropriate authority with the following observations and directions:
[15]
The plaintiff shall file an application seeking appointment of a
Survey Commissioner for identifying, fixing up the boundaries and
demarcating the suit schedule properties and also file a sketch plan of the suit
schedule properties belonged to the plaintiff as well as the property of the
defendant-respondents herein to show whether there is any encroachment by
any party upon other parties land. The plaintiff shall file the appropriate
application after receipt of the LCRs from the High Court and the Court shall
fix a date without any delay and list the matter issuing notices to the parties
from the date of receipt of the LCRs.
[16]
After appointment of the Survey Commissioner following due
procedure, shall file a report. The said Survey Commissioner’s report shall be
received at the earliest after filing the application and the order would be
passed. After receipt of the report, the parties may file their objections, if any,
and the evidence the Survey Commissioner may also be recorded. Thereafter,
the court below shall reconsider the exhibits and the evidence on record and
shall pass orders after hearing both sides.
[17]
It is needless to say that this exercise shall be completed on
priority basis preferably within a period of six months. In view of the balance
of convenience, there shall be an order of status quo be maintained by both the
parties. The parties shall not create any third party interest over the suit
schedule properties. The expenses payable to the Survey Commissioner shall
be borne equally by both the parties.
[18]
In view of the above observations and directions, the present
appeal filed by the appellant stands disposed of. Consequently, the orders
passed by both the courts below, stand set aside and accordingly, the matter is
remitted back to the appropriate authority for fresh adjudication.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review