Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: AP No.12/2019
CM No.5846/2021,
CM No.7286/2025,
CM No. 588/2021
Reserved on: 13.02.2026
Pronounced on:27.02.2026
Uploaded on:27.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced : Full
Rakesh Kumar
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Varun Raina, Advocate.
v/s
Gulshan Kumar and others
…. Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Karman Singh Johal, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. This petition has been filed under Section 11(6) of the J&K
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Act”) seeking appointment of an independent Arbitrator for
adjudication of the disputes that have arisen between the parties.
2. The petitioner contends that a partnership was constituted between the
parties to carry on business under the name and style of M/s Sachdeva
AP No. 12/2019
Garments, with its principal place of business at Jammu. This
partnership was governed by a Partnership Deed dated 01.04.1996.
3. According to the petitioner, disputes surfaced in 2017 when the
respondents failed to remit the petitioner's share of profits and omitted
his name from the firm’s balance sheets and income tax returns. It is
alleged that respondent No. 3, who was in exclusive control of the
firm’s financial management and books of account, denied the
petitioner’s requests for inspection.
4. Despite several demands for an accounting and payment of dues, the
respondents remained non-compliant. Consequently, the petitioner
invoked the arbitration clause contained in the Partnership Deed vide
notice dated 26.08.2017, calling upon the respondents to refer the
disputes to an independent Arbitrator.
5. It is further submitted that following receipt of the aforementioned
notice, the respondent No. 3 instituted a civil suit before the Court of
the learned Municipal Magistrate, Jammu. In response, the petitioner
moved an application under Section 8 of the Act, praying for the
referral of the dispute to arbitration in light of the arbitration
agreement. By way of an order dated 04.01.2018, the learned
Municipal Magistrate allowed the petitioner’s application and
accordingly dismissed the suit. This order was subsequently assailed
by respondent No. 3 by way of a civil appeal.
6. The grievance of the petitioner arises from the fact that,
notwithstanding the existence of a valid arbitration clause in the
Partnership Deed dated 01.04.1996 and the formal invocation thereof,
no independent Arbitrator has been appointed till date to adjudicate
AP No. 12/2019
upon the disputes between the parties. The respondents have failed to
act in accordance with the agreed procedure for appointment of the
Arbitrator, thereby frustrating the mechanism contemplated under the
arbitration clause.
7. The petitioner has tentatively quantified his claim at Rs. 14,78,051.18,
representing his capital investment as of 31.01.2019, inclusive of
interest at the rate of 18% per annum. Furthermore, the petitioner
asserts his entitlement to a proportionate share in the firm's assets,
including the shop premises and any investments allegedly made by
respondent No. 3 using partnership funds.
8. The respondent No. 3 has filed objections, contending that the
partnership business was dissolved by mutual consent on 31.03.2010.
It is further asserted that upon such dissolution, the arbitration clause
contained in the unregistered partnership deed dated 01.04.1996 stood
extinguished and is no longer enforceable for any statutory purpose,
including the appointment of an Arbitrator.
9. Regarding the shop premises, the respondent No. 3 maintains that he
had independently secured a tenancy at Raj Tilak Road on
01.11.1978. A formal Rent Deed was executed on 29.11.1985
between the respondent No. 3 and the landlady, Smt. Shanti Devi,
which was duly registered before the Sub-Registrar, Jammu. It is
averred that respondent No. 3 has, since the inception of said tenancy,
carried on business under the name and style of M/s Amar Soap
Works.
10.According to respondent No. 3, in the year 1983, at the insistence of
his late father, he included the petitioner in the said business as a
AP No. 12/2019
partner, allegedly without any capital contribution from the petitioner
and without execution of any written agreement. It is further stated
that on 10.12.1992, the respondents Nos. 1 and 2 were also inducted
into the business as partners by respondent No. 3, again without any
capital contribution, and that the profits were to be shared equally
amongst all four partners.
11.Subsequently, the firm’s business was changed to readymade
garments. Consequent to this change in the nature of business, a fresh
partnership deed was executed, whereby the firm was reconstituted
under the name and style of M/s Sachdeva Garments. In view of his
role in the active management of the firm's day-to-day operations, the
respondent No. 3 was entitled to a monthly working allowance of
Rs. 3,000/-, which was subject to periodic upward revisions as per the
agreement between the partners.
12.The respondent No. 3 has further averred that he was also a partner,
along with the petitioner and other brothers, in the firms-M/s Bhagat
Soap and General Traders and M/s Sachdeva Brothers. In the year
1996, it was settled amongst the brothers that respondent No. 3 would
withdraw from the aforesaid two firms, namely, M/s Bhagat Soap and
General Traders and M/s Sachdeva Brothers, provided that the
petitioner and respondents No. 1 and 2 also withdraw from M/s
Sachdeva Garments, thereby allowing respondent No. 3 to operate the
said firm as its sole proprietor. It is contended that respondent No. 3
fulfilled his part of the arrangement by withdrawing from the firms
M/s Bhagat Soap and General Traders and M/s Sachdeva Brothers,
and that the petitioner and respondents No. 1 and 2 also withdrew
AP No. 12/2019
their accumulated capital from M/s Sachdeva Garments, leaving
behind only a meagre balance amount in their favour.
13.It is further stated that respondent No. 3 was managing the business
and had engaged the petitioner, namely, Rakesh Kumar, as an
Accountant in the year 1985, who continued in that capacity till
31.03.2010, i.e., the date on which the partnership business was closed
by mutual consent. According to respondent No. 3, the petitioner was
responsible for handling the financial affairs and maintaining the
books of accounts of the firm, and all relevant documents
substantiating this position, were in the custody of the petitioner. It is
also averred that final balance sheets were prepared and final income
tax returns were filed, and that the concerned authorities, including the
Commercial Taxes Department and the Income Tax Department, were
duly informed about the closure of the business. It is further averred
that after the alleged closure of the business of M/s Sachdeva
Garments on 31.03.2010, respondent No. 3 commenced his
independent proprietorship concern under the name and style of M/s
Vijay Enterprises in the same shop premises. The said concern was
engaged in the sale of non-taxable items such as ladies’ suits and dress
material. The goods were stated to have been procured from Delhi as
well as the local market, and sales were conducted from the very
premises earlier utilized for the business of M/s Sachdeva Garments.
It is stated that M/s Vijay Enterprises was closed on 31.03.2014,
thereafter respondent No. 3 started another proprietorship concern
under the name and style of M/s Vijay Dress Material in the same
premises.
AP No. 12/2019
14.The respondent No. 3 has admitted the filing of the civil suit before
the learned Municipal Magistrate, Jammu, and its subsequent
dismissal. However, it is contended that the real dispute between the
parties is not referable to any subsisting partnership but arises out of
alleged attempts by the petitioner, supported by the other respondents,
to lay claim over the share of respondent No. 3 in the joint family
assets and his individual properties by exerting pressure upon him. It
is also contended that the respondent No.3 had earlier filed his income
tax returns in Form ITR-3, which is applicable to individuals having
income from partnership business. However, after 31.03.2010, the
respondent No.3 allegedly ceased to file returns in Form ITR-3 and
instead filed returns in Form Sugam (ITR-4S), thereby indicating that
he had no income from any partnership firm or joint venture after the
said date.
15.Rejoinder has been filed by the petitioner, wherein it is asserted that
the partnership business conducted pursuant to the partnership deed
dated 01.04.1996, which contains the arbitration clause, has never
been dissolved. The petitioner has specifically denied the contention
of respondent No. 3 that the firm was closed with the mutual consent
of all partners on 31.03.2010, submitting that no documentary
evidence has been placed on record to substantiate such a plea. The
petitioner has further denied that the accounts were settled or that the
partners were paid their respective dues, there being no documentary
proof in support thereof. The petitioner has contended that in the event
an Arbitrator is appointed, all the parties would have adequate
opportunity to raise their respective contentions and lead evidence
AP No. 12/2019
before the learned Arbitrator, who would then adjudicate upon the
disputes and render findings on merits.
16.It is further stated that the partners had reposed complete trust and
confidence in respondent No. 3, namely, Sh. Vijay Kumar, who was
entrusted with the management of the partnership business. However,
for the last eight to nine years, he allegedly stopped filing the balance
sheets and income tax returns with the concerned authorities in respect
of the partnership firm. The petitioner claims to have learnt of this fact
only upon receiving information from the Income Tax Department in
response to an application filed under the Right to Information Act.
The petitioner has reiterated that respondent No. 3 was exclusively
handling the financial affairs and management of the partnership
business and was maintaining the books of account. Despite repeated
requests, he allegedly failed to furnish the details of accounts or
produce the books of account for inspection, and also refused to pay
the petitioner his share of profits. Consequently, the petitioner
approached the Income Tax Department seeking copies of the income
tax returns filed by respondent No. 3 on behalf of the partnership firm.
Upon receiving the reply, the petitioner claims to have discovered that
income tax returns had not been filed since the year 2010 and that
proper balance sheets had also not been submitted before the Sales
Tax Department, thereby giving rise to serious suspicion regarding the
conduct of respondent No. 3.
17.Mr. Varun Raina, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
question as to whether the partnership stood dissolved in the year
2010 constitutes a disputed question of fact, which cannot be
AP No. 12/2019
adjudicated in the present proceedings and is required to be
determined on the basis of evidence by the competent forum. It is
argued that such an issue squarely falls within the exclusive domain of
the Arbitral Tribunal and lies beyond the limited scope of examination
by this Court while exercising jurisdiction under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act. He further contends that respondent
No. 3 was managing the business and solely responsible for the firm's
financial compliance and maintenance of accounts. Despite repeated
demands seeking inspection of the books of account and balance
sheets, respondent No. 3 withheld and suppressed the relevant records.
Consequently, the petitioner was constrained to invoke the provisions
of the Right to Information Act to procure the necessary documents
from the Income Tax Department. It was only upon receipt of such
statutory disclosures that the petitioner came to know that respondent
No. 3 had unilaterally discontinued filing the firm’s income tax
returns after the year 2010, thereby keeping the petitioner completely
uninformed about the true financial and operational status of the firm.
18.Per contra, Mr. Karman Singh Johal, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No. 3 has submitted that the disputes, if any, raised by the
petitioner are ex facie barred by limitation. It is contended that the
petitioner’s own Income Tax Returns (ITRs) for the Assessment
Years (AY) 2008-09 and 2009-10 demonstrate that he was deriving
regular income from M/s Sachdeva Garments. During this period, the
petitioner consistently filed Form ITR-3, which is specifically
prescribed for individuals having 'Income from a Partnership Firm.'
Conversely, for the AY 2011-12, 2013-14, and 2014-15, the petitioner
AP No. 12/2019
transitioned to filing Form Sugam (ITR-4S). Learned counsel argues
that this change in filing status constitutes a clear admission that the
petitioner was no longer a partner in any firm and not receiving a
share of profits. The shift from ITR-3 to ITR-4S serves as
contemporaneous evidence that the partnership business, as far as the
petitioner was concerned, had ceased to exist after 2010. It is thus
argued that this conduct unequivocally proves that the partnership
firm stood dissolved with effect from 31.03.2010 and that the present
petition is not maintainable.
19.Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
20.It is worthwhile to mention here that respondents 1 and 2 have
supported the case of the petitioner and have expressed no objection
to the appointment of an Arbitrator. The same has already been duly
recorded by this Court in its order dated 03.02.2021.
21.It is pertinent to mention here that the respondent No. 3 has not
disputed the execution or existence of the Partnership Deed dated
01.04.1996. On the contrary, by way of a categorical admission in
paragraph No. 1 of the Preliminary Objections, the respondent No.3
has conceded to the existence of the said agreement but it is stated that
the same is unregistered. Consequently, the existence of the
arbitration clause, which is the primary subject of inquiry in the
present proceedings, stands admitted and requires no further proof at
this stage.
22.Respondent No. 3 has questioned the maintainability of the present
petition on two principal grounds. Firstly, it is contended that the
AP No. 12/2019
claims sought to be raised by the petitioner are ex facie barred by the
law of limitation. Secondly, it is urged that no arbitrable dispute
presently subsists between the parties. This objection is founded upon
the assertion that the partnership stood dissolved by mutual consent
with effect from 31.03.2010, and that, upon such dissolution, all rights
and obligations arising out of the Partnership Deed dated 01.04.1996
stood settled and extinguished
23.Regarding the contention of respondent No. 3 that the claims are
barred by limitation, based on the petition being filed in February
2019, it is noted that the petitioner’s case rests on a delayed discovery
of facts. It is pleaded in the petition as well as in the rejoinder that
respondent No. 3 had discontinued the filing of income tax returns of
M/s Sachdeva Garments, which constrained the petitioner to approach
the Income Tax Department for clarification. The petitioner asserts
that he became aware of the said default only upon receipt of
communication dated 29.07.2016 from the Income Tax Department,
informing him that the firm had not filed returns since the Assessment
Year 2010-2011.
24.In view of the rival and conflicting stands taken by the parties, a
detailed adjudication on the question of limitation would travel
beyond the limited scope of the present proceedings under Section
11(6) of the Act. The issue of limitation being a mixed question of law
and fact necessarily warrants a comprehensive examination of
pleadings and evidence, which can appropriately be undertaken only
by the learned Arbitrator. Therefore, this issue is left open for the
learned Arbitrator to decide after allowing the parties to present their
AP No. 12/2019
respective evidence and arguments during the arbitral proceedings.
This view is fortified by the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning,
reported in 2024 INSC 532 wherein, in paragraph 114, it has been
held as under:“114. In view of the observations made by this Court in In
Re: Interplay (supra), it is clear that the scope of enquiry at
the stage of appointment of arbitrator is limited to the
scrutiny of prima facie existence of the arbitration
agreement, and nothing else. For this reason, we find it
difficult to hold that the observations made in Vidya Drolia
(supra) and adopted in NTPC v. SPML (supra) that the
jurisdiction of the referral court when dealing with the issue of
“accord and satisfaction” under Section 11 extends to weeding
out ex-facie non-arbitrable and frivolous disputes would
continue to apply despite the subsequent decision in In Re:
Interplay (supra).
(Emphasis added)
25.The respondent No. 3 further contends that the partnership stood
dissolved as of 31.03.2010, pointing to the petitioner's filing of Form
Sugam (ITR-4S) and the alleged receipt of a final share as evidence of
the firm's termination. The petitioner, however, categorically denies
these assertions. It is his specific case that respondent No. 3 exercised
exclusive control over the firm’s management, accounts, and tax
filings. The petitioner maintains that no final settlement was ever
reached and that no valid dissolution occurred. Consequently, the
factum of dissolution and the settlement of accounts are heavily
controverted questions of fact. Such disputes necessitate a full
appreciation of evidence and cannot be conclusively adjudicated in a
summary proceeding under Section 11(6) of the Act.
26.In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is satisfied that a valid
arbitration agreement exists between the parties and that disputes have
AP No. 12/2019
arisen thereunder, which are required to be adjudicated in accordance
with the agreed mechanism contained in the partnership deed.
27.The petitioner has admittedly served notice upon respondent No. 3
invoking the arbitration clause contained in the partnership deed. In
view of the existence of a valid arbitration agreement and the disputes
having arisen between the parties, I am of the considered view that the
present application deserves to be allowed. Accordingly, the
application is allowed. Shri Sobha Ram, Gandhi, District and Sessions
Judge (Retd.) R/O Village Purkhoo, P.O.Domana, Tehsil and Distrit
Jammu is hereby appointed as the Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate upon
the disputes between the parties arising out of the agreement in
question. The learned Sole Arbitrator shall enter upon the reference in
accordance with law and shall be entitled to fees as per the applicable
rules.
28.It is clarified that any observations made herein are confined solely to
the adjudication of the present application under Section 11 of the Act
and shall not be construed as an expression on the merits of the claims
or counter-claims of the parties, which shall be considered
independently by the learned Arbitrator.
29.The Registry shall send a copy of this order to the learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
30.The petition stands disposed of in the above terms.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
27.02.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.02.27 16:49
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
AP No. 12/2019
Yes.
No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review