Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2850
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8916 of 2019
1 - Rakesh Kumar Sahu S/o Rohit Kumar Sahu Aged About 32 Years R/o
Village Fagundaah, Tehsil Guroor, District Balod Chhattisgarh,
2 - Dinesh Mandaavi, S/o Shyam Singh Mandaavi, Aged About 34 Years
Village Kurna, Post Shahbada, District Kanker Chhattisgarh.,
3 - Vinod Netam S/o Amru Ram Netam Aged About 32 Years R/o Village
Arjuni, Post Karaiha, Tehsil Nagari, District Dhamtari Chhattisgarh,
4 - Rajkumaar Anchala S/o Raisingh Anchala Aged About 31 Years R/o Village
Kasadand, Koylibeda, District Kanker Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Home Affairs,
Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Raipur Chhattisgarh,
2 - The Inspector General Of Police, Bastar Range, Laalbagh, Jagadalpur
Chhattisgarh,
3 - The Director General Of Police, Police Headquarters, Atal Nagar, Raipur
Chhattisgarh,
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Shri Sunil Otwani, Sr. Advocate with Shri Shobhit
Koshta, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Shri Amit Buxy, Deputy GA.
Hon'ble Shri Sanjay K. Agrawal, J
Order On Board
Digitally
signed by
KRISHNA
KRISHNA KUMAR
BARVE
KUMAR
Date:
BARVE
2026.01.19
17:01:13
+0530
16/01/2026
1. The four petitioners herein have called in question the legality, validity
and correctness of the order passed by the Appellate Authority i.e.
Inspector General of Police, Bastar Range, Lalbagh, Jagdalpur dated
1.3.2018 (Annexure-P/2) by which their Appeal against the order of
Disciplinary Authority i.e. Superintendent of Police dated 4.6.2016
dismissing them from service has been upheld.
2. The aforesaid challenge has been made on the following factual
backdrop:
3. At the relevant point of time i.e. 27.12.2014 petitioner Nos.1 to 3 were
holding the post of Constable whereas petitioner No.4 was holding the
post of Assistant Constable and they were deputed in security duty at the
residence of former MLA namely, Manturam Pawar at Pakhanjur. During
their duty hours, the Naxalites entered the residence of the said MLA and
at gun point, looted the guns and ammunition kept in the guard room.
After the incident, a preliminary enquiry was conducted and the
following charges were levelled against the petitioners:‘Charge No.1 – on 5.1.2015, while being posted at
Naxal affected area, gross negligence and
unsatisfactory conduct was shown by not following the
Security Rules/Instructions and due to cowardly action,
the issued guns and ammunition were looted by the
unknown Naxalites.
Charge No.2.- Violation of Clause (v) of para No.487
of the Police Regulations.
Charge No.3.- Violation of Clause (2) and (4) of para
No.-64 of the Police Regulations which stipulates the
general service conditions of the Police service.’
4. The Enquiry Officer after a detailed enquiry and after recording
statements of witnesses recorded a finding that Charge Nos.1 and 3 are
found proved whereas charge No.2 was not found proved. Thereafter a
show cause notice dated 24.11.2015 was issued to the petitioners by the
Disciplinary Authority asking them to file response to the enquiry report.
Ultimately, by order dated 4.6.2016 the Disciplinary Authority held that
the conduct of the petitioners in not following the security protocol
proved the charges and accordingly, services of the petitioners were
terminated. The Disciplinary Authority also ordered for recovery of
pecuniary loss from the respective petitioners, which led to filing of an
Appeal before the Appellate Authority and the said Authority vide order
dated 1.3.2018 dismissed the appeal, which gave rise to filing of the
present writ petition.
5. At the outset, Shri Otwani, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf
of the petitioners would submit that the petitioners are not claiming back
wages. Shri Otwani would next make twofold submissions; firstly, Rule
18 of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Classification, Control and
Appeal) Rules, 1966 (for short ‘the Rules, 1966’) would apply, as the
same is applicable to the Police Constables by virtue of Regulation 213
of the CG Police Regulations, which has not been followed and common
proceeding was conducted by virtue of Rule 18 of the Rules, 1966
without leave of the competent authority and thus, it is liable to be
quashed in the light of decision rendered by this Court in the matter of
Ghasiram Kosariya Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and Others 1, and
1 (2011) 2 CGLJ 147
secondly, Presenting Officer was not appointed and, therefore, the
enquiry conducted against the petitioners is impermissible and liable to
be set aside.
6. On the other hand, learned State Counsel would submit that the four
petitioners have consented for holding common departmental enquiry
and, therefore, at this stage, they cannot raise any contention that there is
violation of the Rules, 1966. He would further submit that even if the
writ petition is allowed and the impugned order is quashed, liberty may
be reserved in favour of the respondents to initiate fresh enquiry in
accordance with the Rules, 1966.
7. On rejoinder, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner would submit that
in the light of decision rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
matter of G. Vallikumari Vs. Andhra Education Society and Others 2
which is followed by this Court in the matter of Ghasiram Kosariya
(Supra), back wages may not be granted but looking to the fact that 10
years have elapsed, it may not be proper at this stage to remand the
matter for de novo enquiry.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival
submissions made herein-above and went through the records with
utmost circumspection.
9. In the case at hand, at the relevant point of time, the four petitioners were
working as Constables and Assistant Constable respectively.
Their
services are governed by the CG Police Regulations. However, by virtue
of Regulation 213 of the Police Regulations, the Rules of 1966 are also
2 (2010) 2 SCC 497
applicable to the State Police Service, and as such, the Rules of 1966
would be applicable. It would be profitable to reproduce Rule 18 of the
Rules, 1966:‘18. Common proceedings. (1)Where two or more
Government servants are concerned in any case, the
Governor or any other authority competent to impose
the penalty of dismissal from service on all such
Government servants may make an order directing that
disciplinary action against all of them may be taken in
a common proceeding:
Provided that the powers conferred on the
Governor under this rule shall in case of Judicial
Officers, be exercised by the Chief Justice.
-Proviso added vide GAD Notification No.C - 63-98-3-I, dated 20-5-1998, published in MP Gazette
dated 21-5-1998 at page 486.
Note. - If the authorities competent to impose the
penalty of dismissal on such Government servants are
different, an order for taking disciplinary action in a
common proceeding may be made by the highest of
such authorities with the consent of the others.
(2) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 12,
any such order shall specify :
(i) the authority which may function as the disciplinary
authority for the purpose of such common proceeding;
(ii) the penalties specified in Rule 10 which such
disciplinary authority shall be competent to impose;
and
(iii)whether the procedure laid down in Rule 14 and
Rule 15 or Rule 16 shall be followed in the
proceeding.”
10. The consequence of Rule 18 in common proceeding has been considered
by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in the matter of Mahesh Kumar
Shrikishan Tiwari Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and Others 3 wherein
it has been held that where there is no order of the competent authority
for holding common proceeding against the delinquent officials, the
entire proceeding is vitiated being without jurisdiction irrespective of the
3 1985 MPLJ 516
question of proof of prejudice which must be implied.
Similar
proposition has been laid down in the matter of Navin Kumar
Shankarlal Vyas Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and others 4.
Following the aforesaid decisions of the MP High Court, this Court in
the matter of Ghasiram Kosariya (Supra) has held in para-17 as under:“17. From the aforesaid decision on the applicability
and requirement of Rule 18 of the Rules of 1966,
which are applicable in the present case also, it is too
well settled that in the absence of there being proper
order as contemplated under Rule 18 of the Rules of
1966, the entire enquiry is vitiated and consequently
the order of punishment is also rendered null and
void.”
11. As such, Rule 18 is mandatory and unless proper order is obtained from
the competent authority under Rule 18, common disciplinary proceeding
initiated against the petitioners and subsequent order of punishment are
rendered null and void.
12. Moreover, it is well settled proposition that once the Court sets aside an
order of punishment on the ground that the enquiry was not properly
conducted, the Court cannot reinstate the employee. It must remit the
case concerned to the disciplinary authority for it to conduct the enquiry
from the point that it stood vitiated, and conclude the same. (See : State
of UP & Others Vs. Rajit Singh : (2022) 15 SCC 254).
13. However, in the instant case, charge sheet was issued to the petitioners
on 11.2.2015 and more than 10 years have elapsed.
14. In this regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Vallikumari (Supra) has held in paras-20, 21 & 22 thus:-
4 1989 MPLJ 514
G.
“20. A careful reading of the Tribunal's order shows
that though it did not find any procedural infirmity in
the inquiry against the appellant, the order passed by
the Chairman of the Managing Committee was
nullified only on the ground of violation of Section
8(2) of the Act read with Rule 120(2) of the Rules
inasmuch as permission of the Director was not
obtained before removing the appellant from service.
The High Court set aside the order of the Tribunal and
indirectly restored the order passed by the Chairman of
the Managing Committee because it was of the view
that Section 8(2) is not applicable to the minority
institutions. Neither the Tribunal nor the Division
Bench of the High Court dealt with and decided the
appellant's challenge to the findings recorded by the
inquiry officer and her plea that the extreme penalty of
removal from service imposed on her was not justified
because she was not found guilty of any serious
misconduct.
21. Since the order of punishment passed by the
Chairman of the Managing Committee is vitiated due
to violation of the statutory rules and the principles of
natural justice, we may have remitted the matter to the
Tribunal with a direction to consider whether or not the
penalty of removal from service imposed upon the
appellant was disproportionate to the misconduct found
against her or the action taken by the management was
wholly arbitrary or unjust but keeping in view the fact
that the appellant was removed from service more than
13 years ago, we do not consider it proper to adopt that
course.
22. In Supdt (Tech.I) Central Excise v. Pratap Rai,
1978 (3) SCC 113, this Court held that if an order
passed by the disciplinary authority is annulled on a
technical ground, the concerned authority is free to
pass fresh order but, at the same time, the Court
declined to give such liberty to the administration on
the ground that a period of 15 years had elapsed since
the framing of charge.”
15. The aforesaid proposition has been followed by this Court in the matter
of Ghasiram Kosariya (Supra).
16. Since in the instant case, enquiry was initiated on 11.2.2015, the appeal
also remained pending and about 11 years have elapsed from the date of
initiation of the enquiry, following the principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of G. Vallikumari (Supra) and this
Court in the matter of Ghasiram Kosariya (Supra) and considering the
fact that the petitioners are not claiming back wages except other
benefits, in the interest of justice, this Court is of the opinion that the
matter must be finally set at rest without any further enquiry.
Accordingly, it is directed that the petitioners be reinstated in service and
all other benefits except back wages be also granted to them.
17. In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed to the extent indicated above.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
Barve
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review