Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 13.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 16.07.2026
CRL.A. 677/2016
RAJU
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Harshit Joshi, Advocate.
versus
STATE
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State with
SI Shivam, P.S. Seelampur.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
JUDGMENT
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA, J.
1. This appeal under Section 374(2) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (the Cr.P.C.) has been filed by the sole
accused, in Sessions Case No. 44253/2015 on the file of
Additional Sessions Judge, North East, Karkardooma Courts,
Delhi, assailing the judgment dated 06.06.2016 and order on
sentence dated 10.06.2016 as per which he has been convicted for
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
the offences punishable under Sections 392 and 397 read with
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (the IPC).
2. The prosecution case is that on 29.07.2015 at about 8
PM near Metro Pillar No. 162, 66 Futa Road, Seelampur, Delhi,
the accused in furtherance of his common intention along with his
associate namely, Roshan (not traceable) robbed the mobile phone
of PW1at knife point. Hence, as per the chargesheet/ final report,
the accused is alleged to have committed the offences punishable
under Sections 392, 397, 411 read with Section 34 IPC and
Sections 25 and 27 Arms Act.
3. On the basis of Ext. PW1/A FIS/FIR of PW1, given on
29.07.2015, Crime no. 562/2015, Seelampur Police Station, i.e.,
Ext. PW 2/C FIR was registered by PW2 Head Constable. PW7,
Sub-Inspector conducted investigation into the crime and on
completion of the same filed the chargesheet/final report against
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
the accused alleging the commission of the offences punishable
under abovementioned sections.
4. When the accused was produced before the trial court,
all copies of the prosecution records were furnished to him as
contemplated under Section 207 Cr.P.C. After hearing both sides,
the trial court, vide order dated 20.10.2015, framed a Charge
under Sections 392 read with Section 34 IPC, 397 IPC, 411 IPC
and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act against the accused. The
Charge was read over and explained to the accused, to which he
pleaded not guilty.
5. On behalf of the prosecution, PWs 1 to 7 were
examined and Ext. PW1/1, PW 1/A-G, PW 2/A-D and PW5/A
were marked in support of the case.
6. After the close of the prosecution evidence, the accused
was questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. regarding the
incriminating circumstances appearing against him in the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
evidence of the prosecution. The accused denied all those
circumstances and maintained his innocence. The accused
submitted that he has been falsely implicated.
7. After questioning the accused under Section. 313(1)(b)
Cr.P.C., compliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C. was mandatory. In the
case on hand, no hearing as contemplated under Section 232
Cr.P.C. is seen done by the trial court. However, non-compliance
of the said provision does not, ipso facto vitiate the proceedings,
unless omission to comply with the same is shown to have
resulted in serious and substantial prejudice to the accused (See
Moidu K. vs. State of Kerala, 2009 (3) KHC 89 : 2009 SCC
OnLine Ker 2888). Here, the accused has no case that noncompliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C. has caused any prejudice to
him.
8. No oral or documentary evidence was adduced by the
accused.
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
9. Upon consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence on record, and after hearing both sides, the trial court
vide impugned judgment dated 06.06.2016 held the accused
guilty of the offences punishable under Sections 392 read with
Section 34 IPC, 397 IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act.
Accordingly, vide order on sentence dated 10.06.2016, the
accused has been sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for a period
of 07 years for the offence punishable under “Section 392/34 IPC
read with 397 IPC” and fine of ₹1,000/- for the offence
punishable under Section 392 read with 34 IPC, and in default of
payment of fine, to simple imprisonment for 06 months. He has
been further sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for a period of
01 year for the offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms
Act. The sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
10.
The learned counsel for the appellant/accused
submitted that the evidence regarding identification of the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
accused is quite doubtful, because PW1, the informant/
aggrieved, does not support the prosecution case. The only other
testimony is that of PW3, the Head Constable, which is quite
doubtful. It was also pointed out that as per Ext. PW 1/A FIS/FIR,
the time of the incident is around 07:50 PM. According to PW3,
he received a call regarding the crime at about 08:30 – 08:35 PM
after which he along with PW4 reached the spot, and
apprehended the accused from nearby. It is quite unnatural and
improbable for the accused to have remained near the spot after
having committed the robbery. In the normal course, after the
commission of a crime, the attempt would only be to get as far
away from the scene of the crime and not loiter nearby.
11.
Per contra, it was submitted by the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor that there is no infirmity in the
impugned judgment calling for an interference by this Court.
PW1 in the box narrated the entire incident regarding the robbing
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
of his mobile phone. Only on the point of identification of the
accused he has turned hostile. However, identity is proved by the
testimony of PW3. Further, the accused while questioned under
Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C., never tendered any explanation as to
how and why he was apprehended at the scene of the incident.
The materials on record, according to the prosecutor are sufficient
to convict the accused.
12.
Heard both sides and perused the records.
13.
The only point that arises for consideration in this
appeal is whether there is any infirmity in the impugned judgment
warranting an interference by this Court.
14.
I shall briefly refer to the evidence on record
relied on by the prosecution in support of the case. Ext. PW1/A
FIS/FIR given on 29.07.2015 by PW1 reads thus:-“…On
29.07.2015, at about 7:50 PM, I got off the metro and boarded an
auto-rickshaw from Seelampur Stand. Two boys were hanging
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
onto the back of the auto-rickshaw. My Lava phone was in my
right hand. As soon as the auto-rickshaw reached near the Metro
Pillar No. 162, they suddenly snatched my phone. When I
protested, they showed me a knife and ran away with my Lava
White Color phone no. 9953909778 towards the 66 Futa Road. I
dialed 100 with my other phone and the PCR van came there
immediately and started looking for them. The boy who had
shown me the knife, was found standing nearby whom I identified
and he was apprehended. My phone was recovered from his left
hand. Upon his personal search, a sharp knife was also recovered
from him, which he had used. On enquiry, his name was found to
be Raju (the accused), s/o Ramesh, r/o I-87, Welcome, Delhi. The
mobile phone and knife recovered from the personal search of
Raju (the accused), has been handed over…”
15.
PW1 when examined before the trial court,
broadly supported the version given by him in Ext. PW1/A
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
FIS/FIR. However, he resiled from his version in Ext. PW1/A
wherein he had identified the accused. PW1 deposed that on
29.07.2015 at about 7 PM or 8 PM, he was on his way home and
that when he reached near Metro Pillar No. 162, 66 Futa Road,
two unknown persons accosted him. One of them pointed a knife
at him and while the other snatched away his Lava mobile phone,
after which they ran towards Jafrabad. He made a call to 100
number. PW1 further deposed that the accused person present in
the Court is not one of the robbers. The prosecutor sought the
permission of the court to ‘cross-examine’ the witness on the
ground that he was resiling from his earlier statement. This
request was allowed by the trial court and on further examination
by the prosecutor, PW1 denied having stated to the police that the
police officials who came to the scene on his call had
overpowered the accused herein or that he had identified the
accused as the robber before the police, or that a knife and his
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
mobile phone had been recovered from the accused present in the
court. PW1 denied having stated to the police that he could
identify the associate of accused/robber who had fled from the
spot. PW1 admitted his signatures in Ext. PW1/B,the seizure
memo of the knife; Ext. PW1/C seizure memo of the Lava mobile
phone; Ext. PW1/D sketch of the knife; Ext. PW1/E arrest memo
of the accused and Ext. PW1/F the personal search memo of the
accused. However, he denied that the aforesaid documents had
been prepared by PW7, the Investigating officer (IO) at the spot.
PW1 failed to identify the knife alleged to have been used in the
crime. PW1 admitted that he had taken his mobile phone on
‘Superdari’. He was unable to produce the same before the Court
as he had lost it regarding which he gave Ext. PW1/1 complaint
to the police.
16.
PW3, the vehicle-in-charge at Backer 57 and
base at Tent wala School, Zafrabad, Delhi, deposed that on the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
date of the incident, he along with Constable Kishan Kumar, the
gunmen, and Constable Sanjeev, the driver (PW4), were on duty.
At about 08:30 – 08:35 PM, they received a call from the control
room stating that two boys had snatched a mobile phone and fled
towards Jafrabad, Seelampur. He recorded the information
received in the call book. They proceeded to the scene where they
met PW1 who told them that after robbing his mobile phone, the
two boys had fled the scene towards Seelampur area. PW3 further
deposed that they parked the police vehicle by the side of the road
and started searching for the two boys. One of the boys was
overpowered by them on PW1 identifying him from one gali
falling within the jurisdiction of Seelampur police station. The
other boys managed to flee. PW3 identified the accused herein as
the person apprehended by the police on the said day. PW3
further deposed that a Lava white colour mobile phone along with
one knife were found in the possession of the accused. Within
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
about 20 to 25 minutes two police officials from Seelampur
Police Station arrived and so he handed over the accused; PW1;
the mobile phone, and the knife to Sub-Inspector Rizwan (PW7)
and Constable Naresh Veer (PW5). PW3 identified the knife
alleged to have been in the possession of the accused and the
same has been marked as Ext. P1.
16.1.
PW3 in his cross-examination deposed that he had
received a call from the control room at about 08:40 PM. He
admitted to have made an entry in the call book regarding the
aforesaid incident. He further deposed that there were three police
officials on duty in the vehicle who had searched for the robbers.
There were passersby moving along the road near Metro Pillar
No. 162. However, none joined the search. According to PW3, it
was he and the gunman, namely, Constable Kishan Kumar who
had overpowered the accused in the gali.
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
17.
PW4, Constable Sanjeev Pal, supported the
version of PW3 in his examination-in-chief. However, in his
cross-examination, he admitted that he had not accompanied PW3
and Constable Kishan Kumar when they went in search of the
robbers. According to PW4, he being the driver, remained in the
vehicle.
18.
PW7, Sub-Inspector, Seelampur Police Station,
the Investigating Officer (I.O.) deposed that on the night of the
incident while he was on duty at about 09:00 PM, the duty officer
informed him of the incident. He along with Constable Naresh
Veer (PW5) proceeded to the scene, that is, Metro Pillar No. 162,
66 Futa Road, Seelampur, Delhi, where PW1 produced the
accused herein along with a mobile phone and knife, at which
time PW3, PW4 and Constable Kishan were present. The police
officials informed him that they had overpowered the accused
herein while the latter was attempting to flee and that the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
associate of the accused had managed to flee. He recorded Ext.
PW1/A FIS/FIR of PW1. He prepared Ext. PW1/B sketch of the
knife and seized it vide Ext. PW1/B seizure memo. He also seized
the mobile phone as per Ext. PW1/C seizure memo. The accused
was arrested vide Ext. PW1/E arrest memo and Ext. PW1/F is the
search memo of the accused. PW7 identified the accused as the
person who had been handed over to him on the said date.
18.1. PW7, in his cross-examination, deposed that he had
reached the spot at about 09:10 PM. He had requested 3 to 4
passengers to witness the arrest and recovery proceedings. But,
none agreed.
19. PW5 supports the version of PW7.
20. The trial court has found the accused guilty of the
offences punishable under “Sections 392/397/34 IPC read with
Section 25 of the Arms Act”. Accordingly, he has been sentenced
to rigorous imprisonment for 7 years “under Section 392/34 IPC
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
read with Section 397 IPC.” Section 392 IPC deals with
punishment for robbery. Robbery defined in Section 390 IPC says
that in all robbery there is either theft or extortion. Theft is
robbery if, in order to the committing of the theft, or in
committing the theft, or in carrying away or attempting to carry
away property obtained by the theft, the offender, for that end,
voluntarily causes or attempts to cause to any person death or hurt
or wrongful restraint or fear of instant death or of instant hurt or
of instant wrongful restraint. Section 397 IPC deals with robbery,
or dacoity, with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt. As per
the Section, if, at the time of committing robbery or dacoity, the
offender uses any deadly weapon, or causes grievous hurt to any
person, or attempts to cause death or grievous hurt to any person,
the imprisonment with which such offender shall be punished,
shall not be less than 7 years. The offences contemplated under
the aforesaid Sections are two distinct offences, though the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
element of robbery is common in both. As is evident from a
reading of Section 392, there is no reference to any deadly
weapon as is the case in Section 397 IPC.
21. I will now consider the question whether the
materials on record satisfy the ingredients of the aforesaid
sections. As noticed earlier, PW1 did not identify the accused in
the box. It was only PW3 to PW5 and PW7, the police officials,
who have identified the accused before the trial court. It is true, as
held by the Apex Court in Tahir vs. State, (1996) 3 SCC 338
andAnter Singh vs. State of Rajasthan, (2004) 10 SCC 657,
that police officials are competent witnesses and there is no such
principle that they are not competent witnesses or that their
testimony must be corroborated by independent witnesses. It is
also true that merely because a witness turns hostile his entire
testimony is not liable to be discarded. That portion of his
testimony which is credible and believable is admissible and there
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
is no bar to base a conviction based on such testimony if it is
corroborated by other reliable witnesses. (See Prithi vs. State of
Haryana (2010) 8 SCC 536, LellaSrinivasa Rao vs. State of
Andhra Pradesh AIR 2004 SC 1720, Lakshman Bhai vs. State
of Gujarat AIR 2000 SC 210). Therefore, the question to be
considered is whether the testimony of the police officials
examined in this case are credible, believable and trustworthy so
as to accept the case of the prosecution relating to the identity of
the accused.
22. In Ext. PW1/A FIS/FIR the time of incident is
stated to be 07:50 PM. In the box the case of PW1 is that the
incident took place sometime between 07:00 and 08:00 pm and
that it was immediately thereafter that the accused had been
apprehended with the assistance of the police. According to PW3,
the PCR call was received at about 08:30-08:35 PM. However, in
the cross-examination PW3 deposed that the call was received at
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
08:40 PM. PW7, the IO, claims to have received information at
about 09:00 pm and that immediately thereafter he proceeded to
the scene of occurrence along with PW5 and that he had reached
the scene at 09:10 PM. According to PW7, it was PW1 who had
handed over the custody of the accused, the mobile phone and
knife to him whereas, PW3 claimed that it was he who had
handed over the custody of the accused, the mobile phone and the
knife to PW7. Further, a reading of the examination-in-chief of
PW7 gives the impression that the arrest of the accused was
affected at the scene itself and that immediately thereafter Exts.
PW1/B and PW1/C, the seizure memos relating to the knife and
mobile, were prepared. PW7 in his cross-examination deposed
that he had in fact requested 3 to 4 passersby to witness the arrest
and recovery, which apparently means that the seizure memos
were prepared immediately thereafter at the site itself. However,
Ext. PW1/E arrest memo records the time of arrest as 12:40 AM
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
on 30.07.2015. If PW7 had reached the scene at 09:10 PM and
had immediately thereafter arrested the accused, the time of arrest
would not have been 12:40 AM as recorded in the arrest memo.
23. PW3 claims that the phone and the knife found in
the possession of the accused when he was apprehendedby
himand handed over to PW7. However, PW7 has no such case.
PW7 on the other hand deposed that it was PW1 who had handed
over the knife and mobile phone along with the accused to him.
Ext. PW1/B seizure memo is seen attested by PW1 and PW5.
However, PW1 does not support the prosecution case that it was
from the accused herein that the knife had been seized. PW5 has
never a case that he had witnessed the seizure or recovery of the
knife from the accused. On the other hand, his case is that he had
accompanied PW7 to the scene of occurrence on receipt of
information by PW7 regarding the incident by which time the
accused herein is alleged to have been already apprehended and
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
the recovery/seizure affected. PW3 who is alleged to have
apprehended the accused and seized/recovered the knife and
mobile phone from the accused is not an attester to Ext. PW1/B
for which no reasons have been furnished by the prosecution.
Likewise, in Ext. PW1/C seizure memo relating to the phone,
PW1 alone is the attester. But PW1 does not support the
prosecution case that it was from the accused herein that the
mobile phone had been seized/recovered.
24. Further, it was submitted by the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor that the accused offers no explanation for his
arrest at the scene of occurrence and merely answered when
questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. that he has been
falsely implicated in this case. Reference was also made to
Section 114 of the Evidence Act and illustration (a) thereto,
which says that when a man is found in possession of stolen
goods soon after the theft, the presumption is that he is either the
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
thief or has received the goods knowing them to be stolen unless
he can account for his possession. Therefore, the argument of the
learned Additional Public Prosecutor is that in the light of Section
114 it shall be presumed that the accused herein is theperson who
had
robbed
the
mobile
phone
of
PW1,
which
was
recovered/seized from the accused soon after the incident.
25. I am afraid I am unable to agree with the argument
advanced by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor. The
burden is always on the prosecution to establish the case and the
burden never shifts to the accused unless he takes up a specific
defense. The accused while questioned under Section 313(1)(b)
Cr.P.C. does not admit that he was arrested by the police from the
place of occurrence. This is apparent from his answers given
while questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. A specific
question was put to the accused that PW7 had arrested him on
30.07.2015 at 12:40 AM and that Ext. PW1/E is the arrest memo
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
to which he answered that the same is incorrect. Therefore, there
is no admission of the prosecution case by the accused that he had
been arrested by PW7 from the spot or that he had been
apprehended by PW3 along with the other police officials
immediately after the alleged incident. The evidence regarding
the arrest as well as seizure/recovery of the mobile phone and the
knife is unsatisfactory for the reasons aforesaid discussed. It is
only when the arrest and seizure/recovery are proved, the
presumption contained under Section 114of the Evidence Act
would be attracted. In the light of such unsatisfactory evidence, I
find it unnecessary to discuss the point as to whether the offence
under Section 25 of the Arms Act is made out. As the prosecution
has been unable to establish the offences chargedagainst the
accused beyond reasonable doubt, I find that he is entitled to the
benefit of doubt.
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
26. In the result, the appeal is allowed.The impugned
judgment is set aside and the accused is acquitted under Section
235(1) Cr.P.C. for the offences punishable under Section 392,
397 read with Section 34 IPC as well as Section 25 of the Arms
Act. The appellant/accused shall be set at liberty and his bail bond
shall stand cancelled.
27. Application(s), if any, pending, shall stand closed.
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
(JUDGE)
JULY 16, 2026
Mj/kd
CRL.A. 677/2016
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:36:31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review