Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010437452024
2026:CGHC:36919-
DB
NAFR
Digitally
signed by
PAWAN
PAWAN KUMAR
KUMAR Date:
2026.08.21
10:52:44
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA No. 247 of 2024
1 - Rakesh Ku. Rathore S/o Shri Nohar Lal Rathore Aged About
44 Years R/o Sakti Vihar Colony, Behind Dream Land Ward 54,
Sarkanda, Tah. Dist- Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - Jaimantri Bai W/o Shri Nohar Lal Rathore Aged About 66
Years R/o Sakti Vihar Colony, Behind Dream Land Ward 54,
Sarkanda, Tah. Dist- Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Smt. Mamta Rathore W/o Rajesh Kumar Aged About 40
Years R/o Sakti Vihar Colony, Behind Dream Land Ward 54,
Sarkanda, Tah. Dist- Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- District- Collector, DisttBilaspur ( C.G.).
For Appellant (s)
For Respondent No.1
For State/Respondent
... Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Aman Kumar Kesharwani,
:
:
Advocate
Mr. Shishir Dixit, Advocate
Mr. Anand Gupta, Dy. GA
No. 2
Hon’ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput,JJ
Judgment on Board
18/08/2026
Per Sachin Singh Rajput, J.
The appellants have invoked the first appellate jurisdiction of this
Court under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, “the
CPC”), assailing the legality, correctness and validity of the judgment and
decree dated 19.09.2024 passed by the 8th Additional District Judge,
Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh (for short, “the learned District Judge”) in Civil Suit
No. 43-A of 2021.
2.
The appellants are defendant Nos. 1 and 2, whereas respondent No. 1
is the plaintiff. The parties are hereinafter be referred to their respective
status before the learned Trial Court.
3.
Case of the plaintiff, in brief, is that the suit property comprises land
bearing Khasra Nos. 371/32 and 372/34, admeasuring 1900 sq. ft. in total,
situated at Ward No. 54, Arvind Nagar, behind Sarkanda Dream Land
School, Tahsil and District Bilaspur. A residential house has been
constructed over a portion measuring 1450 sq. ft., consisting of ground and
first floors. The plaintiff claims ownership over the suit property on the
basis of a registered gift deed dated 28.03.2018 executed in her favour by
her father-in-law, Noharlal, who had purchased the property from his selfacquired funds. Her name was thereafter mutated in the revenue records. It
is pleaded that defendant No.1, the plaintiff's brother-in-law, and defendant
No.2, her mother-in-law, were permitted to reside in the first floor
temporarily. Subsequently, they allegedly refused to vacate the premises
and started threatening and quarreling with the plaintiff and her family
members with an intention to usurp the property. A legal notice dated
01.06.2020 was issued calling upon them to vacate the premises, but the
notice was returned unserved. The plaintiff also lodged a complaint before
Police Station Sarkanda on 03.06.2020, but no action was taken.
Defendant No.3 was impleaded as a formal party. On the aforesaid
averments, alleging that the cause of action arose on 03.06.2020 and
continued thereafter, the plaintiff filed the suit seeking appropriate relief
against the defendants. Since the suit property is situated within Ward
No.54, Bilaspur, and the defendants are also residing at Bilaspur, the
learned trial Court was stated to have territorial jurisdiction to entertain the
suit.
4.
Defendants No.1 and 2, in their written statement, have denied the
averments made in the plaint and pleaded that the suit property was
purchased on 06.05.2005 by Shri Nohar Lal Rathore, father of defendant
No.1 and husband of defendant No.2. Defendant No.1 contributed
Rs.50,000/- and his sister, Smt. Vimla Rathore, contributed Rs.1,00,000/towards the purchase consideration. Defendant No.2 also contributed
Rs.1,70,000/- out of the sale proceeds of her self-acquired land at
Takarkala, Gaurela-Pendra, towards construction of the house over the suit
property. Accordingly, they claim right and share therein. It is further
pleaded that defendant No.1 constructed the first floor of the house,
obtained electricity and water connections in his name and has been
residing therein. The plaintiff, without their knowledge, allegedly got a gift
deed executed in respect of the suit property and mutated her name in the
revenue records and thereafter attempted to dispossess defendants No.1
and 2. They further pleaded that the plaintiff has been making false
complaints before the police with a view to oust them from the suit
property. Lastly, it has been pleaded that the suit is not maintainable
against the State of Chhattisgarh for want of the mandatory statutory
notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure and is, therefore,
liable to be dismissed.
5.
On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, the learned Trial Court
framed the following issues:Issue
Conclusion
Whether the suit property, comprising Khasra Nos.
Proved
371/32 and 372/34, admeasuring 1900 sq. ft., situated at
Ward No. 54, Arvind Nagar, Sarkanda, Tahsil and District
Bilaspur, was the self-acquired property of Shri Nohar Lal
Rathore, father-in-law of the plaintiff?
Whether Shri Nohar Lal Rathore, father-in-law of the
Proved
plaintiff, had transferred possession of the suit property to
the plaintiff by way of a registered gift deed dated
28.03.2018?
Whether the
registered
gift
deed
dated
28.03.2018
Proved
executed by Shri Nohar Lal Rathore in favour of the
plaintiff is a valid and legally enforceable document?
Whether the plaintiff is the sole owner of the suit property
Proved
by virtue of the registered gift deed dated 28.03.2018?
Whether defendants No. 1 and 2 have illegally occupied
Proved
and are residing in the house constructed over the suit
property?
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to vacant possession of the
Proved
house constructed over the suit property from defendants
No. 1 and 2?
Relief and costs
In accordance
with paragraph
20 of the
judgment.
6.
The plaintiff, in support of her case, examined herself as P.W-2 and
also examined Nohar Lal Rathore as P.W.- 1 and Chhedilal Rathore as P.W.
– 3 whereas the defendants examined Smt. Jaymantri as D.W. - 1 and
Rakesh Rathore as D.W. – 2.
7.
Upon appreciation of the evidence available on record, the learned
Trial Court decided the issues in favour of the plaintiff and against
defendant Nos. 1 and 2 and, accordingly, passed the following order:
I.
The suit filed by the plaintiff is decreed in the following
terms:
II.
It is held that Nohar Lal Rathore duly gifted the suit
property, being his self-acquired property, in favour of the
plaintiff by way of a registered Gift Deed dated 28.03.2018.
III.
The plaintiff is held to be the sole owner of the suit
property on the strength of the registered Gift Deed dated
28.03.2018.
IV.
The plaintiff is held entitled to recover vacant possession
of the house constructed over the suit property from defendant
Nos. 1 and 2.
V.
The advocate's fee, as certified or as per the schedule,
whichever is less, shall be included in the costs of the suit.
VI.
The parties shall bear their respective costs.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the present first
appeal has been preferred before this Court.
8.
(a)
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the impugned
judgment and decree dated 19.09.2024 passed by the learned Trial Court is
contrary to the facts, evidence and law and is, therefore, liable to be set
aside. It is submitted that the learned Trial Court failed to properly
appreciate the documentary and oral evidence adduced by the defendants
and erred in holding that the suit property was the self-acquired property of
Nohar Lal Rathore. According to the appellants, the evidence on record
clearly establishes that the suit land was purchased by Nohar Lal Rathore
with the financial assistance of defendant No.1 and that the house standing
thereon was also constructed with his financial contribution.
(b)
Learned counsel further submits that the Trial Court failed to
consider the material admissions made by the parties while deciding Issue
No.1 and also overlooked the evidence showing that defendant Nos.1 and 2
had been residing in the suit property from the inception of construction of
the house and continued to remain in possession thereof. It is, therefore,
contended that the finding granting the plaintiff possession of the entire
suit property is perverse and unsupported by the evidence on record.
(c)
It is further submitted that the alleged registered Gift Deed dated
28.03.2018 was not duly proved by the plaintiff in accordance with law. The
plaintiff failed to establish its due execution by examining the attesting
witness, and therefore, the said document could not have been relied upon
for holding that title had validly passed in favour of the plaintiff.
Consequently, the findings recorded by the Trial Court on Issues No.3 and
4 are legally unsustainable.
(d)
Learned counsel also submits that the defendants had established
their lawful and continuous possession over the suit property and,
therefore, their possession could not have been treated as illegal. The
findings recorded by the Trial Court on Issues No.5 and 6 are thus contrary
to the evidence available on record. It is lastly submitted that the plaintiff
failed to discharge the burden of proving her case as well as the validity and
execution of the alleged Gift Deed. The impugned judgment and decree,
having been passed without proper appreciation of the evidence and settled
principles of law, deserve to be set aside.
9.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 1 supports the impugned
judgment and decree. He submits that, on the basis of cogent and prudent
evidence, the plaintiff has duly proved the issues which have rightly been
decided in his favour. He further submits that the suit property was gifted
by the plaintiff’s father-in-law who himself appeared before the learned Trial
Court and deposed in support of the plaintiff’s case. It is further submitted
that defendant No. 2 was living separately from the plaintiff’s father-in-law
and had received an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- towards full and final
settlement of her maintenance claim. He further submits that the defence
set up by defendant Nos. 1 and 2 regarding their contribution towards the
purchase of the suit property and construction of the first floor has not
been established by any cogent and prudent evidence. Thus, he submits
that the impugned judgment and decree does not suffer from any illegality
or irregularity warranting interference by this Court and that the appeal,
being devoid of merit, is liable to be dismissed.
10.
Learned counsel for the State submits that the dispute with regard to
the suit property is essentially a private dispute between the appellants and
the private respondent, and the State has no substantive role to play in the
adjudication of the present matter.
11.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the record,
and duly considered the rival submissions advanced at the Bar.
12.
The question that arises for consideration before this Court is
whether the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Court can
withstand scrutiny in the present appeal. In support of his case, Nohar Lal
Rathore was examined as PW-1. In his affidavit filed under Order XVIII Rule
4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, he deposed that he knew the plaintiff and
defendant Nos. 1 and 2; that the plaintiff was his daughter-in-law,
defendant No. 1 was his younger son, and defendant No. 2 was his wife. He
further deposed that the suit property bearing Khasra Nos. 371/32 and
372/34, admeasuring 1,900 sq. ft., situated at Ward No. 54, Arvind Nagar,
behind Sarkanda Dream Land School, Tahsil and District Bilaspur, was
purchased by him from Sahdev Kashyap out of his self-acquired funds, and
that he had constructed a residential house thereon. He stated that, being
the owner of the property, he executed a registered Gift Deed dated
28.03.2018 in favour of the plaintiff, being satisfied with the care and
services rendered by her, and handed over possession to her. He further
stated that thereafter her name was recorded in the revenue records. He
also deposed that he had provided a plot at Ashok Nagar and a medical
store to defendant No. 1, which was subsequently sold by him, and had
paid a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- to defendant No. 2 towards her maintenance.
According to him, owing to the proper care rendered by the plaintiff and the
misbehaviour and ill-treatment meted out to him by defendant Nos. 1 and
2, he transferred his self-acquired property in favour of the plaintiff, who
thereby became its exclusive owner. In his cross-examination, the witness
admitted that defendant No. 1 was his younger son and defendant No. 2
was his wife and that the suit property situated at Arvind Nagar, Sarkanda,
had been purchased by him in the year 2005. He denied that defendant No.
1 had contributed a sum of Rs.50,000/- towards its purchase. He stated
that defendant No. 1 was running a medical store at Rajkishore Nagar,
which had been established by him, and that he had also purchased 5
decimals of land at Ashok Nagar for defendant No. 1. He denied that the
said land had been purchased from defendant No. 1's own earnings or that
the sale proceeds thereof had been paid to him towards construction of the
house. He admitted that defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were presently residing in
the suit property, but denied having permitted them to reside therein. He
further denied that the first floor had been constructed by defendant No. 1
at his own expense and stated that the same had been constructed by him
at his own expense. He denied that defendant No. 1 used to contribute his
earnings to him and also denied that his daughter, Vimla Rathore, had
contributed a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- towards the purchase of the suit
property or had any share therein. He maintained that the suit property
was his self-acquired property, purchased out of his earnings while he was
employed at BALCO, and denied any contribution towards its purchase by
any family member. He admitted that he had disputes with his wife,
defendant No. 2, and was living separately from her, but denied that she
had contributed towards the purchase of the suit property or that she had
been deprived of any share therein on account of such disputes. He stated
that his wife had received a lump-sum amount of Rs.5,00,000/- towards
maintenance, though no document in support thereof had been produced.
He denied that defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were taking care of him and stated
that he was being looked after by Rajesh, the husband of the plaintiff. He
further denied that the Gift Deed in favour of the plaintiff had been
executed on account of his affection for Rajesh or at his instance.
Significantly, the witness admitted that he had neither issued any legal
notice to defendant Nos. 1 and 2 nor initiated any proceedings for their
eviction from the suit property.
13.
Mamta Rathore (PW-2) and Chedi Lal Rathore (PW-3) were also
examined. Both these witnesses supported the testimony of Nohar Lal
Rathore (PW-1) and deposed substantially in conformity with his version.
14.
In support of her case, the appellant/defendant No.2, namely
Jaimantri Bai, examined herself as DW-1. In her affidavit filed under Order
XVIII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, she deposed that her husband,
Nohar Lal Rathore, had purchased the suit land bearing Khasra
Nos.371/32 and 372/34, admeasuring 1900 square feet, on 06.05.2005,
with financial contributions of Rs.50,000/- by defendant No.1 and
Rs.1,00,000/- by Vimla Rathore. She further deposed that the ground floor
was constructed from Rs.1,70,000/- realised by sale of the land given to
her by her father, while the first floor was constructed by defendant No.1,
Rakesh Rathore, from his own earnings, who also obtained electricity and
water connections in his name. According to her, the suit property was thus
acquired and constructed with the contribution of the family members,
whereas the plaintiff had made no contribution thereto. She alleged that the
plaintiff, by practicing fraud upon Nohar Lal Rathore, got the sale deed
executed in her favour and clandestinely got her name mutated in the
revenue records, despite living separately from her husband. She further
stated that the plaintiff had lodged several false complaints against
defendant No.1, which were found baseless upon inquiry, and had
instituted the present suit with an ulterior motive to harass the defendants
and usurp the entire property. She accordingly contended that the plaintiff
had no exclusive right, title or interest in the suit property, that the suit
was based on false averments and was liable to be dismissed, besides being
improperly valued for the purposes of court fee and jurisdiction. In her
cross-examination, she admitted that she was illiterate, had not read her
affidavit and did not remember its contents. She was unaware of the
Khasra numbers of the suit land and could not explain their mention in her
affidavit. She admitted that Vimla had neither appeared before the Court
nor raised any objection, though she stated for the first time that Vimla had
been prevented from doing so by her elder son. She admitted that Rakesh
started a medical store in 2006, but could not state in whose name its
licence stood or when the suit land was purchased. She further admitted
having instituted maintenance proceedings against her husband while
residing at Kalyan Ashram, Bilaspur, and that the affidavit executed by her
bore her photograph. She admitted that she had never challenged the land
recorded in the name of Nohar Lal Rathore or the subsequent mutation in
the plaintiff's name before any competent authority. She also admitted that
she had produced no document to establish that the Tikrakala land was
received by her from her father, that it was joint family property, or that the
first floor was constructed by defendant No.1. She denied knowledge of any
complaint lodged by the plaintiff at Police Station Sarkanda and stated that
any such assertion in her affidavit would be incorrect. She further admitted
that she had never challenged the mutation in favour of the plaintiff and
that the suit property presently stood recorded in the name of the plaintiff,
Mamta Rathore.
15.
The appellant/defendant No. 1, namely Rakesh Rathore (DW-2), was
also examined. He supported the testimony of Jaimantri Bai (DW-1) and
deposed substantially in consonance with her version.
16.
The evidence available on record demonstrates that the suit property
was purchased by the plaintiff’s father-in-law on 06.05.2005. According to
the plaintiff, the suit property was purchased from his own source of
income, whereas defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have pleaded that they had also
contributed towards the purchase of the suit property and the subsequent
construction of the house. The gift deed has been duly exhibited on record.
The execution of the said gift deed cannot be disputed in view of the
statement of the executant himself. Moreover, the gift deed is a registered
instrument and appears to have been executed in accordance with the
provisions of Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The defence
put forth by the defendants is that defendant No. 1 contributed a sum of
Rs.50,000/- towards the purchase of the suit property and that he was also
working in a medical store. However, there is no document available on
record to establish that defendant No. 1 was running or otherwise engaged
in any medical store business. Another defence raised by defendant No. 1 is
that a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- was contributed by his sister, namely, Mamta
Rathore. However, she was not examined to substantiate the same.
Another defence raised by the defendants is that defendant No. 2 had
contributed towards the construction of the house out of the sale proceeds
received from the sale of her property. Ex. D-1 is the sale deed pertaining to
the property situated at Gourela-Pendra, which was executed by defendant
No. 2 in the year 2006. However, the said document, by itself, does not
establish that the sale consideration received thereunder was utilized
towards the construction of the house situated over the suit property.
17.
Apart from the aforesaid, Nohar Lal, the witness examined on behalf
of the plaintiff, has stated that a maintenance case had been filed by
defendant No. 2, wherein she received a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- towards final
settlement of maintenance. Although this fact was denied by defendant No.
2, she admitted that she had filed a maintenance case against the
respondent. The consistent case of the plaintiff from the very beginning has
been that the suit property was purchased by his father-in-law from his
own source of income. The father-in-law in his statement has stated that he
was working in BALCO and that the suit property was purchased from his
own earnings. It is also significant that defendant Nos. 1 and 2 did not file
any counter-claim seeking cancellation of the gift deed, a declaration that
the gift deed was null and void, or a declaration of their title over the suit
property. The learned Trial Court, after duly appreciating the evidence
available on record, decided the issues in favour of the plaintiff. In the
opinion of this Court, on the basis of the evidence discussed hereinabove,
the plaintiff succeeded in proving the issues in his favour by cogent and
reliable evidence. The defence raised by defendant Nos. 1 and 2 with regard
to their alleged contribution towards the purchase of the suit property and
construction of the house has not been established by cogent and reliable
evidence. The findings recorded by the learned Trial Court are based upon a
proper appreciation of the evidence available on record and do not suffer
from any perversity or illegality. Accordingly, no interference with the
impugned judgment and decree is warranted.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this appeal is devoid of merit and
is accordingly dismissed.
19.
Decree be drawn accordingly. No order as to costs.
Sd/-
Pawan
Sd/-
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review