Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1126
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 374 of 2025
Date of Decision: 24.11.2025
Rakesh Chopra
S/o Sh.Kewal Kumar Chopra
R/o SE (Civil) HQ R&D Estt.
Research & Development
(BRO), C/o. 99 APO.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
Union of India,
Through Secretary,
Ministry of Defence,
Border Road Wing
South Block, New Delhi – 110011.
2.
Union of India,
Through its Secretary
Department of Personnel and Training,
Ministry of Personnel PG and Pensions
North Block, New Delhi – 110011.
3.
Central Vigilance Commission,
Through Secretary,
Satarkta Bhavan, Block-A,
GPO Complex, INA, New Delhi – 23.
2025:MLHC:1126
4.
Joint Secretary Border Road
Department of Defence
Ministry of Defence
Border Road Wing
South Block, New Delhi – 110011.
5.
Lt. Gen. Raghu Srinivasan,
DGBR, Border Road Organisation
Seema Sadak Bhawan,
Ring Road, Delhi Cantt,
New Delhi – 110010.
6.
Lt. Gen. Rajeev Chodhary (Retd)
(Former) DGBR,
(Through) Border Road Organisation
Seema Sadak Bhawan,
Ring Road, Delhi Cantt,
New Delhi – 110010.
7.
The Chief Engineer,
Project Beacon,
Old Air Field, Budgam, Rangreth,
Srinagar, Jammu & Kashmir- 190007.
8.
The Chief Engineer
HQ Research & Development Estt
(BRO) Near William Carey University
Nongmynsong, Shillong
Meghalaya – 793019.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. N.K.Gupta, Adv.
Ms. M.Surong, Adv.
Ms. M.S.Malsom, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N.Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. M.Myrchiang, Adv.
:
2025:MLHC:1126
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner who is currently
serving as Superintending Engineer (CIV) in Border Roads Organisation,
being aggrieved with the chargesheet dated 22-04-2025, issued by the Under
Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Defence, is before this
Court assailing the same on the ground that the said chargesheet is legally
invalid, inasmuch as, the stated charge is that he had “failed to submit the
inquiry report” for 3(three) departmental inquiries when infact, the said
reports had already been submitted by the petitioner.
2.
Mr. N.K.Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
action of the respondents in issuing the impugned chargesheet dated 22-042025, is without due cause, in violation of laid down rules and procedure
and has been made deliberately to victimize and harass the petitioner and
more importantly, to block his promotion which is due very soon. The single
2025:MLHC:1126
charge imputed against the petitioner he submits, is of non-submission of
the inquiry reports with regard to 3(three) disciplinary inquiries, wherein the
petitioner was appointed as Inquiry Officer. This charge, he contends, is
unfounded, inasmuch as, from a bare perusal of the records i.e., two letters
dated 18-06-2024 and one letter dated 20-06-2024, which are annexed to the
writ petition, it can clearly be seen that the inquiry reports had already been
submitted 10(ten) months before issuance of the chargesheet. This fact, he
submits, is not refuted by the respondents as in the counter affidavit itself, it
has been stated that the inquiry reports have been submitted. The sole charge
alleged against the petitioner therefore, he contends, is non-existent,
untenable and is null and void, inasmuch as, the disciplinary authority after
receipt of the inquiry reports, have also passed final orders on the same in
September, 2024. The charge therefore, he submits, being a conscious and
deliberate fabrication to initiate a proceeding where no cause of action
exists, the impugned chargesheet is liable to be set aside.
3.
Learned counsel has further submitted that the impugned chargesheet
is also liable to be quashed for violation of applicable rules, as the
disciplinary authority failed to take first stage CVC advice before issuing
the impugned chargesheet as mandated by CVC Office Order No. 23/04/04
dated 13-04-2004, as amended by CVC Office Order No. 74/12/05 dated
2025:MLHC:1126
21-12-2005, due to the presence of a vigilance angle. The reason, he
submits, is because as per the Office Order No. 74/12/05, any undue delay
in disposal of a case would reinforce a conclusion as to the presence of a
vigilance angle. Further, it is submitted as per the SOP, it had been made
mandatory to obtain first stage advice from the CVC to the Ministry of
Defence, whereever allegation of doubtful integrity is raised which however,
was not done in the present case, nor a preliminary investigation conducted
as per the same SOP. The impugned chargesheet it is contended, has also
been issued without approval from the competent disciplinary authority
which is the President of India through the Minister of Defence, for cases
against Group A Officers such as the petitioner, as per the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965, and no materials had been brought on record to show that such
approval was sought for, or granted prior to the issuance of the chargesheet
dated 22-04-2025. The learned counsel then submits that the impugned
chargesheet had been issued only to victimize the petitioner with malafide
intent, as the petitioner has placed on record a series of events which
unfolded immediately after he had made a whistle blower complaint in
March 2022. Learned counsel has then gone on to illustrate the events of
victimization.
4.
The fact that the chargesheet is incompetent, it is submitted, is beyond
the shadow of any doubt, inasmuch as, the respondents were constrained to
2025:MLHC:1126
admit the defective nature of the chargesheet before this Court, and had even
prayed to be allowed to issue a Corrigendum to this effect, which is
impermissible. Learned counsel submits that it is settled law that a
Corrigendum cannot be issued to change the nature of the charge itself, as
such it clearly shows that the proposed Corrigendum, is nothing but a belated
attempt by the disciplinary authorities, to fundamentally change the nature
of the charge itself from a factually impossible one of “non-submission till
date” to a different unknown charge. Learned counsel in support of his
submissions, has placed reliance on the following judgments:
5.
(i)
Surath Chandra Chakrabarthy Vs. State of West Bengal
(1970) 3 SCC 548, paras 5, 6 and 7.
(ii)
State of Punjab Vs. V.K.Khanna (2001) 2 SCC 330, paras 28
and 37.
On other aspects, it has been submitted that the respondents inspite of
making pointed submissions before this Court, as to the fact that the
impugned chargesheet was not worded in a proper and an appropriate
manner, had however, issued orders on 21-10-2025, appointing an Inquiry
Authority, namely one Shri. Subhash Chandra Loomiya, SE (CIV), thereby
indicating the commencement of the inquiry based on the impugned
chargesheet. The said appointment order he submits, was never
communicated, or served on the petitioner until 18-11-2025, when the
2025:MLHC:1126
hearing had already been concluded which he contends, constitutes a fraud
on the Court. The learned counsel then concludes his arguments by praying
that the impugned chargesheet and a subsequent Corrigendum dated 05-082025, which was issued after filing of the present writ petition be quashed
and set aside.
6.
Dr. N.Mozika, learned DSGI assisted by Ms. M.Myrchiang, learned
counsel on behalf of the respondents in his short reply, has submitted that to
the Memorandum of Charge dated 22-04-2025, the petitioner had already
submitted his reply on 09-05-2025 and without waiting for any response,
had filed the instant writ petition on 26-08-2025, and as such, on this ground
the writ petition is premature and misconceived. With respect to the charges
contained in the chargesheet, the learned DSGI has referred to the counter
affidavit filed by the respondents, to contend that the Memorandum of
Charge revolves around the delayed submission of the inquiry reports and
not non-submission thereof, and there being no vigilance angle or financial
integrity involved, CVC approval is not mandatory.
7.
The learned DSGI then submits that the writ petition is not
entertainable at this stage, inasmuch as, a Memorandum of Charge is only
an opportunity to show cause and it does not give rise to any cause of action,
as it does not amount to an adverse order which affects the rights of any
2025:MLHC:1126
party. To support this contention that a mere chargesheet does not give rise
to any cause of action, the learned DSGI has placed reliance on the following
two judgments:
8.
(i)
Union of India and Anr. vs. Kunisetty Satyanarayana, (2006)
12 SCC 28, paragraphs 12-16.
(ii)
Secretary, Ministry of Defence and Ors. vs. Prabhash
Chandra Mirdha, (2012) 11 SCC 565, paragraphs 8 and 12.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, in the considered view
of this Court, the entire issue revolves only around the Memorandum of
Charge, the Articles thereof, and the Statement of Imputation in support of
the charges framed for the conduct of the disciplinary proceedings against
the petitioner. For the sake of convenience, the Articles of Charge framed
against the petitioner are reproduced hereinbelow:
“No.5(10)/2023-D(Lab)
Government of India
Ministry of Defence
D(Lab)
******
Sena Bhawan, New Delhi – 110105
Dated the 22nd April, 2025
MEMORANDUM
The President proposes to hold an inquiry against
Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) (GO-2434Y) posted to
R&D Shillong, under Rule 14 of the Central Civil
Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965.
The substance of the imputations of misconduct or
misbehavior in respect of which the enquiry is proposed
to be held is set out in the enclosed statement of articles
2025:MLHC:1126
of Charge (Annexure-I). A statement of the imputations
of misconduct or misbehavior in support of each article
of charge is enclosed (Annexure-II). A list of documents
by which, and a list of witnesses by whom, the articles of
charge are proposed to be sustained are also enclosed
(Annexure- III & IV).
2.
Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) (GO-2434Y), is
directed to submit within 15 days of the receipt of this
Memorandum a written statement of his defence and also
to state whether he desires to be heard in person.
3.
He is informed that an inquiry will be held only in
respect of those articles of charge as are not admitted.
He should, therefore, specifically admit or deny each
Article of charge.
4.
Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) (GO-2434Y) is
further informed that if he does not submit his written
statement of defence on or before the date specified in
Para 2 above, or does not appear in person before the
inquiring authority or otherwise fails or refuses to
comply with the provisions of Rule 14 of the CSS
(CC&A) Rules, 1965, or the orders/directions issued in
pursuance of the said rule, the inquiring authority may
hold the inquiry against him ex-parte.
5.
Attention of Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ)(GO2434Y) is invited to Rule 20 of the CSS (Conduct) Rules
1964, under which no Govt. servant shall bring or
attempt to bring any political or outside influence to bear
upon any superior authority to further his interest in
respect of matters pertaining to his service under the
Government. If any representation is received on his
behalf from another person in respect of any matter dealt
with in these proceedings, it will be presumed that he is
aware of such a representation and that it has been made
at his instance and action will be taken against him for
violation of Rule 20 of the CSS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
6.
The receipt of the Memorandum may be
acknowledged.
2025:MLHC:1126
(By Order and in the name of President)
Sd/(Gopal Mehra)
Under Secretary to the Government of India.
To,
Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE(Civ)(GO-2434Y) of R&D
Shillong.
Copy to:- DGBR, Seema Sadak Bhawan, Delhi Cantt.”
“STATEMENT
OF ARTICLES OF CHARGE
FRAMED AGAINST SHRI RAKESH CHOPRA, SE
(CIV)(GO-24334Y)
ARTICLE -I
That Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) (GO-2434Y)
of R&D Shillong, while serving with HQ CE (P) Beacon,
was appointed as Inquiring Authority in a composite
case by Chief Engineer (Project) Beacon (Prescribed
Disciplinary Authority) to inquire into the charges
levelled against three delinquent officials i.e., GS-19479
1N JE (Civ) Kumbhar Ganesh Bhagwan of 209 PWP,
GS-195987N JE (Civ) NS Slathia and GS-194792W JE
(Civ) Khemshetty Satish of 1535RMPL/109 RCC/32 TF
of (Project) Beacon vide Order bearing No.
10016/Disc/Disc
II/Kumbhar
GB/11/RC
dated
20.05.2021, 10016/NS Slathia/10/E1E dated 22.05.2021
and 100016/Disc/Khemshetty Satish/08/E1E dated
27.05.2021 respectively.
2.
As per time prescribed under Sub-Rule 24 of Rule
14 of CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965, as amended vide
Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievance and Pension, DOP&T Notification, published
in the Gazette of India vide G.S.R 548E dated
02.06.2017, Departmental Enquiry Proceedings were
required to be completed and submitted within a
stipulated period of six months from the date of
2025:MLHC:1126
appointment order received by the IO and an additional
time not exceeding six months for completion of the
Inquiry, at a time.
3.
Although Shri. Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ)(Go2434Y) vide his three letters bearing No.
1002/Disc/Kumbhar GB/Gen/59/RC, 1002/Disc/NS
Slathia/36/RC, and 1002/Disc/Khemshetty/39/RC all
dated 29.06.2022 had confirmed that written brief of all
the three Departmental Enquiries were submitted by the
Presenting Officer Shri YC Tiwari, AE(Civ) on
23.06.2022, however, Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ)
(GO-2434Y) has failed to submit the Inquiry Reports
even after repeated reminders issued to him by Chief
Engineer (P) Beacon (Disciplinary Authority) from
02.07.2022 to till date (Ref Sl No. 22 to 46 of AnnexureIII) despite multiple time extensions granted to him.
4.
By the above act, Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ)
(GO-2434Y) acted in a manner which is unbecoming on
part of a Govt servant, thereby contravening the Sub
Rule 1 (ii), (iii), (xviii) & (xix) and Sub Rule 2 (ii) of Rule
3 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
(Emphasis supplied)
9.
A perusal of the Articles of Charge, especially para 3 thereof,
categorically states that the petitioner has failed to submit the inquiry reports
even after repeated reminders issued to him by the disciplinary authority.
Thus, on a plain reading of the Articles of Charge, the main charge for which
disciplinary proceedings were contemplated, was on the failure of the
petitioner to submit the inquiry reports even after repeated reminders had
been issued to him by the disciplinary authority. Further, at paragraph 7 &
2025:MLHC:1126
8 of the Statement of Imputation in support of the Articles of Charge which
is extracted below reads as follows:
“STATEMENT
OF
IMPUTATION
OF
MISCONDUCT OR MISBEHAVIOUR IN SUPPORT
OF THE ARTICLES OF CHARGE FRAMED
AGAINST SHRI RAKESH CHOPRA, SE (CIV) (GO2434Y)
ARTICLE-I
7. The above three DEs are part of same composite case
arising out a CBI enquiry wherein DEs under Rule 14 of
CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965 was recommended/advised by
Central Vigilance Commission against 11 GREF
officials. Out of 11 DEs, eight DEs have already been
completed by the respective Inquiring Authorities and
submitted to the Disciplinary Authorities for follow up
action, whereas three DEs are yet to be completed by
Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) even after expiry of more
than two years.
8. Shri Rakesh Chopra, SE (Civ) (GO-2434Y) apparently
and deliberately delaying to hinder the disciplinary
proceedings, which has not only resulted in delay in
finalisation of the cases, but also adversely affecting the
functional structure of the department. Thus, he has
failed to maintain absolute integrity, devotion to duty
and acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a
Government Servant in the performance of his official
duties, thereby contravening the provisions contained in
CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
Here also, it is seen at para 7, it is stated that the 3(three) Departmental
Inquiries conducted by the petitioner were yet to be completed even after
2025:MLHC:1126
the expiry of more than 2(two) years, and at paragraph 8 thereof, it is
recorded that the petitioner has failed to maintain absolute integrity,
devotion to duty and acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a
government servant.
10.
Thus, from the illustration made hereinabove, it is evident that the
charges framed against the petitioner was that of the failure to complete and
submit the 3(three) inquiry reports. The 3(three) inquiry reports however, as
submitted by the petitioner and not denied by the respondents, had been
submitted by the petitioner on 18-06-2024 and 20-06-2024, the covering
letters thereof have been annexed to the writ petition. Further, on the aspect
of receipt of CVC advice when a vigilance angle is involved, though it has
been stated on affidavit by the respondents that the case of the petitioner
does not fall under vigilance, and as such, advice of CVC is not warranted,
however, the Statement of Imputation at Para 8 speaks otherwise, inasmuch
as, the nature of the charge contained therein would necessarily call for first
stage advice from the CVC. In this context, reference can be made to the
Office Order No. 74/12/05 dated 21-12-2005, wherein, such charge as
contained in para 8 of the Statement of Imputation quoted above calls for
advice from the CVC. The Office Order No. 74/12/05 dated 21-12-2005, is
reproduced hereinbelow:
2025:MLHC:1126
“No. 004/VGL/18
Government of India
Central Vigilance Commission
******
Satarkata Bhawan, Block-A
GPO Complex, INA
New Delhi-110023
Dated the 21st December, 2005
Office Order No. 74/12/05
Sub:- Vigilance angle – definition of (partial
modification regarding)
In partial modification to Commission’s Office
Order No. 23/4/04 issued vide No. 004/VGL/18 dated
13.4.04 on definition of vigilance angle, the following is
added at the end of para 2 for the purpose of
determination of vigilance angle as para 2 (b)
“Any undue/unjustified delay in the disposal of
a case, perceived after considering all relevant factors,
would reinforce a conclusion as to the presence of
vigilance angle in a case”. The existing para 2 will be
marked as para 2 (a).
2.
CVO may bring this to the notice of all concerned.
Sd/(Anjana Dube)
Deputy Secretary
All Chief Vigilance Officers
Copy to :1. Director CBI, New Delhi.
2. AVD-III, Deptt of Personnel & Training, North
Block, New Delhi.”
2025:MLHC:1126
11.
In the case of Surath Chandra Chakrabarty (supra), the case cited
by the petitioner, it has been held that it is not permissible to hold an inquiry
on a vague charge and that the grounds on which action is proposed, would
have to be in the form of definite charges which have to be duly
communicated to the delinquent, or to the person charged. Though normally
no writ would lie against a chargesheet or show cause notice, and a
chargesheet is in this regard, is not liable to be quashed, as it does not
adversely affect the rights of a delinquent employee and does not give rise
to any cause of action, the instant case however, in the considered view of
this Court has fallen into one of those rare exceptions calling for the exercise
of discretionary jurisdiction of this Court in view of the aforesaid
circumstances.
12.
The above observation is made in view of the facts that inspite of the
submission of the 3(three) inquiry reports, the impugned chargesheet had
been issued 10(ten) months thereafter, based on the definite charge of nonsubmission of the same. The incompetency of the chargesheet in this respect,
though sought to be repaired in hindsight by the respondents, to alter the
same to one of delay by means of a Corrigendum, will also not cure the basic
defect and would amount to an irregularity in the due process which cannot
be allowed or condoned. Added to this, is the fact that the charges and
statements in support thereto, clearly show the presence of a vigilance angle
2025:MLHC:1126
for which as mandated no CVC advice was sought. The reply to the show
cause therefore, if indeed already filed by the petitioner before the
disciplinary authority on the charges so framed, is redundant on the stated
facts and circumstances of the case.
13.
Accordingly, in view of the discussions made hereinabove, the
impugned chargesheet dated 22-04-2025 and Corrigendum dated 05-082025, being visited by incurable defects, the same are hereby set aside and
quashed leaving the respondents to take any further action strictly in
accordance with law.
14.
The writ petition is allowed and disposed of, however, with no order
as to costs.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2025.11.24 16:20:14 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review